SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Classes 19-22       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




Using CSS to Develop Compatible
       Supportive Designs



                1
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Goal: Excellence               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Excellent transportation design
• Satisfies stakeholder purpose, needs, and vision
   – Established early
   – Refined as process advances
• Safe for users and community
• Harmonious with community
• Supports other community objectives
• Preserves environmental values and resources



                           2
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                    Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


    Project development process
    • Determine context
      – Existing conditions
         •Physical
             – Roadway, transitway, pathway
             – Roadside, streetside, wayside
             – Adjacent development
                 » Context zones
                 » Land use site design
                 » External factors
         •Activity
             – Transportation facility
             – Roadside, streetside, wayside
             – Adjacent land, buildings
                                3
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Project development process (cont.)
• Determine context (cont.)
  – Environment (relevant)
     • Physical
     • Social
  – Planed changes
  – External factors
                             CS3 – context sensitive sustainable
                             solutions (Oregon DOT version)




                                      4
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Project development process (cont.)
• Identify issues, opportunities, constraints, threats,
  strengths, weaknesses
   – Issues – concerns, problems, questions, uncertainties
   – Opportunities – what could occur (physical, operational,
     policy, transportation, development, economic, etc.)
   – Constraints – limitations on opportunities
   – Threats – negative factors or prospects
   – Strengths – positive attributes on which to build
   – Weaknesses – shortcomings to strengthen


                               5
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Project development process (cont.)
• Identfy goals, objectives, core values
   – Desired outcomes                  – Core values
      •Goals (general statements)                       •Aesthetics
         –   Mobility and access                        •Safety
         –   Economic development
                                                        •Character
         –   Land development
         –   Activity
                                                        •Etc.
         –   Other
      •Objectives
         – More detailed statements



                                    6
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Project development process (cont.)
• Select criteria for evaluation, prioritization
   – Base on
      •Objectives                     •Mobility
      •Issues                         •Socio-econimic
      •Opportunities                  •Environmental
      •Concerns                       •Cost-effectiveness
      •Environmental impacts          •Other




                               7
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Process (Review)                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Project development process (cont.)
• Vision
  – Outcome from goals
     •Functional
     •Appearance
     •Resulting conditions




                             8
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Develop alternatives
• Range
• Design criteria
• Approach
• Flexibility
• Components




                       9
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

   Develop alternatives
   • Range in magnitude
      – “No build”
          •May include improvements elsewhere in system
     – Operational (TSM) improvements
     – Minor
     – Full “build”
   • Range in type
     –   Modal
     –   Alignment
     –   Type of facility
     –   Extent of improvement
     –   Relationship with adjacent development
                             10
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Project Development                           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Develop alternatives
• Design criteria
   –   AASHTO green book (using flexibility)
   –   AASHTO, FHWA Flexibility in Highway Design
   –   State DOT design manual
   –   City/county public works design manual
   –   Local agency guidelines (incl. zoning overlays)
   –   Modal guidelines (ITE CSS for walkable
       communities)
        • Ped – AASHTO ped guide
        • Bike – AASHTO bike facilities guide
        • Bus – TCRP 19, 33, 117       (pending
                                       TCRP D-09
        • Rail – TCRP 17, 69           guide)
   – Landscaping
                                          11
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development         Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Develop alternatives




                       12
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Develop alternatives
• Components
  –   Traveled way                          – Design each
                                            – Adapt per activity
  –   Streetside, roadside, wayside
                                            – Enhance each to work
  –   Land uses                               together
  –   Sense of place
       • Urban design
       • Parks
       • Historic features
       • Social fabric
       • Arts and activity




                                13
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Decision-Making Context                                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



                            Caltrain improvements – S.F. peninsula line


                                                TRANSIT                      THE
               BUILT ENVIRONMENT                                                                  HSR
                                                SERVICES                   PROJECT

                                                                            Alignment           Alignment
    WHAT       Land Use                           Services                   Vehicles
                           Circulation                                                           Vehicles
                 TOD                              Vehicles                  Operations
  DECISIONS?                                    Connectivity
                                                                                                Operations
                                                                             Stations            Stations
                                                                             Services            Services

     WHO            City Councils              Transit Agency         JPB/CHSRA Boards
   DECIDES?      Board of Supervisors                                  Federal agencies        CHSRA Board
                                                   Boards
                                                                       Elected officials     Federal agencies
                                                                             PRP             Elected officials

                                                                            Customers           Customers
                                                  Customers
                                                                            Facilitate           consider
  COMMUNITY                                      Incorporate               community         community input
                 Direct engagement
  INFLUENCE                                      community                 engagement          in decisions
                                                  input into
                                                   decisions               Regional/state       Statewide
                                                                          accountabilility    accountability
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Evaluate
• One measure per objective or issue
   – Quantifiable (with available data)
   – Sensitive to changes in performance
• Can be categorical or ratio
• Need quantification methodology
• Can work within Delphi process




                                15
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



  Evaluate – Option: Delphi process
  • Combines performance and importance
  • One measure per criterion
     – Objective
     – Issue
  • Quantified in ratio scale
  • Criteria weighted per stakeholder input
     – Initial
     – Again after interim results



                          16
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



• Delphi example
(or other evaluation table)




                        17
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Project Development                     Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Evaluation
• Converge by narrowing, refining alternatives
   1.   Distinct ranging alternatives
                                                                     Cycle
   2. Workable more detailed alternatives                            1.Formulate/
                                                                      refine
                                                                     2.Evaluate
   3. (optional) Variations on final alternative(s)                  3.Discuss
                                                              EIS
                                                                     4.Narrow
   4. Preferred alternative

   5. Develop preliminary design



                                 18
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Communities want
• Flexibility
• Compatibility with adjacent land uses
• Balanced land use/transportation functions
• Safe and attractive streets
• Multimodal facilities
• Streets that are quality public space

