Exponential Technology
How can we make sure
everyone benefits?
Dr. Matthijs Pontier
Content
• Why should everyone benefit?
• How do we make sure everyone benefits?
• Democratic Transhumanism
• Machine Ethics
• When we succeed  New ethical dilemma’s
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why should everyone benefit?
Who is everyone?
• Does life matter?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why should everyone benefit?
Who is everyone?
• What is life, anyway?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why should everyone benefit?
Who is everyone?
• Does life matter?
• What is life, anyway?
• Does human life matter?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why should everyone benefit?
Who is everyone?
• Does life matter?
• What is life, anyway?
• Does human life matter?
• Do human individuals matter?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why build technology?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why build technology?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why build technology?
Why build technology?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why build technology?
• Evolutionary progress
• Preserve (human) life
• To preserve human rights
• To improve our well-being
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why build technology?
• Evolutionary progress
– Description of a process or goal in itself?
• Preserve (human) life
• To preserve human rights
• To improve our well-being
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why build technology?
• Evolutionary progress / Preserve humans
• To preserve human rights
• To improve our well-being
• Hedonic utilitarianism?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why build technology?
• Evolutionary progress / Preserve humans
• To preserve human rights
• To improve our well-being
• Hedonic utilitarianism?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Brave New World
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
How do we promote happiness?
Promoting happiness:
Kill all unhappy people?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Promoting happiness:
Improving autonomy?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
How do we promote autonomy?
• If everyone uses cognitive enhancers,
do you still have a free choice to use it yourself?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human?
Democratic Transhumanism
(or Techno-progressivism)
• “Technological developments can be
profoundly empowering and emancipatory when they are regulated by
legitimate democratic and accountable authorities to ensure that
their costs, risks and benefits are all fairly shared by the
actual stakeholders to those developments”
• Equal access to human enhancement technologies
Machine Ethics
• Machines are becoming more autonomous
 Rosalind Picard (1997): ‘‘The greater the freedom of a
machine, the more it will need moral standards.’’
• Machines interact more with people
We should manage that machines do not harm us or
threaten our autonomy
22Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
SELEMCA
• Develop ‘Caredroids’: Robots or Computer Agents
that assist Patients and Care-deliverers
23Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Possible functionalities
• Care-broker: Find care that matches need patient
• Companion: Become friends with the patient to prevent
loneliness and activate the patient
• Coach: Assist the patient in making healthy choices:
Exercising, Eating healthy, Taking medicine, etc.
24
Moral reasoning system
We developed moral reasoning system that balances
between several moral goals
Decisions matched medical-ethical experts
25Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Autonomy
26
Results:
Able to simulate judge
decisions about:
•Assertive outreach
•Judicial coercion after self-
binding declaration
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Emotional Intelligence
+ Moral Reasoning:
Decisions based on:
1. Rational influences
– Does action help me to reach my goals?
2. Affective influences
– Does action lead to desired emotions?
– Does action reflect Involvement I feel towards user?
– Does action reflect Distance I feel towards user?
3. Moral reasoning
– Is this action morally good?
27Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Speed-dating Experiment
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why software should be
open-soure
• Algorithms and robots will increasingly influence our lives
• Who controls the programmers
• Good ideas are made to be copied
Creating extra value with no extra costs
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why we should have mandatory
Machine Ethics
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why we should have mandatory
Machine Ethics
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Why we should have mandatory
Machine Ethics
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Why we should have mandatory
Machine Ethics
• AI-Safety
• Make sure the intelligence explosion benefits us
• Democratically decide about ethics technology
What if we succeed:
Is a changed you still you?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Who wants to live forever?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
If you lived forever
Would you be happy?
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Time
In Time
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Book: Machine Medical Ethics
41
• How to develop robots with human-like
ethics?
• Need for Open Source
• How to use healthcare tech in a way that
improves well-being
• Changed doctor-patient relation
• Deep Brain Stimulation
• Sex-robots
• Etc.
