This document summarizes Bertil Ohlin's 1977 Nobel Memorial Lecture comparing economic expansion policies and their effects in the 1930s versus the 1970s.
Ohlin notes that in the 1930s, recovery began around 1936 without much deliberate expansion policy, while in the 1970s numerous expansion policies were implemented in most industrial nations but recovery was slower and more hesitant. He attributes this to higher wage flexibility and inflation expectations in the 1970s versus the 1930s, making traditional theories like the Phillips curve no longer relevant. Ohlin also discusses differences between the Stockholm and Keynesian models of expansion, focusing more on investment reactions and flexible expectations of prices and wages.
John Maynard Keynes was a 20th century British economist whose ideas helped shape policy responses to the Great Depression. His 1936 work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, challenged classical economic theories that markets would naturally reach full employment. Keynes argued that government needs to stimulate aggregate demand through spending, especially during economic downturns, in order to boost employment. His ideas helped justify New Deal programs in the US and influenced the establishment of institutions and policies aimed at preventing future depressions, including automatic stabilizers, the FDIC, SEC and Federal Reserve reforms. While later challenged, Keynesian economics remain influential in macroeconomic theory and policy.
Keynes was a 20th century British economist whose ideas revolutionized economic thinking. He argued that free markets do not automatically provide full employment and that aggregate demand determines economic activity. Keynes advocated fiscal and monetary policies like government spending to mitigate recessions and depressions. His ideas were widely adopted and formed the basis of postwar economic policies that achieved strong growth and employment.
This chapter discusses classical and Keynesian macroeconomic analyses. It begins with an introduction to the VIX index and how financial market volatility during recessions can impact GDP and prices. The chapter then outlines the classical model, which assumes flexible prices and full employment. It also describes Keynesian economics and how sticky prices can result in demand-determined equilibrium GDP. The chapter explores how aggregate supply and demand shocks can cause inflationary or recessionary gaps from full employment output. It examines factors that shift aggregate supply and demand curves and causes of short-run inflation variations.
John Maynard Keynes was an English economist born in 1883 who developed theories advocating for government intervention in the economy. He believed governments should increase spending and cut taxes during recessions to stimulate demand and employment. This "multiplier effect" would lead to increased manufacturing output and incomes in a self-sustaining cycle. Keynes' theories were influential during the Great Depression and World War II, when deficit spending helped countries recover. While his ideas do not dominate modern economics, aspects of his approach influenced recent economic stimulus packages.
Keynesian theory of money proposes that the relationship between the quantity of money and prices is indirect and non-proportional, unlike quantity theorists. Key provisions include that the economy is unstable and the state should use tools like monetary policy; a change in the money supply causes interest rate changes which lead to changes in investment demand and nominal GDP; and Keynes identified three macroeconomic policies - monetary, fiscal, and incomes policy - that affect GDP. Specifically, monetary policy aims to decrease interest rates to boost investment via money supply increases, while fiscal policy directly increases public investment when private investment is insufficient.
This document provides an overview of the history and evolution of macroeconomic thought. It discusses classical macroeconomics, the Keynesian revolution in response to the Great Depression, and subsequent challenges to and developments in Keynesian theory including monetarism, rational expectations, and real business cycle theory. Modern macroeconomics incorporates elements of different schools of thought with an emphasis on the role of both aggregate demand and supply factors.
This document summarizes and compares classical and Keynesian economics. Classical economics is centered around self-regulating markets that operate at full employment, while Keynesian economics recognizes markets do not always self-adjust and the economy can operate below full employment. Key differences include classical economics believing free markets are always stable versus Keynesian thinking they are unstable. The document also outlines Keynesian principles like markets clearing slowly and government intervention being desirable to stabilize the business cycle through fiscal and monetary policies.
John Maynard Keynes was a British economist born in 1883 who developed theories about government intervention in the economy. His most influential work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, argued that markets are inefficient and governments should stimulate consumption and investment to boost employment during recessions. Keynes believed governments should run deficits and lower taxes to increase aggregate demand. His ideas formed the basis for modern macroeconomic policies focused on fiscal and monetary policy.
John Maynard Keynes was a 20th century British economist whose ideas helped shape policy responses to the Great Depression. His 1936 work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, challenged classical economic theories that markets would naturally reach full employment. Keynes argued that government needs to stimulate aggregate demand through spending, especially during economic downturns, in order to boost employment. His ideas helped justify New Deal programs in the US and influenced the establishment of institutions and policies aimed at preventing future depressions, including automatic stabilizers, the FDIC, SEC and Federal Reserve reforms. While later challenged, Keynesian economics remain influential in macroeconomic theory and policy.
Keynes was a 20th century British economist whose ideas revolutionized economic thinking. He argued that free markets do not automatically provide full employment and that aggregate demand determines economic activity. Keynes advocated fiscal and monetary policies like government spending to mitigate recessions and depressions. His ideas were widely adopted and formed the basis of postwar economic policies that achieved strong growth and employment.
This chapter discusses classical and Keynesian macroeconomic analyses. It begins with an introduction to the VIX index and how financial market volatility during recessions can impact GDP and prices. The chapter then outlines the classical model, which assumes flexible prices and full employment. It also describes Keynesian economics and how sticky prices can result in demand-determined equilibrium GDP. The chapter explores how aggregate supply and demand shocks can cause inflationary or recessionary gaps from full employment output. It examines factors that shift aggregate supply and demand curves and causes of short-run inflation variations.
John Maynard Keynes was an English economist born in 1883 who developed theories advocating for government intervention in the economy. He believed governments should increase spending and cut taxes during recessions to stimulate demand and employment. This "multiplier effect" would lead to increased manufacturing output and incomes in a self-sustaining cycle. Keynes' theories were influential during the Great Depression and World War II, when deficit spending helped countries recover. While his ideas do not dominate modern economics, aspects of his approach influenced recent economic stimulus packages.
Keynesian theory of money proposes that the relationship between the quantity of money and prices is indirect and non-proportional, unlike quantity theorists. Key provisions include that the economy is unstable and the state should use tools like monetary policy; a change in the money supply causes interest rate changes which lead to changes in investment demand and nominal GDP; and Keynes identified three macroeconomic policies - monetary, fiscal, and incomes policy - that affect GDP. Specifically, monetary policy aims to decrease interest rates to boost investment via money supply increases, while fiscal policy directly increases public investment when private investment is insufficient.
This document provides an overview of the history and evolution of macroeconomic thought. It discusses classical macroeconomics, the Keynesian revolution in response to the Great Depression, and subsequent challenges to and developments in Keynesian theory including monetarism, rational expectations, and real business cycle theory. Modern macroeconomics incorporates elements of different schools of thought with an emphasis on the role of both aggregate demand and supply factors.
This document summarizes and compares classical and Keynesian economics. Classical economics is centered around self-regulating markets that operate at full employment, while Keynesian economics recognizes markets do not always self-adjust and the economy can operate below full employment. Key differences include classical economics believing free markets are always stable versus Keynesian thinking they are unstable. The document also outlines Keynesian principles like markets clearing slowly and government intervention being desirable to stabilize the business cycle through fiscal and monetary policies.
John Maynard Keynes was a British economist born in 1883 who developed theories about government intervention in the economy. His most influential work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, argued that markets are inefficient and governments should stimulate consumption and investment to boost employment during recessions. Keynes believed governments should run deficits and lower taxes to increase aggregate demand. His ideas formed the basis for modern macroeconomic policies focused on fiscal and monetary policy.
Keynes and critique of neo classical modelPrabha Panth
Keynes criticized classical economic assumptions that macroeconomics is simply the sum of microeconomics. He argued that if total savings increases in an economy, it can lead to a decrease in total consumption and aggregate demand, resulting in lower investment, output, income, and employment. Keynes also believed that savings do not automatically get invested, unlike in neoclassical theories. Savings are a leakage from the income stream and induced private investment depends more on expected profits from consumption than interest rates alone. According to Keynes, capitalist economies are inherently unstable without government intervention, and recessions can occur even in equilibrium states with less than full employment.
John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946) was one of the most influential economists of the 20th century. He studied at Eton and King's College, Cambridge and had a successful career working for the British government during World War I on issues of war finance. In his major work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936), Keynes argued that high unemployment could persist for long periods without government intervention. He advocated for fiscal policy solutions like government spending and investment to stimulate demand and pull the economy out of recession. Keynes' ideas formed the basis of modern macroeconomics and significantly influenced government policies worldwide in the post-World War II period.
This document provides an overview of the simple Keynesian model of economics. It discusses the model's key assumptions, including that it is a one-sector closed economy model with constant prices and fixed resources in the short run. Equilibrium occurs when aggregate demand (planned expenditure) equals aggregate supply (actual output). The model was developed by John Maynard Keynes to explain unemployment during the Great Depression when demand was weak and actual output fell below potential output.
This document provides an overview of Keynesian economics and the development of macroeconomic thought after Keynes. It discusses:
1) Key aspects of Keynes' work including his critique of classical assumptions, development of aggregate demand and supply analysis, and emphasis on unemployment equilibrium.
2) Post-Keynesian developments like the Hicks-Hansen IS-LM model, the Phillips curve, and the emergence of inflation in the 1960s.
3) Milton Friedman's monetarist critique which emphasized the stability of demand for money and argued that monetary policy focused on steady money growth was better than Keynesian fiscal policies at achieving price stability and low unemployment.
John Maynard Keynes was an influential 20th century English economist known for developing Keynesian economics. Some of his key ideas included that employment is determined by effective demand, which depends on aggregate supply and demand. Consumption and investment determine aggregate demand, with consumption depending on income and propensity to consume. The multiplier effect means that a change in investment leads to a proportional change in national income and output. Interest rates are determined by the supply of money and liquidity preference. Keynes argued governments could fight unemployment through fiscal policy like taxation and public investment.
This document provides an overview of classical economics and compares it to modern/Keynesian economics. Some key points:
- Classical economics is based on flexible prices and wages, and the belief that savings will automatically equal investment through Say's Law. It sees the economy as self-regulating in the long run.
- Modern/Keynesian economics, developed by John Maynard Keynes, recognizes situations where savings and investment are not equal in the short run. It advocates for government intervention through spending and policies to stimulate demand and pull the economy out of slumps.
