Designing and using open pedagogies for the 5Rs: the Opening Educational Practices in Scotland experience
OEPScotland presentation given by Anna Page at OpenEd15 in Vancouver, 18 November 2015
Similar to OEPS presentation at OpenEd15 - Designing and using open pedagogies for the 5Rs: the Opening Educational Practices in Scotland experience (17)
OEPS presentation at OpenEd15 - Designing and using open pedagogies for the 5Rs: the Opening Educational Practices in Scotland experience
1. Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Designing and using open
pedagogies for the 5Rs: the
Opening Educational Practices in
Scotland experience
Anna Page (OEPS), 18 November 2015 for OpenEd15
2. 2
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Project aims
The Opening Educational Practices in Scotland project aims to facilitate
best practice in open education in Scotland. It will do this through
• the development of a peer
support network
• an online hub and awareness
raising activities
Image source: drawn by Anna Page for the OEPScotland project CC-BY
https://www.flickr.com/photos/127972386@N04/shares/KGVnD7
3. 3
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Project objectives
The project encompasses a number of activities over a three
year period (2014-2017):
• Analysis of current open educational practices
• Events programme across Scotland to raise awareness of OEP
• Development of an online hub to encourage and share best practice in
open education
• Development of a small number of high quality OERs of particular benefit
to Scotland
• Badging of informal learning
• Learning design for widening participation
• Research and evaluation building a strong evidence base
• Evaluation of various economic models of openness
4. 4
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Developing practices - themes
Widening participation /
transitions from informal to
formal learning
(OEP rather than OER)
Widening participation /
transitions from informal to
formal learning
(OEP rather than OER)
Partnership
working
Partnership
working
Partners in well
established
networks
Partners in well
established
networks
Individuals
who have
facilitating
roles – learning
champions
Individuals
who have
facilitating
roles – learning
champions
Embedding open
practice in learning
networks
Embedding open
practice in learning
networks
Extending learning
design and practice –
use of materials in
social setting
Extending learning
design and practice –
use of materials in
social setting
Learn from existing OER
practices/approaches,
work with Small/Medium
Enterprises
Learn from existing OER
practices/approaches,
work with Small/Medium
Enterprises
5. 5
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
OEPS is currently working with …
• 12 Universities
• 3 Colleges and 1 pan-College sector organisation
• 6 Third sector organisations
• 1 Football club
• 3 Trade Union organisations
• 13 National or Regional organisations
• 2 Research institutes
• 1 EU funded project
6. 6
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Developing a network and sharing practice
• Informal meetings and dialogue
• Open education workshops
• Learning design workshops
• Advisory forum every 6 months
• Conferences and seminars
• Project blog www.oepscotland.org
• Open Educational Practices site
www.oeps.ac.uk including
community functionality
• OER platform improvements
http://www.open.edu/openlearnworks/
7. 7
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Open Badges
• Currently 5 open badges created
under the umbrella of OEPS and
being used at scale (all hosted in the
OpenLearn Works platform)
• OEPS is working with partners to
create badged courses
• Learners are more likely to trust a
badge if it is issued by a credible
organisation – Open University
Badged Open Courses (OU BOCs) are
proving very popular with learners
who want to show what they have
learned online
8. 8
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Development of new content and new practices
Working in partnership for the 5Rs
• External organisations new to open learning may have some
material to share
• They may already use traditional methods of teaching/training
• Seek to get wider exposure and uptake of their material – OER is one
way of doing this
• Keen to harness collaborative working through supportive networks
but not sure how to start
• OEPS works with partners to explore what openness and the power
of their existing networks might do which they might not have been
able to do before
• Aim to embed open practices within networks or organisations
9. 9
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Development of new content and new practices
How ‘open’ – public
scrutiny at course
development or
community review
stages?
How ‘open’ – public
scrutiny at course
development or
community review
stages?
