Neuromyths
A few things that we thought we knew but it turns
 out are not quite what we thought they were …
We only use 10% of our brain
                • We use all of our brain –
                  this is why a stoke is so
                  devastating
                • Not all the brain is active
                  at one time – but multiple
                  areas are at work at the
                  same time
                • A number of areas active
                  even when we are “doing
                  nothing”
Listening to classical music makes you smarter

• The “Mozart” effect
• Based on study on college
  students – small localised
  effect
• However, learning to play a
  musical instrument does
  have a beneficial cognitive
  effect improving
  coordination, confidence
  and concentration
You can’t make new brain cells
                 • You make new cells all the
                   time but at different rates
                 • Your brain does remain
                   adaptable [plastic] – the
                   connections can change all
                   through your life
                 • Adults can generate new
                   cells – some drugs being
                   developed
                 • Activity reduces the rate of
                   degeneration
The first years of life are crucial for success ..

• There are some periods in which neural
  pathways form more easily
  [synaptogenesis and synaptic pruning]
• Some functions have optimal periods for
  learning (language) but this cannot be
  generalised some periods are more
  sensitive for learning than others
• The links between early success and later
  achievement are mostly an effect of
  social factors and hard work
VAK and other learning styles

           • Promoted by Vester (1975) and
             promulgated by many others since
           • These are all input modes into the
             sensory part of the brain – not
             learning which is the processing of
             this information
           • Variety does appear to be the spice
             of life. We have access to a wide
             variety of senses to gather
             information (at least 10)
Brain Gym – Educational Kinesiology

• The idea of cerebral dominance (Dennison)
• Linked to the idea that the development of
  the individual should mimic the
  development of the species
• Aerobic exercise supports increased oxygen
  supplies which may effect learning.
• There do seem to be brain benefits with a
  healthy body – but general heath not
  exercises before a class
We need to drink lots of water
     • Promoted as a way to improve learning
       (Cohen and Goldsmith)
     • Is true that dehydration can impact on
       cognitive ability – but so can overhydration
       (Vreeman)
     • Thirst is an automotive function – the body
       is self-regulating
     • Comes from the myth of “needing to drink
       6-8 glasses of water a day
Omega-3,6 – “fatty acids” are brain foods
• High ratios of Ω6:Ω3 Highly Saturated Fatty
  Acids(HUFAs) are linked to increase in
  somediseases
• Rations have increased in the last 10,000
  years from 1:1 to 6:1
• Mixed evidence that increase in Ω3 aids with ADHD
• Taking of supplements linked to higher cognitive success
• However, supplements tend to be bought by higher Socio-
  Economic groups
• Where there are links between Ω3 and brain function this
  also correlates to a generally better diet (Bellisle)
Too much chocolate etc…

          • Sugar is an aid to concentrations
          • Poor behaviour often linked to
            expectations
          • No evidence of link between sugar
            levels and poor behaviour –
            thought high sugar often linked
            with poor general diet
          • Some evidence that additives in
            food impact on hyperactivity
We are right or left brained

• There are areas of the brain
  which take primary control over
  certain functions
• However secondary and tertiary
  areas also are in use
• Primary functionality is not a
  correlation to cognitive usage
• MRI scanning indicates that
  highly creative / cognitive people
  are using multiple brain areas
References
"Neural Connections: some you use, some you lose" by John.T.Bruer in the
December 1999 issue of Phi Delta Kappan, pages 264 – 277

http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/28/13/31706603.pdf - Access. October 2011

Understanding the Brain: Towards a New Learning Science, OECD 2002,
Chapter 4.6 pp.69-77

Howard Jones, P (2009) Introducing Neuroeducational Research,
Neuroscience, Education and the Brain from Contexts to Practice, Routledge

Neuroscience and Education: Issues and Opportunities: A Commentary by the
Teaching and Learning Research Programme

The Neuroeducational research network -
http://www.neuroeducational.netAccess. Oct 2011

Neuromyths

  • 1.
    Neuromyths A few thingsthat we thought we knew but it turns out are not quite what we thought they were …
  • 2.
    We only use10% of our brain • We use all of our brain – this is why a stoke is so devastating • Not all the brain is active at one time – but multiple areas are at work at the same time • A number of areas active even when we are “doing nothing”
  • 3.
    Listening to classicalmusic makes you smarter • The “Mozart” effect • Based on study on college students – small localised effect • However, learning to play a musical instrument does have a beneficial cognitive effect improving coordination, confidence and concentration
  • 4.
    You can’t makenew brain cells • You make new cells all the time but at different rates • Your brain does remain adaptable [plastic] – the connections can change all through your life • Adults can generate new cells – some drugs being developed • Activity reduces the rate of degeneration
  • 5.
    The first yearsof life are crucial for success .. • There are some periods in which neural pathways form more easily [synaptogenesis and synaptic pruning] • Some functions have optimal periods for learning (language) but this cannot be generalised some periods are more sensitive for learning than others • The links between early success and later achievement are mostly an effect of social factors and hard work
  • 6.
    VAK and otherlearning styles • Promoted by Vester (1975) and promulgated by many others since • These are all input modes into the sensory part of the brain – not learning which is the processing of this information • Variety does appear to be the spice of life. We have access to a wide variety of senses to gather information (at least 10)
  • 7.
    Brain Gym –Educational Kinesiology • The idea of cerebral dominance (Dennison) • Linked to the idea that the development of the individual should mimic the development of the species • Aerobic exercise supports increased oxygen supplies which may effect learning. • There do seem to be brain benefits with a healthy body – but general heath not exercises before a class
  • 8.
    We need todrink lots of water • Promoted as a way to improve learning (Cohen and Goldsmith) • Is true that dehydration can impact on cognitive ability – but so can overhydration (Vreeman) • Thirst is an automotive function – the body is self-regulating • Comes from the myth of “needing to drink 6-8 glasses of water a day
  • 9.
    Omega-3,6 – “fattyacids” are brain foods • High ratios of Ω6:Ω3 Highly Saturated Fatty Acids(HUFAs) are linked to increase in somediseases • Rations have increased in the last 10,000 years from 1:1 to 6:1 • Mixed evidence that increase in Ω3 aids with ADHD • Taking of supplements linked to higher cognitive success • However, supplements tend to be bought by higher Socio- Economic groups • Where there are links between Ω3 and brain function this also correlates to a generally better diet (Bellisle)
  • 10.
    Too much chocolateetc… • Sugar is an aid to concentrations • Poor behaviour often linked to expectations • No evidence of link between sugar levels and poor behaviour – thought high sugar often linked with poor general diet • Some evidence that additives in food impact on hyperactivity
  • 11.
    We are rightor left brained • There are areas of the brain which take primary control over certain functions • However secondary and tertiary areas also are in use • Primary functionality is not a correlation to cognitive usage • MRI scanning indicates that highly creative / cognitive people are using multiple brain areas
  • 12.
    References "Neural Connections: someyou use, some you lose" by John.T.Bruer in the December 1999 issue of Phi Delta Kappan, pages 264 – 277 http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/28/13/31706603.pdf - Access. October 2011 Understanding the Brain: Towards a New Learning Science, OECD 2002, Chapter 4.6 pp.69-77 Howard Jones, P (2009) Introducing Neuroeducational Research, Neuroscience, Education and the Brain from Contexts to Practice, Routledge Neuroscience and Education: Issues and Opportunities: A Commentary by the Teaching and Learning Research Programme The Neuroeducational research network - http://www.neuroeducational.netAccess. Oct 2011