- Compared to classical economics which sees little role for government spending, Keynesian economics relies on government spending as a key part of
Chapter 7 - inflation ,unemployment and underemployment for BBAginish9841502661
This document defines various types of inflation including low inflation, galloping inflation, and hyperinflation. It also discusses different measures used to calculate inflation rates such as the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Wholesale Price Index (WPI). Finally, it outlines several causes of inflation including demand-pull factors related to increases in the money supply according to the Quantity Theory of Money, and cost-push factors like increases in wages or costs of raw materials.
The document discusses aggregate demand (AD), aggregate supply (AS), and how they interact to determine price levels and output in both the short-term and long-term. It explains that in the short-term, prices are "viscous" or sticky, so a decrease in aggregate demand will lower output but not prices, causing unemployment. In the long-term, prices are flexible so the same decrease in demand only lowers prices, not output. Central banks can use monetary policy to stabilize demand and reduce fluctuations in output and employment. The document also discusses how supply shocks can cause stagflation by raising prices and lowering output.
New Keynesian economics evolved in response to new classical critiques of Keynesian macroeconomics. It incorporates Keynesian ideas like sticky prices and wages to explain short-run economic fluctuations. A key difference from new classical economics is the assumption that prices and wages adjust slowly rather than quickly clearing markets. This allows for involuntary unemployment and a role for monetary policy. A new synthesis has emerged merging tools from both new classical and new Keynesian models.
The document discusses economic challenges related to inflation and unemployment. It defines inflation as a general increase in prices over time which decreases purchasing power. Unemployment is defined as people who are currently not working but have actively sought work in the past four weeks. Different types of unemployment are explained such as frictional, structural, seasonal, and cyclical unemployment. Factors that cause inflation like the quantity theory, cost-push theory, and demand-pull theory are also summarized.
This document discusses unemployment, inflation, and the relationship between the two. It defines different types of unemployment, how unemployment affects the economy and individuals. The natural rate of unemployment hypothesis holds that there is always some level of voluntary unemployment. The Phillips curve shows an inverse relationship between unemployment and inflation, where lower unemployment corresponds with higher inflation.
The document discusses the Phillips curve, which shows the relationship between unemployment and inflation. It describes how Alban Phillips first observed an inverse relationship between wage growth and unemployment rates in Britain. Many economists then concluded there is a negative short-run relationship between unemployment and inflation rates, known as the short-run Phillips curve. However, changes in expected inflation rates can shift this curve. In the long run, policies aimed at reducing unemployment below the natural rate of unemployment lead to accelerating inflation.
Business cycles occur due to disturbances that push an economy above or below full employment. Recessions can be caused by substantial cuts in government or consumer spending, while booms can be generated by surges in public or private spending. Monetary policy, by influencing money supply and interest rates, can also produce booms or recessions by affecting consumer and business spending levels. Historical evidence shows that monetary factors, such as financial panics, interest rates, and monetary contractions have been major causes of business cycle fluctuations.
The document discusses different macroeconomic theories including:
- Classical economists believed in full employment and laissez-faire markets.
- Keynesians believe active government policy is needed to stabilize the economy due to unstable aggregate demand and downwardly inflexible prices and wages.
- Monetarists like Milton Friedman advocated for a monetary rule where the money supply increases 3-5% annually. They believe velocity is stable.
- New Keynesians see the economy as potentially unstable due to changes in investment and supply shocks. They support monetary policy targeting interest rates in the short-run and money supply in the long-run.
This document discusses different types of unemployment including frictional, seasonal, cyclical, structural, and disguised unemployment. It also discusses underemployment and defines unemployment rate, labor force participation rate, and discouraged workers. Additionally, it covers the relationship between unemployment and inflation including the short-run and long-run Phillips curves. Expected inflation rate is identified as a key factor that can shift the short-run Phillips curve. The natural rate hypothesis and need for disinflation policies if unemployment is kept below the natural rate for too long are also summarized.
This document discusses unemployment and inflation. It defines unemployment and discusses how unemployment rates can be manipulated. It also discusses the labor force survey used in Europe. It then discusses different types of unemployment including frictional, structural, and cyclical unemployment. The document also discusses the relationship between unemployment and inflation, including the Phillips curve and the natural rate of unemployment. It discusses criticisms of the relationship between inflation and unemployment and costs of both unemployment and inflation.
The document discusses the costs and measurement of unemployment and inflation. It defines key terms like unemployment rate, labor force participation rate, and sources of unemployment like frictional and cyclical. It also defines inflation and discusses how inflation is measured. Higher than expected inflation creates winners and losers while making long term planning more difficult.
This document discusses macroeconomics and macroeconomic policy debates from classical and Keynesian perspectives. It covers unemployment, price stability, and exchange rates. On unemployment, classical economists believe full employment is always achieved through flexible wages, while Keynesians believe unemployment is normal and government intervention is needed. On price stability, classical economists see prices adjusting to maintain full employment while Keynesians see stable prices with variable output. Exchange rates are influenced by demand and supply factors in both frameworks.
The document discusses business cycles, unemployment, inflation, and the Philippine experience. It covers theories of business cycles and the different phases. It also defines unemployment and inflation, and discusses the government's policies in response to the Philippine recession in the 1980s to promote economic recovery.
Buku modul ini membahas materi Blok Information Manajement Program Studi Pendidikan Dokter Universitas Warmadewa tahun 2012. Blok ini membahas metodologi dan statistik yang menjadi dasar manajemen informasi, pencarian literatur di perpustakaan dan internet, serta kajian kritis terhadap literatur penelitian yang ditemukan. Buku ini diharapkan dapat membantu mahasiswa memahami dan menerapkan informasi di dunia kedokteran.
This document discusses visual mind mapping software. It provides an introduction to visual mind maps and mind mapping. It explains that visual mind is a software tool for capturing, organizing, and presenting information in a flexible and intuitive manner based on the mind mapping technique. The document describes how to use visual mind for activities like brainstorming, organizing information, meeting management, and project planning. It provides instructions on installing visual mind and lists similar mind mapping programs.
Keynes and critique of neo classical modelPrabha Panth
Keynes criticized classical economic assumptions that macroeconomics is simply the sum of microeconomics. He argued that if total savings increases in an economy, it can lead to a decrease in total consumption and aggregate demand, resulting in lower investment, output, income, and employment. Keynes also believed that savings do not automatically get invested, unlike in neoclassical theories. Savings are a leakage from the income stream and induced private investment depends more on expected profits from consumption than interest rates alone. According to Keynes, capitalist economies are inherently unstable without government intervention, and recessions can occur even in equilibrium states with less than full employment.
John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946) was one of the most influential economists of the 20th century. He studied at Eton and King's College, Cambridge and had a successful career working for the British government during World War I on issues of war finance. In his major work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936), Keynes argued that high unemployment could persist for long periods without government intervention. He advocated for fiscal policy solutions like government spending and investment to stimulate demand and pull the economy out of recession. Keynes' ideas formed the basis of modern macroeconomics and significantly influenced government policies worldwide in the post-World War II period.
This document provides an overview of the simple Keynesian model of economics. It discusses the model's key assumptions, including that it is a one-sector closed economy model with constant prices and fixed resources in the short run. Equilibrium occurs when aggregate demand (planned expenditure) equals aggregate supply (actual output). The model was developed by John Maynard Keynes to explain unemployment during the Great Depression when demand was weak and actual output fell below potential output.
This document provides an overview of Keynesian economics and the development of macroeconomic thought after Keynes. It discusses:
1) Key aspects of Keynes' work including his critique of classical assumptions, development of aggregate demand and supply analysis, and emphasis on unemployment equilibrium.
2) Post-Keynesian developments like the Hicks-Hansen IS-LM model, the Phillips curve, and the emergence of inflation in the 1960s.
3) Milton Friedman's monetarist critique which emphasized the stability of demand for money and argued that monetary policy focused on steady money growth was better than Keynesian fiscal policies at achieving price stability and low unemployment.
John Maynard Keynes was an influential 20th century English economist known for developing Keynesian economics. Some of his key ideas included that employment is determined by effective demand, which depends on aggregate supply and demand. Consumption and investment determine aggregate demand, with consumption depending on income and propensity to consume. The multiplier effect means that a change in investment leads to a proportional change in national income and output. Interest rates are determined by the supply of money and liquidity preference. Keynes argued governments could fight unemployment through fiscal policy like taxation and public investment.
This document provides an overview of classical economics and compares it to modern/Keynesian economics. Some key points:
- Classical economics is based on flexible prices and wages, and the belief that savings will automatically equal investment through Say's Law. It sees the economy as self-regulating in the long run.
- Modern/Keynesian economics, developed by John Maynard Keynes, recognizes situations where savings and investment are not equal in the short run. It advocates for government intervention through spending and policies to stimulate demand and pull the economy out of slumps.
- Compared to classical economics which sees little role for government spending, Keynesian economics relies on government spending as a key part of
Chapter 7 - inflation ,unemployment and underemployment for BBAginish9841502661
This document defines various types of inflation including low inflation, galloping inflation, and hyperinflation. It also discusses different measures used to calculate inflation rates such as the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Wholesale Price Index (WPI). Finally, it outlines several causes of inflation including demand-pull factors related to increases in the money supply according to the Quantity Theory of Money, and cost-push factors like increases in wages or costs of raw materials.
The document discusses aggregate demand (AD), aggregate supply (AS), and how they interact to determine price levels and output in both the short-term and long-term. It explains that in the short-term, prices are "viscous" or sticky, so a decrease in aggregate demand will lower output but not prices, causing unemployment. In the long-term, prices are flexible so the same decrease in demand only lowers prices, not output. Central banks can use monetary policy to stabilize demand and reduce fluctuations in output and employment. The document also discusses how supply shocks can cause stagflation by raising prices and lowering output.
New Keynesian economics evolved in response to new classical critiques of Keynesian macroeconomics. It incorporates Keynesian ideas like sticky prices and wages to explain short-run economic fluctuations. A key difference from new classical economics is the assumption that prices and wages adjust slowly rather than quickly clearing markets. This allows for involuntary unemployment and a role for monetary policy. A new synthesis has emerged merging tools from both new classical and new Keynesian models.
The document discusses economic challenges related to inflation and unemployment. It defines inflation as a general increase in prices over time which decreases purchasing power. Unemployment is defined as people who are currently not working but have actively sought work in the past four weeks. Different types of unemployment are explained such as frictional, structural, seasonal, and cyclical unemployment. Factors that cause inflation like the quantity theory, cost-push theory, and demand-pull theory are also summarized.
