This document summarizes the issue of organ trafficking and black markets. It outlines perspectives of buyers, sellers, brokers, and the implications. There is a shortage of organs for transplant which has led to people traveling abroad or using illegal markets to get organs more quickly. However, this often exploits poor donors who receive little payment. Brokers make substantial profits by paying donors little and charging recipients tens of thousands of dollars. Several case studies from countries like Israel, India, and the US are described to show how these illegal networks operate. Solutions proposed include regulated compensation programs and increasing legal organ availability to reduce the demand fuelling the black market.
The organ trade exists due to a shortage of organs for transplantation while demand is increasing due to medical advances. Organ trafficking involves the illegal removal and sale of organs, often exploiting vulnerable donors through deception, coercion, or even removal of organs without consent. The causes of organ trafficking include rising rates of organ failure diseases, advances making organ transplantation more feasible, and desperation of those needing an organ to survive.
Human trafficking for the purpose of organ removalTRACE Project
This document summarizes information from the HOTT project, an international research project on human trafficking for organ removal. It describes the objectives of the project which are to increase knowledge through research, raise awareness, and improve the non-legislative response. It then briefly outlines some of the project's publications and upcoming reports. Finally, it discusses indicators of human trafficking for organ removal by outlining examples of the complex relationships between recipients, donors, brokers and other actors involved.
Organ trafficking involves the illegal transport and sale of human organs. In Indonesia, thousands die each year waiting for organ transplants as demand greatly outweighs supply. This gap has led to a black market where organs are obtained through kidnapping, deception, financial desperation, and sometimes murder. Major countries involved in organ trafficking as exporters include Pakistan, China, India and the Philippines, while importers include Australia, Canada, Israel, Japan, Saudi Arabia and the US. Some countries like Iran have legalized kidney sales with regulation, while most prohibit organ trafficking and commerce. Solutions proposed include regulating organ trade through the state and harmonizing laws internationally to prohibit organ market advertising.
The document discusses the issue of organ trafficking and inequality in organ donation. It describes a case in India where day laborers were kidnapped and had their kidneys removed without consent to be sold for transplants. Experts note this is an ethical failure that exploits the poor. While a kidney could sell for $30,000, the poor are paid just $700. The conclusion calls for encouraging legal organ donation and stopping illegal organ trading to make the system fair for both rich and poor.
An organ transplant involves surgically removing a failing or damaged organ and replacing it with a healthy donor organ. The solid organs that can be transplanted include the heart, lungs, liver, pancreas, and intestines. For a transplant to occur, a matching donor organ must be found either from a deceased donor or a living donor. If the donor organ is from a deceased person it is called a cadaveric organ. Living donors can donate a kidney or part of an organ like a lobe of the lung or portion of the liver. For organ donation from deceased donors to be ethical, consent from family members is required. While organ sales raise ethical issues, recycling organs from deceased donors can benefit the living provided all ethical and legal
The document discusses organ trafficking and laws around organ sales in several countries. Brazil, Israel, South Africa, Iran, India, and China are mentioned, with details provided about their specific laws regarding selling organs and organ transplantation. The document also presents two case studies as examples and discusses debates around legalizing organ sales and potential benefits versus risks.
The document discusses the debate around whether the sale of human organs should be legalized. It notes that there are thousands dying due to lack of organs for transplant and argues that legalizing and regulating organ sales could help save lives by increasing the supply of organs. It provides examples of how those suffering from kidney failure may turn to dangerous black markets due to lack of legal options. While some argue it is immoral to sell organs, the document counters that it is more immoral to deny people transplants and force them into the black market system, suggesting legalization could help protect buyers and ensure operations are done safely.
Organ donation involves removing organs or tissues from deceased or living donors for transplantation into other individuals. Key organs that can be donated include the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, and pancreas. Legislation regarding organ donation varies by country, with some requiring explicit consent from donors and others assuming consent unless the donor explicitly dissents. There are ongoing ethical debates around issues such as defining death, ensuring informed consent, preventing financial exploitation of living donors, and addressing shortages in organ supply.
The organ trade exists due to a shortage of organs for transplantation while demand is increasing due to medical advances. Organ trafficking involves the illegal removal and sale of organs, often exploiting vulnerable donors through deception, coercion, or even removal of organs without consent. The causes of organ trafficking include rising rates of organ failure diseases, advances making organ transplantation more feasible, and desperation of those needing an organ to survive.
Human trafficking for the purpose of organ removalTRACE Project
This document summarizes information from the HOTT project, an international research project on human trafficking for organ removal. It describes the objectives of the project which are to increase knowledge through research, raise awareness, and improve the non-legislative response. It then briefly outlines some of the project's publications and upcoming reports. Finally, it discusses indicators of human trafficking for organ removal by outlining examples of the complex relationships between recipients, donors, brokers and other actors involved.
Organ trafficking involves the illegal transport and sale of human organs. In Indonesia, thousands die each year waiting for organ transplants as demand greatly outweighs supply. This gap has led to a black market where organs are obtained through kidnapping, deception, financial desperation, and sometimes murder. Major countries involved in organ trafficking as exporters include Pakistan, China, India and the Philippines, while importers include Australia, Canada, Israel, Japan, Saudi Arabia and the US. Some countries like Iran have legalized kidney sales with regulation, while most prohibit organ trafficking and commerce. Solutions proposed include regulating organ trade through the state and harmonizing laws internationally to prohibit organ market advertising.
The document discusses the issue of organ trafficking and inequality in organ donation. It describes a case in India where day laborers were kidnapped and had their kidneys removed without consent to be sold for transplants. Experts note this is an ethical failure that exploits the poor. While a kidney could sell for $30,000, the poor are paid just $700. The conclusion calls for encouraging legal organ donation and stopping illegal organ trading to make the system fair for both rich and poor.
