SlideShare a Scribd company logo
A STUDY OF THE EFFECTS OF YOUTH COMPETITVE SPORTS ON
REPETITIVE MOTION INURIES DURING PUBERTY
by
Richard L. Brenkmann
A master’s project submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree
of
Master of Education
in
Health, Physical Education, and Recreation
Approved:
Dr. John M. Kras,Chair Date
Dr. Richard Gordin, Member Date
Dr. Dennis Nelson, Member Date
Dr. Dennis Dolny, Department Head Date
UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY
Logan, Utah
2011
A STUDY OF THE EFFECTS OF YOUTH COMPETITVE SPORTS ON
REPETITIVE MOTION INURIES DURING PUBERTY
Problem Statement
When I was young, my friends and I played whatever sport was in season,except for the
summer when the sport relied on available shade. We never focused on any one particular sport
all the way through high school. Today’s youth are starting to focus on one sport at a much
earlier age in an attempt to elevate their abilities to a level of hopefully being able to become
professional athletes some day. Some kids are starting to specialize in competitive leagues as
early as eight years old, and really only playing that sport until they get out of high school. This
practice, I believe, is dangerous for the young person who does this. Many of these competitive
players end up with nagging injuries that plague them throughout their career.
Most of these injuries are from repetitive motions that put an unnatural strain on a
particular set of joints and muscles. These injuries are mere nuisances in the beginning, but
without proper rest and care the injuries will become chronic and more problematic as the child
gets older. These injuries are developing new names based on the sport such as soccer knee and
pitcher’s elbow. An individual who focuses on one sport also misses out on the skills that cross
over from one sport to the next, and can make a player an overall better player. By participating
in other sports, the joints and muscles will strengthen which could also prevent other injuries.
The literature suggests that youth who participate in only one sport, without decent rest,and
without experiencing “muscle confusion” (Bosgieter, 2010) can suffer overuse injuries that can
eventually develop into chronic injuries. The problem I will study is how prevalent are these
injuries in one sport participants between the ages of ten to 16 years old.
2
Purpose and Objectives
The purpose of this paper is to show a correlation between the repetitive injuries and the
playing of only one sport during the developmental years through puberty. The objectives would
be to show to researchers and parents the need to participate in multiple activities to increase the
skills in the main sport. I would also hope to encourage parents and youth to consider playing
multiple sports because I do not know too many eight year olds who are already planning a career
in something specific. Burnout among these athletes is high because they have nothing else going
on but this one sport, and eventually they may grow to despise the sport. There are several
groups that have banded together to create “’the STOP Sports Injuries’ campaign to raise
awareness about this trend and help prevent athletic overuse and trauma injuries in children”
(Initiative to Stop, 2010). I would hope conscientious readers would realize that this is true and
encourage play for plays sake in their children.
ReviewofLiterature
Competitive sports programs have been growing over the last severalyears with not only
local leagues, but regional and national leagues as well. There are competitive leagues in
basketball, baseball, soccer,hockey and rugby that have contests throughout the year. Most
competitive teams also play in tournaments on weekends all over the region in which they live, as
well as league games during the week. There are those who argue that the “all-embracing goal
for children's sport programs: helping young athletes emerge from the sport experience as
responsible, autonomous people” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). “Coaches should include this goal in their
personal coaching philosophy and many have not done so” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). This
responsibility should fall to “all adults, whether coaching or not, can help young athletes learn to
become responsible for themselves” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). “Sports programs for young people
3
have grown so rapidly that scholars and practitioners alike are hard pressed to keep up with new
knowledge” (Stiehl, 1990, p 205). It is not just the psychological toll, but also the physical toll
that youth face,especially in the repetitive actions that occur in competitive sports.
The adults who participate in competitive youth sports are the parents. The influence of
parents on the youth players is important in determining the efforts of the child, as well as the
level of soreness that the child will endure. “The degree of involvement a parent makes in their
child's sport makes a statement about the relative importance of this domain” (Barber,1999). If a
child senses that playing and doing well is important to the parent, then the child “will adopt
values and beliefs similar to their parents” (Barber,1999). Parents range in the level of
involvement from being over-involved to under-involved. Barber (1999) looked at the
relationship of parents to their children in youth sports, and found that youth participated for fun,
but initially for many it may have been encouragement from their parents to participate.
With the move to earlier specialization, it should be understood that “The American
Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Committee on Sports Medicine and Fitness does not recommend
specialization before the age of 12 or 13 years” (Rosenbaum,p 255). The early start of sports
specialization can lead to injury due to micro-trauma to the growth plate. “Often, younger
athletes do not recognize overuse symptoms until they become debilitating” (Rosenbaum, p 256).
Rosenbaum also stated that “adolescents are not as coordinated or may not yet have adjusted to
physiological changes during an increased velocity of growth. This could result in altered
flexibility with inherent muscle imbalances, making them vulnerable to injury” (p 256). The
AAP recommends as an alternate to early sport specialization is sports diversification, which
would be considered as sampling (multiple sport experiences) from 6 to 12, and specialization
coming after in ages 13 to 15 (Rosenbaum, p 256).
4
There have been a number of studies that have looked at various injuries in youth sports
and the causes behind them. Much of the literature focuses on the kinds of injuries associated
with contact or traumatic stress injury. The focus of my project is to look at repetitive use
injuries due to overuse and not enough rest between competitive activities. “Orthopedic surgeons
are also seeing a rise in the number of youth sports injuries in general, and in the number of
younger athletes who suffer overuse injuries” (Initiative to Stop, 2010). The literature that
focuses on the repetitive injuries seems to be mostly involving the sports of soccer and lower
extremity issues, and baseball pitchers with injuries involving the shoulder and elbow.
A New York Times Magazine article discusses the prevalence of elbow and shoulder
injuries in youth baseball. Berler (2009) did a study of the increasing number of youth players
who were having elbow and shoulder surgeries at much younger ages. “A 13 year old might
pitch Sunday for his travel team, Monday for his middle school team, and Wednesday for his
Babe Ruth team” (Berler, 2009). There are some players today who are “playing baseball nearly
year round, to the exclusion of all other sports” (Berler, 2009). “Parents failed to realize to
recognize that kids need 3 – 4 months of recovery time each year” (Berler,2009).
Childress (2003) describes pitching as “one of the most dynamic motions in sport. This
is demonstrated when the average time from initial foot contact of the stride leg to ball release is
0.145 seconds” (p 1). Injuries to the elbow and shoulder are the normal injury site for youth
baseball players, with the most common being Little League Elbow. “The stress placed on the
elbow during pitching has been implicated as the cause of little league elbow” (Childress, 2003, p
2). Adolescent elbow injuries are repetitive injuries that are mostly skeletal in nature, and rarely
involve the muscle tendon that happens with adults. “When the elbow of an adolescent is
5
subjected to repeated stress,the growth plates are more vulnerable to injury” (Childress 2003, p
3)
Other studies have shown that there is a deficiency in training and proper technique that
is the problem causing the shoulder and elbow pain. Aguinaldo, Butters and Chambers (2007)
looked at a concern described as “’throwing with too much arm,’ in which the energy from trunk
rotation is transferred to the upper arm too early and dissipated instead of being applied to the
hand and ball. (p 43) Aguinaldo, et al studied “the biomechanical patterns of trunk rotation and
shoulder joint torque during baseball pitching between professional, collegiate, high school, and
youth players.” (p 44) Although including some items from an older class, this information is
pertinent to this study because it helps to establish a background of the mechanics that make for
safer pitching. “The current study demonstrated that pitchers who rotated their torsos later in their
delivery exhibited less shoulder internal rotation torque (Aguinaldo, et al, 2007, p 48). Based on
their work, Aguinaldo, et al surmised “that the sequence of body segmental motion was
compromised when the trunk rotated too early, because part of the rotational energy was lost and
made up for by the upper extremity” (2007 p 48).
In a broader study of reported arm pain, Lyman, Fleisig, Waterbor,Funkhouser, Pulley,
Andrews,Osinski, and Rosman looked at 298 youth baseball pitchers over two seasons. The
study was designed “to evaluate the frequency of elbow and shoulder complaints in young
pitchers and to identify the associations between pitch types, pitch volume, and other risk factors
for these conditions.” (Lyman et al, 2001, p 1803) Each participant was contacted after a pitching
outing and asked a series of questions that would help the researchers “identify arm complaints.
Generalized estimating equations were used to assess associations between arm complaints and
