Towards an Ethics of Creative SoundJ A M ES A N D E A N.docxturveycharlyn
Towards an Ethics of Creative Sound
J A M ES A N D E A N
Centre for Music & Technology, Sibelius Academy, University of the Arts Helsinki, PL 30, 00097 Taideyliopisto, Helsinki, Finland
E-mail: [email protected]
This article examines some of the ethical issues involved
in working creatively with sound. Issues considered include:
sound ownership; sound vs. vision as determinations of
identity, and their relative iconicity; recorded sound; sound as
physical phenomenon vs. sound as symbol; issues of copyright
and trademark; community ownership; awareness, sensitivity
and responsibility; composer responsibility vs. listener
responsibility; the relative importance of contextualisation;
and intercultural dialogue. We will conclude with a critique
of the cultural and ethical shortcomings of the article itself,
and a call for social, cultural and ethical engagement in
creative sound work.
1. INTRODUCTION
This article intends to examine some of the issues
involved with and surrounding the ethics of working
creatively with sound. The term ‘creative sound’ is
used here primarily in an attempt to think broadly
about creative sound work, without narrowing it to
an examination of a particular style, genre or prac-
tice; however, due to some of the issues raised, some
of the discussion will be particularly relevant for
categories that include working with recorded sound
in some form.
It should be stressed from the beginning that we are
not here attempting to define or prescribe a particular
ethical framework for creative sound work. This is not
an attempt to judge, nor to preach; it is instead an
attempt to observe and outline some of the existing –
and sometimes contradictory – mores, pressures, stric-
tures, demands, requirements, prejudices and other
social and ethical factors that come into play when
working creatively with sound. It is an attempt to
engage with and bring into play some of the many criss-
crossing ethical strands that impact our work. It should
also be noted that we cannot claim here to be complete,
nor definitive, by any means, but merely to offer a few
small points, and an attempt at an overview of some
aspects of a broad and complex subject.
2. ‘WHOSE SOUND IS IT ANYWAY?’: SOUND
OWNERSHIP
Some of the key questions regarding the ethical use
of sound concern sound rights: which sounds can
be used, and which sounds can’t; by whom; in what
manner, and so on. However, we will open with an
issue that speaks in much less equivocal terms: sound
ownership.
Is it possible – or meaningful – to ‘own’ a sound?
For a sound to be the property of an individual, or of
a community? One finds a range of decisive responses
to this question, often quite polarised. Many of these
are closely tied to questions of identity, as well as
to varying cultural understandings of the nature of
sound.
3. SOUND AND VISION
In both of these respects, it is perhaps informative to
begin with similarities and differences between cultural
attitudes towards owners ...
Towards an Ethics of Creative SoundJ A M ES A N D E A N.docxturveycharlyn
Towards an Ethics of Creative Sound
J A M ES A N D E A N
Centre for Music & Technology, Sibelius Academy, University of the Arts Helsinki, PL 30, 00097 Taideyliopisto, Helsinki, Finland
E-mail: [email protected]
This article examines some of the ethical issues involved
in working creatively with sound. Issues considered include:
sound ownership; sound vs. vision as determinations of
identity, and their relative iconicity; recorded sound; sound as
physical phenomenon vs. sound as symbol; issues of copyright
and trademark; community ownership; awareness, sensitivity
and responsibility; composer responsibility vs. listener
responsibility; the relative importance of contextualisation;
and intercultural dialogue. We will conclude with a critique
of the cultural and ethical shortcomings of the article itself,
and a call for social, cultural and ethical engagement in
creative sound work.
1. INTRODUCTION
This article intends to examine some of the issues
involved with and surrounding the ethics of working
creatively with sound. The term ‘creative sound’ is
used here primarily in an attempt to think broadly
about creative sound work, without narrowing it to
an examination of a particular style, genre or prac-
tice; however, due to some of the issues raised, some
of the discussion will be particularly relevant for
categories that include working with recorded sound
in some form.
It should be stressed from the beginning that we are
not here attempting to define or prescribe a particular
ethical framework for creative sound work. This is not
an attempt to judge, nor to preach; it is instead an
attempt to observe and outline some of the existing –
and sometimes contradictory – mores, pressures, stric-
tures, demands, requirements, prejudices and other
social and ethical factors that come into play when
working creatively with sound. It is an attempt to
engage with and bring into play some of the many criss-
crossing ethical strands that impact our work. It should
also be noted that we cannot claim here to be complete,
nor definitive, by any means, but merely to offer a few
small points, and an attempt at an overview of some
aspects of a broad and complex subject.
