SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 30
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 1
2015 LCEF National Marketing Competition
Prepared By
Dillon LaHaye
Hillary Minnaert
Nancy Mohammed
Thomas Obarski
Brandon Wagner
Faculty Advisor: Dr. Nancy Harrower
April 10th, 2015
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 2
Contents
Executive Summary............................................................................................................................3
Background........................................................................................................................................4
Objective ...........................................................................................................................................4
Target Market.....................................................................................................................................4
Sample Selection ................................................................................................................................5
Methodologies....................................................................................................................................5
Data Analysis .....................................................................................................................................5
Survey Analysis..............................................................................................................................5
Interview Analysis ..........................................................................................................................9
Consumer Decision Process ..............................................................................................................12
Recommendations ............................................................................................................................12
The Big Idea ....................................................................................................................................12
1. Bus Tour ..................................................................................................................................13
2. Print Ads ..................................................................................................................................15
3. Website ....................................................................................................................................18
5. “WE ARE LCEF.” Commercial and Radio Ads ..........................................................................26
Campaign Budget.............................................................................................................................26
Implementation Process ....................................................................................................................28
Conclusion.......................................................................................................................................29
References .......................................................................................................................................29
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 3
Executive Summary
The Lutheran Church Extension Fund (LCEF) was founded to serve and assist members and
workers belonging to the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod (LCMS). In 1978, the Lutheran
Church Extension Fund was incorporated to provide financial resources, investment, support
services and loans and gifts to help minister, witness and provide outreach for the Lutheran
Church Missouri Synod. Within the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, past history and member
education indicates a lack of awareness of the Lutheran Church Extension Fund and its many
services. In order to understand the extent of this problem, primary and secondary research was
conducted for five weeks. Detailed surveys were administered to LCMS students and faculty at
Concordia University St Paul. Personal, phone, and electronic interviews were also carried out
with Concordia University faculty, as well as a number of LCMS members and leaders in the
community.
The largest barrier is the overall lack of awareness of LCEF, its services and mission. Through
data analysis, it was discovered that LCMS members were looking for four main qualities when
considering financial investments and opportunities:
1. Greater awareness of LCEF services
2. Clean and simplistic presentation of information
3. Easy accessibility to services
4. Transparency and personalization of service
In order to satisfy the needs of the consumers, as well as ease the concerns that accompany a
high involvement purchasing decision, a strong, high-impact campaign has been developed to
build awareness of LCEF and its services offered. The forefront of the campaign is the tag line
“WE ARE LCEF.” which projects unity and strength while projecting awareness. A number of
marketing tactics are recommended to accomplish this:
1. Summer Midwest bus tour to build awareness and give personal service
2. Implement print ads, commercials and radio to build awareness
3. Launch a user-friendly website to improve online involvement
4. Redesign social media sites to increase interaction with members
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 4
Background
The Lutheran Church Extension Fund (LCEF) has been in existence for 37 years, financially
assisting and supporting the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod (LCMS). It was created in order to
serve the LCMS by providing financial services that allow the LCMS to sustain its ministry and
expand its outreach. Of the 2.2 million baptized LCMS members, LCEF currently provides
services to more than 50,000 people. LCEF offers investments, loans, ministry resources,
stewardship education, and financial services to LCMS members and actively works to help
grow and sustain the church. Under a unified cause, LCEF has strength in service.
Objective
The objective of the research team for the 2015 LCEF National Student Marketing Competition
was to develop a comprehensive marketing plan that will raise awareness of LCEF in the LCMS
community. The goal of the research team was to develop a multi-tiered marketing plan that will
inspire and motivate LCMS members to diligently and actively develop a partnership through an
investment, loan, gift, or use of a support service nationwide. The campaign and creative
marketing recommendations in this plan will include the history, tradition, mission and values set
forth by LCEF and LCMS members. The creative and advanced focus implemented will
continue to support the mission to share the Gospel of Jesus Christ, provide LCEF resources to
empower ministries in Kingdom work and improve awareness of the many services that are
available to LCMS members of all ages.
Target Market
The population for this study was easily determined by the objective, which was given by LCEF.
In order to raise awareness of LCEF in the LCMS, individuals in those congregations must be
considered the primary population. Parameters for the population include the following:
 Current LCMS member
 Currently employed by an LCMS institution, such as a church, school, or university
 Affiliated with an LCMS institution, such as a church, school, or university
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 5
Sample Selection
Convenience sampling was the primary method of sampling used in this study. Convenience
sampling is the act of the researcher selecting those to participate in the study based on a close
proximity to the researcher and convenience. This means that surveys were sent to faculty and
staff along with students at Concordia University St Paul who are either enrolled in a church
work program or listed themselves as LCMS members when initially applying for Concordia
University.
Methodologies
In order to further explore and understand the current level of awareness of LCEF among LCMS
members, interviews were conducted with LCMS members, LCMS pastors and church workers,
and Concordia University St Paul staff and professors. Emails were exchanged and interviews
occurred with 11 different individuals over the course of two weeks.
In addition to interviews, surveys were sent to faculty, staff, and students at Concordia
University St. Paul. Group members also sent surveys to personal contacts such as family and
friends who are LCMS members or church workers.
Data Analysis
Survey Analysis
A survey was created in order to glean a stronger understanding of the current level of awareness
of LCEF within the selected LCMS sample population. The survey was sent to faculty and staff
members at Concordia University St Paul, as well as to students who are currently enrolled in a
church work program or are identified as LCMS members on the Concordia University St Paul
application. Overall, 258 responses were collected from the total group of 543 recipients. The
following graphs reflect the data and information analyzed.
1. Have you heard of the Lutheran Church Extension Fund?
This question was designed to discover how many people in the sample size have heard of
LCEF. There were 178 people who responded to this question with 70.79% having heard of
LCEF while 29.21% of respondents have not heard of LCEF.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 6
2. Where did you hear about the Lutheran Church
Extension Fund?
This question asked participants to select all that applied to where they heard about LCEF. It was
revealed that of the respondents that have heard of LCEF, 78.18% heard about LCEF through a
congregation. School/University served as the second highest source of information at 43.64%,
followed by Friends/Family at 41.82%. This suggests that congregation members are the most
responsible for the spread of LCEF awareness.
3. At which financial
institution do you currently
bank? Survey data
shows that only 8% of the
participants bank with LCEF. Of those surveyed, 44% use banks, 20% bank with credit unions,
and 18% prefer Thrivent. This shows that even among LCMS members, the involvement in
LCEF is low and suggests that the biggest competition for LCEF are banks.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 7
4. How do you access financial information?
Data shows that most people surveyed preferred to access financial information online; 56.5%
used search engines, 49.7% used news websites, and 43.5% preferred using smartphone and
tablet Apps. Among conventional methods; which are newspapers, magazines and television,
newspapers were the most popular.
5. What forms of media do you use on a
daily basis? Most of the participants
used online media daily. Only 12% of the
respondents used printed media daily.
This shows the importance of having a
strong presence online in order to provide
information and services to customers.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 8
In the open-ended responses, many common themes were discovered. These themes were
summarized and quotes were extracted.
6. How can the Lutheran Church Extension Fund improve to meet your needs?
 Provide more information so we are aware of how it can help us
 More savings option
 Clear content about the financial services they offer
 Promote savings for young people to go to college, scholarships
 Share information on campus
 Speakers explain its services to congregation and other groups
 Offer workshops
 Become more accessible locally
Some direct quotes from this question include:
“Work with HR at Concordia to educate us on their offerings.”
“Continue to offer new products, such as student credit union and student loans
options. Continue to run the organization with low overhead in order to be able to
offer competitive interest rates on investment products.”
“As a student, scholarships would be good. I know one is offered, but it confused
me so much I didn’t bother applying.”
7. What are your views on the Lutheran Church Extension Fund?
 Great Mission- using invested dollars for capital projects in LCMS congregations,
schools, colleges, and universities
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 9
 Great way to mix savings and ministry