This document discusses unemployment, inflation, and the relationship between the two. It defines different types of unemployment, how unemployment affects the economy and individuals. The natural rate of unemployment hypothesis holds that there is always some level of voluntary unemployment. The Phillips curve shows an inverse relationship between unemployment and inflation, where lower unemployment corresponds with higher inflation.
The document discusses the Phillips curve, which shows the relationship between unemployment and inflation. It describes how Alban Phillips first observed an inverse relationship between wage growth and unemployment rates in Britain. Many economists then concluded there is a negative short-run relationship between unemployment and inflation rates, known as the short-run Phillips curve. However, changes in expected inflation rates can shift this curve. In the long run, policies aimed at reducing unemployment below the natural rate of unemployment lead to accelerating inflation.
Business cycles occur due to disturbances that push an economy above or below full employment. Recessions can be caused by substantial cuts in government or consumer spending, while booms can be generated by surges in public or private spending. Monetary policy, by influencing money supply and interest rates, can also produce booms or recessions by affecting consumer and business spending levels. Historical evidence shows that monetary factors, such as financial panics, interest rates, and monetary contractions have been major causes of business cycle fluctuations.
The document discusses different macroeconomic theories including:
- Classical economists believed in full employment and laissez-faire markets.
- Keynesians believe active government policy is needed to stabilize the economy due to unstable aggregate demand and downwardly inflexible prices and wages.
- Monetarists like Milton Friedman advocated for a monetary rule where the money supply increases 3-5% annually. They believe velocity is stable.
- New Keynesians see the economy as potentially unstable due to changes in investment and supply shocks. They support monetary policy targeting interest rates in the short-run and money supply in the long-run.
This document discusses different types of unemployment including frictional, seasonal, cyclical, structural, and disguised unemployment. It also discusses underemployment and defines unemployment rate, labor force participation rate, and discouraged workers. Additionally, it covers the relationship between unemployment and inflation including the short-run and long-run Phillips curves. Expected inflation rate is identified as a key factor that can shift the short-run Phillips curve. The natural rate hypothesis and need for disinflation policies if unemployment is kept below the natural rate for too long are also summarized.
This document discusses unemployment and inflation. It defines unemployment and discusses how unemployment rates can be manipulated. It also discusses the labor force survey used in Europe. It then discusses different types of unemployment including frictional, structural, and cyclical unemployment. The document also discusses the relationship between unemployment and inflation, including the Phillips curve and the natural rate of unemployment. It discusses criticisms of the relationship between inflation and unemployment and costs of both unemployment and inflation.
The document discusses the costs and measurement of unemployment and inflation. It defines key terms like unemployment rate, labor force participation rate, and sources of unemployment like frictional and cyclical. It also defines inflation and discusses how inflation is measured. Higher than expected inflation creates winners and losers while making long term planning more difficult.
This document discusses macroeconomics and macroeconomic policy debates from classical and Keynesian perspectives. It covers unemployment, price stability, and exchange rates. On unemployment, classical economists believe full employment is always achieved through flexible wages, while Keynesians believe unemployment is normal and government intervention is needed. On price stability, classical economists see prices adjusting to maintain full employment while Keynesians see stable prices with variable output. Exchange rates are influenced by demand and supply factors in both frameworks.
The document discusses business cycles, unemployment, inflation, and the Philippine experience. It covers theories of business cycles and the different phases. It also defines unemployment and inflation, and discusses the government's policies in response to the Philippine recession in the 1980s to promote economic recovery.
Buku modul ini membahas materi Blok Information Manajement Program Studi Pendidikan Dokter Universitas Warmadewa tahun 2012. Blok ini membahas metodologi dan statistik yang menjadi dasar manajemen informasi, pencarian literatur di perpustakaan dan internet, serta kajian kritis terhadap literatur penelitian yang ditemukan. Buku ini diharapkan dapat membantu mahasiswa memahami dan menerapkan informasi di dunia kedokteran.
This document discusses visual mind mapping software. It provides an introduction to visual mind maps and mind mapping. It explains that visual mind is a software tool for capturing, organizing, and presenting information in a flexible and intuitive manner based on the mind mapping technique. The document describes how to use visual mind for activities like brainstorming, organizing information, meeting management, and project planning. It provides instructions on installing visual mind and lists similar mind mapping programs.
This document summarizes Bertil Ohlin's 1977 Nobel Memorial Lecture comparing economic expansion policies and their effects in the 1930s versus the 1970s.
Ohlin notes that in the 1930s, recovery began around 1936 without much deliberate expansion policy, while in the 1970s numerous expansion policies were implemented in most industrial nations but recovery was slower and more hesitant. He attributes this to higher wage flexibility and inflation expectations in the 1970s versus the 1930s, making traditional theories like the Phillips curve no longer relevant. Ohlin also discusses differences between the Stockholm and Keynesian models of expansion, focusing more on investment reactions and flexible expectations of prices and wages.
This document discusses a company that provides project cargo logistics services globally including heavy lift and oversize transportation, port operations, chartering of sea and air freight, crane and lifting operations, and escort and permit services. The company aims to be the preferred partner through ethics, quality, truth, integrity, commitment, and by analyzing risks, costs, and schedules to achieve 98% consistency and eliminate surprises.
The document describes a new office recycling system featuring color-coded bins for different waste types. It includes deskside bins for paper recycling and reuse, a mini bin for general waste, and larger eco bins on wastestations. Signage educates users on proper waste sorting. The system aims to reduce landfill waste by 85% and make recycling easy through durable, assembled bins and degradable liners.
This document summarizes Bertil Ohlin's 1977 Nobel Memorial Lecture comparing economic expansion policies and their effects in the 1930s versus the 1970s.
Ohlin notes that in the 1930s, recovery began around 1936 without much deliberate expansion policy, while in the 1970s numerous expansion policies were implemented in most industrial nations but recovery was slower and more hesitant. He attributes this to higher wage inflation and unstable exchange rates in the 1970s versus lower wage flexibility and more moderate price expectations in the 1930s.
Ohlin discusses Keynesian and Stockholm models of using investment to expand output and employment. While generally agreeing on using public investment to boost production without inflation, the models differed in accounting for secondary investment effects and
This document contains references for learning about and using Photoshop. It lists 5 sources - 4 articles or books about Photoshop basics, tools, and editions of the software, as well as a business dictionary definition of Photoshop. The references provide information to understand Photoshop and how to use its tools.
Thyke Logistics offers a wide range of freight forwarding and logistics services including sea, air, and road freight, warehousing, customs brokerage, and container sales and purchasing. They also specialize in project cargo logistics and chartering services. Thyke Logistics has a global network and partnerships to provide solutions between any origin and destination worldwide.
Brands are found everywhere in modern society, representing corporations, products, places, people, and religions. While a brand's logo is not its sole identity, it builds confidence through marketing, advertising, and actions that establish a set of values while providing customers with security, belonging, and passion. Brands have become big business as many entities have embraced branding strategies.
Management involves utilizing available resources like people, money, materials, and machines to achieve defined objectives. It is a dynamic process that guides an organization. Management encompasses planning, organizing, leading, motivating, and controlling human efforts through the basic managerial functions of planning, organizing, coordinating, and controlling. Efficient management is essential for businesses to survive and grow in today's competitive environment.
The Potsdam Conference divided Germany into four occupied zones after World War II. Berlin was also divided. In 1948, the western zones formed West Germany in response to the Soviets refusing to end their occupation. The Cold War began as the US and USSR competed for influence, with the US pursuing containment and the USSR establishing satellite states in Eastern Europe. The Berlin Airlift provided supplies to West Berlin when it was blockaded. NATO and the Warsaw Pact formed military alliances on either side of the Iron Curtain dividing Europe. The Cold War then spread to Asia as communism took hold in China and the Korean War began.
SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden is a leading international research institute that works closely with customers in industry to create value and assist competitiveness through innovation. It has over 1,200 employees across eight subsidiaries and generates revenues of 120 million euros annually serving over 10,000 customers. SP's mission is to create, use, and provide world-class expertise to support innovation and added value for industry and sustainable development.
This document summarizes a presentation about the relationship between growth and inflation. It discusses theories like demand-pull inflation, cost-push inflation, the Phillips curve, and the financial accelerator model. It explains concepts such as NAIRU and how recessions are caused by factors like supply shocks, high wages, and financial crises. The document argues that the synthesis view fits well with a central banker's role in using monetary policy to stabilize the economy while preventing inflation.
The document summarizes key aspects of Keynesian economics. It describes that:
1) Keynesian economics advocates for a mixed economy with an active role of government fiscal and monetary policies to manage aggregate demand and prevent inefficient macroeconomic outcomes from private sector decisions.
2) Some of the major theories of Keynesian economics include the IS-LM model developed by John Hicks for determining policy, and the Phillips curve relationship between inflation and unemployment.
3) Keynes argued that deficit spending by the government during recessions could help stimulate the overall economy through a multiplier effect of increased consumption.
The Expenditure ApproachIn Week #5, we discussed how severe down.docxmehek4
The Expenditure Approach
In Week #5, we discussed how severe downturns in the economy can eventually be destructive and end up as an economic depression, such as that of the 1930's called the Great Depression.
· Severe drops in output, relative high real unemployment, economic contraction, and apathy occur during severe recessions and periods of economic depression.
One famous economist who was called upon to address the economic malaise of the 1930's period was JohnMaynardKeynes. Published in 1933, The Means to Prosperity was Keynes' economic theories and ideas about government responsibility and authority on how to revive a sluggish economy.
The Expenditure Approach derives GDP by taking consumption (C) and adding business investment (I) and adding government expenditures of goods and services (G) and adding net exports (exports - imports). To Keynes, C + I is equal to aggregate demand, and equilibrium is the result of aggregate spending (C + I + G + NX) being equal to total economic output. If total spending is less than it would be if there were full employment (no cyclical unemployment), then there will be economic recessionary pressures.
Once an economy moves out of long-run equilibrium in which long-run aggregate supply, short-run aggregate supply, and aggregate demand are in equilibrium, what happens and should happen? Keynes believed that prices and wages were sticky in the short run, but as long as aggregate spending was below full employment, there will be economic instability and supply won't change.
· Thus, the key would be to concentrate on shiftingaggregatedemand rightward back into long-run equilibrium instead of waiting for prices and wages to fall and the short-run aggregate supply curve to shift rightward to bring about long-run equilibrium.
· Although Keynes did believe that some savings was necessary for capital accumulation in the economy, savings for the most part undercuts aggregate demand and isn't channeled into the economy.
