SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 40
Download to read offline
Mission
Impossible?
This Program Just Might
Self-Destruct in 5Years
Welcome to JAAAR
Just About Anywhere Association of REALTORS(R)
Education Task Force
Changing the World of Education
The Mission
• Propose & Answer Critical Questions
about the direction of the Education
program at JAAAR
• Develop a 1:2:3Year Strategic Plan for the
Education Department at JAAAR
• Present & Acquire Approval from the
JAAAR BOD
The Situation
• Like many associations, JAAAR had great
years in the early to mid-2000’s
• Membership has begun to stabilize after
several years of decline (still down 34%
from the highest membership count)
• BOD is concerned about the financials of
the Education Department (negative for
the past 3 years)
The Situation
• During the “glory” days, there were
surpluses
• The surpluses generated/funded many new
initiatives in the Education Department and
elsewhere in JAAAR
• BOD & Committees are leery of taking
things off the “buffet” for fear of losing
members
The Situation
• 4 years ago, JAAAR launched all new online
education partnerships & saw huge increase
in online revenue
• Since the launch, online revenue has leveled
• BOD approved a member week offering free
CE to all members
• This member week event is held 2 months
prior to license renewal
The Situation
• Competition for the education dollar has
increased significantly
• The “Real Estate Commission” has
instituted 1 or 2 mandatory classes
(changing on an annual basis)
• The state association has developed a
strategy to provide these mandatory
classes statewide at large events
The Situation
• JAAAR has maintained a “club house”
approach to offering live CE: meaning
smaller class sizes, more often to
encourage members to come to the
association office
• The education staff was reduced 2 years
ago by 1/3
The Situation
• All instructors are paid contractors
• JAAAR does not pay instructors for course
development time and thus does not own
the course
• JAAAR Marketing Team has been assigned
several other priorities with no addt’l staff
• The training facility was last updated 10
years ago
3 Directives
Profit vs Benefit
Challenges Financials
Profit Center
vs.
Member Benefit
Directive 1
Directive 1
1’s - Profit Center
2’s - Member Benefit
Directive 1
Identify the Pro’s &
Con’s of your
Assigned Approach
Directive 1:TheVote
Challenges In
Education
Directive 2
Directive 2
Blue = Marketing
Red = Generational
Yellow =Value Proposition
Green = Adv. Education
Directive 2
Identify the +’s and
Δ’s ofYour Assigned
Challenge
Directive 2:TheVote
Financials
Directive 3
Directive 3
North – Current Club House Model
East - $49 Unlimited CE paid by all
South – Combine Current Model
with Large Events
West – Dues Increase while offering
Mandatory Hours at No Charge
Directive 3
Identify the +’s & -’s
along with sustainability
of your assigned
Funding Approach
Directive 3:TheVote
Next Steps
Step 1 - Data Gathering
• InYour Sub-Group: Determine what data/
info you already have at hand
• InYour Sub-Group: Determine what other
data/info would like to have before
formulating recommendations
• InYour Sub-Group: Determine what
questions you might have for the other
Sub-Groups
Step 2 - Recommend
• InYour Sub-Group: Formulate
Recommendations
• InYour Sub-Group: Determine if the
recommendation should be forYear 1,Year
2 orYear 3
• InYour Sub-Group: Note if any of your
recommendations could include another
Sub-Group
Step 3 - Reconvene
• As a Task Force: Review all the
recommendations
• As a Task Force: Rank in order of
importance/priority
• As a Task Force:Assign a time (Year 1,Year
2 orYear 3) to each recommendation
• As a Task Force: Determine the final list
Step 4 - Present
• Task Force Chair, Ed Director & Facilitator
develop the draft recommendation.
• Same 3 meet with CEO; CFO; Current
President
• Present and ask for a motion on the
recommendations at the BOD
Step 5 - Implement
Step 1 - Data
Your Assignment Today
So How Did This
Turn Out?
Real World Case
Business Model
Function as a Member
Benefit but run like a
business.
Year 1
• Review current & consider expanding
Broker Curriculum
• Reconsider Pricing Model for FutureYears
• Review Curriculum forVariety of Topic &
Interactivity
• Develop a revised staffing model for
Education Department
Year 1
• Develop an Experience Level Rating for All
Current Courses
• Launch a revised Deliver Model (combo of
club house and large events)
• Launch an Education Competition
Response Task Force
Year 2
• Launch revised curriculum (including
experience ratings)
• Launch revised pricing model
Year 3
• Develop a business case/model for
products and consulting to other
associations
Member Benefit
Investment
The task force supports operating Education
as a member benefit. However, what portion
of dues dollars should be allocated to
subsidize in the event of negative revenue to
expense stream for the department?
The task force would seek a $6-$8/per member
cost allocation at year end.
Overwhelmed?
•We will capture and share the
work the Sub-Groups have
done today
•I will place a copy of this on
SlideShare for you to refer to
once you get back to the office
•I am offering 15 minute 1:1
sessions starting at 7:30
tomorrow. See me to sign-up!
Thanks!Dwayne Care | 410.790.4628 | dwayne@encoreseminars.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Company
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre CompanyLearning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Company
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Companyjvielman
 