2. ‘WHOSE SOUND IS IT ANYWAY?’: SOUND
OWNERSHIP
Some of the key questions regarding the ethical use
of sound concern sound rights: which sounds can
be used, and which sounds can’t; by whom; in what
manner, and so on. However, we will open with an
issue that speaks in much less equivocal terms: sound
ownership.
Is it possible – or meaningful – to ‘own’ a sound?
For a sound to be the property of an individual, or of
a community? One finds a range of decisive responses
to this question, often quite polarised. Many of these
are closely tied to questions of identity, as well as
to varying cultural understandings of the nature of
sound.
3. SOUND AND VISION
In both of these respects, it is perhaps informative to
begin with similarities and differences between cultural
attitudes towards owners ...
Is a picture worth 1,000 words? Textual AnalysisDeborahJ
This lecture will introduce semiotics or the semiology of art, a mechanism for deriving meaning that is considered to a more inclusive development of Panofsky’s Iconography
Is a picture worth 1,000 words? Textual AnalysisDeborahJ
This lecture will introduce semiotics or the semiology of art, a mechanism for deriving meaning that is considered to a more inclusive development of Panofsky’s Iconography
HANDBOOK OF BRAND SEMIOTICS
Semiotics has been making progressively inroads into marketing
research over the past thirty years. Despite the amply
demonstrated conceptual appeal and empirical pertinence of
semiotic perspectives in various marketing research streams,
spanning consumer research, brand communications, branding
and consumer cultural studies, there has been a marked deficit in
terms of consolidating semiotic brand-related research under a
coherent disciplinary umbrella with identifiable boundaries and
research agenda.
The Handbook of Brand Semiotics furnishes a compass for the
perplexed, a set of anchors for the inquisitive and a solid corpus
for scholars, while highlighting the conceptual richness and
methodological diversity of semiotic perspectives.
Written by a team of expert scholars in various semiotics and
branding related fields, such as John A. Bateman, David Machin,
Xavier Ruiz Collantes, Kay L. O’Halloran, Dario Mangano,
George Rossolatos, Merce Oliva, Per Ledin, Gianfranco
Marrone, Francesco Mangiapane, Jennie Mazur, Carlos Scolari,
Ilaria Ventura, and edited by George Rossolatos, Chief Editor of
the International Journal of Marketing Semiotics, the Handbook is
intended as a point of reference for scholars who wish to enter
the ‘House of Brand Semiotics’ and explore its marvels.
The Handbook of Brand Semiotics, actively geared towards an
inter-disciplinary dialogue between perspectives from the
marketing and semiotic literatures, features the state-of-the-art,
but also offers directions for future research in key streams, such
as:
- Analyzing and designing brand language across media
- Brand image, brand symbols, brand icons vs. iconicity
- The contribution of semiotics to transmedia storytelling
- Could transmedia storytelling turn out to be what IMC
forgot (i.e., the message)?
- Narrativity and rhetorical approaches to branding
- Semiotic roadmap for designing brand identity
- Semiotic roadmap for designing logos and packaging
- Comparative readings of structuralist, Peircean and
sociosemiotic approaches to brandcomms
- Sociosemiotic accounts of building brand identity online
- Multimodality and Multimodal critical discourse analysis
- Challenging the omnipotence of cognitivism in brandrelated
research
- Semiotics and (inter)cultural branding
- Brand equity semiotics
George rossolatos building strong brands with structuralist rhetorical semiot...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
George Rossolatos
Building strong brands with structuralist rhetorical semiotics
New Bulgaria University 19 9 2014
12th International Association for Semiotic Studies World Congress
Brand equity planning with structuralist operations and operations of rhetori...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
This paper furnishes a structuralist rhetorical semiotic conceptual framework for brand equity
planning. The main source of brand equity that is employed for exemplification purposes is the
advertising filmic text. The conceptual framework assumes as its general blueprint Greimas’s
generativist model of the trajectory of signification. Structuralist operations and operations of
rhetorical transformation are posited as the basis for the generation of superior brand associations.
