#med332 
Rap, 
authen0city, 
commerce, 
capitalism 
1
“They 
say 
rap’s 
changed” 
Dr 
Dre 
– 
‘S0ll 
D.R.E.’ 
(1999) 
2
3 
themes 
all 
focused 
around 
capitalist 
enterprise: 
1. Rap’s 
success 
and 
commercial 
dominance 
2. Commodity 
fe0shism 
and 
conspicuous 
consump0on 
3. Authen0city 
and 
selling 
out 
3
4
5
Tim 
Dogg 
– 
‘Fuck 
Compton’ 
(1991) 
6
Dr 
Dre 
– 
‘Fuck 
wit 
Dre 
Day 
(And 
Everybody's 
Celebra0n’)’ 
(1992) 
Dr 
Dre 
– 
‘The 
$20 
Sack 
Pyramid’ 
(1992) 
7
8
Sean 
‘Puff 
Daddy’ 
Combs 
9
10
The 
Notorious 
B.I.G. 
– 
‘Juicy’ 
(1994) 
11
Junior 
M.A.F.I.A 
feat 
The 
Notorious 
B.I.G. 
– 
‘Get 
Money’ 
(1995) 
12
Tupac 
Shakur 
13
Quad 
Recording 
Studios 
, 
NYC 
14
15
First 
ar0st 
to 
have 
a 
#1 
album 
while 
in 
prison 
16
Suge 
Knight 
17
18
“Any 
ar0st 
out 
there 
that 
want 
to 
be 
an 
ar0st 
and 
stay 
a 
star, 
and 
don’t 
have 
to 
worry 
about 
the 
execu0ve 
producer 
trying 
to 
be 
all 
in 
the 
videos 
... 
All 
on 
the 
records 
... 
dancing, 
come 
to 
Death 
Row!” 
1995 
Source 
A1w9 
ards
20
Tupac 
Shakur 
– 
‘Hit 
‘em 
Up’ 
(1996) 
21
Puff 
Daddy 
& 
The 
Family 
22
‘I 
sold 
kilos 
of 
coke, 
I'm 
guessin' 
I 
can 
sell 
CDs 
I'm 
not 
a 
businessman, 
I'm 
a 
business, 
man!’ 
-­‐ 
Jay-­‐Z 
on 
‘Diamonds 
from 
Sierra 
Leone’ 
(Remix) 
23
Sold 
for 
$4 
billion 
to 
Coca-­‐Cola 
24
25
Hip-­‐hop’s 
recent 
focus 
on 
entrepreneurship 
and 
marke0ng 
has 
created 
a 
culture 
where 
hip-­‐hop 
is 
experienced 
primarily 
through 
consump0on 
rather 
than 
produc0on 
-­‐ 
Hunter, 
2011: 
15-­‐6 
26
Rags 
to 
riches 
27
This 
“lifestyle 
product” 
is 
created 
through 
the 
countless 
commodi0es 
now 
associated 
with 
hip-­‐hop. 
Consumers 
can 
buy 
PimpJuice 
energy 
drink 
(Nelly), 
Roc-­‐a-­‐Wear 
sunglasses 
(Jay-­‐Z), 
Sean 
John 
jeans 
(Diddy), 
or 
Conjure 
Cognac 
(Ludacris) 
to 
emulate 
the 
rap 
lifestyle 
whose 
image 
is 
built 
on 
the 
founda0on 
of 
cars, 
women, 
drugs, 
and 
strip 
clubs. 
This 
lifestyle 
product 
is 
reinforced 
through 
lyrics, 
music 
video, 
online 
fan 
gossip, 
and 
constant 
marke0ng. 
The 
consumer-­‐ 
driven 
lifestyle 
product 
is 
epitomized 
in 
50 
Cent’s 
newest 
product 
in 
his 
G-­‐ 
Unit 
line: 
the 
interac0ve 
pornography 
video 
-­‐ 
Hunter, 
2011: 
16 
28
Nelly 
– 
‘Air 
Force 
Ones’ 
(2002) 
29
In 
order 
to 
gain 
and 
to 
hold 
the 
esteem 
of 
men 
it 
is 
not 
sufficient 
merely 
to 
possess 
wealth 
or 
power. 