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Pirate Party & Tech-ethics
• Make sure technology
improves well-being
• Autonomy / Freedom
• Privacy
• Human rights
• Transparency
• Open source / Open Data
• E-democracy
• Evidence-based policy
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
Thanks!
•
@Matthijs85
•
Matthijs Pontier
•
matthijs@piratenpartij.nl
•
http://camera-vu.nl/matthijs
•
http://www.linkedin.com/in/
matthijspontier
Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn

Exponential technology - How do we make sure everyone benefits?

  • 1.
    Exponential Technology How canwe make sure everyone benefits? Dr. Matthijs Pontier
  • 2.
    Content • Why shouldeveryone benefit? • How do we make sure everyone benefits? • Democratic Transhumanism • Machine Ethics • When we succeed  New ethical dilemma’s Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 3.
    Why should everyonebenefit? Who is everyone? • Does life matter? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 4.
    Why should everyonebenefit? Who is everyone? • What is life, anyway? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 5.
    Why should everyonebenefit? Who is everyone? • Does life matter? • What is life, anyway? • Does human life matter? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 6.
    Why should everyonebenefit? Who is everyone? • Does life matter? • What is life, anyway? • Does human life matter? • Do human individuals matter? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 7.
    Why build technology? MatthijsPontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 8.
    Why build technology? MatthijsPontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Why build technology? MatthijsPontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 11.
    Why build technology? •Evolutionary progress • Preserve (human) life • To preserve human rights • To improve our well-being Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 12.
    Why build technology? •Evolutionary progress – Description of a process or goal in itself? • Preserve (human) life • To preserve human rights • To improve our well-being Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 13.
    Why build technology? •Evolutionary progress / Preserve humans • To preserve human rights • To improve our well-being • Hedonic utilitarianism? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 14.
    Why build technology? •Evolutionary progress / Preserve humans • To preserve human rights • To improve our well-being • Hedonic utilitarianism? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Matthijs Pontier, Leiden,27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 17.
    How do wepromote happiness?
  • 18.
    Promoting happiness: Kill allunhappy people? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 19.
    Promoting happiness: Improving autonomy? MatthijsPontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 20.
    How do wepromote autonomy? • If everyone uses cognitive enhancers, do you still have a free choice to use it yourself? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human?
  • 21.
    Democratic Transhumanism (or Techno-progressivism) •“Technological developments can be profoundly empowering and emancipatory when they are regulated by legitimate democratic and accountable authorities to ensure that their costs, risks and benefits are all fairly shared by the actual stakeholders to those developments” • Equal access to human enhancement technologies
  • 22.
    Machine Ethics • Machinesare becoming more autonomous  Rosalind Picard (1997): ‘‘The greater the freedom of a machine, the more it will need moral standards.’’ • Machines interact more with people We should manage that machines do not harm us or threaten our autonomy 22Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 23.
    SELEMCA • Develop ‘Caredroids’:Robots or Computer Agents that assist Patients and Care-deliverers 23Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 24.
    Possible functionalities • Care-broker:Find care that matches need patient • Companion: Become friends with the patient to prevent loneliness and activate the patient • Coach: Assist the patient in making healthy choices: Exercising, Eating healthy, Taking medicine, etc. 24
  • 25.
    Moral reasoning system Wedeveloped moral reasoning system that balances between several moral goals Decisions matched medical-ethical experts 25Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 26.
    Autonomy 26 Results: Able to simulatejudge decisions about: •Assertive outreach •Judicial coercion after self- binding declaration Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 27.
    Emotional Intelligence + MoralReasoning: Decisions based on: 1. Rational influences – Does action help me to reach my goals? 2. Affective influences – Does action lead to desired emotions? – Does action reflect Involvement I feel towards user? – Does action reflect Distance I feel towards user? 3. Moral reasoning – Is this action morally good? 27Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 28.
    Speed-dating Experiment Matthijs Pontier,Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 30.