 Great resource for the Lutheran church and its members. It offers a vast number of
resources that can help people plan for the future
 An excellent fund
 Good value for good cause
 Very positive
 Support it
Some direct quotes from this question include:
“LCEF can be clear, reliably, that they are a church organization. That means 1)
We don’t have FDIC and similar protection; 2) We are making a difference for
what the church can do in the world and the interest rates are good.”
“They are an admirable and useful Christ-centered service for those seeking
financial help in furthering God’s kingdom.”
8. How can the Lutheran Church extension fund improve its awareness in the community?
 Advertising on Concordia campus
 Congregation flyers
 Active representatives in each LCMS congregation seems the best way to supplement
direct mail, social media, and online presences.
 Support local mission projects
 Word of mouth
 Provide more information about what they do in particular
 Connecting to the younger generation
 Partner with Thrivent to build stronger portfolios for investors
 Provide more information on what it does with the funds
Some direct quotes from this question include:
“Any projects they fund/ support could include prominent name placement (e.g.,
when a church is built using LCEF funds, the construction company billboard
could include a citation for LCEF, also describing what it is.)”
“Have a brief video about LCEF that could be played after church service or
during a adult/children bible study or Sunday school hour.”
Interview Analysis
Eleven interviews were conducted with LCMS Pastors, Concordia University professors and
LCMS members. The main objectives of the research was to gain a stronger understanding of
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 10
LCMS awareness in general and in LCMS churches, how to increase LCEF awareness to church
members and communities in which they are located, and how this impacts LCMS individuals
and communities.
The following information is a summary of the interviews that were conducted.
1. Have you heard of the LCEF (Lutheran Church Extension Fund)? How have you heard
of it?
The first question asked if the interviewee has heard of LCEF and how they heard of LCEF. Of
those interviewed, 9 out of 11 have heard of LCEF from being a member of a LCMS church or
from the Concordia University setting. One associate LCMS pastor did not know about LCEF
until a district LCEF representative informed him of the organization during his orientation to his
assigned church. One LCMS member was only aware of the Young Investors club but not LCEF,
another LCMS member had never heard of LCEF.
2. Have you contributed before?
Of the 11 people interviewed, only two have contributed to LCEF.
3. Of what services are you aware?
Even though many interviewed had heard of LCEF, there was still a low or vague awareness of
which services are offered. One interviewee shared, “I have heard of LCEF because of a re-
roofing project for the church that was done a couple of years ago, but I do not invest with them
and don’t know what they offer.”
4. What are your views of LCEF?
Of those who are aware of LCEF, there was a favorable opinion. A campus pastor for Concordia
University St Paul said, “They are a real good thing. They are positive for churches and growth,
and are a safe investment.”
After describing LCEF to those who were unaware, those interviewed saw potential
opportunities for congregations to grow and expand in His word and service.
One LCMS Pastor and Concordia University professor who is an LCEF investor shared, “I have
a very positive view of LCEF as they have done much good for the LCMS in expanding God's
Word, and I have also benefited professionally from my relationship with the LCEF as a guest to
their state and national conventions.”
5. How do you feel LCEF can increase awareness among LCMS members?
Many suggested the power that comes with suggestions from personal friends or congregation
members and the spreading of word of mouth. It was also suggested to provide information on
services offered to LCMS members by flyers, handouts, or videos.
6. How do you feel LCEF can improve on their services offered?
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 11
Some were not aware of the services offered by LCEF and felt that overall improvement of
awareness was essential before considering improvement of services. Those who did know of the
services thought that a simple, clean, and user-friendly approach would be best for LCEF.
7. Do you have any personal examples of how LCEF has benefited your life, congregation,
or community?
The following are a few testimonials from the interviews:
“The first congregation to which I was called invested with and took out loans from the
LCEF to fund a building project that doubled the usable space of its campus. Good rates
and great mission made LCEF a perfect partner.”
“Both in my congregation where offerings where not always very high they were very
forgiving of us when we had to very slow with payments. They allowed us to go on a
payment schedule. In fact they refinance the whole thing very easily to make the process
easier. Personally I did a consolidation loan through LCEF that ended up having very
favorable terms and it was very easy process to take some debt and consolidate it and
they mandated as part of that. We got rid of our credit cards. They went through debt
counseling so I think that it was a very helpful process that they put us through.”
“In my life the savings account gave a percentage to certain Lutheran organizations that
I wanted to support; building programs at my current congregation have made use of
LCEF to finance the project.”
8. How important is it for a business to have community or congregation involvement?
In general, most individuals who were interviewed felt that the involvement of businesses in the
community is not only helpful to the business in the long run, but a very positive influence on the
community. Some individuals felt that they would be more inclined to donate or patronize a
business if it were supporting a local cause or congregation.
9. How do you/your community currently put on fund raisers? Where do you look for
financial support and contributions?
“We go to our school families for bi-annual fundraisers (in the spring it is a walk-a-thon
which is fun for the whole family [and extended family]…while in the fall we put on a
banquet that is more “upscale” and intended only for adults and their friends).”
10. Do you (or your family) have a financial advisor?
Six people interviewed have financial advisors, one of whom is through Thrivent.
11. How do you currently access financial information?
Six people interviewed said that they access financial information though newspapers. Others
said through magazines, websites, employers, and news websites.
12. Do you currently use any other banking institutions and why?
Many interviewed said that they use banks because they are FDIC insured and convenient. One
person said that they use Thrivent because it is well-known.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 12
Consumer Decision Process
Investment and saving choices are considered high involvement purchases that require a lot of
time and energy. High involvement purchasing decisions are typically concerned with high
dollar values or large personal consequences. During this process, consumers typically consider
many different brands, sellers, and product attributes. A considerable amount of time is usually
spent searching for information on the topic and many external information sources are used.
After high involvement purchases are made, there is a higher likelihood that the consumer will
experience post-purchase cognitive dissonance. This means that the tendency to experience
psychological tension or anxiety is much higher after making a high dollar purchase. Individuals
making investments fall into this category.
In order to alleviate the concerns experienced in a high involvement purchase, such as
investments and savings, it is necessary to provide the consumer with a large amount of
comprehensible information. Marketers supply consumers with necessary information via
advertisements, personal selling, and social media. These things make the decision process easier
for the consumer. Companies also use advertising to reinforce the right purchasing decision the
consumer has made.
It is necessary to understand the internal debate the consumer goes through in order to be of
better assistance in the purchasing process. Investments require a high amount of involvement
and information. Awareness naturally flows from the advertisements, personal selling, and social
media pertinent to the consumer decision process.
Recommendations
Based on the data that was analyzed and collected, LCMS members desire several main
characteristics concerning financial investments and opportunities:
1. Greater awareness of LCEF services
2. Clean and simplistic presentation of information
3. Easy accessibility
4. Transparency and personalization of service
This aligns with the characteristics involved in high involvement purchasing decisions, which
include monetary investments. Therefore, it would be pertinent to create an investment process
that is simplistic and personal in order to reduce post-purchase cognitive dissonance.
The Big Idea
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 13
The big idea that was selected for this campaign was designed to generate awareness of LCEF
and appease the needs of LCMS members. “WE ARE LCEF.” is a strong, unified message that
can be translated and related easily to the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. “WE ARE LCEF.”
conveys a powerful message and presence that will inspire LCMS members and eliminate the
lack of awareness that currently exists.
By instituting this new brand, LCEF is informing LCMS members that together, we are
expanding God’s kingdom. This campaign is the beginning of a movement among LCMS
members to unite together to provide strength in service. Through each LCEF investment
opportunity, we are empowering others to spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ while our own
finances grow. We need to educate our current and future members of what services LCEF
provides to ensure God’s mission is accomplished. With our LCMS members coming together
we ensure funds are available now and in the future. Together, WE ARE LCEF.
The tagline of “WE ARE LCEF.” will be delivered throughout the campaign.
Based off of the thorough research that was conducted, the following recommendations are
suggested:
1. Bus Tour
Initiating a summer bus tour to LCMS districts and congregations will increase awareness of
LCEF to LCMS members in an un-masked and personal manner. Not only does a bus tour
command attention, but it also provides a fun way for LCMS members to gather together in His
name and learn about the offerings of LCEF. It also brings the information to the congregation
members, making it easily accessible.
To begin, five informed LCEF representatives would be selected to participate in the month and
a half long summer tour. These representatives will stop at a highly populated congregation in
each district every two days. This allows time for preparation and travel between congregations
and allows for members from surrounding, smaller congregations to commute to the larger, more
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 14
populated area. The congregations that were selected for stops were based on location, a high
population, and average attendance. Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Illinois, and Wisconsin were
selected for tour stops for this campaign.
The tour is designed to be small enough to be a test run for the rest of the districts, but large
enough to gauge the effect of the tour. The first stop will be on July 8th, 2015 in Sauk Rapids,
Minnesota, and will conclude on August 18th, 2015, in Woodbury, Minnesota.
Figure 1. Example of the bus wrap
Upon arrival to the predetermined stops, the representatives will deliver a 30-45 minute
presentation on LCEF and how it can serve the congregation and ultimately, the LCMS as a
