The text analyzes the mutual relations between the liturgy of sacraments
and the most solemn state ceremony in the Republic of Poland, that of swearing-in of
the Head of State. Although the latter ceremony is secular, its antecedence should be
sought in the religious aspects of the enthronement of European rulers in the Middle
Ages. These references make the swearing-in an object of study combining theology
and political science. They invite questions about the relation between the religious
imagination of a given national community and its political organization as embodied in state ceremonies. The candidate who wins the presidential elections becomes
the President of the Polish Republic after their victory is announced by the National
Electoral Commission, and after the Supreme Court confirms validity of this result.
However, they remain President-Elect until they utter the words of the oath. Therefore, the swearing-in is a public ritual regulated by law which needs to be completed
in order to formally commence exercise of the office. The oath, which is spelled out in
the Constitution and delivered by the newly elected Head of State, has a performative
nature, similar to liturgical formulas. Additionally, it comprises an optional reference
to God as witness to the oath delivered. Therefore, the presidential oath is a historically conditioned testimony to public authority, referring to the realm of the sacred.
THE MODERN IMAGE OF THE HOLY LAND: THROUGH THE MANUSCRIPTS OF SOME CHRISTIAN ...islamicjerusalem
This article analyzes representations of the Holy Land presented in accounts from Christian missionaries who visited the region in the 19th century. It examines writings by William Lethaby, a Methodist missionary, and Father Jaussen, a Catholic missionary from France. These missionaries immersed themselves in the local culture but reconstructed the Holy Land according to their own Western perspectives. Their writings helped shape a specific Western image of Palestine, Jerusalem, and the religious rights of its inhabitants that still influences perceptions today. The article also discusses how missionary activities were enabled by political developments like the capitulations system between Western powers and the Ottoman Empire.
Pope Francis confirmed he will visit the Philippines in January 2015 over a 2 day trip, as part of a tour of Sri Lanka and the Philippines. The visit aims to console survivors of Super Typhoon Yolanda, which devastated parts of the Philippines in 2013. Pope Francis is the first non-European Pope and head of the world's largest Christian religion, hoping to visit the country with Asia's largest Roman Catholic population after expressing his desire to help survivors of the deadly storm.
The Pope is the Bishop of Rome and the successor of St. Peter, who was chosen by Jesus to lead the Apostles. As the head of the College of Bishops, the Pope has universal jurisdiction over the Catholic Church and appoints all other bishops. The Pope exercises authority over the entire Church as the visible source and foundation of its unity.
This document provides an overview of the Catholic doctrine of the primacy of St. Peter, which asserts that Saint Peter held a position of prominence among the 12 Apostles and that his successors, the Popes, are the heads of the Catholic Church. It defines key terms, references biblical passages that support Peter's leadership role, and cites canon law codifying the Pope's supreme authority. The objectives are to understand and defend this unifying dogma of Catholicism. It concludes by mentioning Pope Francis' 2015 visit in relation to this topic.
The Bible is a collection of sacred texts that are central to Christianity, consisting of the Old Testament and New Testament. The Old Testament originated from Jewish texts and was written in Hebrew before the 1st century AD. The New Testament contains 27 books written in Greek in the 1st century AD that are unique to Christianity. Some of the oldest surviving manuscripts of the New Testament, such as the Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, date back to the 4th century AD.
First of four blocks of slides for a course on legal history with professor Emanuele Conte. Students should use also Tamar Herzog's A Short History of European Law
The Emergence of the “Church history” and the predicament of Orthodox Hierarc...Евгений Лютько
EHS Conferences 2016-17: The Church and Empire (Pollock Halls, University of Edinburgh, 26-28 July 2016) presentation for the paper "The Emergence of the “Church history” and the predicament of Orthodox Hierarchy in the Russian Empire of the early 1800s"
THE MODERN IMAGE OF THE HOLY LAND: THROUGH THE MANUSCRIPTS OF SOME CHRISTIAN ...islamicjerusalem
This article analyzes representations of the Holy Land presented in accounts from Christian missionaries who visited the region in the 19th century. It examines writings by William Lethaby, a Methodist missionary, and Father Jaussen, a Catholic missionary from France. These missionaries immersed themselves in the local culture but reconstructed the Holy Land according to their own Western perspectives. Their writings helped shape a specific Western image of Palestine, Jerusalem, and the religious rights of its inhabitants that still influences perceptions today. The article also discusses how missionary activities were enabled by political developments like the capitulations system between Western powers and the Ottoman Empire.
Pope Francis confirmed he will visit the Philippines in January 2015 over a 2 day trip, as part of a tour of Sri Lanka and the Philippines. The visit aims to console survivors of Super Typhoon Yolanda, which devastated parts of the Philippines in 2013. Pope Francis is the first non-European Pope and head of the world's largest Christian religion, hoping to visit the country with Asia's largest Roman Catholic population after expressing his desire to help survivors of the deadly storm.
The Pope is the Bishop of Rome and the successor of St. Peter, who was chosen by Jesus to lead the Apostles. As the head of the College of Bishops, the Pope has universal jurisdiction over the Catholic Church and appoints all other bishops. The Pope exercises authority over the entire Church as the visible source and foundation of its unity.
This document provides an overview of the Catholic doctrine of the primacy of St. Peter, which asserts that Saint Peter held a position of prominence among the 12 Apostles and that his successors, the Popes, are the heads of the Catholic Church. It defines key terms, references biblical passages that support Peter's leadership role, and cites canon law codifying the Pope's supreme authority. The objectives are to understand and defend this unifying dogma of Catholicism. It concludes by mentioning Pope Francis' 2015 visit in relation to this topic.
The Bible is a collection of sacred texts that are central to Christianity, consisting of the Old Testament and New Testament. The Old Testament originated from Jewish texts and was written in Hebrew before the 1st century AD. The New Testament contains 27 books written in Greek in the 1st century AD that are unique to Christianity. Some of the oldest surviving manuscripts of the New Testament, such as the Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus, date back to the 4th century AD.
First of four blocks of slides for a course on legal history with professor Emanuele Conte. Students should use also Tamar Herzog's A Short History of European Law
The Emergence of the “Church history” and the predicament of Orthodox Hierarc...Евгений Лютько
EHS Conferences 2016-17: The Church and Empire (Pollock Halls, University of Edinburgh, 26-28 July 2016) presentation for the paper "The Emergence of the “Church history” and the predicament of Orthodox Hierarchy in the Russian Empire of the early 1800s"
Conference Paper: Preserving Transcultural Heritage: your way or my way? July...Svetlana Anderson
This document summarizes a doctoral research proposal examining the communal building traditions and cultural heritage preservation efforts in Karelia, located along the Finland-Russia border. The research will analyze case studies of vernacular settlements through archival research and fieldwork to understand how social transformations and preservation initiatives have shaped these historic localities over time. It will also explore the intersections between technology, research, and human experience in heritage preservation. The goal is to reveal communal preservation efforts and produce media and reference materials to support ongoing conservation work in the region.
A Cult By Any Other Name: Early Christianity and the Greco-Roman Mystery Reli...Haley Shoemaker
A comparison of Early Christianity and the Mystery religions of Rome in the 2nd Century. More specifically I compare baptism as it is depicted in Tertullian's famous work "On Baptism" to its portrayal in Apuleius' novel "The Golden Ass."
Eliseo Ferrer - Fraud and incompetence in research on the origins of Christia...Eliseo Ferrer
(Corrected and enlarged versión, With bibliographical references).
I believe that the secular influence of the theology and dogmatics of the Church (inherited, to a large extent, by the Lutheran reformers), as well as the ideology generated over eighteen centuries on the substratum of the New Testament, have led and They continue to lead in the XXI century to great errors of study and interpretation of the origins of Christianity. I present a twelve-point list of the errors that I consider the most important, and that surprise me the most and call my attention.
This document discusses errors in research on the origins of Christianity that are influenced by theology and church dogma. It provides a 12-point list of major errors, including: 1) Interpreting Paul's letters through edited church texts rather than early gnostic Christianity. 2) Viewing the gospels as biographies rather than allegorical texts. 3) Failing to understand the gospels as midrashic literature with symbolic meaning. 4) Not recognizing that the gospels describe the incarnation of the spirit or wisdom. 5) Failing to understand that in Christianity, the word came before flesh. 6) Lacking knowledge of the myth of the spirit's incarnation from an anthropological perspective. 7)
«The Messiah-Christ is an ancient and archaic myth reformulated by the sects of apocalyptic messianism and transformed by Gnosticism and the Church of the second century». Eliseo Ferrer talks about the myths of primitive Christianity in an interview conducted on the occasion of the presentation of his book SACRIFICE AND DRAMA OF THE SACRED KING, at the beginning of the year 2022.
According Eliseo Ferrer, Christianity is an apocalyptic mythology transformed...Eliseo Ferrer
Eliseo Ferrer talks about the founding myths of Christianity in an interview conducted at the beginning of the year 2022, on the occasion of the presentation of his book SACRIFICE AND DRAMA OF THE SACRED KING.
This document provides an historical and theological analysis of the concept of Purgatory from its roots in early Christian tradition through its development in the Catholic Church and rejection by Protestantism. It examines the views of key figures like Augustine, Luther, and Dante and traces how the concept evolved from the patristic period through the Middle Ages and Reformation, becoming formalized as Catholic dogma while being dismissed by Protestants. It also discusses how the doctrine differs between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy in the aftermath of the Great Schism of 1054.
CHAPTER 12
Incarnation and the Church’s Evangelistic Mission
Darrell L. Guder
In the ecumenical conversation about mission and evangelism in the last decade, there is
frequent reference to “doing mission and evangelism in Jesus Christ’s way.” In 1989, the
World Council of Churches (WCC) convened its conference on world mission and
evangelism in San Antonio under the theme, “Your Will Be Done: Mission in Christ’s Way.”1
In 1987, an international grouping of ecumenical-evangelical missiologists and church
leaders met in Stuttgart to consider the forthcoming San Antonio meeting. Their purpose was
to think about the evangelistic mission of the church and to prepare a statement reflecting
their insights for the 1989 conference. The result was a book entitled Proclaiming Christ in
Christ’s Way: Studies in Integral Evangelism.2 In 1982, the WCC’s Commission on World
Mission and Evangelism presented its major statement, Mission and Evangelism: An
Ecumenical Affirmation.3 It contains a section entitled “Mission in Christ’s Way.” The
reception of this language can be traced around the world. In 1991, for example, the General
Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (USA) adopted a document on mission and evangelism
entitled Turn to the Living God — A Call To Evangelism in Jesus Christ’s Way,4 which
specifically refers to the WCC statement of 1982.5
This imagery, “doing mission and evangelism in Jesus Christ’s way,” indicates a
broadening ecumenical consensus about the relationship between the Incarnation — the
actual way in which the Word became flesh or the model of Jesus’ life — and the way in
which the church goes about its mission. Such an “incarnational” approach (“incarnational”
is apparently a twentieth-century neologism) raises a lot of questions, particularly at a time
when, in some quarters, the Incarnation is itself the theme of heated debate. Therefore, it will
be helpful to examine carefully what is occurring theologically when we talk about “mission
in Jesus Christ’s way.”
When we go back before the appearance of the WCC 1982 document, Mission and
Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation, we enter into a period of several decades in which
most Western mainline Protestant traditions tended to de-emphasize evangelism as the
verbal proclamation of the gospel with the intent to draw people to personal faith in Christ.
The focus was generally more upon the church’s social witness and involvement with a broad
agenda of justice and peace. Often evangelism was redefined as an expression of social
witness, so that the word was used for almost anything a mainline denominational agency
wanted to affirm. The American Presbyterian version of this process is called by Milton J.
Coalter the “rethinking, retooling, and restructuring” of evangelism, which he d ...