An organ transplant involves surgically removing a failing or damaged organ and replacing it with a healthy donor organ. The solid organs that can be transplanted include the heart, lungs, liver, pancreas, and intestines. For a transplant to occur, a matching donor organ must be found either from a deceased donor or a living donor. If the donor organ is from a deceased person it is called a cadaveric organ. Living donors can donate a kidney or part of an organ like a lobe of the lung or portion of the liver. For organ donation from deceased donors to be ethical, consent from family members is required. While organ sales raise ethical issues, recycling organs from deceased donors can benefit the living provided all ethical and legal
The document discusses organ trafficking and laws around organ sales in several countries. Brazil, Israel, South Africa, Iran, India, and China are mentioned, with details provided about their specific laws regarding selling organs and organ transplantation. The document also presents two case studies as examples and discusses debates around legalizing organ sales and potential benefits versus risks.
The document discusses the debate around whether the sale of human organs should be legalized. It notes that there are thousands dying due to lack of organs for transplant and argues that legalizing and regulating organ sales could help save lives by increasing the supply of organs. It provides examples of how those suffering from kidney failure may turn to dangerous black markets due to lack of legal options. While some argue it is immoral to sell organs, the document counters that it is more immoral to deny people transplants and force them into the black market system, suggesting legalization could help protect buyers and ensure operations are done safely.
Organ donation involves removing organs or tissues from deceased or living donors for transplantation into other individuals. Key organs that can be donated include the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, and pancreas. Legislation regarding organ donation varies by country, with some requiring explicit consent from donors and others assuming consent unless the donor explicitly dissents. There are ongoing ethical debates around issues such as defining death, ensuring informed consent, preventing financial exploitation of living donors, and addressing shortages in organ supply.
The document discusses several topics related to organ donation including:
- What organ donation is and which organs can be donated including from living or deceased donors.
- The process of post-death organ donation and challenges with organ degradation after death.
- Differences in opt-in vs opt-out donation systems between countries like England and Spain.
- Ethical dilemmas around situations like a donor's wife refusing donation against their wishes or whether heavy drinkers should receive liver transplants.
- Definitions of terms like organ transplant, donor, and medical tourism.
A 46-year-old man collapsed while training for a marathon. Paramedics were unable to revive him and he was declared dead after 30 minutes of resuscitation efforts in the emergency department. The family informed the doctors that the deceased was a registered organ donor. However, because he did not die in the right way or location as outlined by policies, he could only be a tissue donor, not fulfill his wish to donate organs, leaving his family and those waiting for transplants distraught. The case highlights the complex ethical issues around defining death and the barriers created by policies that can prevent willing donors from donating.
Organ donation is the removal of the tissues of the human body from a person who has recently died, or from a living donor, for the purpose of transplanting.
Organ transplantation is a medical advancement that has improved lives, but organ shortage remains a challenge globally. In India, the deceased organ donation rate is only 0.34 per million people compared to higher rates in other countries. Cultural and religious beliefs influence decisions around organ donation in India. Lack of awareness, religious beliefs, and lack of trust in the healthcare system are major reasons families refuse consent for organ donation. Efforts are ongoing to increase rates through education, organizational support, and legislation.
contains details about what organs can be donated,who and how it can be done,policies and rules in about organ donation in india, what are the myths about donating organs, how many people are in need of organs(some statistics) and some private organizations working towards encouraging organ donation
This document summarizes Indian laws and strategies around organ donation. It discusses the importance of organ donation from religious texts and provides definitions. It outlines the history of organ transplantation and current organ donation laws in India. The document analyzes ethical issues and recommends strategies to increase organ donation rates such as education campaigns, establishing a national registry, and improving infrastructure for organ transplantation in India.
Organ donation ethics and law Y5 UCL Medical School 2013Laura-Jane Smith
Lecture delivered in first week of Year 5 UCL Medical School. Lots of discussion and debate, particularly about the arguments for and against an opt-out system. Engaged students make teaching really fun.
This document provides an overview of organ donation, including:
1) It defines organ donation and briefly outlines the history of organ transplantation from the 1950s to present day.
2) It describes the organ donation process and some of the key parties involved like organ procurement organizations and the United Network for Organ Sharing.
3) It examines some of the ethical issues around organ donation like opt-in vs opt-out policies and who should receive donated organs first.
Background of organ transplant infrastructure in the US. Some history. Definitions. Nursing Care of the transplant patient in hospital, and home settings. Intended for senior level nursing students in an ADN program
This document discusses several ethical issues surrounding organ transplantation. It addresses debates around organ donation from living or deceased donors, including religious objections. Defining life, death, and what constitutes the human body are ongoing philosophical debates that impact organ transplantation policies. Using cloning to produce transplant organs for a recipient raises significant ethical concerns. Xenotransplantation, or cross-species organ transplants, could potentially address the organ shortage but risks transmitting infectious agents to humans. Informed consent is crucial given potential health risks. Countries with opt-out organ donation policies tend to have higher donation rates than opt-in countries.
Organ Donation Presentation - Save Livessaraburtis
Organ donation can save many lives. Every day 19 people die due to the shortage of organ transplants. Someone is added to the organ donor list every 11 minutes. While organ donation saved Grandma Diane's life, she never received her needed liver transplant. The gap between those needing transplants and the number of organ donations grows each year. Becoming an organ donor can save up to 50 lives.
Baby Elizabeth is a 13 month old girl waiting for a lung transplant. She has been in the hospital for months waiting for a donor match. The author discusses the history of organ transplants and different types of transplant procedures. There is a shortage of organ donors, with over 100,000 people in the US on waiting lists. One organ donor can save up to 8 lives. The author urges readers to become organ donors to help save lives.
Nurses play a pivotal role in organ donation and transplantation by educating patients and families, facilitating the donation process, and maintaining organ viability until transplantation. In India, there is a large gap between the need and availability of organs for transplantation due to conditions like diabetes, hypertension, and liver disease. Nurses must be knowledgeable about all aspects of donation and act ethically. They can help increase donations by leading community awareness campaigns emphasizing that organ donation allows recipients to return to normal life while enabling donors to "continue to live forever." Public, private, and non-profit partnerships are needed to expand education and increase India's low organ donation rates.
