FUNDAMENTALS FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF
                    `
 SUSTAINABLE DESIGN STANDARDS AND
 CODE IN THE CONSTRUCTION FIELD OF
              KUWAIT
National Committee of Building Codes in Kuwait

                                                      Eng. Alia Al.Sayegh
                                 Chair of Green Buildings Technical Team
                                                          23rd May, 2012




              KUWAIT GREEN BUILDING FORUM
GCC Construction Projects
Establishment of KNCOBC

• National Committee of Building Codes of
  Kuwait (NCOBC) was established by the
  Council of Ministers’ Decree # 1145, dated
  August 16th,2010.
The need for Building Codes
                  High Energy
 Challenges of   Consumption    Resources
   Climate           Rate       Exhaustion
   Change




            Demand for Unified
               Sustainable
            Construction Codes
Structure of NCOBC

                                NCOBC



                    Technical           Strategic
                      Team                Team


                                         Green      Accessibility
 Concrete     Energy     Fire Code
                                        Buildings    & Special
Code Team   Code Team      Team
                                         Team         Needs
GB Technical Team
Goals
• 1. the ultimate goal- to work towards sustainable
  built environment which is aligned with the
  internationally accepted sustainability values
• 2. to create codes, standards and practices as
  integral and coordinated part of the building &
  construction process
• 3. to coordinate with other teams and to contribute
  to integrated construction building construction
  system of codes, standards and practices
Challenges of Green Approach
1. Lack of Economical Driving Force
2. Social Factors (awareness & knowledge)
3. Shortage in Local experience, specialists and
   expertise
4. Privation of adopting governmental authority
5. Reliance and/or Conflict with other building
   regulations
6. Lack of incentives
7. Poor Green Market
Our Start
• Objectives & road map to Achieve the Goals

• Roles and responsibilities within the team

• Work program and needed Stages

• Necessary studies: references, systems, existing practices

• Terms and Terminology
GBT Team - Work Stages
• To reach the assigned goals and objectives in
  the best way, the GBT team agreed to work in
  the following stages :
1- Studies & Application of GB Systems
2- Elaborating Green Building Standards
3- Elaborating Codes and Regulations
4- Monitor and follow-up with the
  developments of Authorities Implementing
  the issued standards & codes.
Stage I : Studies & Application
          of GB Systems
• Stage Kickoff : Nov,2010
• Stage Report issued : Feb, 2012
• Report Title : Report #1 :
Fundamentals for Establishment of Sustainable Design
    Standards and Code in the Construction Field of
                          Kuwait
• Pending : Finalizing Assessment on the case study
  project.
Vision of GBT on Report #1
• First “Green Building” Official Governmental
  Document
• Coming to a semi “Green-Building”-virgin
  Construction Field
• Fully Understanding of the Challenges
• Producing a general framework Document on
  the sustainability of design and construction
  works and the assessment of integrated
  building performance
Criticality of First Report

                1. Decision Making

           2. Construction Field Practices

           3. Local & Regional Experience

     4. Selection of Recommended Rating System

               5. Setting Benchmark
Tackled Issues Related to
       1. Decision Making
                 Decision Making
                                                 National
                                               Conditions :
                                 Priority of
                                               Mtrological,
Environment                     Sustainable
                  Green                          industry,
al Impacts of                  Construction
              Transformation                   Biodiversity,
  Buildings                     and Urban
                                                  Climate
                                  Design
                                                  Change,
                                               Ecosystems
Scope extended to cover GCC
•   Environmental Condition
•   Construction Market and practices
•   Marine and coastal Resources
•   Biodiversity and Protected areas
•   Policies and Initiatives
•   Legislative Initiatives
•   Institutional Developments
•   Civil Society
STATUS OF ACCESSION TO THE MAJOR MULTILATERAL
             AGREEMENTS DEALING WITH THE ENVIRONMENT
                           IN GCC COUNTRIES