The 400-year period from 1517 to 1918 saw preparations for the Second Coming of Christ. This period was divided into three stages: 1) The Reformation from 1517-1648 which began with Martin Luther, 2) Religious and ideological conflicts from 1648-1789, and 3) The maturation of politics, economy and ideology from 1789-1918 ending with World War I. During the Middle Ages, feudalism and corruption in the Roman Church suppressed humanity's original nature, prompting movements like the Renaissance and Reformation to restore it. The Renaissance revived Hellenism and humanism while the Reformation revived the Hebrew faith tradition, centered on faith in God.
The document provides an overview of the dark criminal history of many popes throughout history. It summarizes that popes were often decadent, savage military strategists, and engaged in trafficking of ecclesiastical appointments, deceit, scandals, immorality, aggression, fraud, murder and cruelty. It describes specific popes like Stephen VII who ordered a posthumous trial of a deceased pope and mutilated his body. It discusses the rule of the whores Theodora and Marozia who controlled the papacy in the 10th century and appointed lovers and relatives to the papacy. The true history of popes is far removed from their modern portrayal as devout and virtuous leaders.
St.Francis.Heytyrop.Penult.Version.4__Scott Thomas
1) The document discusses St. Francis of Assisi's meeting with Sultan Malek el-Kamel in 1213 during the Fifth Crusade and how this encounter has been portrayed and interpreted over time.
2) It questions whether Francis was on a mission of peace or supported the Crusades, as accounts of the meeting are limited and contradictory.
3) The document argues that critical theory and social constructivism perspectives from international relations can provide a framework for understanding how the encounter has been constructed and interpreted differently over hundreds of years.
American Research Journal of Humanities & Social Science (ARJHSS) is a double blind peer reviewed, open access journal published by (ARJHSS).
The main objective of ARJHSS is to provide an intellectual platform for the international scholars. ARJHSS aims to promote interdisciplinary studies in Humanities & Social Science and become the leading journal in Humanities & Social Science in the world.
This document discusses the history of the Roman Catholic Church and the Roman Empire leading up to the time period of the seven trumpets prophecy. It provides background on how Constantine converted to Christianity and legalized the religion, leading the church to become corrupted and seek support from the state, laying the foundations for the papacy. It describes how Constantine built a new capital in Constantinople, and how the empire was divided after his death among his sons and later split permanently between east and west. The document emphasizes that prophecies use symbols to represent world powers and events to reveal God's messages for different time periods.
This study guide, the second half of a two part study on how the early Christian church selected the books that comprise the canon of the New Testament, is one of a series to help leaders of a Bible study or Sunday School class who are too busy to research and prepare as well as they would like for the task. The entire series is engaging, colorful and challenging and is ready to go even at the last moment. More are in the works. Search using keyword "lessonstogo."
This document provides an overview of key terms related to the interpretation of Sacred Scripture according to Catholic teaching. It defines and explains concepts like divine economy, typology, mystagogy, the senses of Scripture, exegesis, hermeneutics, and tradition. Divine economy refers to God's plan governing all of creation and salvation history. Typology sees prefigurations of Christ and the New Covenant in the people and events of the Old Testament. Mystagogy explains the mystery contained within Scripture and liturgy. Exegesis and hermeneutics are the interpretation and study of interpretive methods for Scripture. Tradition encompasses Revelation, Church councils, liturgy, and the life of the
This document provides an overview of early Christianity from the Apostolic Era to the early Church Fathers. It discusses key events like the Councils of Nicea and Constantinople, and influential figures like Ignatius of Antioch, Clement of Rome, Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, and Tertullian. The Apostolic Fathers helped establish church governance and spread Christianity following the deaths of the apostles. Their writings provide insight into early Christian beliefs and practices.
The document provides an overview of early Christianity from the Apostolic Era to the writings of the Apostolic Fathers. It discusses key events like the Councils of Nicea and Constantinople, figures like Ignatius of Antioch and Clement of Rome, and topics addressed in their writings like the authority of the apostles, the historicity of Jesus, and the characteristics of the Apostolic Fathers. The document also provides biographical details on some of the early church fathers.
This document discusses hagiography, which are writings about saints' lives and martyrdom that were intended to educate readers on virtues and inspire emulation of saints, rather than provide strictly historical accounts. It provides definitions and terminology related to hagiography and the cult of saints. It also discusses how historians in Late Antiquity had different approaches than modern historians, prioritizing edification over chronology and impartiality. The document examines themes commonly found in saints' lives and provides perspectives on hagiography from several scholars including Peter Brown, Averil Cameron, and David Brakke.
This document provides biographical information about Saint Luke, the author of the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles. It states that Luke was a Greek physician who traveled with and assisted Saint Paul. Luke is credited as the first historian of Christianity and incorporated eyewitness testimony into his gospel and Acts. The document discusses Luke's special focus on themes of mercy, forgiveness, and the inclusion of Gentiles. It provides details on Luke's travels with Paul and eventual martyrdom. The document also notes artistic traditions associated with Luke and feast days in his honor.
An investigation into the provenance and history of one of the most popular stories of medieval Europe, which had its origins in the life of the Buddha, as recounted in Buddhist literature. The paper details its transmission through various languages and religions from India to the Iranians of Central Asia, to Abbasid Baghdad, Georgia, Greece and Palestine, to Eastern and Western Europe. The religions include Buddhism, Manichaeanism, Shia Islam, Judaism, and Eastern and Western Christianity. The author argues that the tale is an early expression of values that today can be considered ecumenical and interfaith in scope.
This paper aims to examine the activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation [We
have a voice], an organization founded in 2015 by junior high school students from
a handful of towns in Poland. For this purpose, a review of available materials about
this organization will be carried out and information will be collected using in-depth
interviews with the founders of the organization. The main research question concerns
the motivation behind young people’s activity in the foundation, the methods used to
achieve the goals of the organization and its founders’ profiles. Their activity will be
presented in the context of political activism among young people, including gender
differentiation.
The United Kingdom joined the EEC/EU in 1973. Its membership has been
one of the thorniest issues in British politics over the last forty-five years. The United
Kingdom was one of the most Euroskeptic member states in the EU. The ‘added
value’ brought by London to the EU was the English language, which successively
supplanted French from the function of working language of the EU. English is not
only the official language of the EU (it is one of 24 official languages), but primarily
has a dominant position in the EU. It is used for communication between the EU and
the world, between European institutions and during informal meetings. The purpose
of this article is to analyze the position of English in the EU, to show its strengths, and
finally to answer the question of whether the present status of English in the EU will
remain after the UK leaves.
More Related Content
Similar to Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies of the President of the Republic of Poland after 1989
Conference Paper: Preserving Transcultural Heritage: your way or my way? July...Svetlana Anderson
This document summarizes a doctoral research proposal examining the communal building traditions and cultural heritage preservation efforts in Karelia, located along the Finland-Russia border. The research will analyze case studies of vernacular settlements through archival research and fieldwork to understand how social transformations and preservation initiatives have shaped these historic localities over time. It will also explore the intersections between technology, research, and human experience in heritage preservation. The goal is to reveal communal preservation efforts and produce media and reference materials to support ongoing conservation work in the region.
A Cult By Any Other Name: Early Christianity and the Greco-Roman Mystery Reli...Haley Shoemaker
A comparison of Early Christianity and the Mystery religions of Rome in the 2nd Century. More specifically I compare baptism as it is depicted in Tertullian's famous work "On Baptism" to its portrayal in Apuleius' novel "The Golden Ass."
Eliseo Ferrer - Fraud and incompetence in research on the origins of Christia...Eliseo Ferrer
(Corrected and enlarged versión, With bibliographical references).
I believe that the secular influence of the theology and dogmatics of the Church (inherited, to a large extent, by the Lutheran reformers), as well as the ideology generated over eighteen centuries on the substratum of the New Testament, have led and They continue to lead in the XXI century to great errors of study and interpretation of the origins of Christianity. I present a twelve-point list of the errors that I consider the most important, and that surprise me the most and call my attention.
This document discusses errors in research on the origins of Christianity that are influenced by theology and church dogma. It provides a 12-point list of major errors, including: 1) Interpreting Paul's letters through edited church texts rather than early gnostic Christianity. 2) Viewing the gospels as biographies rather than allegorical texts. 3) Failing to understand the gospels as midrashic literature with symbolic meaning. 4) Not recognizing that the gospels describe the incarnation of the spirit or wisdom. 5) Failing to understand that in Christianity, the word came before flesh. 6) Lacking knowledge of the myth of the spirit's incarnation from an anthropological perspective. 7)
«The Messiah-Christ is an ancient and archaic myth reformulated by the sects of apocalyptic messianism and transformed by Gnosticism and the Church of the second century». Eliseo Ferrer talks about the myths of primitive Christianity in an interview conducted on the occasion of the presentation of his book SACRIFICE AND DRAMA OF THE SACRED KING, at the beginning of the year 2022.
According Eliseo Ferrer, Christianity is an apocalyptic mythology transformed...Eliseo Ferrer
Eliseo Ferrer talks about the founding myths of Christianity in an interview conducted at the beginning of the year 2022, on the occasion of the presentation of his book SACRIFICE AND DRAMA OF THE SACRED KING.
This document provides an historical and theological analysis of the concept of Purgatory from its roots in early Christian tradition through its development in the Catholic Church and rejection by Protestantism. It examines the views of key figures like Augustine, Luther, and Dante and traces how the concept evolved from the patristic period through the Middle Ages and Reformation, becoming formalized as Catholic dogma while being dismissed by Protestants. It also discusses how the doctrine differs between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy in the aftermath of the Great Schism of 1054.
CHAPTER 12
Incarnation and the Church’s Evangelistic Mission
Darrell L. Guder
In the ecumenical conversation about mission and evangelism in the last decade, there is
frequent reference to “doing mission and evangelism in Jesus Christ’s way.” In 1989, the
World Council of Churches (WCC) convened its conference on world mission and
evangelism in San Antonio under the theme, “Your Will Be Done: Mission in Christ’s Way.”1
In 1987, an international grouping of ecumenical-evangelical missiologists and church
leaders met in Stuttgart to consider the forthcoming San Antonio meeting. Their purpose was
to think about the evangelistic mission of the church and to prepare a statement reflecting
their insights for the 1989 conference. The result was a book entitled Proclaiming Christ in
Christ’s Way: Studies in Integral Evangelism.2 In 1982, the WCC’s Commission on World
Mission and Evangelism presented its major statement, Mission and Evangelism: An
Ecumenical Affirmation.3 It contains a section entitled “Mission in Christ’s Way.” The
reception of this language can be traced around the world. In 1991, for example, the General
Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (USA) adopted a document on mission and evangelism
entitled Turn to the Living God — A Call To Evangelism in Jesus Christ’s Way,4 which
specifically refers to the WCC statement of 1982.5
This imagery, “doing mission and evangelism in Jesus Christ’s way,” indicates a
broadening ecumenical consensus about the relationship between the Incarnation — the
actual way in which the Word became flesh or the model of Jesus’ life — and the way in
which the church goes about its mission. Such an “incarnational” approach (“incarnational”
is apparently a twentieth-century neologism) raises a lot of questions, particularly at a time
when, in some quarters, the Incarnation is itself the theme of heated debate. Therefore, it will
be helpful to examine carefully what is occurring theologically when we talk about “mission
in Jesus Christ’s way.”
When we go back before the appearance of the WCC 1982 document, Mission and
Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation, we enter into a period of several decades in which
most Western mainline Protestant traditions tended to de-emphasize evangelism as the
verbal proclamation of the gospel with the intent to draw people to personal faith in Christ.
The focus was generally more upon the church’s social witness and involvement with a broad
agenda of justice and peace. Often evangelism was redefined as an expression of social
witness, so that the word was used for almost anything a mainline denominational agency
wanted to affirm. The American Presbyterian version of this process is called by Milton J.
Coalter the “rethinking, retooling, and restructuring” of evangelism, which he d ...
The 400-year period from 1517 to 1918 saw preparations for the Second Coming of Christ. This period was divided into three stages: 1) The Reformation from 1517-1648 which began with Martin Luther, 2) Religious and ideological conflicts from 1648-1789, and 3) The maturation of politics, economy and ideology from 1789-1918 ending with World War I. During the Middle Ages, feudalism and corruption in the Roman Church suppressed humanity's original nature, prompting movements like the Renaissance and Reformation to restore it. The Renaissance revived Hellenism and humanism while the Reformation revived the Hebrew faith tradition, centered on faith in God.
