Think Before You Ink
Julie Mitchell, UBC Library (on leave)
Cindy Underhill, CTLT
Identity
Image credit: Shannon Kringen on Flickr licensed cc:by
digital identity and teachers…
“As a field and society we should be willing to
openly discuss these issues with understanding,
patience, and recognition of the complexities
surrounding SNS [social networking site]
participation and social well-being.”
Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social
Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
JM
Session
We’ll explore 4 questions:
 Why does your digital identity matter – as
teachers?
 How might your digital practices impact your
students?
 What makes the digital world so complex?
 What are some strategies for thoughtful
decision making?
JM
your digital identity: a
fragment
 What did you share?
 Why did you share it?
 How did you share it?
 What did you consider
before hitting send?
5 minutes: Think, Pair, Share
Your social networks:
Your digital identity
JMImage licensed cc:by Maurizio Pesce on Flickr
Stats from: Mary Meeker’s Internet Trends 2015 – Report:
http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends.
 40% of
mobile users
on
smartphones
 73% of
world’s
population
use mobile
phones.
Why does it matter?
 video at 4 billion views per day
(mainly FB)
 gaming growing 122% year over
year
 audio content growing 33% year
over year (10 mill in last 2 years
joined Soundcloud)
 content & stories growing 140%
year over year
Excerpt from: Audrey Watters: What Educators Need to Know About Today’s Internet – EML June 2015
Stats from Mary Meeker’s Internet Report for 2015:
http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends
Image licensed Cc:by:sa by Martin Abbegglen on Flickr
Why does it matter?
 12-24 year olds generating
content – 76% use camera
to post to SM
 Snapchat and Instagram
replacing FB for social
networking
Stats from Mary Meeker’s Internet Report for 2015
http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends
Image licensed Cc:by:sa by Martin Abbegglen on Flickr
Why does it matter?
The rise of the “ephemeralnet”…
“Now of age, those young digital
natives whose lives we cataloged
without their consent are rebelling.
They don’t want open social
networks, they want intimacy. They
don’t believe every action has to be
meaningful and permanent. They
imagine the web as deletable.”
Excerpt from: Techcrunch.com: The Rise of the
Ephemeralnet – June 2013.
Image from: Weheartit - Anonymous
Why does it matter?
“ What apps like these do is
allow us a little bit more
freedom to be ourselves, for
better or worse.”
From: Forbes – Why We Should Celebrate Snapchat and Encourage
Ephemeral Communication (May, 2013)
Why does it matter?
Instagram launched Snapchat
rival – Bolt – in 2014.
Until it hits Canada, your
images can be seen and
shared by anyone if your
account is public.
Just sayin…
Why does it matter to teachers?
“Popular SNS have embedded beliefs about identity
that are naïve and do not fully reflect the negotiated
social participation that frame educators’ evolving
Identities.”
Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social
Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
Considerations/negotiations
Image source: http://www.ivanecoyote.com/page/6/bio Image licensed cc:by on Flickr
Why does it matter to teachers?
“ The Supreme Court of Canada has determined that
educators are held to a higher standard than other
citizens due to their unique role in society.”
From:www.bcteacherregulation
Group Discussion – Part 1
“ The Supreme Court of Canada has determined that
educators are held to a higher standard than other
citizens due to their unique role in society.”
From:www.bcteacherregulation.ca
Group Discussion – Part 2
Go, no-go & shades of grey.
 Join a pair: group brainstorm. Take note of your
group’s thoughts on the following:
Go
Acceptable
activity on
social media
Shades of Grey
Not sure where
this fits
No-Go
Un-acceptable
activity on
social media
Go: professional network
From: Education Canada: Twitter and Canadian Educators
From: educator George Couros’ Twitter timeline
No-Go: criticizing students
Enough said?
No-Go: racism
Winnipeg teacher, on leave after controversial Facebook posts on aboriginals.
Excerpt from: CBC news Manitoba Posted: Dec 11, 2014
Shades of grey…
“If teachers do not clearly understand how
moral turpitude is defined in a given community,
then how can they be sure that their behavior
(online or offline) is beyond reproach?”
Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social
Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
Blurred Boundaries
Do guidelines
help?
VSB drafts social
media guidelines
May, 2013
From Gwyneth Anne-Bronwynn on Flickr – CCbySA 2.0
Blurred boundaries
 You’re on holiday in Mexico and friend posts
and tags a photo of you on the beach with a
drink and cigarette in hand.
Consider context
Photo source: www.dailymail.co.uk
Consider context
Photo source: Huffington Post
Blurred Boundaries
 VSB Draft Social Media Policy (p. 2)
"As role models for students and a representative of
the School District, you must ensure that your use
of social networking, even on your personal time,
does not reflect negatively on your professional
reputation or that of the School District.”
From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
Blurred Boundaries
 VSB Draft Social Media Policy (p. 3)
“Ask friends not to tag you in any photos
or videos without your permission and remove
anything that is not appropriate to your role
in the School District.”
From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
Blurred Boundaries
 You’ve had a terrible first week on your
practicum and you post the following to a
private group on FB:
“Crazy advisor, entitled students, and
mismanaged school. All in a days work.
Anyone up for a drink?”
Blurred Boundaries: Students
Image credit: Flickr user OldShoeWoman JM
Blurred Boundaries: Students
CU
Blurred Boundaries
 VSB Draft Social Media Policy (p. 2)
“Social networking sites and online postings are not
necessarily private. Never criticize students, other
district employees or the School District on online
sites.”
From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
CU
Blurred Boundaries
 You’ve finished a great first week on your
practicum and you receive a FB friend request
from one of the students in your class.
Blurred Boundaries
Excerpt from: The Daily Dot – Jan 9, 2015: Why Teachers Shouldn’t Be Friends With Their Students on Facebook
Blurred Boundaries
 VSB Draft Social Media Policy (p. 2)
“Do not request or accept any students or minor
(person under the age of 19 years) as ‘friends’ on
social networking sites or interact with students or
minors on social networking sites for purposes not
related to the delivery of the student’s educational
program.”
From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
CU
Your digital tattoo: by others
 Not online? Or are you?
 Own your identity
Source: http://mashable.com/2012/09/27/sikh-reddit-response/ CU
Complexity of Online Environment
 Dynamics that influence what we do online
– Anonymity
– Persistence
– Replicability
– Searchability
– Scalability
From: boyd, danah. 2009. "Social Media is Here to Stay... Now What?"
JM
The audience can be invisible
and anonymous
JM
Online Environment | Persistence
what you (or others) put on the internet stays there
The good
The bad
The ugly
JM
Online Environment |Replicability
Content can be taken out of context
JM
Online Environment |Scalability
Scalability: what’s intended for one reaches many JM
Online Environment | Searchability
JM
Online Environment | Searchability
JM
Strategies
What
employers
look for…
Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
CU
Strategies
 Consider what you want out of life.
“By acting online and offline in a
way consistent with what you
value, you simplify the work of
impression management and
increase the chances of finding
a good professional match.”
Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
Strategies
 Get advice and feedback.
Ask friends what three words
come to mind when they google
you or look at your public
profiles.
“Use any feedback you get to
evaluate your digital presence
against the expectations set out
for your profession.”
Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
Strategies
 Curate accordingly.
“having some information online is
generally better than nothing.
Manage privacy settings, check
Google and Bing, update your
profile photos and share your
expertise in relevant online
communities.”
Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
Strategies
 Choose and manage digital
relationships carefully.
“We are known by the friends we
keep online. If you haven’t done so,
use LinkedIn to develop and
maintain a network of relevant
professional connections.”
“Ask people with whom you’ve
worked or volunteered whether
they can offer you an
endorsement.”
Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
Photo release policies
 Become familiar with media
release or photo release
policies of your school district
 It is important to remember
your responsibilities as a
teacher candidate include not
adding to the digital tattoo of
your students.
