This document defines heparin resistance and discusses its management in different clinical settings. Heparin resistance is when high doses of heparin are needed to achieve therapeutic anticoagulation levels. It can occur in patients with venous thromboembolism, during cardiac surgery, or with acute coronary syndromes. Risk factors include antithrombin deficiency and high platelet counts. Management involves adjusting heparin doses based on anti-Factor Xa levels, supplementing with antithrombin, or using direct thrombin inhibitors as alternatives to heparin. The optimal treatment depends on the specific clinical situation and aims to safely achieve adequate anticoagulation.
2. OBJECTIVES
Define Heparin Resistance and Understand the
Mechanisms of Heparin Resistance
Evaluate Different Risk Factors for Heparin
Resistance
Discuss the Therapeutic Management of Heparin
Resistance in Various Settings
3. DEFINITION OF HEPARIN RESISTANCE
For VTE/PE treatment or prevention:
A situation wherein patients require unusually high doses of
heparin to achieve a therapeutic aPTT 1
Daily heparin requirement is >35,000U per 24 hours 2
During cardiac surgery:
Failure to achieve target ACT (activated clotting time) with
unusually high doses of heparin 3
4. MECHANISMS OF HEPARIN RESISTANCE
Mechanism of Action of
Heparin:
Proposed Mechanisms of
Action of Heparin Resistance :
Antithrombin (AT) deficiency
Increased heparin clearance
Elevation in heparin-binding
proteins
High levels of factor VIII and/or
fibrinogen
1. Garcia, David A., et al. "Parenteral anticoagulants: antithrombotic therapy and prevention of thrombosis: American College of Chest Physicians evidence-
based clinical practice guidelines." CHEST Journal 141.2_suppl (2012): e24S-e43S
5. RISK FACTORS FOR HEPARIN RESISTANCE
AT-mediated:
Reduced AT synthesis
(heredity or acquired such as
liver disease, malnutrition)
Accelerated AT clearance
Nephropathy
Accelerated AT
consumption:
Preoperative use of UFH or
LMWH (>24- 48hours)
Endocarditis
Cardiopulmonary bypass,
ventricular assist device,
intra-aortic balloon pump
Non AT-mediated:
High preoperative platelet
counts (> 300,000/mL)
Plasma albumin
concentration <35g/dL
Hypovolemia
Medications: nitroglycerin
(concomitant infusion)
7. IN SETTING OF VTE/PE
Heparin Resistance occurs in 25% of patients with VTE 5
Assessing anti-factor Xa heparin level has been shown
to be more safe and effective in monitoring heparin
resistance than targeting therapeutic aPTT level 2,6
Heparin dose should be adjusted to maintain anti-factor
Xa heparin level of 0.35 – 0.70 IU/mL
Substitution of LMWH can be an option but may be
inadvisable in patients with high risk of bleeding
8. EXAMPLE OF WEIGHT-BASED HEPARIN DOSING USING
APTT AND ANTI-FACTOR XA MONITORING
Adapted from University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics. Therapeutic Dosing of UFH – Adult – Inpatient – Clinical Practice
Guideline. Assessed at:
http://www.uwhealth.org/files/uwhealth/docs/anticoagulation/Therapeutic_Unfractionated_Heparin_Infusion_Guideline.pdf
9. IN SETTING OF CARDIAC SURGERY
Heparin Resistance has also been reported in up to 22%
of patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass 7
1. Additional Heparin administration until the ACT
reaches target level 3
2. Antithrombin (AT) supplementation 3