                          19
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
FDOT TDLC Roads*                                      Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

*Transportation design for livable communities


Examples of flexible DOT design criteria
Minimum lane widths




                                                 20
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
FDOT TDLC roads          Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




Techniques to
support non-drive
modes




                    21
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


 Tenets of CSS
 • Balance
    – Safety
    – Mobility
    – Community objectives
    – Environment
 • Multimodal
 • Involve public, stakeholders
 • Interdisciplinary teams
 • Flexibility in design
 • Incorporate aesthetics 22
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Placemaking
• Community-based approach to the development and
  revitalization of cities and neighborhoods
• Placemaking:
   –   Unique places with lasting value
   –   Compact, mixed-use
   –   Pedestrian and transit oriented
   –   Strong civic character
   –   Contributes to economic development




                                    23
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


ITE framework
• Context zones:
  – Suburbs to downtowns
• Street classification:
  – Functional class
  – Thoroughfare type
     •Boulevard
     •Avenue
     •Street
• Compatibility

                           24
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                                             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


 Context Zones – An Organizing System for
 Thoroughfare Design




 Graphic source: Duany Plater-Zyberk and Company
 Source: Duany Plater-Zyberk and Company


  Source: Context Sensitive Solutions in Designing Major Urban Thoroughfares for Walkable Communities
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                          Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




Features that create context
• Land use
   – Defines urban activity
   – Major factor in design criteria
• Site design
   – Arrangement of buildings, circulation, parking and landscape
   – Vehicle or pedestrian-orientation
• Building design
   – Height, massing shape context
   – Create enclosure/pedestrian interest



                                       26
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Land use influence
• Major factor in thoroughfare design
• Influences:
     •Travel demand
     •Activity in roadside
     •Width of roadside
     •On-street parking
     •Target speed
     •Freight and transit



                             27
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Site design
    Feature            Auto Oriented                  Pedestrian Oriented
  Building          – Set well back into            – Oriented to, and adjacent to
  Orientation and     private property                street
  Setback           – Oriented to parking or        – Direct pedestrian entrance
                      landscape                       on street
                                                    – Integrated with street using
                                                      stoops, arcades, cafes
 Parking Type and   – Surface lot between           – Under or behind building
 Orientation          buildings and street            access by alleys
                                                    – Structured
                                                    – On-street
 Block Length       - Large blocks, often with      - Short blocks
                      no public throughway          - High connected network
                    - Superblocks

                                        28
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Building design
• Significant contributor to
  context defined by:
  – Height and thoroughfare
    enclosure
  – Width
  – Scale and variety
  – Entries



                         29
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Street enclosure
• Building height to
  thoroughfare width
  ratios:
   – 1:4 suburban
   – 1:2-1:3 urban
• Pedestrians first
  perceive enclosure at a
  1:4 ratio




                            30
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



CSS tenet - thoroughfare design changes as
context changes
The thoroughfare both responds to and contributes to
shaping the context and defining the place




                           31
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Thoroughfare types
• Three classifications:
  – Boulevard
  – Avenue
  – Street
• Basis for:
  – Physical configuration
  – Design criteria
  – Design speed

                             32
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Functional classification in thoroughfare design
• Function and role in the network
  –   Continuity
  –   Trip purpose and length
  –   Level of land access
  –   Type of freight
  –   Types of public transit
• Design controls
  – Design speed for sight distance
  – Horizontal and vertical curvature


                            33
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Developing Designs                    Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Relationship: functional classification and thoroughfare type




                                  34
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Thoroughfare type in design
• Design criteria
  – Target speed (desirable operating speed)
• Physical configuration
  – With surrounding context
• Dimensions for:
  – Roadside
  – Traveled way
  – Intersections


                           35
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

Thoroughfare type characteristics




                            36
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
FDOT TDLC Roads        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Speed reduction
techniques




                  37
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs          Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


  Boulevard
  • Divided arterial (4+ lanes)
  • Target speed (35 mph or less)
  • Through and local traffic
  • Serve longer trips
  • Access management
  • Major transit corridor
  • Primary freight route
  • Emergency response route
  • Limited curb parking
                       38
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Boulevard




                     39
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Multi-way boulevard
• Characterized by:
  – Central roadway for through traffic
  – Parallel roadways access abutting property, parking,
    and pedestrian and bicycle facilities
  – Parallel roadways separated from the through lanes
    by curbed islands
• Require significant right-of-way
• Special treatment of intersections


                          40
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs         Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Multi-way boulevard




                      41
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                      Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

Avenue
•   Arterial or collector (4 lanes max)
•   Target speed (30 to 35 mph)
•   Land access
•   Primary ped and bike route
•   Local transit route
•   Freight - local deliveries
•   Optional raised landscaped median
•   Curb parking




                                   42
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                         Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Street
•   Collector or local street (2 lanes)
•   Target speed (25 mph)
•   Land access primary function
•   Designed to:
    – Connect residential neighborhoods
    – Connect neighborhoods with
      commercial districts
    – Connect local streets to arterials
• May be commercial main street
• Emphasizes curb parking
• Freight restricted to local deliveries


                                     43
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Developing Designs                                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


    Changing Thoroughfare & Context
    • Arterial Street
    • C-3: Suburban




Source:   TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co.
          CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage                                     Existing Conditions
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Developing Designs                                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


    Changing Thoroughfare & Context
    • Boulevard Thoroughfare
    • C-4: General Urban




Source:   TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co.
          CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage                        Alternative Future with Initial Network
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Developing Designs                                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


    Changing Thoroughfare & Context
    • Avenue Thoroughfare
    • C-5: Urban Center




Source:   TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co.
          CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage                Alternative Future with Potential “Full” Network
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



