The nCZB is a member of the European Health Property Network (EuHPN). The annual convention late November 2016 in Madrid was among others in the sign of the integrated care and the role of the various stakeholders in the construction industry.
Presentations were also given by several healthcare projects in the countries participating in the EuHPN. The nCZB held a presentation on the benchmark survey conducted for a number of institutions for the disabled in the Netherlands.
Due to the deregulation of the construction and as a result, increased risks, the lack of quality and lack of an institutionalized body for the mutual exchange of information and knowledge institutions increasingly rely on themselves. It is clear that these developments in the housing departments took place a clear professionalization. However, there appears a need for more information sharing. Hence the benchmark study. The benchmark was about three types of care buildings, buildings for the group standard mentally disabled people and people with non-congenital brain abnormality, both at the headquarters and in the district, buildings for clients with behavioural and buildings for the group with multiple complex disabilities. Benchmark in terms of content both to surface indicators as to costs. The benchmark showed that in addition to various agreements also considerable differences between the actual buildings for the different target groups exist both in terms of size and cost. This information can be used as a reference for future projects.
clostridiumbotulinum- BY Muzammil Ahmed Siddiqui.pptx
EuHPN 2016 presentation benchmark building projects for mentally disabled persons
1. Developments in building for
mentally disabled persons
Fred Bisschop, Leo Mimpen, Theo Staats
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 1
2. Who we are
• 35 years of experience in healthcare building design and
construction
• Backgrounds in economics and construction
• Reviewed numerous healthcare projects and
businesscases
• We support large insurance companies and health care
providers
• We make publications of general interest, including
guidelines and standards
• We do our work independent
• Therefore our valuation of healthcare projects is
important for attracting loans from banks
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 2
3. Content
• Developments in the care for mentally disabled
• Benchmark project
• Examples of recent projects
• Concerns for the future
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 3
4. Developments concerning building projects
until 2009
• Until 2009 institutions needed approval for their building plans
• Investments were without financial risks
• New projects needed to comply building guidelines and costs
• For existing buildings there were more moderate criteria
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 4
5. The quality of housing used to be very bad
• In 2003 we carried out a survey about the quality of the buildings for
housing patients
• Conclusions: over 50% of the buildings did not meet the standards set
by the government itself
• A lot of people were just being “put away”
• Result: the government gave extra money for quality improvement
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 5
6. • Since 2009 institutions need no longer approval for projects
• Building guidelines do no longer exist
• Budget for housing costs however is derived from the former
guidelines
• Risk was introduced by making budget depending on number of
clients
• Institutions professionalized their real estate departments
• Obsolete housing has been replaced in many cases
• Patients with relatively few disabilities are no longer entitled to home
care
Developments concerning building projects
since 2009
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 6
7. Consequences of deregulation
• Government advocated in the past decentralisation and small
groups.
• Institutions are now forced to move clients back to the campus and
increase the size of groups.
• The exchange of information and knowledge between
institutions stopped
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 7
8. Benchmark project
• Institutions are starting to share information about their building
activities again
• Together with 3 large institutions we created a benchmarkgroup
• They represent 7% of the total capacity in the Netherlands
• Each institution gave extensive data of 3 or more recent projects
• We analysed the projects on aspects like m², m² per patient, costs etc
• This will result in reference data which may help optimizing future
projects
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 8
9. Benchmark some results
• We defined 4 different patient groups in relation to the building
demands
• For each group we analysed several projects
• Most projects seem to fit in this approach
• Output will be presented as a range of m2 and cost per patient
• Although the number of projects is limited it seems that building on a
campus is cheaper than in a residential neighbourhood
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 9
10. 4 examples of projects from the benchmark
1. Regular care for mentally handicapped and people with brain
damage
2. Regular care for mentally handicapped on the campus
3. Care for clients with difficult behaviour on the campus
4. Care for ageing clients on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 10
11. Project 1:Project 1:Project 1:Project 1: 48 clients, regular care and care for
people with brain damage
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 11
12. Project 1:Project 1:Project 1:Project 1: 48 clients, regular care and care for
people with brain damage
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 12
13. Living room 24,3m²
Bedroom 9,3m²
Bathroom 6,8m²
Project 1:Project 1:Project 1:Project 1: 48 clients, regular care and care for
people with brain damage
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 13
14. Project 2Project 2Project 2Project 2: regular care for 62 mentally
handicapped clients on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 14
15. Project 2Project 2Project 2Project 2: regular care for 62 mentally
handicapped clients on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 15
16. Living room
Bedroom 19,7m²
Bathroom 4,5m²
Project 2:Project 2:Project 2:Project 2: regular care for 62 mentally
handicapped clients on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 16
17. Project 3Project 3Project 3Project 3: care for 20 clients with difficult
behaviour on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 17
18. Project 3:Project 3:Project 3:Project 3: care for 20 clients with difficult
behaviour on the campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 18
19. Project 3 :Project 3 :Project 3 :Project 3 : care for 20 clients with difficult
behaviour on the campus
Living room 15,4m²
Bedroom 8,1m²
Bathroom 5,2m²
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 19
20. Project 4:Project 4:Project 4:Project 4: care for 64 ageing clients on the
campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 20
21. Project 4:Project 4:Project 4:Project 4:care for 64 ageing clients on the
campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 21
22. Bedroom 20,9m²
Bathroom 8,1m²
Project 4:Project 4:Project 4:Project 4: care for 64 ageing clients on the
campus
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 22
23. Concerns for the future
• Due to the improving economy building projects become more
expensive.
• Reimbursement for housing costs will go down
• The government no longer feel resonpsable for the quality of housing
24 November 2016 nCZB - EuHPN Workshop Madrid 23