The conceptual model put forward challenges the Greimasian assumption that
a
depth
semantic
structure is
reducible
to a binarist rationale, while adopting a connectionist approach
in
the form of associative networks. At the same time,
the
proposed
framework
deviates from
the
application of conceptual graphs in textual semiotics,
while
portraying in the form of
associative
networks how the three strata of a brand’s trajectory of signification interact with
view
to generating brand associations.
Exploring the rhetorical semiotic brand image structure of ad films with mult...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
The aim of this paper is to demonstrate the applicability of multivariate
mapping techniques to the exploration of the rhetorical semiotic brand image
structure of ad films. By drawing on correspondence analysis and multidimen
sional scaling, two techniques that are amply used in corpus linguistics and in
marketing research, but also on the data reduction technique of factor analysis, it
will be displayed how a set of nuclear semes and classemes or an intended semic
structure that underlies ad filmic discursive structures may be projected along
side rhetorical figures by its internal stakeholders (i.e., a brand management
team, an account planning team or a marketing research team) with view to
attaining differential brand associations. The illustration of the exploratory ana
lytical methods takes place by recourse to a corpus of 62 ad filmic texts from 13
subbrands of the 3 major brands in the UK cereals market and 321 ad filmic seg
ments that resulted from the segmentation procedure. This paper seeks to con
tribute to advancements in the brand image and advertising rhetoric research
streams by addressing distinctive modes of advertising rhetorical configuration at
the level of the ad filmic text (as against print ads where the bulk of research on
advertising rhetoric has concentrated), and moreover on a segmentbysegment
level, rather than treating the ad film as a standalone unit of analysis, by adopt
ing a multimodal outlook to advertising configurations that takes into account
not only the verbal or the visual mode, but also interactions among modes, by
adopting a product categoryspecific approach to advertising/brand textuality
that draws on rhetorical semiotics and by employing exploratory statistical
methods against the background of content analytic output.
George rossolatos post doctoral application march 2014: For a semiotic model ...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
George rossolatos post doctoral application march 2014: For a semiotic model of cultural branding and the dynamic management of a brandosphere in the face of User Generated Advertising
George rossolatos seminar on branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models an...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
Seminar on Branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models and research methods
Tartu University, Estonia 13-14 May 2014
George Rossolatos MSc, MBA, PhD
//disruptiVesemiOtics// email: georgerossolatos123@gmail.com
http://uni-kassel.academia.edu/georgerossolatos
George rossolatos seminar on branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models an...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
Seminar on Branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models and research methods
Tartu University, Estonia 13-14 May 2014
George Rossolatos MSc, MBA, PhD
//disruptiVesemiOtics// email: georgerossolatos123@gmail.com
http://uni-kassel.academia.edu/georgerossolatos
George rossolatos seminar on branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models an...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
Seminar on Branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models and research methods
Tartu University, Estonia 13-14 May 2014
George Rossolatos MSc, MBA, PhD
//disruptiVesemiOtics// email: georgerossolatos123@gmail.com
http://uni-kassel.academia.edu/georgerossolatos
George rossolatos seminar on branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models an...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
Seminar on Branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models and research methods
Tartu University, Estonia 13-14 May 2014
George Rossolatos MSc, MBA, PhD
//disruptiVesemiOtics// email: georgerossolatos123@gmail.com
http://uni-kassel.academia.edu/georgerossolatos
George rossolatos seminar on branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models an...//disruptiVesemiOtics//
Seminar on Branding, brand equity, brand semiotic models and research methods
Tartu University, Estonia 13-14 May 2014
George Rossolatos MSc, MBA, PhD
//disruptiVesemiOtics// email: georgerossolatos123@gmail.com
http://uni-kassel.academia.edu/georgerossolatos
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.AnnySerafinaLove
This letter, written by Kellen Harkins, Course Director at Full Sail University, commends Anny Love's exemplary performance in the Video Sharing Platforms class. It highlights her dedication, willingness to challenge herself, and exceptional skills in production, editing, and marketing across various video platforms like YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram.
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptxJeremyPeirce1
Discover the top mailing list providers in the USA, offering targeted lists, segmentation, and analytics to optimize your marketing campaigns and drive engagement.
At Techbox Square, in Singapore, we're not just creative web designers and developers, we're the driving force behind your brand identity. Contact us today.
