SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The Asia Pacific Network for Housing Research (APNHR) April 2015 1
Houses design of Low cost Housing in Malaysia
Wan Nur Rukiah Mohd Arshard¹ Ku Azhar Ku Hassan²
Abstract
Lifestyle changes in society nowadays depend on their daily schedule. Today’s society view safety and comfort as crucial in
their lives. This study discusses the ideal design of public and low-cost housing while taking into account the aspects of viable
size and cost and limited land space. Low-cost houses are designed in accordance to the specific guidelines set by the local
city council and the National Housing Department. The boom of the housing and planning evolution in 1970s gave renewed
focus to the low-income class and brought about the relocation of squatters through public housing. This was further
advocated in the 1990s, through the government’s efforts in increasing low-cost housing areas, this effort is ongoing to this
day. The design and organization of the in-house space had also improved through time and the incorporation of
environmental and local conditions and needs. Standard house space design is vital in the carrying out of daily activities,
especially for those of the low-income group. These two states were chosen as both the states have been subject to rapid
public housing and low-cost housing development respectively. This paper discusses the basic approach in terms of rules,
regulation and guidelines in the design of low-cost houses that is being built. An ideal spatial allocation and the suitable space
usage in terms of current needs is focused on. A spatial and size allocation for the low-income group, which will be viable and
efficient for the next 20years, must be established. Establishing an effective and efficient spatial allocation both inside and
outside of a house which is acceptable to the local community’s varied culture, norms and economic activities is crucial as it
will determine the future demand for low-cost housing and its reception by the low-income group.
Keywords: Low Cost Housing, House Design, Space standards, Low-income group.
I. Introduction
In Malaysia, the provisioning of low-cost housing and
meeting the housing needs of the country does not only
involve the public sector, as the private sector also plays an
important role in the efforts of doing so. The government’s
inability to provide adequate low-cost housing for the
people has pushed the private sector into taking over this
role. The government provides more sites for housing
development to the private sector and in return claims a
number of housing units to serve the aforementioned
purpose (Zakiyah, Sh. Sofiah & Afifah 2004).
The design of a house is quite crucial as it facilitates
comfort and security for those living in it, functioning to
protect them from the weather and environmental
conditions while taking into account the local cultural
aspect. Most house designs are adapted from designs
abroad. However, this discussion will focus on the design
of low-cost housing in Malaysia in terms of related policies,
guidelines and government standards which are subject to
the authority of the specific state and its local structural
plans. The low cost houses featured by the two fastest
growing and developing cities socially and economically,
Kuala Lumpur and Penang, are reviewed in this discussion.
The design of low-cost houses are subject to the
guidelines and standards set by the ministry of housing and
the local government (refer to the 1998 guidelines and the
national housing amendment of 2002 under the
Construction Industry Development Board). Each state has
its respective house pricing and household size guidelines
depending on the area, whether urban or rural. The design
of houses are controlled and monitored by the local
councils according to the set characteristics of quality and
living comfort.
II. Low-cost Housing Policies in Malaysia
Housing policies drafted so far have been done based
on issues and problems that had cropped up from time to
time. In other words, policies are designed to ensure that
¹ PhD. Candidate School of Housing, Building and Planning,
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,Malaysia
² Associate Professor, School of Housing, Building and Planning,
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,Malaysia
Contact Author: Wan Nur Rukiah, Student, School of
Housing, Building and Planning,Universiti Sains Malaysia,
Penang,Malaysia.
Tel: +604-6533888 Ext. 2184 Fax: +604-6576271
e-mail: nur77.arshard@gmail.com
2 APNHR April 2015
the long term 20 to 30 year development plan does not veer
too far off from the core values and goals of the New
Economic Policy, which was drafted and approved by the
government to develop a disciplined, loyalty, and
self-reliant society. Many Acts, regulations and guidelines
related to housing development, both directly or indirectly
had been established with the aim of ensuring adequate
supply of homes on the market as indicated by KPKT.
1. Central Government Policies
Low cost housing policies that brought about the active
role of private developers actually began through the
Fourth Malaysian Plan, in line with the era of privatization
in Malaysia (the Malaysian Government, 1981). Ghani and
Lee (1997a) had outlined the characteristics of the low-cost
housing policy, as set by the central government:
a. Thirty (30) percent Low-Cost Component
This policy required private developers who planned to
build a certain number of housing units to provide low-cost
houses, which had to amount to at least 30 percent of the
housing units. This minimum limit, however, differs from
state to state. Moreover, the determination of the 30
percent component has no clear relationship to the low-cost
houses target which is to be built by private developers, as
specified in the Malaysian Five Year Plan (ibid.). This 30
percent low-cost houses component is usually enforced
either at the conversion and subdivision application
approval level or when a private developer receives the
approval of conversion and subdivision. The imposition of
the 30 percent component is detected when the developer
submits an application to the local authority for the
approval of the plans and building projects. Compliance to
these requirements is confirmed when the developer
applies for the certificate of occupancy from the local
authorities.
b. Unit Price of a Low-Cost House
When the low-cost housing policy was first
implemented, the price of a low-cost house was about
RM25,000. This price had remained up until June 1998
when the federal government agreed to allow low-cost
houses to be sold at a price higher than RM25,000,
according to the project site (Government of Malaysia,
2001).Implementation guidelines the prices of new
low-cost homes, which has been in effect from June 10,
1998.However, average house prices had fallen in 1997
and 1998 during the economic downturn. The average
house price reached a record level of RM101,544 in 1996,
before declining to RM82,916 in 1998. The increase in
house prices before 1997 were probably due to high
demand and the rising cost of labour and building materials.
The demand for houses was also assisted by the ease of
access to financing obtained.
However, the prices of low cost houses for
low-income earners have been relatively stable due to the
price control done by the government. (Quality of life of
Malaysia 1999)
There are several low-cost housing programmes
provided by the local government to meet the housing
needs of low-income earners. Each state has its own
low-cost housing programmes which are in line with the
State’s structural plan. On the other hand, the national
housing policy is also set by the Ministry of Urban
Wellbeing, Housing and Local Government (KPKT) to the
same effect. Below are the low-cost housing programmes
in Malaysia which are implemented by the local council in
Kuala Lumpur and Penang.
III. Public Housing Programme
The Low-Cost Housing Programme (PPAKR) aims to
provide homes for low-income earners through a number
of schemes. This program is intended for buyers with
monthly household income of approximately RM1,500 and
below while the per unit selling price of the houses do not
exceed RM35,000. The featured type of houses are by
location and land either 5 storey flats or terraced houses.
The minimum design for a low-cost house is has a standard
built up area of not less than 60 square meters (900 square
feet), featuring three bedrooms, a living room, kitchen,
bathroom and toilet (Quality of life in Malaysia, 2004).
1. Low-Cost Housing Programme
The area of a low-cost house has to be in accordance
with the guidelines of the local government in each state,
while the pricing in line with the guidelines of the National
Housing Department. In the case of low-cost houses
provided by private developers that provide medium cost
housing, a minimum total contribution of low cost houses
of about 20% (up to a maximum of 30%) is imposed.
2. People’s Housing Program (PPR)
Houses featured are with an area of 700 square feet
(larger compared to the age old 650 square feet and 600
square feet practice); with three bedrooms, two bathrooms,
a kitchen, an area for drying clothes, and tiled floors.
Facilities such as community halls, playgrounds for
children, kindergartens, shops, stalls, prayer halls (Surau),
parking areas and other public spaces are also provided for
the comfort of the residents so that they can enjoy a high
quality healthy living environment.Since the introduction
of PPR in 1998 up till December 31st of 2012, the federal
government through the KPKT has completed about 67
APNHR April 2015 3
projects consisting of 64,771 PPR units (rental) and 23
projects consisting of 3109 PPR units (Owned). PPR units
are rented to applicants who meet the requirements and
criteria at a rate of RM124 per month or sold at a price of
RM30,000 to RM35,000 each.
The 67 PPR projects (rental) spans throughout the
country, namely in Perlis, Kedah, Penang, Perak, Selangor,
Negeri Sembilan, Johor, Sabah, Sarawak and Kuala
Lumpur, while 23 PPR projects (Owned) are located
specifically in Pahang. Additionally, a total of 21 projects
involving approximately 11,028 units are currently in
various stages of implementation.
Under the 2013 Budget, a total of RM1.9 billion had
been allocated to build 123,000 affordable homes in
strategic locations throughout the country. From the total
provision, RM543 million had been allocated to KPKT to
finance 45 projects involving 20,454 units under the PPR
project that will be built using the industrialized building
system. (Ministry of Urban Well being, Housing and Local
Government).
IV. Policies, Guidelines and Standards
At the national level, state policies are generally
transfigured in detail into policies and development
strategies of the country. At the state level, there exist
structural and strategic plans in place for each state that
fuels policies. The transformation process of the more
general policies at the national level into detailed strategies
and requirements at the state and local authority level
however, is not uniform, with promised benefits not given
adequate attention and in turn burdening the low-cost
