SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Individual Research Review Article:
Exploring Cultural Drivers for Wildlife Trade via an Ethnoprimatological Approach: A
Case Study of Slender and Slow Lorises (Loris and Nycticebus) in South and Southeast
Asia

       In this article the authors (Nekaris et al.)question the way that conservation is

practiced through the field of ethnoprimatology. Their main topic of study is looking at

which primates (a focus in lorises) are found being illegally sold in markets across South

East Asia. In order to gain information on the lorises in the market, one must look at how

the primates’ origins, the price of the animal (dead or alive), the people usage of them.

Nekaris et al.criticize how those who practice in light only of conservation and

knowledge were not keeping the primate traders in mind, jeopardizing their livelihoods.

Nekaris et al. propose that there needs to be a “satisfactory system for ethically

quantifying the anthropological elements that drive primate trade,” ( 878, Nekaris et al.).

Through this work the authors try to examine ethical practices to establish an

understanding of the relationship between humans and non-human primates as a natural

resource a cultural figure. The theme of human and environmental relations are discussed

from an ethical, economic, and cultural standpoint.

       One of the things done well in the article was mentioning the they read reviews

and literature that needed to analyzed before going out in the field and go into detail of

the data collection. Using anthropological methods, they were able to use participant

observation to gain stories and record beliefs that the communities held about the lorises.

They make a point of the importance in being involved in the interests in all aspects of

the trade to help the researcher understand the trade from an emic perspective. It was

proposed that this would allow for greater rapport between the communities and the

anthropologist, which would create better data, in turn allowing for stronger steps to be
taken for conservation.

       The results were laid out clearly, allowing the readers follow. They noted which

primates were being targeted, where they were being sold to, and for what purpose. The

discussion section linked pieces of the research together to come up with significant

conclusions: 1. the trade is perpetuated by the use of lorises for medicinal purposes due to

the lack of knowledge, poverty, lack of infrastructure and access to modern medicine, 2.

belief systems are so deep set, they are inhibiting the alteration towards a more scientific

conservation of resources. The authors use maps to show where the studies were done; a

chart of the species-specific international trade;and a chart showing which species were

being traded in which specific regions, and whether they were dead or alive. This kind of

data compilation combined which the ethnographic accounts of the attitudes of the people

towards the lorises contributed to comprehensive study. The researchers have laid out the

steps they took so that anyone with experience in primatology and ethnography could

replicate the project. If I were to expand upon this research I would focus on the history

of natural resource use in these areas, government influences on the trade, and would

have work more closely with people who are actually capturing the primates.

       Although there have been other studies done on the trade of animals in South East

Asia ([Stich and Kruger, 2002], [Malone et al., 2002; Shepherd et al., 2005], and

throughout Asia [Schulze & Groves, 2004]),Nekaris et alpresents a unique case

documenting the cultural accounts with the trade. They also take into account that

looking at this cannot be done from just the community specific level; it needs to be

integrated into the global context as well.

       To conclude their work, Nekaris et al. stated that “learning the local language,
building rapport with traders, and spending long periods at each locality along the supply

chain allowed us to uncover the ultimate causes of trade,” (884 Nekaris et al.) Their

methods of collecting data in working with the community through complete

participation observation allowed them to gauge the needs of the people and how they

can be contributed in an environmental context for conservation. Their methods of

intimate participation using ethical practices serve not only the environment and the

people who live on the land. Their practice should be used as framework for conducting

and presenting research in anthropology.




Citation:

       Nekaris, K.A.I.; Shepherd, C.R.; Starr, C.R; andNijman, V. 2010.
       Exploring Cultural Drivers for Wildlife Trade via an EthnoprimatologicalApproach : A Case
       Study of Slender and Slow Lorises (Loris and Nycticebus) in South and Southeast Asia. American
       Journal of Primatology.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Wingate article critiques
Wingate article critiquesWingate article critiques
Wingate article critiques
Nicole Wingate
 
Review article ingles
Review article inglesReview article ingles
Review article ingles
Manuel Diaz
 
Article review
Article reviewArticle review
Article review
piqahamin
 
Research critique front page
Research critique front pageResearch critique front page
Research critique front page
jilly17
 
MA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
MA Thesis Review F. VaklevaMA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
MA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
Fani Vakleva
 
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_RaeesReport_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
Raees Afridi
 
Acceptable internet use in schools
Acceptable internet use in schoolsAcceptable internet use in schools
Acceptable internet use in schoolsvlferrari
 
S porter article summaries final
S porter article summaries finalS porter article summaries final
S porter article summaries final
savannahporter1
 
Article summaries
Article summariesArticle summaries
Article summaries
Laurie Roberts
 
article criticque
article criticquearticle criticque
article criticque
Oscar Ririn
 