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf
Pathway apprenticeships  event for safPathway apprenticeships  event for saf
Pathway apprenticeships event for safThe Pathway Group
 
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310
Pathway apprenticeships  event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310Pathway apprenticeships  event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310The Pathway Group
 
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaboration
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaborationOpportunities and challenges - inter-school collaboration
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaborationBrowne Jacobson LLP
 
Effective Tuition Reimbursement
Effective Tuition ReimbursementEffective Tuition Reimbursement
Effective Tuition ReimbursementStraighterLine
 
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust 4 All of Us
 
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax LevyJay Marino
 
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...Gideon Bernto
 
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & Training
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & TrainingThe Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & Training
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & TrainingThe Pathway Group
 
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe Pathway Group
 
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe Pathway Group
 

What's hot (18)

Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Company
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre CompanyLearning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Company
Learning Sessions #6 Residency Incubator: Classical Theatre Company
 
Into work convention
Into work conventionInto work convention
Into work convention
 
School summary ccr (3)
School summary ccr (3)School summary ccr (3)
School summary ccr (3)
 
Elevate Your Non-Profit or Community Watershed Group to an Educational Improv...
Elevate Your Non-Profit or Community Watershed Group to an Educational Improv...Elevate Your Non-Profit or Community Watershed Group to an Educational Improv...
Elevate Your Non-Profit or Community Watershed Group to an Educational Improv...
 
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf
Pathway apprenticeships  event for safPathway apprenticeships  event for saf
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf
 
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310
Pathway apprenticeships  event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310Pathway apprenticeships  event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310
Pathway apprenticeships event for saf 2016-10-13 21-52-12-310
 
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaboration
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaborationOpportunities and challenges - inter-school collaboration
Opportunities and challenges - inter-school collaboration
 
Effective Tuition Reimbursement
Effective Tuition ReimbursementEffective Tuition Reimbursement
Effective Tuition Reimbursement
 
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust
Creating an SDMP for your NHS Trust
 
PPMA Annual Seminar 2015 - Cost Effective Employee Benefits
PPMA Annual Seminar 2015 - Cost Effective Employee BenefitsPPMA Annual Seminar 2015 - Cost Effective Employee Benefits
PPMA Annual Seminar 2015 - Cost Effective Employee Benefits
 
What is Youth Apprenticeship?
What is Youth Apprenticeship?What is Youth Apprenticeship?
What is Youth Apprenticeship?
 
Apprenticeships- how your organisation can get in and go far...
Apprenticeships- how your organisation can get in and go far...Apprenticeships- how your organisation can get in and go far...
Apprenticeships- how your organisation can get in and go far...
 
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy
12-18-13 Public Presentation on Finances, Budget & the Tax Levy
 
Apprenticeship 2016 2020
Apprenticeship 2016 2020Apprenticeship 2016 2020
Apprenticeship 2016 2020
 
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...
Engaging leaders and employees in the importance of Business Continuity and c...
 
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & Training
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & TrainingThe Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & Training
The Changing Landscape for Funding Apprenticeships & Training
 
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
 
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidexThe changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
The changing landscape for funding apprenticeships and training naidex
 

Similar to Mission impossible rapdd 2013 - the results

NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School Governors
NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School GovernorsNGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School Governors
NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School GovernorsLearning Pool Ltd
 
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session Presentation
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session PresentationT-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session Presentation
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session PresentationEnock Gyan
 
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your Impact
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your ImpactUsing Performance Data: Communicating Your Impact
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your ImpactBlackbaud Pacific
 
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-op
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-opEmployer Information - Cincinnati State Co-op
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-opKelly Harper
 
Strategic Planning
Strategic PlanningStrategic Planning
Strategic Planningace boado
 