housing industry locally (Ghani and Lee 1997). Generally,
according to the national development policy, the market
strategy was proposed and given to the related private
entities after introducing the new guidelines of low-cost
housing on the sales market in June 1998 (amended in
2002). Private developers and agencies are encouraged to
implement market price adjustments for low wage earner
levels (RM750 per month), with a ceiling price of
RM25,000 (with the exception of Johor, which is set at
RM20,000) and houses of 45-56 m² in size.
The guidelines for low-cost housing which was
established in 1982 with a set price of RM25,000 a unit,
had been since reviewed and re-evaluated by the Ministry
of Housing and the local government in June 1998. The
original pricing was deemed no longer appropriate in the
current situation where construction costs are way higher,
thus, a new pricing which is in accordance with the current
situation had to be established.
1. State Policies
Policies at the State level are as a whole a more
detailed and have better overall strategies. State level
policies are derived from the structural and strategic plan
and strategic plans specific to the state. The overall local
plan describes the particular needs of the local authorities.
In the case of the low-cost housing industry, at the local
level policies are more specific on the benefits granted or
the burden on developers. As in the state policies these
aspects are described clearly with regards to the local
authority in each state.
In order to improve the quality of low-cost houses and
simultaneously meet private developers argument for a
review of selling prices of these units the government has
introduced in 1998 the new pricing guidelines for this type
of houses (Morshidi, Abdul Fatah, Abdul Rashid, Alip,
Halim, Usman, 1999).Though part of a same country, there
exist a different understanding in the sense of the local
standards and conditions with regards to the local
authorities.
2. Local Guidelines
In this study, two cities and its local council are
contrasted according to its local structures. There are
advantages and disadvantages in each of the local council
guidelines. As such, there is a need for better guidelines
and its efficient execution in the future. The local
government plays a role in approving building plans
submitted by developers, designers and architects. Thus, in
the efforts of the distribution of housing to the people, the
local government should distribute housing to people of all
walks of life respectively. Mohd Fuad (1998) found that
most of the Malays could not afford to buy houses as the
market price is too high and the form of housing is less
desirable to them. His discussion was specific on the
inability of a certain race in acquiring houses due to high
prices. In other words, there is a lack of low medium and
low-cost housing projects as developers are not very
interested in undertaking such projects. Most homes and
condos in the Federal Territory are priced at RM150,000.00
- 500,000.00. As such, only a handful of Malays are able
to acquire said houses when compared to other races
(Junaidi, Rosmadi & Amer, 2012).
a. Kuala Lumpur
The DBKL local council has a 2020 Structural Plan
goal that is yet to be achieved which aims to make Kuala
Lumpur a city that protects the wellbeing and comfort of
its populace. Squatters in Kuala Lumpur and around the
city have been long eliminated through public housing and
PPAKR programmes to meet the housing demand of the
4 APNHR April 2015
people in the city.
The Affordable basic home policy introduced in the
federal Region has been implemented in the Federal
Territories of Kuala Lumpur, Labuan and Putrajaya, and
have been effective since 28 March 2013. These regions
still use the low-cost housing guidelines (KPKT, 1998) for
house pricing and household size allocation. The table
below shows the variation of the guidelines used by the
two local authorities of Kuala Lumpur and Penang
respectively.
The service of the approval process should be
consistent for all the authorities. Approval time is very
crucial to developers in the short term in order to speed up
the work efforts and effective documentation.
b. Penang State
The table 1 describes the proposed price of low cost
houses in Penang, where the categories of government
owned land and private owned land are divided into two
regions, namely zone A, which is made up of reclaimed
land and the region of Georgetown and Jelutong, and zone
B, which covers the area of Tanjung Tokong, Tanjung
Bunga, Batu Feringghi, Air Itam, new Farlim, Gelugor and
Bukit Bendera. Stated are the prices set by the local
authority on the lands in each region, last amended in July
2003. Since land is limited in Penang, land prices are high
is highly likely to rise even more, thus, high density
housing are given focus and built widely especially in
urban areas while in the outskirts of Balik Pulau there is
are less high rise properties.
Table 1. States and Private Land Proposal Pricing Low-cost
Housing MPPP
LMC- Low medium cost LC- Low cost
(Source: Guidelines Zoning Low medium cost/ low cost Housing
approved on 18 July 2003).
In the state of Penang, the local government had
proposed and fixed the latest housing prices and low-cost
housing area size in 18 June 2013. The standard size of a
house is also emphasized in residential areas and the prices
of these houses depend on the category they belong to,
either government owned or private owned land.
3. Standards
This paper highlights two highly-developed cities
which are Kuala Lumpur and Penang. The local authorities
in both cities used different standards and local conditions,
according to the specific area and district. In June 1998, the
government had given specific instructions that each unit
of an apartment should have a minimum built-up area of
550 sq. ft., comprising of two bedrooms, a living room,
kitchen and bathroom (Ghani and Chong, 1997). However,
the new guideline which was established through the
amendment in 2002, clearly explicated that the design of
low-cost houses must at least, have a minimum built-up
area of 678 sq. ft., comprising of three bedrooms, a living
room, kitchen and bathroom, so as to adhere to the size
specified by CIDB as the standard of the construction
industry.
Table 2. Type houses and Pricing under Category Affordable
Housing (KPKT 2011)
(Source: KPKT 2011).
The development cost increase from time to time give
effect certain amount subsidy from the Government. In
addition the household income slow increase, authority
have proposed for affordable house price refer the table
below. The price selling only on states Wilayah
Persekutuan (Kuala Lumpur, Putrajaya & Labuan). The
price not for low income group to buy the house in the city.
Table 3. Proposal Type house price and size minimum under
RUMAWIP
Type Price Selling Min. Size
Low price
house
RM63,000 (Kuala Lumpur
dan Putrajaya) RM52,000
(Labuan)
700 Sq. Feet
(3 Bedroom)
Medium low
price house
RM63,002 – RM150,000 800 Sq. Feet
(3 Bedroom) and
650 Sq. Feet
(2 Bedroom and
less)
Medium price
house
RM150,001 – RM300,000
(Source: RUMAWIP 2013).
Compare prices and size standard between authorities
Kuala Lumpur (DBKL) and Penang (MPPP) have a
different proposal price and size in a city or rural area. The
price and size should be controlled by local authorities so
low income group can a afford the a house.
The local council referred and adhered to the standard
design of low-cost houses’ guideline which is issued by the
National Housing Department and the Ministry of Housing
and Local Government. The guideline given is based on
Zone Type
Development
Type Of
Houses
Size
(m²)
Minima
Price
(RM)
Max
%
A LMC Flat 60m² 65,000.00 10%
LC Flat 56m² 42,000.00 30%
B
LC
LC
LC
Flat
Terrace
Cluster/
CityHouses
56m²
56m²
56m²
35,000.00
38,000.00
38,000.00
30%
30%
30%
Type Price Selling Size
Low Cost RM 42,000 650 Sq. Feet
Low Medium Cost RM 42,001 –RM150,000 750 Sq. Feet-
800 Sq. Feet
Medium Cost RM150,001–RM300,000 801 Sq. Feet-
900 Sq. Feet
APNHR April 2015 5
the National Housing Policy. There is a difference between
the guideline made in 1998 and the national housing
standard guideline for low-cost houses of 1998, which was
issued by the Malaysian Construction Industry
Development Board (CIDB), regarding the size of houses.
There is a need for further research, study and evaluation
to be conducted by interviewing the group of people who
have owned or rented these low-cost houses for a duration
of more than 5 years in order to identify any changes that
have been made in regards to the social, economic and
physical aspects refer the table 4.
Table 4. Low-Cost Houses-New Design Specifications
Elements Terrace Flats Terrace
CIDB
Flats
CIDB
Floor space 48-60 m² 45-56 m² 60 m² 63 m²
Bedroom
Min. number
Min.area of
habitable room
i. First room
ii. Second room
iii. Third room
3
11.7 m²
9.9 m²
7.2 m²
3
11.7 m²
9.9 m²
7.2 m²
3
11.7 m²
9.9 m²
7.2 m²
3
11.7 m²
9.9 m²
7.2 m²
Kitchen-minimum
area
4.5 m² 4.5 m² 5.4 m² 5.4 m²
Living and dining
rooms
Provided
as one
combined
space or
separately
with
adequate
area
according
to
internal
layout
Provided
as one
combined
space or
separately
with
adequate
area
according
to
internal
layout
Provided
as one
combined
space or
separately
with
adequate
area
according
to
internal
layout
Provided
as one
combined
space or
separately
with
adequate
area
according
to
internal
layout
Bathroom /toilet Provided
separately
with min.
area of
1.8 m²
each
Provided
separately
with min.
area of
1.8 m²
each
Provided
separately
with min.
area of
1.8 m²
each
Provided
separately
with min.
area of
1.8 m²
each
Storage space and
porch
Adequate
provision
for
resident’s
comfort
Adequate
provision
for
resident’s
comfort
Adequate
provision
for
resident’s
comfort
Adequate
provision
for
resident’s
comfort
Drying area
(*) Laundry
Facilities
-
Adequate
provision
for each
unit
-
Adequate
provision
for each
unit
Note: (*) Must be provided according to the “Guidelines for the
provision of launderette facilities in multi-storey building”
prepared by Local Government Department, Ministry of Housing
and Local Government.
(Souce: Minisrty of Housing and Local Government 1998)
V. Typology of Low-cost Houses in Malaysia
Housing plans in Malaysia, especially in cities, used
bricks and reinforced concrete. Under the low-cost housing
design, there are three sub-units of design that fall under
this category; low-density, medium density, and high
density. Wood-based constructions are no longer
implemented, since the burning down of the house owned
by British Administration Officer, Sir Frank Swettenham in
Kuala Lumpur. The enactment of stricter laws for housing
standards was carried out during the early 1870s. The
reconstruction of Kuala Lumpur city using fire-resistant
materials as required by the new regulations enacted
resulted in the establishment of 15 brick kilns and 6 lime
kilns around the city in 1886.
1. Low Density Units
Low density units are under the classification of
terraced and semi-detached houses. There exist housing
schemes categorized under public housing sectors where
the said houses are built on government-owned land. Under
private housing sectors, there are no such housing schemes.
Most of the public housing schemes consist of single and