The document provides an overview of the dark criminal history of many popes throughout history. It summarizes that popes were often decadent, savage military strategists, and engaged in trafficking of ecclesiastical appointments, deceit, scandals, immorality, aggression, fraud, murder and cruelty. It describes specific popes like Stephen VII who ordered a posthumous trial of a deceased pope and mutilated his body. It discusses the rule of the whores Theodora and Marozia who controlled the papacy in the 10th century and appointed lovers and relatives to the papacy. The true history of popes is far removed from their modern portrayal as devout and virtuous leaders.
St.Francis.Heytyrop.Penult.Version.4__Scott Thomas
1) The document discusses St. Francis of Assisi's meeting with Sultan Malek el-Kamel in 1213 during the Fifth Crusade and how this encounter has been portrayed and interpreted over time.
2) It questions whether Francis was on a mission of peace or supported the Crusades, as accounts of the meeting are limited and contradictory.
3) The document argues that critical theory and social constructivism perspectives from international relations can provide a framework for understanding how the encounter has been constructed and interpreted differently over hundreds of years.
American Research Journal of Humanities & Social Science (ARJHSS) is a double blind peer reviewed, open access journal published by (ARJHSS).
The main objective of ARJHSS is to provide an intellectual platform for the international scholars. ARJHSS aims to promote interdisciplinary studies in Humanities & Social Science and become the leading journal in Humanities & Social Science in the world.
This document discusses the history of the Roman Catholic Church and the Roman Empire leading up to the time period of the seven trumpets prophecy. It provides background on how Constantine converted to Christianity and legalized the religion, leading the church to become corrupted and seek support from the state, laying the foundations for the papacy. It describes how Constantine built a new capital in Constantinople, and how the empire was divided after his death among his sons and later split permanently between east and west. The document emphasizes that prophecies use symbols to represent world powers and events to reveal God's messages for different time periods.
This study guide, the second half of a two part study on how the early Christian church selected the books that comprise the canon of the New Testament, is one of a series to help leaders of a Bible study or Sunday School class who are too busy to research and prepare as well as they would like for the task. The entire series is engaging, colorful and challenging and is ready to go even at the last moment. More are in the works. Search using keyword "lessonstogo."
This document provides an overview of key terms related to the interpretation of Sacred Scripture according to Catholic teaching. It defines and explains concepts like divine economy, typology, mystagogy, the senses of Scripture, exegesis, hermeneutics, and tradition. Divine economy refers to God's plan governing all of creation and salvation history. Typology sees prefigurations of Christ and the New Covenant in the people and events of the Old Testament. Mystagogy explains the mystery contained within Scripture and liturgy. Exegesis and hermeneutics are the interpretation and study of interpretive methods for Scripture. Tradition encompasses Revelation, Church councils, liturgy, and the life of the
This document provides an overview of early Christianity from the Apostolic Era to the early Church Fathers. It discusses key events like the Councils of Nicea and Constantinople, and influential figures like Ignatius of Antioch, Clement of Rome, Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, and Tertullian. The Apostolic Fathers helped establish church governance and spread Christianity following the deaths of the apostles. Their writings provide insight into early Christian beliefs and practices.
The document provides an overview of early Christianity from the Apostolic Era to the writings of the Apostolic Fathers. It discusses key events like the Councils of Nicea and Constantinople, figures like Ignatius of Antioch and Clement of Rome, and topics addressed in their writings like the authority of the apostles, the historicity of Jesus, and the characteristics of the Apostolic Fathers. The document also provides biographical details on some of the early church fathers.
This document discusses hagiography, which are writings about saints' lives and martyrdom that were intended to educate readers on virtues and inspire emulation of saints, rather than provide strictly historical accounts. It provides definitions and terminology related to hagiography and the cult of saints. It also discusses how historians in Late Antiquity had different approaches than modern historians, prioritizing edification over chronology and impartiality. The document examines themes commonly found in saints' lives and provides perspectives on hagiography from several scholars including Peter Brown, Averil Cameron, and David Brakke.
This document provides biographical information about Saint Luke, the author of the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles. It states that Luke was a Greek physician who traveled with and assisted Saint Paul. Luke is credited as the first historian of Christianity and incorporated eyewitness testimony into his gospel and Acts. The document discusses Luke's special focus on themes of mercy, forgiveness, and the inclusion of Gentiles. It provides details on Luke's travels with Paul and eventual martyrdom. The document also notes artistic traditions associated with Luke and feast days in his honor.
An investigation into the provenance and history of one of the most popular stories of medieval Europe, which had its origins in the life of the Buddha, as recounted in Buddhist literature. The paper details its transmission through various languages and religions from India to the Iranians of Central Asia, to Abbasid Baghdad, Georgia, Greece and Palestine, to Eastern and Western Europe. The religions include Buddhism, Manichaeanism, Shia Islam, Judaism, and Eastern and Western Christianity. The author argues that the tale is an early expression of values that today can be considered ecumenical and interfaith in scope.
Similar to Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies of the President of the Republic of Poland after 1989 (20)
This paper aims to examine the activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation [We
have a voice], an organization founded in 2015 by junior high school students from
a handful of towns in Poland. For this purpose, a review of available materials about
this organization will be carried out and information will be collected using in-depth
interviews with the founders of the organization. The main research question concerns
the motivation behind young people’s activity in the foundation, the methods used to
achieve the goals of the organization and its founders’ profiles. Their activity will be
presented in the context of political activism among young people, including gender
differentiation.
The United Kingdom joined the EEC/EU in 1973. Its membership has been
one of the thorniest issues in British politics over the last forty-five years. The United
Kingdom was one of the most Euroskeptic member states in the EU. The ‘added
value’ brought by London to the EU was the English language, which successively
supplanted French from the function of working language of the EU. English is not
only the official language of the EU (it is one of 24 official languages), but primarily
has a dominant position in the EU. It is used for communication between the EU and
the world, between European institutions and during informal meetings. The purpose
of this article is to analyze the position of English in the EU, to show its strengths, and
finally to answer the question of whether the present status of English in the EU will
remain after the UK leaves.
This article aims to identify the major cores of the 15-M Movement mindset
and explain how particular historical factors shaped it. The research problems are to identify the types of relations the movement established between the people and the ruling
elites in its political manifestos, and the sources of these discursively created relations.
The research field encompasses the content of political manifestos published between
the Spanish general election on March 9, 2008 and immediately after the demonstrations
held on May 15, 2011. To solve these problems, the research applies source analysis of
the political manifestos. These are: (1) The Manifesto of ¡Democracia Real YA!; (2) The
Manifesto of the Puerta del Sol Camp, and (3) The Manifesto “May 68 in Spain.” The
research uses the technique of relational qualitative content analysis to determine the
relations between the semantic fields of the major categories of populism, ‘the people’
and ‘the elites,’ as well as to identify the meanings formed by their co-occurrence. The
tool used is a content analysis instruction whose major assumption is to identify all the
attempts to create images of ‘the people,’ ‘the elites,’ and relations between them.
The article analyzes the structure, content, properties and effects of the
Russian-Ukrainian ‘hybrid war’ in its non-military dimension. Particular emphasis is
placed on the aspect of the information and propaganda war, as well as activities in
cyberspace. The Russian-Ukrainian conflict is described in the context of the new war
strategy of General Valery Gerasimov. Contemporary practice of hybrid actions in the
conflict in Ukraine has revealed that, for the first time, a stronger opponent, Russia,
uses the full spectrum of hybrid interaction on an opponent who is weak and unable
to defend the integrity of its territory. The military conflict of 2014 showed not only
the weakness of the Ukrainian state, but also, more importantly, the inefficiency of the
organizations responsible for ensuring international security: NATO, OSCE and the
UN. In the longer term, it should be noted that the escalation of hybrid activities in
Ukraine clearly threatens the states on the Eastern flank of the North Atlantic Alliance.
The analysis conducted refers to the problem defined in the form of questions: what
is the essence of hybrid operations? What is the nature of non-military hybrid operations? What was the course of these activities in Ukraine? How was international law
interpreted in relation to this conflict?
The article has three dimensions: methodological, theoretical, and empirical. A point of departure for the methodological remarks is a characterization of the
three main approaches in the vibrant interdisciplinary research field dealing with the
phenomenon of conspiracy theories. In this context, the content analysis method is
discussed as a promising approach to gain new data on conspiracy narratives. On the
theoretical level, the concept of conspiracy narratives is discussed in reference to the
popular understanding of the conspiracy theory. The main aim of the empirical part is
determining to what extent the media are saturated with different kinds of conspiracy
narratives. The analysis covers over 200 articles from two popular Polish news magazines (Sieci and the Polish edition of Newsweek) which occupy positions on opposite sides of the political divide in a society polarized, inter alia, by a conspiratorial
suspicion that in 2010 an airplane carrying President Lech Kaczyński on board was
deliberately crashed in Russia.
: The main goal of the studies described in this article may be defined as an
analysis of the promotional processes of regional and traditional products executed with
the use of symbols regulated by European law: Traditional Speciality Guaranteed (TSG),
Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) and Protected Geographical Indication (PGI).
The analysis presented here and the trends in promotional activities deducted from
it, primarily result from the specifics of the goods. The shape of the information system is also influenced by social and cultural factors decisive for the recognizability
and renown of the products, which have been confirmed by the results of the questionnaire conducted for the study. What is worth noting is the correlation between quality
and tradition, reflected, among other things, in declarations regarding the reasons for
the choice of these products: the sense of pride and the willingness to continue the
traditions were chosen by 45% of the survey participants. The Traditional Speciality
Guaranteed (TSG) has proven to be the most recognizable European symbol (38%).
This paper looks at the proposals of the European Commission for the
Multiannual Financial Framework 2021–2027, and explores how to achieve a better
future for Europe by ensuring compliance with the legally binding values and objectives of the EU: democracy, equality, the rule of law, economic, social and territorial
cohesion and solidarity between the member states.
It is argued that introducing progressivity, a reform of the EU’s finances involving
a paradigm shift in the financing of policies with redistributive effects and a reform of
the system of the EU’s ‘own resources,’ would ensure that solidarity becomes a matter
of the rule of law and not of governance through conditionalities and fines.
It is pointed out that, unless the EU undertakes an effective reform of its redistributive policies to ensure that progressivity and solidarity in the EU become a matter
of the rule of law, the Union will bear less and less resemblance to a democracy and
will increasingly look like an empire with an economically stronger and more rapidly
developing ‘core,’ and an economically weaker ‘periphery’ in the East and the South
lagging behind the ‘core.’
What is needed is collective action by the member states most immediately interested in a reform to make the system of EU’s ‘own resources’ less regressive and to
introduce progressivity in the financing of the policies of the EU. It would take significant skill for those countries to organize themselves as a group and to act together
in the course of the adoption of the legislative proposals for the next MFF in order to
make the EU more equitable.
Contemporary diplomacy has evolved into a network involving various
new actors, including international sports organizations. The article is dedicated to the
issue of the sports diplomacy of international bodies which are in charge of international sporting competitions, particularly the International Federation of Association
Football (FIFA), an organization that manages football on a global level.
The research presented in this article is a case study dedicated to the issue of the
influence of international sports organizations on the governments of sovereign states,
specifically FIFA. The objective of the research is to investigate whether international
sports organizations are able to make governments change their political decisions.
The hypothesis that has been investigated states that international sports governing
bodies are diplomatic actors capable of influencing states.
One of the first laws adopted by the new political leadership in Ukraine
in the aftermath of the Revolution of Dignity in 2014 was the new concept of local
governance reform and the organization of territorial authority in Ukraine. The aforementioned law, as well as official declarations by top politicians on the necessity of
empowering Ukrainian citizens to take part in the decision-making process and shape
their local communities, led to positive expectations regarding the transformation of
local governance in Ukraine. Therefore, this article addresses the issue of the legal
basis framing the functioning of civil society in Ukraine, focusing on major attempts
to conduct reform and on the main outcomes of implemented actions. Additionally,
emphasis is placed on the current state of cooperation between social and political
actors, and the trends in civil participation in the decision-making process regarding
decentralization and local governance reform in Ukraine.
