LIMITED LIABILITY
PARTNERSHIP ACT 2008
     & RULES 2009

       Priya Bhansali
     KUMBHAT & Co.,
    Chartered Accountants
       www.bhansali.in
Agenda
   Genesis
   Salient Features
   Comparison between Partnership/LLP/Private
    Limited Co.
   Chapters under LLP Act
   Rules
   LLP in Other Countries
   Certain Issues

                       KUMBHAT & CO.,
GENESIS OF LLP
   LLP – 1991 in Texas – Loan and savings failures
   Uniform Partnership Act 1996 - USA
   LLP Act 2000 – UK
   Abid Hussain Committee -1997
   Naresh Chandra Committee – 2003
   JJ Irani Expert Committee – 2005
   Naresh Chandra 2nd Committee – July 2005

                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Concept Paper
   Role of service sector
   Limitation of Multi-disciplinary partnership
   Limitation of no. of Partners
   Litigation – joint liabilities in case of partnership
   Hybrid between a Company and Partnership
   Profession as well as SME



                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
What is LLP
   LLP – separate legal entity with unlimited capacity to
    do anything a natural person can do – UK
    Partnership formed under LLP Act 2008




                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Salient Features
   LLP for all kinds of business
   Limited Liability
   Simple when compared to a Company
   Minimum Partners 2 ; no limit for maximum
   Legal Entity – Artificial Juridical Person
   Members & Mutual Rights
   Designated Partners
   Unlimited Capacity – no main objects
   Conversion

                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
Salient Features
   Cannot be listed
   Incorporation Document
   Flexibility on internal structure – No BOD etc
   Mergers
   Winding up




                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Formation of LLP
   Similar to that of formation of Company
   Acquire – DSC and DPIN
   Register DSC and DPIN with LLP
   Check name availability
   Download Forms
   File Electronically
   Track Status
   Receive Certificate
   Start Business

                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
Advantages
   Limited Liability
   Members cannot be responsible for the act of any other
    member – inter se agreement between members
   No Maximum No. of Partners
   Easier Operations – Perpetual
   Compliances – Succession
   No BOD, meetings/minutes
   Remuneration


                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
Disadvantages
   Compliance – Annual Filings, Solvency, Duplication
   One person LLP concept absent
   Limitation of 2 member LLP – result in closure
   Documents available for public scrutiny
   Penalty for non compliance
   Silent about Taxation



                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Regulatory Frame Work
   Legal
   Administration
   Taxation




                     KUMBHAT & CO.,
Regulatory Framework
   Legal –                                      Administration
    LLP Act 2008                                  - MCA
     - Companies Act 1956                            - ROC
      - IT Act 2000                                    - Tribunal
      - Indian Partnership Act 1932                    - Official Liquidator
      - General Clauses Act 1897
      - SEBI Act 1972
      - CPC 1908
      - Other Acts - Professionals
            - Advocate Act 1961
            - CA Act 1949
           - CS Act 1980
           - CWA Act 1959


                                      KUMBHAT & CO.,
Comparison
   Applicable Law
   Liability
   Perpetual Existence
   Separate Legal Entity
   Minimum Number
   Maximum Members
   Documents defining activities

                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Comparison
   Document providing procedure
   Management
   Compliance/Accounts/Audit
   Minimum No. of Directors
   Transferability of shares
   Conversion
   Common Seal
   Change of Regd Office
   Change of Name

                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Comparison
   Oppression & Mis-management
   Annual Filing
   E –filing




                      KUMBHAT & CO.,
Chapters under the Act
   Preliminary
   Nature of LLP
   Incorporation of LLP and matters incidental thereto
   Partners and their relations
   Extent & Limitation of LLP and partners
   Contributions
   Financial Disclosures


                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Chapters
   Assignment & Transfer of partnership rights
   Investigation
   Conversion to LLP
   Foreign LLP
   Compromise, arrangement or reconstruction
   Winding up and dissolution
   Miscellaneous

                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Schedules
   First Schedule - matters relating to mutual rights and
    duties -like Table A
   Second Schedule – Conversion of firm into LLP
   Third Schedule – Conversion of Private Ltd Co into
    LLP
   Fourth Schedule – Conversion of Unlisted Public
    Co. into LLP


                             KUMBHAT & CO.,
LLP Rules
   LLP Rules 2009 is notified, additions as and when
    need arises
   18 chapters, 41 Rules, 4 Annexures, 30 forms
   Covers all the sections – Definitions to Winding up,
    Compounding , Destruction of old records etc
   Concept LLP (Winding up and Dissolutions) Rules
    200…


                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Designated Partner
   To be specified in Agreement
   One must be a Resident of India
   Responsible for all compliance
   Body corporate