double storeyed terrace houses. Currently, the public sector
prefers to build single-storeyed low-cost houses compared
to the double-storeyed ones. During the 1980s, there were
still schemes available for the construction of
double-storeyed low cost houses.
Fig.1. Single-storey Low-cost House
(Source: SPNB).
Fig.2. Perspective view Single-storey Low-cost House
(Source: SPNB).
Single-storey low-cost houses in Taman Apas Permai,
built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB).
Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 700
square feet, whereas house prices range from RM50,000.
Specifications of the single-storey terrace houses are as
follows: reinforced concrete frame structure; walls are also
reinforced concrete, metal decking aluminium roof truss
roofing, asbestos ceiling boards with emulsion paint, metal
framed windows with adjustable glass louvres, plywood
6 APNHR April 2015
doors. House layout is such that there is no privacy for the
host of the living room; dining room overlooks the
entrance to the rooms. Façade of the house is more or less
attractive and in accordance with the current design trend.
Fig.3. Semi-D single- storey Low-Cost House
(Source: SPNB).
Fig.4. Front View Semi-D single- storey Low-Cost House
(Source: SPNB).
Semi-Detached single storey houses at Lahat Indah,
built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB).
Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 1030
square feet, whereas house prices range from RM145,000.
Specifications of the semi-D single storey terrace houses
are as follows: reinforced concrete frame structure with
brick walls, concrete tile roofing and non-asbestos ceiling
boards with emulsion paint, metal framed casement
windows with adjustable glass louvres, plywood and PVC
doors. Unique layout, disjointed living room and dining
area gives increased family privacy. Features tropical
architectural façade.
2. Medium Density Housing
Under this category, many 3, 4 and 5 storey walk-up
flats had been visited throughout East and West Malaysia.
It is noted that the construction of flats are lesser in the city
areas because of limited and expensive land space in
addition to the fact that high density housing is not
suitable for cities such as Kuala Lumpur and Penang.
Majority of the medium density housing features a house
design of two bedrooms, a living room, a kitchen, a
bathroom and balcony. The medium density housing is
designed by the Housing Trust, on some occasions by the
Municipality of Kuala Lumpur and by the state
development corporations, such as that of Selangor (KC
Leong, 1979). Accordingly, (NSW Planning, 2011)
Low-rise medium density residential development is
desirable because it:
1. is less expensive to build
2. Does not need major site amalgamation
3. Performs environmentally better than most
high-rise housing (Holloway and Bunker,
2006; Pullen, 2007)
4. Can deliver a greater mix of more affordable
housing types
5. Fits perfectly into existing streets and
neighbourhoods
6. Suits a wide range of demographic groups
Low-rise medium density design housing is mostly
built in the rural areas depending on the surrounding
environment and the plot ratio of the construction site.
Fig.6 features examples of Low-rise medium density
design houses in Malaysia.
Fig.5. Layout plan 5 storey Low-Cost House
(Source: SPNB).
Fig.6. Perspective view 5 storey flat Low-Cost House
(Source: SPNB).
5 Storey flat low-cost houses in Seremban Putra, built
by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total
built-up floor area per unit is approximately 849 square
feet, whereas house prices range from RM78,000.
Specifications of the 5 story flat low cost houses are as
follows: reinforced concrete frame structure with brick
walls, aluminium truss concrete roof tiles, painted rendered
cement ceiling and asbestos free ceiling for upper units,
APNHR April 2015 7
aluminium framed windows, plywood flush doors and
aluminium framed sliding door (for the balcony), ceramic
tile floor finish for the Living, dining, bedroom, kitchen,
bathroom area, whereas the balcony, wet area and corridor
feature cement floors. Unique layout with disjointed
kitchen and dining area but connected living and dining
area, however not culturally suitable since guests will be
welcomed through the dining room.
3. High Density Housing.
High density housing began in Malaysia in the 1960s,
encouraged and preceded by Singapore’s high density
housing efforts which at the time was better in quality and
design. K.C.Leong (1979) explicated that the construction
of conventional reinforced concrete frame high-rise flats
started in Kuala Lumpur in as early as 1958. The examples
of which are the likes of the Solomon Court Flats and the
Jalan Loke Yew Flats. Almost all the low-cost housing in
cities implemented the high density housing concept due to
the factors of limited land space and its exorbitant prices.
Fig.1. Low Cost Apartment
(Source: SPNB).
Fig.7. Layout plan Low Cost Apartment
(Source: SPNB).
Fig.7. Perspective view Low Cost Apartment
(Source: SPNB).
Seri Molek Perdana Low cost Apartments, built by the
National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total
built-up floor area per unit is approximately 700 square
feet, whereas house prices range from RM35,000.
Specifications of the low cost apartment is as follows:
reinforced concrete frame structure with brick walls,
reinforced concrete roofs, emulsion paint skim coated
ceilings; sliding, adjustable louvered and fixed louvered
windows, plywood flush, solid wood and PVC doors,
cement rendered floor finish in living, dining, master
bedroom and bedrooms with ceramic tile floor finish in
kitchen, bathroom and others. Unique layout with
disjointed kitchen and dining area but connected living and
dining area, however not culturally suitable since guests
will be welcomed through the dining room.
However, current high rise housing is still not up to the
satisfactory level of quality and standards as required by
Malaysian households.
The factors that determine the standards of quality in a
low-cost flats, in descending order of importance are:
house safety, provision of public amenities, internal
environment of unit, maintenance and surrounding
environment, location, sanitary fittings, unit size, type of
house, material used, internal unit layout, quality of
workmanship, structure and appearance of the house (Goh,
Ai & Ahmad, Yahya, 2012).
VI.Conclusion
In a nutshell, the prices of low cost houses are
increasing. If not regulated, it is very likely that people
with low incomes would not be able to afford to own a
house.
Related policies, guidelines and standards must be
reviewed regularly since a household nowadays is quite
varied in size. Low cost housing schemes in every state
needs to have its own specified guidelines enacted by the
respective state authorities since the density of houses built
should be dependent on the need of the occupants. As an
example, a more comfortable design that provides a bigger
space is in demand in cities such as Kuala Lumpur and
Penang. The design of low cost houses need to be reviewed
according to the current social and economic aspects
besides being implemented through new approaches in the
planning of policies, programmes and architectural design
for the future. An extended research needs to be conducted
so that the objectives of tropical architecture for occupants
of houses in Malaysia can be achieved.
REFERENCES
1. CIDB, Malaysia. (1997). Standard perumahan
kebangsaan bagi perumahan kos rendah (Construction
industry standard: CIS2: 1998), Perpustakaan Negara
Malaysia.
2. DBKL. (2008). Draf Pelan Bandar Raya Kuala Lumpur
2020. Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur.
3. Ghani, S. & L.M. Lee. (1997a). Low-cost Housing in
Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Utusan Publications. 1997b.
Private sector low cost housing: Lessons from Malaysia.
8 APNHR April 2015
International Journal for Housing Science and Its
Applications, 21(1):35-44.
4. Ghani, S. & L.C. Choong. (1997). Issues and problems.
Dipetik dari Housing the Nation: A Definitive Study
(Cagamas Berhad, ed.), 215-228. KualaLumpur:
Cagamas Berhad.
5. Goh, Ai Tee and Ahmad, Yahaya (2012). Public
Low-Cost Housing In Malaysia: Case Studies On Ppr
Low-Cost Flats In Kuala Lumpur. Department Of
Architecture, Faculty Of The Built Environment,
University of Malaya.
6. Government of Malaysia. (2001). Eighth Malaysia
Plan, 2001-2005, Jabatan Pencetakan Negara, Kuala
Lumpur.
7. Holloway, D. and Bunker, R. (2006). Planning, Housing
and Energy Use: A Review, Urban Policy and Research,
24 (1), pp. 115-126.
8. Junaidi Awang Besar; Rosmadi Fauzi; Amer Saifude
Ghazal. (2012). Penilaian awal impak perlaksanaan
Dasar Perumahan Negara terhadap sektor perumahan di
Kuala Lumpur. GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysia
Journal of Society and Space 8 issue 6 (90 - 108).
Themed issue on “Pengurusan perubahan sosial ekologi
dan ketidaktentuan dalam era global”.
9. K.C. Leong. (1979). Chapter 6 Low Cost Housing
Design (ed) Tan, S. H. & Sendut H. 1st ed. Kuala
Lumpur: Heineemann Educational Book (Ltd) K.L..
10. Kementerian Kesejahteraan Bandar, Perumahan dan
Kerajaan Tempatan Malaysia. (2011). Dasar Perumahan
Negara. Jabatan Perumahan Negara, Kementerian
Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan, Putrajaya.
11. Kementerian Kesejahteraan Bandar, Perumahan dan
Kerajaan Tempatan Malaysia. (1998). Garispanduan
Pelaksaaan Harga Baru Jualan Rumah Kos Rendah.
Jabatan Perumahan Negara, Kementerian Perumahan
dan Kerajaan Tempatan, Putrajaya.
12. Unit Perancanagn Ekonomi Jabatan Perdana Menteri.
(1999). Kualiti Hidup Malaysia, Malaysia.
13. Unit Perancanagn Ekonomi Jabatan Perdana Menteri.
(2004). Kualiti Hidup Malaysia, Malaysia.
14. Mohd Fuad Mat Jali, Rusnah Alias. (2007).
Pembangunan perumahan: Strategi melestarikan
geopolitik Melayu di kawasan DUN Ampangan, Negeri
Sembilan. In: Abdul Hair Awang, Mohd Ikhwan
Toriman, Marsitah Mohd Radzi (eds) Negeri Sembilan:
Potensi dan cabaran, pp. 66-78. Scholar Press (M) Sdn.
Bhd, Puchong.
15. Morshidi Sirat, Abdul Fatah Che Mamat, Abdul Rashid
Abd Aziz, Alip Rahim, Halim Saleh, Usman Hj. Yaakub.
(1999). Low-cost housing in Urban Industrial Centres of
Malaysia: Issue and Challengers. Penerbit Universiti
Sains Malaysia.
16. Majlis Perbandaran Pualau Pinang. (2003). Zoining
Guidelines Low-cost& medium cost Houses Approved
on 18 July 2003.
17. NSW Department of Planning. (2011). good design for
medium density living (DRAFT). New South Wales.
18. Rancangan Malaysia Kelapan 2001-2005. (2001).
Pencetak Kerajaan. Kuala Lumpur:
19. Rancangan Malaysia Keempat 1981-1985. (1981).
Pencetak Kerajaan. Kuala Lumpur.
20. Pullen, S. (2007). A Tool for Depicting the Embodied
Energy of the Adelaide Urban Environment, Proceedings
of the Australian Institute of Building Surveyors 2007
International Transitions Conference, Adelaide.
21. RUMAWIP. (2013). Kementerian Wilayah Persekutuan
Dan Kesejahteraan Bandar , Putrajaya.
22. Zakiyah, Jamaluddin, and Sh. Sofiah Sy. Ibrahim,
Atiqah and Abu Yazid, Afifah. (2004). Rumah kos
rendah masalah penyelesaian. Penerbit Universiti Utara
Malaysia, Sintok. ISBN 9832479568.