Organ & Tissue Donation Awareness with Recent AdvancesAmol Patil
The Presentation gives brief information about recent statistics of Organ donation figures, problem statement and Recent amendments in Law.
It also mentions some examples of positive changes in view of Organ Donation in India.
This document summarizes information about organ donation. It discusses how organ transplantation works by moving organs from donors to recipients. It notes some of the pros of donation like how one donor can save multiple lives. However, it also outlines some cons such as religious or family beliefs against donation. Statistics provided show a large need for organs but low donation rates in India. The document overviews relevant laws and ethics concerning issues like consent, selling organs, and defining brain death. It emphasizes the need for more public awareness to address myths and safely increase the number of donations.
This document discusses organ donation, including what it is, types of donors (dead and living), religious views on it, and reasons for organ shortage. It also outlines ways to improve organ donation rates such as better patient care, trained transplant coordinators, hospital infrastructure improvements, and qualified medical professionals. The overall message is that organ donation can give hope and life to people in need.
This document discusses organ donation and provides key information. It defines organ donation as removing tissues or organs from a live or recently deceased person to be used for another person. It notes that most organs can be donated after death within a few hours and live donation requires donor consent. It also highlights that organ shortage is an issue, with over 17 people losing their lives daily while waiting for an organ in India. The document proposes several ways to improve organ donation rates, including better public awareness, hospital infrastructure, and support networks.
It gives a brief idea about recent facts related to organ donation in India and clears doubts regarding Organ donation. Explains about need, types of donation, legislation, and coordinating bodies.
Organ donation involves donating biological tissues or organs from living or deceased donors to recipients in need of transplants. While it can save many lives, there is a large shortage of organs available for transplant globally and in India specifically. Effective organ donation programs require addressing issues like lack of public awareness, legal and ethical concerns, and ensuring transparency to prevent exploitation. Models like the one in Tamil Nadu aim to maximize cadaveric organ donation through a centralized allocation system and free transplants to reduce costs as barriers. Kerala has guidelines for organ donation but still faces challenges in identifying brain dead donors, public awareness, funding, and monitoring the program. Increased education and empathy could help address myths and shortages to benefit more patients.
This document discusses the ethics of organ transplantation. It provides background on the history and types of organ transplants, as well as the World Health Organization's guiding principles on transplantation. Some key ethical issues discussed include how to allocate scarce organ resources fairly, whether organ markets should be allowed, and whether living donors should be compensated. Overall, the document examines the complex ethical considerations surrounding this medical procedure.
This document discusses organ trafficking which involves the illegal transporting and harboring of human organs, often across international borders. It violates ethical principles by using living donors and involving commercial transactions rather than being legal, voluntary and non-commercial. Organ trafficking is also known as transplant tourism where people travel to obtain organs from living donors.
The document discusses the history and development of kidney transplantation, noting that while the first successful kidney transplants occurred in the 1950s, significant advancements in tissue typing, immunosuppression, and surgical techniques were required throughout the following decades to allow kidney transplantation to become safer and more routine. It outlines major milestones and medical discoveries that helped overcome barriers to transplantation, such as the first successful transplant between twins in 1954 and developments in dialysis, immunosuppression drugs, and organ preservation techniques.
The document discusses several topics related to organ donation including:
- What organ donation is and which organs can be donated including from living or deceased donors.
- The process of post-death organ donation and challenges with organ degradation after death.
- Differences in opt-in vs opt-out donation systems between countries like England and Spain.
- Ethical dilemmas around situations like a donor's wife refusing donation against their wishes or whether heavy drinkers should receive liver transplants.
- Definitions of terms like organ transplant, donor, and medical tourism.
A 46-year-old man collapsed while training for a marathon. Paramedics were unable to revive him and he was declared dead after 30 minutes of resuscitation efforts in the emergency department. The family informed the doctors that the deceased was a registered organ donor. However, because he did not die in the right way or location as outlined by policies, he could only be a tissue donor, not fulfill his wish to donate organs, leaving his family and those waiting for transplants distraught. The case highlights the complex ethical issues around defining death and the barriers created by policies that can prevent willing donors from donating.
Organ donation is the removal of the tissues of the human body from a person who has recently died, or from a living donor, for the purpose of transplanting.
Organ transplantation is a medical advancement that has improved lives, but organ shortage remains a challenge globally. In India, the deceased organ donation rate is only 0.34 per million people compared to higher rates in other countries. Cultural and religious beliefs influence decisions around organ donation in India. Lack of awareness, religious beliefs, and lack of trust in the healthcare system are major reasons families refuse consent for organ donation. Efforts are ongoing to increase rates through education, organizational support, and legislation.
contains details about what organs can be donated,who and how it can be done,policies and rules in about organ donation in india, what are the myths about donating organs, how many people are in need of organs(some statistics) and some private organizations working towards encouraging organ donation
This document summarizes Indian laws and strategies around organ donation. It discusses the importance of organ donation from religious texts and provides definitions. It outlines the history of organ transplantation and current organ donation laws in India. The document analyzes ethical issues and recommends strategies to increase organ donation rates such as education campaigns, establishing a national registry, and improving infrastructure for organ transplantation in India.
Organ donation ethics and law Y5 UCL Medical School 2013Laura-Jane Smith
Lecture delivered in first week of Year 5 UCL Medical School. Lots of discussion and debate, particularly about the arguments for and against an opt-out system. Engaged students make teaching really fun.
This document provides an overview of organ donation, including:
1) It defines organ donation and briefly outlines the history of organ transplantation from the 1950s to present day.
2) It describes the organ donation process and some of the key parties involved like organ procurement organizations and the United Network for Organ Sharing.
3) It examines some of the ethical issues around organ donation like opt-in vs opt-out policies and who should receive donated organs first.