 Design controls
 • Speed
 • Design vehicle
 • Functional class
 • Location
 • Sight distance
 • Horizontal / vertical alignment
 • Access management
 • Pedestrians and bicyclists
                        47
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Speed definitions
• Target speed
  – Desirable operating speed in specific context
  – Balances
     •Vehicle mobility
     •Safe environment
  – Usually posted speed limit
  – In CSS set by context and thoroughfare type
• Design speed
  – Governs certain geometric features
  – Usually set by functional classification
                            48
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Design vs. Control Vehicle
• Design Vehicle                    • Control Vehicle
   – Accommodated without              – Encroachment allowed
     encroachment                      – Turns infrequently
   – Turns with considerable           – Example: emergency
     frequency                           vehicle
   – High volumes in
     opposing lanes
   – Example: bus




                               49
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




Emergency vehicle operations
• Turning capability
• Access (clear areas)
  – Building entrances
  – Hydrants
  – Walls
• Mountable median crossings (long blocks)
• Work with fire department

                         50
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


CSS vs. conventional design
       Conventional                             CSS Approach
 Context:                                Urban Context:
      Urban                                     Suburban
      Rural                                     General Urban
                                                Urban Center
                                                Urban Core
Design criteria based primarily Design criteria based primarily
on:                             on:
      Functional class                          Community objectives
      Design speed                              Thoroughfare type
      Travel demand forecasts                   Functional class
      Level of service objectives               Adjacent land use
                                    51
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Speed and capacity of urban streets
• Address capacity issues with:
  –   Network capacity
  –   Synchronized signal timing
  –   Access management
  –   Turn lanes
  –   Other operational refinements
• Address safety:
  – Case-by-case basis



                               52
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



CSS design process




                     53
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



 Thoroughfare Components

                                                  Roadside




                     54
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Considerations in cross-section design
 • Local objectives
 • Stakeholder priorities
 • Adjacent activities
 • Functional class
 • Context zone and
   thoroughfare type
 • Modal requirements
 • Other conditions
     – Right-of-way
     – Traffic volumes
     – Vehicle mix

                            55
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Stages in cross-section design
1. Establish general parameters based on:
  – Context zone
  – Thoroughfare type
  – Select starting cross-section
2. Determine number of lanes based on:
  –   Community objectives
  –   Thoroughfare type
  –   Long-range transportation plan
  –   Corridor/network capacity analysis
  –   Maximum 6 lanes in walkable urban areas
                               56
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




Stages in cross-section design
3. Determine design and control vehicle
4. Identify transit, freight, and bicycle requirements
   –   Establish dimensions
5. Develop ideal cross-section - compare to ROW
   –   Acquire ROW or narrow design elements, or
   –   Widen high priority elements to match ROW
   –   Avoid combining minimal widths




                              57
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Designing in constrained ROW
• Prioritize design elements
• Develop sections
  –   Optimal – unconstrained
  –   Predominant – all priority elements
  –   Functional minimum – many priority elements
  –   Absolute minimum – highest priority only
• ROW width less than absolute minimum
  – Acquire ROW incrementally
  – Change thoroughfare type

                           58
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



  Lane widths
  •   Up to 35 mph: 10-12 feet
  •   Over 35 mph: 11-12 feet
  •   With buses: 11-12 feet
  •   Bike lanes: 5-6 feet (4 feet outside gutter pan)
  •   Parking: 7-8 feet




                             59
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                      Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


     Medians
     • Functions
       –   Access management
       –   Pedestrian refuge
       –   Left turn lanes
       –   Aesthetics
     • Widths
       – 4-22 feet
     • Landscaping
       – Trees (45 mph or less)
            • 6-10 foot medians - less than 4 inch caliper
            • 1½ feet lateral clearance
                                   60
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Transitions
• Geometric transitions (use AASHTO)
   – Change in thoroughfare width
   – Lateral shifts
   – Lane drops
• Location: on tangent sections
• Context, visual, operational, environmental transition
   – Speed zone transition
   – Visual cues
      • Urban design, land uses, building design, gateways, signs
   – Change width of thoroughfare
                                    61
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                   Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

Excerpt from ITE CSS guide – cross-sections




                                 6
                                 2
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Streetside design
• From property line to face of curb
• Accommodates street activity
  – Mobility
  – Business
  – Social
• Public space



                        63
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Urban streetside uses
•   Movement of pedestrians
•   Access to buildings/property
•   Utilities/appurtenances
•   Transit stops
•   Landscaping
•   Urban design/public art
•   Sidewalk cafes
•   Business functions
•   Civic spaces (plazas, seating)

                              64
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Streetside components
• Streetside zones:
  –   Edge Zone
  –   Furnishings Zone
  –   Throughway Zone (ADA)
  –   Frontage Zone
• Function and dimensions vary
  by context zone and adjacent
  land use


                              65
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                                                                                                                                                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

Streetside cross-section guidelines
                                                                                                                                                   C-4 w/ Predominantly Commercial Ground
                                         Sidewalk Zone [1]                  C-6 and C-5                                                                                                                                                   C-4 w/ Predominantly Residential Frontage
                                                                                                                                                                  Floor Use

                                                                           1.5 feet                                                                             1.5 feet




                                                                                               21.5 foot (recommended)




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      16.5 foot (recommended)
                                              Edge                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.5 feet




                                                                                                                                                                                    19 foot (recommended)
                                                                2.5 feet at diagonal parking                                                         2.5 feet at diagonal parking




                                                                                                                         12 foot (constrained)




                                                                                                                                                                                                            12 foot (constrained)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       8 feet
                                                                            7 feet                                                                                7 feet
        Boulevard