More Related Content

What's hot

HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
chandigarh experiment with low cost housingchandigarh experiment with low cost housing
chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Affordable housing india 1
Affordable housing india 1Affordable housing india 1
Affordable housing india 1rraghavan19
 
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housingChandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housingChandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
National Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
National  Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007National  Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
National Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in IndiaBuilding Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
Dr K M SONI
 
Kerala housing policy
Kerala housing policyKerala housing policy
Kerala housing policy
Shivani Gilhotra
 
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
RealtyMyths.com
 
Affordable housing
Affordable housingAffordable housing
Affordable housing
Maliha Zugayar
 
Housing policies BJP & UPA
Housing policies BJP & UPAHousing policies BJP & UPA
Affordable Housing - & its future in India
Affordable Housing - & its future in IndiaAffordable Housing - & its future in India
Affordable Housing - & its future in India
Finlace Consulting
 
Affordable Housing
Affordable HousingAffordable Housing
Affordable Housing
Dr K M SONI
 
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
Amura Marketing Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
 
Kerala state housing policy
Kerala state housing policyKerala state housing policy
Kerala state housing policy
SHAMJITH KM
 
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
Manpreet Singh Lotey, MBA
 
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansalHousing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
Hamzah Meraj, Faculty of Architecture, Jamia Millia Islamia, New delhi
 

What's hot (20)

HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
 
chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
chandigarh experiment with low cost housingchandigarh experiment with low cost housing
chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
 
Affordable housing india 1
Affordable housing india 1Affordable housing india 1
Affordable housing india 1
 
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housingChandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
 
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housingChandigarh experiment with low cost housing
Chandigarh experiment with low cost housing
 
National Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
National  Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007National  Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
National Urban Housing and Habitat Policy-2007
 
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in IndiaBuilding Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
Building Development: Issues and Way Forward in India
 
Kerala housing policy
Kerala housing policyKerala housing policy
Kerala housing policy
 
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPERHOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
HOUSING & HOUSING POLICY ,HABITAT III PAPER
 
AH GVS
AH GVSAH GVS
AH GVS
 
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
Case Study on affordable housing_02_06_2015
 
Affordable housing
Affordable housingAffordable housing
Affordable housing
 
Housing policies BJP & UPA
Housing policies BJP & UPAHousing policies BJP & UPA
Housing policies BJP & UPA
 
Affordable Housing - & its future in India
Affordable Housing - & its future in IndiaAffordable Housing - & its future in India
Affordable Housing - & its future in India
 
Affordable 28-12-10
Affordable 28-12-10Affordable 28-12-10
Affordable 28-12-10
 
Affordable Housing
Affordable HousingAffordable Housing
Affordable Housing
 
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
Understanding Housing for All Scheme by the Govt.
 