Background of organ transplant infrastructure in the US. Some history. Definitions. Nursing Care of the transplant patient in hospital, and home settings. Intended for senior level nursing students in an ADN program
This document discusses several ethical issues surrounding organ transplantation. It addresses debates around organ donation from living or deceased donors, including religious objections. Defining life, death, and what constitutes the human body are ongoing philosophical debates that impact organ transplantation policies. Using cloning to produce transplant organs for a recipient raises significant ethical concerns. Xenotransplantation, or cross-species organ transplants, could potentially address the organ shortage but risks transmitting infectious agents to humans. Informed consent is crucial given potential health risks. Countries with opt-out organ donation policies tend to have higher donation rates than opt-in countries.
Organ Donation Presentation - Save Livessaraburtis
Organ donation can save many lives. Every day 19 people die due to the shortage of organ transplants. Someone is added to the organ donor list every 11 minutes. While organ donation saved Grandma Diane's life, she never received her needed liver transplant. The gap between those needing transplants and the number of organ donations grows each year. Becoming an organ donor can save up to 50 lives.
Baby Elizabeth is a 13 month old girl waiting for a lung transplant. She has been in the hospital for months waiting for a donor match. The author discusses the history of organ transplants and different types of transplant procedures. There is a shortage of organ donors, with over 100,000 people in the US on waiting lists. One organ donor can save up to 8 lives. The author urges readers to become organ donors to help save lives.
Nurses play a pivotal role in organ donation and transplantation by educating patients and families, facilitating the donation process, and maintaining organ viability until transplantation. In India, there is a large gap between the need and availability of organs for transplantation due to conditions like diabetes, hypertension, and liver disease. Nurses must be knowledgeable about all aspects of donation and act ethically. They can help increase donations by leading community awareness campaigns emphasizing that organ donation allows recipients to return to normal life while enabling donors to "continue to live forever." Public, private, and non-profit partnerships are needed to expand education and increase India's low organ donation rates.
Organ & Tissue Donation Awareness with Recent AdvancesAmol Patil
The Presentation gives brief information about recent statistics of Organ donation figures, problem statement and Recent amendments in Law.
It also mentions some examples of positive changes in view of Organ Donation in India.
This document summarizes information about organ donation. It discusses how organ transplantation works by moving organs from donors to recipients. It notes some of the pros of donation like how one donor can save multiple lives. However, it also outlines some cons such as religious or family beliefs against donation. Statistics provided show a large need for organs but low donation rates in India. The document overviews relevant laws and ethics concerning issues like consent, selling organs, and defining brain death. It emphasizes the need for more public awareness to address myths and safely increase the number of donations.
This document discusses organ donation, including what it is, types of donors (dead and living), religious views on it, and reasons for organ shortage. It also outlines ways to improve organ donation rates such as better patient care, trained transplant coordinators, hospital infrastructure improvements, and qualified medical professionals. The overall message is that organ donation can give hope and life to people in need.
This document discusses organ donation and provides key information. It defines organ donation as removing tissues or organs from a live or recently deceased person to be used for another person. It notes that most organs can be donated after death within a few hours and live donation requires donor consent. It also highlights that organ shortage is an issue, with over 17 people losing their lives daily while waiting for an organ in India. The document proposes several ways to improve organ donation rates, including better public awareness, hospital infrastructure, and support networks.
It gives a brief idea about recent facts related to organ donation in India and clears doubts regarding Organ donation. Explains about need, types of donation, legislation, and coordinating bodies.
Organ donation involves donating biological tissues or organs from living or deceased donors to recipients in need of transplants. While it can save many lives, there is a large shortage of organs available for transplant globally and in India specifically. Effective organ donation programs require addressing issues like lack of public awareness, legal and ethical concerns, and ensuring transparency to prevent exploitation. Models like the one in Tamil Nadu aim to maximize cadaveric organ donation through a centralized allocation system and free transplants to reduce costs as barriers. Kerala has guidelines for organ donation but still faces challenges in identifying brain dead donors, public awareness, funding, and monitoring the program. Increased education and empathy could help address myths and shortages to benefit more patients.
This document discusses the ethics of organ transplantation. It provides background on the history and types of organ transplants, as well as the World Health Organization's guiding principles on transplantation. Some key ethical issues discussed include how to allocate scarce organ resources fairly, whether organ markets should be allowed, and whether living donors should be compensated. Overall, the document examines the complex ethical considerations surrounding this medical procedure.
This document discusses organ trafficking which involves the illegal transporting and harboring of human organs, often across international borders. It violates ethical principles by using living donors and involving commercial transactions rather than being legal, voluntary and non-commercial. Organ trafficking is also known as transplant tourism where people travel to obtain organs from living donors.
The document discusses the history and development of kidney transplantation, noting that while the first successful kidney transplants occurred in the 1950s, significant advancements in tissue typing, immunosuppression, and surgical techniques were required throughout the following decades to allow kidney transplantation to become safer and more routine. It outlines major milestones and medical discoveries that helped overcome barriers to transplantation, such as the first successful transplant between twins in 1954 and developments in dialysis, immunosuppression drugs, and organ preservation techniques.
Kidney transplantation provides better long-term survival and quality of life than dialysis for patients with end-stage renal disease. While the first successful kidney transplants were between twins in 1954, transplantation techniques and anti-rejection drugs have improved outcomes over decades. Living donors are preferred as they offer reduced rejection rates and improved graft survival, though deceased donors also help many patients. Preemptive transplantation before dialysis starts provides the best results, but early transplantation once on dialysis also benefits patients.
The document outlines principles of organ transplantation including:
- Pre-operative principles involve patient selection, counseling, consent, and optimization.
- Intra-operative principles involve organ procurement and transplantation techniques.
- Post-operative principles involve monitoring for complications, maintaining immunosuppression, and follow-up.
The immune system's response to transplanted organs can result in rejection, so careful patient screening and lifelong immunosuppression are required for transplant success.
Kidney transplantation involves transplanting a kidney from a living or deceased donor into a patient with end-stage renal disease. There are several indications for kidney transplantation including chronic kidney failure, diabetes, and genetic disorders. Compatibility between donor and recipient is based on blood type and human leukocyte antigens. After transplantation, patients take immunosuppressant drugs to prevent rejection and have improved quality of life compared to dialysis. While transplantation carries risks of infection, rejection and side effects, it provides longer survival than remaining on dialysis.