This document discusses how illiberal democracy in Hungary from 2010-2014 negatively influenced the effectiveness of lobbying control in the country. It defines key terms like lobbying, interest groups, and liberal vs illiberal democracy. Illiberal democracies differ from liberal democracies in that they do not strictly follow the rule of law, lack independent oversight of the government, have more corrupt political elites, less free media, and do not fully protect civil rights and minorities. The document analyzes how Hungary met the criteria of an illiberal democracy during this period and repealed its lobbying law, diminishing transparency and accountability in the lobbying process.
The article is based on an analysis of national and European legal acts,
documents and source literature and its aim is to describe education and information
in consumer policy in Poland. The protection of consumer rights within the scope
of information and education is presented as a prime objective of the consumer policy strategy of the European Union and government programs of consumer policy
in Poland. Certain aspects of information and education policy of the government
are investigated, which are included in the Consumer Policy Strategy 2014–2018.
The competencies of consumer authorities in the institutional context are thoroughly
discussed in terms of education and information in Poland. Moreover, the consumer
identity of information and education policy between Poland and the European Union
is indicated.
Agrarianism was founded in Germany in the second half of the nineteenth
century, but it exercised the greatest influence in the predominantly agricultural countries of Central and Eastern Europe. Central European agrarianism was the ideology
of peasants and it proclaimed that land was the greatest wealth of the nation, agriculture was the most important branch of economy, and peasants were the morally
healthiest and thus the most valuable part of the society. Agrarianism was a personalist
ideology, which proclaimed a conception of man as a subject of social and economic
life. It criticized both extreme liberalism and totalitarian political ideology and advocated the concept of a ‘third way of development’ – between capitalism and communism. The main purpose of this paper is to analyze the formation and development
of Polish agrarianism, and the related process of transfer and reception of knowledge.
The analysis focuses on the concept of land, man and labor, formulated by the representatives of the mainstream of agrarianism. In the 1930s, the Polish agrarians voiced
demands for land reform and the development of smallholder agriculture which, in
their opinion, made an optimal use of the land, capital and labor, that is, the most
important resources available to interwar Poland.
Using a proprietary computer program, simulations of voting in the Council
after Great Britain’s withdrawal from the EU were carried out. In the case of some of
them, a methodological innovation consisting in departing from the assumption that
the emergence of each possible coalition is equally probable was used. The analysis
conducted indicates that after Brexit the ability of the Council members to form small
minimally blocking coalitions will change significantly. At the same time, the assessment of the ability of states to block decisions in the Council and made on the basis
of the Preventive Power Index, differs fundamentally from the results of the analysis
focusing on building small minimally blocking coalitions.
This research is funded by the National Science Centre, Poland, under project no.
UMO-2016/23/D/HS5/00408 (SONATA 12 grant) entitled “The Impact of Brexit and
Unconditional Introduction of the ‘Double Majority’ Voting System on DecisionMaking in the Council of the European Union.”
Teoretycy i praktycy storytellingu koncentrują się zazwyczaj na formalnych właściwościach przekazu, upatrując klucza do jego perswazyjnej skuteczności w realizacji strukturalnych cech opowiadania. Niniejszy artykuł kładzie natomiast
nacisk na poznawczy aspekt relacji komunikat-odbiorca, upatrując w nim ważnego
czynnika determinującego siłę perswazyjnego oddziaływania storytellingu. W pierwszej części tekst analizuje psychologiczne przesłanki skuteczności perswazyjnej narracyjnego komunikatu. Część kolejna stanowi teoretyczną propozycję w jaki sposób
zwiększyć skuteczność jego oddziaływania, uwzględniając budowę, właściwości
i funkcje schematów poznawczych oraz w oparciu o model poznawczych reakcji na
perswazję.
The author examines the nexus between international law and the concept
of human security that emerged in the 1990s. The article proceeds in three parts. Part
one outlines the concept of human security, its genesis and contents. Part two examines the nexus between human security and international law and briefly considers the
most representative aspects of international law, including international jurisprudence,
that, in the author’s opinion, reflect human security imperatives. Finally, conclusions
provide answers to the questions posed and indicate the increased value of the human
security concept. The questions read as follows: How can human security strengthen
international actions (actions based on international law)? Where in international law
is human security reflected? In other words, what aspects of international law reflect
a human security-centered approach? What is the role of international law in human
security? Taking all this into account, what is the added value of adopting the concept
of human security? This article is inevitably interdisciplinary, as it combines the perspectives of international law and international relations.
Najważniejszą barierą rozwoju małych i średnich przedsiębiorstw
(MŚP) jest ograniczony dostęp do źródeł finansowania. W fazie startu wykorzystują
one zwykle środki własne, rodziny i przyjaciół. Następnie zaś sięgają one po kredyt bankowy, którego otrzymanie jest trudne ze względu na brak historii finansowej,
gwarancji i ekonomiczną ich słabość. Nieliczne mogą korzystać z grantów rządowych i wsparcia międzynarodowych organizacji (np. Unii Europejskiej). Pomocnymi mogą być alternatywne źródła finansowania takie jak venture capital, mezzanine,
crowdfunding, emisja obligacji oraz publiczna emisja akcji (Initial Public Offering:
IPO). Ten ostatnio wymieniony sposób finansowania może przynieść znaczne korzyści dla MŚP; umocnić ich pozycję rynkową i umożliwić ekonomiczną ekspansję, ale
związany jest z wieloma barierami. Do najważniejszych należą trudność spełnienia
kryteriów notowania na giełdzie lub specjalnych platformach, nawet jeśli są one łagodniejsze niż dla dużych firm, wysokie koszty, brak wiedzy o rynku kapitałowym
i niska płynność akcji MŚP. Dlatego niezbędne jest podjęcie przez rządy, organizacje
międzynarodowe i krajowe oraz interesariuszy działań zmierzających do likwidacji
lub ograniczenia tych barier.
Dyskusje i badania polskiego członkostwa w strefie euro są w obecnych, dynamicznie zmieniających się warunkach obarczone dużą dozą niepewności,
stąd ograniczać się mogą jedynie do kreślenia scenariuszy. Niniejsze opracowanie
skupia się na aspektach gospodarczych decyzji o: 1) definitywnej rezygnacji z wprowadzenia wspólnej waluty w Polsce, 2) szybkiej akcesji do strefy euro oraz 3) odsunięciu w czasie udziału Polski w tej strefie. Każdy z wariantów rodzi inne skutki polityczno-ekonomiczne i tym samym wyznacza inne ścieżki długookresowego rozwoju
polskiej gospodarki.
Artykuł prezentuje wyniki badań nad traumą społeczno-kulturową
w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej. Do weryfikacji teorii traumy zostały wykorzystane reprezentatywne dane sondażowe z Białorusi, Bułgarii, Węgier, Rumunii, Polski,
Rosji i Ukrainy. Prowadzone analizy pokazały, że społeczeństwo postkomunistyczne
negatywnie oceniło zmiany systemu gospodarczego i politycznego. Źródłem traumy był spadek poziomu życia oraz wzrost przestępczości. Respondenci uważali, że
w wyniku transformacji stracili na zmianach i pod wpływem powstałej traumy pesymistycznie oceniali przyszłość. Rekcją na pojawiającą się traumę była nostalgia za
socjalizmem i bezpieczeństwem społecznym przezeń oferowanym. Czynnikami łagodzącymi szok w społeczeństwie postkomunistycznym było wykształcenie, młodszy
wiek i orientacja proeuropejska.
Zasadniczym celem artykułu jest przybliżenie prób reformy systemu
wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy podejmowanych w okresie przypadającym
po Euromajdanie. Analizie zostały poddane rozwiązania prawne zawarte w zarejestrowanych i poddanych pod głosowanie w parlamencie projektach ordynacji wyborczych. Przybliżono także stanowisko poszczególnych sił politycznych wobec potrzeby reformy systemu wyborczego, na co pozwoliła analiza programów wyborczych,
zapisów umowy koalicyjnej zawartej w RN VIII kadencji, jak również wyników
głosowania nad poszczególnymi projektami ustaw w parlamencie. Ponadto uwaga
została skupiona na wynikach badań opinii publicznej, pozwalających ukazać, który
z wariantów systemu wyborczego jest najbardziej pożądany przez ukraińskie społeczeństwo.
Mołdawia jest państwem, które z jednej strony podejmuje wysiłki
zmierzające ku demokratyzacji i europeizacji jej systemu politycznego i prawnego,
z drugiej – działania te są chaotyczne, brak im konsekwencji i są uwarunkowane
bieżącą sytuacją polityczną. Jednym z obszarów podlegających takim politycznym
przesileniom jest samorząd terytorialny. Cele artykułu są dwojakie: po pierwsze, periodyzacja i charakterystyka kolejnych etapów kształtowania się modelu samorządu
lokalnego w Mołdawii, po drugie – charakterystyka aktualnie obowiązujących rozwiązań i wskazanie podstawowych problemów istotnie wpływających na jego funkcjonowanie.
More from Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne (20)
Here is Gabe Whitley's response to my defamation lawsuit for him calling me a rapist and perjurer in court documents.
You have to read it to believe it, but after you read it, you won't believe it. And I included eight examples of defamatory statements/
13062024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
Find Latest India News and Breaking News these days from India on Politics, Business, Entertainment, Technology, Sports, Lifestyle and Coronavirus News in India and the world over that you can't miss. For real time update Visit our social media handle. Read First India NewsPaper in your morning replace. Visit First India.
CLICK:- https://firstindia.co.in/
#First_India_NewsPaper
Essential Tools for Modern PR Business .pptxPragencyuk
Discover the essential tools and strategies for modern PR business success. Learn how to craft compelling news releases, leverage press release sites and news wires, stay updated with PR news, and integrate effective PR practices to enhance your brand's visibility and credibility. Elevate your PR efforts with our comprehensive guide.
Youngest c m in India- Pema Khandu BiographyVoterMood
Pema Khandu, born on August 21, 1979, is an Indian politician and the Chief Minister of Arunachal Pradesh. He is the son of former Chief Minister of Arunachal Pradesh, Dorjee Khandu. Pema Khandu assumed office as the Chief Minister in July 2016, making him one of the youngest Chief Ministers in India at that time.
Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies of the President of the Republic of Poland after 1989
1. DOI 10.14746/ssp.2018.3.9
Magdalena Lorenc
Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań
Michał Mikołajczak
Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń
Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies
of the President of the Republic of Poland
after 1989
“Rational thought could not create rituals whose seriousness
could be comparable to the seriousness of rituals associated
with beliefs that have lost their credibility.”
Edward Shils, Ritual and Crisis, London, p. 449.
Abstract: The text analyzes the mutual relations between the liturgy of sacraments
and the most solemn state ceremony in the Republic of Poland, that of swearing-in of
the Head of State. Although the latter ceremony is secular, its antecedence should be
sought in the religious aspects of the enthronement of European rulers in the Middle
Ages. These references make the swearing-in an object of study combining theology
and political science. They invite questions about the relation between the religious
imagination of a given national community and its political organization as embod-
ied in state ceremonies. The candidate who wins the presidential elections becomes
the President of the Polish Republic after their victory is announced by the National
Electoral Commission, and after the Supreme Court confirms validity of this result.
However, they remain President-Elect until they utter the words of the oath. There-
fore, the swearing-in is a public ritual regulated by law which needs to be completed
in order to formally commence exercise of the office. The oath, which is spelled out in
the Constitution and delivered by the newly elected Head of State, has a performative
nature, similar to liturgical formulas. Additionally, it comprises an optional reference
to God as witness to the oath delivered. Therefore, the presidential oath is a histori-
cally conditioned testimony to public authority, referring to the realm of the sacred.