                                     Kyoto
                        Cb
                         Carta Unfcc       Ozon                                                           Herit Unclo
 Country       Cites                 proto      Ccd                              Pops       Cms   Basel
                         d gena   c         e                                                              age    s
                                      col
Bahrain       .        R .        R    A    A    A                                S     .           R       R      R
                     199        1994 2006 1990 1997                             2002              1992    1991   1985
                     6
Kuwait          R      R .        A    A    A    R                                S     .           R       R      R
              2002 200          1994 2005 1992 1997                             2001              1993    2002   1986
                     2
Oman          .        R    A     R    A    A    A                                R     .           A       A      R
                     199 2003 1995 2005 1999 1996                               2005              1995    1981   1989
                     5
Qatar           A      R    A     A    A    A    A                                A     .           A       A      R
              2001 199 2007 1996 2005 1996 1999                                 2004              1995    1984   2002
                     6
KSA             A      A .        A    A    A    A                                S       A         R       A      R
              1996 200          1994 2005 1993 1997                             2002    1991      1990    1978   1996
                     1
UAE             A      R .        A    A    A    A                                R     .           R       A      S
              1990 200          1995 2005 1989 1998                             2002              1992    2001   1993
                     0

R – Ratified, A – Acceded, S – Signed   ((Source: The Middle East Institute, 2008)
Environmental Footprint Comparison
2008 GCC Key Data
Conclusion

• Despite all steps forward, greening buildings
  and sustainable transformation will require :
                                              Setting of clear and
   Comprehensive
                          Long term             realistic targets
 range of expanded
                          strategies          (energy and water
      policies
                                                 performance)


   Cross-sectoral       Balance between economic incentives,
  policies to fight      effective legislations, regulations and
  climate change                        standards
Tackled Issues Related to
2. Construction Field Practices


     Aspects to consider for sustainability of buildings &
     construction

     Green design approaches, whole building design


     Introduced Steps toward GB standards


     Cultural and historical specifities in architecture


     Construction industry to date in Kuwait and in GCC
Tackled Issues Related to
   3. Local and Regional Experience
• Major Green and Eco-friendly projects in
  Kuwait and across the GCC
• Regional GB standards, codes and regulations
• Regional Green Building Assessment systems
• Analysis , comparisons
Projects Analyzed
Arab Organizations Building in Kuwait
Bahrain World Tradein KSA
 King Abdulla University Center
          Masdar City in UAE
           Eco-Friendly Stadiums in Qatar




            Oman 1st Green Building by 2013
4. Selection of Recommended
        Rating System

• The link between Assessment System and GB
  standards & Codes
• Review of International and Regional Rating
  Systems
• Define Criteria for selection
Review Phase

• GB Team reviewed the following systems :
LEED
BREEAM
Green Star
Estidama
QSAS
Scope of Review
•   Background
•   References & Standards
•   Methodology (Assessment Procedure)
•   Categories/ Classifications
•   Criteria
•   Rating
•   Local Compatibility
Unique Scheme Coverage
Scheme             QSAS        Estidama                                     Comments
                                          QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Mosques that focuses on
                    ++            -       providing healthy and sustainable mosques and range from a measurement of
Mosques                                   energy consumption to the thermal comfort provided to prayer halls. Estidama
                                          does not have an assessment system for Mosques.
                                          QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Hotels developed to assess
                    ++            -       and rate the design of hotels ranging in varying scales from boutique hotels to
Hotels                                    large scale resorts. Estidama does not have an assessment system for Hotels.