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdfthesiliconleaders
In the recent edition, The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024, The Silicon Leaders magazine gladly features Dejan Štancer, President of the Global Chamber of Business Leaders (GCBL), along with other leaders.
Understanding User Needs and Satisfying ThemAggregage
https://www.productmanagementtoday.com/frs/26903918/understanding-user-needs-and-satisfying-them
We know we want to create products which our customers find to be valuable. Whether we label it as customer-centric or product-led depends on how long we've been doing product management. There are three challenges we face when doing this. The obvious challenge is figuring out what our users need; the non-obvious challenges are in creating a shared understanding of those needs and in sensing if what we're doing is meeting those needs.
In this webinar, we won't focus on the research methods for discovering user-needs. We will focus on synthesis of the needs we discover, communication and alignment tools, and how we operationalize addressing those needs.
Industry expert Scott Sehlhorst will:
• Introduce a taxonomy for user goals with real world examples
• Present the Onion Diagram, a tool for contextualizing task-level goals
• Illustrate how customer journey maps capture activity-level and task-level goals
• Demonstrate the best approach to selection and prioritization of user-goals to address
• Highlight the crucial benchmarks, observable changes, in ensuring fulfillment of customer needs
B2B payments are rapidly changing. Find out the 5 key questions you need to be asking yourself to be sure you are mastering B2B payments today. Learn more at www.BlueSnap.com.
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...my Pandit
Dive into the steadfast world of the Taurus Zodiac Sign. Discover the grounded, stable, and logical nature of Taurus individuals, and explore their key personality traits, important dates, and horoscope insights. Learn how the determination and patience of the Taurus sign make them the rock-steady achievers and anchors of the zodiac.
Personal Brand Statement:
As an Army veteran dedicated to lifelong learning, I bring a disciplined, strategic mindset to my pursuits. I am constantly expanding my knowledge to innovate and lead effectively. My journey is driven by a commitment to excellence, and to make a meaningful impact in the world.
G rossolatos mktng trends conf escp paris fetish taboo simulacrum 18 1_2012
1. Fetish, taboo, simulacrum: An applied
psychoanalytic/semiotic approach to the experiential
consumption of music products
George Rossolatos
(University of Kassel)
&
Margaret K. Hogg
(University of Lancaster)
International Marketing Trends Conference, Paris, January 19 2013
2.
3. Fetish, taboo, simulacrum: An applied
psychoanalytic/semiotic approach to the experiential
consumption of music products
George Rossolatos
(University of Kassel)
&
Margaret K. Hogg
(University of Lancaster)
International Marketing Trends Conference, Paris, January 19 2013
4. Fetish-Taboo-Simulacrum: The triadic definition
of the music product
• Fetish- The music product is highly invested with libidinal energy
(overcathected)
• Simulacrum- Music products are self-referential entities that resemble
nothing but themselves
• Taboo- Music products allow access to the ‘forbidden site’ of the
Other (the Real)
5. Music products as fetishes (petits objets a)
• An object invested with libidinal energy (Freud)
• It performs a function that accords with the pleasure principle
• the maximization of pleasure and the avoidance of pain
• Petit objet a (Lacan)
• A signifier or signifying chain that stands obliquely for an impossible
signified
• An object, as object of value, is a small object a (small other).
6. Music products as fetishes (petits objets a)
• The cultural icon provides a cipher for approximating the Other
• a code for communicating among a music act’s fan base a fundamental lack
• the lack of the origin.
• The relation of the subject to the Other is like an insurmountable ‘gap’
• The ‘gap’ is also the reason why the icon is an object of uncritical devotion
• The processes whereby devotees demonstrate psychic attachment to the
icon have been called ‘sacralizing processes’(Belk et al.1989)
7. Music products as taboos
• Taboo is at the same time ‘sacred’, ‘consecrated’ , ‘uncanny’, ‘dangerous’,
‘forbidden’, ‘unclean’ (Freud)
• The transgression of a taboo amounts to the dissolution of the ego and a
lapsing into the dark continent of the unconscious (lapsus mortalis)
• The music product as cultural icon functions as taboo as it guards against
the ultimate transgression
• a necessary condition for entering the symbolic order of language
• A music product and the key signifiers in its signifying chain constitute a
taboo
• they stand metaphorically for an object of devotion on behalf of a core
consumer franchise or a loyal fan base.