Key words: ceremony, swearing in of the Head of State, liturgy, ritual
Introduction
The theatricalization of political life is a universal phenomenon. It in-
volves attributing the features of a spectacle to the public practices
2. 136 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
of power, which can be exemplified by state ceremonies. They take place
in a specific setting, according to a set scenario and with precise roles.
The most important celebration of this type in Poland is the inauguration
of the President, which consists of the following ceremonies: the swear-
ing-in, transfer of presidential insignia, taking over the authorities over
the armed forces and the official welcome to the presidential residence.
They are regulated by both law and custom. Particularly important dur-
ing the inauguration is the swearing-in, the oath of which was enacted in
the Constitution of the Republic of Poland of April 2, 1997. Uttering this
oath before the combined chambers of the Sejm and the Senate is a pre-
requisite, and the initial turning-point as the newly elected head of state
begins to carry out their duties. This distinguishes the swearing-in from
other inaugural ceremonies. The uniqueness of this ceremony also results
from references to Christian religious practices, making it the subject of
research of both theology and political science. In it, the liturgy of the
sacraments of the Catholic Church is echoed, understood as the order of
worship which consists of specific words, gestures and context.
The aim of the current paper is to analyze the mutual ties between
the liturgy of the sacraments, for example of the rite of baptism, and the
most important state ceremony of the Third Republic. The basic research
questions concern the sources and significance of liturgical references of
the swearing-in ceremony of Polish presidents elected after 1989, includ-
ing Lech Wałęsa (December 22, 1990), Aleksander Kwaśniewski (De-
cember 23, 1995, December 23, 2000), Lech Kaczyński (December 23,
2005), Bronisław Komorowski (August 6, 2010) and Andrzej Duda (Au-
gust 6, 2015).
For the elaboration on the subject, historical and legal analyses by
Grzegorz Maroń were particularly helpful, as they discussed the sig-
nificance of the head of state’s oath in Polish fundamental acts of law.
In addition, Arnold van Gennep’s concepts of rites of passage and John
Langshaw Austin’s notions of performatives were used. While the former
served to show the differences between the liturgy and the swearing-in,
the latter made it possible to find an analogy between them. In the case
of baptism, there are three stages of change in the status of the person
undergoing the ritual, which cannot be demonstrated in the swearing-in
ceremony. At the same time, the trinitarian formula and the wording of
the oath, fulfilling the conditions necessary for a successful performative,
bear performative value – purify from sin (baptism), and elect the presi-
dent (swearing-in).
3. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 137
Theological understanding of liturgy
The word liturgy is of Greek provenance. Formed by connecting λαός
(people) and Vργον – (deed) – λειτουργια1
originally meant any public
activity, including organization of games and festivals, sending legates or
launching ships (Nadolski, 1989, p. 9). The understanding of the liturgy,
adopted from Greek, was narrowed down in ancient Rome to cult activi-
ties associated with worshipping gods. In the Bible, liturgy as a derivative
of the Greek root, and the Hebrew forms (sheret and aboad) was applied
to Tanakh rituals.2
The Latin term liturgica was used for the first time
by Georg Cassander in 1558 (Nadolski, 1989, p. 1). At that time, it con-
cerned only the Holy Mass, while with time it would be extended to all
the celebrated mysteries.
Nowadays, the term liturgy is understood in the Catholic Church as
the entire public worship directed to God and anamnetic in nature. This
means that the events remembered during the liturgy ‘make themselves
present;’that is, they are treated by believers as currently happening. Such
was the position of the Second Vatican Pastoral Council of December 4,
1963 expressed in the Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy (CL), according
to which the liturgy is regarded as “an exercise of the priestly office of
Jesus Christ. In it, visible signs are expressed and in a manner appropriate
for particular signs, the sanctification of man takes place, and the Mysti-
cal Body of Jesus Christ, that is, the Head with its members, exercises
full public worship. From this it follows that every liturgical celebration,
because it is an action of Christ the priest and of His Body which is the
Church, is a sacred action surpassing all others; no other action of the
Church can equal its efficacy by the same title and to the same degree”
(CL, point 7).
Antecedents of liturgical practices can be mainly found in classical
theater and court ceremonies (Paprocki, 2007). Using the knowledge of
Greek theater, the early-medieval Christian communities performed short
plays, the subject of which were the events described in the Bible. This
1
Cf. the leiturgia entry in: Słownik grecko-polski, ed. by O. Jurewicz, Warszawa
2015, p. 578; also, liturgia in: Mała encyklopedia kultury antycznej, ed. by Z. Pisz-
czek, Warszawa 1988, p. 424.
2
In the Bible, the term liturgy is used to refer to tax collectors, persons provid-
ing material help and organizing the collection of gifts for poor Christians (see, e.g.,
Romans 13:26). The liturgy also refers to the public spiritual worship in the New
Testament (see, e.g., Hebrews 8:2–6).
4. 138 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
was to facilitate the mission of evangelization and to serve didactic pur-
poses, just as later Bibliae pauperum.Aseparate practice derived from the
theater was the liturgical drama which assisted the Church up to the Coun-
cil of Trent (1545–1563). This concept was understood as all activities
that had the features of a stage work and were subordinated to the liturgy
(cf. Wolański, 2005, pp. 7–8). When writing drama scripts, authors used
the Bible, homilies, legends, apocrypha, responsories and other sources.
The actors were mostly priests, with clerics or monks, and the liturgical
dramas were adapted to the calendar of religious holidays. For example,
performances related to the passion and death of Jesus Christ were per-
formed in Lent, especially during the Holy Week. In this way, “the church
adopted the theater, offering it its biblical content, philosophy, mysticism,
props, interior, word and music. The theater enriched the liturgical rite
with spectacularity, drama and beauty” (Towarek, 2008, p. 111).
The court ceremonial, both in its expanded Byzantine version and the
more modest Roman one, provided the patterns of behavior in the pres-
ence of the ruler which per analogiam would be useful during the Eucha-
rist celebrated in persona Christi. This influence was visible especially
in the liturgy with the participation of the Pope, who until Vatican II was
dressed in a special outfit, shoes and gloves, and wore a tiara on his head.
He did not move independently but was brought to Saint Peter’s Basilica
in a litter, with the sound of trumpets, “among feather fans and a large,
colorful group of lay people and prelates... and representatives of nobility
and Roman patricians, various guard corps and other dignitaries of the
papal court. This was about a ceremonial entrance which gave the pope
the appearance of the prince of this world surrounded by his own court”
(Marini, 2007, p. 76).
Meanwhile, the first half of the twentieth century, with the tragedy of
two world wars and the beginning of the cold-war rivalry between the
East and the West, led to social and cultural changes, the consequences
of which the Church was not spared. Their manifestation was dynami-
cally developing ecclesiological thought which influenced, among others,
a new perception of the liturgy. The encyclical Mediator Dei et Hominum
of November 20, 1947, by Pius XII, together with a grassroots movement
for the renewal of the liturgy, was an important voice on the road to its
simplification which was reflected in the documents of the Second Vatican
Council. It was decided then that “[t]he rite of the Mass is to be revised
in such a way that the intrinsic nature and purpose of its several parts, as
also the connection between them, may be more clearly manifested, and
5. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 139
that devout and active participation by the faithful may be more easily
achieved. For this purpose, the rites are to be simplified, due care being
taken to preserve their substance; elements which, with the passage of
time, came to be duplicated, or were added with but little advantage, are
now to be discarded” (CL, point 50).
The “simplification” of the liturgy concerned not only the Eucharist,
but also other sacraments which “[...] are efficacious signs of grace, insti-
tuted by Christ and entrusted to the Church [...]. The visible rites by which
the sacraments are celebrated signify and make present the graces proper
to each sacrament. They bear fruit in those who receive them with the
required dispositions” (CCC 1131). There are seven of them: Baptism,
Confirmation, Eucharist, Penance, Anointing of the Sick, Holy Orders,
and Matrimony.
The definition contained in the Catechism indicates the special role
of the sacraments in the liturgical life of the Catholic community. In the
opinion of believers, when sacraments are granted, the receiver changes
their status. An example of this is the baptism, which means incorpora-
tion into the community through purification of sins. Its validity requires
pronouncing the baptismal formula: “... (name), I baptize you in the name
of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.” These words are
a quote from the Gospel of Matthew, according to which Christ com-
manded his disciples to go and teach all nations, “baptizing them in the
name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit” (Mt 28:19).
Recalling the Trinity in the trinitarian formula means its presence and
uniting the baptized person with it. For the efficacy of the sacrament, it
is also necessary to use clean water in a gesture of washing the body or
its part (the head). Both activities are the focal point of the celebration of
the sacrament of Baptism. Limiting the ritual to them alone is, however,
rare and concerns special circumstances, for instance when the life of the
baptized person is threatened. In other cases, the rite of the sacrament is
more elaborate. Because children are most often baptized, their parents or
guardians make the decision, bring the child to church and express – on
their behalf – the wish for baptism. A steward, who is the person entitled
to administer a sacrament, introduces the parents or guardians together
with the child to the church. Next, an exorcism is pronounced over the
child, accompanied by the steward’s gesture of the hand. In this way,
they ask for release from the power of sin and for the grace of living with
Jesus Christ. Another element of the liturgy of the baptismal sacrament
is the profession of faith and the obligation of parents or guardians to
6. 140 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
raise the child in the faith of the Catholic Church. After the confession
of faith comes the moment of proper baptism, that is the utterance of the
trinitarian formula and pouring of water on the head. It symbolizes the in-
clusion of a new member into the Catholic (and more broadly, Christian)
community. The subsequent rites are ‘explanatory’and include: anointing
with consecrated oils – consisting in making the sign of the cross with
a finger immersed in a mixture of balm and oil, putting on white garments
and lighting a candle. During each of these activities, the steward prays
aloud, which makes it possible to understand the meaning of individual
gestures. The anointing with the oils is evidence of purification from sin.
Putting on a white gown proves the state of cleanliness, while lighting
of the candle from the paschal candle symbolizes receiving light from
Christ. An indispensable part of the ritual is the participation of one or
two godparents, and optionally also a witness or witnesses to the bap-
tism, who do not replace the godparent (cf. Code of Canon Law, 874 § 2).
The baptized person is treated as newborn, and not burdened with sin.
Baptism is, therefore, an example of a rite of passage. According to the
concept of Arnold van Gennep, it involves a change in the status of the
person concerned (Gennep, 2006, p. 37). The passage has three stages:
preliminal (separation), liminal (transitional) and post-liminal (incorpora-
tion) (Gennep, 2006, p. 45).3
Observance of the order of the ritual, includ-
ing the formulas used, utensils and division of roles, reduces the anxiety
accompanying the change and constitutes the conditions for the effective-
ness of the ritual. Its phatic power consists in transforming reality, and not
only in registering or confirming change.
The celebration of the liturgy of the sacraments was and still is a model
for other public celebrations, including state ceremonies. As Ernst Wolf-
gang Böckenförde pointed out, “for thousands of years, thinking and the-
ories of the political order in society have been associated with religious
imaginations, and in Christian times – also theological ones” (Böcken-
förde, 2005–2006, p. 301). The manifestation of the fact that “Christianity
has left an indelible mark on the European culture” (Gołembski, 2008,
p. 199) and significantly influenced the formation of symbolic space (of
which culture and especially political culture is a part4
), are state ceremo-
3
More on this topic also in: E. Leach, A. J. Greimas, Rytuał i narracja, Warszawa
1989 and V. W. Turner, Proces rytualny. Struktura i antystruktura, Warszawa 2010.
4
More on the relationship between the symbolic space and culture in the context
of Christian roots in Europe can be found in: M. Gierycz, Chrześcijaństwo i Unia
Europejska. Rola religii w procesie integracji europejskiej, Warszawa–Kraków 2008;
7. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 141
nies. The genesis of religious inspirations of state ceremonies is the after-
math of the Middle Ages, when politics was “one of the forms of religious
communities’activity in achieving their goals, and the distinction between
secular and religious authority did not exist” (Gierycz, 2008, p. 26).
