Making CIL Work – Wokingham
Borough Council Experience
Brendan Troy
Service Manager - Community
Infrastructure Delivery
E: brendan.troy@wokingham.gov.uk
T: 0118 974 6824
CIL Implementation in WBC
• Regional Context
• WBC CIL Rates
• Route to WBC Rates
• CIL Administration in WBC
• CIL Governance in WBC
• CIL and Strategic Delivery Location (SDL)
Infrastructure Delivery
• Governance of the CIL ‘Topslice’ in WBC
Regional Context
Adopted WBC CIL Rates
• Adopted 6th
April 2015
• Highest residential rate outside London
• Headline - residential - £365 SqM – outside SDLs
• Development Strategy - 4 SDL’s
– Arborfield 3500 houses - £365/sq.m
– North Wokingham 1500 houses - £340/sq.m
– South Wokingham 2500 houses - £320/sq.m
– Shinfield (SM4) 2500 houses - £300/sq.m
• Sheltered housing, residential institutions and retail
outside town/district centres
Route to SDL Rates
• Core Strategy 2010 - Change of direction –
comprehensive not incremental development -
Masterplan SPD for the 4 SDLs
• Over-arching Infrastructure SPD and individual
IDP for each SDL
• Concerns about the pooling restriction - Strategic
large scale infrastructure would stop unless we
had CIL
• Consulted development industry
• Council left with little choice but to pursue a CIL-
focused strategy
Track record of Delivery
• Formed dedicated Delivery Team and
governance structures to progress the SDLs
• Strong track record of delivery over last 3-5
years
– Planning – feasibility studies for 3 relief roads
– Acquired Farm for sports hub
– LSIF for Eastern Relief Road (delivered
2016/17), £24m Local Growth Fund
– Built 3 new schools 2012/13, secondary school
2016/17
Role of CIL - WBC
• Strategic Transport infrastructure
– South Wokingham Distributor Road (including Road
over Rail Bridge)
– Replacement railway bridges
• Primary and Secondary Education
• Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace (SANG)
• Indoor & Outdoor Sport Facilities
• Community Centres / Halls / Libraries
• Health Centre / GP Surgeries / Emergency
Services
Role of S106 - WBC
• Section 106 agreements cover the following:
Affordable Housing; Strategic Access and
Management Monitoring (SAMM); Enabling works;
site access junctions; Travel Plans; Fire hydrants
• In addition, within the SDLs:
- Land for the provision of Transport Infrastructure,
Education Infrastructure, Green Infrastructure,
and Community/Social Infrastructure
- On-site and off-site delivery of Suitable
Alternative Greenspaces (SANG)
- Amenity open space and play areas
CIL to Date
• Income - £90k
• Demand Notices - £150k
• Liability Notices - £540k
• Consented a further 1,620 dwellings
subject to S106 Agreement – potential
£37m (circa)
• Reliefs - £1.9m
CIL and S106 Team Structure
CIL Administration in WBC
• Business support – Identify CIL liable
applications, upload forms, send follow up
letters, measure plans using .pdf software
• Planning officers – minimal role - attach
informatives, advise on approximate liability
• CIL team – Issue liability / demand notices
(invoices) / process reliefs / notify land charges /
CIL Appeals / allocate funds
• Finance – invoices / debt recovery
• Infrastructure Finance Board
CIL Administration in WBC
• Lack of understanding – small developers
and agents in particular
• So many forms!
• Assumption of Liability is not a validation
requirement
• Extensions over 100sq.m – there are a lot
of them in WBC - heavy on admin / no CIL
• Extensions relief – principal residence
CIL Administration issues
• New finance processes to set up
• SANG and self-build relief – exempt
European Directives from pooling?
• Not possible to grant relief for
development granted retrospectively on
appeal
• Heavy penalty for failure to notify
commencement – reinforce this message!