                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Audit and Accounts
   Proper Books of Accounts
   Cash or accrual basis
   Statement of Account and Solvency
   Audit – Not compulsory unless Turnover is > Rs.40 lacs or
    Contribution > Rs.25.00 lacs, conditions of R 24
   Appointment by DP, 30 days before closure of FY
   Financial year defined as April - March
   Penalty – LLP – Rs.25K – Rs.5.00 lacs & DP – Rs.10K -
    Rs.1.00 lac
                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
Accounts & Annual Returns
   Statement of Account and Solvency Statement to be
    prepared within 6 m of end of FY and file Form 8
    within 30 days of end of 6 m period
   Authenticated by DP
    Penalty for non- compliance – Rs.10K to Rs 1.00 lac
    for each DP and LLP – Rs.25K to Rs.5.00 lacs.
   Annual Return duly authenticated


                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Auditors
   Section 34(4) & Rule 24(8) to 24 (19)
   Authority - Designated Partners – other partners ?
   When the appointment to be made – 30 days before
    the end of each Financial year
   Term of appointment – till the next period
   Audit exempted – if turnover < Rs.40 lacs or
    contribution does < Rs. 25 lacs


                        KUMBHAT & CO.,
Auditors (contd.)
   Re-appointment
   Remuneration
   Removal of an Auditor




                       KUMBHAT & CO.,
Other Countries
   USA
   UK
   Japan
   Canada
   China
   Singapore



                      KUMBHAT & CO.,
TAXATION
   Expect to be cleared in the Budget of 2009 –
    Probable date is 31.7.09
   LLP or members will be taxed
   Capital Gains on sale of LLP assets
   Receiving Share of accumulated profits?
   Transfer of Shares



                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Taxation (contd.)
   UK – Income taxed in hands of partners
   UK – Capital Gains on transfer of assets of LLP is
    also taxed in the hands of partners as if they own the
    same
   US - reported in individual returns of the partners
   Japan – Each member is directly subject to tax
   Singapore – Personally taxed, taxed as self employed
   China – passed through and attributed to partners
                          KUMBHAT & CO.,
Issues
   Minors, HUF can they be partners?
   Act is very small when compared to Co’s Act 1956 –
    but looks as if the Rules/Notifications will rule the
    Act –
   General Names? Small Names ? Disclosure of
    Business in Name/ Objection



                         KUMBHAT & CO.,
Foreign LLP
   Section 59
   Establishment of place of Business in India
   Business activity carried on in India
   Permission from RBI may be required under FEMA
   FLLP has to file certain documents, Accounts and Solvency
    Statement in English
   Notice of cessation
   Certification and Authentication from Notary
    Public/Commissioner of Oaths in the Company it is
    incorporated
                           KUMBHAT & CO.,
Lots to examine and explore !!