Kerala state housing policy
Kerala state housing policyKerala state housing policy
Kerala state housing policy
 
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
A study on Affordable Housing projects in India (by Manpreet Singh)
 
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansalHousing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
Housing Policies-BJP/UPA/STATE -Tushar bansal
 

Viewers also liked

Floating ice
Floating iceFloating ice
Floating ice
MariaChobanova
 
Expeditie mont blanc
Expeditie mont blancExpeditie mont blanc
Expeditie mont blancs25028
 
S ta r chart
S ta r chartS ta r chart
S ta r chartamihill7
 
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielle
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielleMy simple presentetion..by dian gabrielle
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielleshiibalers
 
Icebar
IcebarIcebar
Temario
TemarioTemario
TemarioCECY50
 
6 Reasons
6 Reasons6 Reasons
6 Reasonssam1am
 
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
IRIB
 
Who's watching you
Who's watching youWho's watching you
Who's watching you
Trent Morrow
 
J.23. el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
J.23.  el-angel_fuerte_y_el_libritoJ.23.  el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
J.23. el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
IBE Callao
 
Uwp honors an extraordinary man
Uwp honors an extraordinary manUwp honors an extraordinary man
Uwp honors an extraordinary man
UnitedPac Saint Lucia (Conservative Movement)
 
DisfrutandoOviedo.Com
DisfrutandoOviedo.ComDisfrutandoOviedo.Com
DisfrutandoOviedo.Com
fercorralmestas
 
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavours
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavoursCsic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavours
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavoursvosprl15
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Floating ice
Floating iceFloating ice
Floating ice
 
Expeditie mont blanc
Expeditie mont blancExpeditie mont blanc
Expeditie mont blanc
 
S ta r chart
S ta r chartS ta r chart
S ta r chart
 
15.8.11
15.8.1115.8.11
15.8.11
 
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielle
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielleMy simple presentetion..by dian gabrielle
My simple presentetion..by dian gabrielle
 
Icebar
IcebarIcebar
Icebar
 
Top 27
Top 27Top 27
Top 27
 
14 february
14 february14 february
14 february
 
Lights
LightsLights
Lights
 
Temario
TemarioTemario
Temario
 
Keegan's resume
Keegan's resumeKeegan's resume
Keegan's resume
 
6 Reasons
6 Reasons6 Reasons
6 Reasons
 
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
A publicidade imobiliária no registro eletrônico
 
Who's watching you
Who's watching youWho's watching you
Who's watching you
 
J.23. el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
J.23.  el-angel_fuerte_y_el_libritoJ.23.  el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
J.23. el-angel_fuerte_y_el_librito
 
Uwp honors an extraordinary man
Uwp honors an extraordinary manUwp honors an extraordinary man
Uwp honors an extraordinary man
 
Jantar com louvores
Jantar com louvoresJantar com louvores
Jantar com louvores
 
DisfrutandoOviedo.Com
DisfrutandoOviedo.ComDisfrutandoOviedo.Com
DisfrutandoOviedo.Com
 
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavours
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavoursCsic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavours
Csic technology for a pilot plant producing fragrances and flavours
 
Aquisição
AquisiçãoAquisição
Aquisição
 

Similar to Manuscript 53

Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptxAffordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
ShivamSingh518228
 
Housing and housing policy, HSTU
Housing and housing policy, HSTUHousing and housing policy, HSTU
POLICIES.pdf
POLICIES.pdfPOLICIES.pdf
POLICIES.pdf
Ruchi Gandhi
 
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDYNational Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
ওমর ফারুক
 
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptxcomparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
JanhviGupta22
 
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia IslamiaIndira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
MujibUrRehman1155
 
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
MumbaiMetropolitanRe
 
Measuring housing quality
Measuring housing qualityMeasuring housing quality
Measuring housing quality
Bhawani Tamrakar
 
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
IOSR Journals
 
M012147074
M012147074M012147074
M012147074
IOSR Journals
 
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in NigeriaSteady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
IJMER
 
Housing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeriaHousing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeria
Douglas Okafor
 
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALACURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
JOSIN MATHEW
 
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housingStanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
StanLee GeorGe
 
Affodable housing
Affodable housing Affodable housing
Affodable housing
Simran Aggarwal
 
Usage pattern of low cost building
Usage pattern of low cost buildingUsage pattern of low cost building
Usage pattern of low cost building
Satyendra Patel
 
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTORSTUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
VISHNU VIJAYAN
 
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
EbinJoy11
 
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong KongHousing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
Eric Stryson
 
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIALEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
ASMAH CHE WAN
 

Similar to Manuscript 53 (20)

Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptxAffordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
Affordable_Housing_In_India.pptx
 
Housing and housing policy, HSTU
Housing and housing policy, HSTUHousing and housing policy, HSTU
Housing and housing policy, HSTU
 
POLICIES.pdf
POLICIES.pdfPOLICIES.pdf
POLICIES.pdf
 
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDYNational Housing Policy & Habitat lll  STUDY
National Housing Policy & Habitat lll STUDY
 
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptxcomparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
comparitive analysis between Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka housing policy.pptx
 
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia IslamiaIndira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
Indira Awaas Yojana(IAY) By Mujeeb Ur Rehman, Jamia Millia Islamia
 
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
137593776-National-Housing-Policy.ppt
 
Measuring housing quality
Measuring housing qualityMeasuring housing quality
Measuring housing quality
 
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
Assessment of Mehr Housing Project as an Example of Housing for Low-Income Pe...
 
M012147074
M012147074M012147074
M012147074
 
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in NigeriaSteady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
Steady Resource Selection Model for Housing Projects in Nigeria
 
Housing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeriaHousing development in nigeria
Housing development in nigeria
 
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALACURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING SCHEMES IN KERALA
 
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housingStanlee's presentation on affordable housing
Stanlee's presentation on affordable housing
 
Affodable housing
Affodable housing Affodable housing
Affodable housing
 
Usage pattern of low cost building
Usage pattern of low cost buildingUsage pattern of low cost building
Usage pattern of low cost building
 
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTORSTUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
STUDY ON SUSTAINABLE AND COST EFFECTIVE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION IN HOUSING SECTOR
 
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
1.Government Initiative and Programme for Affordable Housing--Pankaj Joshi, D...
 
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong KongHousing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
Housing Affordability for the Next Generation in Hong Kong
 
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIALEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
LEGAL ISSUES ON HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF LAND LAW IN MALAYSIA
 