So, to Keynes, how can aggregate demand be increased to bring about long-run equilibrium? Fiscal policy. Fiscal policy is spending and taxation by the government. Keynes believed that government spending and taxation should follow business cycles.
· If, for example, the economy is recessionary and experiencing less-than-full employment, proper fiscal policy actions should be to increase spending, even going into a budget deficit, and even lowering taxes.
· Because C and I are down in a recession, raising G will help shift aggregate demand rightward, with the "right amount" of government expenditures leading to full employment and long-run equilibrium.
· If, on the other hand, for example, the economy is at full employment and aggregate expenditures are rising, then proper fiscal policy is to reduce spending, even incurring a budget surplus, and raising taxes.
In summary, John Maynard Keynes was considered an authority of economics, sought after by President FDR especially during the Great Depress ...
The US economy from 1972-1975 was struggling with high unemployment, stagnant industrial output, and high inflation. Unemployment was over 7% and industrial output had declined in 6 of the past 7 months. Inflation was rising without signs of slowing. To address this stagflation, an expansionary fiscal policy of tax cuts and increased government spending was proposed to stimulate aggregate demand and boost the economy. However, Congress rejected this plan and instead enacted their own tax cuts and public service jobs. While the economy recovered by 1976, high inflation persisted and unemployment remained above 6% until 1978 as the Federal Reserve prioritized controlling inflation over full employment.
Inflation refers to a sustained increase in price levels over time that reduces purchasing power. It is measured using indices like CPI and PPI which track the cost of common goods. Inflation can be caused by factors like increased demand, rising production costs, or wage-price spirals. It can lead to issues like uncertainty, reduced savings, and wealth redistribution. India and other nations experienced stagflation in the 1970s due to oil crises and other economic issues. The 1991 Indian crisis demonstrated the need for reforms like currency devaluation and trade liberalization.
This document discusses how asymmetric economic shocks that affect some parts of an economy more than others can create problems for policymakers trying to set macroeconomic policies. It gives the example of how some economies may be dependent on oil prices, so a drop in oil prices would help them but could hurt other parts of the economy. This is a constant problem for those setting interest rates for the eurozone given the differences among eurozone economies and their potential exposures to different shocks.
This document discusses how asymmetric economic shocks that affect some parts of an economy more than others can create problems for policymakers trying to set macroeconomic policies. It gives the example of how some economies may be dependent on oil prices, so a drop in oil prices would help them but could hurt other parts of the economy. This is a constant problem for those setting interest rates for the eurozone given the differences among eurozone economies and their potential exposures to different shocks.
When an unexpected economic shock affects some parts of an economy more than others, it can create problems for policymakers trying to set macroeconomic policies. For example, if some areas depend on oil exports and oil prices plunge, policies aimed at boosting overall demand may not suit the needs of unaffected areas. This is a constant challenge for those setting interest rates for the eurozone given differences in economies within it and their varying exposures to potential shocks.
The document provides an overview and comparison of Keynesian and Austrian business cycle theories. It discusses their differing views on the causes of economic fluctuations and appropriate policy responses. Keynesians advocate government intervention through fiscal and monetary policy, while Austrians argue this distorts interest rates and causes malinvestments. Both theories have been criticized by economists, and there is no consensus on which provides the best framework.
This document summarizes macroeconomic trends in the British economy from the post-war period through the 1970s. It notes that Keynesian policies were largely successful in maintaining full employment and steady growth in the 1950s-60s. However, conditions changed in the 1970s with the collapse of Bretton Woods, the oil crises, and rising inflation. This led economists to reconsider the effectiveness of demand management policies and embrace monetarist ideas emphasizing the role of money supply over fiscal policy. Supply-side issues like declining capital productivity and relative price distortions also contributed to Britain's economic problems.
In today’s global economy, fears of inflation are front and center for many. This fear is driven by massive government stimulus in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
However, many market participants nowadays haven’t experienced truly unhealthy levels of inflation and therefore aren’t prepared to protect themselves against it.
In order to understand where this fear originates from and how one can better protect themselves from unhealthy levels of inflation, it is paramount that market participants and everyday individuals understand the ins and outs of inflation.
In this report, we break down inflation, elaborate on its causes and effects, discuss how central banks manage it, explain what it means for society, and lend insight into how anyone can protect themselves against it.
This document discusses business cycles and their various types and theories. It defines a business cycle as a swing in total national output, income, and employment lasting 2-10 years, marked by widespread economic expansion and contraction. Business cycles have four phases: prosperity, recession, depression, and recovery. The document outlines several types of business cycles including Kitchin cycles, Juglar cycles, Kondratieff waves, building cycles, and Kuznets cycles. It also summarizes several theories that attempt to explain the causes of business cycles, such as monetarist, Keynesian, new classical, external shock, long wave, real business cycle, and political business cycle theories.
The document discusses the stages of a business cycle, including recession, recovery, growth, momentum, and technological innovations. It notes that recessions involve reduced economic activity and levels of production and employment. The recovery stage involves the economy starting to improve from a recession. Growth involves a period of sustained economic expansion, with increased consumer confidence and spending. Momentum refers to how increased consumer spending can encourage more spending. Technological innovations can impact business cycles by affecting industries and investments. Fluctuations in innovations can contribute to fluctuations in the overall economy.
John Maynard Keynes developed his theory of income and employment to explain recessions and offer policy solutions. Key aspects of Keynesian theory include: aggregate demand can fluctuate unexpectedly and lead to unemployment if below potential output; sticky wages and prices can prolong recessions; expansionary fiscal policy can boost aggregate demand to address recessions, while contractionary policy can reduce inflation above potential output. Keynes argued for active but limited government intervention to maintain sufficient aggregate demand.
This document provides an overview of macroeconomics, including its origins, development, and current state. It discusses what macroeconomics is and the key factors it analyzes like GDP, unemployment, inflation. It reviews the major schools of thought in macroeconomics including classical economists, Keynesians, monetarists, and new classical economists. It details the key ideas from each school. It also discusses the origins of macroeconomics in the Great Depression and John Maynard Keynes' work developing theories to explain short-run economic fluctuations.
MT IS-LM-AD-AS___Big Picture Summary with illustrations, explanations and lin...Ari Wibowo
This document provides an overview of different macroeconomic theories and models, including the IS-LM, AD-AS, and LRAS frameworks. It discusses the key differences between theories that assume aggregate supply is vertical (Classic view) versus upward-sloping (Keynesian view). It then demonstrates how the pandemic could be analyzed through each lens, with the Keynesian view suggesting impacts on output and employment but the Classic view suggesting only inflation effects. The document also considers alternative aggregate supply assumptions and implications for policy responses.
This document discusses the business cycle and its effects. It begins with an introduction to business cycles, which are periodic fluctuations in economic activity. It then discusses the impacts of business cycles on employment, consumption, business confidence, and other macroeconomic variables. The document also provides examples of impacts from specific business cycles, such as the impact of the 2001 recession in the US. It analyzes unemployment, job losses, poverty levels, and other economic indicators from that time. Finally, the document argues that the 2001 recession may have been avoided through more proactive fiscal policy interventions.
The Phillips curve describes an inverse relationship between unemployment and inflation, such that lower unemployment is associated with higher inflation. While observed to be stable in the short-run, it does not hold in the long-run. The document discusses the origins of the Phillips curve from William Phillips' 1958 paper and subsequent modifications by economists like Friedman and Phelps who argued it does not reflect long-run economic realities. It also examines shifts to the Phillips curve from supply shocks and how the relationship between unemployment and inflation is now understood with incorporation of inflation expectations.
The Finnish unemployment rose in the early 1990’s from three to eighteen percent in four years. Unemployment has then decreased to the average European level, being 9.0 percent in January 2003. In this paper, we describe the shocks leading to this unforeseen increase in unemployment. We then discuss the role of labour market institutions in the adjustment process that has brought unemployment back to ‘normal’ levels. We argue that these institutions cannot be blamed for the increase in unemployment, but that more flexible institutions could have lead to a more rapid decline in unemployment.
UiPath Test Automation using UiPath Test Suite series, part 6DianaGray10
Welcome to UiPath Test Automation using UiPath Test Suite series part 6. In this session, we will cover Test Automation with generative AI and Open AI.
UiPath Test Automation with generative AI and Open AI webinar offers an in-depth exploration of leveraging cutting-edge technologies for test automation within the UiPath platform. Attendees will delve into the integration of generative AI, a test automation solution, with Open AI advanced natural language processing capabilities.
Throughout the session, participants will discover how this synergy empowers testers to automate repetitive tasks, enhance testing accuracy, and expedite the software testing life cycle. Topics covered include the seamless integration process, practical use cases, and the benefits of harnessing AI-driven automation for UiPath testing initiatives. By attending this webinar, testers, and automation professionals can gain valuable insights into harnessing the power of AI to optimize their test automation workflows within the UiPath ecosystem, ultimately driving efficiency and quality in software development processes.
What will you get from this session?
1. Insights into integrating generative AI.
2. Understanding how this integration enhances test automation within the UiPath platform
3. Practical demonstrations
4. Exploration of real-world use cases illustrating the benefits of AI-driven test automation for UiPath
Topics covered:
What is generative AI
Test Automation with generative AI and Open AI.
UiPath integration with generative AI
Speaker:
Deepak Rai, Automation Practice Lead, Boundaryless Group and UiPath MVP
Full-RAG: A modern architecture for hyper-personalizationZilliz
Mike Del Balso, CEO & Co-Founder at Tecton, presents "Full RAG," a novel approach to AI recommendation systems, aiming to push beyond the limitations of traditional models through a deep integration of contextual insights and real-time data, leveraging the Retrieval-Augmented Generation architecture. This talk will outline Full RAG's potential to significantly enhance personalization, address engineering challenges such as data management and model training, and introduce data enrichment with reranking as a key solution. Attendees will gain crucial insights into the importance of hyperpersonalization in AI, the capabilities of Full RAG for advanced personalization, and strategies for managing complex data integrations for deploying cutting-edge AI solutions.
Dr. Sean Tan, Head of Data Science, Changi Airport Group
Discover how Changi Airport Group (CAG) leverages graph technologies and generative AI to revolutionize their search capabilities. This session delves into the unique search needs of CAG’s diverse passengers and customers, showcasing how graph data structures enhance the accuracy and relevance of AI-generated search results, mitigating the risk of “hallucinations” and improving the overall customer journey.