independent variables. Results: The frequency of elbow pain was 26%; that of shoulder pain, 32%
” (Lyman, et al, 2001, 1803). Lyman, et al (2001) identified severalrisk factors that seemed to be
6
an underlying variable in both locations which included “playing baseball outside the league,
decreased self-satisfaction, arm fatigue during the game pitched, and throwing fewer than 300 or
more than 600 pitches during the season” (1803). It was also noticed that throwing more than 75
pitches in a game will also lead to shoulder or elbow pain. Lyman, et al (2011) concluded that
“arm complaints are common, with nearly half of the subjects reporting pain. The factors
associated with elbow and shoulder pain were different, suggesting differing etiologies.
Developmental factors may be important in both, to lower the risk of pain at both locations young
pitchers probably should not throw more than 75 pitches in a game” (1083).
In a different study by Fleisig, Weber, Hassell and Andrews (2009), they found that “the
risk of Adolescents who competitively pitch more than 85 pitches per game, more than 8 months
out of a year or with arm fatigue are severaltimes more likely to require elbow surgery. Poor
pitching mechanics also appear to contribute to injury risk” (p254). Fleisig, et al. (2009) pointed
to “the number of pitches thrown has the strongest correlation to youth pitching injuries” (p 250).
Although Little League Baseball has created guidelines limiting pitch counts, “many independent
and travel teams have no rules restricting pitch counts, inning limits, or days of rest” (Fleisig, et
al. 2009, p 251). A player who may be a good pitcher could end up pitching 3 or 4 days a week,
throwing hundreds of pitches during that time. Major League baseball pitchers are monitored
constantly, and rarely throw more than 115 pitches in a week, and some coaches are asking youth
to throw more with less rest. Fleisig, et al. (2009) stated that: “Our impression is that in past
generations, most children engaged in a reasonable amount of sports participation; now, there are
many children who do not play enough sports, and a smaller ‘elite’ group of children who
participate too much in one particular sport” (p 252).
Ray (2010) took a more medical look at the injuries incurred by youth and found “that
taller and heavier children have an increased risk of injury to the elbow and shoulder than their
7
counterparts of the same age. One possible explanation for this finding may include their higher
level of performance and subsequent overuse by coaches set on winning” (p 295). It seems that
many youth pitching injuries are blamed on the throwing of a curveball. Ray (2010) states
“shoulder internal rotation torque and proximal force as well as elbow varus torque and proximal
force were significantly less for the curveball than the fastball when comparing the biomechanics
of youth pitchers throwing the fastball, curveball, and change up. Although more research in this
important area is needed, this suggests that the curveball might not be more harmful to the youth
pitcher than the fastball” (p 295-296). More simply put, the torque from a properly thrown
curveball is less on the elbow and shoulder, and likely less harmful (although the emphasis should
be put on a properly thrown curveball) than a fastball or change-up.
Kocher, Waters,and Micheli (2000) also approached Little League Elbow from a more
mechanical standpoint, looking at the biomechanics of the injury. “Recognition of injury patterns
with early activity modification and the initiation of efficacious treatment can prevent
deformity/disability and return the youth athlete to sport” (Kocher,et al. 2000, p 118). Pitchers
suffer from “injury to the paediatric (sic) shoulder from throwing is a result of microtrauma (sic)
from repetitive motions of large rotational forces” (Kocher,et al. 2000, p 119).
Ogden and Warneke (2010) took a look at the correlation between college baseball
pitchers and youth competitive baseball pitchers as to whether these players had more need for
surgery later, and also had more pain from pitching. Select, or competitive, teams are starting
play earlier, as early as 7 or 8 years old, and these kids are encouraged to play year-round. As
stated earlier, it is recommended by researchers and doctors that players take up to 4 months off
of a particular sport in a year to rest and recover. Ogden and Warneke (2010) state “that the
youths who grow to be the best adult athletes are often those who engage in a variety of sports, or
multilateral development, in their earliest years. During those years children should be building
the basic skills of running, jumping, and throwing.” Although these select teams do seem to
8
show a correlation to transitioning to the higher leagues, players were stricken with more stress
and burnout, and sometimes outright quit before reaching that level. Those who participated at
higher skill positions like pitcher and catcher also showed more signs of overuse injuries as they
progressed from level to level.
Studies have also looked at the incidence of injuries in youth soccer players. Just like the
use of the term Little League Elbow, soccer has its own malady of overuse called Soccer Knee.
This injury is characterized by the painful swelling of the patellar tendon, and is cause in large
part by the contraction of the quadriceps muscles to kick the ball and also to plant with the
opposite foot. This injury is less common in the recreational player who plays one game a week,
and practices once per week. Soccer Knee injuries are typically found in competitive soccer
players who will play and practice three or more times per week,and they often play 12 months
of the year. Another issue looked at by Viscovi and Van Heest (2009) was the number of ACL
injuries being suffered by female soccer players (p 394). The injuries in question are non contact
injuries that come from weak muscles that provide support to the knee joint. Viscovi and Van
Heest (2009) investigated the effectiveness of “the Prevent Injury Enhance Program” on
adolescent female soccer players (p 394). “Epidemiological studies with soccer players indicate
that the most common anatomical site for injury is the lower extremities. Of particular concern
for female soccer players is that following puberty they are three times more likely to suffer an
anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury compared with the male soccer players” (Viscovi and
Van Heest,2009, p 394). Although this study was designed to look at injury prevention training,
it showed that part of this rash of ACL injuries could have as much to do with overuse. The
testing was conducted on four club soccer teams who were playing during a summer outdoor
season,with two teams running the training program and two who were doing an ordinary warm
up. At issue were the difference between warm up regimens and whether they decreased injury
or improved performance. There seemed to be no difference in the effects of the two warm-ups,
9
and yet they were working with club athletes who played year round. The look at what was
happening in the injury situation could have been about rest time, time off, and healing of the
micro tears of the ligaments, tendons and muscles that occur when the adolescent soccer player
plays and practices 4 or more times per week. The study concluded “, these programs were
designed with an aim of reducing the risk of non-contact ACL injuries, not enhancing
performance. However,if we are to convince coaches to implement an injury prevention
program, then investigators and clinicians should continue to modify program variables and
develop regimens that have promise to deliver dual benefits – improved performance and reduced
injury risk” (Viscovi and Van Heest,2009, p 401).
In a 10 year study of common injuries in elite youth French soccer players, Le Gall,
Carling, Reilly, Vandewalle, Church, and Rochcongar (2006) found that “players younger than 14
years incurred more injuries in training and sustained more growth-related overuse disorders.
Older players were more often injured during matches. Injury incidence and the frequency of
overuse disorders were highest early in the season” (p 928). The study seemed to suggest the
younger “players still lacked injury-avoidance skills or could have been undertaking too much
intensive training at this age” (Le Gall et al., 2006, p 934). Le Gall et al. (2006) further stated
that “injuries in less experienced, younger players may be owing to weaknesses in technical and
tactical ability as well as in muscle strength, endurance,and coordination” (p 934). “There was a
significantly greater amount of osteochondral disorders at the apophyseal or epiphyseal growth
areas of bones, which are linked to overuse, in U14 players, suggesting that this is a high-risk
group” (Le Gall et al., 2006, p 936).
Elias (2001) conducted a 10 year study that differed from Le Gall et al. by focusing his
study on injuries incurred during a major soccer tournament only. Elias chose the USA Cup
10
Soccer Tournament held in Minnesota every July to study the injuries that were occurring during
the competition at all levels. This tournament lasts 6 days and has “over 800 teams from 23
countries participating in age groups under-12 to under-19. All games are played at the National
Sports Center/Blaine Soccer Complex, which has 55 fields on one site” (Elias, 2001, p 359). At
the end of the ten year study, Elias (2001) holds the notion that “although females are injured at a
rate slightly greater than males, there is a trend suggesting that the overall difference is becoming
less significant” (p 367). This was related to the aggressiveness of play between the sexes,as
well as the differences experienced in conditioning.
Gomez, Neufeld, and Cosby (1996) chose to determine whether middle school soccer
players could “assess the probability of success with which … players could correctly localize
lower leg pain to sites of common overuse injuries” (p 335). The goal is to develop an instrument
that will help youth understand and care for overuse injuries that can lead to significant injuries
later if not cared for early enough. “The majority of overuse injuries in young athletes occur in
the lower extremity. The common overuse injuries of the leg in youngsters include shin splints,
patellar tendonitis, plantar fasciitis, Osgood-Schlatter disease,and Sever disease” (Gomez, et al.,