whole. After the presentation, members will have the opportunity to speak with the
representatives and sign up for an informative email list and whichever programs they desire to
learn more about. To gain further opportunities to inform and build relationships with LCMS
members, a barbeque cookout will also follow, allowing time for food and fellowship. These
relationships will generate positive “word of mouth” promotions around each district, allowing
the awareness of LCEF to grow drastically.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 15
When the bus tour concludes, it is important for district and congregation LCEF representatives
to make follow-ups with the congregations visited. Uniform training and consistent
communication allows for a unified message from LCEF. It also gives members the opportunity
to sign up for programs or donate to causes on a regular basis. Consumers need to be reminded
of products and services provided and follow-ups to these congregations will help with that.
2. Print Ads
The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign will be utilizing print ads to cover three pieces of information.
 Bus Tour dates
 LCEF investments
 LCEF member testimonials
These print ads will consist of clean, simplistic and attractive visuals explain information in a
relatively uncomplicated manner.
Each print ad can be converted to multiple forms of print media. For instance, the size can easily
be adjusted from a magazine print, poster, a bulletin or handout size without losing important
information.
The print ads will be distributed through LCMS publications including the Lutheran Witness, the
Reporter newspaper, the Portals of Prayer and the Lutheran annual. These print ads will also be
featured on the LCEF website, as well as LCEF’s social media sites such as Facebook and
Twitter.
Posters will also be distributed to each LCMS congregation that is featured on the bus tour and
will be sent to all LCMS congregations after the tour. These ads will be included as an insert into
the bulletin and have available in the narthex, or where ever the congregation keeps pamphlets.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 16
Figure 2. Bus tour print ad that advertises the dates and locations of the summer tour
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 17
Figure 3. Print testimonials that provide quotes from LCMS members about LCEF
Figure 4.
LCEF
Investment print ad explaining specific investment opportunities
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 18
3. Website
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 19
To complement a clean, simplistic, and attractive formatting of information, a new user-friendly
website design was created. LCMS members have suggested that information be user friendly,
easily accessible, and not overwhelming. The website was designed to inform the visitor of
LCEF services and events while remaining uncomplicated to retain their attention. It highlights
the bus tour and seamlessly incorporates the print ads. Each page of the website captures the
“WE ARE” tagline by displaying the following phrases on the stated website page.
 WE ARE LCEF. (Home Page)
 WE ARE HERE. (Bus Tour Page)
 WE ARE GROWING. (Get Involved Page)
 WE ARE ONE. (Community Page)
 WE ARE READY. (Contact Page)
These phrases leading into each website page will give the viewer a sense of unity, which
corresponds with our campaign slogan of “WE ARE LCEF.”
The website Home page will feature the mission statement and vision of the “WE ARE LCEF.”
Campaign. It will also display a new short video that is meant to provide a visual to the
campaign’s vision.
Figure 5. LCEF Home page
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 20
The Bus Tour page will provide a short statement regarding the purpose of the Bus Tour and
what is included at each event. This statement is meant to give LCMS members a strong
understanding of what to look forward to. To conclude the page, the Bus Tour infographic will
be on display so that each LCMS member can view when and where the next tour stop is.
Figure 6. LCEF Bus Tour page
The Get Involved page features every investment opportunity presented by the LCEF displayed
as an infographic. As mentioned earlier, these infographics present financial information on each
investment in a very uncomplicated and appealing way. A new feature on this page is to also
display the most popular investment opportunities presented by the LCEF. This will promote a
sense of transparency with each member as well as inform them of what their fellow members
are utilizing.
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 21
Figure 7. LCEF Get Involved page
The Community page will display LCMS member testimonials and pictures from recent LCEF
projects and funding initiatives. These pictures and testimonials will help the LCEF build trust
with LCMS members and generate a sense of transparency. By displaying how LCEF is involved
in the spreading of the Gospel will encourage more members to contribute.
Figure 8. LCEF Community page
The
Contact page will display multiple features that will allow LCMS members to become connected
with the LCEF. The first feature is a contact form that is sent directly from the website that will
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 22
contain the users name, email address and question. This form is sent automatically to the
preferred email address. The next feature is an interactive map that is programmed to locate the
nearest LCEF representative in relation to the user’s location. The map will then pull up the
representative name, location, email address and phone number. This will give the user all
information in an easily accessible way. The last feature that displayed is a live chat option. This
allows visitors to ask questions and immediately receive answers from an LCEF representative.
This chat option would be live during normal business hours allowing personalization and
convenience to each member.
Figure 9. LCEF Contact page
Located at the bottom of each page are links to every social media page run by the Lutheran
Church Extension Fund. These social media pages have been redesigned to display the clean and
simplistic look of the website.
Figure 10. Social media icons at the bottom of each web page
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 23
4. Social Media
Each social media profile picture and cover photo has been redesigned to display the clean and
simplistic look of the website as well as the “WE ARE LCEF.” Tagline.
Figure 11. LCEF Facebook Page
Fig
ure
12.
LC
EF
Twi
tter
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 24
Page
Figure 13. LCEF YouTube Page
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 25
Figure 14. LCEF Vimeo Page
Figure 15. LCEF LinkedIn Page
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 26
Managing numerous social media accounts can be difficult, especially when trying to increase
LCMS member interactions. To combat this, we will be utilizing a third party site called
Hootsuite, which combines all social media accounts into one site. This allows for quick
response time, generating great interactions. Also, this site allows you to schedule future posts
that will be posted on each selected site at the time and date specified. This feature enables LCEF
to become more active on social media sites while increasing personal interactions by responding
to members quickly.
5. “WE ARE LCEF.” Commercial and Radio Ads
The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign features two new commercials and a new radio ad that
captures what it means to contribute to LCEF. The commercials will be available on LCEF’s
Website, YouTube and Vimeo pages as well as the Lutheran Hour. The radio ad will be aired
exclusively on the KFUO radio station and the Lutheran Hour.
Figure 16. LCEF Commercial Snapshot
Campaign Budget
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 27
The Bus Tour holds the greatest weight of the marketing campaign budget because of the
benefits that it offers. It will allow LCEF staff to communicate face to face with LCMS members
about investment opportunities through LCEF. With this in mind, $193,000 of the budget will be
dedicated to the bus tour. Finances have been allocated for the travel to and from the
congregations, wages, lodging, food, travel for the respective district representatives, and
miscellaneous expenses.
Print Ads will be a vital tool in the campaign, and will be utilized in many aspects. The finances
allotted will fulfill the printing requirement needed. $60,000 will be used on the print ads causing
them to be easily accessible which allows for LCMS members to become aware of all personal,
ministry, and business partnerships.
The live chat capability featured on the LCEF website is designed to further the interaction with
LCEF investors looking for information about products and services. The interaction with the
consumer will create a sense of trust in LCEF as a ministry partner, furthering the spreading of
the gospel by the finances they are investing. The $55,000 allocated to the live chat includes the
additional staff to handle the increased volume of interactions. The budget will also be utilized in
the design, upkeep of the chat technology, and wages.
Social media, commercial advertisement, and radio advertisement will also play a key role in the
increasing of awareness among LCMS members of LCEF investment opportunities. $42,000 will
be used to create and air the content.
Figure 17. Breakdown of Budget
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 28
Implementation Process
To implement the recommendations suggested, an eight-step process was created. This process
gives order and structure to the recommendations as well as a generic timeline for when events
should occur. Below, Figure 17 shows the implementation process in detail.
Figure 18. Implementation Process
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 29
Conclusion
The Lutheran Church Extension Fund acts as a financial partner for schools, congregations, and
rostered church workers associated with the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. It is the lending
arm of the LCMS and works to plant, sustain, and revitalize distinctly LCMS churches and
institutions. However, LCEF has been under-utilized in the LCMS due primarily to a lack of
awareness. Through extensive research, it has been discovered that LCMS members are looking
for three main qualities in a financial investment company:
 Greater awareness of services
 Clean and simplistic presentation of information
 Easy accessibility
 Transparency and personalization
The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign is designed to dramatically increase brand awareness and meet
the needs of LCMS members. Using these multiple, integrated tactics that utilize personal
outreach, awareness can be gained by LCMS members and congregations. This plan is multi-
tiered and dimensional in order to reach and unify members of all ages. The bus tour, print
advertising, social media, and other tactics demonstrate a creative yet traditional approach that
brings information to members while increasing trust, involvement, strength, and awareness.
References
 About LCEF. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://lcef.org/about/index.cfm
ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 30
 Hawkins, D., & Mothersbaugh, D. (2010). Consumer Behavior: Building Marketing
Strategy(11th ed., p. 133). New York: McGraw-Hill Irwin.
 Member Profile. (2007, January 1). Retrieved February 1, 2015, from
http://www.thearda.com/Denoms/D_887_p.asp
 MyAccount. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from
http://lcef.org/myaccount/index.cfm
 PartnerPLUS Term Note. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from
http://lcef.org/investments/partnerplus-bus.cfm
 Planned Giving. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://gifting.lcef.org/
 Summary of Key Findings. (2008, January 1). Retrieved February 2, 2015, from
http://religions.pewforum.org/reports
 Third 2014 Charter Will Provide Affordable Financial Services to the Lutheran Church –
Missouri Synod. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from
http://www.ncua.gov/News/Pages/NW20141223Charter.aspx