                                          QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Light Industry created to
                    ++            -       assess and rate the design of new light industrial buildings that use labor
Light Industry                            intensive operations primarily to produce consumer goods. Estidama does not
                                          have an assessment system for Light Industry.
                                          QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Sports developed to assess
                    ++            -       and rate the sustainability performance for spectator sports facilities. Qatar
Sports                                    2022 has adopted the system for its venues for the tournament. Estidama does
                                          not have an assessment system for Sports.
                                          QSAS have a comprehensive system dedicated to parks with multiple scales.
Parks                                     Estidama does not have an assessment system for Parks.
                    ++            -
                    Under                 QSAS will have a comprehensive system dedicated to health care facilities with
Health Care      Development              multiple scales. Estidama does not have an assessment system for health care.
                                  -
                                          QSAS developed this unique scheme for the Rail projects, fully understanding
Rail                                      the specific challenges and considerations of them
                     ++           -
Findings
• All systems address common major goals and
  concerns, addressed in common categories :
  Site Sustainability, Energy Efficiency, Water
  Efficiency, Occupants Health, Materials Use
• However, Systems differ in : background,
  methodologies, standards, rating method,
  specific criteria and special considerations
Recommendations
• Team members recommended the Primary
  System QSAS and the Reference System
  BREEAM-Gulf.
• This was supported by the recommendation of
  The First Forum of the GCC Unified Building
  Code, 11-13 October,2010
• As well as the Saudi Forum of Green Buildings,
  16-18 October, 2010.
5. Setting Benchmark
• Pilot Project : Case Study – Application of
  QSAS on a local governmental project :
  EPWD Building :
Main goals & objectives
Briefly about the project
The building special green building tools
The QSAS method for GB assessment
Expected results and conclusions
Project Data
•   BUILT UP AREA      :   33,000 m2
•   PLOT AREA          :   4670 m2
•   VALUE              :   13,000,000 K.D.
•   TYPE               :   OFFICE BUILDING
•   Number of floors   :   3 basements + Ground + 9 Floors
•   Total parking      :   220 cars
•   Total Users        :   275 employees + Visitors
Project’s Main GB Design Features
• Use of Renewable Energy (4 different solar applications)
• Minimum Energy consumption : HVAC energy efficient
  system, increased thermal insulation, minimized heat
  transmission and radiation by reduced “U” and shading values
  of glass
• Minimum Water consumption : collecting gutter drains ,
  local water treatment plant, double piping for treated water
  reuse
• Fully automated building
• Smart Architecture / Smart Design
• Responsible Materials selection
Expected Impact on
           Local Environment
• Energy saving
• Reduce CO2 emission
• Use of recycled materials
• Reduce the amount of construction waste materials
• Efficient use of resources
• Reduce impacts on
   – Environment
   – Human health
• Improve quality of life
Expected Impact on
         Construction Industry
•   Proper Use of Land and Sites
•   Reduce the life cycle cost of buildings
•   Efficient use of energy inside buildings
•   Proper use of building materials
•   Reduce the deterioration rate of building
•   Better Quality of Life for Building occupants
Finally…

Bringing Green Economy to the Forefront of
  Action is considered as a methodology of
  economics that supports the harmonious
  interaction between humans and nature and
  attempts to meet the needs of both
  simultaneously…

