An evening with TIM
Date – Friday, 23rd Oct 2020
Time – 7:30 PM
Human Resource Professionals Society (HRPS)
presents –
2
3
Why Pay ?
Factors Determining Pay
The Pay Mix
What about Motivation ?
Executive Compensation
4
a ring side view
5
What is equity ?
A company of 100 employees and a wage bill of $10 million. Each
gets $100,000 as pay
Components of Pay
Which components make up Total Rewards and based on which
factors are these components determined?
What about Motivation?
Under which conditions does money impact motivation for
performance?
6
Distributive Equity – What
one gets compared to his/her
peers
Procedural Equity – The
rational behind what is paid.
Fairness is key.
A
B
Reward
Performance
7
Responsibility Strategic Position Performance
Qualification Market Company Success
Cost of Living Civil Status Tenure
8
9
Total
Rewards
Total
Compensation
Base Pay
Salary
Wages
Variable Pay
Individual /
Group
Piece Rate
One Time
Bonus
Target
Bonus
Organisation
Profit
Sharing
Stock
Ownership
Stock
Options
Benefits
Insurance
Pension
Services
Non –
Financial
Rewards
Appreciation
Contacts
Privileges
Titles
10
Job Analysis
Job
Evaluation
Pay Survey
Pay Structure
Individual Pay
Implementation
Communication
Monitoring
Pay Policies
Job
Appointment
11
12
Functional Expertise 8 > 6
Knowledge Managerial Skills 5 > 4
Human Relations 5 > 4
Environment 7 > 6
Problem Solving
Challenges 7 > 6
Freedom to Act 8 > 7
Accountability
Impact on End Result 9 > 8
Compensable Factors Benchmark Scores
13
180
430
680
930
1180
1430
1680
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Relative worth of Job
Com.1 Com.2 Com.3 Com.4
Com.5 Com.6 Com.7 Com.8
Com.9 Com.10 Com.11 Linear (Com.11)
MarketPay(Avg.SalaryintheMkt).
Benchmark Jobs / Job Value
14
Jobs Com.1 Com.2 Com.3 Com.4 Com.5 Com.6 Com.7 Com.8 Com.9 Com.10 Com.11 P10 P25 P50 P66 P75 P90
J1 407 374 339 358 337 311 333 307 363 372 311 311 322 339 361 368 374
J2 565 460 421 533 416 434 566 495 567 483 489 421 447 489 518 549 566
J3 590 601 581 579 568 532 538 534 587 548 581 534 543 579 581 584 590
J4 739 764 652 784 668 638 647 658 708 615 636 636 643 658 692 724 764
J5 737 740 722 743 706 754 724 776 743 800 743 722 731 743 743 749 776
J6 968 872 803 853 741 870 842 893 957 904 961 803 848 872 900 931 961
J7 886 933 885 969 899 965 995 934 962 915 928 886 907 933 951 964 969
J8 970 1,035 1,111 1,053 1,003 1,003 1,081 983 970 1,052 931 970 977 1,003 1,045 1,053 1,081
J9 1,116 1,189 1,204 1,146 1,152 1,108 1,177 1,160 1,164 1,198 1,157 1,116 1,149 1,160 1,172 1,183 1,198
J10 1,257 1,193 1,256 1,248 1,297 1,211 1,247 1,204 1,232 1,214 1,201 1,201 1,208 1,232 1,248 1,252 1,257
J11 1,414 1,328 1,377 1,403 1,386 1,320 1,392 1,381 1,350 1,398 1,370 1,328 1,360 1,381 1,390 1,395 1,403
J12 1,483 1,467 1,393 1,486 1,421 1,473 1,461 1,495 1,460 1,443 1,473 1,421 1,452 1,467 1,473 1,478 1,486
J13 1,585 1,638 1,595 1,423 1,527 1,678 1,571 1,641 1,648 1,400 1,418 1,418 1,475 1,585 1,621 1,640 1,648
Salary Range
What does it helps in –
a) Identify the market positioning
b) Distance from a determined percentile point
c) Create pay bands
d) Make meaningful hiring and promotion decisions
15
1
2
3
4
5
A
B
JobGradebasedonJobValue
PAY Rate
16
The kickers & dampeners
17
150
100
80
60
60 80 100 150
A
B
Target Bonus %
Piece Rate Pay Program
Target Based System –
a) Employee and Supervisor agree on both individual target and relation between
target achievement and target bonus
b) Employee can choose from different options reflecting different risk performance
c) Primarily used for managers and senior management employees
18
The role Compensation Philosophy
19
Author and motivational expert, Daniel Pink at TEDGlobal 2009 explained the “Puzzle of Motivation”
Through the following illustrative experiment.
20
What do we need to decide ?
• How different should the reward program be to meet the need
of different groups
segmentation
• What is the purpose of each reward vehicle (e.g. base salary,
incentives, benefits, etc.