How ‘open’ – initial
discussions before
committing to share
How ‘open’ – initial
discussions before
committing to share
OEPS helps identify
uncertainties, build
expertise, revise partner
content
OEPS helps identify
uncertainties, build
expertise, revise partner
content
Develop course
using appropriate
open practices
Develop course
using appropriate
open practices
Partner more
confident about
developing next
course in open
Partner more
confident about
developing next
course in openEvaluate
feedback,
review
open
practices
Evaluate
feedback,
review
open
practices
If positive experience
& successful courseIf positive experience
& successful course
Evaluation exposes
negative issues
Evaluation exposes
negative issues
Partner
informed about
what does and
doesn’t work
Partner
informed about
what does and
doesn’t work
Overcoming barriers
10. 10
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Development of new content and new practices
Issues and observations
• Materials may exist online already but not in a format best suited for
online learning
• Learning Design discussions to work out the audience and reasons
for creating an online version take time
• A series of discussions might be needed for partners to understand
about OER, open licenses, possible course structures and
assessment options, including badging
• A sample production schedule is a crucial tool in early meetings as it
helps inform discussion, expectations, roles, responsibilities and
future planning leading to an actual production schedule
11. 11
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Development of new content and new practices
Issues and observations
• Encouraging a partner to compile an asset register helps them
re-evaluate the content they want to share
• Involve partner in production
• OEPS is documenting the production process to share openly for
others to try out and revise for their context
• Once the first partner created OERs are made live later this year, case
studies will be written and shared on the OEPS hub
12. 12
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Case Study – a UK national health charity
Face to face workshops for
health care workers
Face to face workshops for
health care workers
Workbooks and
activities
Workbooks and
activities
Video and
Audio assets
Video and
Audio assets Shared Workbooks
as open PDFs
online
Shared Workbooks
as open PDFs
online
Scale and Reach limitedScale and Reach limited
F2F Learner feedback
positive
F2F Learner feedback
positive
RetainRetain
13. 13
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Case Study – a UK national health charity
Create open online course based
on Workshop materials, including
video & audio assets
Create open online course based
on Workshop materials, including
video & audio assets
Quiz 1Quiz 1
Quiz 2Quiz 2
Quiz 3Quiz 3
Quiz 4Quiz 4
Quiz 5Quiz 5
Self-reflection
log
Self-reflection
log
Course badgeCourse badge
Later maybe formal accreditationLater maybe formal accreditation
Some kind of informal
accreditation
Some kind of informal
accreditation
Reuse, Revise and RemixReuse, Revise and Remix
14. 14
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Case Study – a UK national health charity
Learning Design
workshops – identified
audience, aims, tools
for delivery
Learning Design
workshops – identified
audience, aims, tools
for delivery
Partner compiled
Asset list to keep track
of assets and
copyright permissions
Partner compiled
Asset list to keep track
of assets and
copyright permissions
Video introductions to
each section filmed
Video introductions to
each section filmed
Quiz 1Quiz 1
Quiz 2Quiz 2
Quiz 3Quiz 3
Quiz 4Quiz 4
Quiz 5Quiz 5
Video re-filmed to
with new re-use
permissions
Video re-filmed to
with new re-use
permissions
Some images
re-drawn for
online
animation
Some images
re-drawn for
online
animation
Questions in workbooks
re-written for online quizzes
Questions in workbooks
re-written for online quizzes
Workbook content
revised slightly
Workbook content
revised slightly
Activities
reviewed
Activities
reviewed
Reuse, Revise and RemixReuse, Revise and Remix
15. 15
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Case Study – a UK national health charity
Release new open
course on an open
platform
Release new open
course on an open
platform
Partner compiled Asset
list to keep track of
assets and copyright
permissions
Partner compiled Asset
list to keep track of
assets and copyright
permissions
Hold open online events
focussing on the course
themes
Hold open online events
focussing on the course
themes
Encourage learners
to share and discuss
via social media
Encourage learners
to share and discuss
via social media
RedistributeRedistribute
RetainRetain
Scale and Reach wideScale and Reach wide
CC licence allowing others to
reuse and remix for their
context
CC licence allowing others to
reuse and remix for their
context
Promote the course to
network of contacts
Promote the course to
network of contacts
Invite and analyse
feedback, share
findings on OEPS hub
Invite and analyse
feedback, share
findings on OEPS hub
Learners show
badge online
Learners show
badge online
16. 16
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
OEPS Hub Vision
The OEPS hub provides an encouraging and engaging place to learn
more about open educational practices.