                                           Furnishings                                                                                                                                                                                (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or
                                                                    (trees in tree wells)                                                                 (trees in tree wells)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  groundcovers)
                                          Throughway                      10 feet                                                                                8 feet                                                                                 8 feet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         0 feet along lawn and groundcover
                                            Frontage                       3 feet                                                                               2.5 feet                                                             1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences
                                              Edge
        Boulevard Without Parking




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       0.5 feet




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      18.5 foot (Recommended)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        10 feet
                                           Furnishings                                                                                                                                                                              (landscape strip w/ trees and groundcovers or
                                                                   THIS THOROUGHFARE TYPE NOT APPLICABLE TO THE PREDOMINANTLY                                                                                                                        low shrubs)
                                          Throughway            COMMERCIAL GROUND FLOOR LAND USES FOUND IN C-4 THROUGH C-6 CONTEXT                                                                                                                      8 feet
                                                                                             ZONES
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         0 feet along lawn and groundcover
                                            Frontage                                                                                                                                                                                 1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences

                                                                           1.5 feet                                                                             1.5 feet
                                              Edge                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.5 feet
                                                                2.5 feet at diagonal parking                                                         2.5 feet at diagonal parking
                                                                                               19.5 foot (recommended)




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      14.5 foot (recommended)
                                                                                                                                                                                    16 foot (recommended)
                                                                                                                         12.0 foot (constrained)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        8 feet




                                                                                                                                                                                                            12 foot (constrained)
                                                       With                 6 feet                                                                                6 feet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or
                                                      Parking        trees in tree wells                                                                  (trees in tree wells)
                                    Furnishings                                                                                                                                                                                                   groundcovers)
        Avenue




                                                  Without               8 feet with                                                                           8 feet with                                                                            8 feet with
                                                  Parking           buffer landscaping                                                                    buffer landscaping                                                                    buffer landscaping
                                          Throughway                       9 feet                                                                                6 feet                                                                                 6 feet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         0 feet along lawn and groundcover
                                            Frontage                       3 feet                                                                               2.5 feet                                                             1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences
                                                                           1.5 feet                                                                             1.5 feet




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      11.5 foot (recommended)
                                              Edge                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.5 feet
                                                                                               16 foot (recommended)




                                                                                                                                                                                    16 foot (recommended)
                                                                                                                         12.0 foot (constrained)




                                                                2.5 feet at diagonal parking                                                         2.5 feet at diagonal parking

                                                                                                                                                                                                            12 foot (constrained)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       5 feet
                                                                            6 feet                                                                                6 feet
                                           Furnishings                                                                                                                                                                                (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or
                                                                    (trees in tree wells)                                                                 (trees in tree wells)
        Street




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  groundcovers)
                                          Throughway                       6 feet                                                                                6 feet                                                                                6 feet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         0 feet along lawn and groundcover
                                            Frontage                      2.5 feet                                                                    6         2.5 feet                                                             1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges
                                                                                                                                                      6                                                                             1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Edge zone
• Interface with traveled way
• Functions
  – Vehicle overhang and clearance
  – Door opening area
  – Wheelchair access at transit stops

• No (rural) clear zone width
• Lateral clearance
  – 1½ ft from curb face
                               67
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                         Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Furnishings zone
• Buffers pedestrians from traveled
  way
• Functions
   –   Street furniture, public art
   –   Utilities (within zone)
   –   Transit stops
   –   Lighting
   –   Public spaces (seating)
   –   Business space (cafes)
   –   Landscaping
• Safe landscaping
   – Sight lines (CPTED)
   – Sight distances
                                      68
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                     Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Throughway and frontage zones
• Throughway zone
  – Clear area for pedestrian travel
  – ADAAG requirements
  – No utilities
• Frontage zone
  –   Area adjacent to property line
  –   “Shy” distance from buildings
  –   Business space (cafes, signs)
  –   Landscaping
  –   Seating
  –   Building access



                                69
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Clear zones on urban thoroughfares
• Defined as an edge zone clear of fixed objects
• Less consequence than rural context
  – Lower speeds
  – Parked vehicles
• Often not practical in urban areas
• Rural standards not used in urban walkable
  areas


                        70
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs               Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Driveways
• Minimize in high pedestrian activity areas
• Maintain sidewalk cross slope




                    Best   If necessary 




                            71
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs          Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Traveled way
• Central portion of thoroughfare between curbs
• Provides for movement of vehicles
• Interface with roadside via on-street parking




                       72
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                    Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Traveled way components
•   Functions, modes
•   Widths, ROW allocations
•   Through travel and turn lanes
•   Access management
•   Parking, transit stops, bike lanes
•   Emergency vehicle operations
•   Transitions
•   Mid-block crosswalks
•   Medians, pedestrian refuge islands


                                 73
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Lane widths
• Recommended practice
  – Urban freeways:
     • 12 feet normal
     • 11 feet constrained
  – Arterials and collectors
     •10–11 feet on arterials and collectors
     • 12-feet under special circumstances
  – Based on:
     • Target speed
     • Design vehicle
     • Right-of-way
     • Width of adjacent parking and bicycle lanes


                                    74
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Medians                        Recommended Median Widths on Low Speed
                                    Thoroughfares (35 mph or less)

• Recommended practice   Thoroughfare Type
                                                                   Minimum
                                                                    Width
                                                                               Recommende
                                                                                 d Width
                                              Median for access control
                         Arterial Boulevards and Avenues
                                                                      4 ft.        6 ft.
                         Collector Avenues and Streets
                                             Median for pedestrian refuge
                         Arterial Boulevards and Avenues
                                                                      6 ft.        8 ft.
                         Collector Avenues and Streets
                                        Median for street trees and lighting
                         Arterial Boulevards and Avenues
                                                                      6 ft.       10 ft.
                         Collector Avenues and Streets
                                          Median for single left-turn lane
                         Collector Avenues and Streets               10 ft.       14 ft.
                         Arterial Boulevards and Avenues             12 ft.      16-18 ft.
                                             Median for dual left turn lane
                         Arterial Boulevards and Avenues             20 ft.       22 ft.