The 
wealth 
or 
power 
must 
be 
put 
in 
evidence, 
for 
esteem 
is 
awarded 
only 
on 
evidence 
-­‐ 
Veblen, 
1899/1934: 
p36 
30
‘it 
is 
important 
to 
note 
that 
hip-­‐hop 
serves 
doubly 
as 
an 
interven0on 
of 
American 
capitalism 
and 
of 
black 
agency. 
Hip-­‐hop's 
arrac0on 
abroad 
remains 
arached 
to 
its 
roots 
as 
a 
voice 
for 
oppressed 
groups 
… 
In 
the 
same 
breadth, 
hip-­‐hop 
is 
also 
a 
vehicle 
for 
under-­‐ 
standing 
(American) 
blackness 
as 
a 
hyper-­‐commodity’ 
-­‐ 
Bradley, 
2014: 
97-­‐8 
31
Kanye 
West 
-­‐ 
‘We 
Don’t 
Care’ 
(2004) 
The 
College 
Dropout 
Drug 
dealin’ 
jus 
to 
get 
by 
Stack 
ya 
money 
0ll 
it 
gets 
sky 
high 
We 
wasn’t 
supposed 
to 
make 
it 
past 
25 
But 
the 
jokes 
on 
you 
we 
s0ll 
alive 
Throw 
your 
hands 
up 
in 
the 
sky 
and 
say 
“We 
don't 
care 
what 
people 
say” 
If 
this 
is 
your 
first 
0me 
hearing 
this 
You 
are 
about 
to 
experience 
something 
cold 
man 
We 
never 
had 
nothing 
handed 
took 
nothing 
for 
granted 
Took 
nothing 
from 
no 
man, 
man 
I'm 
my 
own 
man 
But 
as 
a 
shorty 
I 
looked 
up 
to 
the 
dopeman 
Only 
adult 
man 
I 
knew 
that 
wasn’t 
a 
broke 
man 
Flickin’ 
starter 
coats 
man, 
Man 
you 
don’t 
know 
man 
We 
don't 
care 
what 
people 
say 
This 
is 
for 
my 
niggas 
outside 
all 
winter 
Cuz 
this 
summer 
they 
ain’t 
finna 
to 
say 
“next 
summer 
I’m 
finna” 
Siun’ 
in 
the 
hood 
like 
community 
colleges 
This 
dope 
money 
here 
is 
Lil 
Trey’s 
scholarship 
Cause 
ain’t 
no 
to 
tui0on 
for 
havin’ 
no 
ambi0on 
And 
ain’t 
no 
loans 
for 
siun’ 
your 
ass 
at 
home 
So 
we 
forced 
to 
sell 
crack 
rap 
and 
get 
a 
job 
You 
gora 
do 
something 
man 
your 
ass 
is 
grown 
[…] 
The 
second 
verse 
is 
for 
my 
dogs 
working 
9 
to 
5 
That 
s0ll 
hustle 
cause 
a 
nigga 
can't 
shine 
off 
$6.55 
And 
everybody 
selling 
make-­‐up, 
Jacobs 
And 
bootleg 
tapes 
just 
to 
get 
they 
cake 
up 
We 
put 
shit 
on 
layaway 
then 
come 
back 
We 
claim 
other 
people 
kids 
on 
our 
income 
tax 
We 
take 
that 
money 
cop 
work 
than 
push 
packs 
to 
get 
paid 
And 
we 
don't 
care 
what 
people 
say 
Momma 
say 
she 
wanna 
move 
south 
Scratchin’ 
lorery 
0ckets 
Eyes 
on 
a 
new 
house 
Around 
the 
same 
0me, 
Doe 
ran 
up 
in 
dude 
house 
Couldn’t 
get 
a 
job, 
So 
since 
he 
couldn’t 
get 
work 
He 
figured 
he’d 
take 
work 
The 
drug 
game 
bolemic 
its 
hard 
to 
get 
weight 
So 
niggas 
money 
is 
homo 
its 
hard 
to 
get 
straight 
So 
we 
gon 
keep 
baking 
to 
the 
day 
we 
get 
cake. 