8. Music products as simulacra
• Simulacrum is not the same as image
• It does not presuppose an object external to itself that causally determines its
appearance as copy
• Simulacrum is self-produced and self-subsistent
• The subject of consumption is instituted in the signifying chain of the music product’s
promotional discourse qua simulacrum.
• The promotionally constituted music product is a verbal, aural and visual
rendition/revision of the primary process of the unconscious libidinal flow
9. Fetish-Taboo-Simulacrum: The triadic definition
of the music product
• Fetish, taboo and simulacrum are the operational pillars of our proposed consumer
psychoanalytic interpretive model
• The model addresses how
• Music products as constituted through various promotional mechanisms function
as simulacra, allowing for a ‘dissimulative’ gaze at the Real.
• Music products function as taboos insofar as they as allow for reliving the
moment of the originary point of entry into the symbolic order, as dynamic
interplay with the order of the Imaginary.
• Music products function as fetishes or small objects a [petits objets a], as they
are (over) cathected with libidinal energy, while furnishing a signifying chain that
allows for encapsulating the desire for the Other.
10. From ego-centrism to inter-subjectivity
• Ego psychology: Informed by the Cartesian ego-centric cogito
• Subjectivity is identical to an omnipresent and stable center
• Lacanian psychoanalysis : The subject is always already absent and ec-
centric
• The subject for Lacan may not be conceived of separately from the notion of
the Other.
• Inter-subjectivity (as opposed to ego-centrism) is of paramount importance
for understanding the foundational character of language and the Other in
Lacanian psychoanalysis.
• The other, as a concrete subject, different from oneself, is an
instantiation of the Big Other (Autre)
11. From ego-centrism to inter-subjectivity
• Experiential consumption of music products from a psychoanalytic
perspective cannot be conceptualized independently of others who are
partaking of a neo-tribe of fans or followers of a music act
• According to Lacan, the ego is absolutely impossible to distinguish from
the imaginary captations that constitute it in its function and in its actuality,
by another and for another (Dor and Gurewich 1998)
12. Schema L: How the subject is constituted in an inter-subjective
manner
1 2
3 4
(Dor and Gurewich 1998)
13. Mirror-mirror on the record-cover: The primacy of the mirror-
stage in inter-subjective specular experiential consumption
• A music product is construed through progressive mirroring effects between
a brand’s discourse and the inter-subjective communicative trajectory of its
followers.
• The concept of the mirror-stage is crucial for understanding this mirroring
process.
• The mirror stage is the inaugural phase of psychic development (Lacan)
• In its mirror reflection the child initially conceives of itself as same and other
at the same time
• The mirror stage accompanies a subject in adult life
• Mirroring in / Identification with the specular image of music artists through
promotional items (i.e. posters) or experiential events (i.e. live shows)
• The subject’s formation in inter-subjective consumptive experiences (i.e. live
shows) takes place through a mutual mirroring in each other’s gaze
14. Mirror-mirror on the record-cover: The primacy of the mirror-
stage in inter-subjective specular experiential consumption
• Identification with the specular object in an inter-subjective setting occurs in
a participatory fashion.
• Participation (and not individual reflection) is the modus operandi whereby
the specular object assumes value for a consumption tribe.
• The mirror phase whereby a subject recognizes (and at the same time
misses) itself in the specular image is enacted in a group participatory
setting through multiple mirrorings.
• The subject is mirrored in another subject’s gaze and both subjects are
mirrored in the music act as simulacrum on stage.
• At the same time, the simulacrum on stage is a mirroring of other signifiers
that make up the imago of the music act, such as record covers and video
clips.
15. The music product as simulacrum on stage- In vivo
enactment of the mirror on the record cover
16. Mirror-mirror on the record-cover: The primacy of the mirror-
stage in inter-subjective specular experiential consumption
• The phenomenological experience of the live show assumes the form of a
triple mirroring structure.
• The participating subject (S)
• gazes at another (o’)
• gazing at itself (o)
• while both are instituted as members of a neo-tribe through the mutual gaze that
is oriented towards the live act as petit objet a on stage standing for (O), based
on Schema L.
17. Hedonism vs. Jouissance: The ec-static facet of experiential
consumption
• The consumption of music products is not only hedonic in line with the pleasure-
principle, but even more fundamentally jouissance-driven, in excess of hedonism.