                   www.llp.gov.in

                  THANK YOU
                 www.bhansali.in



KUMBHAT & CO.,

Limited Liability Partnership Act 2008

  • 1.
    LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP ACT2008 & RULES 2009 Priya Bhansali KUMBHAT & Co., Chartered Accountants www.bhansali.in
  • 2.
    Agenda  Genesis  Salient Features  Comparison between Partnership/LLP/Private Limited Co.  Chapters under LLP Act  Rules  LLP in Other Countries  Certain Issues KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 3.
    GENESIS OF LLP  LLP – 1991 in Texas – Loan and savings failures  Uniform Partnership Act 1996 - USA  LLP Act 2000 – UK  Abid Hussain Committee -1997  Naresh Chandra Committee – 2003  JJ Irani Expert Committee – 2005  Naresh Chandra 2nd Committee – July 2005 KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 4.
    Concept Paper  Role of service sector  Limitation of Multi-disciplinary partnership  Limitation of no. of Partners  Litigation – joint liabilities in case of partnership  Hybrid between a Company and Partnership  Profession as well as SME KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 5.
    What is LLP  LLP – separate legal entity with unlimited capacity to do anything a natural person can do – UK  Partnership formed under LLP Act 2008 KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 6.
    Salient Features  LLP for all kinds of business  Limited Liability  Simple when compared to a Company  Minimum Partners 2 ; no limit for maximum  Legal Entity – Artificial Juridical Person  Members & Mutual Rights  Designated Partners  Unlimited Capacity – no main objects  Conversion KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 7.
    Salient Features  Cannot be listed  Incorporation Document  Flexibility on internal structure – No BOD etc  Mergers  Winding up KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 8.
    Formation of LLP  Similar to that of formation of Company  Acquire – DSC and DPIN  Register DSC and DPIN with LLP  Check name availability  Download Forms  File Electronically  Track Status  Receive Certificate  Start Business KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 9.
    Advantages  Limited Liability  Members cannot be responsible for the act of any other member – inter se agreement between members  No Maximum No. of Partners  Easier Operations – Perpetual  Compliances – Succession  No BOD, meetings/minutes  Remuneration KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 10.
    Disadvantages  Compliance – Annual Filings, Solvency, Duplication  One person LLP concept absent  Limitation of 2 member LLP – result in closure  Documents available for public scrutiny  Penalty for non compliance  Silent about Taxation KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 11.
    Regulatory Frame Work  Legal  Administration  Taxation KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 12.
    Regulatory Framework  Legal –  Administration LLP Act 2008 - MCA - Companies Act 1956 - ROC - IT Act 2000 - Tribunal - Indian Partnership Act 1932 - Official Liquidator - General Clauses Act 1897 - SEBI Act 1972 - CPC 1908 - Other Acts - Professionals - Advocate Act 1961 - CA Act 1949 - CS Act 1980 - CWA Act 1959 KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 13.
    Comparison  Applicable Law  Liability  Perpetual Existence  Separate Legal Entity  Minimum Number  Maximum Members  Documents defining activities KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 14.
    Comparison  Document providing procedure  Management  Compliance/Accounts/Audit  Minimum No. of Directors  Transferability of shares  Conversion  Common Seal  Change of Regd Office  Change of Name KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 15.
    Comparison  Oppression & Mis-management  Annual Filing  E –filing KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 16.
    Chapters under theAct  Preliminary  Nature of LLP  Incorporation of LLP and matters incidental thereto  Partners and their relations  Extent & Limitation of LLP and partners  Contributions  Financial Disclosures KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 17.
    Chapters  Assignment & Transfer of partnership rights  Investigation  Conversion to LLP  Foreign LLP  Compromise, arrangement or reconstruction  Winding up and dissolution  Miscellaneous KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 18.
    Schedules  First Schedule - matters relating to mutual rights and duties -like Table A  Second Schedule – Conversion of firm into LLP  Third Schedule – Conversion of Private Ltd Co into LLP  Fourth Schedule – Conversion of Unlisted Public Co. into LLP KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 19.
    LLP Rules  LLP Rules 2009 is notified, additions as and when need arises  18 chapters, 41 Rules, 4 Annexures, 30 forms  Covers all the sections – Definitions to Winding up, Compounding , Destruction of old records etc  Concept LLP (Winding up and Dissolutions) Rules 200… KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 20.
    Designated Partner  To be specified in Agreement  One must be a Resident of India  Responsible for all compliance  Body corporate KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 21.
    Audit and Accounts  Proper Books of Accounts  Cash or accrual basis  Statement of Account and Solvency  Audit – Not compulsory unless Turnover is > Rs.40 lacs or Contribution > Rs.25.00 lacs, conditions of R 24  Appointment by DP, 30 days before closure of FY  Financial year defined as April - March  Penalty – LLP – Rs.25K – Rs.5.00 lacs & DP – Rs.10K - Rs.1.00 lac KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 22.
    Accounts & AnnualReturns  Statement of Account and Solvency Statement to be prepared within 6 m of end of FY and file Form 8 within 30 days of end of 6 m period  Authenticated by DP  Penalty for non- compliance – Rs.10K to Rs 1.00 lac for each DP and LLP – Rs.25K to Rs.5.00 lacs.  Annual Return duly authenticated KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 23.
    Auditors  Section 34(4) & Rule 24(8) to 24 (19)  Authority - Designated Partners – other partners ?  When the appointment to be made – 30 days before the end of each Financial year  Term of appointment – till the next period  Audit exempted – if turnover < Rs.40 lacs or contribution does < Rs. 25 lacs KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 24.
    Auditors (contd.)  Re-appointment  Remuneration  Removal of an Auditor KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 25.
    Other Countries  USA  UK  Japan  Canada  China  Singapore KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 26.
    TAXATION  Expect to be cleared in the Budget of 2009 – Probable date is 31.7.09  LLP or members will be taxed  Capital Gains on sale of LLP assets  Receiving Share of accumulated profits?  Transfer of Shares KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 27.
    Taxation (contd.)  UK – Income taxed in hands of partners  UK – Capital Gains on transfer of assets of LLP is also taxed in the hands of partners as if they own the same  US - reported in individual returns of the partners  Japan – Each member is directly subject to tax  Singapore – Personally taxed, taxed as self employed  China – passed through and attributed to partners KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 28.
    Issues  Minors, HUF can they be partners?  Act is very small when compared to Co’s Act 1956 – but looks as if the Rules/Notifications will rule the Act –  General Names? Small Names ? Disclosure of Business in Name/ Objection KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 29.
    Foreign LLP  Section 59  Establishment of place of Business in India  Business activity carried on in India  Permission from RBI may be required under FEMA  FLLP has to file certain documents, Accounts and Solvency Statement in English  Notice of cessation  Certification and Authentication from Notary Public/Commissioner of Oaths in the Company it is incorporated KUMBHAT & CO.,
  • 30.
    Lots to examineand explore !! www.llp.gov.in THANK YOU www.bhansali.in KUMBHAT & CO.,