Pushing the limits of ePRTC: 100ns holdover for 100 daysAdtran
At WSTS 2024, Alon Stern explored the topic of parametric holdover and explained how recent research findings can be implemented in real-world PNT networks to achieve 100 nanoseconds of accuracy for up to 100 days.
Enchancing adoption of Open Source Libraries. A case study on Albumentations.AIVladimir Iglovikov, Ph.D.
Presented by Vladimir Iglovikov:
- https://www.linkedin.com/in/iglovikov/
- https://x.com/viglovikov
- https://www.instagram.com/ternaus/
This presentation delves into the journey of Albumentations.ai, a highly successful open-source library for data augmentation.
Created out of a necessity for superior performance in Kaggle competitions, Albumentations has grown to become a widely used tool among data scientists and machine learning practitioners.
This case study covers various aspects, including:
People: The contributors and community that have supported Albumentations.
Metrics: The success indicators such as downloads, daily active users, GitHub stars, and financial contributions.
Challenges: The hurdles in monetizing open-source projects and measuring user engagement.
Development Practices: Best practices for creating, maintaining, and scaling open-source libraries, including code hygiene, CI/CD, and fast iteration.
Community Building: Strategies for making adoption easy, iterating quickly, and fostering a vibrant, engaged community.
Marketing: Both online and offline marketing tactics, focusing on real, impactful interactions and collaborations.
Mental Health: Maintaining balance and not feeling pressured by user demands.
Key insights include the importance of automation, making the adoption process seamless, and leveraging offline interactions for marketing. The presentation also emphasizes the need for continuous small improvements and building a friendly, inclusive community that contributes to the project's growth.
Vladimir Iglovikov brings his extensive experience as a Kaggle Grandmaster, ex-Staff ML Engineer at Lyft, sharing valuable lessons and practical advice for anyone looking to enhance the adoption of their open-source projects.
Explore more about Albumentations and join the community at:
GitHub: https://github.com/albumentations-team/albumentations
Website: https://albumentations.ai/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/100504475
Twitter: https://x.com/albumentations
Why You Should Replace Windows 11 with Nitrux Linux 3.5.0 for enhanced perfor...SOFTTECHHUB
The choice of an operating system plays a pivotal role in shaping our computing experience. For decades, Microsoft's Windows has dominated the market, offering a familiar and widely adopted platform for personal and professional use. However, as technological advancements continue to push the boundaries of innovation, alternative operating systems have emerged, challenging the status quo and offering users a fresh perspective on computing.
One such alternative that has garnered significant attention and acclaim is Nitrux Linux 3.5.0, a sleek, powerful, and user-friendly Linux distribution that promises to redefine the way we interact with our devices. With its focus on performance, security, and customization, Nitrux Linux presents a compelling case for those seeking to break free from the constraints of proprietary software and embrace the freedom and flexibility of open-source computing.
In the rapidly evolving landscape of technologies, XML continues to play a vital role in structuring, storing, and transporting data across diverse systems. The recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) present new methodologies for enhancing XML development workflows, introducing efficiency, automation, and intelligent capabilities. This presentation will outline the scope and perspective of utilizing AI in XML development. The potential benefits and the possible pitfalls will be highlighted, providing a balanced view of the subject.
We will explore the capabilities of AI in understanding XML markup languages and autonomously creating structured XML content. Additionally, we will examine the capacity of AI to enrich plain text with appropriate XML markup. Practical examples and methodological guidelines will be provided to elucidate how AI can be effectively prompted to interpret and generate accurate XML markup.
Further emphasis will be placed on the role of AI in developing XSLT, or schemas such as XSD and Schematron. We will address the techniques and strategies adopted to create prompts for generating code, explaining code, or refactoring the code, and the results achieved.
The discussion will extend to how AI can be used to transform XML content. In particular, the focus will be on the use of AI XPath extension functions in XSLT, Schematron, Schematron Quick Fixes, or for XML content refactoring.
The presentation aims to deliver a comprehensive overview of AI usage in XML development, providing attendees with the necessary knowledge to make informed decisions. Whether you’re at the early stages of adopting AI or considering integrating it in advanced XML development, this presentation will cover all levels of expertise.
By highlighting the potential advantages and challenges of integrating AI with XML development tools and languages, the presentation seeks to inspire thoughtful conversation around the future of XML development. We’ll not only delve into the technical aspects of AI-powered XML development but also discuss practical implications and possible future directions.
Unlocking Productivity: Leveraging the Potential of Copilot in Microsoft 365, a presentation by Christoforos Vlachos, Senior Solutions Manager – Modern Workplace, Uni Systems
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !KatiaHIMEUR1
Today, after several years of existence, an extremely active community and an ultra-dynamic ecosystem, Kubernetes has established itself as the de facto standard in container orchestration. Thanks to a wide range of managed services, it has never been so easy to set up a ready-to-use Kubernetes cluster.
However, this ease of use means that the subject of security in Kubernetes is often left for later, or even neglected. This exposes companies to significant risks.
In this talk, I'll show you step-by-step how to secure your Kubernetes cluster for greater peace of mind and reliability.
20 Comprehensive Checklist of Designing and Developing a WebsitePixlogix Infotech
Dive into the world of Website Designing and Developing with Pixlogix! Looking to create a stunning online presence? Look no further! Our comprehensive checklist covers everything you need to know to craft a website that stands out. From user-friendly design to seamless functionality, we've got you covered. Don't miss out on this invaluable resource! Check out our checklist now at Pixlogix and start your journey towards a captivating online presence today.
For the full video of this presentation, please visit: https://www.edge-ai-vision.com/2024/06/building-and-scaling-ai-applications-with-the-nx-ai-manager-a-presentation-from-network-optix/
Robin van Emden, Senior Director of Data Science at Network Optix, presents the “Building and Scaling AI Applications with the Nx AI Manager,” tutorial at the May 2024 Embedded Vision Summit.
In this presentation, van Emden covers the basics of scaling edge AI solutions using the Nx tool kit. He emphasizes the process of developing AI models and deploying them globally. He also showcases the conversion of AI models and the creation of effective edge AI pipelines, with a focus on pre-processing, model conversion, selecting the appropriate inference engine for the target hardware and post-processing.
van Emden shows how Nx can simplify the developer’s life and facilitate a rapid transition from concept to production-ready applications.He provides valuable insights into developing scalable and efficient edge AI solutions, with a strong focus on practical implementation.
In his public lecture, Christian Timmerer provides insights into the fascinating history of video streaming, starting from its humble beginnings before YouTube to the groundbreaking technologies that now dominate platforms like Netflix and ORF ON. Timmerer also presents provocative contributions of his own that have significantly influenced the industry. He concludes by looking at future challenges and invites the audience to join in a discussion.
Goodbye Windows 11: Make Way for Nitrux Linux 3.5.0!SOFTTECHHUB
As the digital landscape continually evolves, operating systems play a critical role in shaping user experiences and productivity. The launch of Nitrux Linux 3.5.0 marks a significant milestone, offering a robust alternative to traditional systems such as Windows 11. This article delves into the essence of Nitrux Linux 3.5.0, exploring its unique features, advantages, and how it stands as a compelling choice for both casual users and tech enthusiasts.
TrustArc Webinar - 2024 Global Privacy SurveyTrustArc
How does your privacy program stack up against your peers? What challenges are privacy teams tackling and prioritizing in 2024?
In the fifth annual Global Privacy Benchmarks Survey, we asked over 1,800 global privacy professionals and business executives to share their perspectives on the current state of privacy inside and outside of their organizations. This year’s report focused on emerging areas of importance for privacy and compliance professionals, including considerations and implications of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies, building brand trust, and different approaches for achieving higher privacy competence scores.
See how organizational priorities and strategic approaches to data security and privacy are evolving around the globe.
This webinar will review:
- The top 10 privacy insights from the fifth annual Global Privacy Benchmarks Survey
- The top challenges for privacy leaders, practitioners, and organizations in 2024
- Key themes to consider in developing and maintaining your privacy program
Observability Concepts EVERY Developer Should Know -- DeveloperWeek Europe.pdfPaige Cruz
Monitoring and observability aren’t traditionally found in software curriculums and many of us cobble this knowledge together from whatever vendor or ecosystem we were first introduced to and whatever is a part of your current company’s observability stack.
While the dev and ops silo continues to crumble….many organizations still relegate monitoring & observability as the purview of ops, infra and SRE teams. This is a mistake - achieving a highly observable system requires collaboration up and down the stack.
I, a former op, would like to extend an invitation to all application developers to join the observability party will share these foundational concepts to build on:
How to Get CNIC Information System with Paksim Ga.pptxdanishmna97
Pakdata Cf is a groundbreaking system designed to streamline and facilitate access to CNIC information. This innovative platform leverages advanced technology to provide users with efficient and secure access to their CNIC details.
How to Get CNIC Information System with Paksim Ga.pptx
Ohlin lecture
1. 1933 AND 1977 - SOME EXPANSION POLICY PROBLEMS IN CASES
OF UNBALANCED DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC
RELATIONS
Nobel Memorial Lecture, December 8, 1977
by
BERTIL OHLIN
Stockholm, Sweden
I. Introduction
The economic history of the last half century offers two cases of serious international
depressions in countries with an essential orientation towards a market economy: In the first
half of the 1930ies and in the middle of the 1970ies. With some simplification one can say
that in the former case recovery started after a few years without the aid of much conscious
expansionist policy. An adaptation of the external values of the currencies took place in
Northern Europe and in some British Dominions in 1931. It came almost two years later in
the United States and in 1936 in Southern Europe. In the 1970ies, on the other hand, internal
policy measures for expansion1 have been numerous and far-reaching in almost all
industrial nations except some with weak balances of payments. They have been
accompanied by numerous adaptations of foreign exchange rates to relative cost levels. Yet
the recovery which started in 1975 and 1976 has not been more forceful – perhaps instead
somewhat slower and more hesitant than in the earlier case - in spite of the more serious
breakdown of large parts of the banking system in the 1930ies. The immediate impression of
these facts is hardly favourable to a policy of expansion built on the macro-economic theory
developed in the thirties chiefly at Cambridge and in Stockholm.2 But closer investigation
and comparison is necessary.
The limited time at my disposal for this lecture makes it necessary for me to jump
straight into a problem analysis, presenting some facts as I go along. Let me also mention
that by the term “expansion” I mean a rising gross national product in monetary terms (GNP)
and by contraction I mean the opposite. In some connections it will be clear that I have the
net income - which does not include “depreciation allowances” - in mind.
