SlideShare a Scribd company logo
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Developing Corporate Social Responsibility for a Sustainable Food
System in Hong Kong
Connie Lee 2011533181
August 12, 2013
FOSS0018 Social Innovation Internship
Category: Corporate Social Responsibility
Community Partner: PwC Hong Kong
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
I. INTRODUCTION
As the world population grows, sustainable food systems are becoming
more crucial in maintaining the world’s environment for future generations.
Hong Kong faces a rapidly growing population, diminishing resources and
increasing reliance on imports and thus, the unsustainable development of the
city’s food system is becoming increasingly threatening. (Yang, S.P., 2008).
Management of the system requires a high input of resources that go beyond
the ability of the government and civil society (Lam, Y., 2012). Corporations
have the capacity to provide these resources; however, CSR in HK is still
underdeveloped and unresponsive. (Williams 2011). For corporations to
maximize their input of resources into co-creating a sustainable food system,
HK corporations should communicate and cooperate with stakeholders to
develop long-term partnerships, adopt a strategic, long-term CSR strategy that
would give a direction for company’s CSR initiatives, and carry out and
encourage more innovation on developing sustainable production processes
and technology.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Sustainable Food Production and Consumption World-wide
In 1976, the world’s ecological footprint exceeded the earth’s
biocapacity and by 2007, it would have taken 1.5 years for the world to absorb
the CO2 emitted and regenerate the used resources. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011).
Out of all the contributors to the ecological footprint, agriculture and food
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
consumption are the most significant “drivers of environmental pressures,
especially habitat change, climate change, water use and toxic emissions.”
(Hertwich, E., van der Voet, E., Suh, S., Tukker, A., Huijbregts M.,
Kazmierczyk, P., Lenzen, M., McNeely, J., Moriguchi, Y., 2010). According
to the UNEP report, 14% of the world’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are
created by the agricultural sector and 13% by transport, which includes the
transport of food. (2010). However, GHG emissions and land use changes are
in fact caused mostly by “energy conversion, agriculture and industrial
production”. (Herwich, E., et. al. 2010). Based on the figures, one may take
the perspective that most of the damage resulted from production activities.
However, from a consumption perspective, these consequences are in response
to the demands of final consumers.
2.2 Environmental Sustainability in Hong Kong
HK has the 45th
largest ecological footprint compared to other
countries with populations over one million. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). HK
has a large population of over seven million in 2012 and is one of the most
affluent regions in Asia, with the 37th
highest GDP in the world and a GDP
growth rate of 2.8% in the first quarter of 2013. (World Bank, 2013). Its
average citizen has a footprint of about 4.0 gha, which is more than double the
available biocapacity per person globally. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). If the
world’s population were to live like an average Hong Kong citizen, the world
would need 2.2 planets to survive. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). Most of this
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
impact results from HK’s heavy reliance on imports and exports for food due
to the growing population and globalization that led to resource restraints,
changes in diet and food security concerns, growing wealth, and the
unsustainable consumption and production behavior.
There are increasingly more initiatives addressing this issue. Green
NGOs run programs and campaigns to raise awareness to the public about the
importance of the sustainability of our food; food banks are becoming more
common, redistributing the food to those in need to prevent waste; and green
social enterprises such as organic farms are filling the gaps between supply of
and demand for local, more environmentally friendly, and healthier produce.
HK’s first organic supermarket, ThreeSixty, opened in in 2006 and the number
of organic farms in HK have grown from 204 in 2012 to 464 in June 2013.
(Hong Kong, 2013). Ultimately, this would not only reduce the CO2 emission
emitted from N-fertilization, but also reduce the CO2 emitted from long-
distance transportation of organic goods. (Yang, S.P., 2008). Although
corporations are often backing these initiatives, the partnerships are often
short-term and unengaging such as one-off volunteering and/or financial
capital (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013). To better
understand how to improve CSR efforts, this study serves to identify the major
drivers of the unsustainable food system, the gaps in CSR initiatives, and
possible amendments of the role corporations can play.
III.METHODOLOGY
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
3.1 Objective
There is little attention given to the sustainability of the food system in
Hong Kong. Thus, the objective of this study is to: identify the drivers of the
problem; and provide recommendations for corporations in how to play a
larger, more effective role in creating a sustainable food system.
3.1 Methodology
To achieve the objectives, this study utilizes research from newspaper and
magazine articles, books, and academic papers on the factors that shaped the
food system. Further, two interviews with CR professionals and one with the
project coordinator of the YMCA’s subsidiary SE, Green Organic Farm were
conducted for on their perspectives of CSR in HK.
IV.FINDINGS
There are many factors that shaped HK’s food system to the state it is
in today; however, three categories of contributors that are significantly tied to
the actions of corporations are globalization, increase in wealth, and
consumer-corporate engagement.
4.1 Global Trade and Limitation of Resources
In 2008, HK’s total value of food imports has steadily increased 39%
due to the population growth and the “rugged uplands” that makes most land
unsuitable for agriculture. (World Bank, 2011; Yang, S.P., 2008). As the food
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
system is progressively shaped by globalization and technological
advancement, more food is being transported from farther away, exacerbating
issues of global warming, acid rain, pollution and more. (Yang, S.P., 2008). In
2004, transport in general was found to be one of the biggest emitters of GHG
emissions, accounting for 13.1%. (Yang, S.P., 2008). While many of HK’s
food imports are from China, which reduces the food miles, other factors
including the amount of meat consumed, food safety factors, increasing wealth
and changing diet patterns offsets much of the miles saved. (Yang, S.P., 2008)
4.1.1 China Food Safety and Sustainable Food
Although importing food from China reduces GHG emissions, recent
food security issues have raised concerns about Chinese imports, leading
people to seek alternatives that are transported from farther away (Yang, S.P.,
2008). In 2008, 76,500 fake food cases were discovered in China, one of
which was the baby formula scandal. (Mu, X., 2009). With low consumer
confidence of Chinese goods, more goods must be imported from farther
countries to compensate, raising the amount of carbon emissions generated.
4.2.2 Limited Space and Food Waste
One of the major problems in HK is the lack of space, which results in
another problem of managing waste, 1/3 of which is food. (UNEP, 2013).
About 3,2000 tons of food waste is produced per day in HK, a rate that will
eventually exhaust all three landfills in HK within five years (Feeding Hong
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Kong, n.d.). In 2012, domestic food waste accounted for 39.1% of the total
domestic waste weight with commercial and industrial food waste accounting
for 28.2%. (Lam, Y., 2012). The 28.2% includes waste from restaurants, shops,
offices, shops, markets and hotels. (Lam, Y., 2012). The growing economic
activities in these two sectors resulted in a doubling of amount of waste within
the past five years. (Lam, Y., 2012). This amount of waste will have severe
environmental costs that range from overuse of chemicals such as pesticides to
the increase in the GHG, Methane, coming from the rotting food, which will
further accelerate global climate change. (UNEP, 2013).
There are no regulations for managing food waste in HK; instead, the
government and civil society holds programs and campaigns to raise
awareness and build a source waste separation system. One such program is
the “Food Waste Recycling Partnership Scheme” where participating
companies from various private sectors must categorize and separate the food
waste that would then be composted. (Lam, Y., 2012).
However, this “voluntary” system has several faults. One is that the
workers hired to separate the waste are rarely educated on how to do so
correctly, which ultimately results in higher costs for all stakeholders. To
avoid such costs, it is in businesses’ interests to start taking certain measures
to avoid having to take on such costs before it these actions become obligatory.
(A. Wood, personal communication, July 31, 2013).
4.3 Increasing Wealth and Sustainable Food
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Industrialized and developing countries differ in the amount of energy
used, carbon emissions emitted and other environmental impacts of household
consumption of different categories. In most industrialized countries, the
impact of household consumption is higher than that of government
consumption and their investment in infrastructure and capital goods.
Hertwich, E., et. al. 2010). Additionally, researchers calculated an overall
elasticity of carbon dioxide of 0.81, meaning when income doubles, 81% more
carbon dioxide is emitted globally. (Hertwich, E., et. al, 2010). Thus, as HK’s
GDP per capita increases, certain changes in consumption behaviour occur
including the consumption of meat and luxury items.
4.3.1 Meat
Average food consumption per person in Hong Kong grew 52% from
1971 to 1997. (Adamo, B., Foley, M., Graef, J., Stone, K., 2002). Out of the
entire East Asia region, HK has the most westernized diet, characterized by
“larger portions and higher protein and fat intake” (Adamo, B., et. al., 2002),
especially from beef and seafood that is often produced unsustainably. As