Human trafficking is the illegal trade of human beings for commercial sexual exploitation, forced labour, or slavery. It is a lucrative criminal industry and one of the key drivers is poverty. Victims are typically young girls who are vulnerable to being targeted by traffickers. While females are most commonly trafficked, men and children can also become victims. Statistics show over 800,000 people globally are currently living as slaves to human trafficking.
The Transplantation of Human Organs Act of 1994 regulates organ transplantation in India by prohibiting commercial dealings in human organs and establishing an authorization process for organ transplants.
It allows donations from near relatives and live donors not related to the recipient with approval from an Authorization Committee. Paying for human organs is illegal.
Proposed amendments include removing the age limit for cadaver donors, permitting paired donor exchanges between incompatible families, and providing direct compensation to living donors for losses like wages. However, some argue this could promote illegal organ trading.
Human Trafficking PowerPoint Presentationlbrowning9
This document discusses human trafficking, which it defines as tricking, luring, or forcing people into situations of forced labor or sexual exploitation where they receive little to no payment. It notes that over 27 million people worldwide are trafficked, making it one of the largest criminal industries. Victims are often promised better opportunities but instead face conditions of modern slavery, experiencing physical and sexual abuse with no freedom or pay. The document urges readers to educate themselves on this issue and get involved in efforts to combat human trafficking.
HE 485W Bioethics for Public Health
please answers each of the following in a brief paragraph.
l. Please explain why we should have cause for concern regarding
the Bioethical issues facing us in today's modern contemporary
Society
2. When does an individuals' right to choose begin to threaten the
autonomy of others? Likewise, when does the quest for
autonomy begin to threaten individual rights?
3. Please explain how genetic engineering and testing along with
Bio-technology has the potential to promote discrimination.
4. Please describe the inherent social challenges in cloning human
beings as we have discussed them in class or otherwise.
5. In your opinion, would it ever be appropriate for employers to
screen for predetermined genetic disorders. Why and Why not?
6. Would it ever be ethical to withhold information from a dying
patient? Why and Why not?
Organ Transplants
Ethical Issues
What are Organ Transplants?Cadaveric organ donation: Involves removing organs from a recently deceased donor.Living organ donation: Involves the donation of one of a paired organ (ex: kidneys) or a portion of an organ (such as a lobe of the liver or lung). The donor's organ system is still able to function after the donation. Living donors are often related to the patient, but that is not always the case.
HistoryIn 1954, the first successful kidney transplant was performed in the United States. It was a kidney from a living identical twin donor.
History cont.More than a half of a century after the very first transplant, more than 80,000 people whose death without a donor is certain are on waitlists in the United States waiting for a new lung, kidney, heart, or liver. The United Network for Organ Sharing reports that about half of these people will die without receiving the necessary organs. Human organs are a scarce medical resource and have many ethical issues concerning organ transplantation.
ConsentA donor card is the main signal for permission to collect an organ from a potential donor. Also there is an attempt to gain approval from a next of kin or other family members. If a family member isn’t present for that decision then recovery agencies would act solely on the donor card.
Donor Card ConcernsThere is fear and distrust that if you are a organ donor then less effort would be placed into saving your life if your death meant organs for others.Coercion takes place when signing up for a license, because everyone’s license is marked with the decision to be a organ donor or not.
Allocation ConcernsOrgan recipients are chosen from a long waiting list after they have been medically determined to be a eligible candidate. The criteria for these lists are weighed upon factors such as age range, causes of failure, and stage of organ failure.
An attempt to balance justice...The United Network for Organ Sharing policy tries to make the decision of organ donating fair by placing criteria on the donatin ...
Organ TransplantsEthical Issues What are Organ T.docxgerardkortney
Organ Transplants
Ethical Issues
What are Organ Transplants?Cadaveric organ donation: Involves removing organs from a recently deceased donor.Living organ donation: Involves the donation of one of a paired organ (ex: kidneys) or a portion of an organ (such as a lobe of the liver or lung). The donor's organ system is still able to function after the donation. Living donors are often related to the patient, but that is not always the case.
HistoryIn 1954, the first successful kidney transplant was performed in the United States. It was a kidney from a living identical twin donor.
History cont.More than a half of a century after the very first transplant, more than 80,000 people whose death without a donor is certain are on waitlists in the United States waiting for a new lung, kidney, heart, or liver. The United Network for Organ Sharing reports that about half of these people will die without receiving the necessary organs. Human organs are a scarce medical resource and have many ethical issues concerning organ transplantation.
ConsentA donor card is the main signal for permission to collect an organ from a potential donor. Also there is an attempt to gain approval from a next of kin or other family members. If a family member isn’t present for that decision then recovery agencies would act solely on the donor card.
Donor Card ConcernsThere is fear and distrust that if you are a organ donor then less effort would be placed into saving your life if your death meant organs for others.Coercion takes place when signing up for a license, because everyone’s license is marked with the decision to be a organ donor or not.
Allocation ConcernsOrgan recipients are chosen from a long waiting list after they have been medically determined to be a eligible candidate. The criteria for these lists are weighed upon factors such as age range, causes of failure, and stage of organ failure.
An attempt to balance justice...The United Network for Organ Sharing policy tries to make the decision of organ donating fair by placing criteria on the donating circumstances. These circumstances include; the need for the organ and those with the possibility of the maximum outcome.
UNOS Criteria
Maximize the availability of transplantable organs.
Maximize patient and graft survival (allograft-human to human transplant).
Minimize the deaths while waiting for a transplant.
UNOS Criteria cont.
Maximize opportunity for patients with biological or medical disadvantages to receive a transplant.
Minimize the effects related to geography.
Allow convenient access to transplantation.
UNOS Criteria cont.Minimize overall transplantation costs.Provide for flexibility in policy making. Provide for accountability and public trust.
The UNOS Ethical PositionThe only ethically sound motivation for donation is humanity. They interpret humanity to be solidarity with the national community and the absence of personal benefit.