Fundamentals for establishment may 2012

  • 1.
    FUNDAMENTALS FOR ESTABLISHMENTOF ` SUSTAINABLE DESIGN STANDARDS AND CODE IN THE CONSTRUCTION FIELD OF KUWAIT National Committee of Building Codes in Kuwait Eng. Alia Al.Sayegh Chair of Green Buildings Technical Team 23rd May, 2012 KUWAIT GREEN BUILDING FORUM
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Establishment of KNCOBC •National Committee of Building Codes of Kuwait (NCOBC) was established by the Council of Ministers’ Decree # 1145, dated August 16th,2010.
  • 5.
    The need forBuilding Codes High Energy Challenges of Consumption Resources Climate Rate Exhaustion Change Demand for Unified Sustainable Construction Codes
  • 6.
    Structure of NCOBC NCOBC Technical Strategic Team Team Green Accessibility Concrete Energy Fire Code Buildings & Special Code Team Code Team Team Team Needs
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Goals • 1. theultimate goal- to work towards sustainable built environment which is aligned with the internationally accepted sustainability values • 2. to create codes, standards and practices as integral and coordinated part of the building & construction process • 3. to coordinate with other teams and to contribute to integrated construction building construction system of codes, standards and practices
  • 9.
    Challenges of GreenApproach 1. Lack of Economical Driving Force 2. Social Factors (awareness & knowledge) 3. Shortage in Local experience, specialists and expertise 4. Privation of adopting governmental authority 5. Reliance and/or Conflict with other building regulations 6. Lack of incentives 7. Poor Green Market
  • 10.
    Our Start • Objectives& road map to Achieve the Goals • Roles and responsibilities within the team • Work program and needed Stages • Necessary studies: references, systems, existing practices • Terms and Terminology
  • 11.
    GBT Team -Work Stages • To reach the assigned goals and objectives in the best way, the GBT team agreed to work in the following stages : 1- Studies & Application of GB Systems 2- Elaborating Green Building Standards 3- Elaborating Codes and Regulations 4- Monitor and follow-up with the developments of Authorities Implementing the issued standards & codes.
  • 12.
    Stage I :Studies & Application of GB Systems • Stage Kickoff : Nov,2010 • Stage Report issued : Feb, 2012 • Report Title : Report #1 : Fundamentals for Establishment of Sustainable Design Standards and Code in the Construction Field of Kuwait • Pending : Finalizing Assessment on the case study project.
  • 13.
    Vision of GBTon Report #1 • First “Green Building” Official Governmental Document • Coming to a semi “Green-Building”-virgin Construction Field • Fully Understanding of the Challenges • Producing a general framework Document on the sustainability of design and construction works and the assessment of integrated building performance
  • 14.
    Criticality of FirstReport 1. Decision Making 2. Construction Field Practices 3. Local & Regional Experience 4. Selection of Recommended Rating System 5. Setting Benchmark
  • 15.
    Tackled Issues Relatedto 1. Decision Making Decision Making National Conditions : Priority of Mtrological, Environment Sustainable Green industry, al Impacts of Construction Transformation Biodiversity, Buildings and Urban Climate Design Change, Ecosystems
  • 16.
    Scope extended tocover GCC • Environmental Condition • Construction Market and practices • Marine and coastal Resources • Biodiversity and Protected areas • Policies and Initiatives • Legislative Initiatives • Institutional Developments • Civil Society
  • 17.
    STATUS OF ACCESSIONTO THE MAJOR MULTILATERAL AGREEMENTS DEALING WITH THE ENVIRONMENT IN GCC COUNTRIES Kyoto Cb Carta Unfcc Ozon Herit Unclo Country Cites proto Ccd Pops Cms Basel d gena c e age s col Bahrain . R . R A A A S . R R R 199 1994 2006 1990 1997 2002 1992 1991 1985 6 Kuwait R R . A A A R S . R R R 2002 200 1994 2005 1992 1997 2001 1993 2002 1986 2 Oman . R A R A A A R . A A R 199 2003 1995 2005 1999 1996 2005 1995 1981 1989 5 Qatar A R A A A A A A . A A R 2001 199 2007 1996 2005 1996 1999 2004 1995 1984 2002 6 KSA A A . A A A A S A R A R 1996 200 1994 2005 1993 1997 2002 1991 1990 1978 1996 1 UAE A R . A A A A R . R A S 1990 200 1995 2005 1989 1998 2002 1992 2001 1993 0 R – Ratified, A – Acceded, S – Signed ((Source: The Middle East Institute, 2008)
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Conclusion • Despite allsteps forward, greening buildings and sustainable transformation will require : Setting of clear and Comprehensive Long term realistic targets range of expanded strategies (energy and water policies performance) Cross-sectoral Balance between economic incentives, policies to fight effective legislations, regulations and climate change standards
  • 21.
    Tackled Issues Relatedto 2. Construction Field Practices Aspects to consider for sustainability of buildings & construction Green design approaches, whole building design Introduced Steps toward GB standards Cultural and historical specifities in architecture Construction industry to date in Kuwait and in GCC
