Stop Wasting Money On Outdated
PPC Tactics
Navah Hopkins - Optmyzr
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
I Have A Confession…
This Is Version Three Of This Deck
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
The Amount Of Changes Lately Have
Necessitated Pivots
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
We Are Going To Look At
Three Core Questions
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Questions
● Are Google’s Recommendations Viable?
● How To Balance Suggestions With What’s
Working For You Now?
● What Does A Healthy Account Structure Look
Like?
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
About Me
● 15 years in digital marketing
with experience in SAAS, in-
house, and agency.
● Board member of PSA, Foxwell
Founders, judge for digital
marketing awards, and regular
contributor to SEL, SEJ and
others.
● Pet mom, gamer girl, and metal
fan
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Are Google’s Recommendations
Viable?
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Performance Max Is
Here To Stay.
Google
Recommends
Pairing With
Traditional
Campaigns
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Between Search Themes & PMax Exclusions, It’s No
Longer A Black Box
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Earlier This Year We Tested Removing All But PMax
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
It Did Not Go Well
32%
Spend Increase
41%
Fewer
Conversions
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Both PMax and Traditional Need Placement
Exclusions & Audience Feedback
https://support.google.com/google-
ads/contact/pmax_implementation#
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Heed Google’s Recommendation: PMax &
Siloed Campaigns Have A Healthy Relationship
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Traditional Campaigns Are Subject
To:
Match Types
Audiences
Negatives/Exclusions
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
I Have Always Given Broad the Benefit Of The
Doubt
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
We Wanted To See If Broad Match Has Really Improved
Enough To Justify The Mass Migration
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
90 Days
Accounts Needed To Be
Active for at least 90
days to be considered
Both
Entities
Accounts needed to have
both entities (either both
match types or both
bidding strategies)
$10K~
Global ad spends
converted to USD -
Optmyzr customers
usually spend at least
$10k per month
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
2637 accounts with spend and conversion
data in Q1 2023
Data shows percentage of analyzed
advertisers who did better on broad or
exact
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
2637 accounts with spend and conversion
data in Q1 2023
Data shows percentage of analyzed
advertisers who did better on broad or
exact
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
2637 accounts with spend and conversion
data in Q1 2023
Data shows percentage of analyzed
advertisers who did better on broad or
exact
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
2637 accounts with spend and conversion
data in Q1 2023
Data shows percentage of analyzed
advertisers who did better on broad or
exact
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
What About Volume?
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Broad Match Can Work, But Use Caution!
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
If You Use Broad,
You Must Couple It With
Smart Bidding
&
Aggressive Negative Keywords
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Different Markets Search Can
Spike Close Variants 56.21%
average
visible spend
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Value Rules Can Help Mitigate These ROAS
Losses
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Your CPA Is Tied To Primary vs Secondary
Conversion Actions
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Different Markets Will Have Different Margins
Be Sure You’re Only Opting Into The Markets You
Intend
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Value Based Bidding & ROAS Is At The Heart
Of The Algorithm
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Some Are
Hesitant To
Adopt Value
Based Rules
Due To Not
Having An
Exact
Customer
Value
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
1334 accounts with spend and
conversion data in Q1 2023
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
1334 accounts with spend and
conversion data in Q1 2023
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
1334 accounts with spend and
conversion data in Q1 2023
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
1334 accounts with spend and
conversion data in Q1 2023
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
You Are Hurting Yourself By Not Leveraging
Value Based Bidding
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
This Will Be Easier To Do If You
Factor In
Locations & Audiences
Into Your Conversion Settings
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Say Yes To This Google Recommendation:
Max Conversion Value Wins
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Upload Conversion Data To Benefit From
Conversion Based Audiences
& Trust Reporting
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
It’s Hard To Let Go Of Control…Which Is Why
Many Resist Google’s Recommendation To
Avoid Pinning Ad Copy
93,055
Responsive
Search Ads
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
The Answer Lies In Compromise
93,055
Responsive
Search Ads
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
DKI & Customizers Aren’t As Viable Anymore
432,343
ads
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Heed This Recommendation:
Creative Control Can Get In The Way Of Profit
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Balancing Suggestions With What’s Working
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
There Are Many Thought Leaders Telling Us
Which Strategies To Follow
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
It Can Be Frustrating To Hear Conflicting
Information From Trusted Sources
https://www.searchenginejournal.com/digital-marketing-tells/334737/#close
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
If You Want To Test A Strategy Pick A “B”
Level Campaign/Part Of Your Business
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Considerations Campaign A Campaign B Campaign C
Cost Seen as
investment
because of
profitability
Needs to prove
itself
Often seen as
waste or struggles
to spend at all
Priority Highest priority
campaign due to
profit/customer
type
Mid priority Low priority
Risk Tolerance Risk Averse: All
Tests run in other
campaigns first
Risk Tolerant:
Home of Tests
Risk addict:
Anything and
everything is fair
game
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Set Clear Expectations Of What You’re Hoping
To See Out Of The Test
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Any Restructure You Do Will Have A 30-60 Day
Down Time On Performance
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
If You Disagree With A Strategy, You’ll Likely
Find Fault Early.