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Dussehra 2015
Dussehra 2015Dussehra 2015
Dussehra 2015ixigo.com
 
Presentation and bitstrips
Presentation and bitstripsPresentation and bitstrips
Presentation and bitstripssamr300
 
Most Beautiful Villages In India
Most Beautiful Villages In IndiaMost Beautiful Villages In India
Most Beautiful Villages In Indiaixigo.com
 
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand Carrie Kerpen
 
The ROI of Trust in Social Selling
The ROI of Trust in Social SellingThe ROI of Trust in Social Selling
The ROI of Trust in Social SellingBarbara Giamanco
 
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)TrackMaven
 
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social MediaConstant Contact
 
Amazon ppt
Amazon pptAmazon ppt
Amazon pptaftabssm
 
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media Post
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media PostHow to Create the Perfect Social-Media Post
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media PostGuy Kawasaki
 
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and Twitter
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and TwitterHow Often Should You Post to Facebook and Twitter
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and TwitterBuffer
 
Amazon.com Strategic Analysis
Amazon.com Strategic AnalysisAmazon.com Strategic Analysis
Amazon.com Strategic AnalysisMax Jallifier
 
How to Determine the ROI of Anything
How to Determine the ROI of AnythingHow to Determine the ROI of Anything
How to Determine the ROI of AnythingGary Vaynerchuk
 
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media StrategyMark Schaefer
 
Trump and Hitler Compared
Trump and Hitler ComparedTrump and Hitler Compared
Trump and Hitler ComparedTom Richey
 
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!XPLAIN
 
Why Content Marketing Fails
Why Content Marketing FailsWhy Content Marketing Fails
Why Content Marketing FailsRand Fishkin
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Dussehra 2015
Dussehra 2015Dussehra 2015
Dussehra 2015
 
Presentation and bitstrips
Presentation and bitstripsPresentation and bitstrips
Presentation and bitstrips
 
Bitstrips
BitstripsBitstrips
Bitstrips
 
Most Beautiful Villages In India
Most Beautiful Villages In IndiaMost Beautiful Villages In India
Most Beautiful Villages In India
 
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand
Be a Digital Trailblazer When Building Your Brand
 
The ROI of Trust in Social Selling
The ROI of Trust in Social SellingThe ROI of Trust in Social Selling
The ROI of Trust in Social Selling
 
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)
A Complete Guide To The Best Times To Post On Social Media (And More!)
 
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media
50 Expert Tips for Getting Started on Social Media
 
Amazon ppt
Amazon pptAmazon ppt
Amazon ppt
 
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media Post
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media PostHow to Create the Perfect Social-Media Post
How to Create the Perfect Social-Media Post
 
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and Twitter
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and TwitterHow Often Should You Post to Facebook and Twitter
How Often Should You Post to Facebook and Twitter
 
Amazon.com Strategic Analysis
Amazon.com Strategic AnalysisAmazon.com Strategic Analysis
Amazon.com Strategic Analysis
 
How to Determine the ROI of Anything
How to Determine the ROI of AnythingHow to Determine the ROI of Anything
How to Determine the ROI of Anything
 
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy
6 Questions to Lead You to a Social Media Strategy
 
Trump and Hitler Compared
Trump and Hitler ComparedTrump and Hitler Compared
Trump and Hitler Compared
 
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!
Go Viral on the Social Web: The Definitive How-To guide!
 