JM
Image credit: Flickr user OldShoeWoman
Facebook Guide for Educators
Facebook for Educators and Community Leaders (2013): http://bit.ly/1MoldeC
Soundcloud: Ask A Teacher Series
Panoply Media: Ask a Teacher Series: Episode 9: Friending Your Students
How did we do together?
Consider what you’ve learned…
 Why does your digital identity matter – as
teachers?
 How might your digital practices impact your
students?
 What makes the digital world so complex?
 What are some strategies for thoughtful
decision making?
JM
Resources
 BC College of Teachers: Standards, Questions and Case Studies
http://www.bcct.ca/Standards/QuestionsCaseStudiesContents.aspx#
 Berkelaar, B. (2014)What Employers Want To See When They Google You.
Brazencareerist.com
 boyd, danah. 2009. "Social Media is Here to Stay... Now What?" Microsoft Research Tech Fest,
Redmond, Washington, February 26. Retrieved March 10, 2009:
http://www.danah.org/papers/talks/MSRTechFest2009.html
 Digital Tattoo: digitaltattoo.ubc.ca
 Foresight Future Identities (2013) Final Project Report.The Government Office for Science,
London.
 Haberman,S. (2012) Sikh Woman Teaches Reddit a Lesson in Tolerance. Mashable.com
 Vancouver School Board (May, 2013): Draft Policy and Regulations: Acceptable Use of
Technology and Social Media Policy for Employees
 Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social
Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
 Meeker, Mary (2015). Internet Trends 2015: http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends
 Watters, Audrey (2015) What Educators Need to Know About Today’s Internet – EML June
2015
Connect with us…
digitaltattoo.ubc.ca
Twitter: DT@UBC
Slideshare: Digital Tattoo
http://www.slideshare.net/digitaltattoo/digital-
tattoo-for-teacher-candidates-at-ubc
JM

Digital Tattoo for UBC Teacher Candidates: Fall 2015

  • 1.
    Think Before YouInk Julie Mitchell, UBC Library (on leave) Cindy Underhill, CTLT
  • 2.
    Identity Image credit: ShannonKringen on Flickr licensed cc:by
  • 3.
    digital identity andteachers… “As a field and society we should be willing to openly discuss these issues with understanding, patience, and recognition of the complexities surrounding SNS [social networking site] participation and social well-being.” Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas. JM
  • 4.
    Session We’ll explore 4questions:  Why does your digital identity matter – as teachers?  How might your digital practices impact your students?  What makes the digital world so complex?  What are some strategies for thoughtful decision making? JM
  • 5.
    your digital identity:a fragment  What did you share?  Why did you share it?  How did you share it?  What did you consider before hitting send? 5 minutes: Think, Pair, Share Your social networks:
  • 6.
    Your digital identity JMImagelicensed cc:by Maurizio Pesce on Flickr Stats from: Mary Meeker’s Internet Trends 2015 – Report: http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends.  40% of mobile users on smartphones  73% of world’s population use mobile phones.
  • 7.
    Why does itmatter?  video at 4 billion views per day (mainly FB)  gaming growing 122% year over year  audio content growing 33% year over year (10 mill in last 2 years joined Soundcloud)  content & stories growing 140% year over year Excerpt from: Audrey Watters: What Educators Need to Know About Today’s Internet – EML June 2015 Stats from Mary Meeker’s Internet Report for 2015: http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends Image licensed Cc:by:sa by Martin Abbegglen on Flickr
  • 8.
    Why does itmatter?  12-24 year olds generating content – 76% use camera to post to SM  Snapchat and Instagram replacing FB for social networking Stats from Mary Meeker’s Internet Report for 2015 http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends Image licensed Cc:by:sa by Martin Abbegglen on Flickr
  • 9.
    Why does itmatter? The rise of the “ephemeralnet”… “Now of age, those young digital natives whose lives we cataloged without their consent are rebelling. They don’t want open social networks, they want intimacy. They don’t believe every action has to be meaningful and permanent. They imagine the web as deletable.” Excerpt from: Techcrunch.com: The Rise of the Ephemeralnet – June 2013. Image from: Weheartit - Anonymous
  • 10.
