Building on Innovation:
Competing in the 21st Century
Sweeping Away the Old Rules

• Globalization

• Technology

• Demographics
Infrastructure: Ports
Employment Changes 1990 -2011
                Manufacturing              Professional and Business Services   Education and Health Services
U.S. Metro      1990    2010    % Change   1990     2010        % Change         1990     2010     % Change
RESEARCH TRI.    76.9    62.1     -19%      62.4    121.4          95%           51.6    118.5       130%
SAN DIEGO       123.4    90.7     -26%     124.1    198.8          60%           84.1    147.4       75%
PHILADELPHIA    246.9   130.1     -47%     213.6    286            34%          278.3    434.5       56%
WASHINGTON       50.8    35.2     -31%     289.8    557.8          92%          152.7    280.6       84%
BALTIMORE       128.5    59.5     -54%     123.1    191.4          55%          145.8    244.6       68%
SAN FRAN        170.5   113.4     -33%     275.7    339.8          23%          173.7    235.5       36%
PITTSBURGH      130.6    85.5     -35%     126.6    155.6          23%          160.2    239.8       50%
NEW YORK        867.0   367.6     -58%     957.4   1529.9          60%          1008.1   1257.4      25%
DENVER           84.8    59       -30%     129.5    202.6          56%            72     143.9       100%
NEW ORLEANS      46.9    31.2     -33%      52.6    68.6           30%           58.7     76.8       31%
USA             17695   11743     -34%     10848   16991           57%          10984    19838       81%




                           Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics (OES);
Education and Health Services:
   Rebuilding after Katrina




                                   All Employees, In Thousands


    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics (OES);
The Trend Setters
•Seniors from 65-75 will be the fastest growing
group this decade
•Will grow from 28 to 42 million – a 50% growth
by 2020.
                  •Children of the 60s, have
                   redefined every age they
                   entered
                  •When will they retire? For
                   most, not for years
Gen Y
• Late teens to early 30s - 83 million

• The largest generation in US history

• At the prime household formation age
Building a 21st Century City

•   Well Managed
•   Vibrant
•   Educated
•   “Raw Materials”
•   Entrepreneurial
•   Capital availability
Denver: Bond Issue
• In 2004, Fastrak Referendum
• $2 Billion Bond Approval
• 119 miles of light rail
• 7 Counties & 32 Municipalities
Vibrant:
Parks, Culture & Design




                     Millennium Park, Chicago
Weathering the Economic Storm




   Source: The College Advantage, Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce
Education:
 Changes in Educational Attainment, 1990-2010
                    % HS Grad      % Bachelors      % Grad Degree
U.S. Metro             1990   2010     1990    2010      1990     2010

Research Triangle      82%     88%        20%       26%         12%          18%
Philadelphia           76%     87%        14%       19%         8%           13%
San Diego              82%     85%        16%       22%         9%           13%
Boston                 81%     91%        17%       24%         11%          18%
Seattle                88%     91%        21%       24%         9%           13%
New York               75%     84%        15%       21%         11%          14%
Baltimore              75%     88%        14%       20%         9%           15%
San Francisco          82%     87%        22%       27%         13%          17%
Pittsburgh             77%     91%        12%       17%         7%           11%
Denver                 86%     89%        20%       25%         9%           13%
New Orleans            78%     87%        14%       16%         8%           9%
U.S. Total             75%     85%        13%       18%         7%           10%

                             Source: American Community Survey, U.S. Census Bureau
Singapore and Jamaica, 1960-2011
   Per Capita income
             Singapore   Jamaica
   1960       $ 5,100     $5,200
   2011       $ 43,000    $8,000
Raw Materials
TOTAL 2010 U.S. R&D INVESTMENT: $395,800,000,000




                                Source: Battelle, R&D Magazine
Raw Materials
Annual R&D Spending by Country




                Source: Battelle, R&D Magazine, OECD, IMF, CIA
Raw Materials
• Scripps Research Institute (TSRI) biomedical research
  facility, Florida: $310M Public Funds