Why Content Marketing Fails
Why Content Marketing FailsWhy Content Marketing Fails
Why Content Marketing Fails
 

Similar to LCEF Final

2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final
2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final
2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_finalShane O'Farrell
 
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor Relationship
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor RelationshipCASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor Relationship
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor RelationshipMarc Whitt
 
Campaign 377 final
Campaign 377 finalCampaign 377 final
Campaign 377 finalBrad Johnson
 
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needs
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit NeedsBoomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needs
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needsazgrantmakers
 
Engaging older adults as untapped resources 04-2011 - ch
Engaging older adults as untapped resources   04-2011 - chEngaging older adults as untapped resources   04-2011 - ch
Engaging older adults as untapped resources 04-2011 - chazgrantmakers
 
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016Marci Gaines
 
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_Morrissey
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_MorrisseyA Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_Morrissey
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_MorrisseyOlivia Morrissey
 
Psychological Services Marketing
Psychological Services MarketingPsychological Services Marketing
Psychological Services MarketingAndrewCorliss2
 
Psychological Service PLan Book
Psychological Service PLan BookPsychological Service PLan Book
Psychological Service PLan BookAndrew Corliss
 
PR470 UT Campaign Proposal
PR470 UT Campaign ProposalPR470 UT Campaign Proposal
PR470 UT Campaign ProposalVirginia Nagy
 
Client Report FINAL copy
Client Report FINAL copyClient Report FINAL copy
Client Report FINAL copyToni Setaro
 
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...Alexandra Lashner
 
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...Diane Allen
 

Similar to LCEF Final (20)

2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final
2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final
2 HomesofHope_campaign_booklet_final
 
Internship report 2
Internship report 2Internship report 2
Internship report 2
 
IHLF Research Report
IHLF Research ReportIHLF Research Report
IHLF Research Report
 
SOSC Final Campaign
SOSC Final CampaignSOSC Final Campaign
SOSC Final Campaign
 
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor Relationship
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor RelationshipCASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor Relationship
CASE16 Communications for Lasting Donor Relationship
 
Campaign 377 final
Campaign 377 finalCampaign 377 final
Campaign 377 final
 
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needs
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit NeedsBoomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needs
Boomer Solution: Skilled Talent to Meet Nonprofit Needs
 
Engaging older adults as untapped resources 04-2011 - ch
Engaging older adults as untapped resources   04-2011 - chEngaging older adults as untapped resources   04-2011 - ch
Engaging older adults as untapped resources 04-2011 - ch
 
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016
Capstone_ Marci E. Gaines_July 2016
 
A3: Strength in difference: Practical ways to address board diversity
A3: Strength in difference: Practical ways to address board diversityA3: Strength in difference: Practical ways to address board diversity
A3: Strength in difference: Practical ways to address board diversity
 
MomentumArticle
MomentumArticleMomentumArticle
MomentumArticle
 
Momentum article
Momentum articleMomentum article
Momentum article
 
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_Morrissey
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_MorrisseyA Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_Morrissey
A Strategic Communications Campaign_BFKS_Morrissey
 
Psychological Services Marketing
Psychological Services MarketingPsychological Services Marketing
Psychological Services Marketing
 
Psychological Service PLan Book
Psychological Service PLan BookPsychological Service PLan Book
Psychological Service PLan Book
 
PR470 UT Campaign Proposal
PR470 UT Campaign ProposalPR470 UT Campaign Proposal
PR470 UT Campaign Proposal
 
Client Report FINAL copy
Client Report FINAL copyClient Report FINAL copy
Client Report FINAL copy
 
Campaigns
CampaignsCampaigns
Campaigns
 
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...
Revolution Communication Planbook - Millersville University; Public Relations...
 
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...
Role Of A Care Coordinator At The Community Care Access...
 