    Why does itmatter? “ What apps like these do is allow us a little bit more freedom to be ourselves, for better or worse.” From: Forbes – Why We Should Celebrate Snapchat and Encourage Ephemeral Communication (May, 2013)
  • 11.
    Why does itmatter? Instagram launched Snapchat rival – Bolt – in 2014. Until it hits Canada, your images can be seen and shared by anyone if your account is public. Just sayin…
  • 12.
    Why does itmatter to teachers? “Popular SNS have embedded beliefs about identity that are naïve and do not fully reflect the negotiated social participation that frame educators’ evolving Identities.” Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Why does itmatter to teachers? “ The Supreme Court of Canada has determined that educators are held to a higher standard than other citizens due to their unique role in society.” From:www.bcteacherregulation
  • 15.
    Group Discussion –Part 1 “ The Supreme Court of Canada has determined that educators are held to a higher standard than other citizens due to their unique role in society.” From:www.bcteacherregulation.ca
  • 16.
    Group Discussion –Part 2 Go, no-go & shades of grey.  Join a pair: group brainstorm. Take note of your group’s thoughts on the following: Go Acceptable activity on social media Shades of Grey Not sure where this fits No-Go Un-acceptable activity on social media
  • 17.
    Go: professional network From:Education Canada: Twitter and Canadian Educators From: educator George Couros’ Twitter timeline
  • 18.
  • 19.
    No-Go: racism Winnipeg teacher,on leave after controversial Facebook posts on aboriginals. Excerpt from: CBC news Manitoba Posted: Dec 11, 2014
  • 20.
    Shades of grey… “Ifteachers do not clearly understand how moral turpitude is defined in a given community, then how can they be sure that their behavior (online or offline) is beyond reproach?” Excerpt from: Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.
  • 21.
    Blurred Boundaries Do guidelines help? VSBdrafts social media guidelines May, 2013 From Gwyneth Anne-Bronwynn on Flickr – CCbySA 2.0
  • 22.
    Blurred boundaries  You’reon holiday in Mexico and friend posts and tags a photo of you on the beach with a drink and cigarette in hand.
  • 23.
    Consider context Photo source:www.dailymail.co.uk
  • 24.
  • 25.
    Blurred Boundaries  VSBDraft Social Media Policy (p. 2) "As role models for students and a representative of the School District, you must ensure that your use of social networking, even on your personal time, does not reflect negatively on your professional reputation or that of the School District.” From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
  • 26.
    Blurred Boundaries  VSBDraft Social Media Policy (p. 3) “Ask friends not to tag you in any photos or videos without your permission and remove anything that is not appropriate to your role in the School District.” From VSB Draft Social Media Policy
  • 27.
    Blurred Boundaries  You’vehad a terrible first week on your practicum and you post the following to a private group on FB: “Crazy advisor, entitled students, and mismanaged school. All in a days work. Anyone up for a drink?”
  • 28.
    Blurred Boundaries: Students Imagecredit: Flickr user OldShoeWoman JM
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Blurred Boundaries  VSBDraft Social Media Policy (p. 2) “Social networking sites and online postings are not necessarily private. Never criticize students, other district employees or the School District on online sites.” From VSB Draft Social Media Policy CU
  • 31.
    Blurred Boundaries  You’vefinished a great first week on your practicum and you receive a FB friend request from one of the students in your class.
  • 32.
    Blurred Boundaries Excerpt from:The Daily Dot – Jan 9, 2015: Why Teachers Shouldn’t Be Friends With Their Students on Facebook
  • 33.
    Blurred Boundaries  VSBDraft Social Media Policy (p. 2) “Do not request or accept any students or minor (person under the age of 19 years) as ‘friends’ on social networking sites or interact with students or minors on social networking sites for purposes not related to the delivery of the student’s educational program.” From VSB Draft Social Media Policy CU
  • 34.
