This document summarizes the key steps and techniques for conducting legal due diligence for cross-border M&A transactions. It discusses the scope of legal due diligence, including types of investigations and documents to review. It outlines important legal aspects to examine regarding the target company and its business. The document also addresses common requirements for legal due diligence, such as letters of intent and parties' obligations. It provides techniques for efficient due diligence investigations and identifies potential problems and risks to consider.
Everything You Should Know About Child Custody and Parenting While Living in ...
LDD.cross border m&a transactions
1. 0
LEGAL DUE DILIGENCE FOR CROSS-BORDER
M&A TRANSACTIONS
Kowit Somwaiya
Managing Partner
LawPlus Ltd.
25th June 2019
Cross-Border Mergers & Acquisitions
OmegaWorldClass Research Institute
3. 2
Kowit Somwaiya
• Managing Partner, LawPlus Ltd.
• Managing Partner, LawPlus Myanmar Ltd.
• Board of Directors, INTA
• Anti-Counterfeiting Committee, APAA
• B.A. (Education – English), Ubon Ratchathani Rajbhat University
• LL.B., Thammasat University
• LL.M., University of Illinois
• Certificate of Instruction for Lawyers, Harvard Law School
4. 3
LawPlus Ltd.
• Established in 2003
• Major practices
Banking and finance
Corporate and M&A
FDI and investment promotion
IP and ICT
Dispute resolution and litigation
• Rankings:
• www.lawplusltd.com
5. 4
Presentation Topics
Scope of Legal Due Diligence (“LDD”) in Cross-Border M&A
Transactions
Legal Aspects of Target Company (“TC”) and Its Business: Key
Issues
LDD Requirements, Agreements and Obligations
Techniques for Conducting Cross-Border LDD
Key Steps of Cross-Border LDD Investigation
Problems in LDD
Risks in Cross-Border M&A
Case Study
6. 5
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Types of LDD
Limited LDD: Limited Investigation
- basic corporate documents of 3-5 years
- material transaction documents of high values
- no asset investigation
- no litigation investigation
Full LDD: Full Investigation
- corporate documents starting from registration
date or at least 10 years
- HR documents
- transaction documents
- assets, licenses and permits
- litigation and disputes
7. 6
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Independent Searches on TC
Company Search: Company Affidavit,
objectives, MOA, AOA, lists of
shareholders
Property Searches: Lands, buildings,
factories, machinery, intellectual property,
vehicles
Insolvency Search: Central Bankruptcy
Court
Bankruptcy Search: Legal Execution
Department
Litigation Searches:Criminal cases
and civil cases
8. 7
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Review of LDD Documents
Documents on Company Registration and Corporate Matters
- Registration details
- Business objectives
- Business operation
- Minutes of AGMs, EGMs and BOD meetings
- Shareholders Agreement/Joint Venture Agreement
Permits and Licenses
- Investment promotion certificate
- Foreign Business License/Foreign Business Certificate
- Factory construction and factory operation licenses
- Other licenses for business operation
9. 8
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Review of LDD Documents
Major Commercial Transaction Agreements
- Sale and Purchase Agreements
- Distribution Agreements
- Manufacturing Agreements
- Confidentiality Agreements
Major Investment and Internal Transaction
Documents
- Transactions with directors or persons related to
or associated with directors or major shareholders
- Joint venture or partnership agreements with
business partners or within the group of the TC
10. 9
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Review of LDD Documents
Borrowings and Liabilities
- Loan Agreements, B/E, P/N, O/D, T/R, L/C, SBLC
- Guarantee Agreements
- Assignment Agreements
- Mortgage Agreements
- Pledge Agreements
- Business Collateral Agreements
- Factoring Agreements
- Foreign exchange hedging and other derivatives agreements
Land, Buildings, Factories, Machinery and Other Assets
- Land title deeds, machinery ownership documents, vehicle registration books
- Land Lease Agreements, Office Lease Agreements, Machinery Lease Agreements
- Lists and details of account receivables and inventories
11. 10
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Review of LDD Documents
Labour Protection and Employment Matters
- List and details of employees
- Work Rules and Code of Conduct
- Employment contracts / Employment service (sub-contract) agreements
- Benefit schemes (stock option plan, profit sharing schemes, etc.)