Racial BiasRacial bia.
This document discusses various issues related to organ donation, including ethical, biological, political/religious, and legal issues. Ethical issues include the gap between organ supply and demand, organ sale, and concerns around presumed consent policies. Biological issues center around the debate around using animal organs or fetal tissues for transplantation. Political and religious factors involve corruption influencing organ sourcing and varying views among religions. Legally, laws like the Human Tissue Act and Transplantation of Human Organs Act establish rules around consent and living donation to prevent exploitation.
The document discusses the issue of international organ trade. It provides background on organ transplantation and notes that while live organ donation is practiced, the sale of organs is prohibited. It then examines the issues of "transplant tourism," where people travel abroad for organ transplants, often through intermediaries. While this provides transplants for some patients, it can involve human trafficking and exploitation of live organ donors in other countries. The key messages are that organ trade is an ethical, economic, and social problem and that governments and researchers must work to address it.
This document summarizes key information about human organ transplantation. It discusses the first heart transplant by Dr. Barnard in 1967 (the patient lived 18 days). It describes types of transplants and criteria for donor death. Quality of life has improved for recipients with drugs like cyclosporine, though living donors face risks. There is a shortage of organs, leading to debates around creating a market for organs or using presumed consent to increase donations. Concerns include exploiting vulnerable groups and treating people as a means rather than ends.
Baby Elizabeth is a 13 month old girl waiting for a lung transplant. She has been in the hospital for months waiting for a donor match. Organ transplants have a long history dating back to ancient times, but the first successful transplant was not performed until 1954. There are different types of transplants including living, deceased, and between identical twins. Over 100,000 people in the US are currently waiting for organ donations, but only a fraction of that number are eligible donors. One organ donor can save up to 8 lives.
This is a research presentation I did with Empire Research. I offer this to anyone who wants to know more about the silent epidemic of kidney disease.
Please read and pass on. LV
This document discusses the lucrative but unregulated global trade in human organs for transplantation. It notes the long wait times and high costs patients face in developed countries contrasted with the low compensation and destitution of organ donors in developing countries. The document examines ethical issues regarding informed consent and risks of transnational crime. It analyzes sources of information on this trade, compares organ prices worldwide, and profiles the various desperate parties involved including recipients, donors, complicit medical businesses, and intermediaries. The document considers approaches for managing this issue and concludes that accurately tracking this hidden cross-border trade and regulating organ markets could help address the exploitation of vulnerable donors and patients.
This document discusses the burden of kidney disease globally and in Nigeria. It notes that renal failure is a major public health problem worldwide, contributing to over 850,000 deaths annually. In Nigeria, chronic kidney disease accounts for 8-10% of hospital admissions, with an estimated 18,000 new cases per year. However, less than 2000 patients are able to receive dialysis treatment due to financial constraints. The document calls for government funding of dialysis treatment through programs like NHIS to increase access to life-saving care for kidney patients in Nigeria.
Organ transplants affect over 100,000 Americans each year by providing a lifesaving treatment when organ failure occurs, however the shortage of donated organs means that many patients die waiting for transplants. The process of organ donation begins with an individual agreeing to donate their organs after death, which allows their organs to potentially save multiple lives, but the lack of donated organs contributes to the gap between those needing transplants and available organs. Increasing organ donation would help reduce this shortage and save more lives.
This document discusses organ cloning and its arguments. It begins with an overview of organ cloning and the goals of cloning organs to address the organ shortage crisis. It then examines several arguments for and against organ cloning. Pro arguments include addressing the organ shortage and avoiding transplant complications and rejection. Con arguments discuss the unknown health effects of cloned organs, risks to women whose eggs are used, and concerns that organ cloning could lead to human cloning. The document concludes that organ cloning is currently unethical and dangerous.
Role of nurse in organ donation, retrievel and banking RakhiYadav53
Nurses play a vital role in organ donation, from facilitating potential donors to supporting families. They begin by identifying potential donors and managing their care until donation. Nurses guide families through the difficult process, obtain consent, and initiate the donor protocol according to hospital policy. After retrieval, organs are preserved and transported to recipients. Nurses coordinate multiple teams and care for donors and recipients through all stages of donation and transplantation. Their role is critical in this complex process.
This document provides an outline on organ transplantation. It begins by defining organ transplantation and the emerging field of regenerative medicine. It then describes the main types of transplants - autograft, allograft, isograft, xenograft, split transplants, and domino transplants. The major organs and tissues transplanted are also outlined. The types of donors for transplants are defined as living donors and deceased donors. Reasons for organ donation include being a living related donor, participating in paired exchange, being a good Samaritan donor, and compensated donation. The document concludes by discussing some of the ethical concerns regarding organ transplantation including sources of organs and distributive justice.
This document discusses organ donation and transplantation in India. It provides an introduction to organ donation and outlines the need for organ donation due to the large gap between available organs and people in need. It then discusses the history of successful transplants in India, types of transplants, living donor requirements, reasons for the shortage of organ donors, and situations under which organ donation occurs. The document also covers the legal aspects, forms, transplant rejection, immunosuppressive therapy, and the green corridor concept in India.
Alex Tabarrock on Using Incentives to Increase Organ Donation. More at http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/05/changing-views-on-organ-prohibition.html
This document discusses organ donation in India, outlining several key challenges. It notes that the organ donation rate in India is very low at 1 donor per million people compared to countries like Spain with a rate of 35 donors per million. Some obstacles mentioned include bureaucratic hurdles in approving transplants, a lack of awareness about organ donation among the public and reluctance from families of potential donors. It also discusses the challenges with identifying brain dead donors and religious superstitions that sometimes prevent donation. The document advocates for reducing red tape and increasing education to improve organ donation rates in India.
Organ donation is ethically and morally acceptance compared to organ harvesting which is non ethic.
donating an organs for saving a human life is ok, and acceptance but to donate your organs for economics is bad because you didn't have a grantee that your organs may save till you dying.
the most expensive organ donation is ................
Organ Donation.
Organ Donation gift of life.
importance of organ donation.
organ donors save life.