                              75
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                         Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Street trees - Recommended practice
• In medians
  – Min. median width
     • 6 feet for up to 4” caliper trees
     • 10 feet for larger trees
  – Avoid trees larger than 4” caliper
     • Speed > 45 mph
     • Or use barrier




                                     76
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Bicycle lanes
• Recommended practice
  – Combined with on-street parking = 13 feet
  – Without on-street parking = 6 feet




                          77
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                                     Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


On-street parking – recommended practice

           Recommended Parallel Parking Lane Widths
        Thoroughfare Type in C-3 through C-6 Context Zones

                Parallel Parking Lane Width (commercial and residential areas)

        Arterial Boulevard (commercial)                                     8 ft.

        Arterial Boulevard (residential)                                    7 ft.
                          Parallel Parking Lane Width (residential areas)

        Arterial Avenue                                                     7 ft.

        Collector Avenue and Street                                         7 ft.

                          Parallel Parking Lane Width (commercial areas)

        Arterial Avenue                                                     8 ft.

        Collector Avenue and Street                                         8 ft.



                                                78
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                      Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



• Mid-block crosswalks - Recommended practice
  – Locate so crossings are 200-300 feet apart
  – Significant pedestrian demand
  – Criteria
     • 12,000 ADT or less
     • 15,000 ADT with median refuge
     • Speed less than 40 mph
     • Adequate sight distance




                                   79
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                    Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Urban intersections
• General principles
   – Minimize conflicts between modes
   – Minimize pedestrian exposure
   – Provide crosswalks on all
     approaches
   – Minimize curb radii consistent with
     design/control vehicle
   – Ensure good visibility
   – Balance vehicle LOS with
     pedestrian convenience and safety


                                 80
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


• Urban intersections - Design elements
  –   Through and turning lanes
  –   Intersection sight distance
  –   Medians
  –   Curb return radii
  – Design vehicle
  – Channelized right turns
  – Modern roundabouts
  – Crosswalks and refuges
  – Curb extensions
  – Bicycle lane treatment
  – Bus stops
  – Traffic signals
                                    81
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
 Developing Designs                             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



  Urban intersections
  • Avoid large undefined open spaces




Source:   City of Palo Alto
          CD+A, FPA, and Urban Advantage   82
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
  Developing Designs                            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



   Urban intersections - Creating opportunities to
   improve context




Source:   City of Palo Alto
          CD+A, FPA, and Urban Advantage   83
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Intersections – simplify for all modes




                         84
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



• Intersections – Curb return radius - recommended
  practice
  – Consider
     • Design vehicle
     • Effective width
     • Curb return radii
  – Minimum radius = 5 feet
  – Use 10-15 feet radius
     • High ped volumes
     • Low turning volumes and speed
     • Bike/parking lanes create higher effective radii



                                    85
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
FDOT TDLC Roads              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Curb extension and effective corner radius




                        86
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                          Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Curb extensions
• Improve visibility
• Reduce crossing width
• On streets with parking
• Recommended practice
   – Extend curb line 1 ft. less than parking
     width
   – Curb return radius for control vehicle
   – Use with bus stops to increase waiting
     area



                                       87
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Channelized right turns - recommended
  practice
• Generally discouraged in walkable
  environments
• Signalized intersections with heavy right
  turns
• Low pedestrian volumes
• Where pedestrian volumes high – eliminate
  or install pedestrian signal
• Low-angle turn
• Clear visibility
• Illumination


                              88
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs                                       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Roundabouts - recommended practice
                                    Minimum              Urban          Urban          Urban
                                       “Mini-           Compact      Single-Lane   Double-Lane
            Parameter              Roundabout”         Roundabout    Roundabout    Roundabout
   Maximum Entry Speed (mph)             15                15            20              25
                                      Bus and                                       WB-67 with
                                                        Bus and
                                    Single-unit                                         lane
   Design Vehicle                                      Single-Unit     WB-50
                                    truck drive                                    encroachment
                                                          Truck
                                    over apron                                     on truck apron
   Inscribed circle diameter (feet)   45 to 80          80 to 100     100 to 130     150 to 180
   Maximum number of entering
                                          1                 1             1              2
   lanes
   Typical capacity (vehicles per
   day entering from all               10,000            15,000        20,000         40,000
   approaches)
   Applicability by Thoroughfare Type:
                                        Not                Not           Not
   Boulevard                                                                        Applicable
                                     Applicable         Applicable    Applicable
                                        Not                Not
   Arterial Avenue                                                    Applicable    Applicable
                                     Applicable         Applicable
                                                           Not
   Collector Avenue                  Applicable                       Applicable   Not Applicable
                                                        Applicable
   Street                            Applicable         Applicable    Applicable   Not Applicable


                                                  89
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs       Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




                     9
                     0
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Developing Designs        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Roundabouts




                     91
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Design exceptions – 13 controlling criteria
  –   Design/target speed         •   Vertical alignment
  –   Lane width                  •   Grade
  –   Shoulder width              •   Stopping sight distance
  –   Bridge width                •   Vertical clearance
  –   Horizontal alignment        •   Horizontal clearance
  –   Superelevation              •   Structural capacity
  –   Cross slope
• Needed when
  – Cannot meet minimums in applicable design manual
  – Reasonable alternative design will work safely


                             92
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Frequent design Exceptions                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




 Number state DOTs reporting frequent design exceptions by criterion
 NCHRP Synthesis 316
                                      93
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions              Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



        Consider trade-offs
        •   Mobility, access
        •   Road user needs
        •   Environmental impacts
        •   Capital and operating costs
        •   Safety
        •   Aesthetics
        •   Local considerations



                          94
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions                                                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


                            Design Domain and Risk



          Speed or Volume

                                                                    Lower limit of extended
                                                                    design domain – new
                                                                    roads


                             Increasing liability risk,
                                Decreasing scope             Extended                         Normal
                                   for defense

                                                                     Design Domain

                                                    Lower limit of extended
                                                    design domain –
                                                    existing roads
                                                                              Standard           Design Criteria
                                                                              Minimums



                                   Adapted from: O. Arndt, R. Cox, “Using an Enlarged Design Domain for
                                   Road Restoration Projects,” Queensland Department of Main Roads, 2006.