- Registrations and filings with SSF and WCF
- Insurance policies for directors and employees
- Labour union documents
- Work permits for non-Thai employees
Filings and Reports
- Regulatory filings (in relation to company registration and operation, employment, etc.)
- Government reports (in relation to investment, promotion, environment, money
laundering, exchange control, etc.)
12. 11
Scope of LDD in Cross-Border M&A Transactions:
Review of LDD Documents
Intellectual Property and Information Technology
- Trademark applications and trademark registration certificates
- Patent and design applications and registration certificates
- Domain name and website and related agreements
- Trademark License Agreements, Patent License Agreements, Copyright License
Agreements
- Software License Agreements
- IT and Data Service Agreements
Litigation Documents
- Reports on pending lawsuits, arbitration proceedings, demand notices and potential
disputes
- Copies of claims, answers, court orders and judgements
- Confirmation letter of directors in relation to litigation
13. 12
Legal Aspects of TC and Its Business: Key Issues
Check key issues in LLD Report
Jurisdiction / country of registration
- Registered office
- Head office
- Branches
Shareholding structure
- Local shareholders and foreign shareholders
- Foreign ownership limit
- Parent companies and ultimate shareholders
- Subsidiaries, related companies, associated companies, affiliated
companies
Board of directors and their authorizations (authorized directors)
Objectives, core business and related (ancillary) businesses
14. 13
Legal Aspects of TC and Its Business: Key Issues
Major provisions of AOA
- Transactions required approvals from BOD/shareholders
- Requirements for calling BOD meeting/shareholders meeting
- Pre-emptive rights of shareholders
Licenses/permits for operating business and other filings with authorities
Major assets
- Tangible assets
- Intangible assets
Existing liabilities/obligations
- Duties and liabilities under material agreements
- Payments of compensation for judgement damages, etc.
Existing lawsuits disputes and potential disputes
15. 14
LDD Requirements, Agreements and Obligations:
Letter of Intent (“LOI”)
Signed by seller and acquirer prior to LDD
Intention to enter into M&A transaction, subject to:-
- LDD investigation
- successful negotiation and execution of SPA or APA
Details of shares or assets to be acquired and their prices
LDD investigation commitment
Exclusivity period for LDD investigation and negotiations of SPA
Non-disclosure undertakings during and post exclusivity period
16. 15
LDD Requirements, Agreements and Obligations:
Obligations of Seller, TC and Acquirer
Seller and TC
- Making LDD documents available in a prompt manner
- Making full disclosure of LDD documents
- Being cooperative in giving additional LDD documents, explanations,
clarifications or confirmation letters
Acquirer
- Appointing lawyers for LDD investigation
- Giving lists of LDD documents to seller and TC
- Asking for additional documents and more information as lawyers may direct
- Communicating and meeting with seller and TC to clarify unclear issues
17. 16
Techniques for Conducting Cross-Border LDD
Quick checking basic information
- Obtaining basic information on TC and its business
- Checking basic information on TC and its shareholder (seller)
Obtaining LDD documents
- LDD data room and sufficient accession must be made available
- List of LDD documents must be prepared and given promptly
- Additional LDD documents must be obtained from TC promptly
- Cooperation from TC must be requested
Allocating LDD documents for reviewing
- Reviewing by lawyers having relevant experience and expertise
- Templates for summary of documents reviewed
- Setting up timeframe and deadline for LDD investigations
18. 17
Techniques for Conducting Cross-Border LDD
Meeting with TC
- Meeting if necessary for clarification of unclear or suspicious issues
- Checking originals of documents if necessary
- Clarification letter may be necessary
Independent searches