Hong Kong grows wealthier, people start to eat more meat (Yang, S.P., 2008).
HK has one of the highest beef consumption per capita rates in the world.
(Yang, S.P., 2008). In terms of consumption, beef is much less energy
efficient, taking about 40 calories of fossil fuel energy to make one calorie
worth of beef compared to the 2.2 calories used per plant-based protein.
(Gidon E., Martin, P. A., 2005). In terms of transportation, although the more
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
energy-efficient railway transports 77% of the imported meat for HK
consumption, the long refrigeration of meat burns more fossil fuel. (Yang, S.P.,
2008). Most of the environmental costs come from the production stage,
where producing one kilogram of beef emits 36 kilos of CO2-e. (WWF-Hong
Kong). However by eating one meatless meal a week, 213 kg of carbon – or
86,000 cars – can be saved. (Green Monday, 2013).
4.3.2 Dietary Patterns and Shift to Exotic Tastes
As wealth increased, more HK people started to consume more
“luxurious” types of foods from far-away countries. (Yang, S.P., 2008). As
traditional Chinese believe that animals such as snakes and some protected
animals are high in nutrition and have healing functions, many Cantonese
import these rare products from the Guangdong province, decreasing
biodiversity. (Qifeng, Z., Gan., J., Xun., L., 2012). HK supermarkets also
unsustainably import a variety of out-of-season fruits and vegetables from
overseas to sell them at a higher price, which increases food miles. (Yang, S.P.,
2008). These shifts towards more extravagant foods are proof of unsustainable
consumption behavior caused by not only cultural and economic factors but
also by corporate marketing efforts, appealing to people’s desire for status and
superior quality. Changing consumption patterns would require a change in
consumer perception and values of food. (Moomaw, W., Griffin, T., Kurczak,
K., Lomax, J., 2012).
4.4 Consumers and Corporate Engagement
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Aside from the economic trends mentioned, lack consumer and
corporate understanding and participation in this issue are also a key reason
for the current state of affairs.
4.4.1 Low Consumer Awareness and Perception
Despite increasing awareness on this issue, based on studies of HK’s
food consumption patterns, people are not changing their consumption
behaviour. (Yang, S.P., 2008). As quoted from my supervisor, “waste is a big
thing in HK but people are not particularly aware”. This is because of the lack
of knowledge and “remoteness between producers and consumers” (Yang,
S.P., 2008). Studies have shown that improving the links between producer
and consumer can encourage consumers to change their behavior. An example
is having more local farmer’s markets or community supported schemes,
which has been successful in western countries. (Yang, S.P., 2008).
People are not only under-exposed to the matter, they also participate
little in programs. In HK, people think CR activities should be “fun” and less
focused on how “we should help the community” (D. Johnson, personal
communication, August 1, 2013). During the internship, even though we sent
out information on the NGO and our service targets to participants, often times
the volunteers were still not knowledgeable of the target of our activity. Extra
measures should be taken to involve the thousands of company employees in
CSR planning and activities.
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
4.4.2 Low Corporate Responsibility Involvement
According to Walker, Welford and Kwok, companies in HK do not
contribute much to society either in cash or non-cash forms. (2008).
Businesses are not doing enough in “product design, life cycle and consumer
communication strategies” in regards to sustainability and disconnects CSR
from its profit-making activities. (Walker, Welford, Kwok, 2008). Based on
their survey, businesses as well as SMEs view CSR as “expensive and not
central to profit-oriented strategy” (Walker, R. M., Welford, R.J., Kwok,
W.W.C., 2008). Therefore, unless it is to comply with regulations or is
demanded by consumers, companies are unlikely to work towards change in
any environmental issue. (Walker, R. M., et. al., 2008)
Conversely, based on my internship research, many companies,
especially larger ones, are beginning to adopt CSR goals into their core
businesses although still imperfect. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013). Because of
the nascent stages, the initiatives are often ad hoc, project-based, and loosely
tied to their company mission and goals. The companies usually rely on three
tools when engaging with the outside world: a CR team based in company
headquarters, a few “high-profile (but relatively cheap) initiatives”, and an
annual report to highlight the progress of these initiatives. (Browne, J., Nuttall,
R., 2013). Because of this narrow approach, businesses often run on the
“whim of senior executives” rather than the impact and are thus “short-lived”.
(Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013).
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Most Asian companies are more disconnected from NGOs than
companies overseas, which is why communication between corporations and
stakeholders is still disorganized. (Williams, G., 2011). This is partly a cultural
issue, as HK’s hierarchical social structure often prevents organization
representatives from reaching others directly or speaking straightforwardly.
This was supported by a statement in the McKinsey article that stated how
NGOs want businesses to do more on “external aspects” including
“communication and cooperation with other parties, management of supply
chains, adherence to international standards” (Walker, R.M, et. al., 2008).
Although HK is one of Asia’s innovation hubs, having ranked 4th
in
INSEAD’s Global Innovation Index 2011, several experts have stated a
different view, saying Hong Kong’s innovation is still “immature” since only
1% of the city’s GDP is invested in technological innovation (2011; Perez, B.,
2013). Therefore, corporations should carry out and support more innovation
to discover new and improved products, services, environmental technology or
processes, to fill gaps in the food system.
There is growing development in innovation amongst social enterprises
(SE) however. Green Monday, a new, local SE that promotes green eating, is
the first to target the issue of sustainable food consumption. (Green Monday,
2013). However, many small SEs still struggle as most social workers
managing the SEs have limited business acumen and training, thus examples
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
of SEs with both social and economic success is difficult to find. (Yuen, T.,
Lee, J., 2004).
V. DISCUSSION
5.1 Recommendations for CSR Improvements
With knowledge on the drivers of this unsustainable food system and
the gaps of CSR strategy in Hong Kong, corporations can be more efficient in
reducing environmental costs of unsustainable consumption by adopting both
internally and externally-oriented changes. To help resolve the food
sustainability issue, companies must communicate and cooperate with other
stakeholders.
5.1.1 Communication with Employees
To raise awareness and participation of people’s consumption behavior,
companies should communicate more internally about the importance of the
issue. HK has a large banking sector, employing 80,000 people in 2008, so the
reach of the message is broader. (Williams, G., 2011). Companies have
increased their efforts in skilled-volunteering, as the proportion of companies
with formal employee volunteer programs has risen to 94% in 2009 from 84%.
(Williams, G., 2011). In order to improve on these programs and create a
larger impact, the company CSR team needs to involve “big-spending
functions” like production or marketing. Although the norm for companies
now is to avoid high costs for CSR, the CSR team must engage all internal
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
stakeholders in order move people to change their consumption patterns,
within and outside of the office. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013).
There are various tools companies could use to encourage sustainable
behavior or increase volunteering such as giving cash bonuses. A way to raise
awareness would be through internal “green marketing”. We adopted this
technique to encourage colleagues in PwC HK to join the green-eating
workshop we organized via the company’s internal social media site, internal
email. Our marketing strategy was to showcase the impact that the event will
have on the target group while educating employees on low-carbon living. For
other events, PwC’s CR team also writes CR excerpts that highlight key CR
projects in weekly and monthly newsletters, TV screens throughout the office
and computer pop-up notifications. By making the problem more “visible” to
present in their surroundings, employees can be more aware of the sustainable
consumption issue and become more conscious of their consumption choices.
When people feel that the problem is more related to their lives, such as to
their individual health, the bigger the chance their behaviours will change and
be imitated by cohorts. (Williams, G., 2011).
5.1.2 Communication with NGOs
Because findings have shown ineffective communication between
corporates and external stakeholders, corporations should develop more
efficient communication networks amongst those dealing with the issue. CSR
teams contact NGOs frequently; however, there are expected challenges in
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
aligning both sides’ missions and expectations whilst forming any kind of
partnership. (A. Wood, personal communication, August 1, 2013). This was
the case between PwC HK and WWF. While PwC was looking towards
making tangible environmental changes, WWF’s approach leaned towards
attracting extensive media attention for PwC’s CR. Also, although PwC
wished to engage more in skilled volunteering and provide their environmental
services such as sustainability accounting services to community partners,
WWF did not need their services; therefore again, there was misalignment
between the partners. (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013).
Thus, companies must clearly lay out their objectives, needs, and services to
the community partners so as to be able to discuss more effective ways that the
company can contribute.
There are setbacks to communicating across all sectors, one of which is
culture. As previously mentioned, HK organizations are more hierarchical
than that of Australia, which makes communication less efficient. Moreover,
