Narrative Coherence and Fidelity: American Protest Songs Communication Theory  20.11.2009
Some Reminders (Tues. Lecture) Storytelling defines human nature  Stories create reasons to agree Rooted in time and space Explains all human experience  3 Elements Symbolic actions Sequence and meaning People who live, create and interpret Aristotle  Pathos Ethos
Narrative Coherence (pp. 302-3) Lines of Arguments  Aristotle’s Topoi or Topics  Accepted set of reasons  Comparison to stories of a similar theme Genre: a grouping of similar stories  Characters: Reliable Action  Characters must act consistently (internal coherence)
Narrative Fidelity : 4 Criteria (p. 304)   Truthful and humane Greater human truth Kindness to others  Ideal audience  Share the values Timeless values Like “truth”, “the good”, “justice”, and “friendship” Shared values cause action
Protest Music  American popular music form  Response to social injustice Women’s lives  Environmentalism  War  Civil Rights Movement Hunger/Poverty
“ Big Yellow Taxi ” Written and Performed by Joni Mitchell Environmental Statements  “ Paved paradise and put up a parking lot” “ Took all the trees, put ‘em in a tree museum”  “ Hey farmer, farmer put away that DDT now”
“ We Are the World”  Written by Michael Jackson Performed by  USA for Africa  USA for Africa created after the American Music Awards  Singers on the album include Michael Jackson, Bruce Springsteen, Cyndi Lauper, Stevie Wonder, Bob Dylan, Tina Turner, Billy Joel Quincy Jones Produced
“ We Are the World” Analysis  Friendship/Family  “ We are all a part of/God's great big family”  The Good “ When you're down and out/There seems no hope at all/But if you just believe/There's no way we can fall”  Justice There's a choice we're making/We're saving our own lives/It's true we'll make a better day/Just you and me
“ That’s What Friends Are For ” Written by Burt Bacharach and Carol Bayer Sager  Benefit 1985 American Center for AIDS Research Dionne Warwick and Friends  Stevie Wonder, Gladys Knight, Elton John
“ That’s What Friends are For” Analysis  Friendship “ Well, you came and opened me/And now there's so much more I see/And so by the way I thank you”  Human kindness  “ And I never thought I'd feel this way / And as far as I'm concerned / I'm glad I got the chance to say / That I do believe I love you ”
“ We Shall Overcome ” The anthem of the US Civil Rights Movement  Published in 1947 “People’s Song Bulletin”  Used by  United Farm Workers The Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association Promisekeepers
“ We Shall Overcome” Analysis Friendship “ Walk hand in hand” Safety “ We are not afraid”  Freedom “ We shall all be free” “ We shall overcome” Future “ some day”
Some Summary  These songs address  The environment Hunger/poverty AIDS/HIV Civil Rights  By telling us stories  Humane truth  Social justice

Narrative Coherence And Fidelity

  • 1.
    Narrative Coherence andFidelity: American Protest Songs Communication Theory 20.11.2009
  • 2.
    Some Reminders (Tues.Lecture) Storytelling defines human nature Stories create reasons to agree Rooted in time and space Explains all human experience 3 Elements Symbolic actions Sequence and meaning People who live, create and interpret Aristotle Pathos Ethos
  • 3.
    Narrative Coherence (pp.302-3) Lines of Arguments Aristotle’s Topoi or Topics Accepted set of reasons Comparison to stories of a similar theme Genre: a grouping of similar stories Characters: Reliable Action Characters must act consistently (internal coherence)
  • 4.
    Narrative Fidelity :4 Criteria (p. 304) Truthful and humane Greater human truth Kindness to others Ideal audience Share the values Timeless values Like “truth”, “the good”, “justice”, and “friendship” Shared values cause action
  • 5.
    Protest Music American popular music form Response to social injustice Women’s lives Environmentalism War Civil Rights Movement Hunger/Poverty
  • 6.
    “ Big YellowTaxi ” Written and Performed by Joni Mitchell Environmental Statements “ Paved paradise and put up a parking lot” “ Took all the trees, put ‘em in a tree museum” “ Hey farmer, farmer put away that DDT now”
  • 7.
    “ We Arethe World” Written by Michael Jackson Performed by USA for Africa USA for Africa created after the American Music Awards Singers on the album include Michael Jackson, Bruce Springsteen, Cyndi Lauper, Stevie Wonder, Bob Dylan, Tina Turner, Billy Joel Quincy Jones Produced
  • 8.
    “ We Arethe World” Analysis Friendship/Family “ We are all a part of/God's great big family” The Good “ When you're down and out/There seems no hope at all/But if you just believe/There's no way we can fall” Justice There's a choice we're making/We're saving our own lives/It's true we'll make a better day/Just you and me
  • 9.
    “ That’s WhatFriends Are For ” Written by Burt Bacharach and Carol Bayer Sager Benefit 1985 American Center for AIDS Research Dionne Warwick and Friends Stevie Wonder, Gladys Knight, Elton John
  • 10.
    “ That’s WhatFriends are For” Analysis Friendship “ Well, you came and opened me/And now there's so much more I see/And so by the way I thank you” Human kindness “ And I never thought I'd feel this way / And as far as I'm concerned / I'm glad I got the chance to say / That I do believe I love you ”
  • 11.
    “ We ShallOvercome ” The anthem of the US Civil Rights Movement Published in 1947 “People’s Song Bulletin” Used by United Farm Workers The Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association Promisekeepers
  • 12.
    “ We ShallOvercome” Analysis Friendship “ Walk hand in hand” Safety “ We are not afraid” Freedom “ We shall all be free” “ We shall overcome” Future “ some day”
  • 13.
    Some Summary These songs address The environment Hunger/poverty AIDS/HIV Civil Rights By telling us stories Humane truth Social justice