Film Adaptation
The Quiet American
Adaptations & Criticism
Content
• Book – Film Adaptation
• The Quiet American
• 1958 vs. 2002 Adaptations
• Film Criticism
• Discussion
What is Film Adaptation?
• Book: original work
• Film: derivative work
• novel + short stories + comic >> 65%
films
• All works classic literature
–Romeo and Juliet 50 film adaptations
–British Literature >> American Films
Why Film Adaptation?
• Entertainment : contemporary viewers
• Business – box office (HBO)
• Direct visual stimulation >> Imagination
& Interaction
What to Adapt?
• Time frame
• Narrator
• Characters & characterization
• Plot & Subplot
• Music, theme song
Film Adaptations - examples
• Wuthering Heights 2011
• Schindler’s List 1993
• Harry Potter and the Prisoner of
Azkaban 2004
• The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2011
• Sherlock Holmes 2010
Faithfulness?
• Should the derivative work be faithful to
the original work?
• How much faithful it should be?
–Once Flew Over the Cuckoo Nest
1975
–The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2009
–Gone with the Wind 1986
The Quiet American
• Graham Green – war correspondent
• Setting: Saigon, 1952
• Protagonist: Fowler, British journalist
• Antagonist: Pyle, CIA agent
• Anti-war novel
–Reading of the excerpt
The Film Adaptations
• 1958 – Hollywood Rambo movie
–anti-war message excised
• 2002 – Phillip Noyce’s movie
–Michael Caine, Brendan Fraser, Do Thi
Hai Yen
Film Criticism
• Theme, tone, attitude
• Music
• Dialogue
• Performance
• Symbolism
• Cinematography
Discussion
• How successful is the film adaptation?
– Music, theme song
– Dialogue adaptation
– Inner thoughts / narrator adaptation
– Narrator Tone, director attitude adaptation

Film adaptation

  • 1.
    Film Adaptation The QuietAmerican Adaptations & Criticism
  • 2.
    Content • Book –Film Adaptation • The Quiet American • 1958 vs. 2002 Adaptations • Film Criticism • Discussion
  • 3.
    What is FilmAdaptation? • Book: original work • Film: derivative work • novel + short stories + comic >> 65% films • All works classic literature –Romeo and Juliet 50 film adaptations –British Literature >> American Films
  • 4.
    Why Film Adaptation? •Entertainment : contemporary viewers • Business – box office (HBO) • Direct visual stimulation >> Imagination & Interaction
  • 5.
    What to Adapt? •Time frame • Narrator • Characters & characterization • Plot & Subplot • Music, theme song
  • 6.
    Film Adaptations -examples • Wuthering Heights 2011 • Schindler’s List 1993 • Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban 2004 • The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2011 • Sherlock Holmes 2010
  • 7.
    Faithfulness? • Should thederivative work be faithful to the original work? • How much faithful it should be? –Once Flew Over the Cuckoo Nest 1975 –The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2009 –Gone with the Wind 1986
  • 8.
    The Quiet American •Graham Green – war correspondent • Setting: Saigon, 1952 • Protagonist: Fowler, British journalist • Antagonist: Pyle, CIA agent • Anti-war novel –Reading of the excerpt
  • 9.
    The Film Adaptations •1958 – Hollywood Rambo movie –anti-war message excised • 2002 – Phillip Noyce’s movie –Michael Caine, Brendan Fraser, Do Thi Hai Yen
  • 10.
    Film Criticism • Theme,tone, attitude • Music • Dialogue • Performance • Symbolism • Cinematography
  • 11.
    Discussion • How successfulis the film adaptation? – Music, theme song – Dialogue adaptation – Inner thoughts / narrator adaptation – Narrator Tone, director attitude adaptation