1996, p 335). Gomez, et al. (1996) discovered that these nagging injuries were rarely significant
enough to warrant a trip to a doctor or trainer (p 338). “Since athletes with overuse injuries can
often ‘play through’ the pain, it may be more useful in evaluating the clinical significance of
these injuries to ask about the extent to which the pain compromised the athletes’ performance”
(Gomez et al. 1996, p 338).
With the recent emphasis being placed on head injuries, and the cumulative effects on the
brain of repeated minor concussions, a new field has grown out of competitive injuries involving
the heading of the ball. Contact among soccer players is generally not significant enough to
11
warrant more than a look at contusions, but heading a soccer ball repeatedly can lead to minor
concussive events in the brain. Salinas, Webbe, and Devore (2009) looked at this phenomenon
and found that “the head injury rate accounts for 4.9–22% of soccer injuries in adolescents” (p
15). “The majority of soccer headings were direct rather than flicks. Almost half of our
participants reported headache and one-fourth reported dizziness after instances of heading the
ball” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 15). “Children are even more likely to lack awareness of concussion
symptoms and so may not accurately report their symptoms. Without knowledge of such critical
information about their child’s symptoms, parents may not understand that these injuries require
medical attention” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 16). Parents,coaches and players need to understand
both the symptoms and related problems that can come from repeated concussions. “In soccer
play, concussive head injuries are most likely to happen when two players make a mutual attempt
to head the ball. Heads banging together or elbows and fists striking a head are common. Less
common are injuries related to the ball striking the head” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 17).
Discussion
As this information is looked at, I understand that repetitive injury is not limited to only
the competitive sports, but can occur in recreational sports as well. In a humorous article for
Sports Illustrated,Rick Reilly looks at what could be considered the absurd side of competitive
sports, but there still is the need to look at the potential for injury when a child who is still
growing plays one sport exclusively.
“But then my wife gets to talking to some other moms at Justin's slap shot workshop, and
they say we're crazy if we don't have a 'performance-enhancement specialist' for our kids.
So she signs them both up with one. Then she finds out most of these girls have
'recruiting consultants' who make highlight reels of kids and send them to college
12
coaches. I'm like, 'She's 14!' And my wife is like, 'You're gonna tell our little girl no?'
Then we add a rating-service guy and a sports psychologist and a webmaster” (Reilly,
2006, p 76).
Competitive sports are leading to new needs in pediatric health as nagging injuries become more
serious in nature. “Because it's unrealistic to expect an enthusiastic young athlete or an
overzealous parent to recognize the severity of the issue and consequently know when to ease
back, it's up to recreation professionals and youth sports administrators to get the word out on
preventing overuse injuries” (Bach and Shilling, 2008, p 24). Bach and Shilling (2008) went on
to further state:
“Today's youth athletics are rife with single- sport specialization, heavy practice
schedules, and year-round training. The result is that a disturbing number of young
athletes have their seasons chopped short—and their long-term health jeopardized—by
overuse injuries.
As more and more youngsters are forced to visit doctors' offices for everything
from bone fractures and Little League elbow to shin splints and damaged knees,the
alarm is being sounded loud and clear by sports medicine professionals that too much of
the same activity can do more harm than good. Overuse injuries are sabotaging what
should be a fun and rewarding experience for millions of young athletes. These children,
who are breaking down due to the constant stress being placed on their young and
developing bodies, often face the unenviable prospect of long and sometimes painful
rehabilitations — and even surgery—to repair the damage” (p 24).
Conclusion
The youth are playing one sport exclusively more and more, and many are starting at a
much earlier age. The literature shows that, at least while growth is continuing to occur, there
13
should be multiple sports tried by youth so that the muscles and bones can rest and recover.
Playing one sport year round never allows for the micro trauma to heal. I look at Washington
Nationals pitching phenom Stefan Strassbourg, and I see a young man who probably focused on
baseball at an early age. Granted,he signed a big money contract, but since being called up to the
majors at 19, he has spent more time recovering from elbow and shoulder pain than he has
playing. The micro trauma and lack of healing has caught up with him, and a bright future in
baseball is looking rather tenuous at this time.
14
REFERENCES
Aguinaldo, A. L., Buttermore, J., & Chambers, H. (2007). Effects of upper trunk rotation on
shoulder joint torque among baseball pitchers of various levels. Journal of Applied
Biomechanics,23(1),42-51.
Allen, S. (2011) Do components of a pre-participation examination in female adolescent soccer
players predict acute lower extremity injuries in soccer? M.Sc. dissertation, University
of Calgary (Canada),Canada. (Publication No. AAT MR75201).
Bach,G., & Shilling, A. (2008). Research update: combating the overuse epidemic. Parks &
Recreation, 43(8),24-27.
Barber,H. H., Sukhi, H. H., & White, S. A. (1999). The influence of parent-coaches on
participant motivation and competitive anxiety in youth sport participants. Journal of
Sport Behavior, 22(2),162-180.
Berler, R. (2009, August). More and more youth pitchers are having operations on their elbows
and shoulders. So why aren't the grown-ups doing something about it? New York Times
Magazine,20-25. (Document ID: 1830321111).
Bosgieter, Kory, (2011) [Lecture notes]
Butcher, J., Lindner, K. J., & Johns, D. P. (2002). Withdrawal from competitive youth sport: a
retrospective ten-year study. Journal of Sport Behavior,25(2),145.
Callender, S. (2010). The early specialization of youth in sports. Athletic Training & Sports
Health Care: The Journal for the Practicing Clinician,2(6),255-257.
15
Childress, Ronda Gail (2003). Elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball players. Ph.D.
dissertation, The University of Alabama, United States -- Alabama. (Publication No.
AAT 3101738).
DiFiori, J. P. (2010). Evaluation of overuse injuries in children and adolescents. Current Sports
Medicine Reports,9(6),372-378.
Elias, S. R. (2001). 10-year trend in usa cup soccer injuries: 1988-1997. Medicine & Science in
Sports & Exercise,33(3),359-367.
Fleisig, G. S., Weber, A.,Hassell, N., & Andrews,J. R. (2009). Prevention of elbow injuries in
youth baseball pitchers. Current Sports Medicine Reports, 8(5),250-254.
Gomez, J. E., Neufeld, M. D.,& Cosby, B. K. (1996). Ability of middle-school soccer players to
localize overuse leg pain correctly using a graphic self-report form. Perceptual & Motor
Skills,82(1),335-338.
Hawkins, D. D.,& Metheny, J. J. (2001). Overuse injuries in youth sports: biomechanical
considerations. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 33(10),1701-1707.
Initiative to stop youth sport injuries. (2010). JOPERD: The Journal of Physical Education,
Recreation & Dance,81(7),6.
Kocher, M. S., Waters,P. M., & Micheli, L. J. (2000). Upper extremity injuries in the pediatric
athlete. Sports Medicine, 30(2),117-135.
Le Gall, F., Carling, C., Reilly, T., Vandewalle, H.,Church, J.,and Rochconger, P. (2006).
Incidence of injuries in elite French youth soccer players: a 10 – season study, American
Journal of Sports Medicine, June, 34, p 928 – 938.
16
Lyman, S.L. (1999). Arm complaints in youth baseball pitchers: frequency and associationswith
pitch volume, pitch type, and other factors.Ph.D.dissertation, The University of
Alabama at Birmingham, United States -- Alabama. (Publication No. AAT 9935513).
Lyman, S. S., Fleisig, G. S., Waterbor, J. W., Funkhouser, E. M., Pulley, L. L., Andrews,J. R.,
Roseman, J. M. (2001). Longitudinal study of elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball
pitchers. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,33(11),1803-1810.
Mattson, J. M., & Richards, J. (2010). Early specialization in youth sport: a biomechanical
perspective. JOPERD: The Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 81(8),
26-39.
Myer, G. D., Faigenbaum, A. D.,Ford, K. R., Best,T. M., Bergeron, M. F., & Hewett,T. E.
(2011). When to initiate integrative neuromuscular training to reduce sports-related
injuries and enhance health in youth?. Current Sports Medicine Reports,10(3),157-166.
Ogden, D. C., & Warneke, K. (2010). Theoretical considerations in college baseball's relationship
with youth select baseball. Journal of Sport Behavior,33(3),256-275.
Pfeiffer,R. P. (2002). Theme introduction. Athletic Therapy Today,7(6),5.
Ray, T. R. (2010). Youth baseball injuries: recognition, treatment, and prevention. Current Sports
Medicine Reports,9(5),294-298.
Reilly, R. (2006). The parent trap. Sports Illustrated,105(4),76.
Rowland, T. W. (1990). Clinical sports medicine--a new direction for pediatric exercise science.
Pediatric Exercise Science,2(4),291.
17
Salinas, C. M., Webbe, F. M., & Devore, T. T. (2009). The epidemiology of soccer heading in
competitive youth players. Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology,3(1),15-33.
Stiehl, J. (1990). Competitive sports for children and youth. Journal of Sport & Exercise
Psychology,12(2),205-207.
Vescovi, J. D., & VanHeest,J. L. (2010). Effects of an anterior cruciate ligament injury
prevention program on performance in adolescent female soccer players. Scandinavian
Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports,20(3),394-402.
Whittle, R. C., & Crow, B. (2009). Prevention of acl injuries in female athletes through early
intervention. Sport Journal,12(3),1.
Willer, B., Kroetsch,B., Darling, S., Hutson, A.,& Leddy, J. (2005). Injury rates in house league,
select, and representative youth ice hockey. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,
37(10), 1658-1663.

