”Ensuring	
  Homes	
  for	
  All:	
  	
  
An	
  Equity	
  Primer	
  on	
  Housing	
  Elements”	
  
December	
  18,	
  2013	
  
UH	
  News	
  
Executive	
  Director	
  Position	
  Available	
  
Shared	
  office	
  for	
  rent	
  @	
  Urban	
  
Habitat	
  
Land	
  Use/Affordable	
  Housing	
  
Coordinator	
  Position	
  Available	
  
Our	
  Approach	
  
•  Policy	
  Advocacy	
  
•  Mobilizing	
  and	
  Educating	
  Community	
  
Coalitions	
  around	
  Policy	
  
•  Training	
  Advocates	
  to	
  become	
  Decision-­‐
Makers	
  
The	
  BCLI	
  Model	
  
Train	
  
Place	
  
Connect	
  
Recruit	
  
1	
  
2	
  
3	
  
4	
  
The	
  Fellowship	
  
Deep	
  and	
  integrated	
  equity	
  knowledge	
  	
   Political	
  skills	
  
Power	
  structures	
  and	
  influences	
  
Commission	
  procedures	
  and	
  best	
  
practices	
  
SKILLS	
  KNOWLEDGE	
  
NETWORK	
  
Current	
  Issues	
  Series	
  
•  Network	
  
•  Critically	
  question	
  and	
  engage	
  
•  Share	
  your	
  perspective	
  with	
  our	
  speakers	
  
•  Inform	
  your	
  communities	
  and	
  your	
  work	
  
• Affordable	
  Housing	
  Advocacy	
  
Coalition	
  founded	
  in	
  1984	
  
• Based	
  in	
  Oakland,	
  work	
  throughout	
  
Alameda	
  and	
  Contra	
  Costa	
  Counties	
  –
also	
  on	
  regional	
  and	
  state	
  issues	
  
• Preserve,	
  Promote	
  and	
  Expand	
  
Affordable	
  Housing	
  Opportunities	
  
through	
  Education,	
  Advocacy,	
  
Coalition	
  Building	
  and	
  Organizing	
  
• Membership-­‐based:	
  300+	
  individual	
  
and	
  organizational	
  members	
  
www.EBHO.org	
  
East	
  Bay	
  Housing	
  Organizations	
  
Evvy	
  Stivers	
  
Sam	
  Tepperman-­‐
Gelfant	
  
Laura	
  Thomas	
  
Lilli	
  Lew-­‐Hailer	
  
 
Ensuring	
  
Homes	
  for	
  
All:	
  	
  
An	
  Equity	
  
Primer	
  on	
  
Housing	
  
Elements	
  
	
  
Bay	
  Area	
  Housing	
  Elements:	
  	
  
What’s	
  Happening	
  Now	
  
Sam	
  Tepperman-­‐
Gelfant,	
  	
  
Public	
  Advocates	
  
Inc.	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
•  Plan	
  Bay	
  Area	
  
Sustainable	
  Communities	
  Strategy	
  (SCS)	
  
•  Regional	
  Housing	
  Need	
  Allocation	
  (RHNA)	
  numbers	
  
finalized	
  July	
  18,	
  2013	
  
•  Housing	
  Element	
  Updates	
  by	
  January	
  31,	
  2015	
  
•  Some	
  Positive	
  aspects	
  of	
  regional	
  framing	
  
–  Displacement	
  risk	
  front	
  and	
  center	
  
–  Zoning	
  near	
  transit	
  and	
  amenities	
  
•  2014-­‐2022	
  RHNA	
  Cycle	
  will	
  be	
  SMALLER	
  and	
  
FASTER	
  
14	
  
Local	
  Housing	
  Elements:	
  	
  
Regional	
  Context	
  
•  Sites	
  for	
  Affordable	
  Housing	
  
•  Local	
  Funding	
  for	
  Affordable	
  Housing	
  
–  Impact	
  and	
  Linkage	
  Fees	
  
–  Boomerang	
  Funds	
  
•  Policies	
  and	
  Programs	
  	
  
–  Tenant	
  Protections	
  
–  Incentive/Overlay	
  zoning	
  
–  Site	
  consolidation	
  
•  See	
  Results:	
  Pleasanton,	
  Alameda,	
  Menlo	
  Park,	
  
Concord,	
  Marin	
  County,	
  etc.	
  