• Louisiana State University Medical Center and Veterans
  Administration complex, New Orleans: $2B in Federal and
  State Funds

 • Cleveland Clinic and the Lou
   Ruvo Brain Center, Las Vegas:
   $100M part of a larger
   development plan known as
   Symphony Park--a $2.8B
   investment.
High-tech industry is a bright spot in an otherwise
             gray economic picture




  High-tech jobs have grown nearly four times faster than overall
               economy during the past 18 months.
Entrepreneurial:
              Research Triangle
It is now the largest
high-tech research
park in North America,
boasting 20 million sq.
ft. of developed space,
and home to 157
companies, employing
39,000 people. It is a
center of innovation.
UC, San Diego
Torrey Pines Mesa
Johns Hopkins
Forest City Science + Technology Park
Central Florida: “Medical City”
• Sanford-Burnham Research Institute biomedical
  research facility, Florida: $310M Public Funds
• Since 2006, 5,000 jobs created
• University of Florida's Research and Academic Center
• Nemours Children's Hospital
• Orlando Veteran's Affairs Medical Center
• UCF College of Medicine
Pittsburgh
The Collaborative Innovation Center at
                Carnegie Mellon
JOBS                                   State of the Art facility adjacent
To be Created: 489                     to Carnegie Mellon University that
                                       will:
NEW PROPERTY TAXES
Collected During TIF: $239,000          ◦ Attract Private technology
Collected After Expiration: $598,000      firms to expand research
                                          and education
SPURRED INVESTMENT                        collaborations
$55 Million
                                        ◦ Accelerate development of
                                          new technologies

                                        ◦ Support growth of
                                          region's technology
                                          industry base
From Vacant Nabisco Building to Google
               Offices
Ben Franklin Partnership
• At 25, Ben Franklin Technology Partners is one of the
  nation’s longest-running technology-based economic
  development programs.
• BFTP has provided both early-stage and established
  companies with funding, business and technical
  expertise and access to a network of innovative, expert
  resources.
• Goal: To accelerate technology development and
  commercialization in the state of Pennsylvania, and to
  create high-paying, sustainable jobs for Pennsylvanians.
• Serve as catalysts for economic growth.
• Launched with high hopes in 1983, BFTP has a 3.5-to-1
  return on investment that the organization has yielded
  for every state dollar invested.
Venture Capital Availability:
       International




         Source: Dow Jones VentureSource, 2008; PriceWaterhouseCoopers,
                                    National Venture Capital Association
Capital Availability:
                    Regional
Region                      By Millions                  % of Total
USA                         $ 17,222                         100%
Silicon Valley              $ 6,990                            40%
New England                 $ 2,161                            12%
NY Metro                    $ 1,413                             8%
Southeast                   $       986                         6%
LA/Orange County            $       943                         5%
San Diego                   $       903                         5%
Midwest                     $       740                         4%
Northwest                   $       705                         4%
Texas                       $       645                         4%
Dc/Metroplex                $       546                         3%
Philadelphia Metro          $       424                         2%
Other US                    $ 1,235                             7%

                                         Source: Dow Jones VentureSource, 2008;
                     PriceWaterhouseCoopers, National Venture Capital Association
Venture Capital & Universities
                         Venture Capital
             Start-Ups   Investment ($M)
  2000           0       $     -
  2001           3       $     -
  2002           0       $     -
  2003           1       $    0.5
  2004           0       $     -
  2005           0       $     -
  2006           2       $    5.0
  2007           3       $    1.0
  2008           5       $    8.2
  2009           1       $   17.0
  2010           1       $     -


TOTAL UNIVERSITY R&D:
• Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center:$59,473,000
• Tulane: $153,242,000
Principles of Success