                                                            95
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions                  Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



• Strong case
  – Show criteria not applicable
     •Project can be safe not following criteria
     •Environmental or community needs prohibit meeting
      criteria
     •Criteria impractical to meet
  – Weak case
     •Saves money
     •Saves time
     •Designer found loop hole
     •Design similar to other existing designs

                              96
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Minimum documentation
• Established design criteria
• Reasons criteria cannot be met
• Why proposal is most applicable
• Applicable background information
• Pertinent information
  – Safety assessment
  – Operations


                        97
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exception Form        Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




                        98
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions                             Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design


Documentation must be
•   Deliberative
•   Defensible
•   Clearly written
•   Explicitly evaluate safety
    – Who is at risk
        • Motorists, pedestrians, etc.
    – Exposure
        • Traffic volumes
        • Location
    – Extent of exception
    – How risk is managed (solely relying on standards does not
      guaranty facility free of risk)
                                         99
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exception Process                Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design




 Florida DOT design and utility
 exception process




                                  100
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions                 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Rule of thumb for success
• No reasonable, feasible, practical solution available that
  meets criteria, or
• Selection of proposed criteria is advantageous and
  results in overall superior design
and
• Use of proposed criteria is not expected to unduly
  degrade or hinder safety or operational performance of
  the proposed facility


                            101
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design Exceptions            Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



Reference (available
on-line):




                       102
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Design References                                    Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design

AASHTO
• A Guide for Achieving Flexibility in Highway Design, 1st Edition
• A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets, 5th Edition
• Guide for the Planning, Design, and Operation of Pedestrian Facilities, 1st Edition
• Guide for High-Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) Facilities, 3rd Edition
• Guide for Park-and-Ride Facilities, 2nd Edition
• Guide for the Development of Bicycle Facilities, 3rd Edition
• Roadside Design Guide, 3rd Edition
• Roadway Lighting Design Guide
• Design for Transit Vehicles and Facilities on Streets and Highways (pending from TCRP D-09)
ITE
•Context Sensitive Solutions in Designing Major Urban Thoroughfares for Walkable Communities (2nd
  edition pending – retitled to Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: A Context Sensitive Approach)
•Urban Geometric Design Handbook
•Guidelines for Driveway Location and Design
•Guidelines for Neighborhood Street Design
TRB
•A Guide for Transportation Landscape and Environmental Design (update pending)
•Access Management Manual
                                               103
Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation
Class Project Discussion           Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design



 • Projects to be
    – Presented Class 28
    – Submitted at start of Class 29


 • Student questions?




                             104

More Related Content

What's hot

Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third DraftTysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
Fairfax County
 
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14Bhim Upadhyaya
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.122040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
CHCRPA
 
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...Virtual ULI
 
Css class 3 definition and benefits 120309
Css class 3   definition and benefits 120309Css class 3   definition and benefits 120309
Css class 3 definition and benefits 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINESUTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
Uttipec Dda
 
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
City of Leander
 

What's hot (8)

Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third DraftTysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
Tysons Comprehensive Plan Amendment: Overview of Third Draft
 
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14
Introduction to rural infrastructure development in nepal 2012.01.14
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.122040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium 8.24.12
 
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...
ULI Seattle’s Bus Rapid Transit and Land Use Initiative Developing the Next F...
 
Css class 3 definition and benefits 120309
Css class 3   definition and benefits 120309Css class 3   definition and benefits 120309
Css class 3 definition and benefits 120309
 
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINESUTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
UTTIPEC STREET DESIGN GUIDELINES
 
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
The District at Leander Overview 8/3/17
 
PM tools and techniques
PM tools and techniquesPM tools and techniques
PM tools and techniques
 

Viewers also liked

Sustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
Sustainable places, Rosemary CoyneSustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
Sustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
Design South East
 
Roadspace Allocation for Better Streets
Roadspace Allocation for Better StreetsRoadspace Allocation for Better Streets
Roadspace Allocation for Better Streets
Design South East
 
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
Hossam Shafiq I
 
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
Andy Boenau
 
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008Iain Barker
 
04 transport modelling
04 transport modelling04 transport modelling
04 transport modelling
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
 
Complete Streets
Complete StreetsComplete Streets
Complete Streets
NCTAPA
 
SPEED- Final Design Report
SPEED- Final Design ReportSPEED- Final Design Report
SPEED- Final Design ReportLeah Segerlin
 
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action AgendaTransportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
Barry Wellar
 
Roundabouts in series with short separation
Roundabouts in series with short separationRoundabouts in series with short separation
Roundabouts in series with short separation
THECITYALLIANCE
 
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
Kristen Carney
 
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
비영리 소셜정보안전센터
 
Urban transportation systems redesigning main street
Urban transportation systems redesigning main streetUrban transportation systems redesigning main street
Urban transportation systems redesigning main street
Julianne Crawford
 
Save Earth, Use Public Transport
Save Earth, Use Public TransportSave Earth, Use Public Transport
Save Earth, Use Public Transport
Jaspal Singh
 
Link And Place A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter Jones
Link And Place   A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter JonesLink And Place   A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter Jones
Link And Place A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter JonesEngineers Australia
 
Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design
Trailnet
 
Travel demand management
Travel demand managementTravel demand management
Travel demand managementPresi
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Sustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
Sustainable places, Rosemary CoyneSustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
Sustainable places, Rosemary Coyne
 
Roadspace Allocation for Better Streets
Roadspace Allocation for Better StreetsRoadspace Allocation for Better Streets
Roadspace Allocation for Better Streets
 
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
Lec 14 Demand Forecasting 2008 (Transportation Engineering Dr.Lina Shbeeb)
 
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
Functional Classification of Streets: So important that no one wants to talk ...
 
