Stryker, Althusser and Marcuse Theories on
Althusser’s Theory
   Althusser’s concept of ‘interpellation’
    purported to show how an individuals
    identity or sense of self is absorbed in
    and produced by the dominant
    ideologies within a society
Althusser’s Theory
   Interpellation occurs when a person
    connects with a media text: when we
    enjoy a TV show, for example, this
    uncritical consumption means that the
    text has interpellated us into a certain
    set of assumptions.
Althusser’s Theory
    In other word, we are interpellated (seduced)
     into a certain view from the media we
     consume.

    For example a lifestyle magazine using
     glamorous photography to interpllate its
     readers into a particular world view, or
     certain identity representations on TV or Film
     which interpllate viewers into certain beliefs.
Media, Gender and Identity (David Gauntlett)
Stykers Theory
   Stykers (1980) identity salience
    hierarchy refers to the ordering of
    identities into a hierarchy in such a way
    that the higher the positioning of a
    particular identity, the higher the
    probability of its activation
Stykers Theory
   Identity salience is defined as the
    probability of a particular identity being
    invoked by self or others within or
    across social situations.

   While an identity is often invoked
    wilfully, the role of commitment could
    change the salience.
Stykers Theory
   Example question to illustrate how
    salience and commitment are related to
    identity:

   Why does one parent, given a free
    weekend, spend it playing golf with
    friends while another takes his or her
    children to the zoo?
Stykers Theory: discussion
 Golfer identity>
 Parent identity>


 Salience= the importance of a specific
  identity
 Commitment= could change which
  identity is higher up the hierarchy.
Marcuse Theory
   Marcuse’s account of identity formation
    is negative as he is mainly concerned
    with the political and social forces that
    limit identity formation.

   Marcuse focuses on the constraints
    placed on identity formation.
Marcuse Theory
   His central argument is that identity
    formation is controlled by the forces of
    consumerism and technology, leaving
    no room for the internal ego identity, the
    inner self, to develop.
Marcuse Theory
   Marcuse argues that society creates false needs
    which divert us from our private identity.

   These false needs are created through
    advertising and the media in general,
    emphasising the need to behave and consume
    like everybody else.



From Chicago to Frankfurt: Goffman and Marcuse on Identity 3 April 2006
Activity
   Argue ways that you could relate each
    theorists argument to our case study
    texts.

 E20
 Inbetweeners
 Attack the Block

Identity theories

  • 1.
    Stryker, Althusser andMarcuse Theories on
  • 2.
    Althusser’s Theory  Althusser’s concept of ‘interpellation’ purported to show how an individuals identity or sense of self is absorbed in and produced by the dominant ideologies within a society
  • 3.
    Althusser’s Theory  Interpellation occurs when a person connects with a media text: when we enjoy a TV show, for example, this uncritical consumption means that the text has interpellated us into a certain set of assumptions.
  • 4.
    Althusser’s Theory  In other word, we are interpellated (seduced) into a certain view from the media we consume.  For example a lifestyle magazine using glamorous photography to interpllate its readers into a particular world view, or certain identity representations on TV or Film which interpllate viewers into certain beliefs. Media, Gender and Identity (David Gauntlett)
  • 5.
    Stykers Theory  Stykers (1980) identity salience hierarchy refers to the ordering of identities into a hierarchy in such a way that the higher the positioning of a particular identity, the higher the probability of its activation
  • 6.
    Stykers Theory  Identity salience is defined as the probability of a particular identity being invoked by self or others within or across social situations.  While an identity is often invoked wilfully, the role of commitment could change the salience.
  • 7.
    Stykers Theory  Example question to illustrate how salience and commitment are related to identity:  Why does one parent, given a free weekend, spend it playing golf with friends while another takes his or her children to the zoo?
  • 8.
    Stykers Theory: discussion Golfer identity>  Parent identity>  Salience= the importance of a specific identity  Commitment= could change which identity is higher up the hierarchy.
  • 9.
    Marcuse Theory  Marcuse’s account of identity formation is negative as he is mainly concerned with the political and social forces that limit identity formation.  Marcuse focuses on the constraints placed on identity formation.
  • 10.
    Marcuse Theory  His central argument is that identity formation is controlled by the forces of consumerism and technology, leaving no room for the internal ego identity, the inner self, to develop.
  • 11.
    Marcuse Theory  Marcuse argues that society creates false needs which divert us from our private identity.  These false needs are created through advertising and the media in general, emphasising the need to behave and consume like everybody else. From Chicago to Frankfurt: Goffman and Marcuse on Identity 3 April 2006
  • 12.
    Activity  Argue ways that you could relate each theorists argument to our case study texts.  E20  Inbetweeners  Attack the Block