1. via Fresh Frozen Plasma (FFP)
2. AT concentrates
3. Nafamostat Mesilate 8
10. Proposed Treatment Algorithm of Heparin
Resistance in Cardiopulmonary Bypass 3
Heparin Resistance with ACT level target
not reached
*Preoperative plasma AT concentration is
recommended
Low AT level
AT supplementation 500
– 1000 IU
*AT concentrate is
preferred over FFP
If ACT fails to reach target
with initial dose, repeated
doses should be given
Normal AT
Administer larger dose of
heparin
Check whole blood
heparin concentration
to ensure adequate
heparin level ( 4U/mL)
Recheck ACT
level
Normal AT and heparin
level > 4U/mL
Clinical judgment and
empirical treatment
11. OTHER SETTINGS
ACUTE CORONARY SYNDROMES
A cohort study showed use of bivalirudin resulted in a
more consistent anticoagulation activity compared to
heparin 9
COMORBIDITY OF OBESITY WITH HEPARIN
RESISTANCE
A case report of use of subcutaneous lepirudin after
subtherapeutic AT level and aPTT were reported with an
escalated dose of heparin 10
12. SUMMARY OF HEPARIN RESISTANCE MANAGEMENT
SETTINGS RECOMMENDED TREATMENT OPTIONS
VTE/PE 1. Adjust Heparin dose based on anti-factor Xa level
(instead of aPTT level)
2. LMWH (unless patients have high risk of
bleeding)
Cardiac Surgery
*recommend
checking
preoperative plasma
AT level
1. Increase Heparin dose
2. AT supplementation (either FFP or AT
concentrates)
3. Nafamostat Mesilate (limited evidence)
Acute Coronary
Syndrome
1. Direct Thrombin Inhibitors (Argatroban,
Bivalirudin, Lepirudin)
13.
14. REFERENCES
1. Garcia, David A., et al. "Parenteral anticoagulants: antithrombotic therapy and prevention of thrombosis: American
College of Chest Physicians evidence-based clinical practice guidelines." CHEST Journal 141.2_suppl (2012): e24S-e43S
2. Hirsh J, Warkentin TE, Shaughnessy SG, et al. Heparin and Low-Molecular-Weight Heparin Mechanisms of Action,
Pharmacokinetics, Dosing, Monitoring, Efficacy, and Safety. Chest 2001;119(1).
3. Finley A, Greenberg C. Heparin Sensitivity and Resistance. Anesthesia & Analgesia 2013;116(6):1210–1222.
4. Chan T, Hwang NC, Lim CH. A statistical analysis of factors predisposing patients to heparin resistance. Perfusion
perfusion 2006;21(2):99–103.
5. Mcrae SJ. Initial Treatment of Venous Thromboembolism. Circulation 2004;110(9_suppl_1).
6. Levine MN. A Randomized Trial Comparing Activated Thromboplastin Time With Heparin Assay in Patients With
Acute Venous Thromboembolism Requiring Large Daily Doses of Heparin. Arch Intern Med Archives of Internal
Medicine 1994;154(1):49.
7. Spiess BD. Treating Heparin Resistance With Antithrombin or Fresh Frozen Plasma. The Annals of Thoracic Surgery
2008;85(6):2153–2160.
8. Kikura M, Tanaka K, Hiraiwa T, Tanaka K. Nafamostat Mesilate, as a Treatment for Heparin Resistance, Is Not
Associated With Perioperative Ischemic Stroke in Patients Undergoing Cardiac Surgery With Cardiopulmonary
Bypass. Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia 2012;26(2):239–244.
9. Rich JD, Maraganore JM, Young E, et al. Heparin resistance in acute coronary syndromes. Journal of Thrombosis and
Thrombolysis J Thromb Thrombolysis 2007;23(2):93–100.
10. Inman KR, Gerlach AT. Use of Subcutaneous Lepirudin in an Obese Surgical Intensive Care Unit Patient with Heparin
Resistance. Annals of Pharmacotherapy 2009;43(10):1714–1718.