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008
Context Is Everything from OZ-IA 2008
 
04 transport modelling
04 transport modelling04 transport modelling
04 transport modelling
 
Complete Streets
Complete StreetsComplete Streets
Complete Streets
 
SPEED- Final Design Report
SPEED- Final Design ReportSPEED- Final Design Report
SPEED- Final Design Report
 
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action AgendaTransportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
Transportation: Inspiring a Sustainability Action Agenda
 
Elgin Smi2
Elgin Smi2Elgin Smi2
Elgin Smi2
 
Roundabouts in series with short separation
Roundabouts in series with short separationRoundabouts in series with short separation
Roundabouts in series with short separation
 
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
Transportation Planning 101: The Role of Resource and Regulatory Agencies in ...
 
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
프라이버시 보호를 위한 법률
 
Urban transportation systems redesigning main street
Urban transportation systems redesigning main streetUrban transportation systems redesigning main street
Urban transportation systems redesigning main street
 
Save Earth, Use Public Transport
Save Earth, Use Public TransportSave Earth, Use Public Transport
Save Earth, Use Public Transport
 
Link And Place A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter Jones
Link And Place   A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter JonesLink And Place   A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter Jones
Link And Place A Guide To Street Planning And Design By Prof Peter Jones
 
Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design
 
Final Ite Css
Final Ite CssFinal Ite Css
Final Ite Css
 
Travel demand management
Travel demand managementTravel demand management
Travel demand management
 
Guide to Sustainable Urban Transport Plans
Guide to Sustainable Urban Transport PlansGuide to Sustainable Urban Transport Plans
Guide to Sustainable Urban Transport Plans
 

Similar to Css classes 19 22 - developing compatible supportive design 120309

Css class 7 creating a css project 100410
Css class 7   creating a css project 100410Css class 7   creating a css project 100410
Css class 7 creating a css project 100410
TTI-UTCM
 
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 5 css and environmental analysis 111809
Css class 5   css and environmental analysis 111809Css class 5   css and environmental analysis 111809
Css class 5 css and environmental analysis 111809TTI-UTCM
 
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 8 multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
Css class 8   multi-disciplinary teaming 120309Css class 8   multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
Css class 8 multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 9 physical context 120309
Css class 9   physical context 120309Css class 9   physical context 120309
Css class 9 physical context 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 17 multimodal options 112309
Css class 17   multimodal options 112309Css class 17   multimodal options 112309
Css class 17 multimodal options 112309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 18 placemaking 120309
Css class 18   placemaking 120309Css class 18   placemaking 120309
Css class 18 placemaking 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 26 using css in practice 113009
Css class 26   using css in practice 113009Css class 26   using css in practice 113009
Css class 26 using css in practice 113009
TTI-UTCM
 
2006 Infrastructure Conference
2006 Infrastructure Conference2006 Infrastructure Conference
2006 Infrastructure ConferenceJoe Sanchez, P.E.
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.132040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
CHCRPA
 
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design FlexJoe Sanchez, P.E.
 
Css class 2 my favorite street 120309
Css class 2   my favorite street 120309Css class 2   my favorite street 120309
Css class 2 my favorite street 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Site plan review sneapa final
Site plan review sneapa finalSite plan review sneapa final
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
TRANSPORTATION PLANNINGTRANSPORTATION PLANNING
TRANSPORTATION PLANNINGintan fatihah
 

Similar to Css classes 19 22 - developing compatible supportive design 120309 (20)

Css class 7 creating a css project 100410
Css class 7   creating a css project 100410Css class 7   creating a css project 100410
Css class 7 creating a css project 100410
 
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
Css classes 11 13 superceded - stakeholder involvement 111909
 
Css class 5 css and environmental analysis 111809
Css class 5   css and environmental analysis 111809Css class 5   css and environmental analysis 111809
Css class 5 css and environmental analysis 111809
 
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
Css classes 11 13 - stakeholder involvement 120309
 
Css class 8 multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
Css class 8   multi-disciplinary teaming 120309Css class 8   multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
Css class 8 multi-disciplinary teaming 120309
 
Css class 9 physical context 120309
Css class 9   physical context 120309Css class 9   physical context 120309
Css class 9 physical context 120309
 
Css class 17 multimodal options 112309
Css class 17   multimodal options 112309Css class 17   multimodal options 112309
Css class 17 multimodal options 112309
 
Css class 18 placemaking 120309
Css class 18   placemaking 120309Css class 18   placemaking 120309
Css class 18 placemaking 120309
 
Css class 26 using css in practice 113009
Css class 26   using css in practice 113009Css class 26   using css in practice 113009
Css class 26 using css in practice 113009
 
2006 Infrastructure Conference
2006 Infrastructure Conference2006 Infrastructure Conference
2006 Infrastructure Conference
 
Rolling Climate Change, Transportation & Land Use Planning into One Innovativ...
Rolling Climate Change, Transportation & Land Use Planning into One Innovativ...Rolling Climate Change, Transportation & Land Use Planning into One Innovativ...
Rolling Climate Change, Transportation & Land Use Planning into One Innovativ...
 