LCEF Final

  • 1. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 1 2015 LCEF National Marketing Competition Prepared By Dillon LaHaye Hillary Minnaert Nancy Mohammed Thomas Obarski Brandon Wagner Faculty Advisor: Dr. Nancy Harrower April 10th, 2015
  • 2. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 2 Contents Executive Summary............................................................................................................................3 Background........................................................................................................................................4 Objective ...........................................................................................................................................4 Target Market.....................................................................................................................................4 Sample Selection ................................................................................................................................5 Methodologies....................................................................................................................................5 Data Analysis .....................................................................................................................................5 Survey Analysis..............................................................................................................................5 Interview Analysis ..........................................................................................................................9 Consumer Decision Process ..............................................................................................................12 Recommendations ............................................................................................................................12 The Big Idea ....................................................................................................................................12 1. Bus Tour ..................................................................................................................................13 2. Print Ads ..................................................................................................................................15 3. Website ....................................................................................................................................18 5. “WE ARE LCEF.” Commercial and Radio Ads ..........................................................................26 Campaign Budget.............................................................................................................................26 Implementation Process ....................................................................................................................28 Conclusion.......................................................................................................................................29 References .......................................................................................................................................29
  • 3. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 3 Executive Summary The Lutheran Church Extension Fund (LCEF) was founded to serve and assist members and workers belonging to the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod (LCMS). In 1978, the Lutheran Church Extension Fund was incorporated to provide financial resources, investment, support services and loans and gifts to help minister, witness and provide outreach for the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. Within the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, past history and member education indicates a lack of awareness of the Lutheran Church Extension Fund and its many services. In order to understand the extent of this problem, primary and secondary research was conducted for five weeks. Detailed surveys were administered to LCMS students and faculty at Concordia University St Paul. Personal, phone, and electronic interviews were also carried out with Concordia University faculty, as well as a number of LCMS members and leaders in the community. The largest barrier is the overall lack of awareness of LCEF, its services and mission. Through data analysis, it was discovered that LCMS members were looking for four main qualities when considering financial investments and opportunities: 1. Greater awareness of LCEF services 2. Clean and simplistic presentation of information 3. Easy accessibility to services 4. Transparency and personalization of service In order to satisfy the needs of the consumers, as well as ease the concerns that accompany a high involvement purchasing decision, a strong, high-impact campaign has been developed to build awareness of LCEF and its services offered. The forefront of the campaign is the tag line “WE ARE LCEF.” which projects unity and strength while projecting awareness. A number of marketing tactics are recommended to accomplish this: 1. Summer Midwest bus tour to build awareness and give personal service 2. Implement print ads, commercials and radio to build awareness 3. Launch a user-friendly website to improve online involvement 4. Redesign social media sites to increase interaction with members
  • 4. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 4 Background The Lutheran Church Extension Fund (LCEF) has been in existence for 37 years, financially assisting and supporting the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod (LCMS). It was created in order to serve the LCMS by providing financial services that allow the LCMS to sustain its ministry and expand its outreach. Of the 2.2 million baptized LCMS members, LCEF currently provides services to more than 50,000 people. LCEF offers investments, loans, ministry resources, stewardship education, and financial services to LCMS members and actively works to help grow and sustain the church. Under a unified cause, LCEF has strength in service. Objective The objective of the research team for the 2015 LCEF National Student Marketing Competition was to develop a comprehensive marketing plan that will raise awareness of LCEF in the LCMS community. The goal of the research team was to develop a multi-tiered marketing plan that will inspire and motivate LCMS members to diligently and actively develop a partnership through an investment, loan, gift, or use of a support service nationwide. The campaign and creative marketing recommendations in this plan will include the history, tradition, mission and values set forth by LCEF and LCMS members. The creative and advanced focus implemented will continue to support the mission to share the Gospel of Jesus Christ, provide LCEF resources to empower ministries in Kingdom work and improve awareness of the many services that are available to LCMS members of all ages. Target Market The population for this study was easily determined by the objective, which was given by LCEF. In order to raise awareness of LCEF in the LCMS, individuals in those congregations must be considered the primary population. Parameters for the population include the following:  Current LCMS member  Currently employed by an LCMS institution, such as a church, school, or university  Affiliated with an LCMS institution, such as a church, school, or university
  • 5. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 5 Sample Selection Convenience sampling was the primary method of sampling used in this study. Convenience sampling is the act of the researcher selecting those to participate in the study based on a close proximity to the researcher and convenience. This means that surveys were sent to faculty and staff along with students at Concordia University St Paul who are either enrolled in a church work program or listed themselves as LCMS members when initially applying for Concordia University. Methodologies In order to further explore and understand the current level of awareness of LCEF among LCMS members, interviews were conducted with LCMS members, LCMS pastors and church workers, and Concordia University St Paul staff and professors. Emails were exchanged and interviews occurred with 11 different individuals over the course of two weeks. In addition to interviews, surveys were sent to faculty, staff, and students at Concordia University St. Paul. Group members also sent surveys to personal contacts such as family and friends who are LCMS members or church workers. Data Analysis Survey Analysis A survey was created in order to glean a stronger understanding of the current level of awareness of LCEF within the selected LCMS sample population. The survey was sent to faculty and staff members at Concordia University St Paul, as well as to students who are currently enrolled in a church work program or are identified as LCMS members on the Concordia University St Paul application. Overall, 258 responses were collected from the total group of 543 recipients. The following graphs reflect the data and information analyzed. 1. Have you heard of the Lutheran Church Extension Fund? This question was designed to discover how many people in the sample size have heard of LCEF. There were 178 people who responded to this question with 70.79% having heard of LCEF while 29.21% of respondents have not heard of LCEF.
  • 6. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 6 2. Where did you hear about the Lutheran Church Extension Fund? This question asked participants to select all that applied to where they heard about LCEF. It was revealed that of the respondents that have heard of LCEF, 78.18% heard about LCEF through a congregation. School/University served as the second highest source of information at 43.64%, followed by Friends/Family at 41.82%. This suggests that congregation members are the most responsible for the spread of LCEF awareness. 3. At which financial institution do you currently bank? Survey data shows that only 8% of the participants bank with LCEF. Of those surveyed, 44% use banks, 20% bank with credit unions, and 18% prefer Thrivent. This shows that even among LCMS members, the involvement in LCEF is low and suggests that the biggest competition for LCEF are banks.
  • 7. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 7 4. How do you access financial information? Data shows that most people surveyed preferred to access financial information online; 56.5% used search engines, 49.7% used news websites, and 43.5% preferred using smartphone and tablet Apps. Among conventional methods; which are newspapers, magazines and television, newspapers were the most popular. 5. What forms of media do you use on a daily basis? Most of the participants used online media daily. Only 12% of the respondents used printed media daily. This shows the importance of having a strong presence online in order to provide information and services to customers.
  • 8. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 8 In the open-ended responses, many common themes were discovered. These themes were summarized and quotes were extracted. 6. How can the Lutheran Church Extension Fund improve to meet your needs?  Provide more information so we are aware of how it can help us  More savings option  Clear content about the financial services they offer  Promote savings for young people to go to college, scholarships  Share information on campus  Speakers explain its services to congregation and other groups  Offer workshops  Become more accessible locally Some direct quotes from this question include: “Work with HR at Concordia to educate us on their offerings.” “Continue to offer new products, such as student credit union and student loans options. Continue to run the organization with low overhead in order to be able to offer competitive interest rates on investment products.” “As a student, scholarships would be good. I know one is offered, but it confused me so much I didn’t bother applying.” 7. What are your views on the Lutheran Church Extension Fund?  Great Mission- using invested dollars for capital projects in LCMS congregations, schools, colleges, and universities