The most important state ceremony
The swearing-in of the newly elected head of state is part of the in-
auguration of the presidency, and the most important state ceremony in
Poland. It consists in saying the words of the oath, in accordance with
the pattern set out by law, before the relevant auditorium. Among the
highest representatives of state power, apart from the President, an oath
is taken by the President, Vice-President, and Members of the Council of
Ministers. However, because the mandate of the head of state comes from
general elections, it makes it stronger than the other organs of the execu-
tive, including prime ministers and ministers.5
The legal basis for the political position of the president is the Con-
stitution of the Republic of Poland of April 2, 1997, according to which
he or she takes office after uttering before the National Assembly an oath
with the following wording: “By taking the office of the President of the
Republic of Poland by the will of the Nation, I solemnly swear that I will
be faithful to the provisions of the Constitution, I will steadfastly protect
the dignity of the Nation, independence and security of the State, and the
well-being of my citizens will always be the highest command for me.”
The oath may finish with the phrase “So help me God” (Article 130).
Over the 25 years between the inaugurations of Presidents Wałęsa
in 1990 and Duda in 2015, the text of the written and spoken oath has
slightly evolved. The basic difference concerned the constitution, which
F. Gołembski, Cywilizacja europejska, Warszawa 2012; idem, Jedność europejska,
Warszawa 2006; J. Kłoczkowski, Europa – chrześcijańskie korzenie, Warszawa
2004.
5
More on this topic also in: D. Górecki, Wpływ polskich tradycji ustrojowych
na współczesne rozwiązania konstytucyjne, in: Konstytucyjne systemy rządów, ed.
M. Domagała, Warszawa 1997; R. Mojak, Instytucja Prezydenta RP w świetle nowej
Konstytucji, “Państwo i Prawo” 1997, 11–12; R. Mojak, Pozycja ustrojowa i struktu-
ra władzy wykonawczej. Problematyka stosunków między prezydentem a rządem, in:
Ustrój i struktura aparatu państwowego i samorządu terytorialnego, ed. W. Skrzydło,
Warszawa 1997; R. Mojak, Władza wykonawcza w Konstytucji RP, in: Ustrój konsty-
tucyjny Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, Wyd. UMCS, Lublin 2000.
8. 142 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
the new president swore to be faithful to, and the appeal to God as a help
in fulfilling the obligation. Lech Wałęsa swore on the Constitution of the
Republic of Poland, being the amended Constitution of the Polish Peo-
ple’s Republic of July 22, 1952. During his first inauguration, Aleksander
Kwaśniewski swore on the Constitutional Act of October 17, 1992 on
the mutual relations between the legislative and executive power of the
Republic of Poland and local government (the so-called Small Constitu-
tion). His second oath, as well as the ceremonies of successive presidents:
Kaczyński, Komorowski and Duda, included swearing on the Constitu-
tion of the Republic of Poland of April 2, 1997.
The oath pronounced by the first President of the Third Republic6
elected in equal, free and universal elections, read: “Embracing the office
of the President of the Republic of Poland, I swear solemnly to the Polish
Nation that I will be true to the provisions of the Constitution, and I will
steadfastly guard the dignity of the Nation, the sovereignty and security
of the state. I vow that the good of the Homeland and the well-being of
citizens will always be the highest command for me” (Art. 32(c)). The
oath of Lech Wałęsa was introduced by the Act of April 7, 1989 on the
amendment of the Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic, and took
into account subsequent amendments, including: the Act of December 29,
1989 on the change of the Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic,
in which the name of the state, “Polish People’s Republic,” was amended
to “Republic of Poland,” as well as the Act of September 27, 1990 on the
election of the President of the Republic of Poland, under which the elec-
tion of the head of state was no longer done by the National Assembly.
When uttering the oath, at the end Lech Wałęsa added “So help me
God.” This was a deviation from the formula required by law, and at the
same time a reference to the tradition of the Second Polish Republic. Spe-
cifically, according to the Constitution of March 17, 1921, the words of
the oath were: “I swear to the Almighty God, One in the Holy
Trinity, and I vow to you, the Polish nation, in the office of the Presi-
6
Lech Wałęsa assumed the office of the President of the Republic of Poland af-
ter Wojciech Jaruzelski who had been elected by the National Assembly under the
amended Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic and sworn in as President of
the Polish People’s Republic on July 19, 1989. On December 31, 1989, with the entry
into force of the regulation introducing a new nomenclature of state offices, the office
he held was renamed as President of the Republic of Poland. This office was held by
Jaruzelski until the end of the term of office, namely until December 22, 1990 when
the oath was taken by the president elected in the general election.
9. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 143
dent of the Republic which I am assuming: the rights of the Republic
and, above all, the Constitutional Law, to honor and defend; the universal
good of the Nation to serve faithfully with all my strength; all evil and
danger from you, to turn away watchfully; the dignity of the Polish name
to protect unwaveringly; justice for all without distinction to have as the
first virtue; and to sacrifice to the duties of office and service. So help me
God and the Holy Passion of His Son. Amen [emphasis
– ML]” (Article 54).
A similar solution was applied in the Constitution of April 23, 1935,
which featured the following oath: “Aware of the responsibility towards
G o d and history for the fate of the State, I swear to the Almighty
God, One in the Holy Trinity, at the office of the President of
the Republic to protect State sovereignty, protect State dignity, apply the
constitutional law, be guided by justice towards all citizens, avert evil and
danger from the State, and care for its good as my chief duty. So help me
God and the Holy Passion of His Son. Amen [emphasis
– ML]” (Article 19).
The pre-war oaths contained, thus, references to transcendence. Both
cases, however, did not concern an abstract being, but the Christian God
in his three hypostases: God the Father, the Son of God and the Holy
Spirit. The legislator, taking into account the dominance of the Catholic
religion among the citizens of the Second Republic, simultaneously did
not take into account the possible lack of any denomination, or different
faith of the president. Thus, according to the records, on December 11,
1922, the first president of free Poland Gabriel Narutowicz uttered the
complete oath, regardless of his Freemason views. After the one-person
institution of the head of state was restored to the Polish constitutional
order,7
which took place under the Act of April 7, 1989 on the amendment
of the Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic, four of five presidents
of the Third Republic elected in free elections before 2015 ended their
oath with an appeal to God. The exception was Aleksander Kwaśniewski
who during the swearing-in for his first term repeated the oath recorded
7
More on this topic also in: M. Chmaj, Sejm „kontraktowy” w transformacji
systemu politycznego Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, Wyd. UMCS, Lublin 1996; P. Sar-
necki, Prezydent jako organ czuwający nad przestrzeganiem Konstytucji, “Państwo
i Prawo” 1990, 11; W. Sokolewicz, Kwietniowa zmiana Konstytucji, “Państwo i Pra-
wo” 1989 6; W. Skrzydło, Przemiany polityczno-ustrojowe w Polsce na przełomie
lat osiemdziesiątych i dziewięćdziesiątych, in: Prawo konstytucyjne, ed. W. Skrzydło,
Lublin 1996.
10. 144 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
in the Small Constitution, as follows: “By taking the office of President
of the Republic of Poland by the will of the Nation, I solemnly swear that
I will be faithful to the provisions of the Constitution, I will steadfastly
protect the dignity of the Nation, independence and security of the State,
and that the good of the Homeland and the well-being of citizens will
always be my highest command” (Article 30(1)). Therefore, he resigned
from the appeal to God, foreseen as optional in this act, and did the same
during his swearing-in for a second term, which took place under the con-
ditions of the Constitution of 1997, which also provided for voluntariness
in this respect.
The swearing-in ceremonies of presidents Kaczyński, Komorowski
and Duda, did not differ in formal terms and had as their basis the same
wording of the oath, in each case with the added appeal to God. However,
the ceremony was not free from errors. Bronisław Komorowski used the
word “dobrość” instead of “dobro,” i.e. “goodness” instead of “good,”
which aroused the doubts of some of his opponents. They accused the
newly elected president of not fulfilling the obligation to take the oath in
accordance with the constitutional model, and that consequently he had
no right to perform his function. To support this argument, the example of
Barack Obama was quoted, when he confused the order of the words of
the oath during his swearing-in ceremony as 44th
President of the United
States, on January 20, 2009. It was due to a mistake by the President of
the Supreme Court, John Roberts, after whom the President repeated the
words. In this situation it was decided the oath would be taken once again,
although at the same time the validity of the first ceremony was empha-
sized. Unlike the American President, however, Bolesław Komorowski
decided not to repeat the oath.
Pursuant to the Act of January 5, 2011 (Election Code), the result of
the presidential election is stated by the National Electoral Commission
(NEC) by way of a resolution which is forwarded immediately to the
Speaker of the Sejm, the acting president and newly elected head of state
(Article 317). The Commission’s announcement is subject to publication
in the Journal of Laws. From the moment the presidential election results
are made public, it is possible to submit an electoral protest before the
Supreme Court (SC) within 14 days. The Court ultimately decides on
the validity of the election and adopts a resolution in this matter within
30 days. It is presented promptly to the Speaker of the Sejm, sent to the
National Electoral Commission and announced in the Journal of Laws.
At the same time, neither the Constitution currently in force nor the Elec-
11. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 145
tion Code, specify the number of days from the moment the resolution is
passed by the Supreme Court until the day the oath is taken. This is not
exceptional; starting from 1990 the date of taking office of the President
of the Republic of Poland was more often dictated by custom than by
statutory regulations. However, it should not be understood that the law
did not stipulate the initial and final day of the term of the president, but
only that in most legal acts the number of days between the date of the
resolution of the Supreme Court and the date of the swearing-in was not
specified.
Table 1
The dates of the announcement of the presidential election results
by the National Electoral Commission (NEC), the issuance of a resolution
confirming the validity of elections by the Supreme Court (SN)
and the swearing-in of the newly elected head of state, after 1989
President
The date of the an-
nouncement of the
result by NEC
The date of the resolu-
tion issued by the SC
The date of the
swearing-in
Lech Wałęsa December 10, 1990 December 22, 1990 (va-
lidity declared by the Na-
tional Assembly)
December 22, 1990
Aleksander
Kwaśniewski
(first term)
November 20, 1995 December 9, 1995 December 23, 1995
Aleksander
Kwaśniewski
(second term)
October 9, 2000 November 6, 2000 December 23, 2000
Lech Kaczyński October 24, 2005 November 23, 2005 December 23, 2005
Bronisław
Komorowski
July 5, 2010 August 3, 2010 August 6, 2010
Andrzej Duda May 25, 2015 June 23, 2015 August 6, 2015
Source: Own work [M.L.].
Lech Wałęsa took the oath on the last day of office of the outgoing
head of state, within 7 days from the day on which the election was con-
firmed. Meanwhile, Aleksander Kwaśniewski, taking the office of Presi-
dent for the first time, took the oath the day after the expiration of the
predecessor’s term; the only time such a situation occurred in the Third
Republic. Another set of exceptional circumstances characterized the in-
auguration of Bronisław Komorowski, who took office as a result of ac-
celerated elections after the death of Lech Kaczyński in the plane crash
12. 146 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
of April 10, 2010. In his case, the period from the confirmation of the
validity of the election by the NEC to the moment of the swearing-in
was the shortest, and amounted to three days. The remaining presidents
participated in the ceremony on the day the predecessors’ office ended.
Aleksander Kwaśniewski waited the longest for the swearing-in ceremo-
ny (of his second term, as in the case of the first it was only two weeks).
Similarly to Andrzej Duda, he took the oath after approximately a month
and a half. Lech Kaczyński was sworn in a month after the validity of the
election was confirmed.
Taking of the oath is a prerequisite for taking office, and also marks
the beginning of the new president’s term of office and the end of the
predecessor’s office. The ceremony takes place in the Sejm. The invited
guests are, among others, the outgoing President and their spouse, the act-
ing Prime Minister and ministers, representatives of the most important
institutions, former Speakers of Parliament and Prime Ministers, mem-
bers of the Diplomatic Corps, representatives of churches and religious
associations, and journalists. The heads of the Chancellery of the Sejm
and Senate as well as the Speakers of the Sejm and the Senate welcome
the President-Elect and their spouse to the Sejm.