Developing school business partnerships CONVERTED
Developing school business  partnerships CONVERTEDDeveloping school business  partnerships CONVERTED
Developing school business partnerships CONVERTEDDon Alan Bogard
 
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team Update
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team UpdateHCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team Update
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team UpdateHouston Community College
 
SAI Evaluation Report-for issue
SAI Evaluation Report-for issueSAI Evaluation Report-for issue
SAI Evaluation Report-for issueMeghan Mathieson
 
2017 short stack - reviewing your current academic programs
2017   short stack - reviewing your current academic programs2017   short stack - reviewing your current academic programs
2017 short stack - reviewing your current academic programsStamats
 
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdf
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdfFebruary Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdf
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdfEducationNC
 
Faculty Salary Proposal
Faculty Salary ProposalFaculty Salary Proposal
Faculty Salary ProposalDave Dobson
 
President-Principal Model Presentation
President-Principal Model PresentationPresident-Principal Model Presentation
President-Principal Model PresentationXavier High School
 
Tracking Volunteer Impact
Tracking Volunteer ImpactTracking Volunteer Impact
Tracking Volunteer ImpactINGovConf
 
Working w/ the Generations
Working w/ the GenerationsWorking w/ the Generations
Working w/ the GenerationsHiggins
 

Similar to Mission impossible rapdd 2013 - the results (20)

CIMSPA AGM presentation 2014
CIMSPA AGM presentation 2014CIMSPA AGM presentation 2014
CIMSPA AGM presentation 2014
 
NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School Governors
NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School GovernorsNGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School Governors
NGA reveals the challenges & opportunities for School Governors
 
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session Presentation
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session PresentationT-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session Presentation
T-TEL Challenge FUND Info Session Presentation
 
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your Impact
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your ImpactUsing Performance Data: Communicating Your Impact
Using Performance Data: Communicating Your Impact
 
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-op
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-opEmployer Information - Cincinnati State Co-op
Employer Information - Cincinnati State Co-op
 
Strategic Planning
Strategic PlanningStrategic Planning
Strategic Planning
 
Developing school business partnerships CONVERTED
Developing school business  partnerships CONVERTEDDeveloping school business  partnerships CONVERTED
Developing school business partnerships CONVERTED
 
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team Update
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team UpdateHCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team Update
HCC Transformation Phase 2 Transformation Team Update
 
Accelerate IT
Accelerate ITAccelerate IT
Accelerate IT
 
SAI Evaluation Report-for issue
SAI Evaluation Report-for issueSAI Evaluation Report-for issue
SAI Evaluation Report-for issue
 
2017 short stack - reviewing your current academic programs
2017   short stack - reviewing your current academic programs2017   short stack - reviewing your current academic programs
2017 short stack - reviewing your current academic programs
 
Quality in Action - July 2011
Quality in Action - July 2011Quality in Action - July 2011
Quality in Action - July 2011
 
FundReady Orientation No.1 of 4 2023.pptx
FundReady Orientation No.1 of 4 2023.pptxFundReady Orientation No.1 of 4 2023.pptx
FundReady Orientation No.1 of 4 2023.pptx
 
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdf
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdfFebruary Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdf
February Superintendent SBE Report 1.12.23_347984yturdpaadaely1a0jhvpvg0k.pdf
 
LOPEZ 2014 RESUME
LOPEZ 2014 RESUMELOPEZ 2014 RESUME
LOPEZ 2014 RESUME
 
Michigan CSP Informational Meeting - February 2021
Michigan CSP Informational Meeting - February 2021Michigan CSP Informational Meeting - February 2021
Michigan CSP Informational Meeting - February 2021
 
Faculty Salary Proposal
Faculty Salary ProposalFaculty Salary Proposal
Faculty Salary Proposal
 
President-Principal Model Presentation
President-Principal Model PresentationPresident-Principal Model Presentation
President-Principal Model Presentation
 
Tracking Volunteer Impact
Tracking Volunteer ImpactTracking Volunteer Impact
Tracking Volunteer Impact
 
Working w/ the Generations
Working w/ the GenerationsWorking w/ the Generations
Working w/ the Generations
 