people in Australia are more communicative in general compared to people in
HK, which is reflected in the company culture. These are issues that
companies have to take into account before establishing communication
systems in order to encourage more cross-sector collaboration.
5.1.2 Communication within the Private Sector
Multinational corporations (MNC) are closely connected throughout
the supply chain; therefore they have significant influence each other’s actions.
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
In one of my CSR courses, I learned about the “Walmart Effect” which
describes the ripple effect MNCs have on the community. As leaders, MNCs
should utilize their influence by communicating their environmental concerns
and needs to partners such as requesting the use of locally grown, organic
produce or green catering for events. By taking assertive action, other market
leaders will be forced respond with other sustainable actions in order to
compete. Companies should also include supplier conduct into the company’s
purchasing policies while monitoring and verifying the suppliers’ compliance
to these policies. (CSR Asia, Oxfam, 2008). Since many of the companies in
HK are working with suppliers from China, HK companies can ensure stricter
food safety policies and encourage more transparency in order to reduce the
number of health incidences, progressively improve consumer confidence in
Chinese goods, and thus be able to import more foods from China rather than
from faraway countries.
Since policy plays a large part in improving the sustainability of the
food system, it would be beneficial if companies could work more closely
with the government on the issue. Environmental politics started evolving
rapidly since the 1980s and government-business relations have shifted from
“cooperation to accommodation” or even to confrontation in certain industries
contributing to climate change. (Lee, H., 2004). Some officials have felt that
corporations’ approach with the government has been “reactive, conservative
and behind-the-scenes” (Loh, C., 2004), which suggest that companies should
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
invest in being more involved political planning. In the long run, it will be “in
the interest of businesses to help customers adopt to sustainable lifestyles and
behaviour” (Williams, G., 2011); thus, by taking the initiative to speak with
the government on making the supply chain more sustainable and delineating
why fulfilling certain business needs would benefit society as a whole, the
company can create a win-win situation for all. (Loh, C., 2004).
In all, because the issue of food sustainability requires complex
infrastructure and special knowledge, all stakeholders should be
knowledgeable on the happenings within the network so as to not have too
many overlapping projects and be more efficient in filling the gaps.
5.1.2 Strategic CSR
CSR in Asia is developing quickly, however management of CSR
activities is often “unstructured or piecemeal” (Williams, G., 2011). The CSR
strategy is meant to give focus to the ventures and partners the company
chooses to get involved with based on its resources, core business,
environmental mission and objectives. These were the factors I had to take
into account when selecting compatible long-term NGO partners for PwC.
Companies should be clear on the business value of CR and how it
ties into the core business when forming a strategy (D. Johnson, personal
communication, August 1, 2013). When CR is just considered as “an add-on”,
companies pursue more low-cost, project-based initiatives to take on such as
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
one-time employee volunteering activities or community event sponsorships.
(Williams, G., 2011). Whatever the focus is, the company should aim to create
long-term, sustainable relationships and impact. For example, CLP Power
Hong Kong Limited, an energy company, runs a very successful skilled-
volunteering program called “Rewiring for the Elderly” where CLP’s
engineers help low-income, single elderly living to “conduct rewiring,
electricity safety inspections and maintenance of electrical appliances service”
(CLP, 2010). The project is voluntarily continued by engineers in the company
and has been running steadily for many years. The success of the project lies
in its leveraging of engineering expertise of the employees, its long-term
commitment to the cause and the alignment of the project’s objectives with
that of the company’s overall.
5.1.3 Innovation
The process of shaping a sustainable food production and consumption
system is highly technical. Thus, society would significantly benefit from
further innovation all along the supply chain focusing on creating sustainable
food. No matter in which stage or of what function of the process that the
business chooses to innovate, companies should be responsible of taking into
account of the product or service’s entire life cycle even after consumption.
For example, in 2012, Starbucks Hong Kong invested in a study that
developed biorefinery technology that could convert food waste into plastic
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
used in certain products. (Bladon, A., 2012). If the pilot plant is successful,
long supply chains and transportation can be reduced.
VI.CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the overarching driver of the issue of unsustainable food
is globalization, which includes the increase in trade, an increase in wealth and
the lack of stakeholder engagement. To maximize impact, businesses should
not only consume and produce sustainably but also increase stakeholder
dialogue and form long-term, high-engagement partnerships to create long-
lasting impact, develop a overarching CSR strategy that clearly defines the
company’s CSR objectives and leverages on the resources that company has,
and to innovate or support innovation in environmental sustainability.
However, with limited studies on these topics that are written from an Asian
perspective, more research on best practices for HK companies when targeting
environmental systems is needed. The key to sustainable food in HK is
changing consumption patterns and behaviour; therefore, corporations must
collaborate with all stakeholders to create a sustainable future. (Word count:
3993)
VII. REFERENCES
Adamo, B., Foley, M., Graef, J., Stone, K. (2002). A consumption analysis of
Hong Kong and Guangzhou. Retrieved July 2, 2013 from
http://www.civic-
exchange.org/eng/upload/files/Report__Consumption_Analysis_of_HK_
and_Guangdong.pdf
Bladon, A. (2012). Starbucks Hong Kong Turns Food Waste into Bioplastic.
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
This big city. Retrieved http://thisbigcity.net/starbucks-hong-kong-turns-
food-waste-into-bioplastic/
Browne, J., Nutall, R. (2013). Beyond corporate social responsibility:
Integrated external engagement. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from
http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/strategy/beyond_corporate_social_re
sponsibility_integrated_external_engagement
Cambridge (2013). Corporate social responsibility. Retrieved August 1, 2013
from http://www.cambridge.org.br/cambridge-brazil/social-
responsibility/corporate-social-responsibility
CLP. (2010). Volunteering. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from
https://www.clp.com.hk/ourvalues/social/community/volunteering/Pages
/volunteering.aspx
CSR Asia, Oxfam. (2008). Corporate social responsibility survey of Hang
Seng Index Constituent Companies 2011. Hong Kong: Oxfam.
Environmental impact of the UK food economy with particular reference to
WWF priority places and the North-east Atlantic. (2008). Retrieved July
10, 2013 from
http://assets.wwf.org.uk/downloads/environmentalimpacts_ukfoodconsu
mption.pdf
Feeding Hong Kong. (n.d.). Food waste in HK. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from
http://feedinghk.org/food-waste-in-hk/
Gidon E., Martin, P. A. (2005). Diet, Energy, and Global Warming. Earth
interactions. 10(9), p. 1-14. Retrieved July 4, 2-13 from
http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/pdf/10.1175/EI167.1
Green Monday. (2013). Environmental impact. Retrieved July 2, 2013 from
http://www.greenmonday.org.hk/impact.php
Guide Me Hong Kong. (2011). Hong Kong, one of the world’s most
innovative economies. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from
http://www.guidemehongkong.com/story/doing-business/hong-kong-
one-of-the-worlds-most-innovative-economies
Hertwich, E., van der Voet, E., Suh, S., Tukker, A., Huijbregts M.,
Kazmierczyk, P., Lenzen, M., McNeely, J., Moriguchi, Y. (2010)
Assessing the environmental impacts of consumption and production:
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Priority products and materials. A report of the working group on the
environmental impacts of products and materials to the International
Panel for Sustainable Resource Management. Retrieved July 2, 2013
from http://www.unep.org/resourcepanel/Portals/24102/
PDFs/PriorityProductsAndMaterials_Report.pdf
Hong Kong: The facts. (2013, January). Agriculture and fisheries. Retrieved
August 1, 2013 from
http://www.gov.hk/en/about/abouthk/factsheets/docs/agriculture.pdf
World Bank. (2011). Hong Kong-SAR, China. Retrieved July 16, 2013 from
http://search.worldbank.org/data?qterm=Hong+kong+population&langu
age=EN&format=
Lam, Y. (2012). Partnership for sustainable waste management: a case study
of the food waste recycling partnership scheme in Hong Kong. Retrieved
August 1, 2013 from http://hdl.handle.net/10722/180093
Lee, H. (2004). Environmental politics in Hong Kong: Dynamic of
government-business relations in air quality management. Retrieved
August 1, 2013 from
http://repository.lib.polyu.edu.hk/jspui/handle/10397/2234
Loh, C. (2004). Government and Business Alliance: Hong Kong’s Functional
Constituencies. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.civic-
exchange.org/eng/upload/files/200408_GovBusinessAlliance.pdf
Moomaw, W., Griffin, T., Kurczak, K., Lomax, J. (2012). The critical role of
global food consumption patterns in achieving sustainable food systems
and food for all: A UNEP discussion paper. United Nations
Environment Programme, Division of Technology, Industry and
Economics, Paris, France.
Mu, X. (2009). China investigates 76,500 fake food cases in 2008. China view.
Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-
03/16/content_11016531.htm
Perez, B. (2013, August 8). Business group calls for creation of innovation and
technology bureau. The South China Morning Post. Retrieved August 1,
2013 from
http://www.scmp.com/business/economy/article/1295144/business-
group-calls-creation-innovation-and-technology-bureau?login=1
 