Donate life.
Be a hero be a donor.
organ donation in India.
.
American Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Development is indexed, refereed and peer-reviewed journal, which is designed to publish research articles.
American Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Development is indexed, refereed and peer-reviewed journal, which is designed to publish research articles.
2. Overview Why the proliferation of Organ Rackets? Organ Transplantation Buyer’s Perspective Seller’s Perspective Broker’s and Facility’s Perspective Case Studies Implications/Policy Considerations
3. Organ Transplantation Organ Shortage Increase in incidence of diseases requiring organ transplantation Diabetes, high blood pressure, etc Poor disease outcomes Cost of dialysis is high Medical and nonmedical The current annual cost of the ESKF program is estimated at $32.5 billion, > 6.5% of the total cost of Medicare. Better technology since the 1950s Better outcomes with live donors (immunosuppressants) Don’t need to be related 5-10% of all transplants are performed illegally
4. Buyer’s Perspective Kidneys are most in demand Kidneys can be removed from deceased or living donors, since most people are born with two and can live healthily with only one kidney 9 year wait in NY >3 year wait is US average Source: TransplantLiving.org
6. Illegal Organ Transplantation (Buyer’s Perspective) Cheap Globalization Easy communication Easy travel Shorter Wait Time Vacation (transplant tourism) 10% of recipients in 2004 traveled from developed countries to poor countries for transplants Package deals
7. Seller’s Perspective Coercion, exploitation, physical harm Organ traders prey on the most desperate, impoverished, and uneducated most donors are 20-40 years old and either illiterate or with very low educational attainment Vendors with children 7 times more common Need to pay off accumulated debts 87-95% need immediate cash Brokers quote high payments, but pay out little
8. Organ Rackets - Results Pay as little as $1,000 to donors, but receive as much as $50,000 in payments from recipients Paid donations are often associated with depression, regret, and discrimination Risks Poor post-operative care for recipients and “donors” Complications Less employable and therefore worse off economically Sellers exiled from communities
9. Broker’s and Facilitator’s Perspectives Broker Insulated from punishment Sellers reluctant to go to authorities Weak penalties Fines and short prison sentences Corrupt officials Low transaction costs Hospitals & Doctors Highly Profitable procedures Hippocratic Oath – an oath to treat the sick
10. Major Players in the Organ Trade Organ trafficking is a global phenomenon Major Organ Exporters Pakistan, China, India, the Philippines, Bolivia, Brazil, Iraq, Israel, the Republic of Moldova, Peru, Turkey, Egypt, and South Africa Major Organ Importers Australia, Canada, Israel, Japan, Oman, Saudi Arabia and the USA
12. Case Study 1: Israel/Ukraine August 2007 MuhammedTahaJeeth and Hassan Zahalka Sellers procured in Israel and transported to Ukraine Dr. Michael Zis (an Israeli surgeon) operated for $125,000 Paid $1800 to “donors” First time sellers came forward to prosecute 4 years in prison for 2 brokers Dr. Zis was released last year after a 2 year detention in Ukraine “Wanted-kidney donor of any blood type- blood type unimportant- a monetary prize during the convalescence- Dr. Muhammed 054-4423827”
13. Case Study 2: India About 2000 Indians per year sell a kidney “Dr. Kidney” Amit Kumar Lured poor laborers to Gurgaon Paid 30,000 rupees (about 660 USD) More than 500 transplants $50,000 for each operation Pts from UK, US, Turkey, Nepal, Dubai, Syria, and Saudi Arabia
14. Case Study 3: USA July 2009- 1st documented U.S. case Originated in Israel Operates in 12 countries Most extensive network Levy Izhak Rosenbaum Hunters in Israel Doctors in Israel Donor Bought organs from Israel for $10,000 and sold them to patients for as much as $160,000
15. What’s Being Done? Campaign to educate people about organ donation based on altruism Opt-out Policy in some countries, including Spain and Singapore Istanbul Declaration Transplantation Society & International Society of Nephrology emphasizes need to address the safety and health care needs of the donor before, during, and after donation calls upon countries to increase programs for the prevention of kidney disease and enhance regional programs for availability of organs to meet the transplant needs of its residents from donors within their own populations No legal standing; only an ethical agreement among surgeons Prohibited in China, Philippines, Pakistan
16. What Can Be Done? Regulate the organ trade through state sanctions Iran donors could be compensated in other ways lifetime access to medical care life insurance tax credit help with college a small direct payment Harmonization of laws Prohibit advertisements Poor enforcement Overwhelming anecdotal evidence, underwhelming quantitative data
17. Bibliography HDNet. "Kidney Pirates." Dan Rather Reports.HDNet, 26 January 2010. Interlandi, Jeneen. Not Just Urban Legend. 10 January 2009. 23 November 2010 <http://www.newsweek.com/2009/01/09/not-just-urban-legend.html>. Jafar, Tazeen H. "Organ Trafficking: Global Solutions for a Global Problem: Regulated Compensated Kidney Transplantation." American Journal of Kidney Disease (2009): 1145-1157. Johnson, David Porter and Carla. First case of organ trafficking in U.S.?: NYC man accused of buying kidneys abroad, selling at hefty profit. 24 July 2009. 9 November 2010 <http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/32132371/>. Matas, AJ and M. Schnitzler. "Payment for living donor (vendor) kidneys: a cost-effectiveness analysis." The American Journal of Transplantation February 2004: 216-221. Mendoza, Roger Lee. "Colombia's organ trade: Evidence from Bogotá and Medellín." Journal of Public Health (2010): 375-384. —. "Price deflation and the underground organ economy in the Philippines." Journal of Public Health (2010). National Kidney Foundation. 25 Facts About Organ Donation and Transplantation. 13 November 2010 <http://www.kidney.org/news/newsroom/fs_new/25factsorgdon&trans.cfm>. National Public Radio. The International Organ Trafficking Market. Washington, 3 July 2009. Pearson, Elaine. Coercion in the Kidney Trade?: A background study on trafficking in human organs worldwide.Eschborn: Deutsche GesellschaftfürTechnischeZusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH, 2004.