Manuscript 53

  • 1. The Asia Pacific Network for Housing Research (APNHR) April 2015 1 Houses design of Low cost Housing in Malaysia Wan Nur Rukiah Mohd Arshard¹ Ku Azhar Ku Hassan² Abstract Lifestyle changes in society nowadays depend on their daily schedule. Today’s society view safety and comfort as crucial in their lives. This study discusses the ideal design of public and low-cost housing while taking into account the aspects of viable size and cost and limited land space. Low-cost houses are designed in accordance to the specific guidelines set by the local city council and the National Housing Department. The boom of the housing and planning evolution in 1970s gave renewed focus to the low-income class and brought about the relocation of squatters through public housing. This was further advocated in the 1990s, through the government’s efforts in increasing low-cost housing areas, this effort is ongoing to this day. The design and organization of the in-house space had also improved through time and the incorporation of environmental and local conditions and needs. Standard house space design is vital in the carrying out of daily activities, especially for those of the low-income group. These two states were chosen as both the states have been subject to rapid public housing and low-cost housing development respectively. This paper discusses the basic approach in terms of rules, regulation and guidelines in the design of low-cost houses that is being built. An ideal spatial allocation and the suitable space usage in terms of current needs is focused on. A spatial and size allocation for the low-income group, which will be viable and efficient for the next 20years, must be established. Establishing an effective and efficient spatial allocation both inside and outside of a house which is acceptable to the local community’s varied culture, norms and economic activities is crucial as it will determine the future demand for low-cost housing and its reception by the low-income group. Keywords: Low Cost Housing, House Design, Space standards, Low-income group. I. Introduction In Malaysia, the provisioning of low-cost housing and meeting the housing needs of the country does not only involve the public sector, as the private sector also plays an important role in the efforts of doing so. The government’s inability to provide adequate low-cost housing for the people has pushed the private sector into taking over this role. The government provides more sites for housing development to the private sector and in return claims a number of housing units to serve the aforementioned purpose (Zakiyah, Sh. Sofiah & Afifah 2004). The design of a house is quite crucial as it facilitates comfort and security for those living in it, functioning to protect them from the weather and environmental conditions while taking into account the local cultural aspect. Most house designs are adapted from designs abroad. However, this discussion will focus on the design of low-cost housing in Malaysia in terms of related policies, guidelines and government standards which are subject to the authority of the specific state and its local structural plans. The low cost houses featured by the two fastest growing and developing cities socially and economically, Kuala Lumpur and Penang, are reviewed in this discussion. The design of low-cost houses are subject to the guidelines and standards set by the ministry of housing and the local government (refer to the 1998 guidelines and the national housing amendment of 2002 under the Construction Industry Development Board). Each state has its respective house pricing and household size guidelines depending on the area, whether urban or rural. The design of houses are controlled and monitored by the local councils according to the set characteristics of quality and living comfort. II. Low-cost Housing Policies in Malaysia Housing policies drafted so far have been done based on issues and problems that had cropped up from time to time. In other words, policies are designed to ensure that ¹ PhD. Candidate School of Housing, Building and Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,Malaysia ² Associate Professor, School of Housing, Building and Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,Malaysia Contact Author: Wan Nur Rukiah, Student, School of Housing, Building and Planning,Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang,Malaysia. Tel: +604-6533888 Ext. 2184 Fax: +604-6576271 e-mail: nur77.arshard@gmail.com
  • 2. 2 APNHR April 2015 the long term 20 to 30 year development plan does not veer too far off from the core values and goals of the New Economic Policy, which was drafted and approved by the government to develop a disciplined, loyalty, and self-reliant society. Many Acts, regulations and guidelines related to housing development, both directly or indirectly had been established with the aim of ensuring adequate supply of homes on the market as indicated by KPKT. 1. Central Government Policies Low cost housing policies that brought about the active role of private developers actually began through the Fourth Malaysian Plan, in line with the era of privatization in Malaysia (the Malaysian Government, 1981). Ghani and Lee (1997a) had outlined the characteristics of the low-cost housing policy, as set by the central government: a. Thirty (30) percent Low-Cost Component This policy required private developers who planned to build a certain number of housing units to provide low-cost houses, which had to amount to at least 30 percent of the housing units. This minimum limit, however, differs from state to state. Moreover, the determination of the 30 percent component has no clear relationship to the low-cost houses target which is to be built by private developers, as specified in the Malaysian Five Year Plan (ibid.). This 30 percent low-cost houses component is usually enforced either at the conversion and subdivision application approval level or when a private developer receives the approval of conversion and subdivision. The imposition of the 30 percent component is detected when the developer submits an application to the local authority for the approval of the plans and building projects. Compliance to these requirements is confirmed when the developer applies for the certificate of occupancy from the local authorities. b. Unit Price of a Low-Cost House When the low-cost housing policy was first implemented, the price of a low-cost house was about RM25,000. This price had remained up until June 1998 when the federal government agreed to allow low-cost houses to be sold at a price higher than RM25,000, according to the project site (Government of Malaysia, 2001).Implementation guidelines the prices of new low-cost homes, which has been in effect from June 10, 1998.However, average house prices had fallen in 1997 and 1998 during the economic downturn. The average house price reached a record level of RM101,544 in 1996, before declining to RM82,916 in 1998. The increase in house prices before 1997 were probably due to high demand and the rising cost of labour and building materials. The demand for houses was also assisted by the ease of access to financing obtained. However, the prices of low cost houses for low-income earners have been relatively stable due to the price control done by the government. (Quality of life of Malaysia 1999) There are several low-cost housing programmes provided by the local government to meet the housing needs of low-income earners. Each state has its own low-cost housing programmes which are in line with the State’s structural plan. On the other hand, the national housing policy is also set by the Ministry of Urban Wellbeing, Housing and Local Government (KPKT) to the same effect. Below are the low-cost housing programmes in Malaysia which are implemented by the local council in Kuala Lumpur and Penang. III. Public Housing Programme The Low-Cost Housing Programme (PPAKR) aims to provide homes for low-income earners through a number of schemes. This program is intended for buyers with monthly household income of approximately RM1,500 and below while the per unit selling price of the houses do not exceed RM35,000. The featured type of houses are by location and land either 5 storey flats or terraced houses. The minimum design for a low-cost house is has a standard built up area of not less than 60 square meters (900 square feet), featuring three bedrooms, a living room, kitchen, bathroom and toilet (Quality of life in Malaysia, 2004). 1. Low-Cost Housing Programme The area of a low-cost house has to be in accordance with the guidelines of the local government in each state, while the pricing in line with the guidelines of the National Housing Department. In the case of low-cost houses provided by private developers that provide medium cost housing, a minimum total contribution of low cost houses of about 20% (up to a maximum of 30%) is imposed. 2. People’s Housing Program (PPR) Houses featured are with an area of 700 square feet (larger compared to the age old 650 square feet and 600 square feet practice); with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a kitchen, an area for drying clothes, and tiled floors. Facilities such as community halls, playgrounds for children, kindergartens, shops, stalls, prayer halls (Surau), parking areas and other public spaces are also provided for the comfort of the residents so that they can enjoy a high quality healthy living environment.Since the introduction of PPR in 1998 up till December 31st of 2012, the federal government through the KPKT has completed about 67