Give Yourself Time To Truly Test
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
You May Want To Exclude Some Conversion
Data During The Testing Periods
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
What Does A Healthy Account Structure
Look Like?
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Spoiler Alert: There Is No One Size Fits All Ad
Account Structure
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Tenet #1: PMax Should Play Some
Role In The Account
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Build Multiple PMax Campaigns Rather Than
Making One All Encompassing One
Budget Allocation Behaves
The Same As Ad Groups
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Tenet #2: Campaigns Should Only Be
Asked To Support One Strategic
Objective
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Be Careful Around Location and Bidding
Settings For New Campaigns
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Tenet #3: Exclusions Are Just As
Important As Targets
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Tenet #4: Match-Types Matter More
Than We Thought,
But Shouldn’t Be The Strategic Focus
Of The Campaign
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Build Campaigns Around Objectives Or You’ll Get
Hit With Privacy First Data Holes
56.21%
average
visible spend
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Tenet #5: There Is No Perfect
Campaign
© 2022 Optmyzr Inc. All rights reserved.
@navahf
Be Empowered To Use Experiments And
Test Wild & Crazy Ideas
SUBSCRIBE WEBSITE SUPPORT PODCAST FOLLOW
Thank You! Questions?
Navah Hopkins
navah@optmyzr.com
@navahf

ISS PPC Structure Deck.pptx

  • 1.
    Stop Wasting MoneyOn Outdated PPC Tactics Navah Hopkins - Optmyzr
  • 2.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf I Have A Confession… This Is Version Three Of This Deck
  • 3.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf The Amount Of Changes Lately Have Necessitated Pivots
  • 4.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf We Are Going To Look At Three Core Questions
  • 5.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Questions ● Are Google’s Recommendations Viable? ● How To Balance Suggestions With What’s Working For You Now? ● What Does A Healthy Account Structure Look Like?
  • 6.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf About Me ● 15 years in digital marketing with experience in SAAS, in- house, and agency. ● Board member of PSA, Foxwell Founders, judge for digital marketing awards, and regular contributor to SEL, SEJ and others. ● Pet mom, gamer girl, and metal fan
  • 7.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Are Google’s Recommendations Viable?
  • 8.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Performance Max Is Here To Stay. Google Recommends Pairing With Traditional Campaigns
  • 9.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Between Search Themes & PMax Exclusions, It’s No Longer A Black Box
  • 10.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Earlier This Year We Tested Removing All But PMax
  • 11.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf It Did Not Go Well 32% Spend Increase 41% Fewer Conversions
  • 12.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Both PMax and Traditional Need Placement Exclusions & Audience Feedback https://support.google.com/google- ads/contact/pmax_implementation#
  • 13.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Heed Google’s Recommendation: PMax & Siloed Campaigns Have A Healthy Relationship
  • 14.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Traditional Campaigns Are Subject To: Match Types Audiences Negatives/Exclusions
  • 15.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf I Have Always Given Broad the Benefit Of The Doubt
  • 16.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf We Wanted To See If Broad Match Has Really Improved Enough To Justify The Mass Migration
  • 17.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 90 Days Accounts Needed To Be Active for at least 90 days to be considered Both Entities Accounts needed to have both entities (either both match types or both bidding strategies) $10K~ Global ad spends converted to USD - Optmyzr customers usually spend at least $10k per month
  • 18.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 19.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 2637 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023 Data shows percentage of analyzed advertisers who did better on broad or exact
  • 20.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 2637 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023 Data shows percentage of analyzed advertisers who did better on broad or exact
  • 21.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 22.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 2637 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023 Data shows percentage of analyzed advertisers who did better on broad or exact
  • 23.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 2637 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023 Data shows percentage of analyzed advertisers who did better on broad or exact
  • 24.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf What About Volume?
  • 25.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 26.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 27.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 28.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 29.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 30.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Broad Match Can Work, But Use Caution!