15	
  
Playing	
  to	
  Win	
  
•  Reduced	
  Regional	
  Housing	
  Need	
  Number	
  
–  2007-­‐2014	
  =	
  214,500	
  	
  
–  2014-­‐2022	
  =	
  187,990	
  
•  70%	
  of	
  RHNA	
  distributed	
  to	
  Priority	
  Development	
  
Areas	
  (PDAs)	
  	
  
–  PDAs	
  are	
  disproportionately	
  in	
  low-­‐income	
  
communities	
  of	
  color	
  
–  Most	
  wealthy	
  suburbs	
  got	
  reduced	
  numbers	
  	
  	
  	
  
16	
  
Smaller	
  Numbers	
  
•  Streamlined	
  Review	
  by	
  HCD	
  
–  Certified	
  Housing	
  Element	
  for	
  2007-­‐14	
  cycle	
  
–  Rezoning	
  Completed	
  
–  Density	
  Bonus	
  Ordinance	
  
–  Zoning	
  for	
  Emergency	
  Shelters,	
  Transitional	
  and	
  Supportive	
  
Housing	
  
–  Reasonable	
  Accommodation	
  
•  Statutory	
  Incentives	
  for	
  Timely	
  Adoption	
  
–  Revise	
  every	
  4	
  years	
  if	
  Housing	
  Element	
  not	
  adopted	
  within	
  120	
  
days	
  of	
  deadline	
  
•  The	
  OneBayArea	
  Grant	
  Program	
  
–  HCD	
  Certified	
  Housing	
  Element	
  required	
  to	
  access	
  some	
  
transportation	
  dollars	
  
17	
  
Faster	
  Process	
  
•  Menlo	
  Park	
  
–  No	
  Housing	
  Element	
  for	
  decades	
  
–  Virtually	
  no	
  affordable	
  housing	
  production	
  
–  Virtually	
  no	
  appropriately	
  zoned	
  sites	
  	
  
•  FACEBOOK	
  
–  Needed	
  discretionary	
  approval	
  to	
  expand	
  
–  CEQA	
  review	
  
•  Peninsula	
  Interfaith	
  Action,	
  et	
  al	
  v.	
  City	
  of	
  Menlo	
  Park	
  
–  Settlement	
  Agreement	
  
•  May	
  21,	
  2013:	
  Housing	
  Element	
  Adopted,	
  Sites	
  
Rezoned	
  	
  
–  Affordable	
  Housing	
  Overlay	
  
18	
  
Getting	
  Creative:	
  
	
  Menlo	
  Park	
  
Things	
  are	
  moving	
  fast:	
  
Do	
  you	
  know	
  where	
  your	
  
city	
  council	
  and	
  planning	
  
staff	
  are?	
  
19	
  
ACT	
  NOW!	
  	
  
•  Sam	
  Tepperman-­‐Gelfant	
  
Senior	
  Staff	
  Attorney,	
  Public	
  Advocates	
  
–  stepperman-­‐gelfant@publicadvocates.org	
  
–  www.publicadvocates.org	
  
–  Facebook:	
  publicadvocates	
  
–  Twitter:	
  @publicadvocates	
  
20	
  
More	
  Information	
  
Lillian	
  Lew-­‐Hailer	
  
MidPen	
  Housing	
  Corporation	
  
December	
  18,	
  2013	
  
	
  
	
  
	
  
URBAN	
  HABITAT	
  
BOARDS	
  AND	
  COMMISSIONS	
  
LEADERSHIP	
  INSTITUTE	
  
	
  
	
  
Real	
  Estate	
  Development:	
  
•  7,000	
  affordable	
  homes;	
  
1,600	
  units	
  in	
  pipeline;	
  640	
  
units	
  under	
  construction.	
  
	
  
Property	
  Management:	
  	
  
•  87	
  properties,	
  14,000	
  	
  
residents	
  
	
  
Resident	
  Services:	
  
•  $5	
  million	
  annually;	
  300	
  
service	
  partners.	
  