More Related Content

What's hot

Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health Perspective
Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health PerspectivePhysical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health Perspective
Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health PerspectiveLouise Miller Frost
 
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
AJP Health and Wellbeing Consultancy
 
Winter Activities In Decorah And Exercise
Winter Activities In Decorah And ExerciseWinter Activities In Decorah And Exercise
Winter Activities In Decorah And Exerciseiowafoodandfitness
 
Evidence based physical activity for school age youth
Evidence based physical activity for school age youthEvidence based physical activity for school age youth
Evidence based physical activity for school age youth
beatriz9911
 
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
igbenito777
 
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
youth_nex
 
The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...
 The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm... The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...
The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...jk_l33 mn_3l
 
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITYPREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
Dr Goje Mohammed
 
BSc (Hons) Dissertation
BSc (Hons) DissertationBSc (Hons) Dissertation
BSc (Hons) DissertationFrancis Long
 
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee InjuriesTaddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
Nicola Taddio
 
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuriesCheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
Gavin_Randall
 
Movement competency presentation ACHPER 2014 conference
Movement competency presentation  ACHPER 2014 conferenceMovement competency presentation  ACHPER 2014 conference
Movement competency presentation ACHPER 2014 conference
Mark McKean
 
CED grant application Jodie Smith
CED grant application Jodie SmithCED grant application Jodie Smith
CED grant application Jodie SmithJodie Jones
 
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
Jeremy Burnham
 

What's hot (17)

Youth&vitality v1
Youth&vitality v1Youth&vitality v1
Youth&vitality v1
 
Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health Perspective
Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health PerspectivePhysical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health Perspective
Physical Activity in Australian Adults: A Public Health Perspective
 
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
Strength and conditioning Royal Osteoporosis Society 2021
 
Winter Activities In Decorah And Exercise
Winter Activities In Decorah And ExerciseWinter Activities In Decorah And Exercise
Winter Activities In Decorah And Exercise
 
Evidence based physical activity for school age youth
Evidence based physical activity for school age youthEvidence based physical activity for school age youth
Evidence based physical activity for school age youth
 
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
Perceived barriers to exercise in people with spinal cord injury
 
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
Tamara Valovich McLeod, Ph.D. - "The Impact of Sport-Related Injury on Health...
 
The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...
 The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm... The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...
The influence of intensive physical training on growth and pubertal developm...
 
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITYPREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
PREVALENCE OF PHYSICAL INACTIVITY
 
Dallas Huddle Program (2)
Dallas Huddle Program (2)Dallas Huddle Program (2)
Dallas Huddle Program (2)
 
thesis paper
thesis paperthesis paper
thesis paper
 
BSc (Hons) Dissertation
BSc (Hons) DissertationBSc (Hons) Dissertation
BSc (Hons) Dissertation
 
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee InjuriesTaddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
Taddio Isokinetic London 2012: Football Medicine Strategies for Knee Injuries
 
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuriesCheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
Cheerleading where non contact sports can lead to severe injuries
 
Movement competency presentation ACHPER 2014 conference
Movement competency presentation  ACHPER 2014 conferenceMovement competency presentation  ACHPER 2014 conference
Movement competency presentation ACHPER 2014 conference
 
CED grant application Jodie Smith
CED grant application Jodie SmithCED grant application Jodie Smith
CED grant application Jodie Smith
 
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
Single Leg Step-Down Test is Associated with Lower Extremity Injury Risk in H...
 

Viewers also liked

Presentación2 informatica
Presentación2 informaticaPresentación2 informatica
Presentación2 informatica
heliodoro huertas moreno
 
Trajes E Costumes De Portugal
Trajes E Costumes De PortugalTrajes E Costumes De Portugal
Trajes E Costumes De PortugalMcllyr
 
La amistad cataina adriana 803
La amistad cataina adriana 803La amistad cataina adriana 803
La amistad cataina adriana 803
daisytriana123
 
Poland focus on construction permits
Poland    focus on construction permitsPoland    focus on construction permits
Poland focus on construction permits
LAZOVOY
 
Las imagenes digitales
Las imagenes digitalesLas imagenes digitales
Las imagenes digitales
albina rivas
 
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
Silvia Mancero
 
El romance gp
El romance gpEl romance gp
El romance gp
Giuliana Pendola
 
Algemene informatie Stevin
Algemene informatie StevinAlgemene informatie Stevin
Algemene informatie Stevin
Albert-Jan Egmond
 
Sena
SenaSena
Relações entre jogador e avatar
Relações entre jogador e avatarRelações entre jogador e avatar
Relações entre jogador e avatarAlan da Luz
 
Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
 Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
Edu Cezimbra
 
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao MestradoLing Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
Alan da Luz
 
Tecnologia
TecnologiaTecnologia
Tecnologia
Fabiola Gaya
 

Viewers also liked (20)