  • 22.
    Tackled Issues Relatedto 3. Local and Regional Experience • Major Green and Eco-friendly projects in Kuwait and across the GCC • Regional GB standards, codes and regulations • Regional Green Building Assessment systems • Analysis , comparisons
  • 23.
    Projects Analyzed Arab OrganizationsBuilding in Kuwait Bahrain World Tradein KSA King Abdulla University Center Masdar City in UAE Eco-Friendly Stadiums in Qatar Oman 1st Green Building by 2013
  • 24.
    4. Selection ofRecommended Rating System • The link between Assessment System and GB standards & Codes • Review of International and Regional Rating Systems • Define Criteria for selection
  • 25.
    Review Phase • GBTeam reviewed the following systems : LEED BREEAM Green Star Estidama QSAS
  • 26.
    Scope of Review • Background • References & Standards • Methodology (Assessment Procedure) • Categories/ Classifications • Criteria • Rating • Local Compatibility
  • 29.
    Unique Scheme Coverage Scheme QSAS Estidama Comments QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Mosques that focuses on ++ - providing healthy and sustainable mosques and range from a measurement of Mosques energy consumption to the thermal comfort provided to prayer halls. Estidama does not have an assessment system for Mosques. QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Hotels developed to assess ++ - and rate the design of hotels ranging in varying scales from boutique hotels to Hotels large scale resorts. Estidama does not have an assessment system for Hotels. QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Light Industry created to ++ - assess and rate the design of new light industrial buildings that use labor Light Industry intensive operations primarily to produce consumer goods. Estidama does not have an assessment system for Light Industry. QSAS has a comprehensive assessment system for Sports developed to assess ++ - and rate the sustainability performance for spectator sports facilities. Qatar Sports 2022 has adopted the system for its venues for the tournament. Estidama does not have an assessment system for Sports. QSAS have a comprehensive system dedicated to parks with multiple scales. Parks Estidama does not have an assessment system for Parks. ++ - Under QSAS will have a comprehensive system dedicated to health care facilities with Health Care Development multiple scales. Estidama does not have an assessment system for health care. - QSAS developed this unique scheme for the Rail projects, fully understanding Rail the specific challenges and considerations of them ++ -
  • 30.
    Findings • All systemsaddress common major goals and concerns, addressed in common categories : Site Sustainability, Energy Efficiency, Water Efficiency, Occupants Health, Materials Use • However, Systems differ in : background, methodologies, standards, rating method, specific criteria and special considerations
  • 31.
    Recommendations • Team membersrecommended the Primary System QSAS and the Reference System BREEAM-Gulf. • This was supported by the recommendation of The First Forum of the GCC Unified Building Code, 11-13 October,2010 • As well as the Saudi Forum of Green Buildings, 16-18 October, 2010.
  • 32.
    5. Setting Benchmark •Pilot Project : Case Study – Application of QSAS on a local governmental project : EPWD Building : Main goals & objectives Briefly about the project The building special green building tools The QSAS method for GB assessment Expected results and conclusions
  • 34.
    Project Data • BUILT UP AREA : 33,000 m2 • PLOT AREA : 4670 m2 • VALUE : 13,000,000 K.D. • TYPE : OFFICE BUILDING • Number of floors : 3 basements + Ground + 9 Floors • Total parking : 220 cars • Total Users : 275 employees + Visitors
  • 35.
    Project’s Main GBDesign Features • Use of Renewable Energy (4 different solar applications) • Minimum Energy consumption : HVAC energy efficient system, increased thermal insulation, minimized heat transmission and radiation by reduced “U” and shading values of glass • Minimum Water consumption : collecting gutter drains , local water treatment plant, double piping for treated water reuse • Fully automated building • Smart Architecture / Smart Design • Responsible Materials selection
  • 36.
    Expected Impact on Local Environment • Energy saving • Reduce CO2 emission • Use of recycled materials • Reduce the amount of construction waste materials • Efficient use of resources • Reduce impacts on – Environment – Human health • Improve quality of life
  • 37.
    Expected Impact on Construction Industry • Proper Use of Land and Sites • Reduce the life cycle cost of buildings • Efficient use of energy inside buildings • Proper use of building materials • Reduce the deterioration rate of building • Better Quality of Life for Building occupants
  • 38.
    Finally… Bringing Green Economyto the Forefront of Action is considered as a methodology of economics that supports the harmonious interaction between humans and nature and attempts to meet the needs of both simultaneously…