MidPen	
  Housing	
  
 
•  Site	
  near	
  neighborhood	
  
amenities	
  
•  Great	
  design	
  matters	
  
	
  
	
  
•  Mixed-­‐income	
  works	
  
•  Quality	
  property	
  and	
  
asset	
  management	
  
•  Services	
  enriched	
  
housing	
  
	
  
MidPen	
  Model	
  
 
	
  
	
  
§  Finding	
  Good	
  Sites	
  
§  Predicting	
  in	
  the	
  Process	
  
§  Zoning	
  and	
  entitlement	
  
§  NIMBYism	
  
§  High	
  Costs	
  
§  City	
  fees	
  
§  Special	
  requirements	
  
§  Lack	
  of	
  Funding	
  	
  
Challenges	
  
 
§  Create	
  Good	
  Sites	
  
§  Predictability	
  in	
  the	
  Process	
  
§  Design	
  and	
  parking	
  standards	
  
§  YIMBYism	
  
§  Lower	
  Costs	
  
§  Reduced	
  fees	
  for	
  affordable	
  housing	
  
§  Expedite	
  processes	
  
§  Don’t	
  pile	
  on!	
  
§  Generate	
  Funding	
  	
  
§  Inclusionary	
  policies	
  
§  Housing	
  Impact	
  Fees	
  &	
  Jobs/Housing	
  Linkage	
  Fees	
  
§  “Boomerang”	
  funds	
  
Housing	
  Element	
  
Solutions	
  
§  Participate!	
  
§  Sign	
  up	
  for	
  emails,	
  fill	
  out	
  surveys,	
  write	
  letters	
  
§  Represent!	
  
§  Show	
  up	
  at	
  hearings	
  
§  Be	
  the	
  face	
  of	
  affordable	
  housing	
  
§  Be	
  a	
  YIMBY!	
  
§  Be	
  the	
  face	
  of	
  affordable	
  housing’s	
  neighbors	
  
§  Make	
  low	
  and	
  moderate	
  income	
  housing	
  a	
  priority	
  
Advocate	
  
Engagement	
  
”Ensuring	
  Homes	
  for	
  All:	
  	
  
An	
  Equity	
  Primer	
  on	
  Housing	
  Elements”	
  
