Neal invites his roommates Brent and Zach to a hipster party hosted by Atticus. At the party, Zach connects well with the hipsters by portraying himself as an underground artist. However, Neal struggles to fit in and impress the hipsters with his comments. Brent also tries hard to understand hipster irony but is confused. Throughout the night, various hipsters praise Brent for hanging up coats in the closet in an "artistic" way.