	
  
	
  
	
  
Qifeng, Z., Gan., J., Xun., L. (2012). Eating habits in South China driving
endangered animals to extinction. Chinadialogue. Retrieved August, 1,
2013 from http://www.chinadialogue.net/article/show/single/ch/5506-
Eating-habits-in-south-China-driving-endangered-animals-to-extinction-
UNEP. (2013). Food waste facts. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from
http://www.unep.org/wed/quickfacts/
Walker, R.M., Welford, R., J., Kwok, W.W. (2008). Corporate social
responsibility in Hong Kong: Perceptions from business, government,
and NGOs. Hong Kong: HKU.
Williams, G. (2011). Responsible management in Asia: Perspectives on CSR.
London, United Kingdom: Palgrave Macmillan.
World Bank. (2013). World Development Indicators 2013. Retrieved August 1,
2013 from http://databank.worldbank.org/data/download/GDP.pdf
WWF-Hong Kong. (2011). Hong Kong ecological footprint report 2010:
Paths to a sustainable future. Retrieved July 5, 2013 from
http://awsassets.wwfhk.panda.
org/downloads/hong_kong_ecological_footprint_report_2010.pdf
Yang, S.P. (2008). Food miles: a case of sustainability consumption In Hong
Kong. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://hdl.handle.net/10722/54624
Yuen, T., Lee, J. (2004). Social Entrepreneurship in Hong Kong: Perspectives,
Trends and Prospects. Retrieved August, 1, 2013
from web.hku.hk/~ccsg/HKSE1

More Related Content

What's hot

TFSL_ConceptPaper
TFSL_ConceptPaperTFSL_ConceptPaper
TFSL_ConceptPaper
Ntila
 
Economics Of Environmental Sustainability
Economics Of Environmental SustainabilityEconomics Of Environmental Sustainability
Economics Of Environmental Sustainability
Masood Zaidi
 
Inter generational equality and ecological resources
Inter generational equality and ecological resourcesInter generational equality and ecological resources
Inter generational equality and ecological resources
Burning Brain Society
 
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
Naturskyddsföreningen
 
Economics, Environment, and Sustainability
Economics, Environment, and SustainabilityEconomics, Environment, and Sustainability
Economics, Environment, and Sustainability
Shohail Choudhury
 
Concept of total economic value in environmental management
Concept of total economic value in environmental managementConcept of total economic value in environmental management
Concept of total economic value in environmental management
Teresa Muthoni Gitonga
 

What's hot (19)

Benefits of Organic Agriculture as a Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation...
Benefits of Organic Agriculture as a Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation...Benefits of Organic Agriculture as a Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation...
Benefits of Organic Agriculture as a Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation...
 
Agri-Food System Dynamics: Pathways to Sustainability in an Era of Uncertainty
Agri-Food System Dynamics: Pathways to Sustainability in an Era of UncertaintyAgri-Food System Dynamics: Pathways to Sustainability in an Era of Uncertainty
Agri-Food System Dynamics: Pathways to Sustainability in an Era of Uncertainty
 
Environment assignment
Environment assignmentEnvironment assignment
Environment assignment
 
Food Matters: Researching the Viability of a Sustainable Food System at the U...
Food Matters: Researching the Viability of a Sustainable Food System at the U...Food Matters: Researching the Viability of a Sustainable Food System at the U...
Food Matters: Researching the Viability of a Sustainable Food System at the U...
 
Assessing the implication of liquid bioenergy production from food crops on f...
Assessing the implication of liquid bioenergy production from food crops on f...Assessing the implication of liquid bioenergy production from food crops on f...
Assessing the implication of liquid bioenergy production from food crops on f...
 
TFSL_ConceptPaper
TFSL_ConceptPaperTFSL_ConceptPaper
TFSL_ConceptPaper
 
Effect of Environmental Awareness on Willingness to Pay for Renewable Energy
Effect of Environmental Awareness on Willingness to Pay for Renewable EnergyEffect of Environmental Awareness on Willingness to Pay for Renewable Energy
Effect of Environmental Awareness on Willingness to Pay for Renewable Energy
 
Sustainable Development through Waste Management: An Empirical Research throu...
Sustainable Development through Waste Management: An Empirical Research throu...Sustainable Development through Waste Management: An Empirical Research throu...
Sustainable Development through Waste Management: An Empirical Research throu...
 
Eat Well Guide : A more sustainable Diet : Carbon Trust UK
Eat Well Guide : A more sustainable Diet : Carbon Trust UKEat Well Guide : A more sustainable Diet : Carbon Trust UK
Eat Well Guide : A more sustainable Diet : Carbon Trust UK
 
Economics Of Environmental Sustainability
Economics Of Environmental SustainabilityEconomics Of Environmental Sustainability
Economics Of Environmental Sustainability
 
Inter generational equality and ecological resources
Inter generational equality and ecological resourcesInter generational equality and ecological resources
Inter generational equality and ecological resources
 
Industrialization & sustainability v1
Industrialization & sustainability v1Industrialization & sustainability v1
Industrialization & sustainability v1
 
Food systems and natural resources-2016 Food Security and Climate change im...
 Food systems and natural resources-2016  Food Security and Climate change im... Food systems and natural resources-2016  Food Security and Climate change im...
Food systems and natural resources-2016 Food Security and Climate change im...
 
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
Productivity, environment, climate and food security –how can agriculture mee...
 