Editor's Notes
Indications of Heparin:
VTE/PE: PPx and Tx
Atrial fibrillation
Acute coronary syndromes(NSTEMI, unstable angina) to reduce risk of MI or death
Cardiac surgery: during procedure (CABG), after procedure (mechanical heart valves)
Monitor for effects of heparin:
APTT – activated partial thrombinplastin time
global test that reflects the ability of the heparin-antithrombin III complex to inactivate thrombin, factor Xa, and other coagulation enzyme
If aPTT falls below thrp range there will be increased risk of recurrent thrombosis, while there is also risk of bleeding with increasing heparin dose
Normal aPTT for heparin is 1.5-2.5x controlled reagents. (according to a study done in 1970s, aPTT ratio between 1.5-2.5 was associated with a reduced risk of recurrent VTE) . For example: different for every lab (every institution will have their own goal of aPTT range), if control: 40s, goal: 60-100s.
Usually check aPTT as follow:
Every 6h initially until 2 consecutive values are within thrp range
Once daily thereafter
2. Heparin assay (anti-factor Xa)
based on the ability of heparin to neutralize fixed amount of either thrombin or Xa that are added to plasma
The assay is more expensive than aPTT and not used routinely.
The correlation between aPTT and heparin assay is fairly good but the results of these tests can be dissociated in some patients because the aPTT response to heparin is influenced by the levels of coagulation factors, which is not the case for heparin assay. As a result, such patient can have a subthrp aPTT despite a heparin level within the thrp range
What is ACT? How is it measured?
ACT is measured to monitor anticoagulant effect of heparin
When given in therapeutic doses, the anticoagulant effect of heparin is usually monitored using aPTT.
The ACT is used to monitor the higher heparin doses given to patients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention
Test to measure the time required to transform blood from liquid to gel.
Unlike the aPTT, which becomes unclottable at the heparin concentrations commonly used during cardiac surgery (2-10U/mL), ACT then can still be used to detect the effects of heparin
Only 1/3 of administered dose of heparin binds to AT and this fraction is responsible for most of its anticoagulation effect
When heparin binds to AT change the conformation of AT that makes it have more affinity to the clotting enzyme and bind to it and the AT-heparin complexes inactivate the procoagulatant effect of the clotting enz
Clotting enz/coagulantion enz include thrombin factor IIa, Xa, IXa, and XIIa. Of these, thombin IIa and factor Xa are most responsive to inhibition
In circulation, heparin also binds to other molecules, such as plasma proteins and platelets, which reduces its anticoag activity at low concentrations thereby contributing to the variability of the anticoagulant response to heparin among patients with thromboembolic disorder and to the phenomenon of heparin resistance
Increased factor VIII activity has been shown to augment the clotting phase and reduce the heparin dose response curve. Factor VIII is acute phase reactant that increases in the setting of inflammation and is often seen in cardiac surgical population.
4. Chan T, Hwang NC, Lim CH. A statistical analysis of factors predisposing patients to heparin resistance. Perfusion perfusion 2006;21(2):99–103.
Hypovolemia due to preoperative administration of diuretic in patient with lower ejection fraction with congestive cardiac syndromes lead to requirement of greater infusion volumes prior to cardiac bypass surgery to maintain hemodynamic stability during anesthesia
Platelet factor 4 (released during platelet activation) can neutralize heparin
Albumin has also been shown to enhance the neutralization of factor Xa by AT-heparin complex
In the setting of cardiac surgery where heparin is used, nitroglycerin can also be infused IV concomitantly to prevent perioperative hypertension. There are study reports showing that NR can induce heparin resistance and found out that the propylene glycol preparation used in IV infusion NTG is the main cause because it binds to heparin NTG without propylene glycol may not have the same effect.
Mcrae SJ. Initial Treatment of Venous Thromboembolism. Circulation 2004;110(9_suppl_1).
Levine MN. A Randomized Trial Comparing Activated Thromboplastin Time With Heparin Assay in Patients With Acute Venous Thromboembolism Requiring Large Daily Doses of Heparin. Arch Intern Med Archives of Internal Medicine 1994;154(1):49.
A trial comparing antiXa with aPTT: “A comparative trial of anti-factor Xa levels versus the activated partial thromboplastin time for heparin monitoring.”
Use of an anti–factor Xa assay–based UFH-monitoring protocol resulted in a higher percentage of within-range blood plasma heparin monitoring tests, fewer monitoring tests for the patient to achieve blood plasma monitoring tests within goal range, and fewer dose adjustments compared with a protocol based on blood plasma monitoring using the aPTT.