And 
we 
don’t 
care 
what 
people 
say 
32
No 
rapper 
has 
embodied 
hip-­‐hop’s 
oxen 
contradictory 
impulses 
of 
narcissism 
and 
social 
good 
quite 
as 
he 
has, 
and 
no 
producer 
has 
celebrated 
the 
lush 
and 
the 
ornate 
quite 
as 
he 
has. 
He 
has 
spent 
most 
of 
his 
career 
in 
addi0ve 
mode, 
figuring 
out 
how 
to 
make 
music 
that’s 
majes0c 
and 
thought-­‐provoking 
and 
grand-­‐scaled. 
And 
he’s 
also 
widened 
the 
genre’s 
gates, 
whether 
for 
middle-­‐class 
values 
or 
high-­‐ 
fashion 
and 
high-­‐art 
dreams. 
-­‐ 
Caramonica, 
2013 
33
34 
‘George 
Bush 
doesn’t 
care 
about 
black 
people’ 
‘I 
have 
a 
hard 
0me 
believing 
George 
Bush 
cares 
about 
anyone’
Kanye 
West 
– 
‘Flashing 
Lights’ 
(2007) 
35 
She 
don’t 
believe 
in 
shoo0n’ 
stars, 
But 
she 
believe 
in 
shoes 
and 
cars 
Wood 
floors 
in 
the 
new 
apartment, 
Couture 
from 
the 
store’s 
department 
You 
more 
like 
L’eau 
de 
Stardee 
shit, 
I’m 
more 
of 
the, 
trips 
to 
Florida 
Order 
the 
hors 
d’oeuvres, 
Views 
of 
the 
water.
Peter 
Rosenberg 
36
He’s 
the 
only 
motherfucker 
on 
the 
motherfuckin’ 
megahertz 
frequency 
that’s 
s0ll 
trying 
to 
implement 
that 
filthy-­‐under-­‐the-­‐nail, 
holy, 
sacred 
and 
pure, 
unmixed, 
undiluted, 
un-­‐ 
tampered-­‐with, 
real 
hip-­‐hop 
shit. 
-­‐ 
Busta 
Rhymes 
in 
Marantz, 
2014 
37
Nicki 
Minaj 
– 
‘Starships’ 
(2012) 
38
I 
am 
a 
hip-­‐hop 
head, 
and, 
to 
be 
frank, 
this 
song 
right 
here, 
‘Starships,’ 
is 
literally 
one 
of 
the 
most 
sellout 
songs 
in 
hip-­‐hop 
history 
… 
Pop 
and 
rap 
are 
separate 
things. 
It’s 
one 
thing 
for 
J. 
Lo 
to 
make 
a 
dance 
record, 
but 
Nicki 
was 
supposed 
to 
be 
one 
of 
ours. 
I 
didn’t 
want 
young 
kids 
looking 
at 
this 
dance-­‐pop 
song, 
going, 
‘This 
is 
what 
rappers 
do.’ 
Rosenberg 
in 
Marantz 
(2014) 
39
40 
Rosenberg 
Summer 
Jam 
2012 
Nicki 
Minaj 
diss
41 
“Fuck 
Peter 
ROSENBERG, 
U 
RACIST 
WANNA 
BE 
BLACK 
FAGGOT 
JEW 
BITCH”
Rosenberg’s 
apology 
42
43 
Minaj: 
“I 
get 
it. 
That’s 
what 
you 
do. 
I 
guess, 
to 
me—I 
just 
don’t 
know 
your 
résumé, 
you 
know 
what 
I’m 
saying? 
So 
I 
never 
found 
you 
funny. 
. 
. 
. 
I 
was 
just, 
like, 
‘Who 
are 
you?’”
44 
Ebro 
Darden 
(the 
sta0on’s 
program 
director): 
“And 
you’re 
white.”
