Toward a Radically Critical Media Education:
A Case of Wiki Pedagogical Integration in Greece




                Marianna Vivitsou
             PhD Scholar, Researcher
       CICERO Learning, University of Helsinki



                   MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012       1
Networked Sociality: Virtue or Vice?
• “So what exactly are teens _doing_ on
  MySpace? Simple: they're hanging out…..
  This is important in the development of a
  social worldview.” danah boyd, 2006
  – SNSs profile grounded within the context of
    offline friends & contacts (boyd, 2006; Zhao et
    al., 2008)
  – Social presence sustained through ‘catching-up’
    technologies (comments, status updates etc)
    (Miller, 2011)

                    MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012         2
On the other hand…
Collaborative Learning requires
• Common goals & joint efforts toward problem
  solving situations (Rochelle & Teasley 1995)
• And negotiation targeting shared meaning,
  cognitive field, knowledge (Nystrand 1986,
  Rogoff 1990; and others)




                 MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012   3
The Challenges
• In what ways                                   Alexandros

  – student networked sociality manifests ?
  – students approach collaboration ?
  – Teacher blended presence develops ?


  Dimitris




  Marianna

                     MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                4
School BREAK migrates @Sch.I.P.

• Wiki technical functionalities allow for:
  – Combination of Collaboration…
     • Collaborative content development
     • Editing & Commenting individually or not
  – With Sociality: Creation & maintenance of pages
     • personal & of general interest
  – + Visual element embeddedness
     • images & videos


                      MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012       5
Individual + Collective = (Sum)?

            188 members                    • 121 active (118S : 3T)
             (178S : 10T)                  • 26 admins (20S : 6T)


                                           • 12 parent (environment,
            100 pages (52                    School, Web tools etc.)
                                           • 31 sub-topics
             : 48PP, 38S)                  • 09 child-pages


             Plethora of                   • images, videos, other
               Media


               MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                               6
Most Visited Pages

                                          ‘If I were the
                   Main page
                                            Education
                   (V=8094,
socialization                                Minister’
                    C=589)
                                         (V=1709, C=83)



                                        ‘A School with a
                                           Difference:
                    ‘Topics’
                                         Between Now
                 (V=1413, C=39)
                                        and the Future’
                                         (V=935, C=54).    argumentation



                          MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                        7
MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012   8
Personal Pages


From the self to the external world


      Visual Arts, Music,
      Flirting, Friendship,
         Current news,                                    Profiles
       Obesity, Books &
            reading…




                              MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012              9
MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012   10
MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012   11
The Study: Participants & Methods
                      Male               Female
         School 1      23                   38     61
         School 2      31                   43     74
         School 3      10                   15     25
                       64                   96     160

• Qualitative Approach and Statistical analysis (SPSS)
  of quantitative data (questionnaires)
• Content Analysis
  – Questionnaire open-ended items
  – Student contributions
     • page edits, comments

                       MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012         12
11
                                 /1
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9
                            18
                                 /1
                                   /2




                                                 10
                                        00
                                             9




                                                                  185
                            25
                                 /1
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9

                             1/
                                  2/




                                                      102
                                    20
                                         09




                                                                        200
                             8/
                                  2/
                                    20
                                         09




                                                                        186
                            15
                                 /2
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9




                                                                   175
                            22
                                 /2
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9




                                                            133
                             1/
                                  3/
                                    20
                                         09

                             8/
                                  3/

                                                      107
                                    20
                                         09

                            15
                                                                                                                  Active participation/week




                                 /3
                                   /2




MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012
                                                                                                      628




                                        00
                                             9
                                                                                    427




                            22
                                 /3
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9
                            29
                                 /3
                                   /2
                                                                                          443




                                        00
                                             9

                             5/
                                                                                                            706




                                  4/
                                                                                                553




                                    20
                                         09

                            12
                                 /4
                                   /2
                                        00
                                             9
                            19
                                                                              343




                                 /4
                                   /2
                                                                                                            706




                                        00
                                             9
13
Student perspective shifts
8


7
                                               School as a Space for :
6
                                                    Collaboration
                                            Ομάδα ζςνεπγαηών
5
                                                 Personality growth
                                            Χώπορ ανάπηςξηρ νέων ςπεύθςνων
                                            ανθπώπων
4
                                                   Idea exchange
                                            Χώπορ ανηαλλαγήρ ιδεών

3                                           Σηήπιγμα –Enhancement
                                                  Life εθόδιο για ηο μέλλον

2


1


0      Q1                 Q2
      Απσικό             Ύζηεπο


                MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                            14
Traditional School in Doubt
                                Q1      Αρχικό                   Q2      Ύστερο


Schooling & Skill Development    Mean             St. dev.        Mean        St. dev.