Economics, Environment, and Sustainability
Economics, Environment, and SustainabilityEconomics, Environment, and Sustainability
Economics, Environment, and Sustainability
 
Public Perceptions of Bioenergy
Public Perceptions of BioenergyPublic Perceptions of Bioenergy
Public Perceptions of Bioenergy
 
Kitty van der Heijden World Circular Economy Forum 2017 Helsinki Finland
Kitty van der Heijden World Circular Economy Forum 2017 Helsinki FinlandKitty van der Heijden World Circular Economy Forum 2017 Helsinki Finland
Kitty van der Heijden World Circular Economy Forum 2017 Helsinki Finland
 
Poyry - Are you ready for the Age of Confluence? - Point of View
Poyry - Are you ready for the Age of Confluence? - Point of ViewPoyry - Are you ready for the Age of Confluence? - Point of View
Poyry - Are you ready for the Age of Confluence? - Point of View
 
Concept of total economic value in environmental management
Concept of total economic value in environmental managementConcept of total economic value in environmental management
Concept of total economic value in environmental management
 

Similar to Developing Corporate Social Responsibility for a Sustainable Food System in Hong Kong - IE

Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docxRunning Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
wlynn1
 
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗPresentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
Ilias Pappas
 
Excessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
Excessive Consumerism and the Global ClimateExcessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
Excessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
Sarah M
 
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity 1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
AnastaciaShadelb
 
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in JapanFederica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Federica Marra
 
Complete paper arbaaz & suhail
Complete paper arbaaz & suhailComplete paper arbaaz & suhail
Complete paper arbaaz & suhail
Arbaaz khan
 
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS. .docx
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS.                            .docxRUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS.                            .docx
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS. .docx
wlynn1
 
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
Alexander Decker
 
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and Manufacturing Indust...
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and  Manufacturing Indust...Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and  Manufacturing Indust...
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and Manufacturing Indust...
IJMER
 

Similar to Developing Corporate Social Responsibility for a Sustainable Food System in Hong Kong - IE (20)

Dr Mae Wan Ho - Ten+One
Dr Mae Wan Ho - Ten+OneDr Mae Wan Ho - Ten+One
Dr Mae Wan Ho - Ten+One
 
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docxRunning Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
 
Environmental auditing and sustainable development in nigeria
Environmental auditing and sustainable development in nigeriaEnvironmental auditing and sustainable development in nigeria
Environmental auditing and sustainable development in nigeria
 
Waste management and environmental sustainability in ghana
Waste management and environmental sustainability in ghanaWaste management and environmental sustainability in ghana
Waste management and environmental sustainability in ghana
 
Blog
BlogBlog
Blog
 
Essay globalization
Essay globalizationEssay globalization
Essay globalization
 
AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF PUBLIC’S OPINION ON GLOBAL WARMING AND SUSTAINABLE DEVE...
AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF PUBLIC’S OPINION ON GLOBAL WARMING AND SUSTAINABLE DEVE...AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF PUBLIC’S OPINION ON GLOBAL WARMING AND SUSTAINABLE DEVE...
AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF PUBLIC’S OPINION ON GLOBAL WARMING AND SUSTAINABLE DEVE...
 
Guercio sustainability and economic degrowth
Guercio sustainability and economic degrowthGuercio sustainability and economic degrowth
Guercio sustainability and economic degrowth
 
Global Warming Local Updates
Global Warming Local UpdatesGlobal Warming Local Updates
Global Warming Local Updates
 
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗPresentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
Presentation1-ΠΤΥΧΙΑΚΗ
 
Excessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
Excessive Consumerism and the Global ClimateExcessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
Excessive Consumerism and the Global Climate
 
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity 1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
1Food and Water SecurityJasmine JonesUniversity
 
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in JapanFederica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Federica Marra - Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
 
Complete paper arbaaz & suhail
Complete paper arbaaz & suhailComplete paper arbaaz & suhail
Complete paper arbaaz & suhail
 
Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in JapanFighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
Fighting Food Loss and Food Waste in Japan
 
Climate change in context of sustainable development
Climate change in context of sustainable developmentClimate change in context of sustainable development
Climate change in context of sustainable development
 
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS. .docx
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS.                            .docxRUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS.                            .docx
RUNNING Head IMPACTS ON FOOD SYSTEMS. .docx
 
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
The impact of environmental accounting and reporting on sustainable developme...
 
Innovation and Sustainable Development: The Question of Energy Efficiency
Innovation and Sustainable Development: The Question of Energy EfficiencyInnovation and Sustainable Development: The Question of Energy Efficiency
Innovation and Sustainable Development: The Question of Energy Efficiency
 
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and Manufacturing Indust...
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and  Manufacturing Indust...Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and  Manufacturing Indust...
Integrating Environmental Accounting in Agro-Allied and Manufacturing Indust...
 

Developing Corporate Social Responsibility for a Sustainable Food System in Hong Kong - IE