6
66
6
 
Presentación2 informatica
Presentación2 informaticaPresentación2 informatica
Presentación2 informatica
 
AMP_APPD_Manual_pdf
AMP_APPD_Manual_pdfAMP_APPD_Manual_pdf
AMP_APPD_Manual_pdf
 
Trajes E Costumes De Portugal
Trajes E Costumes De PortugalTrajes E Costumes De Portugal
Trajes E Costumes De Portugal
 
Publication
PublicationPublication
Publication
 
La amistad cataina adriana 803
La amistad cataina adriana 803La amistad cataina adriana 803
La amistad cataina adriana 803
 
Poland focus on construction permits
Poland    focus on construction permitsPoland    focus on construction permits
Poland focus on construction permits
 
Las imagenes digitales
Las imagenes digitalesLas imagenes digitales
Las imagenes digitales
 
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
07 clonezilla silvia_mancero
 
Map1
Map1Map1
Map1
 
El romance gp
El romance gpEl romance gp
El romance gp
 
Algemene informatie Stevin
Algemene informatie StevinAlgemene informatie Stevin
Algemene informatie Stevin
 
Sena
SenaSena
Sena
 
Relações entre jogador e avatar
Relações entre jogador e avatarRelações entre jogador e avatar
Relações entre jogador e avatar
 
EMS - BNI ORLEANS
EMS - BNI ORLEANSEMS - BNI ORLEANS
EMS - BNI ORLEANS
 
Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
 Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
Cada ser humano carrega em si o universo
 
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao MestradoLing Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
Ling Graf Videogames Arguicao Mestrado
 
Boletim (2)
Boletim (2)Boletim (2)
Boletim (2)
 
Frases blog
Frases blogFrases blog
Frases blog
 
Tecnologia
TecnologiaTecnologia
Tecnologia
 

Similar to Masters Final Project

Austin C. Research Paper
Austin C. Research PaperAustin C. Research Paper
Austin C. Research Paperaustintchester
 
Final Copy Research Study
Final Copy Research StudyFinal Copy Research Study
Final Copy Research StudyKevin Strybosch
 
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and Sports
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and SportsDerek Evans Research Paper Parents and Sports
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and SportsDerek Evans
 
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docxInstructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
LaticiaGrissomzz
 
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructed
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructedSocialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructed
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructedJudith van der Leek - Overdevest
 
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In SportsSeven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
Dr Matthew Boente MD
 
10 myths about strength training
10 myths about strength training10 myths about strength training
10 myths about strength training
Aledhughes
 
concussion PowerPoint
concussion PowerPointconcussion PowerPoint
concussion PowerPoint
Eric Schultz
 
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...Alexander Decker
 
US Lacrosse Position Paper
US Lacrosse Position PaperUS Lacrosse Position Paper
US Lacrosse Position Paper
Mark Moreno
 
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docxWeek 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
helzerpatrina
 
Health, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activityHealth, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activity
AllieBarber
 
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
Vinay Ghosh
 
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docxPOSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
harrisonhoward80223
 
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
NahriyahSalsabilah
 
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports InjuriesIntroduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
aamcEvents
 
nick vandelogt concussions in sport poster
nick vandelogt concussions in sport posternick vandelogt concussions in sport poster
nick vandelogt concussions in sport posterNick Vandelogt
 
Sports Specialization Poster Final
Sports Specialization Poster FinalSports Specialization Poster Final
Sports Specialization Poster FinalNicole Miela
 
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCER
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCERTHE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCER
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCERReza Rahimi-Moghaddam
 

Similar to Masters Final Project (19)

Austin C. Research Paper
Austin C. Research PaperAustin C. Research Paper
Austin C. Research Paper
 
Final Copy Research Study
Final Copy Research StudyFinal Copy Research Study
Final Copy Research Study
 
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and Sports
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and SportsDerek Evans Research Paper Parents and Sports
Derek Evans Research Paper Parents and Sports
 
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docxInstructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
Instructor’s Feedback Depth and Relevance 4.5 out of 4.5Rep.docx
 
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructed
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructedSocialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructed
Socialization in sport - how children's sports habitus is constructed
 
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In SportsSeven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
Seven Ways To Reduce Risk of Traumatic Brain Injury In Sports
 
10 myths about strength training
10 myths about strength training10 myths about strength training
10 myths about strength training
 
concussion PowerPoint
concussion PowerPointconcussion PowerPoint
concussion PowerPoint
 
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...
An elaborative view about the physical, social and cultural barriers faced by...
 
US Lacrosse Position Paper
US Lacrosse Position PaperUS Lacrosse Position Paper
US Lacrosse Position Paper
 
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docxWeek 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
Week 4Assignment 4a Annotated BibliographyInstructions You ne.docx
 
Health, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activityHealth, sport and physical activity
Health, sport and physical activity
 
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
Physical Fitness Involvement Among Young Adults and its Relation to other Act...
 
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docxPOSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
POSITION STATEMENTOveruse Injuries and Burnout in Youth Sp.docx
 
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
Nahriyah salsabilah 2020 b_075_jurnal 1
 
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports InjuriesIntroduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
Introduction: Preventing Youth Sports Injuries
 
nick vandelogt concussions in sport poster
nick vandelogt concussions in sport posternick vandelogt concussions in sport poster
nick vandelogt concussions in sport poster
 
Sports Specialization Poster Final
Sports Specialization Poster FinalSports Specialization Poster Final
Sports Specialization Poster Final
 
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCER
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCERTHE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCER
THE ROLE OF PARENTS IN PREVENTION OF SOCCER
 