The session starts in the morning hours, usually at 10:00 am. The ses-
sions of the combined chambers of the Sejm and the Senate are chaired
by the Speaker of the Sejm, while additional services are provided by the
Chancellery of the Sejm. The Speaker of the Sejm heads at the presidium
table and has the Speaker of the Senate to the left. The guests stand up,
while the newly elected head of state enters in the company of their clos-
est family members and co-workers. The Speaker opens the proceedings
and strikes three times with the Speaker’s staff, and then welcomes both
the newly elected and the resigning president together with their accom-
panying persons, as well as guests and members of the Assembly. The
Speaker appoints two secretaries – a senator and an MP and indicates
the MP as the clerk. Further, the Speaker of the Sejm turns to the newly
elected president with a request to take the oath. The presidential couple
approaches the presidential table, and the Speaker asks the President to
repeat the oath after them. Afterwards, the Speaker of the Sejm declares
that the President has uttered the oath prescribed by law before the Na-
tional Assembly, after which the Polish anthem is played. Following that,
the Speaker congratulates the President on their election, wishes them
good luck and asks them to speak. The President makes an address, while
the guests are sitting. When they finish their speech, the Speaker of the
13. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 147
Sejm asks the secretary who has been recording the session to read the
minutes out and then asks the members of the Assembly if there are any
objections to the minutes. In the absence of objections, they announce
the acceptance of the minutes and close the debate by striking three times
with the Speaker’s staff. After approximately 30 minutes, the ceremony
comes to an end.
After leaving the session chamber, it is time for farewells to the out-
going head of state, visiting the parliamentary cabinet and the meeting of
the President with the conventions of seniors of the Sejm and the Senate.
These elements are of courteous character and depend on the individual
preferences of the new head of state, as well as on the circumstances.
Due to the lack of clearly distinguished stages of separation, liminal-
ity and incorporation, the swearing-in ceremony does not meet Gennep’s
criteria for a rite of passage. This stems mainly from the inability to rec-
ognize the period of being an elect as a transient state, even though there
is such a state in the colloquial sense. In cultural anthropology, however,
this is not enough, because the immanent feature of the liminal phase is
the suspension of the existing order, including the moral norms in force,
in relation to the person subjected to the ritual. It is impossible to see this
in relation to the president-elect who is elected and whose choice has
been legally confirmed, but they have not yet formally taken the position.
Although the custom is that they change their place of residence for the
period between the announcement of election results and the swearing-in,
this is not a sufficient condition to consider being elect as a liminal phase.
So far, the invitation to stay at the Przeździecki Palace, also known as the
Palace of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs was accepted by Aleksander
Kwaśniewski, Lech Kaczyński and Andrzej Duda.
Performativity of expression and divine sanction
A ceremony is “an official celebration or ritual, running according to
a set plan or ritual, [but also – ML] an act performed with seriousness and
attention to preserving conventions” (Słownik). This definition is derived
from colloquial language, and is far from the approach well-founded in
anthropology that requires the aspect of the sacrum (Émile Durkheim); it
is closer to the position of Mary Douglas, whose merit was the liberation
of rituals from religious affiliation, and giving them a wider symbolic
meaning. This allowed non-religious rituals, including political ones, to
14. 148 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
be called rituals (Churska-Nowak, 2009, p. 60; Churska-Nowak, Orylski,
2010, p. 64; Eller, 2012, p. 353; Filipowicz, 1998, p. 166). Although such
an attitude limited the semantic value of the concepts of ceremony, rite
and ritual, at the same time it decreased the risk of aporia resulting from
the use of rigid definitions of these activities (according to Durkheim,
Mauss or Hubert), none of which gained a canonical rank. The basic value
of such an approach consisted in avoiding an epistemological trap as a re-
sult of choosing one narrow definition – from a number of possible ones
– and treating it as a reliable criterion for the selection of social phenom-
ena. The only ordering procedure in this regard has been and remains the
use of the term liturgy in relation to religious practices, which excludes
speaking of the “liturgy of the swearing-in of the President of the Repub-
lic of Poland,” while using the terms ritual or ceremony in relation to the
sacraments.
The central point of the swearing-in ceremony is the utterance of the
oath by the president-elect. This is an analogous activity to the trinitarian
formula spoked by the steward during the baptism. Both these statements
are performative according to Austin, who stated that “to say something
means to do something” (2013, p. 561). Here, we deal not with a simple
statement on an event (observation), but rather a statement of a perfor-
mative nature, creating reality. For a performative to be successful, six
conditions must be met:
“(A.1) There must be a recognized conventional procedure with
a certain conventional effect: this procedure must involve the ex-
pression of certain words by certain persons in certain circum-
stances, whereby.
(A.2) individual persons and circumstances in a given case must
be appropriate for establishing a specific procedure.
(B.1) All participants must carry out the procedure both correctly
and
(B.2) fully.
(Γ.1) When, as it happens often, a given procedure is intended for
use by people who have certain thoughts and feelings (or to initi-
ate the participant’s certain subsequent behavior), then the partici-
pant, and thus the person who executes a given procedure, must
indeed harbor these thoughts and nurture these feelings, and the
intention of the participants must be to act in a given way. In ad-
dition,
(Γ.2) they are supposed to execute the deed in the future in the
same way” (Austin, 2013, pp. 563–564).
15. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 149
Failure to meet these conditions means that the performative violates
the felicity condition or is faulty. The violation of the conditions A or B
means that the intended activities are futile (fiascos), and of the conditions
Γ – that these activities are infelicitous and empty (and constitute abuse)
(Kałuszyńska, p. 3). Therefore, in order for a baptism and a swearing-in
to be effective, the spoken words must be consistent; in the first case, with
the adopted trinitarian formula, and in the second with the oath included in
the Constitution of the Republic of Poland. Only particular persons should
participate in the rite. The words are accompanied by gestures. How the
sign of the cross is made over the baptized person must correspond to the
liturgical ritual adopted in the given church. The same applies to fingers
folded in a gesture of oath and/or the hand laid on the constitution. Only
if these criteria are compatible with the convention is the performative
successful and triggers the effect desired by the participants.
Among the conditions of a successful performative, the intentionality
of the statement is also often mentioned. This is particularly evident in
the case of the presidential oath. By analogy with Austin’s promise, it is
right for the person who utters its words to have the will to keep it (Aus-
tin, 1993, p. 557). This stems also from the meaning of the word oath as
“a solemn commitment to fulfill certain obligations, to comply with cer-
tain rules,” as well as “the text of this commitment” (Słownik, 2018).8
In Polish language practice the word oath (Pl. przysięga) is used in-
terchangeably with vow (Pl. ślubowanie) (Słownik, 1984, vol. 2, pp. 1055
and vol. 3, p. 448). This raises doubts from the viewpoint of legal lan-
guage, in which an oath should refer to such a vow which is of a reli-
gious nature and – for example – begins with the words “I swear to the
Lord God Almighty” (Maroń, 2012b, pp. 126–127). At the same time, the
sacral context of the swearing-in may mean not only the spoken words,
but also the form of the ceremony. An example of this was the oath of al-
legiance to the monarch and loyalty of the state in the times of the First
Polish Republic.9
It was not uncommon to utter the oath in the kneeling
position, with the cross and the Gospel laid out (Maroń, 2012b, p. 127).
This practice did not only apply to the highest representatives of power,
8
Compare the terms przysięga and ślubowanie in: Słownik języka polskiego, ed.
M. Szymczak, Warszawa 1984, vol. 2, p. 1055–1056 and vol. 3, p. 448, 127.
9
More on this topic also in: J. Pietrzak, Senat Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. Tradycja
i współczesność XV–XXI w., Warszawa 2010; S. Ochmann-Staniszewska, Przysięga
marszałka poselskiego na sejmach lat 1648–1668, “Czasopismo Prawno-Historycz-
ne” 1995, vol. XVVII, iss. 1–2.
16. 150 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
but also to the deputies who swore on the Bible before going on a mis-
sion, promising to strictly follow the instructions given to them.
Most fully – due to the importance of the event – the influence of
religion could be seen in the case of the coronation of kings in the time
of the First Polish Republic. He swore on the Gospel and was crowned
by the primates, after they accepted the oath and anointed the king with
holy oils (Pietrzak, 2010, p. 37). This celebration was a portrayal of me-
dieval political theology, according to which a European monarch was of
double nature, both earthly and supernatural. One of them was mortal, as
the human body of a man, while the latter immortal as an idea; this was
exemplified by the cry of the French heralds: “The king is dead, long live
the king.” These two aspects of the monarch’s nature – “the two bodies
of the king” – resembled Christ per analogiam to his humanity and divin-
ity (Kantorowicz, 1957). The medieval ruler, as a result of the anointing
treated as a sacrament, was no longer an ordinary human (Baszkiewicz,
1998, p. 112). “The clericalization of power was closely related to the
sacralization of political life” (Gierycz, 2008, p. 29).10
It was only pro-
gressive secularization that made the King-Christ dualism give way to the
king as law, and finally the king as state, finding expression in the words
attributed to Louis XIV, “L’Etat, c’est moi.” This meant abandoning the
“Christocentric accents of the concept of royal power,” in favor of the
head of a secular community – a state that, equally with the Church, “is
treated as something immortal and lasting eternally” (Strzelczyk, 2007,
p. XX).
After regaining independence in 1918, the words of the presidential
oath recorded in both fundamental acts referred directly to Catholic dog-
mas. Both Gabriel Narutowicz, of no religious denomination (on Decem-
ber 11, 1922), and the declared Catholics Stanisław Wojciechowski (on
December 20, 1922) and Ignacy Mościcki (for the first time on June 4,
1926, for the second on May 9, 1933) appealed to “God Almighty, One in
the Holy Trinity.” Since the utterance of the oath in accordance with the
constitutional provisions was obligatory, the omission of the divine re-
cipient of the oath would invalidate it. Thus, the legislator did not foresee
the atheism, or other faith of the head of state, favoring Christians of the
Catholic denomination.At the same time, in the Constitution of March 17,
1921, a distinction was made between an oath and a vow. The presidential
10
More on this topic also in: Monarchia w średniowieczu, eds. J. Pysiak, A. Pie-
niądz-Skrzypczak, M. R. Pauk, Warszawa–Kraków 2002; P. Urbańczyk, Władza i po-
lityka we wczesnym średniowieczu, Wrocław 2000.
17. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 151
oath enshrined in it included the requirement to take an oath to God and
a vow to the Polish nation. However, it is difficult to say whether this was
dictated by the desire to avoid a stylistic error in the form of repetition,
or whether it was semantic purism that required an oath to be associated
with the sphere of sacrum.11
Oaths spoken by the highest representatives of state power in the
times of the First and Second Republic contained references to God as
the recipient, witness and help in the implementation of the oath. They
served to authenticate the commitment and were a manifestation of reli-
gious worship. Failure to keep the oath meant perjury, and therefore the
breaking of the second commandment of the Decalogue. It was an insult
to God, consisting in calling him a witness to lies, and included – on
the basis of canon law – among crimes against religion. If, on the other
hand, falsehood was to be the basis for legal classification, perjury meant
a crime against truth, justice or falsification (Syryjczyk, 1991, p. 122).
The condition, however, was that the oath be made by a believer. Mean-
while, passive suffrage in the presidential election in the Second Polish
Republic did not prescribe any religious denomination for the candidates.
Both fundamental acts promoted freedom in this regard and the separa-
tion of church from state. The oath of the newly elected president took
place before the National Assembly in the Sejm or in the Royal Castle.
It was sworn on the constitution, not the Bible (Witkowski, 1987, p. 33).
The religious references concerned only the content of the oath and the
fact that it was uttered next to a cross. However, this does not change the
fact that the legal obligation to take the oath to God could, and in the case
of Gabriel Narutowicz did, violate the freedom of conscience and reli-
gion, and therefore with the fundamental rights of the individual.