Role of each element
• What is the competitive labor market for talent
Comparator group(s)
• Where should pay be positioned to the market?
Competitive positioning
• How should rewards aligned to individual and/or organizational
performance
Performance orientation
• What is the importance of the relative internal value of work
Internal equity
• Who makes decisions regarding rewards; management
responsibility?
Governance
• How and with whom rewards information be shared?
communication
• How will you administer programs and ensure regulatory
compliances?
Administration
21
Inappropriate jobs:
“I talk to the customers. That’s
selling.”
“I sit near a sales person and help
them in releasing invoices.”
“I am in touch with clients regularly
and take feedback on services.”
Establishing clear eligibility
criteria such as:
Customer facing
Impacts the customer by
persuading them to buy
Responsible for a sales target as a
primary goal
Document and communicate
both the…
What?
Why?
22
How much should be at Risk ?
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Minimal to none
Performance reminder
Directional
Highly Directional
Independent action
23
The C suite
24
Salary
Short term incentives (STI)
Long term incentives (LTI)
Guaranteed Severance Package
Perquisites – like club
memberships, private planes
Insurance – health insurance for
self and dependents
25
Incentive Plan Stretch –
a) Threshold in incentive plan should be achievable in 85% of the time
b) Target should be achievable in 50 – 60% of the time
c) Max about 15 – 20% of the time
Viewing Ex-Compensation through the Compensation Committee’s lens –
a) Internal Absolute Lens – Performance related to the operating plan or budget
b) Internal Relative Lens – Look at the performance of last 5 years. How is the target achievement
c) External Relative Lens – Mapping with the industry growth standards and projections
d) External Absolute Lens – Meeting market expectation
26
Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
TSR = Current Price - Purchase Price + Dividend
Purchase Price
Incentive Matrix –
a) Revenue
b) Operating Expenditure
c) Profitability
d) Efficient use of capita (Return on Investor Capital)
27
The exponential rise of CEO Compensation –
a) The rise is attributed to the incentive components
b) Linkage to equity based compensation
c) In the 80’s CEO compensation was 1.5 time higher. It
zoomed to 3 times in 2000’s
d) Pay inequality by size of organisation
The ethical dilemma –
a) The rise in CEO compensation; is it driven by powerful
CEOs
b) Are the shareholders happy to pay for more ROCE
28
Eat, drink and be merry. For
tomorrow you may diet !!!
Araktim@gmail.com
+91 9811, 757, 697

Decoding Total Rewards

  • 1.
    An evening withTIM Date – Friday, 23rd Oct 2020 Time – 7:30 PM Human Resource Professionals Society (HRPS) presents –
  • 2.
  • 3.
    3 Why Pay ? FactorsDetermining Pay The Pay Mix What about Motivation ? Executive Compensation
  • 4.
  • 5.
    5 What is equity? A company of 100 employees and a wage bill of $10 million. Each gets $100,000 as pay Components of Pay Which components make up Total Rewards and based on which factors are these components determined? What about Motivation? Under which conditions does money impact motivation for performance?
  • 6.
    6 Distributive Equity –What one gets compared to his/her peers Procedural Equity – The rational behind what is paid. Fairness is key. A B Reward Performance
  • 7.
    7 Responsibility Strategic PositionPerformance Qualification Market Company Success Cost of Living Civil Status Tenure
  • 8.
  • 9.
    9 Total Rewards Total Compensation Base Pay Salary Wages Variable Pay Individual/ Group Piece Rate One Time Bonus Target Bonus Organisation Profit Sharing Stock Ownership Stock Options Benefits Insurance Pension Services Non – Financial Rewards Appreciation Contacts Privileges Titles
  • 10.
    10 Job Analysis Job Evaluation Pay Survey PayStructure Individual Pay Implementation Communication Monitoring Pay Policies Job Appointment
  • 11.
  • 12.
    12 Functional Expertise 8> 6 Knowledge Managerial Skills 5 > 4 Human Relations 5 > 4 Environment 7 > 6 Problem Solving Challenges 7 > 6 Freedom to Act 8 > 7 Accountability Impact on End Result 9 > 8 Compensable Factors Benchmark Scores
  • 13.
    13 180 430 680 930 1180 1430 1680 0 1 23 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Relative worth of Job Com.1 Com.2 Com.3 Com.4 Com.5 Com.6 Com.7 Com.8 Com.9 Com.10 Com.11 Linear (Com.11) MarketPay(Avg.SalaryintheMkt). Benchmark Jobs / Job Value
  • 14.