CIL Administration in WBC
• Beware of basements
WBC CIL Governance and
Infrastructure Delivery
• Infrastructure Delivery Programme Board (IDPB)
• Reports to Sustainable Communities Working
Group and Executive
• Meets monthly and brings all service heads
together
• Remit is to manage infrastructure delivery–
projects are monitored monthly - from inception to
completion
• IDPB informs Capital Planning - CIL funds
allocated through Capital Programme
CIL and SDL infrastructure Delivery
• Arborfield SDL - 3500 units - 2,000 units S106 /
1500 CIL (subject to S106)
• South Wokingham SDL – 650 under
construction, 1850 will come forward under CIL
• Circa £66m CIL between the two sites
• CIL will fund strategic transport improvements
(including South Wokingham Relief Road);
contribute to a secondary school; primary
schools on-site; community and sports facilities
• S106 will provide land for on-site delivery
CIL and SDL infrastructure Delivery
• High rates are not preventing housing coming
forward
• Less protracted negotiation
• Necessity to have IDPs on SDLs at an early
stage and in consultation with developers
• Strategic enabling infrastructure is often required
on SDL’s
– Local authority is key delivery partner but no ability to
borrow against CIL
– Large Sites Infrastructure Fund (LSIF) only available
to developers not LA’s
CIL and SDL Infrastructure Delivery
• Strategic enabling infrastructure is often required
on SDL’s
– Widely held view that the Payment in Kind for
Infrastructure mechanism is not workable
• We believe a wider interpretation can be
provided
– On Reg 123 List – not necessary in planning terms
as it will be provided by other means
– Separate planning applications on strategic sites
• Any further clarification would be helpful
WBC Meaningful Proportion
• 17 Parishes – 3 Parishes will benefit from 99%
of WBC ‘CIL Topslice’
• Small organisations which lack staff / knowledge
/ skills to prioritise / commission / finance to deal
with large amounts of infrastructure funding
• Significant drain on SDL infrastructure packages
on sites that affect more than one Parish
• WBC working very closely with Parishes
Shared priorities /
responsibilities
Terms of Reference
• WBC and T&PC’s working on a ‘Terms of
Reference for the management of the CIL’
• Year long process of engagement – workshops,
clerks forums, 1 to 1’s
• Three strands – not finalised:
– Co-fund infrastructure projects with WBC – WBC
would lead on commissioning, procurement and
delivery
– Deliver on their own – WBC offer design and
build package / traded services
– Joint Commissioning
Questions?

Making CIL Work

  • 1.
    Making CIL Work– Wokingham Borough Council Experience Brendan Troy Service Manager - Community Infrastructure Delivery E: brendan.troy@wokingham.gov.uk T: 0118 974 6824
  • 2.
    CIL Implementation inWBC • Regional Context • WBC CIL Rates • Route to WBC Rates • CIL Administration in WBC • CIL Governance in WBC • CIL and Strategic Delivery Location (SDL) Infrastructure Delivery • Governance of the CIL ‘Topslice’ in WBC
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Adopted WBC CILRates • Adopted 6th April 2015 • Highest residential rate outside London • Headline - residential - £365 SqM – outside SDLs • Development Strategy - 4 SDL’s – Arborfield 3500 houses - £365/sq.m – North Wokingham 1500 houses - £340/sq.m – South Wokingham 2500 houses - £320/sq.m – Shinfield (SM4) 2500 houses - £300/sq.m • Sheltered housing, residential institutions and retail outside town/district centres
  • 5.
    Route to SDLRates • Core Strategy 2010 - Change of direction – comprehensive not incremental development - Masterplan SPD for the 4 SDLs • Over-arching Infrastructure SPD and individual IDP for each SDL • Concerns about the pooling restriction - Strategic large scale infrastructure would stop unless we had CIL • Consulted development industry • Council left with little choice but to pursue a CIL- focused strategy
  • 6.
    Track record ofDelivery • Formed dedicated Delivery Team and governance structures to progress the SDLs • Strong track record of delivery over last 3-5 years – Planning – feasibility studies for 3 relief roads – Acquired Farm for sports hub – LSIF for Eastern Relief Road (delivered 2016/17), £24m Local Growth Fund – Built 3 new schools 2012/13, secondary school 2016/17
  • 7.
    Role of CIL- WBC • Strategic Transport infrastructure – South Wokingham Distributor Road (including Road over Rail Bridge) – Replacement railway bridges • Primary and Secondary Education • Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace (SANG) • Indoor & Outdoor Sport Facilities • Community Centres / Halls / Libraries • Health Centre / GP Surgeries / Emergency Services
  • 8.