  • 3. APNHR April 2015 3 projects consisting of 64,771 PPR units (rental) and 23 projects consisting of 3109 PPR units (Owned). PPR units are rented to applicants who meet the requirements and criteria at a rate of RM124 per month or sold at a price of RM30,000 to RM35,000 each. The 67 PPR projects (rental) spans throughout the country, namely in Perlis, Kedah, Penang, Perak, Selangor, Negeri Sembilan, Johor, Sabah, Sarawak and Kuala Lumpur, while 23 PPR projects (Owned) are located specifically in Pahang. Additionally, a total of 21 projects involving approximately 11,028 units are currently in various stages of implementation. Under the 2013 Budget, a total of RM1.9 billion had been allocated to build 123,000 affordable homes in strategic locations throughout the country. From the total provision, RM543 million had been allocated to KPKT to finance 45 projects involving 20,454 units under the PPR project that will be built using the industrialized building system. (Ministry of Urban Well being, Housing and Local Government). IV. Policies, Guidelines and Standards At the national level, state policies are generally transfigured in detail into policies and development strategies of the country. At the state level, there exist structural and strategic plans in place for each state that fuels policies. The transformation process of the more general policies at the national level into detailed strategies and requirements at the state and local authority level however, is not uniform, with promised benefits not given adequate attention and in turn burdening the low-cost housing industry locally (Ghani and Lee 1997). Generally, according to the national development policy, the market strategy was proposed and given to the related private entities after introducing the new guidelines of low-cost housing on the sales market in June 1998 (amended in 2002). Private developers and agencies are encouraged to implement market price adjustments for low wage earner levels (RM750 per month), with a ceiling price of RM25,000 (with the exception of Johor, which is set at RM20,000) and houses of 45-56 m² in size. The guidelines for low-cost housing which was established in 1982 with a set price of RM25,000 a unit, had been since reviewed and re-evaluated by the Ministry of Housing and the local government in June 1998. The original pricing was deemed no longer appropriate in the current situation where construction costs are way higher, thus, a new pricing which is in accordance with the current situation had to be established. 1. State Policies Policies at the State level are as a whole a more detailed and have better overall strategies. State level policies are derived from the structural and strategic plan and strategic plans specific to the state. The overall local plan describes the particular needs of the local authorities. In the case of the low-cost housing industry, at the local level policies are more specific on the benefits granted or the burden on developers. As in the state policies these aspects are described clearly with regards to the local authority in each state. In order to improve the quality of low-cost houses and simultaneously meet private developers argument for a review of selling prices of these units the government has introduced in 1998 the new pricing guidelines for this type of houses (Morshidi, Abdul Fatah, Abdul Rashid, Alip, Halim, Usman, 1999).Though part of a same country, there exist a different understanding in the sense of the local standards and conditions with regards to the local authorities. 2. Local Guidelines In this study, two cities and its local council are contrasted according to its local structures. There are advantages and disadvantages in each of the local council guidelines. As such, there is a need for better guidelines and its efficient execution in the future. The local government plays a role in approving building plans submitted by developers, designers and architects. Thus, in the efforts of the distribution of housing to the people, the local government should distribute housing to people of all walks of life respectively. Mohd Fuad (1998) found that most of the Malays could not afford to buy houses as the market price is too high and the form of housing is less desirable to them. His discussion was specific on the inability of a certain race in acquiring houses due to high prices. In other words, there is a lack of low medium and low-cost housing projects as developers are not very interested in undertaking such projects. Most homes and condos in the Federal Territory are priced at RM150,000.00 - 500,000.00. As such, only a handful of Malays are able to acquire said houses when compared to other races (Junaidi, Rosmadi & Amer, 2012). a. Kuala Lumpur The DBKL local council has a 2020 Structural Plan goal that is yet to be achieved which aims to make Kuala Lumpur a city that protects the wellbeing and comfort of its populace. Squatters in Kuala Lumpur and around the city have been long eliminated through public housing and PPAKR programmes to meet the housing demand of the
  • 4. 4 APNHR April 2015 people in the city. The Affordable basic home policy introduced in the federal Region has been implemented in the Federal Territories of Kuala Lumpur, Labuan and Putrajaya, and have been effective since 28 March 2013. These regions still use the low-cost housing guidelines (KPKT, 1998) for house pricing and household size allocation. The table below shows the variation of the guidelines used by the two local authorities of Kuala Lumpur and Penang respectively. The service of the approval process should be consistent for all the authorities. Approval time is very crucial to developers in the short term in order to speed up the work efforts and effective documentation. b. Penang State The table 1 describes the proposed price of low cost houses in Penang, where the categories of government owned land and private owned land are divided into two regions, namely zone A, which is made up of reclaimed land and the region of Georgetown and Jelutong, and zone B, which covers the area of Tanjung Tokong, Tanjung Bunga, Batu Feringghi, Air Itam, new Farlim, Gelugor and Bukit Bendera. Stated are the prices set by the local authority on the lands in each region, last amended in July 2003. Since land is limited in Penang, land prices are high is highly likely to rise even more, thus, high density housing are given focus and built widely especially in urban areas while in the outskirts of Balik Pulau there is are less high rise properties. Table 1. States and Private Land Proposal Pricing Low-cost Housing MPPP LMC- Low medium cost LC- Low cost (Source: Guidelines Zoning Low medium cost/ low cost Housing approved on 18 July 2003). In the state of Penang, the local government had proposed and fixed the latest housing prices and low-cost housing area size in 18 June 2013. The standard size of a house is also emphasized in residential areas and the prices of these houses depend on the category they belong to, either government owned or private owned land. 3. Standards This paper highlights two highly-developed cities which are Kuala Lumpur and Penang. The local authorities in both cities used different standards and local conditions, according to the specific area and district. In June 1998, the government had given specific instructions that each unit of an apartment should have a minimum built-up area of 550 sq. ft., comprising of two bedrooms, a living room, kitchen and bathroom (Ghani and Chong, 1997). However, the new guideline which was established through the amendment in 2002, clearly explicated that the design of low-cost houses must at least, have a minimum built-up area of 678 sq. ft., comprising of three bedrooms, a living room, kitchen and bathroom, so as to adhere to the size specified by CIDB as the standard of the construction industry. Table 2. Type houses and Pricing under Category Affordable Housing (KPKT 2011) (Source: KPKT 2011). The development cost increase from time to time give effect certain amount subsidy from the Government. In addition the household income slow increase, authority have proposed for affordable house price refer the table below. The price selling only on states Wilayah Persekutuan (Kuala Lumpur, Putrajaya & Labuan). The price not for low income group to buy the house in the city. Table 3. Proposal Type house price and size minimum under RUMAWIP Type Price Selling Min. Size Low price house RM63,000 (Kuala Lumpur dan Putrajaya) RM52,000 (Labuan) 700 Sq. Feet (3 Bedroom) Medium low price house RM63,002 – RM150,000 800 Sq. Feet (3 Bedroom) and 650 Sq. Feet (2 Bedroom and less) Medium price house RM150,001 – RM300,000 (Source: RUMAWIP 2013). Compare prices and size standard between authorities Kuala Lumpur (DBKL) and Penang (MPPP) have a different proposal price and size in a city or rural area. The price and size should be controlled by local authorities so low income group can a afford the a house. The local council referred and adhered to the standard design of low-cost houses’ guideline which is issued by the National Housing Department and the Ministry of Housing and Local Government. The guideline given is based on Zone Type Development Type Of Houses Size (m²) Minima Price (RM) Max % A LMC Flat 60m² 65,000.00 10% LC Flat 56m² 42,000.00 30% B LC LC LC Flat Terrace Cluster/ CityHouses 56m² 56m² 56m² 35,000.00 38,000.00 38,000.00 30% 30% 30% Type Price Selling Size Low Cost RM 42,000 650 Sq. Feet Low Medium Cost RM 42,001 –RM150,000 750 Sq. Feet- 800 Sq. Feet Medium Cost RM150,001–RM300,000 801 Sq. Feet- 900 Sq. Feet
  • 5. APNHR April 2015 5 the National Housing Policy. There is a difference between the guideline made in 1998 and the national housing standard guideline for low-cost houses of 1998, which was issued by the Malaysian Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB), regarding the size of houses. There is a need for further research, study and evaluation to be conducted by interviewing the group of people who have owned or rented these low-cost houses for a duration of more than 5 years in order to identify any changes that have been made in regards to the social, economic and physical aspects refer the table 4. Table 4. Low-Cost Houses-New Design Specifications Elements Terrace Flats Terrace CIDB Flats CIDB Floor space 48-60 m² 45-56 m² 60 m² 63 m² Bedroom Min. number Min.area of habitable room i. First room ii. Second room iii. Third room 3 11.7 m² 9.9 m² 7.2 m² 3 11.7 m² 9.9 m² 7.2 m² 3 11.7 m² 9.9 m² 7.2 m² 3 11.7 m² 9.9 m² 7.2 m² Kitchen-minimum area 4.5 m² 4.5 m² 5.4 m² 5.4 m² Living and dining rooms Provided as one combined space or separately with adequate area according to internal layout Provided as one combined space or separately with adequate area according to internal layout Provided as one combined space or separately with adequate area according to internal layout Provided as one combined space or separately with adequate area according to internal layout Bathroom /toilet Provided separately with min. area of 1.8 m² each Provided separately with min. area of 1.8 m² each Provided separately with min. area of 1.8 m² each Provided separately with min. area of 1.8 m² each Storage space and porch Adequate provision for resident’s comfort Adequate provision for resident’s comfort Adequate provision for resident’s comfort Adequate provision for resident’s comfort Drying area (*) Laundry Facilities - Adequate provision for each unit - Adequate provision for each unit Note: (*) Must be provided according to the “Guidelines for the provision of launderette facilities in multi-storey building” prepared by Local Government Department, Ministry of Housing and Local Government. (Souce: Minisrty of Housing and Local Government 1998) V. Typology of Low-cost Houses in Malaysia Housing plans in Malaysia, especially in cities, used bricks and reinforced concrete. Under the low-cost housing design, there are three sub-units of design that fall under this category; low-density, medium density, and high density. Wood-based constructions are no longer implemented, since the burning down of the house owned by British Administration Officer, Sir Frank Swettenham in Kuala Lumpur. The enactment of stricter laws for housing standards was carried out during the early 1870s. The reconstruction of Kuala Lumpur city using fire-resistant materials as required by the new regulations enacted resulted in the establishment of 15 brick kilns and 6 lime kilns around the city in 1886. 1. Low Density Units Low density units are under the classification of terraced and semi-detached houses. There exist housing schemes categorized under public housing sectors where the said houses are built on government-owned land. Under private housing sectors, there are no such housing schemes. Most of the public housing schemes consist of single and double storeyed terrace houses. Currently, the public sector prefers to build single-storeyed low-cost houses compared to the double-storeyed ones. During the 1980s, there were still schemes available for the construction of double-storeyed low cost houses. Fig.1. Single-storey Low-cost House (Source: SPNB). Fig.2. Perspective view Single-storey Low-cost House (Source: SPNB). Single-storey low-cost houses in Taman Apas Permai, built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 700 square feet, whereas house prices range from RM50,000. Specifications of the single-storey terrace houses are as follows: reinforced concrete frame structure; walls are also reinforced concrete, metal decking aluminium roof truss roofing, asbestos ceiling boards with emulsion paint, metal framed windows with adjustable glass louvres, plywood