Information literacy paper
Information literacy paperInformation literacy paper
Information literacy paper
Laurie Roberts
 
Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500
Sarah Richer
 
Revised article review 2
Revised article review 2Revised article review 2
Revised article review 2
bjai7903
 
Viviano, rich article critique
Viviano, rich article critiqueViviano, rich article critique
Viviano, rich article critique
richviviano
 
Article Review
Article ReviewArticle Review
Article Review
fatinnah
 
Article review
Article reviewArticle review
Article review
Sham Azril Ibn La'Ahad
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Wingate article critiques
Wingate article critiquesWingate article critiques
Wingate article critiques
 
Review article ingles
Review article inglesReview article ingles
Review article ingles
 
Article review
Article reviewArticle review
Article review
 
Research critique front page
Research critique front pageResearch critique front page
Research critique front page
 
MA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
MA Thesis Review F. VaklevaMA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
MA Thesis Review F. Vakleva
 
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_RaeesReport_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
Report_on_Critique_Ansi_SQL_By_Raees
 
Acceptable internet use in schools
Acceptable internet use in schoolsAcceptable internet use in schools
Acceptable internet use in schools
 
S porter article summaries final
S porter article summaries finalS porter article summaries final
S porter article summaries final
 
Article summaries
Article summariesArticle summaries
Article summaries
 
article criticque
article criticquearticle criticque
article criticque
 
Information literacy paper
Information literacy paperInformation literacy paper
Information literacy paper
 
Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500Article critique etec500
Article critique etec500
 
Revised article review 2
Revised article review 2Revised article review 2
Revised article review 2
 
Viviano, rich article critique
Viviano, rich article critiqueViviano, rich article critique
Viviano, rich article critique
 
Article Review
Article ReviewArticle Review
Article Review
 
Article review
Article reviewArticle review
Article review
 

Similar to L. Emmerson Individual Research Review Article

NWFP-102.pdf
NWFP-102.pdfNWFP-102.pdf
NWFP-102.pdf
dkstudio555
 
Ethnography research
Ethnography researchEthnography research
Ethnography research
MAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY
 
Laura emmerson position paper
Laura emmerson  position paperLaura emmerson  position paper
Laura emmerson position paper
Laura Emmerson
 
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90 Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
TanaMaeskm
 
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
Intesar Aba-Conding
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final ThesisMaria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
Maria Dahlman Ström
 
Thesis Final
Thesis FinalThesis Final
Thesis Final
Sarah Grayson
 
Ethnography nursing
Ethnography nursing Ethnography nursing
Ethnography nursing
L Ngahneilam
 
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
copppldsecretariat
 
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
DrJitendraKumarPremi
 
Sustainability of natural resource management
Sustainability of natural resource managementSustainability of natural resource management
Sustainability of natural resource management
Alexander Decker
 
International Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
International Journal of Veterinary Science & TechnologyInternational Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
International Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
SciRes Literature LLC. | Open Access Journals
 
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docxABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
bartholomeocoombs
 
Barthel-Schuett-73-902
Barthel-Schuett-73-902Barthel-Schuett-73-902
Barthel-Schuett-73-902
Guillermo Barthel
 
Introduction_Etnobiology
Introduction_EtnobiologyIntroduction_Etnobiology
Introduction_Etnobiology
Iis Naza
 
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
Alexander Decker
 
Converging indigenous and western knowledge systems
Converging indigenous and western knowledge systemsConverging indigenous and western knowledge systems
Why save the tiger alapw presentation final
Why save the tiger alapw presentation finalWhy save the tiger alapw presentation final
Why save the tiger alapw presentation final
Louis Plowden-Wardlaw
 

Similar to L. Emmerson Individual Research Review Article (20)

NWFP-102.pdf
NWFP-102.pdfNWFP-102.pdf
NWFP-102.pdf
 
Ethnography research
Ethnography researchEthnography research
Ethnography research
 
Laura emmerson position paper
Laura emmerson  position paperLaura emmerson  position paper
Laura emmerson position paper
 
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90 Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
Environment and Society Advances in Research 9 (2018) 75–90
 
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
Maranao Ethnobiology of G’nda/Chives (Allium schoenoprasum)
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
 
Chapter 2
Chapter 2Chapter 2
Chapter 2
 
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final ThesisMaria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
Maria Dahlman Ström - Final Thesis
 
Thesis Final
Thesis FinalThesis Final
Thesis Final
 
Ethnography nursing
Ethnography nursing Ethnography nursing
Ethnography nursing
 
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
Building Fodder Security in Rural Areas - Validation of Traditional Knowledge...
 