  • 9. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 9  Great way to mix savings and ministry  Great resource for the Lutheran church and its members. It offers a vast number of resources that can help people plan for the future  An excellent fund  Good value for good cause  Very positive  Support it Some direct quotes from this question include: “LCEF can be clear, reliably, that they are a church organization. That means 1) We don’t have FDIC and similar protection; 2) We are making a difference for what the church can do in the world and the interest rates are good.” “They are an admirable and useful Christ-centered service for those seeking financial help in furthering God’s kingdom.” 8. How can the Lutheran Church extension fund improve its awareness in the community?  Advertising on Concordia campus  Congregation flyers  Active representatives in each LCMS congregation seems the best way to supplement direct mail, social media, and online presences.  Support local mission projects  Word of mouth  Provide more information about what they do in particular  Connecting to the younger generation  Partner with Thrivent to build stronger portfolios for investors  Provide more information on what it does with the funds Some direct quotes from this question include: “Any projects they fund/ support could include prominent name placement (e.g., when a church is built using LCEF funds, the construction company billboard could include a citation for LCEF, also describing what it is.)” “Have a brief video about LCEF that could be played after church service or during a adult/children bible study or Sunday school hour.” Interview Analysis Eleven interviews were conducted with LCMS Pastors, Concordia University professors and LCMS members. The main objectives of the research was to gain a stronger understanding of
  • 10. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 10 LCMS awareness in general and in LCMS churches, how to increase LCEF awareness to church members and communities in which they are located, and how this impacts LCMS individuals and communities. The following information is a summary of the interviews that were conducted. 1. Have you heard of the LCEF (Lutheran Church Extension Fund)? How have you heard of it? The first question asked if the interviewee has heard of LCEF and how they heard of LCEF. Of those interviewed, 9 out of 11 have heard of LCEF from being a member of a LCMS church or from the Concordia University setting. One associate LCMS pastor did not know about LCEF until a district LCEF representative informed him of the organization during his orientation to his assigned church. One LCMS member was only aware of the Young Investors club but not LCEF, another LCMS member had never heard of LCEF. 2. Have you contributed before? Of the 11 people interviewed, only two have contributed to LCEF. 3. Of what services are you aware? Even though many interviewed had heard of LCEF, there was still a low or vague awareness of which services are offered. One interviewee shared, “I have heard of LCEF because of a re- roofing project for the church that was done a couple of years ago, but I do not invest with them and don’t know what they offer.” 4. What are your views of LCEF? Of those who are aware of LCEF, there was a favorable opinion. A campus pastor for Concordia University St Paul said, “They are a real good thing. They are positive for churches and growth, and are a safe investment.” After describing LCEF to those who were unaware, those interviewed saw potential opportunities for congregations to grow and expand in His word and service. One LCMS Pastor and Concordia University professor who is an LCEF investor shared, “I have a very positive view of LCEF as they have done much good for the LCMS in expanding God's Word, and I have also benefited professionally from my relationship with the LCEF as a guest to their state and national conventions.” 5. How do you feel LCEF can increase awareness among LCMS members? Many suggested the power that comes with suggestions from personal friends or congregation members and the spreading of word of mouth. It was also suggested to provide information on services offered to LCMS members by flyers, handouts, or videos. 6. How do you feel LCEF can improve on their services offered?
  • 11. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 11 Some were not aware of the services offered by LCEF and felt that overall improvement of awareness was essential before considering improvement of services. Those who did know of the services thought that a simple, clean, and user-friendly approach would be best for LCEF. 7. Do you have any personal examples of how LCEF has benefited your life, congregation, or community? The following are a few testimonials from the interviews: “The first congregation to which I was called invested with and took out loans from the LCEF to fund a building project that doubled the usable space of its campus. Good rates and great mission made LCEF a perfect partner.” “Both in my congregation where offerings where not always very high they were very forgiving of us when we had to very slow with payments. They allowed us to go on a payment schedule. In fact they refinance the whole thing very easily to make the process easier. Personally I did a consolidation loan through LCEF that ended up having very favorable terms and it was very easy process to take some debt and consolidate it and they mandated as part of that. We got rid of our credit cards. They went through debt counseling so I think that it was a very helpful process that they put us through.” “In my life the savings account gave a percentage to certain Lutheran organizations that I wanted to support; building programs at my current congregation have made use of LCEF to finance the project.” 8. How important is it for a business to have community or congregation involvement? In general, most individuals who were interviewed felt that the involvement of businesses in the community is not only helpful to the business in the long run, but a very positive influence on the community. Some individuals felt that they would be more inclined to donate or patronize a business if it were supporting a local cause or congregation. 9. How do you/your community currently put on fund raisers? Where do you look for financial support and contributions? “We go to our school families for bi-annual fundraisers (in the spring it is a walk-a-thon which is fun for the whole family [and extended family]…while in the fall we put on a banquet that is more “upscale” and intended only for adults and their friends).” 10. Do you (or your family) have a financial advisor? Six people interviewed have financial advisors, one of whom is through Thrivent. 11. How do you currently access financial information? Six people interviewed said that they access financial information though newspapers. Others said through magazines, websites, employers, and news websites. 12. Do you currently use any other banking institutions and why? Many interviewed said that they use banks because they are FDIC insured and convenient. One person said that they use Thrivent because it is well-known.
  • 12. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 12 Consumer Decision Process Investment and saving choices are considered high involvement purchases that require a lot of time and energy. High involvement purchasing decisions are typically concerned with high dollar values or large personal consequences. During this process, consumers typically consider many different brands, sellers, and product attributes. A considerable amount of time is usually spent searching for information on the topic and many external information sources are used. After high involvement purchases are made, there is a higher likelihood that the consumer will experience post-purchase cognitive dissonance. This means that the tendency to experience psychological tension or anxiety is much higher after making a high dollar purchase. Individuals making investments fall into this category. In order to alleviate the concerns experienced in a high involvement purchase, such as investments and savings, it is necessary to provide the consumer with a large amount of comprehensible information. Marketers supply consumers with necessary information via advertisements, personal selling, and social media. These things make the decision process easier for the consumer. Companies also use advertising to reinforce the right purchasing decision the consumer has made. It is necessary to understand the internal debate the consumer goes through in order to be of better assistance in the purchasing process. Investments require a high amount of involvement and information. Awareness naturally flows from the advertisements, personal selling, and social media pertinent to the consumer decision process. Recommendations Based on the data that was analyzed and collected, LCMS members desire several main characteristics concerning financial investments and opportunities: 1. Greater awareness of LCEF services 2. Clean and simplistic presentation of information 3. Easy accessibility 4. Transparency and personalization of service This aligns with the characteristics involved in high involvement purchasing decisions, which include monetary investments. Therefore, it would be pertinent to create an investment process that is simplistic and personal in order to reduce post-purchase cognitive dissonance. The Big Idea
  • 13. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 13 The big idea that was selected for this campaign was designed to generate awareness of LCEF and appease the needs of LCMS members. “WE ARE LCEF.” is a strong, unified message that can be translated and related easily to the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. “WE ARE LCEF.” conveys a powerful message and presence that will inspire LCMS members and eliminate the lack of awareness that currently exists. By instituting this new brand, LCEF is informing LCMS members that together, we are expanding God’s kingdom. This campaign is the beginning of a movement among LCMS members to unite together to provide strength in service. Through each LCEF investment opportunity, we are empowering others to spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ while our own finances grow. We need to educate our current and future members of what services LCEF provides to ensure God’s mission is accomplished. With our LCMS members coming together we ensure funds are available now and in the future. Together, WE ARE LCEF. The tagline of “WE ARE LCEF.” will be delivered throughout the campaign. Based off of the thorough research that was conducted, the following recommendations are suggested: 1. Bus Tour Initiating a summer bus tour to LCMS districts and congregations will increase awareness of LCEF to LCMS members in an un-masked and personal manner. Not only does a bus tour command attention, but it also provides a fun way for LCMS members to gather together in His name and learn about the offerings of LCEF. It also brings the information to the congregation members, making it easily accessible. To begin, five informed LCEF representatives would be selected to participate in the month and a half long summer tour. These representatives will stop at a highly populated congregation in each district every two days. This allows time for preparation and travel between congregations and allows for members from surrounding, smaller congregations to commute to the larger, more
  • 14. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 14 populated area. The congregations that were selected for stops were based on location, a high population, and average attendance. Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Illinois, and Wisconsin were selected for tour stops for this campaign. The tour is designed to be small enough to be a test run for the rest of the districts, but large enough to gauge the effect of the tour. The first stop will be on July 8th, 2015 in Sauk Rapids, Minnesota, and will conclude on August 18th, 2015, in Woodbury, Minnesota. Figure 1. Example of the bus wrap Upon arrival to the predetermined stops, the representatives will deliver a 30-45 minute presentation on LCEF and how it can serve the congregation and ultimately, the LCMS as a whole. After the presentation, members will have the opportunity to speak with the representatives and sign up for an informative email list and whichever programs they desire to learn more about. To gain further opportunities to inform and build relationships with LCMS members, a barbeque cookout will also follow, allowing time for food and fellowship. These relationships will generate positive “word of mouth” promotions around each district, allowing the awareness of LCEF to grow drastically.