  • 6. 6 APNHR April 2015 doors. House layout is such that there is no privacy for the host of the living room; dining room overlooks the entrance to the rooms. Façade of the house is more or less attractive and in accordance with the current design trend. Fig.3. Semi-D single- storey Low-Cost House (Source: SPNB). Fig.4. Front View Semi-D single- storey Low-Cost House (Source: SPNB). Semi-Detached single storey houses at Lahat Indah, built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 1030 square feet, whereas house prices range from RM145,000. Specifications of the semi-D single storey terrace houses are as follows: reinforced concrete frame structure with brick walls, concrete tile roofing and non-asbestos ceiling boards with emulsion paint, metal framed casement windows with adjustable glass louvres, plywood and PVC doors. Unique layout, disjointed living room and dining area gives increased family privacy. Features tropical architectural façade. 2. Medium Density Housing Under this category, many 3, 4 and 5 storey walk-up flats had been visited throughout East and West Malaysia. It is noted that the construction of flats are lesser in the city areas because of limited and expensive land space in addition to the fact that high density housing is not suitable for cities such as Kuala Lumpur and Penang. Majority of the medium density housing features a house design of two bedrooms, a living room, a kitchen, a bathroom and balcony. The medium density housing is designed by the Housing Trust, on some occasions by the Municipality of Kuala Lumpur and by the state development corporations, such as that of Selangor (KC Leong, 1979). Accordingly, (NSW Planning, 2011) Low-rise medium density residential development is desirable because it: 1. is less expensive to build 2. Does not need major site amalgamation 3. Performs environmentally better than most high-rise housing (Holloway and Bunker, 2006; Pullen, 2007) 4. Can deliver a greater mix of more affordable housing types 5. Fits perfectly into existing streets and neighbourhoods 6. Suits a wide range of demographic groups Low-rise medium density design housing is mostly built in the rural areas depending on the surrounding environment and the plot ratio of the construction site. Fig.6 features examples of Low-rise medium density design houses in Malaysia. Fig.5. Layout plan 5 storey Low-Cost House (Source: SPNB). Fig.6. Perspective view 5 storey flat Low-Cost House (Source: SPNB). 5 Storey flat low-cost houses in Seremban Putra, built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 849 square feet, whereas house prices range from RM78,000. Specifications of the 5 story flat low cost houses are as follows: reinforced concrete frame structure with brick walls, aluminium truss concrete roof tiles, painted rendered cement ceiling and asbestos free ceiling for upper units,
  • 7. APNHR April 2015 7 aluminium framed windows, plywood flush doors and aluminium framed sliding door (for the balcony), ceramic tile floor finish for the Living, dining, bedroom, kitchen, bathroom area, whereas the balcony, wet area and corridor feature cement floors. Unique layout with disjointed kitchen and dining area but connected living and dining area, however not culturally suitable since guests will be welcomed through the dining room. 3. High Density Housing. High density housing began in Malaysia in the 1960s, encouraged and preceded by Singapore’s high density housing efforts which at the time was better in quality and design. K.C.Leong (1979) explicated that the construction of conventional reinforced concrete frame high-rise flats started in Kuala Lumpur in as early as 1958. The examples of which are the likes of the Solomon Court Flats and the Jalan Loke Yew Flats. Almost all the low-cost housing in cities implemented the high density housing concept due to the factors of limited land space and its exorbitant prices. Fig.1. Low Cost Apartment (Source: SPNB). Fig.7. Layout plan Low Cost Apartment (Source: SPNB). Fig.7. Perspective view Low Cost Apartment (Source: SPNB). Seri Molek Perdana Low cost Apartments, built by the National Housing Company Limited (SPNB). Total built-up floor area per unit is approximately 700 square feet, whereas house prices range from RM35,000. Specifications of the low cost apartment is as follows: reinforced concrete frame structure with brick walls, reinforced concrete roofs, emulsion paint skim coated ceilings; sliding, adjustable louvered and fixed louvered windows, plywood flush, solid wood and PVC doors, cement rendered floor finish in living, dining, master bedroom and bedrooms with ceramic tile floor finish in kitchen, bathroom and others. Unique layout with disjointed kitchen and dining area but connected living and dining area, however not culturally suitable since guests will be welcomed through the dining room. However, current high rise housing is still not up to the satisfactory level of quality and standards as required by Malaysian households. The factors that determine the standards of quality in a low-cost flats, in descending order of importance are: house safety, provision of public amenities, internal environment of unit, maintenance and surrounding environment, location, sanitary fittings, unit size, type of house, material used, internal unit layout, quality of workmanship, structure and appearance of the house (Goh, Ai & Ahmad, Yahya, 2012). VI.Conclusion In a nutshell, the prices of low cost houses are increasing. If not regulated, it is very likely that people with low incomes would not be able to afford to own a house. Related policies, guidelines and standards must be reviewed regularly since a household nowadays is quite varied in size. Low cost housing schemes in every state needs to have its own specified guidelines enacted by the respective state authorities since the density of houses built should be dependent on the need of the occupants. As an example, a more comfortable design that provides a bigger space is in demand in cities such as Kuala Lumpur and Penang. The design of low cost houses need to be reviewed according to the current social and economic aspects besides being implemented through new approaches in the planning of policies, programmes and architectural design for the future. An extended research needs to be conducted so that the objectives of tropical architecture for occupants of houses in Malaysia can be achieved. REFERENCES 1. CIDB, Malaysia. (1997). Standard perumahan kebangsaan bagi perumahan kos rendah (Construction industry standard: CIS2: 1998), Perpustakaan Negara Malaysia. 2. DBKL. (2008). Draf Pelan Bandar Raya Kuala Lumpur 2020. Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur. 3. Ghani, S. & L.M. Lee. (1997a). Low-cost Housing in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Utusan Publications. 1997b. Private sector low cost housing: Lessons from Malaysia.
  • 8. 8 APNHR April 2015 International Journal for Housing Science and Its Applications, 21(1):35-44. 4. Ghani, S. & L.C. Choong. (1997). Issues and problems. Dipetik dari Housing the Nation: A Definitive Study (Cagamas Berhad, ed.), 215-228. KualaLumpur: Cagamas Berhad. 5. Goh, Ai Tee and Ahmad, Yahaya (2012). Public Low-Cost Housing In Malaysia: Case Studies On Ppr Low-Cost Flats In Kuala Lumpur. Department Of Architecture, Faculty Of The Built Environment, University of Malaya. 6. Government of Malaysia. (2001). Eighth Malaysia Plan, 2001-2005, Jabatan Pencetakan Negara, Kuala Lumpur. 7. Holloway, D. and Bunker, R. (2006). Planning, Housing and Energy Use: A Review, Urban Policy and Research, 24 (1), pp. 115-126. 8. Junaidi Awang Besar; Rosmadi Fauzi; Amer Saifude Ghazal. (2012). Penilaian awal impak perlaksanaan Dasar Perumahan Negara terhadap sektor perumahan di Kuala Lumpur. GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysia Journal of Society and Space 8 issue 6 (90 - 108). Themed issue on “Pengurusan perubahan sosial ekologi dan ketidaktentuan dalam era global”. 9. K.C. Leong. (1979). Chapter 6 Low Cost Housing Design (ed) Tan, S. H. & Sendut H. 1st ed. Kuala Lumpur: Heineemann Educational Book (Ltd) K.L.. 10. Kementerian Kesejahteraan Bandar, Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan Malaysia. (2011). Dasar Perumahan Negara. Jabatan Perumahan Negara, Kementerian Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan, Putrajaya. 11. Kementerian Kesejahteraan Bandar, Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan Malaysia. (1998). Garispanduan Pelaksaaan Harga Baru Jualan Rumah Kos Rendah. Jabatan Perumahan Negara, Kementerian Perumahan dan Kerajaan Tempatan, Putrajaya. 12. Unit Perancanagn Ekonomi Jabatan Perdana Menteri. (1999). Kualiti Hidup Malaysia, Malaysia. 13. Unit Perancanagn Ekonomi Jabatan Perdana Menteri. (2004). Kualiti Hidup Malaysia, Malaysia. 14. Mohd Fuad Mat Jali, Rusnah Alias. (2007). Pembangunan perumahan: Strategi melestarikan geopolitik Melayu di kawasan DUN Ampangan, Negeri Sembilan. In: Abdul Hair Awang, Mohd Ikhwan Toriman, Marsitah Mohd Radzi (eds) Negeri Sembilan: Potensi dan cabaran, pp. 66-78. Scholar Press (M) Sdn. Bhd, Puchong. 15. Morshidi Sirat, Abdul Fatah Che Mamat, Abdul Rashid Abd Aziz, Alip Rahim, Halim Saleh, Usman Hj. Yaakub. (1999). Low-cost housing in Urban Industrial Centres of Malaysia: Issue and Challengers. Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia. 16. Majlis Perbandaran Pualau Pinang. (2003). Zoining Guidelines Low-cost& medium cost Houses Approved on 18 July 2003. 17. NSW Department of Planning. (2011). good design for medium density living (DRAFT). New South Wales. 18. Rancangan Malaysia Kelapan 2001-2005. (2001). Pencetak Kerajaan. Kuala Lumpur: 19. Rancangan Malaysia Keempat 1981-1985. (1981). Pencetak Kerajaan. Kuala Lumpur. 20. Pullen, S. (2007). A Tool for Depicting the Embodied Energy of the Adelaide Urban Environment, Proceedings of the Australian Institute of Building Surveyors 2007 International Transitions Conference, Adelaide. 21. RUMAWIP. (2013). Kementerian Wilayah Persekutuan Dan Kesejahteraan Bandar , Putrajaya. 22. Zakiyah, Jamaluddin, and Sh. Sofiah Sy. Ibrahim, Atiqah and Abu Yazid, Afifah. (2004). Rumah kos rendah masalah penyelesaian. Penerbit Universiti Utara Malaysia, Sintok. ISBN 9832479568.