Oral Communication               8,16               2,02          3,48            2,12



Written Communication            7,75               2,09          3,59            2,16



Internet Use                     6,88               2,65          4,09            2,13


Willingness to Learn             6,39               3,00          3,41            2,03

                                     MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                           15
@Social Virtual Space for…
• Dialogue development
• Collaboration & creativity boost; active participation (even for
  less ‘sociable’ students)
• Peer learning & support; cognitive & meta-cognitive
  development
• Student leadership & initiative
• Emotion expressiveness
• Real life requirements (“our parents will not always be able to
  support us”): Self-efficacy, self-esteem
• Collective thinking; understanding the ‘otherness’ (“we needed
  to function not only as individuals but also as a team, and we
  did..”, “we managed to ‘see’ the other students’ perspective”
• Looking at reality Critically (“It would be great if the teachers
  allowed more space for us…” «Agree... The majority of the
  teachers… are restrictive… we can’t grow wings to fly away”»

                           MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                  16
The Difference
• Networked Sociality & Content development
  – Internet & services as Tools for Learning
• Global perspective of the local, the regional, the
  national
  – The Self, the Other, the Community
• Human relations
  – Negotiation, Conflict management
• (Shared) Knowledge (Co-)Construction

                      MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012   17
The School of the Future
   Blends                           Reconsiders
   • Virtuality & Actuality         Student-Teacher
   • Synchronous &                  Roles
     @synchronous acts
                                    • asymmetry reviewed
                                    • multiple actor
                                      involvement




       Negotiates                   Enhances Student
        curricular                     & Teacher
      specifications                    Mobility



                  MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                18
Connective technologies as…
• Vehicles of educational change toward the
  School of the Future. In this space, content
  emerges out of the learners’ definitions of own
  needs in an on-going negotiation process.




                  MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012    19
Toward a Radically Critical Media Education

• founded upon the principles of
democratic, communitarian, global citizenship




                                                20
                  MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012
Thank You
             for Your Attention! 



                   Mari@nna Vivitsou
                   • Contact: animavit@gmail.com

Presentation based on:
Vivitsou, Μ., Konetas, D., Gkikas, Αl., Kotoulas, V. (2009). From Social Networking
to Web-based Collaborative Learning in Lower Secondary Education: A Case
Study. In Proceedings 1st Conference Educational Sciences, University of Athens.
Athens, 28-31 May 2009.
                               MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012                              21

Toward a Radically Critical Media Education : A case on Wiki pedagogical Integration