    Role of S106- WBC • Section 106 agreements cover the following: Affordable Housing; Strategic Access and Management Monitoring (SAMM); Enabling works; site access junctions; Travel Plans; Fire hydrants • In addition, within the SDLs: - Land for the provision of Transport Infrastructure, Education Infrastructure, Green Infrastructure, and Community/Social Infrastructure - On-site and off-site delivery of Suitable Alternative Greenspaces (SANG) - Amenity open space and play areas
  • 9.
    CIL to Date •Income - £90k • Demand Notices - £150k • Liability Notices - £540k • Consented a further 1,620 dwellings subject to S106 Agreement – potential £37m (circa) • Reliefs - £1.9m
  • 10.
    CIL and S106Team Structure
  • 11.
    CIL Administration inWBC • Business support – Identify CIL liable applications, upload forms, send follow up letters, measure plans using .pdf software • Planning officers – minimal role - attach informatives, advise on approximate liability • CIL team – Issue liability / demand notices (invoices) / process reliefs / notify land charges / CIL Appeals / allocate funds • Finance – invoices / debt recovery • Infrastructure Finance Board
  • 12.
    CIL Administration inWBC • Lack of understanding – small developers and agents in particular • So many forms! • Assumption of Liability is not a validation requirement • Extensions over 100sq.m – there are a lot of them in WBC - heavy on admin / no CIL • Extensions relief – principal residence
  • 13.
    CIL Administration issues •New finance processes to set up • SANG and self-build relief – exempt European Directives from pooling? • Not possible to grant relief for development granted retrospectively on appeal • Heavy penalty for failure to notify commencement – reinforce this message!
  • 14.
    CIL Administration inWBC • Beware of basements
  • 15.
    WBC CIL Governanceand Infrastructure Delivery • Infrastructure Delivery Programme Board (IDPB) • Reports to Sustainable Communities Working Group and Executive • Meets monthly and brings all service heads together • Remit is to manage infrastructure delivery– projects are monitored monthly - from inception to completion • IDPB informs Capital Planning - CIL funds allocated through Capital Programme
  • 16.
    CIL and SDLinfrastructure Delivery • Arborfield SDL - 3500 units - 2,000 units S106 / 1500 CIL (subject to S106) • South Wokingham SDL – 650 under construction, 1850 will come forward under CIL • Circa £66m CIL between the two sites • CIL will fund strategic transport improvements (including South Wokingham Relief Road); contribute to a secondary school; primary schools on-site; community and sports facilities • S106 will provide land for on-site delivery
  • 17.
    CIL and SDLinfrastructure Delivery • High rates are not preventing housing coming forward • Less protracted negotiation • Necessity to have IDPs on SDLs at an early stage and in consultation with developers • Strategic enabling infrastructure is often required on SDL’s – Local authority is key delivery partner but no ability to borrow against CIL – Large Sites Infrastructure Fund (LSIF) only available to developers not LA’s
  • 18.
    CIL and SDLInfrastructure Delivery • Strategic enabling infrastructure is often required on SDL’s – Widely held view that the Payment in Kind for Infrastructure mechanism is not workable • We believe a wider interpretation can be provided – On Reg 123 List – not necessary in planning terms as it will be provided by other means – Separate planning applications on strategic sites • Any further clarification would be helpful
  • 19.
    WBC Meaningful Proportion •17 Parishes – 3 Parishes will benefit from 99% of WBC ‘CIL Topslice’ • Small organisations which lack staff / knowledge / skills to prioritise / commission / finance to deal with large amounts of infrastructure funding • Significant drain on SDL infrastructure packages on sites that affect more than one Parish • WBC working very closely with Parishes
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Terms of Reference •WBC and T&PC’s working on a ‘Terms of Reference for the management of the CIL’ • Year long process of engagement – workshops, clerks forums, 1 to 1’s • Three strands – not finalised: – Co-fund infrastructure projects with WBC – WBC would lead on commissioning, procurement and delivery – Deliver on their own – WBC offer design and build package / traded services – Joint Commissioning
  • 22.

Editor's Notes

  • #5 Risk to strategic infrastructure if CIL spent on non-priority projects