II. Keynesian and Stockholm Models For Expansion of Output and Employment.
Among the theories which attempt an explanation of changes in employment and may be
relevant for a comparison of recovery problems in the thirties and the seventies, I cannot
pass over Keynes’ underemployment equilibrium ideas.
_________
1 The fact that the expansive policy in 1976-77 proved insufficient to bring about the desired economic development
does not justify to call this policy “restrictive”.
2 Similar ideas were current also among Australian economists although with less support of basic theory.
2. B. Ohlin 319
Keynes pointed out that-given a certain propensity to consume-an increase
in the volume of investment would bring about an increase in the national
income until it reaches a size which makes people willing to save an amount
equal to the value of the investment. The change in the national income is the
variable which had to reach a magnitude which is compatible with equality
between savings and investment. The conclusion was important. If the volume
of investment is increased the volume of employment would rise much more.
This was an abbreviated form of a reasoning that was included also in the
theory which the so-called Stockholm School built on the foundation of Wick-
sell’s cumulative process. But the Swedish theory took into account also the
indirect and endogeneous increase in investment which would be caused by
the expansion of the national income. And this secondary investment would
bring about a further growth of income and savings. Furthermore, in the paral-
lel work which took place in Stockholm while Keynes and his pupils worked
at Cambridge, we tried to give a concrete picture of the reactions of savings
by business firms and the public treasury, not only by individuals, thereby
presenting a more realistic account of the propensity to save which I as a rule
called “intention to save”.1 I also tried to pay attention to the speed of reac-
tions between price and income changes for different groups of people in
processes of expansion and contraction, in order to find out something about
the effects that would be dependent on the order of events. Large commodity
stocks, e.g. of wheat, will intensity price reductions in the case of falling de-
mand. This would reduce incomes of farmers and merchants and their pur-
chases of other goods much quicker than the cost of bread purchases would
decline. Consumers would only slowly save money on cheaper bread and
increase their other purchases. This process took place in 1929 and exercised
a depressing influence on total demand.
Furthermore, the flexibility of prices and wages and the relation between
them would affect the development of profits which would play a role for the
process of expansion. All this was important for a study of the effects of policies
which aimed at increased employment and output with only small inflation.
Could an increase in investment bring about a rise in prices e.g. through an
upward pressure on wages rather than in the quantity output. Keynes’ answer
was in general in the negative. Contrary to many earlier assumptions he as a
rule assumed that, in cases where the unused supply of labour was large, the
flexibility upwards for wages was very small. Price flexibility in the beginning
of the recovery was assumed to be a little larger but still rather small. Hence,
an increase in aggregate demand early in a recovery phase would expand
output and employment. There would be almost no general wage increase but
some minor price increase. Profits would rise and investments might be further
stimulated, although this was not built into his basic equilibrium model.
1
See “Monetary Policy, Public Works, Subsidies and Tariffs as Remedies for Unem-
ployment”, (1934). -- An excellent survey of the scientific debate about Keynes’
theory is found in “On Keynesian Economics and the Economics of Keynes” by Axel
Leijonhufvud (1968).
3. 320 Economic Sciences 1977
The process outlined in Stockholm was not much different although more
attention was paid both to investment reactions and to the nature of expectations
concerning future prices for raw materials as well as finished products. But
there was on the whole agreement between the Keynesian group and the young
Stockholm economists that public investments financed by borrowing-in such
a manner that credits to business firms were not restricted but expanded if
necessary-would lead to a rise in production and employment without neces-
sarily much inflation as long as excess capacity was utilized.
Unfortunately, the conservatism of the British administration and a large
labour conflict in Sweden from early April 1933 until February 1934 prevented
an experiment on a large scale until a time when recovery was well under way
for other reasons. Then the restrictions on municipal expenditure in Sweden
in 1934 largely offset the expansive effect of the growing state financed invest-
ments.
An experiment on a much larger scale was carried out in Germany after
1933 under the leadership of Dr. Schacht and extensive central bank financing.
The result was a large increase in employment which continued several years
without much inflation. The administration checked wage increases and by
extended rationing measures weakened the price driving forces.
The 1970ies.
Let me compare these experiences with what happened in the seventies,
leaving some ups and downs of certain raw material prices aside. In most
industrial countries an expansive financial policy has been pursued in 1975-
77 under conditions of general expectations that price inflation would remain
strong. Wage demands and wage rates were substantially increased in the
beginning of the decade, oil prices were suddenly substantially raised towards
the end of 1973. Prices rose more or less in accordance with wages per unit
of output and the extra cost of oil and some raw materials. Production varied
with the business cycle but in some countries with only a faintly rising trend-
weaker than in the 1960ies. In some countries like Sweden cost levels were
too high-due to appreciation of the “krona” and substantially rising wages.
Hence the balance of trade from 1975 became weak and employment declined.
In several other countries a recovery started hesitatingly in 1975 but a set back
took place in the following year until some rise in output started again. All
the time unemployment remained on a high level and yet prices and costs of
living were rising, although with reduced force.
Evidently, some essential reasons for this unfavourable development can be
found in the high upward mobility of wages, in the unbalanced foreign exchan-
ge relations and in the general expectations of continued cost inflation, during
a period of expansive finance policies in most countries and expansive credit
policies in several countries through low levels of real rates of interest under
the influence of inflation which reduced the value of debts.
The early theories in the thirties were built on the assumptions of low wage
flexibility and moderate price expectations. This was realistic at that time but
had no contact with reality in the seventies. This explains why the so-called
4. B. Ohlin 321
Phillips’ curve is no longer relevant-as explained by professor Milton Fried-
man in the last year’s excellent Nobel lecture. Professor Friedman emphasized
the difference between an inflation which is expected-as in the seventies-and
one which is not foreseen when business firms make profit calculations for the
future. It took a long time before a general recognition of this fact found its
due place in the debate on employment policy.
I do not deny that the theory of expansion which was developed in Stock-
holm in the early thirties was deficient in not explaining clearly enough the
role of the different assumptions about the flexibility and speed of reactions of
wages, raw material prices and the prices of manufactured products and the
alternative possibilities of profit expectations. But more attention than in the
Keynesian model was given to these matters-and to the external balance.
The future cost-price relation may, of course, appear as unfavourable for
other reasons than rising labour costs per unit of output. Raw materials have
in several recovery periods been available only at rising prices, which may
cause risks for future losses.
It is also possible that a fall in the value of foreign currencies may cheapen
imported manufactured goods. This can mean unsatisfactory profit conditions
and, possibly, pessimistic profit expectations for the future.
I have chosen a few unbalanced price, cost and foreign exchange relations
to exemplify the obvious possibility that they may counteract tendencies to
expansion. Such unbalanced relations and consequent pessimistic expectations
were numerous in 1934 and 1935 in countries like France and Switzerland
which put off devaluation of their currencies until 1936, while most of the
other countries had devalued much earlier. Apart from brief periods after
the depreciation of the currency, e.g. in the United States in 1933,
there was no general expectation of a general rise of the price level nor were
wage costs going up or expected to do so in the near future, except in the
United States-particularly in 1933-34. As soon as sales volumes of export
goods started to grow under the stimulus of currency depreciation and the
cheapening of such goods on the world market-profits rose and the outlook
became more optimistic. This illustrates the great importance of the adapta-
tion of international cost relations and foreign exchange rates, a question I
shall return to. In the last few years there are other examples of a similar kind,
e.g. in France, which this time was quicker with a reasonable depreciation than
in the thirties.
So far I have said next to nothing about the great difference in interest
rates between the depressions in the early thirties and in the middle seventies.
Was the relatively greater force of the economic recovery in the former period
perhaps due to low interest level in the industrialized countries, whereas the
much higher interest level served as a break the recovery in the seventies?
In my opinion the answer is “No”. As a matter of fact, in spite of higher
nominal interest rates, it was cheaper to borrow capital in the seventies than
in the thirties. The influence of price level changes on the real value of the
sums one had to repay should be taken into account.
5. 322
From 1929 retail and wholesale prices were falling several years-longer
in the gold standard countries-and rising a few per cent in the following
period. Nominal bond yields in the leading countries-except Germany with
a level around 8 per cent-lay between 4 and 5 per cent-with a falling ten-
dency for some years. It is uncertain how much expectations of price level
changes influenced the borrowers’ opinion in the thirties about the “real”
interest they had to pay. The interest level was, in any case, positive not only
before 1933 but also in the following years. In the middle of the present dec-
ade, on the other hand, the rate of inflation and probably the expected price
rise in most countries exceeded the bond yield. Hence, “real” interest rates were
negative and remained negative or around zero to 1976 in most industrialized
countries, except Switzerland, where the inflation was insignificant. The
interest rate on middle term bank credit was higher everywhere and the
“real” level was often positive, but it does not much alter the picture. The
general impression is that in most industrialized countries borrowing was
cheaper in the seventies than in the thirties.
The “hesitant” character of the recovery in 1975-77 no doubt had more to
do with the restrictive credit policies in countries with “weak” payment balan-
ces, like Great Britain, Italy and Scandinavia-whereby the effects of an expan-
sive public finance policy was more or less offset-than with the “high” level
of interest charges. In countries with “strong” payment balances and general
confidence in the economic future, the interest policy did not deprive the
economic policy of its expansive character, e.g. in the United States and West
Germany where budget deficits were considerable, and a moderately expansive
policy of public expenditure was pursued. The net total effect of national eco-
nomic policy in weak and strong payment balance countries could be assumed
to be expansive.
The unfavourable factors include the monopoly price increase for oil and
the inability of the oil exporting countries to spend their new extra income.
Among the other circumstances which made profit expectations insufficient for
prosperity in the world economy one must reckon the rapid rise in labour
costs and the expectations that cost increase might outrun price increase, which
spread in business circles in many countries. This was one if the chief differen-
ces between the recovery periods in the 30ies and the 70ies.
Another difference was no doubt the fact that the percentage reduction in
world output and employment during the downward phase of the recession
was several times greater in the 1930ies than in the 1970ies. For this reason
surplus capacity when recovery started was greater-in percentage terms-in
the former period that in the latter. Without many “bottle necks” output
could grow more and the process of expansion could gather greater strength. On
the other hand, the relatively greater surplus capacity limited the stimulus to
new investment which may have weakened the forces making for recovery.
6. B. Ohlin 323
III. The Relative Size of Inflation and of Production Growth When National
Income in Monetary Terms Is Expanded-under the Influesace o f Different
Policies and Conditions.