  • 1.         Developing Corporate Social Responsibility for a Sustainable Food System in Hong Kong Connie Lee 2011533181 August 12, 2013 FOSS0018 Social Innovation Internship Category: Corporate Social Responsibility Community Partner: PwC Hong Kong
  • 2.         I. INTRODUCTION As the world population grows, sustainable food systems are becoming more crucial in maintaining the world’s environment for future generations. Hong Kong faces a rapidly growing population, diminishing resources and increasing reliance on imports and thus, the unsustainable development of the city’s food system is becoming increasingly threatening. (Yang, S.P., 2008). Management of the system requires a high input of resources that go beyond the ability of the government and civil society (Lam, Y., 2012). Corporations have the capacity to provide these resources; however, CSR in HK is still underdeveloped and unresponsive. (Williams 2011). For corporations to maximize their input of resources into co-creating a sustainable food system, HK corporations should communicate and cooperate with stakeholders to develop long-term partnerships, adopt a strategic, long-term CSR strategy that would give a direction for company’s CSR initiatives, and carry out and encourage more innovation on developing sustainable production processes and technology. II. LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Sustainable Food Production and Consumption World-wide In 1976, the world’s ecological footprint exceeded the earth’s biocapacity and by 2007, it would have taken 1.5 years for the world to absorb the CO2 emitted and regenerate the used resources. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). Out of all the contributors to the ecological footprint, agriculture and food
  • 3.         consumption are the most significant “drivers of environmental pressures, especially habitat change, climate change, water use and toxic emissions.” (Hertwich, E., van der Voet, E., Suh, S., Tukker, A., Huijbregts M., Kazmierczyk, P., Lenzen, M., McNeely, J., Moriguchi, Y., 2010). According to the UNEP report, 14% of the world’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are created by the agricultural sector and 13% by transport, which includes the transport of food. (2010). However, GHG emissions and land use changes are in fact caused mostly by “energy conversion, agriculture and industrial production”. (Herwich, E., et. al. 2010). Based on the figures, one may take the perspective that most of the damage resulted from production activities. However, from a consumption perspective, these consequences are in response to the demands of final consumers. 2.2 Environmental Sustainability in Hong Kong HK has the 45th largest ecological footprint compared to other countries with populations over one million. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). HK has a large population of over seven million in 2012 and is one of the most affluent regions in Asia, with the 37th highest GDP in the world and a GDP growth rate of 2.8% in the first quarter of 2013. (World Bank, 2013). Its average citizen has a footprint of about 4.0 gha, which is more than double the available biocapacity per person globally. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). If the world’s population were to live like an average Hong Kong citizen, the world would need 2.2 planets to survive. (WWF-Hong Kong, 2011). Most of this
  • 4.         impact results from HK’s heavy reliance on imports and exports for food due to the growing population and globalization that led to resource restraints, changes in diet and food security concerns, growing wealth, and the unsustainable consumption and production behavior. There are increasingly more initiatives addressing this issue. Green NGOs run programs and campaigns to raise awareness to the public about the importance of the sustainability of our food; food banks are becoming more common, redistributing the food to those in need to prevent waste; and green social enterprises such as organic farms are filling the gaps between supply of and demand for local, more environmentally friendly, and healthier produce. HK’s first organic supermarket, ThreeSixty, opened in in 2006 and the number of organic farms in HK have grown from 204 in 2012 to 464 in June 2013. (Hong Kong, 2013). Ultimately, this would not only reduce the CO2 emission emitted from N-fertilization, but also reduce the CO2 emitted from long- distance transportation of organic goods. (Yang, S.P., 2008). Although corporations are often backing these initiatives, the partnerships are often short-term and unengaging such as one-off volunteering and/or financial capital (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013). To better understand how to improve CSR efforts, this study serves to identify the major drivers of the unsustainable food system, the gaps in CSR initiatives, and possible amendments of the role corporations can play. III.METHODOLOGY
  • 5.         3.1 Objective There is little attention given to the sustainability of the food system in Hong Kong. Thus, the objective of this study is to: identify the drivers of the problem; and provide recommendations for corporations in how to play a larger, more effective role in creating a sustainable food system. 3.1 Methodology To achieve the objectives, this study utilizes research from newspaper and magazine articles, books, and academic papers on the factors that shaped the food system. Further, two interviews with CR professionals and one with the project coordinator of the YMCA’s subsidiary SE, Green Organic Farm were conducted for on their perspectives of CSR in HK. IV.FINDINGS There are many factors that shaped HK’s food system to the state it is in today; however, three categories of contributors that are significantly tied to the actions of corporations are globalization, increase in wealth, and consumer-corporate engagement. 4.1 Global Trade and Limitation of Resources In 2008, HK’s total value of food imports has steadily increased 39% due to the population growth and the “rugged uplands” that makes most land unsuitable for agriculture. (World Bank, 2011; Yang, S.P., 2008). As the food
  • 6.         system is progressively shaped by globalization and technological advancement, more food is being transported from farther away, exacerbating issues of global warming, acid rain, pollution and more. (Yang, S.P., 2008). In 2004, transport in general was found to be one of the biggest emitters of GHG emissions, accounting for 13.1%. (Yang, S.P., 2008). While many of HK’s food imports are from China, which reduces the food miles, other factors including the amount of meat consumed, food safety factors, increasing wealth and changing diet patterns offsets much of the miles saved. (Yang, S.P., 2008) 4.1.1 China Food Safety and Sustainable Food Although importing food from China reduces GHG emissions, recent food security issues have raised concerns about Chinese imports, leading people to seek alternatives that are transported from farther away (Yang, S.P., 2008). In 2008, 76,500 fake food cases were discovered in China, one of which was the baby formula scandal. (Mu, X., 2009). With low consumer confidence of Chinese goods, more goods must be imported from farther countries to compensate, raising the amount of carbon emissions generated. 4.2.2 Limited Space and Food Waste One of the major problems in HK is the lack of space, which results in another problem of managing waste, 1/3 of which is food. (UNEP, 2013). About 3,2000 tons of food waste is produced per day in HK, a rate that will eventually exhaust all three landfills in HK within five years (Feeding Hong
  • 7.         Kong, n.d.). In 2012, domestic food waste accounted for 39.1% of the total domestic waste weight with commercial and industrial food waste accounting for 28.2%. (Lam, Y., 2012). The 28.2% includes waste from restaurants, shops, offices, shops, markets and hotels. (Lam, Y., 2012). The growing economic activities in these two sectors resulted in a doubling of amount of waste within the past five years. (Lam, Y., 2012). This amount of waste will have severe environmental costs that range from overuse of chemicals such as pesticides to the increase in the GHG, Methane, coming from the rotting food, which will further accelerate global climate change. (UNEP, 2013). There are no regulations for managing food waste in HK; instead, the government and civil society holds programs and campaigns to raise awareness and build a source waste separation system. One such program is the “Food Waste Recycling Partnership Scheme” where participating companies from various private sectors must categorize and separate the food waste that would then be composted. (Lam, Y., 2012). However, this “voluntary” system has several faults. One is that the workers hired to separate the waste are rarely educated on how to do so correctly, which ultimately results in higher costs for all stakeholders. To avoid such costs, it is in businesses’ interests to start taking certain measures to avoid having to take on such costs before it these actions become obligatory. (A. Wood, personal communication, July 31, 2013). 4.3 Increasing Wealth and Sustainable Food
  • 8.         Industrialized and developing countries differ in the amount of energy used, carbon emissions emitted and other environmental impacts of household consumption of different categories. In most industrialized countries, the impact of household consumption is higher than that of government consumption and their investment in infrastructure and capital goods. Hertwich, E., et. al. 2010). Additionally, researchers calculated an overall elasticity of carbon dioxide of 0.81, meaning when income doubles, 81% more carbon dioxide is emitted globally. (Hertwich, E., et. al, 2010). Thus, as HK’s GDP per capita increases, certain changes in consumption behaviour occur including the consumption of meat and luxury items. 4.3.1 Meat Average food consumption per person in Hong Kong grew 52% from 1971 to 1997. (Adamo, B., Foley, M., Graef, J., Stone, K., 2002). Out of the entire East Asia region, HK has the most westernized diet, characterized by “larger portions and higher protein and fat intake” (Adamo, B., et. al., 2002), especially from beef and seafood that is often produced unsustainably. As Hong Kong grows wealthier, people start to eat more meat (Yang, S.P., 2008). HK has one of the highest beef consumption per capita rates in the world. (Yang, S.P., 2008). In terms of consumption, beef is much less energy efficient, taking about 40 calories of fossil fuel energy to make one calorie worth of beef compared to the 2.2 calories used per plant-based protein. (Gidon E., Martin, P. A., 2005). In terms of transportation, although the more