• Jouissance is a mood that transcends joy
• It is sometimes described as pain in pleasure and accompanies ecstatic
experiences
• “Jouissance is what serves no purpose” (Lacan 1999)
• Fun, entertainment
• In the case of jouissance consumption, subjectivity yields to a loss of selfhood
through a ritualistic act of fusion with others.
• Participation in a live-show constitutes an act of jouissance consumption through
• the way it engages the gaze in the face of small objects a
• ritualistic fusion of a neo-tribe’s fans
18. In summary
• The experiential consumption of music products is an act of jouissance,
rather than hedonic consumption.
• Consumers gain jouissance, that is a mixed feeling of pleasure in pain, by
identifying with a decentralised signifier that marks the permanent absence
of the centre of the simulacrum.
• In the act of music products’ experiential consumption the subject re-lives on
an imaginary level its split that allowed entry into the symbolic order
• thus attesting to the music product’s taboo character.
• Contamination is the mode whereby the re-enactment of the subject’s split is
commonly experienced in the context of the specular encounter with the
signifiers that make up the simulacrum.
19. Research objectives
Exploratory research, aiming to
• shed light on the “ways whereby people in particular settings come to
understand, account for, take action and otherwise manage their day-to-day
lives” (Miles and Huberman 1994) in the context of the experiential consumption
of music products.
• examine how music products are constructed through live-shows
• by extension how the image of a music product promotes intra-tribe
coherence as a sacralizing ritual process for neo-tribes of fans
• how jouissance consumption assumes wider cultural significance for the
maintenance of the sacred character of music products and how this is
reinforced through promotional techniques.
20. Data collection- Focus-groups
• The three key interpretive operational categories of fetish, taboo,
simulacrum guided the data collection and interpretation process.
• Focus groups with four different groups of fans
• Nineteen members were recruited as focus group participants from four well-
established fan clubs
• Pulp (Group 1: 5 participants)
• The Smiths (Group 2: 5 participants)
• Depeche Mode (Group 3: 5 participants)
• Madonna (Group 4: 4 participants).
21. Data collection- Focus-groups
• Semi-structured focus-group discussions, driven by a list of key themes,
such as:
• What is a music product?
• Prompting for various features of a music product: music, lyrics, cover, band-image
• What does music act XY mean to you?
• In what contexts in your daily lives as consumers do you apply this/these meaning(s)?
• How do you communicate with your friends and peers about this act?
• Which promotions techniques are more important to you in terms of communicative
content?
• What examples can you identify where promotional messages have acted as vehicles of
intra-group communication?
• What kind of ‘value’ do you derive from making use of promotional
items, such as posters, limited edition items, t-shirts?
22. Data analysis/interpretation
• Discourse analysis for data analysis and interpretation
• Discourse analysis is the study of language, which is viewed not only as
reflecting psychological and social life, but above all as constructing it.
• Discourse analysis (Elliott 1996) is characterised by
• the use of texts
• concentration on the role of language
• we applied discourse analysis to focus groups’ findings in order to elicit how
the three operative categories of fetish, taboo, simulacrum surface in
consumers’ discourse
• to show how the experiential consumption of music products furnishes useful
cultural cues for the construction of coherent and meaningful intra-group
communication
• representativeness
• which implies that participants in the focus groups should have similar music
tastes and life-styles
• variability in accounts
• How commonly lived experiences are interpreted on an
23. Discussion of findings (a)
The function of music products as taboos: [No] access to
the Real
• The progressive shift in importance from the order of the symbolic to the
order of the imaginary in accessing the order of the Real takes place
through a shift of focus
• from the symbolic value of fetishes (i.e. posters)
• to the participatory immersion of neo-tribe members in the context of the live-
show, where the simulacrum is present on stage or present in absentia through
special events.
• Participatory immersion in the live-show
• Group 3’s recollections of U2 on stage converge on the verbatim ‘Time has
stopped for me’, coupled with an anticipation of a hysteric response at the sight
of the ‘cultural icon’.
24. Discussion of findings (a)
The function of music products as taboos: [No] access to
the Real
• The visual contact that is established between band and consumers
becomes an overflowing experience, over-abundantly pleasant, a moment of
jouissance consumption.
• Hence the inevitable paradox of the ‘gaze’: it affirms and at the same time
negates the truthfulness of what is seen, i.e. the fleeting centre of the
simulacrum.