- Necessary for documents available to the public
- Online searches where possible
- Relying on independent search results if they conflict with those given by TC
Focusing on legal risks
- Existing legal risks
- Future legal risks that may occur
- Add them as red flags in the LDD report
19. 18
Techniques for Conducting Cross-Border LDD
Post LDD opinion and advice
- Given if critical legal risks are found in order to mitigate risks
- Opinion on validity and enforceability of documents
- Opinion on regulatory compliance
- Determining and assessing legal risks
- Advice on legal issues and measures to mitigate legal risks
Avoid delay and cost-overun
- Act fast by all parties
- Take several steps parallelly
20. 19
Key Steps of Cross-Border LDD Investigation
(1) • Signing LOI by Buyer and Seller
(2) • Appointment of LDD Lawyers by Buyer
(3)
• Independent Searches on TC
(4) • Obtaining LDD Documents from TC
(5) • Reviewing of LDD Documents
(6) • Clarification Meeting with TC
(7)
• Issuing LDD Report to Buyer
7 Key Steps
Post LDD opinion and advice given separately if required
7 Key Steps
21. 20
Problems in LDD
Incomplete
Documents
Missing
Documents
Lack of
Cooperation
from TC
Concealment
of Facts and
Documents
No Data
Room
Limited
Access to
Documents
Limited Track
Records
Major Problems
Suggested Solutions
- Seller’s instructions to TC to cooperate
- TC’s written clarifications on missing documents
Problems
22. 21
Risks in Cross-Border M&A
Differences in language, culture and management style
Unfamiliar laws and regulations
Missing corporate and compliance documents
Breaches of material agreements
Internal fraudulent transactions
Borrowing and liabilities
Failure to comply with laws, e.g. failure to obtain or renew licenses/permits,
failure to file required reports
Violation of laws related to business operation, e.g. foreign ownership limit,
money laundering, tax evasion
Pending legal proceedings, e.g. claims by financial creditors on default of
debts repayments, enforcement of securities
23. 22
Case Study 1
Our client, acquirer, a Korean company
LDD at office/factory of target company in Rayong
LDD investigation on database and printed documents + clarification
meetings on both legal and technical issues and physical checks of
machinery and inventory
Within 3 working days
Lawyer team and client’s technical-business team work at the same
time
Full cooperation of TC’s team
M&A deal succeed in 2 months (with SPA signed)
24. 23
Case Study 2
Our client, acquirer, a BVI company owned by a Thai company
LDD on seller and its NPL portfolio (accounts receivable)
Seller is registered in BVI with HQ address in Hong Kong and its
authorized director is a Hong Kong company
LDD took place in Thailand, Singapore and BVI (by us and our client’s
foreign lawyers)
Lots of notarizations (and legalizations for post M&A rehabilitation of
the Thai parent company of the acquirer at the Central Bankruptcy
Court)
M&A deal succeeded
Business rehabilitation succeeded with THB1.5 billion debt written off
25. 24
Case Study 3
Our client, an Australian petroleum engineering services company
LDD against an engineering TC in Thailand to acquire shares in TC
TC did not have data room. Documents were at different rooms on
different floors with different departments
A lot of missing documents and incomplete documents
Minimal and slow cooperation from TC in giving clarifications and
confirmations of facts and documents in need of clarifications
LDD took 6 months before LDD Report could be issued with a lot of
qualifications
Deal failed
26. 25
Case Study 4
Our client is registered in Singapore
TC is a Thai company holding licenses to develop and operate a marina
project on state property (under control of the Treasury Department,
the Marine Department and the Navy)
LDD was involved with complicated concessions and permits and
investment promotion conditions
LDD took place at the same time with negotiations of SPA and SHA
Lengthy negotiations but in good faith
M&A deal succeeded with signing of SPA, SHA and other transaction
agreements
LDD and negotiations of agreements took 1.5 years