    Matthijs Pontier, Leiden,27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 31.
    Why software shouldbe open-soure • Algorithms and robots will increasingly influence our lives • Who controls the programmers • Good ideas are made to be copied Creating extra value with no extra costs Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 32.
    Why we shouldhave mandatory Machine Ethics Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 33.
    Why we shouldhave mandatory Machine Ethics Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 34.
    Why we shouldhave mandatory Machine Ethics Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016
  • 35.
    Why we shouldhave mandatory Machine Ethics • AI-Safety • Make sure the intelligence explosion benefits us • Democratically decide about ethics technology
  • 36.
    What if wesucceed: Is a changed you still you? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 37.
    Who wants tolive forever? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 38.
    If you livedforever Would you be happy? Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 39.
  • 40.
    In Time Matthijs Pontier,Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 41.
    Book: Machine MedicalEthics 41 • How to develop robots with human-like ethics? • Need for Open Source • How to use healthcare tech in a way that improves well-being • Changed doctor-patient relation • Deep Brain Stimulation • Sex-robots • Etc. Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 42.
    Pirate Party &Tech-ethics • Make sure technology improves well-being • Autonomy / Freedom • Privacy • Human rights • Transparency • Open source / Open Data • E-democracy • Evidence-based policy Matthijs Pontier, Leiden, 27-2-2016 Where is the boundary of the human? The new technological turn
  • 43.

Editor's Notes

  • #2 AI + Psychology Developed emotionally intelligent robots and computer agents with human-like ethics
  • #4 First define who’s everyone Life  Prevent extinction Human race  evolution & diversity Individuals?  Human rights
  • #5 Life  Prevent extinction Human race  evolution & diversity Individuals?  Human rights
  • #6 Life  Prevent extinction Human race  evolution & diversity Individuals?  Human rights
  • #7 Life  Prevent extinction Human race  evolution & diversity Individuals?  Human rights
  • #8 Evolutionary progress  Diversity Survival
  • #9 Survival Evolutionary progress  Diversity
  • #10 Comfort
  • #11 Companionship and pleasure
  • #12 Evolutionary progress  Descrption of a process or goal in itself? Evolutionary progress  Diversity
  • #13 Evolutionary progress  Descrption of a process or goal in itself? Evolutionary progress  Diversity
  • #14 Evolutionary progress  Diversity
  • #15 Evolutionary progress  Diversity
  • #16 Technology to amuse yourselves to death = Dystopia
  • #18 What do you think?
  • #19 Should we kill unhappy people?
  • #22 Decentralization of power Cognitive Enhancement in basic insurance?
  • #24 Science + Health Care + Creative Industry Triangle Patient / Care-deliverer / Robot Robot: Repetitive tasks, so that Care-deliverer has time for: Medical + Social tasks
  • #25 Functionalities can all be in the same robot Same functionality can be in different kind of robots (physical robot, agent, app)
  • #26 Results: Able to match decisions medical ethical experts
  • #27 Resultaten: Mogelijk om rechtszaken te simuleren over: -bemoeizorg -gedwongen opname na zelfbindingsverklaring
  • #29 Robot (met Silicon Coppelia) vs Mens Multiple Choice & Emoties Wat vond dit mannetje nou van jou?
  • #33 Open source to see whether Machine Ethics norms are matched Not realistic?
  • #34 Intelligence explosion / Singularity Realistic that a robot accidentally destroys us
  • #37 Voorbeeld van mensen wiens hersenen nu al veranderen door Deep Brain Stimulation
  • #38 Queen’s “Who wants to live forever” is theme song Highlander
  • #40 In a future where people stop aging at 25, but are engineered to live only one more year, having the means to buy your way out of the situation is a shot at immortal youth.
  • #43 Bring back moral reasoning in politics and stimulate autonomy of civilians Make sure Google doesn’t decide what our healthcare and education look like
  • #44 Flyeren Ideeen bedenken Jonge Piraten