How is a policy of expansion of GNP in value terms to lead to as much pro-
duction and as little inflation as possible? This is a question of great practical
importance. Some economists belonging to the monetarist school are inclined
to believe that a policy which raises the national income in terms of money-
starting from a position with considerable unemployment-will in most cases
bring much inflation and only a small increase of output. The opinion among
the expansionistic economists in the thirties was more optimistic. They believed
that it would be possible -- under the then existing conditions-to obtain a
large increase in output with only a little inflation. There is still a large group
of economists who hold an optimistic opinion, in spite of some gloomy recent
experiences.
My previous reasoning seems to point in the direction that a great many
circumstances will be able to influence the development, i.e. determine the
share of increase in GNP which takes the form of inflation and increased
production respectively. This seems to be a problem where-following Alfred
Marshall-one is justified in saying: “All brief statements are wrong”.
At which stage of the recovery will producers and traders in a certain in-
dustry start increasing their prices ? My impression is that it will as a rule hap-
pen before the stage of full utilization of capacity is reached, but that rules
of behaviour vary from one country to another and change gradually. Much
depends on with utilization that is regarded as “normal” and what the market
outlook is for the near future. The influence of price control can be essential
as in Germany in the thirties, but small in other cases. If there is a general
expectation in the world that production in manufacturing industries will
expand, a speculative rise in raw material prices may come at an early stage
and lead immediately to somewhat higher prices for the finished products.
Expectations of this sort may lead to an increase in commodity stocks at all
stages of activity, which means an increased demand for primary products and
a further upward movement of their prices.
Evidently the behaviour of the world markets for primary products make
it much easier for an individual country to expand without inflation than it
is to bring about a world wide international recovery without inflation.
In general it can be said-with the abovementioned qualifications-that
the greater and the more evenly spread the surplus capacity is, the smaller
the inflation will be as a result of a certain expansion measure. Naturally, the
spread of unemployment among skilled workers, the wage policy of trade unions
and the possiblility of “wage sliding”, particularly in industries with piece
rate payment systems, will play a great role. It may also exercise a contagious
effect on wage rates in other industries.
The question I raised was the following: Which kind of policy of expansion
can lead to relatively large increase in output and employment and a relative-
ly small degree of inflation: It will be a political decision to determine what is
to be considered an optimum combination, i.e. the best choice between margi-
7. 324 Economic Sciences 1977
nal “trade off” between one per cent more output and a certain per cent less
inflation at different stages of development. A number of policy aspects can
stimulate output and counteract inflation. They can change the optimum
position and can only be enumerated in this lecture.
1. The policy makers and the business world need knowledge about the
relevant conditions. It is not always easy, e.g. to get a true picture of the local
and inter-industry spread of surplus capacity with regard to labour and fac-
tories. If the facts in these respects are made generally known, it will help
industry to plan resource utilization e.g. increased supply of raw materials,
available when and where it is needed.
2. Stimulus to the private and public demand for the types of goods and
services which can be produced through a better utilization of the existing
capacity and available stocks of primary products and with the aid of new
capacity, which can be created within reasonable time. Public works fall under
this heading.
3. Counteract if possible disturbances in demand conditions which create
new and uneven surplus capacity.
4. Stimulate and facilitate movements of labour between places and regions
and between different occupations. Organise additional training for people
from all industries including agriculture, who want to qualify for new jobs.
Counteract a possible preference of some persons to live on social assistance
rather than seek a new job in new places or new occupations.
All these things and some others will facilitate an increase in output, as a
result of a selective increase in demand. With regard to the task of a weaken-
ning of the forces making for inflation I shall now mention some policy aspects
that can be essential.
5. Use strategic price control in some periods to counteract price increases
that go beyond the rise in costs and reasonable profits. This is particularly
important if monopolistic organisations will otherwise raise prices to obtain
profits that are generally regarded as unjust and bad to high wage claims.
6. Discourage tendencies to wage and salary increases which go beyond the
rise in costs of living and in productivity. (See section IV).
7. Attempt a general agreement between government, parliament and orga-
nisations that inflation should be kept back in accordance with a definite goal.
Lead in this way the price expectations away from anticipations of a contin-
ued inflation of the size of the preceding decade in industrialised market
economy countries.
8. Use a flexible monetary system which can reduce the value of foreign
currencies to counteract the effects of an inflation abroad if it is a natural part
of a policy to avoid deflation.
This kind of policy is naturally coordinated with the general policy of credit
and finance, which affects the aggregate volume of demand. The policy makers
have to make the “trade off” between the different possible combinations of
output and inflation. The goal is to find a “Pareto optinum”, where no possible
increase in output is worth the price of the consequent extra inflation and no
8. B. Ohlin 325
possible reduction of inflation is worth the sacrifice of accepting the consequent
reduction of output.
The speed of the process of expansion of aggregate purchases, which is
called forth in this way will affect the character and durability of the develop-
ment. E.g. the adaptation of the supply of labour with regard to regional
location and quality will better correspond to the demand for labour if reasona-
ble time is available for the adjustment. This may be one reason why many
observers with practical experience from business hold the opinion that a
recovery will go further and that the high level of activity will last longer, if
the expansion is not speeded up excessively through measures to increase
aggregate demand. A cautious procedure also permits the gaining of insight
through “trial and error”.
The problem have here been seen from the point of view of an individual
country. Several extra difficulties and problems are created by the shifting
developments in different countries and their influence on international econo-
mic relations. See the last section of the lecture.
An analysis in equilibrium terms of the conditions of simultaneous internal
and external balances-a subject where a pioneer work has been done by
James Meade in “The Theory of International Economic Policy” (1951)--can
provide a helpful basic insight. Even though it is seldom directly applicable to
the study of a process of change in output and in price levels, it can give
indications as to which kind of such changes, that is a movement away from
the Pareto optium.
IV. Further Observations On the Increase of Real Income and the Limitation
of Inflation In a Phase of Expansion.
How is a continuation of an inflation of the magnitude which the industrialized
countries have experienced in the last decade to be avoided? My analysis
can be brief as there is a considerable agreement between economists about this
question, although the difficulties in making such policy effective in real cases
are great for social and political reasons. Insight in this matter is important
for successful policies which aim at an expansion of real income.
It is a generally accepted procedure to make a distinction between three
types of inflation. The first is “demand inflation” which occurs when the
aggregate demand exceeds the value of the aggregate supply at existing prices.
The sum total of consumers demand and investment demand coming from
domestic or foreign sources exceeds the value of the supply, which also has
its origin both at home and abroad. In other words, there is a lack of general
monetary balance. It is often caused by an increase in private investment
demand or demand for public purposes but can also be due to an expansion
of consumers’ purchases connected with a reduction in the disposition to save on
the part of individuals and business firms, as well as public authorities. A
characteristic of this kind of inflation is usually that the excess of demand
leads to increased business profits. Business incomes rise quicker than costs.
The second type of inflation can be called "cost and monopoly inflation”.
It is often due to the pressure of increased wage rates or new or higher wage
9. 326 Economic Sciences 1977
taxes. In these cases the cost of labour in production is moved upwards more
than productivity. In the absence of special obstacles, e.g. foreign competition,
the consequence is rising commodity prices but not rising profits. It occurs
sometimes that demand inflation is superimposed on cost inflation.
However, cost and monopoly inflation may also be caused by monopolistic
price increases at home or abroad. The leading instance is the lifting of the
price of oil to three or four times its former level a few years ago. The con-
sequence was higher costs throughout industries which need large quantities
of energy and higher commodity prices. If the credit systems of the different
countries should refuse to supply the means of payments and volumes of new
credit required for such a development - with the intention of preventing rise
of the price level-the result will be a growth of unemployment.
From the point of view of an individual country a third kind of inflation
is the upward pressure on costs and prices which can be the result of rising
prices abroad, unless this effect is prevented by a rise of the exchange rate
of the domestic currency.
It goes without saying that many difficulties meet a government which-
under present conditions-in cooperation with the central bank tries to avoid
demand inflation, control monopolistic pricing and create conditions where a
trade union pressure or so-called wage sliding does not lead to wage increases
which exceed the average growth of productivity. Besides, to avoid contagious
import inflation due to rising prices abroad-when they are rising -it is
necessary to use a system of flexible foreign exchange rates, which may be
complicated by speculative capital movements. It may, however, sometimes
be assisted by such movements, if a skilful policy of declarations of monetary
goals is used.
There can be no doubt that the greatest problem in the long run is how
to create the situation where excessive wage increases are avoided. In a country
like Sweden the share of the national income after deduction of taxes, which
goes to wage earners and salaried people is normally above 80 per cent. The
extra income which is due to monopolistic price policies of domestic business
firms is insignificant, except perhaps during boom periods. Foreign monopolies
have played a much greater role in the seventies than the private domestic
monopolies, most of which have to reckon with competition from abroad and,
therefore, are rather “single producers” than real monopolists.
Under the conditions created by high marginal income taxes and expecta-
tions of continued inflation trade unions in Sweden in the last three years
found it necessary to ask for-and obtained-wage increases which-including
wage sliding and increased wage taxes-increased the labour costs almost ten
times as much as the increase in real wages. A system which makes it necessary
to obtain a nominal wage increase of 15 per cent to give a reasonable chance
of an increase in real earnings by 2 per cent can hardly be called rational.
The centralised negotiations between employers and unions are under these
conditions chiefly concerned with the question: how much inflation Sweden is
to have. Only secondarily the issue is how large the increase in real earnings
shall be, but the answers to these two questions hang together. Consequently,
10. B. Ohlin 327
the discussion has run in terms of very high nominal wage increases. This is so
in spite of the fact that the outcome with regard to real earnings during a one
or two year period after the agreement is uncertain as it depends on the un-
known future increase in costs of living.
Evidently-apart from the progressive tax system, heavier through inflation
-one of the main reasons for wage demands which are many times higher
than the rise in productivity is the expectation of continued large inflation.
Here we meet a great difference between the actual situation and the condi-
tions during the depression of the 1930ies. The experience of falling prices from
1929 to 1932 led to the belief that no large rise in the cost of living could be
expected in the first few years. This in turn led to what seems now very modest
wage demands, moderate price increases and low inflation in the following
years even in countries where depreciation had paved the way for recovery.