. Heparin assay (anti-factor Xa)
based on the ability of heparin to neutralize fixed amount of either thrombin or Xa that are added to plasma
The assay is more expensive than aPTT and not used routinely.
The correlation between aPTT and heparin assay is fairly good but the results of these tests can be dissociated in some patients because the aPTT response to heparin is influenced by the levels of coagulation factors, which is not the case for heparin assay. As a result, such patient can have a subthrp aPTT despite a heparin level within the thrp range
2. Case report using off-label high dose of LMWH (1.5mg/kg BID) resulted in achievement of therapeutic anti-Xa levels in proven heparin-resistant patient in cancer patient with VTE
Normal dose: 1mg/kg BID or 1.5mg/kg QD (in case of renal insufficiency: 1mg/kg QD)
However, it is still inadvisable due to its long half-life and lack of effective neutralizing agent
Finley A, Greenberg C. Heparin Sensitivity and Resistance. Anesthesia & Analgesia 2013;116(6):1210–1222.
Kikura M, Tanaka K, Hiraiwa T, Tanaka K. Nafamostat Mesilate, as a Treatment for Heparin Resistance, Is Not Associated With Perioperative Ischemic Stroke in Patients Undergoing Cardiac Surgery With Cardiopulmonary Bypass. Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia 2012;26(2):239–244.
- Spiess BD. Treating Heparin Resistance With Antithrombin or Fresh Frozen Plasma. The Annals of Thoracic Surgery 2008;85(6):2153–2160.
Several case reports have documented heparin doses as high as 1200U/kg to achieve target ACT. However, there is also risk associated with such high dose of heparin as total heparin dose is correlated with heparin rebound (the reappearance of anticoagulant activity after adequate neutralization with protamine, is thought to contribute to excessive postoperative bleeding after cardiac surgery) and a potential increase in post-surgery chest tube drainage. Another study demonstrated that whole blood heparin concentration > 4U/mL failed to further increase the ACT
2U of FFP may be sufficient to improve clinical outcome in heparin resistance. However, safety concerns with transfusions and the time delay to thaw FFP makes this a less appealing therapy. AT concentrates have emerged as an alternative method of AT supplementation and recently become preferred method. AT concentrates can be either purified human or recombinant form. Recombinant form has short half-life requires maintenance infusion if supplementation is needed for extended period of time. Supplied in vials with different doses (human 500IU, recombinant 750IU)
A retrospective cohort study looked at patients undergo cardiopulmonary bypass with heparin resistance were treated with nafamostat 10-20mg bolus plus 25-50mg per hour of nafamostat and heparin at 100U/kg every 1.5-2h to maintain ACT over 480s. The study also showed that nafamostat treatment for heparin resistance is not associated with perioperative ischemic stroke in patients undergoing CBP
Nafamostat – short-acting protease inhibitor used to treat pancreatitis, disseminated intravascular coagulopathy and it is used for anticoagulation in HD
10. Rich JD, Maraganore JM, Young E, et al. Heparin resistance in acute coronary syndromes. Journal of Thrombosis and Thrombolysis J Thromb Thrombolysis 2007;23(2):93–100.
11. Inman KR, Gerlach AT. Use of Subcutaneous Lepirudin in an Obese Surgical Intensive Care Unit Patient with Heparin Resistance. Annals of Pharmacotherapy 2009;43(10):1714–1718.
- Case report of a 34-yo morbidly obese male presenting with hypoxia 1 day after his sigmoid colectomy. UFH was given to prevent both VTE and PE (even though PE was ruled out later). Both aPTT and AT level were not in thrp range and lepirudin (direct thrombin inhibitor) was then administered 50mg SQ BID, which resulting in thrp level of aPTT. Then lepirudin dose was adjusted to 25mg BID with aPTT still in range and minor bleeding noted. Patients were finally discharged with no development of VTE.