  • 15. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 15 When the bus tour concludes, it is important for district and congregation LCEF representatives to make follow-ups with the congregations visited. Uniform training and consistent communication allows for a unified message from LCEF. It also gives members the opportunity to sign up for programs or donate to causes on a regular basis. Consumers need to be reminded of products and services provided and follow-ups to these congregations will help with that. 2. Print Ads The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign will be utilizing print ads to cover three pieces of information.  Bus Tour dates  LCEF investments  LCEF member testimonials These print ads will consist of clean, simplistic and attractive visuals explain information in a relatively uncomplicated manner. Each print ad can be converted to multiple forms of print media. For instance, the size can easily be adjusted from a magazine print, poster, a bulletin or handout size without losing important information. The print ads will be distributed through LCMS publications including the Lutheran Witness, the Reporter newspaper, the Portals of Prayer and the Lutheran annual. These print ads will also be featured on the LCEF website, as well as LCEF’s social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter. Posters will also be distributed to each LCMS congregation that is featured on the bus tour and will be sent to all LCMS congregations after the tour. These ads will be included as an insert into the bulletin and have available in the narthex, or where ever the congregation keeps pamphlets.
  • 16. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 16 Figure 2. Bus tour print ad that advertises the dates and locations of the summer tour
  • 17. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 17 Figure 3. Print testimonials that provide quotes from LCMS members about LCEF Figure 4. LCEF Investment print ad explaining specific investment opportunities
  • 19. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 19 To complement a clean, simplistic, and attractive formatting of information, a new user-friendly website design was created. LCMS members have suggested that information be user friendly, easily accessible, and not overwhelming. The website was designed to inform the visitor of LCEF services and events while remaining uncomplicated to retain their attention. It highlights the bus tour and seamlessly incorporates the print ads. Each page of the website captures the “WE ARE” tagline by displaying the following phrases on the stated website page.  WE ARE LCEF. (Home Page)  WE ARE HERE. (Bus Tour Page)  WE ARE GROWING. (Get Involved Page)  WE ARE ONE. (Community Page)  WE ARE READY. (Contact Page) These phrases leading into each website page will give the viewer a sense of unity, which corresponds with our campaign slogan of “WE ARE LCEF.” The website Home page will feature the mission statement and vision of the “WE ARE LCEF.” Campaign. It will also display a new short video that is meant to provide a visual to the campaign’s vision. Figure 5. LCEF Home page
  • 20. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 20 The Bus Tour page will provide a short statement regarding the purpose of the Bus Tour and what is included at each event. This statement is meant to give LCMS members a strong understanding of what to look forward to. To conclude the page, the Bus Tour infographic will be on display so that each LCMS member can view when and where the next tour stop is. Figure 6. LCEF Bus Tour page The Get Involved page features every investment opportunity presented by the LCEF displayed as an infographic. As mentioned earlier, these infographics present financial information on each investment in a very uncomplicated and appealing way. A new feature on this page is to also display the most popular investment opportunities presented by the LCEF. This will promote a sense of transparency with each member as well as inform them of what their fellow members are utilizing.
  • 21. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 21 Figure 7. LCEF Get Involved page The Community page will display LCMS member testimonials and pictures from recent LCEF projects and funding initiatives. These pictures and testimonials will help the LCEF build trust with LCMS members and generate a sense of transparency. By displaying how LCEF is involved in the spreading of the Gospel will encourage more members to contribute. Figure 8. LCEF Community page The Contact page will display multiple features that will allow LCMS members to become connected with the LCEF. The first feature is a contact form that is sent directly from the website that will
  • 22. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 22 contain the users name, email address and question. This form is sent automatically to the preferred email address. The next feature is an interactive map that is programmed to locate the nearest LCEF representative in relation to the user’s location. The map will then pull up the representative name, location, email address and phone number. This will give the user all information in an easily accessible way. The last feature that displayed is a live chat option. This allows visitors to ask questions and immediately receive answers from an LCEF representative. This chat option would be live during normal business hours allowing personalization and convenience to each member. Figure 9. LCEF Contact page Located at the bottom of each page are links to every social media page run by the Lutheran Church Extension Fund. These social media pages have been redesigned to display the clean and simplistic look of the website. Figure 10. Social media icons at the bottom of each web page
  • 23. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 23 4. Social Media Each social media profile picture and cover photo has been redesigned to display the clean and simplistic look of the website as well as the “WE ARE LCEF.” Tagline. Figure 11. LCEF Facebook Page Fig ure 12. LC EF Twi tter
  • 25. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 25 Figure 14. LCEF Vimeo Page Figure 15. LCEF LinkedIn Page
  • 26. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 26 Managing numerous social media accounts can be difficult, especially when trying to increase LCMS member interactions. To combat this, we will be utilizing a third party site called Hootsuite, which combines all social media accounts into one site. This allows for quick response time, generating great interactions. Also, this site allows you to schedule future posts that will be posted on each selected site at the time and date specified. This feature enables LCEF to become more active on social media sites while increasing personal interactions by responding to members quickly. 5. “WE ARE LCEF.” Commercial and Radio Ads The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign features two new commercials and a new radio ad that captures what it means to contribute to LCEF. The commercials will be available on LCEF’s Website, YouTube and Vimeo pages as well as the Lutheran Hour. The radio ad will be aired exclusively on the KFUO radio station and the Lutheran Hour. Figure 16. LCEF Commercial Snapshot Campaign Budget
  • 27. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 27 The Bus Tour holds the greatest weight of the marketing campaign budget because of the benefits that it offers. It will allow LCEF staff to communicate face to face with LCMS members about investment opportunities through LCEF. With this in mind, $193,000 of the budget will be dedicated to the bus tour. Finances have been allocated for the travel to and from the congregations, wages, lodging, food, travel for the respective district representatives, and miscellaneous expenses. Print Ads will be a vital tool in the campaign, and will be utilized in many aspects. The finances allotted will fulfill the printing requirement needed. $60,000 will be used on the print ads causing them to be easily accessible which allows for LCMS members to become aware of all personal, ministry, and business partnerships. The live chat capability featured on the LCEF website is designed to further the interaction with LCEF investors looking for information about products and services. The interaction with the consumer will create a sense of trust in LCEF as a ministry partner, furthering the spreading of the gospel by the finances they are investing. The $55,000 allocated to the live chat includes the additional staff to handle the increased volume of interactions. The budget will also be utilized in the design, upkeep of the chat technology, and wages. Social media, commercial advertisement, and radio advertisement will also play a key role in the increasing of awareness among LCMS members of LCEF investment opportunities. $42,000 will be used to create and air the content. Figure 17. Breakdown of Budget
  • 28. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 28 Implementation Process To implement the recommendations suggested, an eight-step process was created. This process gives order and structure to the recommendations as well as a generic timeline for when events should occur. Below, Figure 17 shows the implementation process in detail. Figure 18. Implementation Process
  • 29. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 29 Conclusion The Lutheran Church Extension Fund acts as a financial partner for schools, congregations, and rostered church workers associated with the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. It is the lending arm of the LCMS and works to plant, sustain, and revitalize distinctly LCMS churches and institutions. However, LCEF has been under-utilized in the LCMS due primarily to a lack of awareness. Through extensive research, it has been discovered that LCMS members are looking for three main qualities in a financial investment company:  Greater awareness of services  Clean and simplistic presentation of information  Easy accessibility  Transparency and personalization The “WE ARE LCEF.” campaign is designed to dramatically increase brand awareness and meet the needs of LCMS members. Using these multiple, integrated tactics that utilize personal outreach, awareness can be gained by LCMS members and congregations. This plan is multi- tiered and dimensional in order to reach and unify members of all ages. The bus tour, print advertising, social media, and other tactics demonstrate a creative yet traditional approach that brings information to members while increasing trust, involvement, strength, and awareness. References  About LCEF. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://lcef.org/about/index.cfm
  • 30. ConcordiaUniversity St.Paul 30  Hawkins, D., & Mothersbaugh, D. (2010). Consumer Behavior: Building Marketing Strategy(11th ed., p. 133). New York: McGraw-Hill Irwin.  Member Profile. (2007, January 1). Retrieved February 1, 2015, from http://www.thearda.com/Denoms/D_887_p.asp  MyAccount. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://lcef.org/myaccount/index.cfm  PartnerPLUS Term Note. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://lcef.org/investments/partnerplus-bus.cfm  Planned Giving. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://gifting.lcef.org/  Summary of Key Findings. (2008, January 1). Retrieved February 2, 2015, from http://religions.pewforum.org/reports  Third 2014 Charter Will Provide Affordable Financial Services to the Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2015, from http://www.ncua.gov/News/Pages/NW20141223Charter.aspx