Pierre 
Bourdieu 
" 1930-­‐2002 
" École 
Normale 
Supérieure 
(Paris) 
" 1964: 
University 
of 
Paris 
Director 
of 
Studies 
at 
the 
École 
Pratique 
des 
Hautes 
Études 
" 1968: 
took 
over 
the 
Centre 
de 
Sociologie 
Européenne 
" 1981: 
Chair 
of 
Sociology 
at 
the 
Collège 
de 
France 
45
46
Research: 
1963-­‐1968 
1200 
quantitative 
surveys, 
interviews 
and 
photographs. 
Cross-­‐referenced 
with 
national 
trends 
and 
government 
data 
The 
things 
you 
prefer 
correspond 
tightly 
to 
defining 
measures 
of 
social 
class: 
your 
profession, 
your 
highest 
degree 
and 
your 
father’s 
profession. 
47
"Taste 
classifies, 
and 
it 
classifies 
the 
classifier. 
Social 
subjects, 
classified 
by 
their 
classifications, 
distinguish 
themselves 
by 
the 
distinctions 
they 
make, 
between 
the 
beautiful 
and 
the 
ugly, 
the 
distinguished 
and 
the 
vulgar, 
in 
which 
their 
position 
in 
the 
objective 
classifications 
is 
expressed 
or 
betrayed." 
-­‐ 
Bourdieu, 
1984: 
6 
48
Art? 
49
‘The 
very 
title 
Distinction 
serves 
as 
a 
reminder 
that 
what 
is 
commonly 
called 
distinction, 
that 
is, 
a 
certain 
quality 
of 
bearing 
and 
manners, 
most 
often 
considered 
innate 
[…], 
is 
nothing 
other 
than 
difference, 
a 
gap, 
a 
distinctive 
feature, 
in 
short, 
a 
relational 
property 
existing 
only 
in 
and 
through 
its 
relation 
with 
other 
properties’ 
-­‐ 
Bourdieu, 
1994/1998: 
20 
50
Hip 
hop 
is 
universal? 
51
52 
In 
the 
search 
for 
authen0city 
it 
has 
become 
fairly 
commonplace 
to 
acknowledge 
that 
authen0city 
is 
a 
sham. 
Indeed, 
the 
more 
sophis0cated 
poses 
available 
[…] 
in 
the 
popular 
music 
scene 
hold 
that 
the 
conscious 
recogni0on 
of 
the 
staged 
character 
of 
"authen0c" 
performance 
does 
not 
compromise, 
but 
can 
in 
effect 
enhance, 
authen0city. 
-­‐ 
Hutnyk, 
2000: 
90
images 
• Chris 
Porer 
(2013) 
The 
Color 
of 
Money 
• Tupac 
Amaru 
Shakur 
(2010) 
2Pac 
• Rodrigoferrari 
(2011) 
Kanye 
West 
01 
• David 
(2005) 
Christmas 
Bling! 
• Anna 
Fox 
(2009) 
Monopoly 
in 
the 
Park 
• Steffi 
Reichert 
(2010) 
CAPITALISM 
53

Med332 rap authenticity commerce capitalism

  • 1.
    #med332 Rap, authen0city, commerce, capitalism 1
  • 2.
    “They say rap’s changed” Dr Dre – ‘S0ll D.R.E.’ (1999) 2
  • 3.
    3 themes all focused around capitalist enterprise: 1. Rap’s success and commercial dominance 2. Commodity fe0shism and conspicuous consump0on 3. Authen0city and selling out 3
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Tim Dogg – ‘Fuck Compton’ (1991) 6
  • 7.
    Dr Dre – ‘Fuck wit Dre Day (And Everybody's Celebra0n’)’ (1992) Dr Dre – ‘The $20 Sack Pyramid’ (1992) 7
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    The Notorious B.I.G. – ‘Juicy’ (1994) 11
  • 12.