It is hard to avoid the conclusion that if we are to combine a reasonably
high volume of employment with a greater stability of price levels in the
industrial world in the future than we have had in the seventies, some revision
of the method of collective agreements is called for-in some countries at
least. The trade union members are concerned with real earnings and not
earnings in terms of money. It should not be impossible to negotiate about
what the parties concerned are interested in. If this proves impossible, there
must be some kind of “income policy”, e.g. through agreement between govern-
ments, parliaments and labour market organizations. It can limit the nominal
wage increase without reducing labours’ dominating share of the real national
net income. A system of “index scales” of income taxerates will probably be
necessary.
Besides, it seems inevitable that some adaptation of the foreign exchange
rates must take place now and then, as labour costs, productivity and demand
conditions cannot be expected to follow the same lines in all industrial coun-
tries. The question also arises if the need of foreign exchange variations could
be reduced through some coordination of the relative changes of the wage
demands of the trade unions in different countries. But it is obvious that
enormous difficulties would meet such an attempt.’ When will time be ripe
for an attempt?
V. Brief Observations on the Results of Insufficient Adaptations of Internatio-
nal Cost Relations.
Let me begin with the influence of an adaptation of the foreign exchange
rates on the development of output in an early case. Finland avoided parti-
cipation in the world wide deflation in the beginning of the 1920-ies and
1
A very skilfully made survey of some problems which I have dealt with in this part of
the lecture is to be found in “Inflation and Unemployment” by Lars Calmfors and Erik
Lundberg, Stockholm 1974 (in Swedish). A more recent OECD-investigation “Towards
Full Employment and Price Stability” by seven leading economists from seven industrial
countries under the chairmanship of Paul McCracken, Paris 1977, -- the Swedish member
was Assar Lindbeck - also provides an excellent survey and analysis.
11. 328 Economic Sciences 1977
also suffered less than other North European countries through increased un-
employment and decline in industrial production. From 1920 to 1923-the
period of deflation in Scandinavia and Great Britain, which were close trade
partners of Finland-the Finnish cost of living rose by 22 per cent. The
quotation of the Finnish mark at the same time fell by 46 per cent. Finnish
wage costs were in the rest of the 1920ies relatively low compared to in most
European industrialised countries.
More important for my lecture is the influence of the depreciation of the
British and Scandinavian currencies in the autumn of 1931-by roughly 27 per
cent for the pound and a little over 30 per cent for the Scandinavian curren-
cies. The Italian lire followed a similar course. But the dollar was depreciated
by 40 per cent in the course of 1933 and the Scandinavian currencies slided
down to about the same relative position. while pound sterling was kept a
little higher in its relation to gold. The French and Swiss currencies were
kept stable in gold until the autumn of 1936, when they also were depreciated.
Without going into the differences with regard to the development of
relative wage costs-which differences were much smaller than the foreign
exchange variations-it is possible to draw some conclusions about the effects
of the changes in competitive power, which took place as between Great Britain
and Scandinavia, on the one hand, and France, on the other.
1929 100 123 100 115 100 115 100 125 100 168
1931 68 107 84 103 89 117 68 110 96 158
1933 64 94 88 98 77 107 61 96 91 151
1935 76 100 106 100 67 100 94 100 123 155
1937 92 105 124 108 83 128 117 101 149 161
Table I shows that the development of production in industry from 1931
to 1933 was more favourable for the depreciating countries, although Sweden
-where output was almost as high in 1931 as two years earlier-suffered
from a delayed recession and the special Kreuger crisis in 1932. The countries
with fixed gold value currencies saw their industrial output decline. In France
the drop from 1931 to 1935 was about 25 per cent, while the index for Great
Britain rose by 26 per cent and for Sweden by 28 per cent. In Germany the
enormous expansion of public activity chiefly for rearmament brought about
a large increase in output and employment, in spite of the high quotation of
the mark. Import restrictions were used to keep the foreign trade deficit
down.
The development in the United States was affected by a quite different
“economic policy program” from the summer of 1933 when the policy of the
Roosevelt regime got going. From 1929 to 1931 industrial production declined
by 32 per cent and by a further 6 per cent in the following two years. Then,
12. B. Ohlin 329
in the first two-years periods, came an increase of output by 17 per cent and 21
per cent respectively. But these figures hide the fact that the volume index
rose from 63 in the first quarter of 1933 to 100 in July and then fell to 73 in
November. It remained on this low level for 13 months to November 1934.
Only thereafter did the lasting recovery start! This serious set back is a
problem in itself.
I must confine myself to some brief observations. The recovery program-
started in the first half of 1933-which aimed at higher wages-brought an
end to pessimistic price expectations in many circles, which stimulated produc-
tion. However, it became gradually more and more evident that to increase
the price of something you want to sell-in this case labour-was not an
effective means of stimulating the sales, i.e. the demand for labour and employ-
ment. A certain distrust of “government intervention on a large scale” persua-
ded important business circles to “wait and see”. If prices were expected to
rise as much as wage rates, expected profits would not go up, unless one could
be reasonable certain of an increased future volume of sales, which the business
world was not in the beginning. This I maintain is one of the main reasons
why the original optimism in many American business circles disappeared and
a set-back in production came.
There was, however, after some time a considerable stimulus to American
export industry from the increase of competitive power due to the devalua-
tion of the dollar and from improvement in business in some European and
other countries. The import competing home market industries also got a
better chance. Besides, some government measures to stimulate private build-
ing and large public works exercised positive effect on production. Under
such conditions the cheapening of credit and the reorganisation of the credit
system could assist also. However, the wrong method to increase demand for
labour, must have delayed and weakened the recovery. To what extent “time
was ripe” for an ordinary upswing of the business cycle-once the expectations
of continued price decline had vanished-is impossible to say without detailed
analysis of all possibly relevant facts.
Let me now turn to the 1970-ies and inquire if here, like in the 30-ies, one
can trace an influence of unbalanced relative cost relations in different coun-
tries due to maladjusted foreign exchange rates.
Like France and other gold standard countries in the years 1931-36 some
countries in the seventies kept the international quotations of their currencies
on too high levels. Internal cost developments were not sufficiently or only
belatedly taken into consideration. In other countries the devaluation was
excessive. The fall in the external value of the dollar, pound sterling and lira
brought difficulties e.g. for French industry, until a downward movement of
the quotation of the French franc in the middle of the decade helped to restore
the competitive ability of the French industry. The overvaluation of the
currency lasted longer in Sweden, where in the two years 1975 and 1976
labour costs rose by 42 per cent, while the external value of the Swedish
13. 330 Economic Sciences 1977
currency was raised by 8 per cent relative to the average quotation of the
currencies that were important for Swedish trade. The result was a growing
loss of markets for Swedish export industry and great difficulties for some
import competing domestic industries as well. Naturally, the changing structure
of the world economy, e.g. textiles, steel and wharfs also played a significant
role.
The failure to adapt the foreign exchange rates when internal costs rose
differently in different countries also brought some other indirect negative
effects for the world economy, which made themselves felt not only in coun-
tries with “overvalued” currencies, but also in countries with a long lasting
inflation, a falling external value of its currency and a “lack of confidence” i.e.
pessimistic expectations and a flight of capital. Profit expectations were
unsatisfactory in countries like Great Britain and Italy, although their
currencies were not “overvalued”.
The direct and indirect negative effect of overvalued currencies was well
known already in the 1930-ies. It was emphasized particularly by J. M. Keynes,
when Great Britain had returned to the old gold parity in 1925, without a
natural balance with costs in the chief competing countries. When finally the
pound was depreciated in 1931, Keynes reaction was optimistic. In a letter I
received a few days later he wrote: “We in Great Britain are living in a state
of boisterous cheerfulness over the events of the last week!” (24th sept 1931).
It may be worth while to add some brief comments on the Swedish econo-
mic development in the periods after the devaluation of its currency in the
early 1930-ies, the late 1940-ies and in the present year 1977. As I have already
mentioned, there was only a very insignificant expansionary economic policy
in the years 1932-1935, although much more had been planned. Some years
the contraction in the municipal financial policy offset the expansion of the
state. But, a rising demand for Swedish exports from the autumn of 1932 and
the relatively low Swedish costs after a depreciation around 40 per cent in the
years 1931-33 brought a substantial recovery in the Swedish economy, which
lasted until the second world war. Particularly for a small country, an under-
valued currency seems to have a very considerable expansionary effect-
particularly after a certain lapse of time.
This conclusion is corroborated by the Swerish development after the depre-
ciation of the “krona” by 30 per cent in 1949. Swedish costs became relatively
low and the competitive power remained large during many years thereafter, in
spite of substantial wage increases. A very favourable economic development
characterized Swedish industry in practically the whole of 1950-ies.
In the last few years, the opposite Swedish development, which I have indi-
cated for 1975-76, brought a larger labour cost increase than in most coun-
tries, which had the opposite effects on output and employment. They
stagnated and declined.
Competitive prices based on relatively low money costs in some countries
seem to exercise a favourable influence on industry in those countries but
probably a negative effect on other countries. This, however, depends a great
deal on the reaction of profits and profit expectations.
14. B. Ohlin 331
The impression gained is no doubt that a better international cost balance
in the 1970-ies would have made the competitive power of different countries
more “normal”. It would also have increased confidence in business, dimin-
ished certain speculative capital movements and led to a more efficient conglo-
merate of measures for economic expansion. To avoid an “overvalued” curren-
cy is, evidently, not a sufficient condition for such profit expectations and
investment volumes, that are necessary for the maintenance of high employ-
ment. But the maladjustment of relative cost levels seems in many cases-both
in the 1930-ies and the 1970-ies-to have been one of the major causes of an
unfavourable development of employment.
The erratic development of relative production costs in different countries
and of the external currency values, could, of course, be modified so as to im-
prove the international cost balance and, reduce discrepancies in competitive
power. The International Monetary Fund or some other institution could
serve as an expert advisory agency with regard to minor depreciations and
appreciations of the currencies in the member countries. IMF-rules of be-
haviour with regard to the relation between cost level variations and foreign
exchange rates could be laid down in the same way as the codex of principles
for trade policy by the GATT. It is conceivable that thereby the conditions
for reasonable policies of expansion could be improved from a world econom-
ic point of view.
It should not be overlooked, however, that a natural depreciation of a
currency of a country with an excessive cost level will make international cost
relations during a considerable period of time more natural only if the price
raising effect of the depreciation does not lead to considerable extra labour
cost increases or an unfavourable development of productivity. If it does, infla-
tion will get new force and an international cost relation maladjustment will
continue.