After the political transformation of the late 1980s and early 1990s,
the need to distinguish between oath and vow was not recognized. With
regard to the president-elect, the word oath was used in legal acts, de-
spite its secular content and form. This meant adopting the understand-
ing of this institution as per legal sciences, according to which an oath
is a “solemn, usually public and verbal promise of a particular way of
conduct, verbalized in words of officially defined content and sometimes
also submitted in a specific form” (Maroń, 2015, p. 52). Religious refer-
ences of the presidential oath were limited to the optional reference to
11
The presidential oath prescribed by the Constitution of 23 April, 1935 did not
include a vow to the Polish nation.
18. 152 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
God at the end of the formula and to the presence of the cross in the Sejm
sessions chamber. Thus, God was no longer the addressee or the witness
of the promise, and could be only a helper. Although the authors of the
Catechism of the Catholic Church stated that “discretion in calling upon
God is allied with a respectful awareness of his presence” (CCC 2153),
all the presidents-elects declaring their Catholic faith ended the oath with
the words “So help me God.”12
Conclusion
The swearing-in ceremony of the President of the Republic of Po-
land after 1989 features a number of references to the liturgy of the
sacraments in the Catholic Church. As with the sacraments, the status
of the person who participates in the ceremony is subject to change.
Although one becomes the President of the Republic of Poland as a re-
sult of electoral victory announced by the National Electoral Commis-
sion, which the Supreme Court affirms, without uttering the words of
the oath, the victor remains only a president-elect. Thus, swearing-in is
a legally regulated public ritual which must be completed in order to
formally begin the function. Written in the Constitution, and uttered by
the newly elected head of state, the oath has performative value. This
means that, analogously to the baptismal formula, pronouncing certain
words is an action that causes the assumed effect. However, in order
for the performative to be successful, it is also necessary to fulfill the
non-verbal conditions, which include the appropriate gestures, proper
context and authorized participants. Despite these analogies, as well as
despite the fact that it draws on the medieval tradition of enthroning
Christian European rulers, the swearing-in of the head of state is now
secular. The sacred references were, in this case, limited to the optional
formula of an appeal to God as a helper and witness of the oath. This is
the only literal remnant of the influence of religion on the most impor-
tant state ceremony in Poland.
12
Compare the categorical objection to swearing to heaven, among others in the
Gospel according to Matthew (Mt 5:34). The mere requirement to take an oath and
the inability to replace it with a vow may, however, give rise to difficulties in the
future, resulting from the conflict between the legal norm and conscience (e.g., for
people who for whom any swearing is banned for religious reasons; Maroń, 2015,
p. 72).
19. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 153
Bibliography
Legal acts:
The Act of January 5, 2011 – Election Code, Journal of Laws 2011, No. 21, item 112
as amended.
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland of April 2, 1997, Journal of Laws 1997,
No. 78, item 483 as amended.
Constitutional Act of October 17, 1992 on mutual relations between the legislative
and executive power of the Republic of Poland and the local government,
Journal of Laws 1992, No. 84, item 426.
Act of September 27, 1990 on the election of the President of the Republic of Poland,
Journal of Laws 1990, No. 67, item 398 as amended.
Act of December 29, 1989 amending the Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic,
Journal of Laws 1989, No. 75, item 444.
Act of April 7, 1989 amending the Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic, Jour-
nal of Laws 1989, No. 19, item 101.
The Constitution of the Polish People’s Republic of July 22, 1952, Journal of Laws
1952, No. 33, item 232.
Constitutional Act of February 19, 1947, Journal of Laws 1947, No. 18, item 71.
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland of April 23, 1935.
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland of March 17, 1921.
Other sources:
Austin J. L. (1993), Mówienie i poznawanie, Warszawa.
Baszkiewicz J. (1998), Myśl polityczna wieków średnich, Poznań.
Biblia Tysiąclecia. Pismo Święte Starego i Nowego Testamentu (2003), Poznań.
Böckenförde E. W. (2005–2006), Teoria polityki a teologia polityczna. Uwagi na
temat ich wzajemnego stosunku, “Teologia Polityczna,” no. 3.
Chmaj M. (1996), Sejm „kontraktowy” w transformacji systemu politycznego Rzeczy-
pospolitej Polskiej, Lublin.
Churska-Nowak K. (2009), Rytuały polityczne w demokracji masowej, Poznań.
Churska-Nowak K., Orylski Ł. (2010), The boundaries between the religious and the
secular on the Polish political scene, “Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Politycz
ne,” no. 2.
Eller J. D. (2012), Antropologia kulturowa. Globalne siły, lokalne światy, Kraków.
Filipowicz S. (1998), Mit i spektakl władzy, Warszawa.
Gennep A. van (2006), Obrzędy przejścia. Systematyczne studium ceremonii,
Warszawa.
Gierycz M. (2008), Chrześcijaństwo i Unia Europejska. Rola religii w procesie inte-
gracji europejskiej, Warszawa–Kraków.
20. 154 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
Gołembski F. (2012), Cywilizacja europejska, Warszawa.
Gołembski F. (2006), Jedność europejska, Warszawa.
Gołembski F. (2008), Kulturowe aspekty integracji europejskiej, Warszawa.
Górecki D. (1997), Wpływ polskich tradycji ustrojowych na współczesne rozwiązania
konstytucyjne, in: Konstytucyjne systemy rządów, ed. M. Domagała,
Warszawa.
Kałuszyńska E. (n.d.), Język a rzeczywistość. Performatywna funkcja języka, Lublin,
http://bacon.umcs.lublin.pl/~lukasik/Konferencja%20(teksty%20referatow)/
Kaluszynska.pdf, 15.06.2018.
Kantorowicz E. (2007), Dwa ciała króla. Studium ze średniowiecznej teologii poli
tycznej, Warszawa.
Katechizm Kościoła Katolickiego (KKK, 1994 [1992]), Poznań.
Kłoczkowski J. (2004), Europa – chrześcijańskie korzenie, Warszawa.
Kodeks prawa kanonicznego (KPK, 1983).
Konstytucja o Liturgii Świętej (KL, 1963).
Leach E., Greimas A. J. (1989), Rytuał i narracja, Warszawa.
Mała encyklopedia kultury antycznej (1988), ed. Z. Piszczek, Warszawa.
Marini P. (2007), Liturgia i piękno. Nobilis pulchritudo, Pelplin.
Maroń G. (2012a), Instytucja przysięgi prezydenta w polskim porządku prawnym,
“Przegląd Prawa Konstytucyjnego,” no. 2.
Maroń G. (2015), Instytucja przysięgi (ślubowania) a poszanowanie wolności su
mienia i religii, “Przegląd Prawa Konstytucyjnego,” no. 4 (26).
Maroń G. (2012b), Ślubowanie senatorskie w polskim porządku prawnym, “Zeszyty
Naukowe Uniwersytetu Rzeszowskiego. Seria prawnicza,” no. 74/11.
Mojak R. (1997a), Instytucja Prezydenta RP w świetle nowej Konstytucji, “Państwo
i Prawo,” no. 11–12.
Mojak R. (1997b), Pozycja ustrojowa i struktura władzy wykonawczej. Problematy-
ka stosunków między prezydentem a rządem, in: Ustrój i struktura aparatu
państwowego i samorządu terytorialnego, ed. W. Skrzydło, Warszawa.
Mojak R. (2000), Władza wykonawcza w Konstytucji RP, in: Ustrój konstytucyjny
Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, Lublin.
Monarchia w średniowieczu (2002), eds. J. Pysiak, A. Pieniądz-Skrzypczak,
M. R. Pauk, Warszawa–Kraków.
Nadolski B. (1989), Liturgika, vol. I: Liturgika fundamentalna, Poznań.
Ochmann-Staniszewska S. (1995), Przysięga marszałka poselskiego na sejmach lat
1648–1668, “Czasopismo Prawno-Historyczne,” vol. XVVII, 1–2.
Paprocki H. (2007), Bóg i teatr na antypodach…, “Więź,” nr 5, electronic version:
http://www.wiez.pl/czasopismo/;s,czasopismo_szczegoly,id,525,art,14445,
20.06.2018.
Pietrzak J. (2010), Senat Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. Tradycja i współczesność XV–XXI w.,
Warszawa.
21. ŚSP 3 ’18 Liturgical references in the swearing-in ceremonies... 155
Sarnecki P. (1990), Prezydent jako organ czuwający nad przestrzeganiem Konstytucji,
“Państwo i Prawo,” no. 11.
Segalen M. (2009), Obrzędy i rytuały współczesne, Warszawa.
Skrzydło W. (1996), Przemiany polityczno-ustrojowe w Polsce na przełomie
lat osiemdziesiątych i dziewięćdziesiątych, in: Prawo konstytucyjne, ed.
W. Skrzydło, Lublin.
Słownik języka polskiego (2018), electronic version: https://sjp.pwn.pl/, 14.06.2018.
Słownik języka polskiego (1984), ed. M. Szymczak, Warszawa, vol. 2, 3.
Słownik grecko-polski (2015), ed. O. Jurewicz, Warszawa.
Sokolewicz W. (1989), Kwietniowa zmiana Konstytucji, “Państwo i Prawo,” no. 6.
Strzelczyk J. (2007), Cis Oceanum et Ultra. Ernst Kantorowicz i jego dzieło, in: Kan-
torowicz E., ibid.
Syryjczyk J. (1991), Krzywoprzysięstwo w systematyce kanonicznego prawa karnego,
“Prawo Kanoniczne. Kwartalnik prawno-historyczny,” no. 34/1–2.
Towarek P. (2008), Średniowieczny dramat liturgiczny i jego oddziaływanie na
współczesną liturgię Kościoła, “Studia Elbląskie,” no. 9.
Turner V. W. (2010), Proces rytualny. Struktura i antystruktura, Warszawa.
Urbańczyk P. (2000), Władza i polityka we wczesnym średniowieczu, Wrocław.
Witkowski Z. (1987), Prezydent Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej 1921–1935, Warszawa–
Poznań––Toruń.
Wolański A. (2005), Dramat liturgiczny w średniowieczu, Gdańsk.
Liturgiczne odniesienia zaprzysiężenia
Prezydenta Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej po 1989 roku
Streszczenie
Celem tekstu jest analiza wzajemnych powiązań między liturgią sakramentów
a najważniejszą ceremonią państwową Trzeciej Rzeczypospolitej, którą jest zaprzy-
siężenie głowy państwa. Ma ono charakter świecki, choć jego antecedencji należy
upatrywać w religijnych aspektach intronizacji władców europejskich w wiekach
średnich. Te odniesienia czynią z zaprzysiężenia przedmiot badań łączący teologię
i politologię. Prowokują one pytania o związki między religijnymi wyobrażeniami
danej wspólnoty narodowej a jej organizacją polityczną, wyrażające się w ceremo-
niach państwowych. Prezydent Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej staje się nim w wyniku
zwycięstwa wyborczego, ogłoszonego przez Państwową Komisję Wyborczą, którego
ważność stwierdza Sąd Najwyższy. Do czasu wypowiedzenia słów roty, nowo wybra-
ny prezydent pozostaje jednak jedynie elektem. Zaprzysiężenie jest zatem uregulowa-
nym prawem rytuałem publicznym, którego należy dopełnić, aby formalnie rozpocząć
wykonywanie funkcji. Zapisana w Konstytucji i wypowiedziana przez nowo wybra-
ną głowę państwa przysięga ma tym samym walor performatywny, analogicznie do
22. 156 Magdalena Lorenc, Michał Mikołajczak ŚSP 3 ’18
formuł liturgicznych. Ponadto zawiera ona fakultatywną formułę wezwania Boga na
świadka złożonej przysięgi. Rota prezydencka pozostaje zatem uwarunkowanym hi-
storycznie świadectwem odwołania się do sfery sacrum przed władzę publiczną.
Słowa kluczowe: ceremoniał, zaprzysiężenie głowy państwa, liturgia, rytuał