  • 9.         energy-efficient railway transports 77% of the imported meat for HK consumption, the long refrigeration of meat burns more fossil fuel. (Yang, S.P., 2008). Most of the environmental costs come from the production stage, where producing one kilogram of beef emits 36 kilos of CO2-e. (WWF-Hong Kong). However by eating one meatless meal a week, 213 kg of carbon – or 86,000 cars – can be saved. (Green Monday, 2013). 4.3.2 Dietary Patterns and Shift to Exotic Tastes As wealth increased, more HK people started to consume more “luxurious” types of foods from far-away countries. (Yang, S.P., 2008). As traditional Chinese believe that animals such as snakes and some protected animals are high in nutrition and have healing functions, many Cantonese import these rare products from the Guangdong province, decreasing biodiversity. (Qifeng, Z., Gan., J., Xun., L., 2012). HK supermarkets also unsustainably import a variety of out-of-season fruits and vegetables from overseas to sell them at a higher price, which increases food miles. (Yang, S.P., 2008). These shifts towards more extravagant foods are proof of unsustainable consumption behavior caused by not only cultural and economic factors but also by corporate marketing efforts, appealing to people’s desire for status and superior quality. Changing consumption patterns would require a change in consumer perception and values of food. (Moomaw, W., Griffin, T., Kurczak, K., Lomax, J., 2012). 4.4 Consumers and Corporate Engagement
  • 10.         Aside from the economic trends mentioned, lack consumer and corporate understanding and participation in this issue are also a key reason for the current state of affairs. 4.4.1 Low Consumer Awareness and Perception Despite increasing awareness on this issue, based on studies of HK’s food consumption patterns, people are not changing their consumption behaviour. (Yang, S.P., 2008). As quoted from my supervisor, “waste is a big thing in HK but people are not particularly aware”. This is because of the lack of knowledge and “remoteness between producers and consumers” (Yang, S.P., 2008). Studies have shown that improving the links between producer and consumer can encourage consumers to change their behavior. An example is having more local farmer’s markets or community supported schemes, which has been successful in western countries. (Yang, S.P., 2008). People are not only under-exposed to the matter, they also participate little in programs. In HK, people think CR activities should be “fun” and less focused on how “we should help the community” (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013). During the internship, even though we sent out information on the NGO and our service targets to participants, often times the volunteers were still not knowledgeable of the target of our activity. Extra measures should be taken to involve the thousands of company employees in CSR planning and activities.
  • 11.         4.4.2 Low Corporate Responsibility Involvement According to Walker, Welford and Kwok, companies in HK do not contribute much to society either in cash or non-cash forms. (2008). Businesses are not doing enough in “product design, life cycle and consumer communication strategies” in regards to sustainability and disconnects CSR from its profit-making activities. (Walker, Welford, Kwok, 2008). Based on their survey, businesses as well as SMEs view CSR as “expensive and not central to profit-oriented strategy” (Walker, R. M., Welford, R.J., Kwok, W.W.C., 2008). Therefore, unless it is to comply with regulations or is demanded by consumers, companies are unlikely to work towards change in any environmental issue. (Walker, R. M., et. al., 2008) Conversely, based on my internship research, many companies, especially larger ones, are beginning to adopt CSR goals into their core businesses although still imperfect. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013). Because of the nascent stages, the initiatives are often ad hoc, project-based, and loosely tied to their company mission and goals. The companies usually rely on three tools when engaging with the outside world: a CR team based in company headquarters, a few “high-profile (but relatively cheap) initiatives”, and an annual report to highlight the progress of these initiatives. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013). Because of this narrow approach, businesses often run on the “whim of senior executives” rather than the impact and are thus “short-lived”. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013).
  • 12.         Most Asian companies are more disconnected from NGOs than companies overseas, which is why communication between corporations and stakeholders is still disorganized. (Williams, G., 2011). This is partly a cultural issue, as HK’s hierarchical social structure often prevents organization representatives from reaching others directly or speaking straightforwardly. This was supported by a statement in the McKinsey article that stated how NGOs want businesses to do more on “external aspects” including “communication and cooperation with other parties, management of supply chains, adherence to international standards” (Walker, R.M, et. al., 2008). Although HK is one of Asia’s innovation hubs, having ranked 4th in INSEAD’s Global Innovation Index 2011, several experts have stated a different view, saying Hong Kong’s innovation is still “immature” since only 1% of the city’s GDP is invested in technological innovation (2011; Perez, B., 2013). Therefore, corporations should carry out and support more innovation to discover new and improved products, services, environmental technology or processes, to fill gaps in the food system. There is growing development in innovation amongst social enterprises (SE) however. Green Monday, a new, local SE that promotes green eating, is the first to target the issue of sustainable food consumption. (Green Monday, 2013). However, many small SEs still struggle as most social workers managing the SEs have limited business acumen and training, thus examples
  • 13.         of SEs with both social and economic success is difficult to find. (Yuen, T., Lee, J., 2004). V. DISCUSSION 5.1 Recommendations for CSR Improvements With knowledge on the drivers of this unsustainable food system and the gaps of CSR strategy in Hong Kong, corporations can be more efficient in reducing environmental costs of unsustainable consumption by adopting both internally and externally-oriented changes. To help resolve the food sustainability issue, companies must communicate and cooperate with other stakeholders. 5.1.1 Communication with Employees To raise awareness and participation of people’s consumption behavior, companies should communicate more internally about the importance of the issue. HK has a large banking sector, employing 80,000 people in 2008, so the reach of the message is broader. (Williams, G., 2011). Companies have increased their efforts in skilled-volunteering, as the proportion of companies with formal employee volunteer programs has risen to 94% in 2009 from 84%. (Williams, G., 2011). In order to improve on these programs and create a larger impact, the company CSR team needs to involve “big-spending functions” like production or marketing. Although the norm for companies now is to avoid high costs for CSR, the CSR team must engage all internal
  • 14.         stakeholders in order move people to change their consumption patterns, within and outside of the office. (Browne, J., Nuttall, R., 2013). There are various tools companies could use to encourage sustainable behavior or increase volunteering such as giving cash bonuses. A way to raise awareness would be through internal “green marketing”. We adopted this technique to encourage colleagues in PwC HK to join the green-eating workshop we organized via the company’s internal social media site, internal email. Our marketing strategy was to showcase the impact that the event will have on the target group while educating employees on low-carbon living. For other events, PwC’s CR team also writes CR excerpts that highlight key CR projects in weekly and monthly newsletters, TV screens throughout the office and computer pop-up notifications. By making the problem more “visible” to present in their surroundings, employees can be more aware of the sustainable consumption issue and become more conscious of their consumption choices. When people feel that the problem is more related to their lives, such as to their individual health, the bigger the chance their behaviours will change and be imitated by cohorts. (Williams, G., 2011). 5.1.2 Communication with NGOs Because findings have shown ineffective communication between corporates and external stakeholders, corporations should develop more efficient communication networks amongst those dealing with the issue. CSR teams contact NGOs frequently; however, there are expected challenges in
  • 15.         aligning both sides’ missions and expectations whilst forming any kind of partnership. (A. Wood, personal communication, August 1, 2013). This was the case between PwC HK and WWF. While PwC was looking towards making tangible environmental changes, WWF’s approach leaned towards attracting extensive media attention for PwC’s CR. Also, although PwC wished to engage more in skilled volunteering and provide their environmental services such as sustainability accounting services to community partners, WWF did not need their services; therefore again, there was misalignment between the partners. (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013). Thus, companies must clearly lay out their objectives, needs, and services to the community partners so as to be able to discuss more effective ways that the company can contribute. There are setbacks to communicating across all sectors, one of which is culture. As previously mentioned, HK organizations are more hierarchical than that of Australia, which makes communication less efficient. Moreover, people in Australia are more communicative in general compared to people in HK, which is reflected in the company culture. These are issues that companies have to take into account before establishing communication systems in order to encourage more cross-sector collaboration. 5.1.2 Communication within the Private Sector Multinational corporations (MNC) are closely connected throughout the supply chain; therefore they have significant influence each other’s actions.