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
Lectuire on ethnographic method (jkp)
 
Sustainability of natural resource management
Sustainability of natural resource managementSustainability of natural resource management
Sustainability of natural resource management
 
International Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
International Journal of Veterinary Science & TechnologyInternational Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
International Journal of Veterinary Science & Technology
 
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docxABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
ABORIGINAL PEOPLES AND KNOWLEDGEDECOLONIZING OUR PROCESSES.docx
 
Barthel-Schuett-73-902
Barthel-Schuett-73-902Barthel-Schuett-73-902
Barthel-Schuett-73-902
 
Introduction_Etnobiology
Introduction_EtnobiologyIntroduction_Etnobiology
Introduction_Etnobiology
 
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
Indigenous knowledge language systems as source of educational psychology pri...
 
Converging indigenous and western knowledge systems
Converging indigenous and western knowledge systemsConverging indigenous and western knowledge systems
Converging indigenous and western knowledge systems
 
Why save the tiger alapw presentation final
Why save the tiger alapw presentation finalWhy save the tiger alapw presentation final
Why save the tiger alapw presentation final
 

L. Emmerson Individual Research Review Article

  • 1. Individual Research Review Article: Exploring Cultural Drivers for Wildlife Trade via an Ethnoprimatological Approach: A Case Study of Slender and Slow Lorises (Loris and Nycticebus) in South and Southeast Asia In this article the authors (Nekaris et al.)question the way that conservation is practiced through the field of ethnoprimatology. Their main topic of study is looking at which primates (a focus in lorises) are found being illegally sold in markets across South East Asia. In order to gain information on the lorises in the market, one must look at how the primates’ origins, the price of the animal (dead or alive), the people usage of them. Nekaris et al.criticize how those who practice in light only of conservation and knowledge were not keeping the primate traders in mind, jeopardizing their livelihoods. Nekaris et al. propose that there needs to be a “satisfactory system for ethically quantifying the anthropological elements that drive primate trade,” ( 878, Nekaris et al.). Through this work the authors try to examine ethical practices to establish an understanding of the relationship between humans and non-human primates as a natural resource a cultural figure. The theme of human and environmental relations are discussed from an ethical, economic, and cultural standpoint. One of the things done well in the article was mentioning the they read reviews and literature that needed to analyzed before going out in the field and go into detail of the data collection. Using anthropological methods, they were able to use participant observation to gain stories and record beliefs that the communities held about the lorises. They make a point of the importance in being involved in the interests in all aspects of the trade to help the researcher understand the trade from an emic perspective. It was proposed that this would allow for greater rapport between the communities and the anthropologist, which would create better data, in turn allowing for stronger steps to be
  • 2. taken for conservation. The results were laid out clearly, allowing the readers follow. They noted which primates were being targeted, where they were being sold to, and for what purpose. The discussion section linked pieces of the research together to come up with significant conclusions: 1. the trade is perpetuated by the use of lorises for medicinal purposes due to the lack of knowledge, poverty, lack of infrastructure and access to modern medicine, 2. belief systems are so deep set, they are inhibiting the alteration towards a more scientific conservation of resources. The authors use maps to show where the studies were done; a chart of the species-specific international trade;and a chart showing which species were being traded in which specific regions, and whether they were dead or alive. This kind of data compilation combined which the ethnographic accounts of the attitudes of the people towards the lorises contributed to comprehensive study. The researchers have laid out the steps they took so that anyone with experience in primatology and ethnography could replicate the project. If I were to expand upon this research I would focus on the history of natural resource use in these areas, government influences on the trade, and would have work more closely with people who are actually capturing the primates. Although there have been other studies done on the trade of animals in South East Asia ([Stich and Kruger, 2002], [Malone et al., 2002; Shepherd et al., 2005], and throughout Asia [Schulze & Groves, 2004]),Nekaris et alpresents a unique case documenting the cultural accounts with the trade. They also take into account that looking at this cannot be done from just the community specific level; it needs to be integrated into the global context as well. To conclude their work, Nekaris et al. stated that “learning the local language,
  • 3. building rapport with traders, and spending long periods at each locality along the supply chain allowed us to uncover the ultimate causes of trade,” (884 Nekaris et al.) Their methods of collecting data in working with the community through complete participation observation allowed them to gauge the needs of the people and how they can be contributed in an environmental context for conservation. Their methods of intimate participation using ethical practices serve not only the environment and the people who live on the land. Their practice should be used as framework for conducting and presenting research in anthropology. Citation: Nekaris, K.A.I.; Shepherd, C.R.; Starr, C.R; andNijman, V. 2010. Exploring Cultural Drivers for Wildlife Trade via an EthnoprimatologicalApproach : A Case Study of Slender and Slow Lorises (Loris and Nycticebus) in South and Southeast Asia. American Journal of Primatology.