Masters Final Project

  • 1. A STUDY OF THE EFFECTS OF YOUTH COMPETITVE SPORTS ON REPETITIVE MOTION INURIES DURING PUBERTY by Richard L. Brenkmann A master’s project submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Education in Health, Physical Education, and Recreation Approved: Dr. John M. Kras,Chair Date Dr. Richard Gordin, Member Date Dr. Dennis Nelson, Member Date Dr. Dennis Dolny, Department Head Date UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Logan, Utah 2011
  • 2. A STUDY OF THE EFFECTS OF YOUTH COMPETITVE SPORTS ON REPETITIVE MOTION INURIES DURING PUBERTY Problem Statement When I was young, my friends and I played whatever sport was in season,except for the summer when the sport relied on available shade. We never focused on any one particular sport all the way through high school. Today’s youth are starting to focus on one sport at a much earlier age in an attempt to elevate their abilities to a level of hopefully being able to become professional athletes some day. Some kids are starting to specialize in competitive leagues as early as eight years old, and really only playing that sport until they get out of high school. This practice, I believe, is dangerous for the young person who does this. Many of these competitive players end up with nagging injuries that plague them throughout their career. Most of these injuries are from repetitive motions that put an unnatural strain on a particular set of joints and muscles. These injuries are mere nuisances in the beginning, but without proper rest and care the injuries will become chronic and more problematic as the child gets older. These injuries are developing new names based on the sport such as soccer knee and pitcher’s elbow. An individual who focuses on one sport also misses out on the skills that cross over from one sport to the next, and can make a player an overall better player. By participating in other sports, the joints and muscles will strengthen which could also prevent other injuries. The literature suggests that youth who participate in only one sport, without decent rest,and without experiencing “muscle confusion” (Bosgieter, 2010) can suffer overuse injuries that can eventually develop into chronic injuries. The problem I will study is how prevalent are these injuries in one sport participants between the ages of ten to 16 years old.
  • 3. 2 Purpose and Objectives The purpose of this paper is to show a correlation between the repetitive injuries and the playing of only one sport during the developmental years through puberty. The objectives would be to show to researchers and parents the need to participate in multiple activities to increase the skills in the main sport. I would also hope to encourage parents and youth to consider playing multiple sports because I do not know too many eight year olds who are already planning a career in something specific. Burnout among these athletes is high because they have nothing else going on but this one sport, and eventually they may grow to despise the sport. There are several groups that have banded together to create “’the STOP Sports Injuries’ campaign to raise awareness about this trend and help prevent athletic overuse and trauma injuries in children” (Initiative to Stop, 2010). I would hope conscientious readers would realize that this is true and encourage play for plays sake in their children. ReviewofLiterature Competitive sports programs have been growing over the last severalyears with not only local leagues, but regional and national leagues as well. There are competitive leagues in basketball, baseball, soccer,hockey and rugby that have contests throughout the year. Most competitive teams also play in tournaments on weekends all over the region in which they live, as well as league games during the week. There are those who argue that the “all-embracing goal for children's sport programs: helping young athletes emerge from the sport experience as responsible, autonomous people” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). “Coaches should include this goal in their personal coaching philosophy and many have not done so” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). This responsibility should fall to “all adults, whether coaching or not, can help young athletes learn to become responsible for themselves” (Stiehl, 1990, p 207). “Sports programs for young people
  • 4. 3 have grown so rapidly that scholars and practitioners alike are hard pressed to keep up with new knowledge” (Stiehl, 1990, p 205). It is not just the psychological toll, but also the physical toll that youth face,especially in the repetitive actions that occur in competitive sports. The adults who participate in competitive youth sports are the parents. The influence of parents on the youth players is important in determining the efforts of the child, as well as the level of soreness that the child will endure. “The degree of involvement a parent makes in their child's sport makes a statement about the relative importance of this domain” (Barber,1999). If a child senses that playing and doing well is important to the parent, then the child “will adopt values and beliefs similar to their parents” (Barber,1999). Parents range in the level of involvement from being over-involved to under-involved. Barber (1999) looked at the relationship of parents to their children in youth sports, and found that youth participated for fun, but initially for many it may have been encouragement from their parents to participate. With the move to earlier specialization, it should be understood that “The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Committee on Sports Medicine and Fitness does not recommend specialization before the age of 12 or 13 years” (Rosenbaum,p 255). The early start of sports specialization can lead to injury due to micro-trauma to the growth plate. “Often, younger athletes do not recognize overuse symptoms until they become debilitating” (Rosenbaum, p 256). Rosenbaum also stated that “adolescents are not as coordinated or may not yet have adjusted to physiological changes during an increased velocity of growth. This could result in altered flexibility with inherent muscle imbalances, making them vulnerable to injury” (p 256). The AAP recommends as an alternate to early sport specialization is sports diversification, which would be considered as sampling (multiple sport experiences) from 6 to 12, and specialization coming after in ages 13 to 15 (Rosenbaum, p 256).
  • 5. 4 There have been a number of studies that have looked at various injuries in youth sports and the causes behind them. Much of the literature focuses on the kinds of injuries associated with contact or traumatic stress injury. The focus of my project is to look at repetitive use injuries due to overuse and not enough rest between competitive activities. “Orthopedic surgeons are also seeing a rise in the number of youth sports injuries in general, and in the number of younger athletes who suffer overuse injuries” (Initiative to Stop, 2010). The literature that focuses on the repetitive injuries seems to be mostly involving the sports of soccer and lower extremity issues, and baseball pitchers with injuries involving the shoulder and elbow. A New York Times Magazine article discusses the prevalence of elbow and shoulder injuries in youth baseball. Berler (2009) did a study of the increasing number of youth players who were having elbow and shoulder surgeries at much younger ages. “A 13 year old might pitch Sunday for his travel team, Monday for his middle school team, and Wednesday for his Babe Ruth team” (Berler, 2009). There are some players today who are “playing baseball nearly year round, to the exclusion of all other sports” (Berler, 2009). “Parents failed to realize to recognize that kids need 3 – 4 months of recovery time each year” (Berler,2009). Childress (2003) describes pitching as “one of the most dynamic motions in sport. This is demonstrated when the average time from initial foot contact of the stride leg to ball release is 0.145 seconds” (p 1). Injuries to the elbow and shoulder are the normal injury site for youth baseball players, with the most common being Little League Elbow. “The stress placed on the elbow during pitching has been implicated as the cause of little league elbow” (Childress, 2003, p 2). Adolescent elbow injuries are repetitive injuries that are mostly skeletal in nature, and rarely involve the muscle tendon that happens with adults. “When the elbow of an adolescent is
  • 6. 5 subjected to repeated stress,the growth plates are more vulnerable to injury” (Childress 2003, p 3) Other studies have shown that there is a deficiency in training and proper technique that is the problem causing the shoulder and elbow pain. Aguinaldo, Butters and Chambers (2007) looked at a concern described as “’throwing with too much arm,’ in which the energy from trunk rotation is transferred to the upper arm too early and dissipated instead of being applied to the hand and ball. (p 43) Aguinaldo, et al studied “the biomechanical patterns of trunk rotation and shoulder joint torque during baseball pitching between professional, collegiate, high school, and youth players.” (p 44) Although including some items from an older class, this information is pertinent to this study because it helps to establish a background of the mechanics that make for safer pitching. “The current study demonstrated that pitchers who rotated their torsos later in their delivery exhibited less shoulder internal rotation torque (Aguinaldo, et al, 2007, p 48). Based on their work, Aguinaldo, et al surmised “that the sequence of body segmental motion was compromised when the trunk rotated too early, because part of the rotational energy was lost and made up for by the upper extremity” (2007 p 48). In a broader study of reported arm pain, Lyman, Fleisig, Waterbor,Funkhouser, Pulley, Andrews,Osinski, and Rosman looked at 298 youth baseball pitchers over two seasons. The study was designed “to evaluate the frequency of elbow and shoulder complaints in young pitchers and to identify the associations between pitch types, pitch volume, and other risk factors for these conditions.” (Lyman et al, 2001, p 1803) Each participant was contacted after a pitching outing and asked a series of questions that would help the researchers “identify arm complaints. Generalized estimating equations were used to assess associations between arm complaints and independent variables. Results: The frequency of elbow pain was 26%; that of shoulder pain, 32% ” (Lyman, et al, 2001, 1803). Lyman, et al (2001) identified severalrisk factors that seemed to be