  • 16.         In one of my CSR courses, I learned about the “Walmart Effect” which describes the ripple effect MNCs have on the community. As leaders, MNCs should utilize their influence by communicating their environmental concerns and needs to partners such as requesting the use of locally grown, organic produce or green catering for events. By taking assertive action, other market leaders will be forced respond with other sustainable actions in order to compete. Companies should also include supplier conduct into the company’s purchasing policies while monitoring and verifying the suppliers’ compliance to these policies. (CSR Asia, Oxfam, 2008). Since many of the companies in HK are working with suppliers from China, HK companies can ensure stricter food safety policies and encourage more transparency in order to reduce the number of health incidences, progressively improve consumer confidence in Chinese goods, and thus be able to import more foods from China rather than from faraway countries. Since policy plays a large part in improving the sustainability of the food system, it would be beneficial if companies could work more closely with the government on the issue. Environmental politics started evolving rapidly since the 1980s and government-business relations have shifted from “cooperation to accommodation” or even to confrontation in certain industries contributing to climate change. (Lee, H., 2004). Some officials have felt that corporations’ approach with the government has been “reactive, conservative and behind-the-scenes” (Loh, C., 2004), which suggest that companies should
  • 17.         invest in being more involved political planning. In the long run, it will be “in the interest of businesses to help customers adopt to sustainable lifestyles and behaviour” (Williams, G., 2011); thus, by taking the initiative to speak with the government on making the supply chain more sustainable and delineating why fulfilling certain business needs would benefit society as a whole, the company can create a win-win situation for all. (Loh, C., 2004). In all, because the issue of food sustainability requires complex infrastructure and special knowledge, all stakeholders should be knowledgeable on the happenings within the network so as to not have too many overlapping projects and be more efficient in filling the gaps. 5.1.2 Strategic CSR CSR in Asia is developing quickly, however management of CSR activities is often “unstructured or piecemeal” (Williams, G., 2011). The CSR strategy is meant to give focus to the ventures and partners the company chooses to get involved with based on its resources, core business, environmental mission and objectives. These were the factors I had to take into account when selecting compatible long-term NGO partners for PwC. Companies should be clear on the business value of CR and how it ties into the core business when forming a strategy (D. Johnson, personal communication, August 1, 2013). When CR is just considered as “an add-on”, companies pursue more low-cost, project-based initiatives to take on such as
  • 18.         one-time employee volunteering activities or community event sponsorships. (Williams, G., 2011). Whatever the focus is, the company should aim to create long-term, sustainable relationships and impact. For example, CLP Power Hong Kong Limited, an energy company, runs a very successful skilled- volunteering program called “Rewiring for the Elderly” where CLP’s engineers help low-income, single elderly living to “conduct rewiring, electricity safety inspections and maintenance of electrical appliances service” (CLP, 2010). The project is voluntarily continued by engineers in the company and has been running steadily for many years. The success of the project lies in its leveraging of engineering expertise of the employees, its long-term commitment to the cause and the alignment of the project’s objectives with that of the company’s overall. 5.1.3 Innovation The process of shaping a sustainable food production and consumption system is highly technical. Thus, society would significantly benefit from further innovation all along the supply chain focusing on creating sustainable food. No matter in which stage or of what function of the process that the business chooses to innovate, companies should be responsible of taking into account of the product or service’s entire life cycle even after consumption. For example, in 2012, Starbucks Hong Kong invested in a study that developed biorefinery technology that could convert food waste into plastic
  • 19.         used in certain products. (Bladon, A., 2012). If the pilot plant is successful, long supply chains and transportation can be reduced. VI.CONCLUSION In conclusion, the overarching driver of the issue of unsustainable food is globalization, which includes the increase in trade, an increase in wealth and the lack of stakeholder engagement. To maximize impact, businesses should not only consume and produce sustainably but also increase stakeholder dialogue and form long-term, high-engagement partnerships to create long- lasting impact, develop a overarching CSR strategy that clearly defines the company’s CSR objectives and leverages on the resources that company has, and to innovate or support innovation in environmental sustainability. However, with limited studies on these topics that are written from an Asian perspective, more research on best practices for HK companies when targeting environmental systems is needed. The key to sustainable food in HK is changing consumption patterns and behaviour; therefore, corporations must collaborate with all stakeholders to create a sustainable future. (Word count: 3993) VII. REFERENCES Adamo, B., Foley, M., Graef, J., Stone, K. (2002). A consumption analysis of Hong Kong and Guangzhou. Retrieved July 2, 2013 from http://www.civic- exchange.org/eng/upload/files/Report__Consumption_Analysis_of_HK_ and_Guangdong.pdf Bladon, A. (2012). Starbucks Hong Kong Turns Food Waste into Bioplastic.
  • 20.         This big city. Retrieved http://thisbigcity.net/starbucks-hong-kong-turns- food-waste-into-bioplastic/ Browne, J., Nutall, R. (2013). Beyond corporate social responsibility: Integrated external engagement. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/strategy/beyond_corporate_social_re sponsibility_integrated_external_engagement Cambridge (2013). Corporate social responsibility. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.cambridge.org.br/cambridge-brazil/social- responsibility/corporate-social-responsibility CLP. (2010). Volunteering. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from https://www.clp.com.hk/ourvalues/social/community/volunteering/Pages /volunteering.aspx CSR Asia, Oxfam. (2008). Corporate social responsibility survey of Hang Seng Index Constituent Companies 2011. Hong Kong: Oxfam. Environmental impact of the UK food economy with particular reference to WWF priority places and the North-east Atlantic. (2008). Retrieved July 10, 2013 from http://assets.wwf.org.uk/downloads/environmentalimpacts_ukfoodconsu mption.pdf Feeding Hong Kong. (n.d.). Food waste in HK. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://feedinghk.org/food-waste-in-hk/ Gidon E., Martin, P. A. (2005). Diet, Energy, and Global Warming. Earth interactions. 10(9), p. 1-14. Retrieved July 4, 2-13 from http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/pdf/10.1175/EI167.1 Green Monday. (2013). Environmental impact. Retrieved July 2, 2013 from http://www.greenmonday.org.hk/impact.php Guide Me Hong Kong. (2011). Hong Kong, one of the world’s most innovative economies. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.guidemehongkong.com/story/doing-business/hong-kong- one-of-the-worlds-most-innovative-economies Hertwich, E., van der Voet, E., Suh, S., Tukker, A., Huijbregts M., Kazmierczyk, P., Lenzen, M., McNeely, J., Moriguchi, Y. (2010) Assessing the environmental impacts of consumption and production:
  • 21.         Priority products and materials. A report of the working group on the environmental impacts of products and materials to the International Panel for Sustainable Resource Management. Retrieved July 2, 2013 from http://www.unep.org/resourcepanel/Portals/24102/ PDFs/PriorityProductsAndMaterials_Report.pdf Hong Kong: The facts. (2013, January). Agriculture and fisheries. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.gov.hk/en/about/abouthk/factsheets/docs/agriculture.pdf World Bank. (2011). Hong Kong-SAR, China. Retrieved July 16, 2013 from http://search.worldbank.org/data?qterm=Hong+kong+population&langu age=EN&format= Lam, Y. (2012). Partnership for sustainable waste management: a case study of the food waste recycling partnership scheme in Hong Kong. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://hdl.handle.net/10722/180093 Lee, H. (2004). Environmental politics in Hong Kong: Dynamic of government-business relations in air quality management. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://repository.lib.polyu.edu.hk/jspui/handle/10397/2234 Loh, C. (2004). Government and Business Alliance: Hong Kong’s Functional Constituencies. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.civic- exchange.org/eng/upload/files/200408_GovBusinessAlliance.pdf Moomaw, W., Griffin, T., Kurczak, K., Lomax, J. (2012). The critical role of global food consumption patterns in achieving sustainable food systems and food for all: A UNEP discussion paper. United Nations Environment Programme, Division of Technology, Industry and Economics, Paris, France. Mu, X. (2009). China investigates 76,500 fake food cases in 2008. China view. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009- 03/16/content_11016531.htm Perez, B. (2013, August 8). Business group calls for creation of innovation and technology bureau. The South China Morning Post. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.scmp.com/business/economy/article/1295144/business- group-calls-creation-innovation-and-technology-bureau?login=1
  • 22.         Qifeng, Z., Gan., J., Xun., L. (2012). Eating habits in South China driving endangered animals to extinction. Chinadialogue. Retrieved August, 1, 2013 from http://www.chinadialogue.net/article/show/single/ch/5506- Eating-habits-in-south-China-driving-endangered-animals-to-extinction- UNEP. (2013). Food waste facts. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://www.unep.org/wed/quickfacts/ Walker, R.M., Welford, R., J., Kwok, W.W. (2008). Corporate social responsibility in Hong Kong: Perceptions from business, government, and NGOs. Hong Kong: HKU. Williams, G. (2011). Responsible management in Asia: Perspectives on CSR. London, United Kingdom: Palgrave Macmillan. World Bank. (2013). World Development Indicators 2013. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://databank.worldbank.org/data/download/GDP.pdf WWF-Hong Kong. (2011). Hong Kong ecological footprint report 2010: Paths to a sustainable future. Retrieved July 5, 2013 from http://awsassets.wwfhk.panda. org/downloads/hong_kong_ecological_footprint_report_2010.pdf Yang, S.P. (2008). Food miles: a case of sustainability consumption In Hong Kong. Retrieved August 1, 2013 from http://hdl.handle.net/10722/54624 Yuen, T., Lee, J. (2004). Social Entrepreneurship in Hong Kong: Perspectives, Trends and Prospects. Retrieved August, 1, 2013 from web.hku.hk/~ccsg/HKSE1