  • 1.
    Toward a RadicallyCritical Media Education: A Case of Wiki Pedagogical Integration in Greece Marianna Vivitsou PhD Scholar, Researcher CICERO Learning, University of Helsinki MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 1
  • 2.
    Networked Sociality: Virtueor Vice? • “So what exactly are teens _doing_ on MySpace? Simple: they're hanging out….. This is important in the development of a social worldview.” danah boyd, 2006 – SNSs profile grounded within the context of offline friends & contacts (boyd, 2006; Zhao et al., 2008) – Social presence sustained through ‘catching-up’ technologies (comments, status updates etc) (Miller, 2011) MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 2
  • 3.
    On the otherhand… Collaborative Learning requires • Common goals & joint efforts toward problem solving situations (Rochelle & Teasley 1995) • And negotiation targeting shared meaning, cognitive field, knowledge (Nystrand 1986, Rogoff 1990; and others) MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 3
  • 4.
    The Challenges • Inwhat ways Alexandros – student networked sociality manifests ? – students approach collaboration ? – Teacher blended presence develops ? Dimitris Marianna MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 4
  • 5.
    School BREAK migrates@Sch.I.P. • Wiki technical functionalities allow for: – Combination of Collaboration… • Collaborative content development • Editing & Commenting individually or not – With Sociality: Creation & maintenance of pages • personal & of general interest – + Visual element embeddedness • images & videos MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 5
  • 6.
    Individual + Collective= (Sum)? 188 members • 121 active (118S : 3T) (178S : 10T) • 26 admins (20S : 6T) • 12 parent (environment, 100 pages (52 School, Web tools etc.) • 31 sub-topics : 48PP, 38S) • 09 child-pages Plethora of • images, videos, other Media MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 6
  • 7.
    Most Visited Pages ‘If I were the Main page Education (V=8094, socialization Minister’ C=589) (V=1709, C=83) ‘A School with a Difference: ‘Topics’ Between Now (V=1413, C=39) and the Future’ (V=935, C=54). argumentation MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 7
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Personal Pages From theself to the external world Visual Arts, Music, Flirting, Friendship, Current news, Profiles Obesity, Books & reading… MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 9
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    The Study: Participants& Methods Male Female School 1 23 38 61 School 2 31 43 74 School 3 10 15 25 64 96 160 • Qualitative Approach and Statistical analysis (SPSS) of quantitative data (questionnaires) • Content Analysis – Questionnaire open-ended items – Student contributions • page edits, comments MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 12
  • 13.
    11 /1 /2 00 9 18 /1 /2 10 00 9 185 25 /1 /2 00 9 1/ 2/ 102 20 09 200 8/ 2/ 20 09 186 15 /2 /2 00 9 175 22 /2 /2 00 9 133 1/ 3/ 20 09 8/ 3/ 107 20 09 15 Active participation/week /3 /2 MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 628 00 9 427 22 /3 /2 00 9 29 /3 /2 443 00 9 5/ 706 4/ 553 20 09 12 /4 /2 00 9 19 343 /4 /2 706 00 9 13
  • 14.
    Student perspective shifts 8 7 School as a Space for : 6 Collaboration Ομάδα ζςνεπγαηών 5 Personality growth Χώπορ ανάπηςξηρ νέων ςπεύθςνων ανθπώπων 4 Idea exchange Χώπορ ανηαλλαγήρ ιδεών 3 Σηήπιγμα –Enhancement Life εθόδιο για ηο μέλλον 2 1 0 Q1 Q2 Απσικό Ύζηεπο MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 14
  • 15.
    Traditional School inDoubt Q1 Αρχικό Q2 Ύστερο Schooling & Skill Development Mean St. dev. Mean St. dev. Oral Communication 8,16 2,02 3,48 2,12 Written Communication 7,75 2,09 3,59 2,16 Internet Use 6,88 2,65 4,09 2,13 Willingness to Learn 6,39 3,00 3,41 2,03 MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 15
  • 16.
    @Social Virtual Spacefor… • Dialogue development • Collaboration & creativity boost; active participation (even for less ‘sociable’ students) • Peer learning & support; cognitive & meta-cognitive development • Student leadership & initiative • Emotion expressiveness • Real life requirements (“our parents will not always be able to support us”): Self-efficacy, self-esteem • Collective thinking; understanding the ‘otherness’ (“we needed to function not only as individuals but also as a team, and we did..”, “we managed to ‘see’ the other students’ perspective” • Looking at reality Critically (“It would be great if the teachers allowed more space for us…” «Agree... The majority of the teachers… are restrictive… we can’t grow wings to fly away”» MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 16
  • 17.
    The Difference • NetworkedSociality & Content development – Internet & services as Tools for Learning • Global perspective of the local, the regional, the national – The Self, the Other, the Community • Human relations – Negotiation, Conflict management • (Shared) Knowledge (Co-)Construction MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 17
  • 18.
    The School ofthe Future Blends Reconsiders • Virtuality & Actuality Student-Teacher • Synchronous & Roles @synchronous acts • asymmetry reviewed • multiple actor involvement Negotiates Enhances Student curricular & Teacher specifications Mobility MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 18
  • 19.
    Connective technologies as… •Vehicles of educational change toward the School of the Future. In this space, content emerges out of the learners’ definitions of own needs in an on-going negotiation process. MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 19
  • 20.
    Toward a RadicallyCritical Media Education • founded upon the principles of democratic, communitarian, global citizenship 20 MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012
  • 21.
    Thank You for Your Attention!  Mari@nna Vivitsou • Contact: animavit@gmail.com Presentation based on: Vivitsou, Μ., Konetas, D., Gkikas, Αl., Kotoulas, V. (2009). From Social Networking to Web-based Collaborative Learning in Lower Secondary Education: A Case Study. In Proceedings 1st Conference Educational Sciences, University of Athens. Athens, 28-31 May 2009. MEDEA Webinar, 18.10.2012 21