  • 7. 6 an underlying variable in both locations which included “playing baseball outside the league, decreased self-satisfaction, arm fatigue during the game pitched, and throwing fewer than 300 or more than 600 pitches during the season” (1803). It was also noticed that throwing more than 75 pitches in a game will also lead to shoulder or elbow pain. Lyman, et al (2011) concluded that “arm complaints are common, with nearly half of the subjects reporting pain. The factors associated with elbow and shoulder pain were different, suggesting differing etiologies. Developmental factors may be important in both, to lower the risk of pain at both locations young pitchers probably should not throw more than 75 pitches in a game” (1083). In a different study by Fleisig, Weber, Hassell and Andrews (2009), they found that “the risk of Adolescents who competitively pitch more than 85 pitches per game, more than 8 months out of a year or with arm fatigue are severaltimes more likely to require elbow surgery. Poor pitching mechanics also appear to contribute to injury risk” (p254). Fleisig, et al. (2009) pointed to “the number of pitches thrown has the strongest correlation to youth pitching injuries” (p 250). Although Little League Baseball has created guidelines limiting pitch counts, “many independent and travel teams have no rules restricting pitch counts, inning limits, or days of rest” (Fleisig, et al. 2009, p 251). A player who may be a good pitcher could end up pitching 3 or 4 days a week, throwing hundreds of pitches during that time. Major League baseball pitchers are monitored constantly, and rarely throw more than 115 pitches in a week, and some coaches are asking youth to throw more with less rest. Fleisig, et al. (2009) stated that: “Our impression is that in past generations, most children engaged in a reasonable amount of sports participation; now, there are many children who do not play enough sports, and a smaller ‘elite’ group of children who participate too much in one particular sport” (p 252). Ray (2010) took a more medical look at the injuries incurred by youth and found “that taller and heavier children have an increased risk of injury to the elbow and shoulder than their
  • 8. 7 counterparts of the same age. One possible explanation for this finding may include their higher level of performance and subsequent overuse by coaches set on winning” (p 295). It seems that many youth pitching injuries are blamed on the throwing of a curveball. Ray (2010) states “shoulder internal rotation torque and proximal force as well as elbow varus torque and proximal force were significantly less for the curveball than the fastball when comparing the biomechanics of youth pitchers throwing the fastball, curveball, and change up. Although more research in this important area is needed, this suggests that the curveball might not be more harmful to the youth pitcher than the fastball” (p 295-296). More simply put, the torque from a properly thrown curveball is less on the elbow and shoulder, and likely less harmful (although the emphasis should be put on a properly thrown curveball) than a fastball or change-up. Kocher, Waters,and Micheli (2000) also approached Little League Elbow from a more mechanical standpoint, looking at the biomechanics of the injury. “Recognition of injury patterns with early activity modification and the initiation of efficacious treatment can prevent deformity/disability and return the youth athlete to sport” (Kocher,et al. 2000, p 118). Pitchers suffer from “injury to the paediatric (sic) shoulder from throwing is a result of microtrauma (sic) from repetitive motions of large rotational forces” (Kocher,et al. 2000, p 119). Ogden and Warneke (2010) took a look at the correlation between college baseball pitchers and youth competitive baseball pitchers as to whether these players had more need for surgery later, and also had more pain from pitching. Select, or competitive, teams are starting play earlier, as early as 7 or 8 years old, and these kids are encouraged to play year-round. As stated earlier, it is recommended by researchers and doctors that players take up to 4 months off of a particular sport in a year to rest and recover. Ogden and Warneke (2010) state “that the youths who grow to be the best adult athletes are often those who engage in a variety of sports, or multilateral development, in their earliest years. During those years children should be building the basic skills of running, jumping, and throwing.” Although these select teams do seem to
  • 9. 8 show a correlation to transitioning to the higher leagues, players were stricken with more stress and burnout, and sometimes outright quit before reaching that level. Those who participated at higher skill positions like pitcher and catcher also showed more signs of overuse injuries as they progressed from level to level. Studies have also looked at the incidence of injuries in youth soccer players. Just like the use of the term Little League Elbow, soccer has its own malady of overuse called Soccer Knee. This injury is characterized by the painful swelling of the patellar tendon, and is cause in large part by the contraction of the quadriceps muscles to kick the ball and also to plant with the opposite foot. This injury is less common in the recreational player who plays one game a week, and practices once per week. Soccer Knee injuries are typically found in competitive soccer players who will play and practice three or more times per week,and they often play 12 months of the year. Another issue looked at by Viscovi and Van Heest (2009) was the number of ACL injuries being suffered by female soccer players (p 394). The injuries in question are non contact injuries that come from weak muscles that provide support to the knee joint. Viscovi and Van Heest (2009) investigated the effectiveness of “the Prevent Injury Enhance Program” on adolescent female soccer players (p 394). “Epidemiological studies with soccer players indicate that the most common anatomical site for injury is the lower extremities. Of particular concern for female soccer players is that following puberty they are three times more likely to suffer an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury compared with the male soccer players” (Viscovi and Van Heest,2009, p 394). Although this study was designed to look at injury prevention training, it showed that part of this rash of ACL injuries could have as much to do with overuse. The testing was conducted on four club soccer teams who were playing during a summer outdoor season,with two teams running the training program and two who were doing an ordinary warm up. At issue were the difference between warm up regimens and whether they decreased injury or improved performance. There seemed to be no difference in the effects of the two warm-ups,
  • 10. 9 and yet they were working with club athletes who played year round. The look at what was happening in the injury situation could have been about rest time, time off, and healing of the micro tears of the ligaments, tendons and muscles that occur when the adolescent soccer player plays and practices 4 or more times per week. The study concluded “, these programs were designed with an aim of reducing the risk of non-contact ACL injuries, not enhancing performance. However,if we are to convince coaches to implement an injury prevention program, then investigators and clinicians should continue to modify program variables and develop regimens that have promise to deliver dual benefits – improved performance and reduced injury risk” (Viscovi and Van Heest,2009, p 401). In a 10 year study of common injuries in elite youth French soccer players, Le Gall, Carling, Reilly, Vandewalle, Church, and Rochcongar (2006) found that “players younger than 14 years incurred more injuries in training and sustained more growth-related overuse disorders. Older players were more often injured during matches. Injury incidence and the frequency of overuse disorders were highest early in the season” (p 928). The study seemed to suggest the younger “players still lacked injury-avoidance skills or could have been undertaking too much intensive training at this age” (Le Gall et al., 2006, p 934). Le Gall et al. (2006) further stated that “injuries in less experienced, younger players may be owing to weaknesses in technical and tactical ability as well as in muscle strength, endurance,and coordination” (p 934). “There was a significantly greater amount of osteochondral disorders at the apophyseal or epiphyseal growth areas of bones, which are linked to overuse, in U14 players, suggesting that this is a high-risk group” (Le Gall et al., 2006, p 936). Elias (2001) conducted a 10 year study that differed from Le Gall et al. by focusing his study on injuries incurred during a major soccer tournament only. Elias chose the USA Cup
  • 11. 10 Soccer Tournament held in Minnesota every July to study the injuries that were occurring during the competition at all levels. This tournament lasts 6 days and has “over 800 teams from 23 countries participating in age groups under-12 to under-19. All games are played at the National Sports Center/Blaine Soccer Complex, which has 55 fields on one site” (Elias, 2001, p 359). At the end of the ten year study, Elias (2001) holds the notion that “although females are injured at a rate slightly greater than males, there is a trend suggesting that the overall difference is becoming less significant” (p 367). This was related to the aggressiveness of play between the sexes,as well as the differences experienced in conditioning. Gomez, Neufeld, and Cosby (1996) chose to determine whether middle school soccer players could “assess the probability of success with which … players could correctly localize lower leg pain to sites of common overuse injuries” (p 335). The goal is to develop an instrument that will help youth understand and care for overuse injuries that can lead to significant injuries later if not cared for early enough. “The majority of overuse injuries in young athletes occur in the lower extremity. The common overuse injuries of the leg in youngsters include shin splints, patellar tendonitis, plantar fasciitis, Osgood-Schlatter disease,and Sever disease” (Gomez, et al., 1996, p 335). Gomez, et al. (1996) discovered that these nagging injuries were rarely significant enough to warrant a trip to a doctor or trainer (p 338). “Since athletes with overuse injuries can often ‘play through’ the pain, it may be more useful in evaluating the clinical significance of these injuries to ask about the extent to which the pain compromised the athletes’ performance” (Gomez et al. 1996, p 338). With the recent emphasis being placed on head injuries, and the cumulative effects on the brain of repeated minor concussions, a new field has grown out of competitive injuries involving the heading of the ball. Contact among soccer players is generally not significant enough to