    14 Jobs Com.1 Com.2Com.3 Com.4 Com.5 Com.6 Com.7 Com.8 Com.9 Com.10 Com.11 P10 P25 P50 P66 P75 P90 J1 407 374 339 358 337 311 333 307 363 372 311 311 322 339 361 368 374 J2 565 460 421 533 416 434 566 495 567 483 489 421 447 489 518 549 566 J3 590 601 581 579 568 532 538 534 587 548 581 534 543 579 581 584 590 J4 739 764 652 784 668 638 647 658 708 615 636 636 643 658 692 724 764 J5 737 740 722 743 706 754 724 776 743 800 743 722 731 743 743 749 776 J6 968 872 803 853 741 870 842 893 957 904 961 803 848 872 900 931 961 J7 886 933 885 969 899 965 995 934 962 915 928 886 907 933 951 964 969 J8 970 1,035 1,111 1,053 1,003 1,003 1,081 983 970 1,052 931 970 977 1,003 1,045 1,053 1,081 J9 1,116 1,189 1,204 1,146 1,152 1,108 1,177 1,160 1,164 1,198 1,157 1,116 1,149 1,160 1,172 1,183 1,198 J10 1,257 1,193 1,256 1,248 1,297 1,211 1,247 1,204 1,232 1,214 1,201 1,201 1,208 1,232 1,248 1,252 1,257 J11 1,414 1,328 1,377 1,403 1,386 1,320 1,392 1,381 1,350 1,398 1,370 1,328 1,360 1,381 1,390 1,395 1,403 J12 1,483 1,467 1,393 1,486 1,421 1,473 1,461 1,495 1,460 1,443 1,473 1,421 1,452 1,467 1,473 1,478 1,486 J13 1,585 1,638 1,595 1,423 1,527 1,678 1,571 1,641 1,648 1,400 1,418 1,418 1,475 1,585 1,621 1,640 1,648 Salary Range What does it helps in – a) Identify the market positioning b) Distance from a determined percentile point c) Create pay bands d) Make meaningful hiring and promotion decisions
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    17 150 100 80 60 60 80 100150 A B Target Bonus % Piece Rate Pay Program Target Based System – a) Employee and Supervisor agree on both individual target and relation between target achievement and target bonus b) Employee can choose from different options reflecting different risk performance c) Primarily used for managers and senior management employees
  • 18.
  • 19.
    19 Author and motivationalexpert, Daniel Pink at TEDGlobal 2009 explained the “Puzzle of Motivation” Through the following illustrative experiment.
  • 20.
    20 What do weneed to decide ? • How different should the reward program be to meet the need of different groups segmentation • What is the purpose of each reward vehicle (e.g. base salary, incentives, benefits, etc. Role of each element • What is the competitive labor market for talent Comparator group(s) • Where should pay be positioned to the market? Competitive positioning • How should rewards aligned to individual and/or organizational performance Performance orientation • What is the importance of the relative internal value of work Internal equity • Who makes decisions regarding rewards; management responsibility? Governance • How and with whom rewards information be shared? communication • How will you administer programs and ensure regulatory compliances? Administration
  • 21.
    21 Inappropriate jobs: “I talkto the customers. That’s selling.” “I sit near a sales person and help them in releasing invoices.” “I am in touch with clients regularly and take feedback on services.” Establishing clear eligibility criteria such as: Customer facing Impacts the customer by persuading them to buy Responsible for a sales target as a primary goal Document and communicate both the… What? Why?
  • 22.
    22 How much shouldbe at Risk ? 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Minimal to none Performance reminder Directional Highly Directional Independent action
  • 23.
  • 24.
    24 Salary Short term incentives(STI) Long term incentives (LTI) Guaranteed Severance Package Perquisites – like club memberships, private planes Insurance – health insurance for self and dependents
  • 25.
    25 Incentive Plan Stretch– a) Threshold in incentive plan should be achievable in 85% of the time b) Target should be achievable in 50 – 60% of the time c) Max about 15 – 20% of the time Viewing Ex-Compensation through the Compensation Committee’s lens – a) Internal Absolute Lens – Performance related to the operating plan or budget b) Internal Relative Lens – Look at the performance of last 5 years. How is the target achievement c) External Relative Lens – Mapping with the industry growth standards and projections d) External Absolute Lens – Meeting market expectation
  • 26.
    26 Total Shareholder Return(TSR) TSR = Current Price - Purchase Price + Dividend Purchase Price Incentive Matrix – a) Revenue b) Operating Expenditure c) Profitability d) Efficient use of capita (Return on Investor Capital)
  • 27.
    27 The exponential riseof CEO Compensation – a) The rise is attributed to the incentive components b) Linkage to equity based compensation c) In the 80’s CEO compensation was 1.5 time higher. It zoomed to 3 times in 2000’s d) Pay inequality by size of organisation The ethical dilemma – a) The rise in CEO compensation; is it driven by powerful CEOs b) Are the shareholders happy to pay for more ROCE
  • 28.
    28 Eat, drink andbe merry. For tomorrow you may diet !!!
  • 29.