    Junior M.A.F.I.A feat The Notorious B.I.G. – ‘Get Money’ (1995) 12
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    First ar0st to have a #1 album while in prison 16
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    “Any ar0st out there that want to be an ar0st and stay a star, and don’t have to worry about the execu0ve producer trying to be all in the videos ... All on the records ... dancing, come to Death Row!” 1995 Source A1w9 ards
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Tupac Shakur – ‘Hit ‘em Up’ (1996) 21
  • 22.
    Puff Daddy & The Family 22
  • 23.
    ‘I sold kilos of coke, I'm guessin' I can sell CDs I'm not a businessman, I'm a business, man!’ -­‐ Jay-­‐Z on ‘Diamonds from Sierra Leone’ (Remix) 23
  • 24.
    Sold for $4 billion to Coca-­‐Cola 24
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Hip-­‐hop’s recent focus on entrepreneurship and marke0ng has created a culture where hip-­‐hop is experienced primarily through consump0on rather than produc0on -­‐ Hunter, 2011: 15-­‐6 26
  • 27.
  • 28.
    This “lifestyle product” is created through the countless commodi0es now associated with hip-­‐hop. Consumers can buy PimpJuice energy drink (Nelly), Roc-­‐a-­‐Wear sunglasses (Jay-­‐Z), Sean John jeans (Diddy), or Conjure Cognac (Ludacris) to emulate the rap lifestyle whose image is built on the founda0on of cars, women, drugs, and strip clubs. This lifestyle product is reinforced through lyrics, music video, online fan gossip, and constant marke0ng. The consumer-­‐ driven lifestyle product is epitomized in 50 Cent’s newest product in his G-­‐ Unit line: the interac0ve pornography video -­‐ Hunter, 2011: 16 28
  • 29.
    Nelly – ‘Air Force Ones’ (2002) 29
  • 30.
    In order to gain and to hold the esteem of men it is not sufficient merely to possess wealth or power. The wealth or power must be put in evidence, for esteem is awarded only on evidence -­‐ Veblen, 1899/1934: p36 30
  • 31.
    ‘it is important to note that hip-­‐hop serves doubly as an interven0on of American capitalism and of black agency. Hip-­‐hop's arrac0on abroad remains arached to its roots as a voice for oppressed groups … In the same breadth, hip-­‐hop is also a vehicle for under-­‐ standing (American) blackness as a hyper-­‐commodity’ -­‐ Bradley, 2014: 97-­‐8 31
  • 32.
    Kanye West -­‐ ‘We Don’t Care’ (2004) The College Dropout Drug dealin’ jus to get by Stack ya money 0ll it gets sky high We wasn’t supposed to make it past 25 But the jokes on you we s0ll alive Throw your hands up in the sky and say “We don't care what people say” If this is your first 0me hearing this You are about to experience something cold man We never had nothing handed took nothing for granted Took nothing from no man, man I'm my own man But as a shorty I looked up to the dopeman Only adult man I knew that wasn’t a broke man Flickin’ starter coats man, Man you don’t know man We don't care what people say This is for my niggas outside all winter Cuz this summer they ain’t finna to say “next summer I’m finna” Siun’ in the hood like community colleges This dope money here is Lil Trey’s scholarship Cause ain’t no to tui0on for havin’ no ambi0on And ain’t no loans for siun’ your ass at home So we forced to sell crack rap and get a job You gora do something man your ass is grown […] The second verse is for my dogs working 9 to 5 That s0ll hustle cause a nigga can't shine off $6.55 And everybody selling make-­‐up, Jacobs And bootleg tapes just to get they cake up We put shit on layaway then come back We claim other people kids on our income tax We take that money cop work than push packs to get paid And we don't care what people say Momma say she wanna move south Scratchin’ lorery 0ckets Eyes on a new house Around the same 0me, Doe ran up in dude house Couldn’t get a job, So since he couldn’t get work He figured he’d take work The drug game bolemic its hard to get weight So niggas money is homo its hard to get straight So we gon keep baking to the day we get cake. And we don’t care what people say 32
  • 33.