December	
  18,	
  2013	
  

Ensuring Homes for All: An Equity Primer on Housing Elements

  • 1.
    ”Ensuring  Homes  for  All:     An  Equity  Primer  on  Housing  Elements”   December  18,  2013  
  • 3.
    UH  News   Executive  Director  Position  Available   Shared  office  for  rent  @  Urban   Habitat   Land  Use/Affordable  Housing   Coordinator  Position  Available  
  • 4.
    Our  Approach   • Policy  Advocacy   •  Mobilizing  and  Educating  Community   Coalitions  around  Policy   •  Training  Advocates  to  become  Decision-­‐ Makers  
  • 5.
    The  BCLI  Model   Train   Place   Connect   Recruit   1   2   3   4  
  • 6.
    The  Fellowship   Deep  and  integrated  equity  knowledge     Political  skills   Power  structures  and  influences   Commission  procedures  and  best   practices   SKILLS  KNOWLEDGE   NETWORK  
  • 7.
    Current  Issues  Series   •  Network   •  Critically  question  and  engage   •  Share  your  perspective  with  our  speakers   •  Inform  your  communities  and  your  work  
  • 8.
    • Affordable  Housing  Advocacy   Coalition  founded  in  1984   • Based  in  Oakland,  work  throughout   Alameda  and  Contra  Costa  Counties  – also  on  regional  and  state  issues   • Preserve,  Promote  and  Expand   Affordable  Housing  Opportunities   through  Education,  Advocacy,   Coalition  Building  and  Organizing   • Membership-­‐based:  300+  individual   and  organizational  members   www.EBHO.org   East  Bay  Housing  Organizations  
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
      Ensuring   Homes  for   All:     An  Equity   Primer  on   Housing   Elements     Bay  Area  Housing  Elements:     What’s  Happening  Now   Sam  Tepperman-­‐ Gelfant,     Public  Advocates   Inc.        
  • 14.
    •  Plan  Bay  Area   Sustainable  Communities  Strategy  (SCS)   •  Regional  Housing  Need  Allocation  (RHNA)  numbers   finalized  July  18,  2013   •  Housing  Element  Updates  by  January  31,  2015   •  Some  Positive  aspects  of  regional  framing   –  Displacement  risk  front  and  center   –  Zoning  near  transit  and  amenities   •  2014-­‐2022  RHNA  Cycle  will  be  SMALLER  and   FASTER   14   Local  Housing  Elements:     Regional  Context  
  • 15.
    •  Sites  for  Affordable  Housing   •  Local  Funding  for  Affordable  Housing   –  Impact  and  Linkage  Fees   –  Boomerang  Funds   •  Policies  and  Programs     –  Tenant  Protections   –  Incentive/Overlay  zoning   –  Site  consolidation   •  See  Results:  Pleasanton,  Alameda,  Menlo  Park,   Concord,  Marin  County,  etc.   15   Playing  to  Win  
  • 16.
    •  Reduced  Regional  Housing  Need  Number   –  2007-­‐2014  =  214,500     –  2014-­‐2022  =  187,990   •  70%  of  RHNA  distributed  to  Priority  Development   Areas  (PDAs)     –  PDAs  are  disproportionately  in  low-­‐income   communities  of  color   –  Most  wealthy  suburbs  got  reduced  numbers         16   Smaller  Numbers  
  • 17.
    •  Streamlined  Review  by  HCD   –  Certified  Housing  Element  for  2007-­‐14  cycle   –  Rezoning  Completed   –  Density  Bonus  Ordinance   –  Zoning  for  Emergency  Shelters,  Transitional  and  Supportive   Housing   –  Reasonable  Accommodation   •  Statutory  Incentives  for  Timely  Adoption   –  Revise  every  4  years  if  Housing  Element  not  adopted  within  120   days  of  deadline   •  The  OneBayArea  Grant  Program   –  HCD  Certified  Housing  Element  required  to  access  some   transportation  dollars   17   Faster  Process  
  • 18.
    •  Menlo  Park   –  No  Housing  Element  for  decades   –  Virtually  no  affordable  housing  production   –  Virtually  no  appropriately  zoned  sites     •  FACEBOOK   –  Needed  discretionary  approval  to  expand   –  CEQA  review   •  Peninsula  Interfaith  Action,  et  al  v.  City  of  Menlo  Park   –  Settlement  Agreement   •  May  21,  2013:  Housing  Element  Adopted,  Sites   Rezoned     –  Affordable  Housing  Overlay   18   Getting  Creative:    Menlo  Park  
  • 19.
    Things  are  moving  fast:   Do  you  know  where  your   city  council  and  planning   staff  are?   19   ACT  NOW!    
  • 20.
    •  Sam  Tepperman-­‐Gelfant   Senior  Staff  Attorney,  Public  Advocates   –  stepperman-­‐gelfant@publicadvocates.org   –  www.publicadvocates.org   –  Facebook:  publicadvocates   –  Twitter:  @publicadvocates   20   More  Information  
  • 21.
    Lillian  Lew-­‐Hailer   MidPen  Housing  Corporation   December  18,  2013         URBAN  HABITAT   BOARDS  AND  COMMISSIONS   LEADERSHIP  INSTITUTE      
  • 22.
    Real  Estate  Development:   •  7,000  affordable  homes;   1,600  units  in  pipeline;  640   units  under  construction.     Property  Management:     •  87  properties,  14,000     residents     Resident  Services:   •  $5  million  annually;  300   service  partners.   MidPen  Housing  
  • 23.
      •  Site  near  neighborhood   amenities   •  Great  design  matters       •  Mixed-­‐income  works   •  Quality  property  and   asset  management   •  Services  enriched   housing     MidPen  Model  
  • 24.
          § Finding  Good  Sites   §  Predicting  in  the  Process   §  Zoning  and  entitlement   §  NIMBYism   §  High  Costs   §  City  fees   §  Special  requirements   §  Lack  of  Funding     Challenges  
  • 25.
      §  Create  Good  Sites   §  Predictability  in  the  Process   §  Design  and  parking  standards   §  YIMBYism   §  Lower  Costs   §  Reduced  fees  for  affordable  housing   §  Expedite  processes   §  Don’t  pile  on!   §  Generate  Funding     §  Inclusionary  policies   §  Housing  Impact  Fees  &  Jobs/Housing  Linkage  Fees   §  “Boomerang”  funds   Housing  Element   Solutions  
  • 26.
    §  Participate!   § Sign  up  for  emails,  fill  out  surveys,  write  letters   §  Represent!   §  Show  up  at  hearings   §  Be  the  face  of  affordable  housing   §  Be  a  YIMBY!   §  Be  the  face  of  affordable  housing’s  neighbors   §  Make  low  and  moderate  income  housing  a  priority   Advocate   Engagement  
  • 27.
    ”Ensuring  Homes  for  All:     An  Equity  Primer  on  Housing  Elements”   December  18,  2013