1. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
“Design and Construction of
Mortarless Interlocking Masonry”
Prepared by:
Jesse Edwards, Mina Gayed,
Michael Pyra, & Tisbeth Rodriguez
2. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Goals
Part I
– Introduction: what is mortarless masonry?
– Why was it introduced and what are its benefits?
– Currently available systems
– Design example
Part II
– Construction aspects
• Applications and limitations
– Productivity and cost comparisons
– Case study
3. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Introduction: What is mortarless masonry?
Eliminates the use of mortar
in head and bed joints
Geometric interlocking
mechanisms
Reinforced and grouted
Post-tensioned and surface
bonded
Manufactured with tighter
tolerances for alignment
4. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Current Systems Available
Name of System
(Country, Year)
Block Type
(Material)
Interlocking
Mechanism
Reinforcement
Type
Haener (USA, 1975) Hollow (concrete)
Nibs in bed joint, T&G
in head joint
Vertical &
horizontal
Sparlock (Canada, 1986) Hollow (concrete)
Geometric interlocking
and stacking
Vertical
Mecano (Peru, 1998) Hollow (concrete) No interlocking*
Vertical &
horizontal
Sparfil (Canada, 1989)
Hollow (light-
weight concrete)
No interlocking* None
Whelan-Hatzinikolas-
Drexel (USA, 1992)
Hollow (concrete)
Rounded dovetail lug on
head joint
Vertical
Azar (Canada, 1997*) Hollow (concrete)
3 mechanisms: web key,
head and bed joint face
shell interlocking
Vertical &
horizontal
Silblock (India, 1999) Solid (concrete) Geometric interlocking Vertical
5. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Masonry Statistics
60% of traditional masonry construction is skilled labour
Average age of a skilled mason in the U.S.A. and Canada is
56 years old. (National Concrete Masonry Association)
– Influx of young skilled masons in industry is decreasing
Traditional crew consists of 3 masons and 1 labourer; the
crew is reversed for mortarless masonry
Ex: Construction of house foundation
– 3 unskilled labourers can construct a 1,200 block foundation in 4-5 hours
Up to 10X faster than traditional masonry and cast in place concrete!
6. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Some Benefits
Significant labour savings
Contractors win owners win
Multitude of applications: commercial, industrial, and
residential projects
All weather construction
Fuels masonry growth in
the building sector
Establish masonry as
a competitive material!!
7. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Design Aspects
Given a shear wall:
– 200 mm block, fully grouted
– 3.2 m long and 10.0 m high
– Dead load: 300 kN
– Shear: 200 kN & moment of 1200 kN-m
Given a flexure wall:
– 200 mm block, fully grouted
– 4.0 m high
– Dead load: 150 kN/m
– Live load: 100 kN/m
Design with 30 MPa blocks for both the
traditional and Azar systems using vertical
reinforcement of 15M bars @ 400 c/c
8. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Design Aspects
Shear Wall Flexure Wall (per meter)
Traditional Mortarless Traditional Mortarless
Axial Resistance (kN) 3348 4315 1047 1348
Moment Strength (kN-m) 1660 1680 19.5 22.3
Shear Reinforcement
Yes (15M at
600mm c/c)
No N/A N/A
Diagonal Shear (kN) 270 480 N/A N/A
Sliding Shear (kN) 542 542 115 115
Mortarless masonry is equal to or exceeds traditional
masonry strength!
Note: Mortarless values are based on Azar Block design.
9. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
PART II - Construction
10. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
“Traditional” Applications
The North American market:
– Haener: individual consumer use (primarily Los
Angeles), variable commercial applications
– Sparlock: firewall construction
– Azar: house foundations and firewall construction
The untapped potential of these systems is huge
Large industrial and commercial applications of these
systems have only become more common in the last
decade
11. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Integrated Systems
Integrated Masonry Systems Inc.
(IMSI): cavities for insulation and
electrical wires
Durisol and Faswall: Portland cement
and mineralized wood fibre for high
R-value and ease of handling
Primarily residential applications
IMSI
Faswall
12. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Limitations
Regional building code restrictions
– Ex: Azar Block review by the Canadian Construction
Materials Center (CCMC) for compliance with NBCC:
• Buildings up to 3 storeys and an area of 600 m²
• Wall construction must be fully grouted
• Basement walls cannot exceed 2.5 m in height
• Exterior above-grade walls and interior load-bearing walls
are limited to 20 times the wall thickness
Challenges posed by high initial settlement and
attaining plumb
13. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Productivity and Cost Comparison
Two identical commercial buildings in Edmonton, AB;
one built traditionally and the other with the Azar
system:
– 15 m (W) x 50 m (L) x 4 m (H)
– 200 mm x 200 mm x 400 mm units
– 20M vertical bars at 600 mm spacing
– Grouted every third core (Azar fully grouted)
– Traditional team: 3M-1L (30 blocks/hr)
– Azar team: 1M-3L (300 blocks/hr)
14. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Productivity and Cost Comparison
Time = 1377 hrs (34.4 wks) Time = 505 hrs (12.6 wks)
$141,174
$212,511
$888
Material
Labour
Equipment
$189,360
$76,073
$2,536
Material
Labour
Equipment
$141,174
$189,360 Traditional
Azar
$212,511
$76,073
Traditional
Azar
Material Comparison Labour Comparison
Traditional Construction = $354,573 Azar Mortarless System = $267,969
15. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
2,952 sq. ft. residence
Built in 2006
FlexLock Wall System
Post-tensioned walls
Case Study: Magnolia, Texas
16. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Case Study: Magnolia, Texas
Laying the First Two Courses
Dry-Stacking the Walls
17. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Case Study: Magnolia, Texas
Pouring the Bond Beam Tensioning the Wall
18. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Case Study: Magnolia, Texas
FlexLock performed a comparative cost analysis based
on installed cost of standard 8" masonry in the region:
– Total masonry costs declined by 24%
– Productivity increased by 120%.
19. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Condos in Bois-
Franc Community,
Montreal
Constructed using
the Sparlock
Interlocking
Building System
Mortarless Construction in Canada
20. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Besser Proneq machine
shop in Quebec City
Sparlock blocks use for
the building envelope
Mortarless Construction in Canada
21. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Conclusion
The structural capacity of mortarless blocks is
comparable to standard concrete masonry units
Not suitable for all applications
Mortarless construction is more efficient and cost-
effective than conventional masonry
Mortarless units are becoming more readily available
and have been implemented in many projects around
the world
22. MCAA Chair in Masonry Systems | 2nd Masonry Mini Symposium | University of Alberta | March 30, 2010
Questions?
Sacsahuaman, Peru -1423 A.D.
“ Arguably, the biggest change in the world of concrete masonry
units is the mortarless system.”
(Masonry Magazine)
Editor's Notes
These values should be taken with a grain of salt, especially the diagonal shear strength. It is rather indicative of the excessive conservatism in the standard S304.1