It enables users to:
• UNDERSTAND about OER and Open Educational Practices
• FIND useful OER
• Provide tools to DO open – finding, remixing, building
• Have a place to DELIVER their OER to the public
23. 23
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Good practice guidance
Case studies from those who practice open education or use OER in an
effective or innovative way (there is a route for people to offer case studies)
Online courses and guidance:
• How to do OEP (Creating OER and Good OEP) – coming soon
• How to create OER on the platform (OpenLearn Works) – already
on OLW
• How to add badges to your OER on the platform (OpenLearn
Works) – coming soon
24. 24
Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
OpenLearn Works to OpenLearn Create
Existing OER platform hosted by the OU
Free public space for
people to run their own
open learning projects or
share OER
25. OpenLearn Create – creating and
re-versioning courses
OER1 – course
learner
Draft course in OLC –
experimental sharing space
for OER creators to
collaborateGuidance/good
practice
(OEPS site, OLC
how to guide)
becomes
OER2 – copy of course
re-versioned for other
learners, purpose
learner
learner
learner learner
learner
Experience of OER
creation feedback to
guidance
Experience of OER
re-versioning
feedback to guidance
Feedback
and
evaluation
copied
26. OpenLearn Create – creating open courses
Embedded or
linked video
Statement of
Participation
Textual
contentimages
Quizzes Open
Badges
Forums
Interactive
glossaries
Blogs
Polls
Feedback
and
evaluation
Choice of
Creative
Commons
licences
User stats and data
dashboard for reports
and analytics
Remixing and
re-versioning
content
OER
search
Peer
assessment
Exportable
and accessible
formats
Multiple
languages
RSS/XML
feeds
User profile
(creator and
learner)
27. Opening Educational Practices in Scotland
Contact Us: Email:
OEPScotland@gmail.com
Social media:
@OEPScotland
www.oepscotland.org
www.oeps.ac.uk
Editor's Notes
The Opening Educational Practices in Scotland project facilitates best practice in Scottish open education. We aim to enhance Scotland’s reputation and capacity for developing publicly available and licenced online materials, supported by high quality pedagogy and learning technology.
PROMISE AND CHALLENGE
Free access to high quality education on a mass scale
Widening participation
MEET THE CHALLENGE
Redraw the boundaries between informal and formal learning and between community/workplace learning and college/university learning
Combine best practice in adult and community education pedagogy with the affordances of open education to widen participation
Widening participation and transitions from informal to formal education (develop OER practices that support participation and transition) – OEP rather than OER
Partnership working with partners who- are already embedded in well established networks- where individuals play intermediary or facilitating roles with fellow workers or clients (e.g. helping ULRs become learning champions)
Embedding open practice in learning networks
Extending learning design and practice to include the use of materials in social settings
Learning from the practices and approaches associated with existing OERs (e.g. Rural Entrepreneurship course – working with SMEs)
Open education practices draws in a lot of different educational practices.
OEPS is interested in practices about designing learning in, for and through openness as well as educational practices that support learning in the open.
Open to beyond the academy, bring in learners who are distanced from mainstream education, via partnerships and networks that those potential learners already trust.
design, structure and support, partnership, networks, social models of learning
This partnership approach is important to OEPS – we’re using it both with HE and organisations outside the academy. The range of organisations who are interested in and starting to engage in open educational practices goes beyond the traditional formal learning routes of FE and HE.
Some OEPS project activities
Our work so far indicates that OpenBadges might be a crucial enabling factor.
However like anything based on value and trust they will only be valued by learners if they have a currency that people can trust, and there is a lot of work to do in this area.
We are working with some partners to test out how badging might enable their learners to progress from informal to formal learning.
Might have published workbooks to accompany f2f workshops
Cannot just assume “built it and they will come” – work with them to identify users, needs, behaviours and methods which would work best for their context
Barriers to open working
Partners may not want to expose the initial discussions about their plans to explore ‘open’ – they may want to understand the options and possible routes to sharing materials before committing to share assets openly – brave to do open
How ‘open’ – public scrutiny at course development stage or later at community review stage? - Even after committing to share assets, partners may want to work only with OEPS team to develop the assets for online use rather than expose the development of their online courses or resources to public scrutiny as they are built, even if there are advantages with public scrutiny
OEPS works with them to identify where uncertainties exist and where expertise is needed to complement and strengthen what the partner is proposing to share openly
In the future, after developing one course and gaining confidence, partner might be more willing to develop course in the open from the start
It is quite brave to openly build a course for many to critique as it evolves.
For these reasons because we’re currently working with some partners whose open materials are in development, I’m not going to say who they are yet, however what the project is learning as we help them develop open courses I can share.
For example a series of PDFs of workbooks which are used in a f2f workshop may not transfer into an guided online learning experience particularly well
Sometimes a series of LD discussions are needed to familiarise the partner with open learning concepts and practices – this needs to be built into the timescale for the project with the partner
A production schedule can help expose all the steps that might need to be taken depending on what the OER is likely to include
Compiling the asset register reminds the partner to seek copyright information about the assets they wish to use and to confirm that they can share them openly. For example some video they might previously have used in f2f sessions might not have the relevant permission from participants for sharing on the open web so may need to be re-filmed or placed online behind a password.