    Your digital tattoo:by others  Not online? Or are you?  Own your identity Source: http://mashable.com/2012/09/27/sikh-reddit-response/ CU
  • 35.
    Complexity of OnlineEnvironment  Dynamics that influence what we do online – Anonymity – Persistence – Replicability – Searchability – Scalability From: boyd, danah. 2009. "Social Media is Here to Stay... Now What?" JM
  • 36.
    The audience canbe invisible and anonymous JM
  • 37.
    Online Environment |Persistence what you (or others) put on the internet stays there The good The bad The ugly JM
  • 38.
    Online Environment |Replicability Contentcan be taken out of context JM
  • 39.
    Online Environment |Scalability Scalability:what’s intended for one reaches many JM
  • 40.
    Online Environment |Searchability JM
  • 41.
    Online Environment |Searchability JM
  • 42.
    Strategies What employers look for… Excerpt from:Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com CU
  • 43.
    Strategies  Consider whatyou want out of life. “By acting online and offline in a way consistent with what you value, you simplify the work of impression management and increase the chances of finding a good professional match.” Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
  • 44.
    Strategies  Get adviceand feedback. Ask friends what three words come to mind when they google you or look at your public profiles. “Use any feedback you get to evaluate your digital presence against the expectations set out for your profession.” Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
  • 45.
    Strategies  Curate accordingly. “havingsome information online is generally better than nothing. Manage privacy settings, check Google and Bing, update your profile photos and share your expertise in relevant online communities.” Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
  • 46.
    Strategies  Choose andmanage digital relationships carefully. “We are known by the friends we keep online. If you haven’t done so, use LinkedIn to develop and maintain a network of relevant professional connections.” “Ask people with whom you’ve worked or volunteered whether they can offer you an endorsement.” Excerpt from: Berkelaar, B. (2014) What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com
  • 47.
    Photo release policies Become familiar with media release or photo release policies of your school district  It is important to remember your responsibilities as a teacher candidate include not adding to the digital tattoo of your students. JM Image credit: Flickr user OldShoeWoman
  • 48.
    Facebook Guide forEducators Facebook for Educators and Community Leaders (2013): http://bit.ly/1MoldeC
  • 49.
    Soundcloud: Ask ATeacher Series Panoply Media: Ask a Teacher Series: Episode 9: Friending Your Students
  • 50.
    How did wedo together? Consider what you’ve learned…  Why does your digital identity matter – as teachers?  How might your digital practices impact your students?  What makes the digital world so complex?  What are some strategies for thoughtful decision making? JM
  • 51.
    Resources  BC Collegeof Teachers: Standards, Questions and Case Studies http://www.bcct.ca/Standards/QuestionsCaseStudiesContents.aspx#  Berkelaar, B. (2014)What Employers Want To See When They Google You. Brazencareerist.com  boyd, danah. 2009. "Social Media is Here to Stay... Now What?" Microsoft Research Tech Fest, Redmond, Washington, February 26. Retrieved March 10, 2009: http://www.danah.org/papers/talks/MSRTechFest2009.html  Digital Tattoo: digitaltattoo.ubc.ca  Foresight Future Identities (2013) Final Project Report.The Government Office for Science, London.  Haberman,S. (2012) Sikh Woman Teaches Reddit a Lesson in Tolerance. Mashable.com  Vancouver School Board (May, 2013): Draft Policy and Regulations: Acceptable Use of Technology and Social Media Policy for Employees  Kimmons, R.; Veletsianos, G (in press) Teacher Professionalization in the Age of Social Networking Sites: Identifying Major Tensions and Dilemmas.  Meeker, Mary (2015). Internet Trends 2015: http://www.kpcb.com/internet-trends  Watters, Audrey (2015) What Educators Need to Know About Today’s Internet – EML June 2015
  • 52.
    Connect with us… digitaltattoo.ubc.ca Twitter:DT@UBC Slideshare: Digital Tattoo http://www.slideshare.net/digitaltattoo/digital- tattoo-for-teacher-candidates-at-ubc JM