18. Bibliography (cont.) Shimazono, Yosuke. "The State of the International Organ Trade: a provisional picture based on integration of available information." Bulletin of the World Health Organization (2007): 955-962. Srinivasan, Sandhya. " 'Dr Kidney' arrest exposes Indian organ traffic." Asia Times Online 22 February 2008. Transplant Living. Financing a Transplant. 2010 November 11 <http://www.transplantliving.org/beforethetransplant/finance/costs.aspx>. Yakupoglu, Yarkin, et al. "Transplantation tourism: high risk for the recipients." Clinical Transplantation (2009): 1-4.
Editor's Notes
“The current shortage in both living and deceased organ donors is expected to worsen in the near future. This owes to the increasing global incidence of diabetes, hypertension (key risks of kidney disease), hepatitis B and C (key risks of liverdisease), and various chronic abdominal organ illnesses. In recent years, there has also been an epidemic rise in the number of patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and end-stage liver disease (ESLD), where kidneys and livers fail to perform permanently (Hamer and El Nahas 2006; Lim and Kim 2008; Interlandi 2009).”
Kidneys are the most needed organ.Also, most folks can survive on 1 kidney, and are as a result, the most traded organ. Can wait for up to 9 years in NY for a kidney (varies by state). The present median waiting time on the transplant list in the United States is > 3 years and is projected to increase substantially during the next few years.4,500 Americans die each year waiting for a kidney.
Craigslist As discussed before, the internet is often used to lure foreign customers. Several web sites offer all-inclusive “transplant packages” – the price of a renal transplant package ranges from US$ 70 000 to 160 000.
India, Egypt, Israel, Turkey, Italy,India was especially popular due to its large number of doctors and low cost, but it appears that Egypt has taken over as the hot spot in the past 5 yearsBrokers or middlemen frequently lie about the procedures and consequences of kidney removal. For example, they tell sellers that the operation is a minor one, that they can return to work immediately, that one kidney is 'useless' or dormant so this one will be removed etc.A study of organ sellers in Colombia showed that “Vendors with dependents, whether single or married,numbered seven times more than those who did not report any dependents.”In between 87 and 95% of the subjects, the primary reason that vendors sold their organs was for “immediate” cash.A study in Chennai, India interviewing 305 kidney sellers in the State of Tamil Nadu found that the amounts promised to kidney vendors (by both brokers and clinics) were an average of one third more than what they were actually paid.
One study showed that recipients of the organs had more post-surgical complications that the acceptable international standard. Some of these complications include transmission of HIV and Hep C. The Indian study that I mentioned earlier reported that sellers’ family income was reduced on average by 36%. 86% reported a decline in health after removal. 79% of participants would not recommend others to sell a kidney.
*surgical fees, hospitalization fees make human trafficking of donors more profitable for hospitals than simply shipping the organ on ice
In Colombia, a typical kidney seller will receive about $1,700. By comparison, the black market price for a kidney (exclusive of gratuities and other valuable considerations) in the US is at least US$ 30,000, US$ 10,000.00–20,000,00 in Israel, US$ 7,500 in Turkey and US$ 6,000 in Brazil.
This case set a precedent in that it was the first case where the organ sellers went to the courtsTwo of the accused were sentenced to 4 yrs in prisonDr. Zis (a Moldovan surgeon) was arrested in UkraineThose who answered the ad were offered the opportunity to sell one of their kidneys (some accepted while others were coerced with threats)They all underwent a series of medical tests and were transported to Ukraine, where Dr. Zis surgically removed the kidneys.the eventual decision to commute his sentence stemmed from the fact that his offenses were "relatively mild" and "because he has a minor daughter".
“Kumar is accused of luring poor laborers to his "hospital" in the New Delhi suburb of Gurgaon with promises of job offers or large sums of money. Typically, they were promised 300,000 rupees (US$7,500) but paid only 30,000 ($750) after the surgery, police said. He is alleged to have conducted more than 500 transplants over an unspecified period, charging up to $50,000 dollars for each operation. Investigators say his patients came from Britain, the United States, Turkey, Nepal, Dubai, Syria and Saudi Arabia. The racket first came to light on January 24 when police raided Kumar's hospital following a complaint by a "donor" who had been paid less than the amount promised. At his hospital police found recipients recovering from surgery and arrested a number of doctors, nurses and support staff. The kidney trade requires the collusion of highly trained surgeons. Kumar was the organizer of the enterprise and seems to have either hired or partnered with surgeons and other medical personnel. He had contacts all over the world who directed patients needing transplants to him, and a network of brokers all over India who ensnared poor people into parting with a kidney with promises of large rewards”
A federal corruption probe in NJ involving several government officials revealed an extensive black market organ trade.Israeli network in: Argentina, Brazil, India, Iran, Cuba, Israel/West Bank, Moldova/Romania, Philippines, Russia, Turkey, USA and South Africa). Rosenbaum lived in an Orthodox Jewish neighborhood in Brooklyn and claimed to be running a nonprofit organization.The scheme lasted for a decade until Rosenbaumwas arrested, 10 days after meeting in his basement with a government informant and an FBI agent posing as the informant's secretary. The agent claimed to be searching for a kidney for a sick uncle on dialysis who was on a transplant list at a Philadelphia hospital.the organ donors were brought from Israel to the United States, where they underwent surgery to remove the kidneys.The Israeli network is the most extensive in the world, and Rosenbaum was a part of this organization. This network’s brokerages in Brazil and South Africa had already been broken up, but the U.S. was late on this…Usually, US brokers set up independent businesses, and are not a part of a larger networkRosenbaum carried a gun, and when a potential organ seller would get cold feet, Rosenbaum would use his finger to simulate firing a gun at the person's head
Concerns about ethics arise here A few transplant surgeons support changing the law to allow a system of regulated compensation to increase the pool of donor kidneys.Existing prosecutions have tended to focus on low-level brokers rather than including medical staff, and traffickers have received light sentences.