       1-2 December 2009
1. Leadership

2. Strategy

3. Institutional
   Capacity
                   Hong Kong
4. Financing
   Infrastructure

5. Education

6. Design
   Excellence

        Highline Park, New York City
Where Will the New Roads Lead…

Nola bio lunch 2012(4)

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Sweeping Away theOld Rules • Globalization • Technology • Demographics
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Employment Changes 1990-2011 Manufacturing Professional and Business Services Education and Health Services U.S. Metro 1990 2010 % Change 1990 2010 % Change 1990 2010 % Change RESEARCH TRI. 76.9 62.1 -19% 62.4 121.4 95% 51.6 118.5 130% SAN DIEGO 123.4 90.7 -26% 124.1 198.8 60% 84.1 147.4 75% PHILADELPHIA 246.9 130.1 -47% 213.6 286 34% 278.3 434.5 56% WASHINGTON 50.8 35.2 -31% 289.8 557.8 92% 152.7 280.6 84% BALTIMORE 128.5 59.5 -54% 123.1 191.4 55% 145.8 244.6 68% SAN FRAN 170.5 113.4 -33% 275.7 339.8 23% 173.7 235.5 36% PITTSBURGH 130.6 85.5 -35% 126.6 155.6 23% 160.2 239.8 50% NEW YORK 867.0 367.6 -58% 957.4 1529.9 60% 1008.1 1257.4 25% DENVER 84.8 59 -30% 129.5 202.6 56% 72 143.9 100% NEW ORLEANS 46.9 31.2 -33% 52.6 68.6 30% 58.7 76.8 31% USA 17695 11743 -34% 10848 16991 57% 10984 19838 81% Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics (OES);
  • 5.
    Education and HealthServices: Rebuilding after Katrina All Employees, In Thousands Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics (OES);
  • 6.
    The Trend Setters •Seniorsfrom 65-75 will be the fastest growing group this decade •Will grow from 28 to 42 million – a 50% growth by 2020. •Children of the 60s, have redefined every age they entered •When will they retire? For most, not for years
  • 7.
    Gen Y • Lateteens to early 30s - 83 million • The largest generation in US history • At the prime household formation age
  • 8.
    Building a 21stCentury City • Well Managed • Vibrant • Educated • “Raw Materials” • Entrepreneurial • Capital availability
  • 9.
    Denver: Bond Issue •In 2004, Fastrak Referendum • $2 Billion Bond Approval • 119 miles of light rail • 7 Counties & 32 Municipalities
  • 10.
    Vibrant: Parks, Culture &Design Millennium Park, Chicago
  • 11.
    Weathering the EconomicStorm Source: The College Advantage, Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce
  • 12.
    Education: Changes inEducational Attainment, 1990-2010 % HS Grad % Bachelors % Grad Degree U.S. Metro 1990 2010 1990 2010 1990 2010 Research Triangle 82% 88% 20% 26% 12% 18% Philadelphia 76% 87% 14% 19% 8% 13% San Diego 82% 85% 16% 22% 9% 13% Boston 81% 91% 17% 24% 11% 18% Seattle 88% 91% 21% 24% 9% 13% New York 75% 84% 15% 21% 11% 14% Baltimore 75% 88% 14% 20% 9% 15% San Francisco 82% 87% 22% 27% 13% 17% Pittsburgh 77% 91% 12% 17% 7% 11% Denver 86% 89% 20% 25% 9% 13% New Orleans 78% 87% 14% 16% 8% 9% U.S. Total 75% 85% 13% 18% 7% 10% Source: American Community Survey, U.S. Census Bureau
  • 13.
    Singapore and Jamaica,1960-2011 Per Capita income Singapore Jamaica 1960 $ 5,100 $5,200 2011 $ 43,000 $8,000
  • 14.
    Raw Materials TOTAL 2010U.S. R&D INVESTMENT: $395,800,000,000 Source: Battelle, R&D Magazine
  • 15.
    Raw Materials Annual R&DSpending by Country Source: Battelle, R&D Magazine, OECD, IMF, CIA
  • 16.