Mission impossible rapdd 2013 - the results

  • 1. Mission Impossible? This Program Just Might Self-Destruct in 5Years
  • 2. Welcome to JAAAR Just About Anywhere Association of REALTORS(R)
  • 3. Education Task Force Changing the World of Education
  • 4. The Mission • Propose & Answer Critical Questions about the direction of the Education program at JAAAR • Develop a 1:2:3Year Strategic Plan for the Education Department at JAAAR • Present & Acquire Approval from the JAAAR BOD
  • 5. The Situation • Like many associations, JAAAR had great years in the early to mid-2000’s • Membership has begun to stabilize after several years of decline (still down 34% from the highest membership count) • BOD is concerned about the financials of the Education Department (negative for the past 3 years)
  • 6. The Situation • During the “glory” days, there were surpluses • The surpluses generated/funded many new initiatives in the Education Department and elsewhere in JAAAR • BOD & Committees are leery of taking things off the “buffet” for fear of losing members
  • 7. The Situation • 4 years ago, JAAAR launched all new online education partnerships & saw huge increase in online revenue • Since the launch, online revenue has leveled • BOD approved a member week offering free CE to all members • This member week event is held 2 months prior to license renewal
  • 8. The Situation • Competition for the education dollar has increased significantly • The “Real Estate Commission” has instituted 1 or 2 mandatory classes (changing on an annual basis) • The state association has developed a strategy to provide these mandatory classes statewide at large events
  • 9. The Situation • JAAAR has maintained a “club house” approach to offering live CE: meaning smaller class sizes, more often to encourage members to come to the association office • The education staff was reduced 2 years ago by 1/3
  • 10. The Situation • All instructors are paid contractors • JAAAR does not pay instructors for course development time and thus does not own the course • JAAAR Marketing Team has been assigned several other priorities with no addt’l staff • The training facility was last updated 10 years ago
  • 14. Directive 1 1’s - Profit Center 2’s - Member Benefit
  • 15. Directive 1 Identify the Pro’s & Con’s of your Assigned Approach
  • 18. Directive 2 Blue = Marketing Red = Generational Yellow =Value Proposition Green = Adv. Education
  • 19. Directive 2 Identify the +’s and Δ’s ofYour Assigned Challenge
  • 22. Directive 3 North – Current Club House Model East - $49 Unlimited CE paid by all South – Combine Current Model with Large Events West – Dues Increase while offering Mandatory Hours at No Charge
  • 23. Directive 3 Identify the +’s & -’s along with sustainability of your assigned Funding Approach
  • 26. Step 1 - Data Gathering • InYour Sub-Group: Determine what data/ info you already have at hand • InYour Sub-Group: Determine what other data/info would like to have before formulating recommendations • InYour Sub-Group: Determine what questions you might have for the other Sub-Groups
  • 27. Step 2 - Recommend • InYour Sub-Group: Formulate Recommendations • InYour Sub-Group: Determine if the recommendation should be forYear 1,Year 2 orYear 3 • InYour Sub-Group: Note if any of your recommendations could include another Sub-Group
  • 28. Step 3 - Reconvene • As a Task Force: Review all the recommendations • As a Task Force: Rank in order of importance/priority • As a Task Force:Assign a time (Year 1,Year 2 orYear 3) to each recommendation • As a Task Force: Determine the final list
  • 29. Step 4 - Present • Task Force Chair, Ed Director & Facilitator develop the draft recommendation. • Same 3 meet with CEO; CFO; Current President • Present and ask for a motion on the recommendations at the BOD
  • 30. Step 5 - Implement
  • 31. Step 1 - Data Your Assignment Today
  • 32. So How Did This Turn Out? Real World Case
  • 33. Business Model Function as a Member Benefit but run like a business.
  • 34. Year 1 • Review current & consider expanding Broker Curriculum • Reconsider Pricing Model for FutureYears • Review Curriculum forVariety of Topic & Interactivity • Develop a revised staffing model for Education Department
  • 35. Year 1 • Develop an Experience Level Rating for All Current Courses • Launch a revised Deliver Model (combo of club house and large events) • Launch an Education Competition Response Task Force
  • 36. Year 2 • Launch revised curriculum (including experience ratings) • Launch revised pricing model
  • 37. Year 3 • Develop a business case/model for products and consulting to other associations
  • 38. Member Benefit Investment The task force supports operating Education as a member benefit. However, what portion of dues dollars should be allocated to subsidize in the event of negative revenue to expense stream for the department? The task force would seek a $6-$8/per member cost allocation at year end.
  • 39. Overwhelmed? •We will capture and share the work the Sub-Groups have done today •I will place a copy of this on SlideShare for you to refer to once you get back to the office •I am offering 15 minute 1:1 sessions starting at 7:30 tomorrow. See me to sign-up!
  • 40. Thanks!Dwayne Care | 410.790.4628 | dwayne@encoreseminars.com