  • 31.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf If You Use Broad, You Must Couple It With Smart Bidding & Aggressive Negative Keywords
  • 32.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Different Markets Search Can Spike Close Variants 56.21% average visible spend
  • 33.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Value Rules Can Help Mitigate These ROAS Losses
  • 34.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Your CPA Is Tied To Primary vs Secondary Conversion Actions
  • 35.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Different Markets Will Have Different Margins Be Sure You’re Only Opting Into The Markets You Intend
  • 36.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Value Based Bidding & ROAS Is At The Heart Of The Algorithm
  • 37.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Some Are Hesitant To Adopt Value Based Rules Due To Not Having An Exact Customer Value
  • 38.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 1334 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023
  • 39.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 1334 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023
  • 40.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 1334 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023
  • 41.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf 1334 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023
  • 42.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf You Are Hurting Yourself By Not Leveraging Value Based Bidding
  • 43.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf This Will Be Easier To Do If You Factor In Locations & Audiences Into Your Conversion Settings
  • 44.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Say Yes To This Google Recommendation: Max Conversion Value Wins
  • 45.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Upload Conversion Data To Benefit From Conversion Based Audiences & Trust Reporting
  • 46.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf It’s Hard To Let Go Of Control…Which Is Why Many Resist Google’s Recommendation To Avoid Pinning Ad Copy 93,055 Responsive Search Ads
  • 47.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf The Answer Lies In Compromise 93,055 Responsive Search Ads
  • 48.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf DKI & Customizers Aren’t As Viable Anymore 432,343 ads
  • 49.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Heed This Recommendation: Creative Control Can Get In The Way Of Profit
  • 50.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Balancing Suggestions With What’s Working
  • 51.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf There Are Many Thought Leaders Telling Us Which Strategies To Follow
  • 52.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf It Can Be Frustrating To Hear Conflicting Information From Trusted Sources https://www.searchenginejournal.com/digital-marketing-tells/334737/#close
  • 53.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf If You Want To Test A Strategy Pick A “B” Level Campaign/Part Of Your Business
  • 54.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Considerations Campaign A Campaign B Campaign C Cost Seen as investment because of profitability Needs to prove itself Often seen as waste or struggles to spend at all Priority Highest priority campaign due to profit/customer type Mid priority Low priority Risk Tolerance Risk Averse: All Tests run in other campaigns first Risk Tolerant: Home of Tests Risk addict: Anything and everything is fair game
  • 55.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Set Clear Expectations Of What You’re Hoping To See Out Of The Test
  • 56.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Any Restructure You Do Will Have A 30-60 Day Down Time On Performance
  • 57.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf If You Disagree With A Strategy, You’ll Likely Find Fault Early. Give Yourself Time To Truly Test
  • 58.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf You May Want To Exclude Some Conversion Data During The Testing Periods
  • 59.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf What Does A Healthy Account Structure Look Like?
  • 60.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Spoiler Alert: There Is No One Size Fits All Ad Account Structure
  • 61.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Tenet #1: PMax Should Play Some Role In The Account
  • 62.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Build Multiple PMax Campaigns Rather Than Making One All Encompassing One Budget Allocation Behaves The Same As Ad Groups
  • 63.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Tenet #2: Campaigns Should Only Be Asked To Support One Strategic Objective
  • 64.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Be Careful Around Location and Bidding Settings For New Campaigns
  • 65.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Tenet #3: Exclusions Are Just As Important As Targets
  • 66.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf
  • 67.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Tenet #4: Match-Types Matter More Than We Thought, But Shouldn’t Be The Strategic Focus Of The Campaign
  • 68.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Build Campaigns Around Objectives Or You’ll Get Hit With Privacy First Data Holes 56.21% average visible spend
  • 69.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Tenet #5: There Is No Perfect Campaign
  • 70.
    © 2022 OptmyzrInc. All rights reserved. @navahf Be Empowered To Use Experiments And Test Wild & Crazy Ideas
  • 71.
    SUBSCRIBE WEBSITE SUPPORTPODCAST FOLLOW Thank You! Questions? Navah Hopkins navah@optmyzr.com @navahf

Editor's Notes

  • #21 2637 accounts with spend and conversion data in Q1 2023
  • #47 https://www.optmyzr.com/blog/optmyzr-study-responsive-search-ad-performance/
  • #48 https://www.optmyzr.com/blog/optmyzr-study-responsive-search-ad-performance/ 93,055 Responsive Search Ads
  • #49  432,343 ads https://www.optmyzr.com/blog/optmyzr-study-responsive-search-ad-performance/