    Raw Materials • ScrippsResearch Institute (TSRI) biomedical research facility, Florida: $310M Public Funds • Louisiana State University Medical Center and Veterans Administration complex, New Orleans: $2B in Federal and State Funds • Cleveland Clinic and the Lou Ruvo Brain Center, Las Vegas: $100M part of a larger development plan known as Symphony Park--a $2.8B investment.
  • 17.
    High-tech industry isa bright spot in an otherwise gray economic picture High-tech jobs have grown nearly four times faster than overall economy during the past 18 months.
  • 18.
    Entrepreneurial: Research Triangle It is now the largest high-tech research park in North America, boasting 20 million sq. ft. of developed space, and home to 157 companies, employing 39,000 people. It is a center of innovation.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Johns Hopkins Forest CityScience + Technology Park
  • 21.
    Central Florida: “MedicalCity” • Sanford-Burnham Research Institute biomedical research facility, Florida: $310M Public Funds • Since 2006, 5,000 jobs created • University of Florida's Research and Academic Center • Nemours Children's Hospital • Orlando Veteran's Affairs Medical Center • UCF College of Medicine
  • 22.
  • 23.
    The Collaborative InnovationCenter at Carnegie Mellon JOBS State of the Art facility adjacent To be Created: 489 to Carnegie Mellon University that will: NEW PROPERTY TAXES Collected During TIF: $239,000 ◦ Attract Private technology Collected After Expiration: $598,000 firms to expand research and education SPURRED INVESTMENT collaborations $55 Million ◦ Accelerate development of new technologies ◦ Support growth of region's technology industry base
  • 24.
    From Vacant NabiscoBuilding to Google Offices
  • 25.
    Ben Franklin Partnership •At 25, Ben Franklin Technology Partners is one of the nation’s longest-running technology-based economic development programs. • BFTP has provided both early-stage and established companies with funding, business and technical expertise and access to a network of innovative, expert resources. • Goal: To accelerate technology development and commercialization in the state of Pennsylvania, and to create high-paying, sustainable jobs for Pennsylvanians. • Serve as catalysts for economic growth. • Launched with high hopes in 1983, BFTP has a 3.5-to-1 return on investment that the organization has yielded for every state dollar invested.
  • 26.
    Venture Capital Availability: International Source: Dow Jones VentureSource, 2008; PriceWaterhouseCoopers, National Venture Capital Association
  • 27.
    Capital Availability: Regional Region By Millions % of Total USA $ 17,222 100% Silicon Valley $ 6,990 40% New England $ 2,161 12% NY Metro $ 1,413 8% Southeast $ 986 6% LA/Orange County $ 943 5% San Diego $ 903 5% Midwest $ 740 4% Northwest $ 705 4% Texas $ 645 4% Dc/Metroplex $ 546 3% Philadelphia Metro $ 424 2% Other US $ 1,235 7% Source: Dow Jones VentureSource, 2008; PriceWaterhouseCoopers, National Venture Capital Association
  • 28.
    Venture Capital &Universities Venture Capital Start-Ups Investment ($M) 2000 0 $ - 2001 3 $ - 2002 0 $ - 2003 1 $ 0.5 2004 0 $ - 2005 0 $ - 2006 2 $ 5.0 2007 3 $ 1.0 2008 5 $ 8.2 2009 1 $ 17.0 2010 1 $ - TOTAL UNIVERSITY R&D: • Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center:$59,473,000 • Tulane: $153,242,000
  • 29.
    Principles of Success 1-2 December 2009
  • 30.
    1. Leadership 2. Strategy 3.Institutional Capacity Hong Kong
  • 31.
    4. Financing Infrastructure 5. Education 6. Design Excellence Highline Park, New York City
  • 32.
    Where Will theNew Roads Lead…