Overview of the WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry (IMR) highlighting indicator harmonization functionality. Patrick Whitaker

1. WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry (IMR)
SDMX-HD Summary Data Format
Patrick Whitaker
1| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

2. Definitions
 M&E – Monitoring and Evaluation
 Summary data – Data summarized from raw, e.g. clinical, data
 Indicator – An indicator quantifies and simplifies phenomena and helps us
understand complex realities. Indicators are aggregates of raw and
processed data but they can be further aggregated to form complex indices.
International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
 IMR – WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry
 SDMX – Statistical Data and Metadata Exchange(ISO/TS 17369:2005)
 SDMX-HD – WHO implementation of SDMX for the health domain
2| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

3. Human Nature?
Content Systems
Computers are dumb and precise.
People are brilliant and less precise.
3| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

4. Focus on Summary Data
4| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

5. Issues Impacting Interoperability
 Multitude of guidelines documents.
 Insufficient metadata in indicator definitions.
 Competing organizational standards.
 Weak harmonization processes.
 Lack of a global repository for indicator (and clinical concept) definitions.
 Lack of a standard exchange format for summary data.
5| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

6. Focus of Presentation
Message Format Content Reference Model
Individual Data HIC HL7, XML SNOMED-CT, LOINC, ICD HL7 V3, ISO 13606 (OpenEHR)
LIC CCR, CCD, HSR SNOMED-CT, LOINC, ICD HL7 V3, ISO 13606 (OpenEHR)
Summary Data SDMX-HD IMR, SDMX MCV, ISO SDMX
CCD HL7 CCR-based Clinical Document Architecture Continuity of Care Document
CCR ASTM Continuity of Care Record (XML)
DCM ISO Detailed Clinical Model
HIC High Income Country
HL7 Health Level Seven
HSR Health Summary Record
ICD WHO International Classification of Diseases
ISO equal', International Organization for Standardization
IMR WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry
LIC Low Income Country
LOINC Logical Observation Identifiers Names and Codes
RIM Reference Information Model
SDMX Statistical Data and Metadata Exchange
SDMX MCV Metadata Common Vocabulary
SDMX-HD WHO Statistical Data and Metadata Exchange – Health Domain
SNOMED-CT Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine – Clinical Terms
6| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

7. Problems
 Varying indicator and measurement definitions.
Solution: WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry (IMR)
Interoperability of computer systems (summary data).
Solution: SDMX-HD data exchange format
7| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

8. Multitude of Guidelines
Documents
8| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

9. Inconsistent and Incomplete Definitions
Source Indicator Name
UNSD Men 15-24 years old with comprehensive correct knowledge of HIV/AIDS, percentage
Percentage of young people aged 15–24 who both correctly identify ways of preventing the sexual
UNAIDS
transmission of HIV and who reject major misconceptions about HIV transmission
Percentage of young women and men aged 15–24 who both correctly identify ways of preventing the sexual
PEPFAR
transmission of HIV and who reject major misconceptions about HIV transmission
Percentage of young women and men aged 15–24 years who both correctly identify ways of preventing the
GFATM
sexual transmission of HIV and who reject the major misconceptions about HIV transmission
WHO Proportion of population aged 15-24 years with comprehensive correct knowledge of HIV/AIDS (%)
Indicator Sources:
UNSD mdgs.un.org/unsd/mdg/Metadata.aspx
UNAIDS data.unaids.org/pub/manual/2009/jc1676_core_indicators_2009_en.pdf
PEPFAR www.pepfar.gov/documents/organization/81097.pdf
GFATM www.theglobalfund.org/en/me/guidelines_tools/?lang=en#toolkit
WHO apps.who.int/gho/indicatorregistry/App_Main/browse_indicators.aspx
9| Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

10. Metadata Views
All concepts can
have different
names and values
10 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

11. IMR
WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry
11 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

12. Indicator and Measurement Registry (IMR)
 Definition, management, and harmonization of indicator definitions by WHO and
partners.
 Incorporation of international standards.
 Human and computer readable definitions.
 Global definition distribution.
12 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

13. 13 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

16. Support for Cross-
Domain Codelists

17. Harmonization
Establishment of processes to reconcile country and organizational
differences in indicator definitions without duplication.
17 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

18. Programme-specific Metadata
Program-specific
profile
Name is an
associated attribute,
inherited from WHO
Program-specific in this case.
metadata

19. Publishing
Human and Computer-readable Indicator Definitions
19 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

20. Reports
20 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

21. 21 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

22. SDMX-HD
Statistical Data and Metadata Exchange – Health Domain
22 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

23. Summary Data Interoperability
23 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

24. SDMX History
 Evolved from work on GESMES/TS in Central Banking community.
 Developed in ISO Technical Committee (TC)154 - Processes, data
elements and documents in commerce, industry and administration.
 Note that the version 1.0 of SDMX is ISO Technical Specification (TS)
17369.
 Current SDMX version is 2.1.
24 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

25. ISO/TS 17369:2005
Statistical data and metadata exchange (SDMX)
SDMX 2.1 Technical Specification
 Section 1 – Framework. Introduces the documents and the content of the revised Version 2.1
 Section 2 – Information Model. UML model and functional description, definition of classes, associations and
attributes
 Section 3A – SDMX_ML. Specifies and documents the XML formats for describing structure, data, reference
metadata, and interfaces to the registry
 Section 3B – SDMX-ML. XML schemas, samples, WADL and WSDL (update: 12 May 2011)
 Section 4 – SDMX-EDI. Specifies and documents the UN/EDIFACT format for describing structure and data.
 Section 5 – Registry Specification – Logical Interfaces. Provides the specification for the logical registry
interfaces, including subscription/notification, registration of data and metadata, submission of structural
metadata, and querying
 Section 6 – Technical Notes. Provides some technical information which may be useful for the
implementation (this was called “Implementor’s Guide” in the 2.0 release)
 Section 7 – Web Services Guidelines. Provides guidelines for using SDMX standards to promote
interoperability among SDMX web services
25 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

26.  Data exchange standard for summary data.
 Defines structure and content of data.
 Attributes
– Common
• Interoperability
• Documentation
– Custom
• Local customization
• Harmonization, i.e. support for current definition
26 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

27. XML
27 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

28. SDMX-HD Use
Public Domain Applications
 M&E/Surveillance
– DHIS2
– CRIS (planned)
 HR
– iHRIS
 Clinical
– OSHIP
– OpenMRS
 Logistics
– OpenLMIS
 Lab
– OpenELIS
28 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

29. SDMX-HD Use
Governments
 Implemented
– Sierra Leone
– India
– Netherlands
• National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM)
• Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research (NIVEL)
 In process
– Philippines
 Planned
– Viet Nam
– Fiji
– Tonga
– Thailand
– Bangladesh
– China
– WHO Regional Offices
29 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012

30. SDMX-HD Group

31. Links
 WHO Indicator and Measurement Registry
– Public: www.who.int/gho/indicatorregistry
– Public with write access: extranet.who.int/IndicatorRegistry
Request extranet account from: extranet.who.int/ads
– Web Service www.who.int/gho/indicatorregistryservice
 SDMX: www.sdmx.org
 SDMX-HD: www.sdmx-hd.org
31 | Health Care Informatics | May 9, 2012