Here are the key points a utilitarian would have to consider in evaluating the arguments made in this case: - A utilitarian would have to accept the premise that actions should be evaluated based on their overall costs and benefits to society. Maximizing overall utility is the goal. - However, a utilitarian could reject arguments that ignore long-term or indirect costs/benefits. Simply focusing on short-term monetary costs misses important factors. - A utilitarian could also reject claims that some people's lives are less valuable just because they are poorer or live shorter lives. All individuals should equally count in the utility calculation. - Non-monetary costs like health impacts and environmental degradation also need to be properly considered and