• Group 1 informants remained speechless after having met the ‘real’ band, before
waking up from a hallucinatory, trance-like state
• hardly capable of finding any words to articulate the in vivo visual encounter
with their cultural icon
• thus witnessing a temporary breakdown of the symbolic order, the function of
the music product as taboo, the transgression of which allows for a
dissimulated immersion in the Order of the Real.
• The significance of the promotion technique of the live-show for consumer
psychology lies in its promise of a dissimulatory encounter
with the Real
25. Discussion of findings (b)
The function of music products as fetishes or small objects a
• Gazing at posters as small objects a, functions as a visual evocation of the
Big Other (l’Autre)
[Group 4] Q: Do you have any posters in your room? Informant 4: ‘All over the place. If you
come in you think that Madonna is watching you. I have a big one on the ceiling, facing my
pillow, so every time I wake up I can see Madonna right in front of me.’
• What are the ‘neo-tribe paraphernalia’ in this case?
• For Group 1 it seems that posters is a way of achieving intra-group
coherence, something like an emblem that suggests a ‘shared
past’ for the group.
• Each promotional item is fetishistically cathected with libidinal energy; it
instantiates a music product’s meaning as chain of signifiers
• wearing club t-shirts
• waving at each other in the same way the lead-singer waves at
the end of a video-clip (Group 3)
• employing song lyrics while approaching another in a flirting
manner during a special fan club event
26. Discussion of findings (c)
The function of music products as simulacra: Visual and oral
signifiers as cultural glue for collective neo-tribal
experiences
• The signification of the music product qua simulacrum takes place in the
collective locus of the neo-tribe
• which constructs its world-sense on the basis of shared interpretive repertoires.
• Even though the live-show is the pinnacle of promotions techniques in the
music industry, different elements from different promotions techniques act
as multimodal anchors or master signifiers for different occasions.
• Group 3 informants unanimously agreed that video-clips offer more input for their ordinary
communicative exchanges than print-adverts
• They also converged on the primacy of live-shows over other promotions techniques in
constructing a ‘direct’ relationship with the group, emphasizing that it is on stage that they
can check whether the band is ‘real’.
• The video-clip is just one step in the process of approximating the ‘essence’ of the music
product
• the next one being the participation in a live-show.
27. Discussion of findings (c)
The function of music products as simulacra: Visual and oral
signifiers as cultural glue for collective neo-tribal
experiences
• Contamination as the mode whereby the circulation of the signifiers making
up a simulacrum is effected among the neo-tribe’s members.
• Wearing hats at a live-show was one way whereby club-members of Group 3
maintained their coherence as a group of disciples following their favourite
cultural icon.
• Whistling a tune is also a way of maintaining group-identity amongst Group 2
consumers.
• Dancing and singing-along during a live-show is a way of communicating directly
for Group 1 consumers.
• Each common experience bears a different meaning for individual consumers,
the same ‘promotional currency’ is exchanged for different ‘psychic goods’, in the
process of connotative displacement.
28. Conclusions
• From a psychoanalytic perspective, the music product does not necessarily
enter into a one-to-one symbolic relationship with an abstract idea
• it constitutes a signifying chain, where signifiers are contiguously ordered
according to the rationale of the Imaginary order
• Hedonism is not sufficient in accounting for the ec-static feeling of
jouissance, deriving from the loss of self which is experienced while gazing
at the simulacrum during a live-show
• This is rather experienced as a re-enactment of the split of the subject
• a decisive moment that sets in motion the cultural imagery of the product qua
signifying chain.
29. Conclusions
• The distinction between affective and symbolic levels alludes to the
distinctive orders of the Imaginary and the Symbolic
• they are imbricated in the same fashion that the mirror stage underpins and
precedes the identificatory logic of the subject’s formation.
• Jouissance consumption aims to effect an interpretive shift from
• perspectives which presuppose the existence of distinctive egos
• towards an approach that prioritizes ‘fusion’ and ‘communion’ among consumer-
group members
30. Directions for further research
• The proposed triadic model (fetish, taboo, simulacrum) leads to a tentative
segmentation of a consumer base in terms of unconscious, rather than
conscious, processes
• Examples of how psychoanalytic concepts may be fruitfully employed in
consumer research:
• Typology of promotions techniques in relation to the different Lacanian orders
• Evaluation of a brand according to its jouissance consumption potential