Taking care of the actual production on behalf of a partner can risk preventing them from learning how to do it themselves, so keeping the partner involved in every step and decision is importantIt is very tempting to take complete control as it might seem quicker but the whole purpose is to embed unfamiliar practices by learning together – empowering them to do it for themselves another time
- Partner with subject expertise redrafts their existing material with OEPS team providing guidance on appropriate pedagogy- Ideal if the partner has someone to do the content upload otherwise OEPS arranges this activity
We’re in the process of documenting the production processes we’ve been adopting so far with partners and noting when issues arise which might not have come about in an internal OU context. This will be shared online.
Previously delivered face to face workshops for health care workers about the condition to improve understanding and care
Workshop resources included a series of workbooks and activities about the condition, also video and audio assets
The resources are pedagogically robust and received positive feedback from learners in the f2f workshops
Charity shared the workbooks as open PDFs online
Want more people (family of sufferers, other health professionals) to benefit from the resources but cannot deliver the workshops at scale
Partner would like the option for those studying the open course online to be able to gain some kind of informal accreditation for working through the materials (the face to face course has a certificate)
Learners can compile a reflection log as they work through the course
A series of quizzes are designed to reinforce learning and lead towards gaining the course digital badge
Later there are plans to seek formal accreditation for learners who complete the badge and submit a reflection log – so the quizzes have to be fair and robust to be officially recognised by accreditation bodies
OEPS has guided the charity through the learning design workshop process to help them identify the audience for the online course and most appropriate tools for delivery
OEPS has made use of the Open University’s long standing guided learning expertise to revise the materials for online learning
Video footage has been re-shot, sometimes with the same subjects, as the original footage didn’t always carry the correct permissions for sharing openly online, introduction videos for each section have also been filmed
Some images and tables have been re-designed for online animation to make them more engaging, though with accessibility issues kept in mind
The OEPS hub helps users UNDERSTAND what OER and open educational practices are – it will provide an encouraging and engaging place to learn more about open educational practices.
It helps users FIND useful OER.
It will provide users with a simple set of tools to DO open – finding, remixing, building resources for their learners
It will provide a place where users can DELIVER their OER services to the public.
The OEPS hub home page is a portal to a number of things:
a guidance section introducing users to OER and OEP concepts and good practice
Links to open educational practice case studies
The OER search
Communities
News about OEPS and open educational practices (blog & tweets)
An events calendar for OEPS events (workshops, advisory forum, webinars)
It will showcase OEP projects which may be hosted elsewhere
The OEPS hub get started page signposts the various resources on the site including the OER aggregated search which will search OER repositories and collections from around the world (not just Scotland or the UK).
The OEPS hub using OEP page
The OEPS hub create your own page
The site allows users to create or join communities in the OEPS hub to support each other using OER in practice in their particular context. They can:
import existing or newly created Google forums into their OEPS Community space (in future they will also have the option to set up a Drupal forum hosted within the community space on the site),
set up a twitter feed to relevant twitter account,
pull in links to relevant Open Educational Resources
showcase individual projects or resources in their community,
Share experiences via a community blog,
An events calendar where users can post up events which are of interest to the community.
This is the OEPS community home page.
We are currently compiling case studies of open educational practice in action and the OEPS hub encourages users to suggest case studies
The course on how to do OEP is being created at the moment with the first part out for community review this week.
The guidance course on how to create OER in OLW is already available on OpenLearn Works and has been used by a Moodle novice to publish her OER which is currently being used by a cohort of learners.
How to add badges will come later – currently if you want your course to have badges OpenLearn Works managers can set it up for you. We want to make it possible for any course creator to set up their own badges and completion criteria on the platform.
The OEPS hub links to OpenLearn Works, which is an existing OER building sandbox and repository site.
OpenLearn Works has been built with contributors in mind.
Users could find some existing OER and rework it on OLW. Or they can publish their own open content on OLW.
The site is Moodle based for open course materials publishing and hosting.
OpenLearn Works draws on the OU’s expertise to facilitate good online pedagogy and open educational practice. It allows the creation and delivery of educational content for free.
OpenLearn Works was created as a sandpit area for experimenting and creating OER. We are developing further features to support learners as it becomes a live course hosting space.
It is a place where the OU and others course creators can model their open educational practice to help learners using OER hosted on OLW to have a good learning experience.
Guiding principles:
Content available openly and for free (unless in a closed cohort)
Content released under CC licence
Site promotes and shares good open pedagogical practice
No advertising on the site