  • 12. 11 warrant more than a look at contusions, but heading a soccer ball repeatedly can lead to minor concussive events in the brain. Salinas, Webbe, and Devore (2009) looked at this phenomenon and found that “the head injury rate accounts for 4.9–22% of soccer injuries in adolescents” (p 15). “The majority of soccer headings were direct rather than flicks. Almost half of our participants reported headache and one-fourth reported dizziness after instances of heading the ball” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 15). “Children are even more likely to lack awareness of concussion symptoms and so may not accurately report their symptoms. Without knowledge of such critical information about their child’s symptoms, parents may not understand that these injuries require medical attention” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 16). Parents,coaches and players need to understand both the symptoms and related problems that can come from repeated concussions. “In soccer play, concussive head injuries are most likely to happen when two players make a mutual attempt to head the ball. Heads banging together or elbows and fists striking a head are common. Less common are injuries related to the ball striking the head” (Salinas, et al., 2009, p 17). Discussion As this information is looked at, I understand that repetitive injury is not limited to only the competitive sports, but can occur in recreational sports as well. In a humorous article for Sports Illustrated,Rick Reilly looks at what could be considered the absurd side of competitive sports, but there still is the need to look at the potential for injury when a child who is still growing plays one sport exclusively. “But then my wife gets to talking to some other moms at Justin's slap shot workshop, and they say we're crazy if we don't have a 'performance-enhancement specialist' for our kids. So she signs them both up with one. Then she finds out most of these girls have 'recruiting consultants' who make highlight reels of kids and send them to college
  • 13. 12 coaches. I'm like, 'She's 14!' And my wife is like, 'You're gonna tell our little girl no?' Then we add a rating-service guy and a sports psychologist and a webmaster” (Reilly, 2006, p 76). Competitive sports are leading to new needs in pediatric health as nagging injuries become more serious in nature. “Because it's unrealistic to expect an enthusiastic young athlete or an overzealous parent to recognize the severity of the issue and consequently know when to ease back, it's up to recreation professionals and youth sports administrators to get the word out on preventing overuse injuries” (Bach and Shilling, 2008, p 24). Bach and Shilling (2008) went on to further state: “Today's youth athletics are rife with single- sport specialization, heavy practice schedules, and year-round training. The result is that a disturbing number of young athletes have their seasons chopped short—and their long-term health jeopardized—by overuse injuries. As more and more youngsters are forced to visit doctors' offices for everything from bone fractures and Little League elbow to shin splints and damaged knees,the alarm is being sounded loud and clear by sports medicine professionals that too much of the same activity can do more harm than good. Overuse injuries are sabotaging what should be a fun and rewarding experience for millions of young athletes. These children, who are breaking down due to the constant stress being placed on their young and developing bodies, often face the unenviable prospect of long and sometimes painful rehabilitations — and even surgery—to repair the damage” (p 24). Conclusion The youth are playing one sport exclusively more and more, and many are starting at a much earlier age. The literature shows that, at least while growth is continuing to occur, there
  • 14. 13 should be multiple sports tried by youth so that the muscles and bones can rest and recover. Playing one sport year round never allows for the micro trauma to heal. I look at Washington Nationals pitching phenom Stefan Strassbourg, and I see a young man who probably focused on baseball at an early age. Granted,he signed a big money contract, but since being called up to the majors at 19, he has spent more time recovering from elbow and shoulder pain than he has playing. The micro trauma and lack of healing has caught up with him, and a bright future in baseball is looking rather tenuous at this time.
  • 15. 14 REFERENCES Aguinaldo, A. L., Buttermore, J., & Chambers, H. (2007). Effects of upper trunk rotation on shoulder joint torque among baseball pitchers of various levels. Journal of Applied Biomechanics,23(1),42-51. Allen, S. (2011) Do components of a pre-participation examination in female adolescent soccer players predict acute lower extremity injuries in soccer? M.Sc. dissertation, University of Calgary (Canada),Canada. (Publication No. AAT MR75201). Bach,G., & Shilling, A. (2008). Research update: combating the overuse epidemic. Parks & Recreation, 43(8),24-27. Barber,H. H., Sukhi, H. H., & White, S. A. (1999). The influence of parent-coaches on participant motivation and competitive anxiety in youth sport participants. Journal of Sport Behavior, 22(2),162-180. Berler, R. (2009, August). More and more youth pitchers are having operations on their elbows and shoulders. So why aren't the grown-ups doing something about it? New York Times Magazine,20-25. (Document ID: 1830321111). Bosgieter, Kory, (2011) [Lecture notes] Butcher, J., Lindner, K. J., & Johns, D. P. (2002). Withdrawal from competitive youth sport: a retrospective ten-year study. Journal of Sport Behavior,25(2),145. Callender, S. (2010). The early specialization of youth in sports. Athletic Training & Sports Health Care: The Journal for the Practicing Clinician,2(6),255-257.
  • 16. 15 Childress, Ronda Gail (2003). Elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball players. Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Alabama, United States -- Alabama. (Publication No. AAT 3101738). DiFiori, J. P. (2010). Evaluation of overuse injuries in children and adolescents. Current Sports Medicine Reports,9(6),372-378. Elias, S. R. (2001). 10-year trend in usa cup soccer injuries: 1988-1997. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,33(3),359-367. Fleisig, G. S., Weber, A.,Hassell, N., & Andrews,J. R. (2009). Prevention of elbow injuries in youth baseball pitchers. Current Sports Medicine Reports, 8(5),250-254. Gomez, J. E., Neufeld, M. D.,& Cosby, B. K. (1996). Ability of middle-school soccer players to localize overuse leg pain correctly using a graphic self-report form. Perceptual & Motor Skills,82(1),335-338. Hawkins, D. D.,& Metheny, J. J. (2001). Overuse injuries in youth sports: biomechanical considerations. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 33(10),1701-1707. Initiative to stop youth sport injuries. (2010). JOPERD: The Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance,81(7),6. Kocher, M. S., Waters,P. M., & Micheli, L. J. (2000). Upper extremity injuries in the pediatric athlete. Sports Medicine, 30(2),117-135. Le Gall, F., Carling, C., Reilly, T., Vandewalle, H.,Church, J.,and Rochconger, P. (2006). Incidence of injuries in elite French youth soccer players: a 10 – season study, American Journal of Sports Medicine, June, 34, p 928 – 938.
  • 17. 16 Lyman, S.L. (1999). Arm complaints in youth baseball pitchers: frequency and associationswith pitch volume, pitch type, and other factors.Ph.D.dissertation, The University of Alabama at Birmingham, United States -- Alabama. (Publication No. AAT 9935513). Lyman, S. S., Fleisig, G. S., Waterbor, J. W., Funkhouser, E. M., Pulley, L. L., Andrews,J. R., Roseman, J. M. (2001). Longitudinal study of elbow and shoulder pain in youth baseball pitchers. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,33(11),1803-1810. Mattson, J. M., & Richards, J. (2010). Early specialization in youth sport: a biomechanical perspective. JOPERD: The Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 81(8), 26-39. Myer, G. D., Faigenbaum, A. D.,Ford, K. R., Best,T. M., Bergeron, M. F., & Hewett,T. E. (2011). When to initiate integrative neuromuscular training to reduce sports-related injuries and enhance health in youth?. Current Sports Medicine Reports,10(3),157-166. Ogden, D. C., & Warneke, K. (2010). Theoretical considerations in college baseball's relationship with youth select baseball. Journal of Sport Behavior,33(3),256-275. Pfeiffer,R. P. (2002). Theme introduction. Athletic Therapy Today,7(6),5. Ray, T. R. (2010). Youth baseball injuries: recognition, treatment, and prevention. Current Sports Medicine Reports,9(5),294-298. Reilly, R. (2006). The parent trap. Sports Illustrated,105(4),76. Rowland, T. W. (1990). Clinical sports medicine--a new direction for pediatric exercise science. Pediatric Exercise Science,2(4),291.
  • 18. 17 Salinas, C. M., Webbe, F. M., & Devore, T. T. (2009). The epidemiology of soccer heading in competitive youth players. Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology,3(1),15-33. Stiehl, J. (1990). Competitive sports for children and youth. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology,12(2),205-207. Vescovi, J. D., & VanHeest,J. L. (2010). Effects of an anterior cruciate ligament injury prevention program on performance in adolescent female soccer players. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports,20(3),394-402. Whittle, R. C., & Crow, B. (2009). Prevention of acl injuries in female athletes through early intervention. Sport Journal,12(3),1. Willer, B., Kroetsch,B., Darling, S., Hutson, A.,& Leddy, J. (2005). Injury rates in house league, select, and representative youth ice hockey. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 37(10), 1658-1663.