    No rapper has embodied hip-­‐hop’s oxen contradictory impulses of narcissism and social good quite as he has, and no producer has celebrated the lush and the ornate quite as he has. He has spent most of his career in addi0ve mode, figuring out how to make music that’s majes0c and thought-­‐provoking and grand-­‐scaled. And he’s also widened the genre’s gates, whether for middle-­‐class values or high-­‐ fashion and high-­‐art dreams. -­‐ Caramonica, 2013 33
  • 34.
    34 ‘George Bush doesn’t care about black people’ ‘I have a hard 0me believing George Bush cares about anyone’
  • 35.
    Kanye West – ‘Flashing Lights’ (2007) 35 She don’t believe in shoo0n’ stars, But she believe in shoes and cars Wood floors in the new apartment, Couture from the store’s department You more like L’eau de Stardee shit, I’m more of the, trips to Florida Order the hors d’oeuvres, Views of the water.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    He’s the only motherfucker on the motherfuckin’ megahertz frequency that’s s0ll trying to implement that filthy-­‐under-­‐the-­‐nail, holy, sacred and pure, unmixed, undiluted, un-­‐ tampered-­‐with, real hip-­‐hop shit. -­‐ Busta Rhymes in Marantz, 2014 37
  • 38.
    Nicki Minaj – ‘Starships’ (2012) 38
  • 39.
    I am a hip-­‐hop head, and, to be frank, this song right here, ‘Starships,’ is literally one of the most sellout songs in hip-­‐hop history … Pop and rap are separate things. It’s one thing for J. Lo to make a dance record, but Nicki was supposed to be one of ours. I didn’t want young kids looking at this dance-­‐pop song, going, ‘This is what rappers do.’ Rosenberg in Marantz (2014) 39
  • 40.
    40 Rosenberg Summer Jam 2012 Nicki Minaj diss
  • 41.
    41 “Fuck Peter ROSENBERG, U RACIST WANNA BE BLACK FAGGOT JEW BITCH”
  • 42.
  • 43.
    43 Minaj: “I get it. That’s what you do. I guess, to me—I just don’t know your résumé, you know what I’m saying? So I never found you funny. . . . I was just, like, ‘Who are you?’”
  • 44.
    44 Ebro Darden (the sta0on’s program director): “And you’re white.”
  • 45.
    Pierre Bourdieu "1930-­‐2002 " École Normale Supérieure (Paris) " 1964: University of Paris Director of Studies at the École Pratique des Hautes Études " 1968: took over the Centre de Sociologie Européenne " 1981: Chair of Sociology at the Collège de France 45
  • 46.
  • 47.
    Research: 1963-­‐1968 1200 quantitative surveys, interviews and photographs. Cross-­‐referenced with national trends and government data The things you prefer correspond tightly to defining measures of social class: your profession, your highest degree and your father’s profession. 47
  • 48.
    "Taste classifies, and it classifies the classifier. Social subjects, classified by their classifications, distinguish themselves by the distinctions they make, between the beautiful and the ugly, the distinguished and the vulgar, in which their position in the objective classifications is expressed or betrayed." -­‐ Bourdieu, 1984: 6 48
  • 49.
  • 50.
    ‘The very title Distinction serves as a reminder that what is commonly called distinction, that is, a certain quality of bearing and manners, most often considered innate […], is nothing other than difference, a gap, a distinctive feature, in short, a relational property existing only in and through its relation with other properties’ -­‐ Bourdieu, 1994/1998: 20 50
  • 51.
    Hip hop is universal? 51
  • 52.
    52 In the search for authen0city it has become fairly commonplace to acknowledge that authen0city is a sham. Indeed, the more sophis0cated poses available […] in the popular music scene hold that the conscious recogni0on of the staged character of "authen0c" performance does not compromise, but can in effect enhance, authen0city. -­‐ Hutnyk, 2000: 90
  • 53.
    images • Chris Porer (2013) The Color of Money • Tupac Amaru Shakur (2010) 2Pac • Rodrigoferrari (2011) Kanye West 01 • David (2005) Christmas Bling! • Anna Fox (2009) Monopoly in the Park • Steffi Reichert (2010) CAPITALISM 53