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.132040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
2040 RTP Leadership Symposium II 3.13.13
 
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex
2005 Eng Conf CSS & Design Flex
 
Stakeholder Meeting Csss092909
Stakeholder Meeting Csss092909Stakeholder Meeting Csss092909
Stakeholder Meeting Csss092909
 
Css class 2 my favorite street 120309
Css class 2   my favorite street 120309Css class 2   my favorite street 120309
Css class 2 my favorite street 120309
 
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
Css classes 14 16 - class project startup & charrette 120309
 
Site plan review sneapa final
Site plan review sneapa finalSite plan review sneapa final
Site plan review sneapa final
 
Public Workshop #1
Public Workshop #1Public Workshop #1
Public Workshop #1
 
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
TRANSPORTATION PLANNINGTRANSPORTATION PLANNING
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
 
Wellborn Area Plan
Wellborn Area PlanWellborn Area Plan
Wellborn Area Plan
 

More from TTI-UTCM

UTCM 09-37-15 Zietsman
UTCM 09-37-15 ZietsmanUTCM 09-37-15 Zietsman
UTCM 09-37-15 ZietsmanTTI-UTCM
 
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 25 project checklist and approval process 113009
Css class 25   project checklist and approval process 113009Css class 25   project checklist and approval process 113009
Css class 25 project checklist and approval process 113009
TTI-UTCM
 
Css slide template 111609
Css slide template 111609Css slide template 111609
Css slide template 111609
TTI-UTCM
 
Css class 4 css and project development 120309
Css class 4   css and project development 120309Css class 4   css and project development 120309
Css class 4 css and project development 120309
TTI-UTCM
 
Supplemental class description 120908
Supplemental class description 120908Supplemental class description 120908
Supplemental class description 120908
TTI-UTCM
 
Css flyer 12 10-08
Css flyer 12 10-08Css flyer 12 10-08
Css flyer 12 10-08
TTI-UTCM
 
Syllabus css course - 15 weeks 072408
Syllabus   css course - 15 weeks 072408Syllabus   css course - 15 weeks 072408
Syllabus css course - 15 weeks 072408
TTI-UTCM
 
Syllabus css course - 10 weeks 022309
Syllabus   css course - 10 weeks 022309Syllabus   css course - 10 weeks 022309
Syllabus css course - 10 weeks 022309TTI-UTCM
 
Project 11 culver blvd 092710
Project 11   culver blvd 092710Project 11   culver blvd 092710
Project 11 culver blvd 092710
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 10 tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
Project 10   tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710Project 10   tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
Project 10 tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 9 south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
Project 9   south lake shore drive - chicago 092210Project 9   south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
Project 9 south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 6 paris pike 092210
Project 6   paris pike 092210Project 6   paris pike 092210
Project 6 paris pike 092210
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 5 cooper river bridge 092210
Project 5   cooper river bridge 092210Project 5   cooper river bridge 092210
Project 5 cooper river bridge 092210
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 4 mopac 1 092210
Project 4   mopac 1 092210Project 4   mopac 1 092210
Project 4 mopac 1 092210
TTI-UTCM
 
Project 2 north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
Project 2   north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210Project 2   north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
Project 2 north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
TTI-UTCM
 

More from TTI-UTCM (16)

UTCM 09-37-15 Zietsman
UTCM 09-37-15 ZietsmanUTCM 09-37-15 Zietsman
UTCM 09-37-15 Zietsman
 
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
Css classes 27 28 - term project presentations 100410
 
Css class 25 project checklist and approval process 113009
Css class 25   project checklist and approval process 113009Css class 25   project checklist and approval process 113009
Css class 25 project checklist and approval process 113009
 
Css slide template 111609
Css slide template 111609Css slide template 111609
Css slide template 111609
 
Css class 4 css and project development 120309
Css class 4   css and project development 120309Css class 4   css and project development 120309
Css class 4 css and project development 120309
 
Supplemental class description 120908
Supplemental class description 120908Supplemental class description 120908
Supplemental class description 120908
 
Css flyer 12 10-08
Css flyer 12 10-08Css flyer 12 10-08
Css flyer 12 10-08
 
Syllabus css course - 15 weeks 072408
Syllabus   css course - 15 weeks 072408Syllabus   css course - 15 weeks 072408
Syllabus css course - 15 weeks 072408
 
Syllabus css course - 10 weeks 022309
Syllabus   css course - 10 weeks 022309Syllabus   css course - 10 weeks 022309
Syllabus css course - 10 weeks 022309
 
Project 11 culver blvd 092710
Project 11   culver blvd 092710Project 11   culver blvd 092710
Project 11 culver blvd 092710
 
Project 10 tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
Project 10   tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710Project 10   tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
Project 10 tri-party downtown streets - san antonio 092710
 
Project 9 south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
Project 9   south lake shore drive - chicago 092210Project 9   south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
Project 9 south lake shore drive - chicago 092210
 
Project 6 paris pike 092210
Project 6   paris pike 092210Project 6   paris pike 092210
Project 6 paris pike 092210
 
Project 5 cooper river bridge 092210
Project 5   cooper river bridge 092210Project 5   cooper river bridge 092210
Project 5 cooper river bridge 092210
 
Project 4 mopac 1 092210
Project 4   mopac 1 092210Project 4   mopac 1 092210
Project 4 mopac 1 092210
 
Project 2 north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
Project 2   north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210Project 2   north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
Project 2 north central expy-high 5 interchange 092210
 

Recently uploaded

Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software FuzzingRemoving Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
Aftab Hussain
 
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptxSecstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
nkrafacyberclub
 
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
Pierluigi Pugliese
 
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the FutureVideo Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
Alpen-Adria-Universität
 
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
sonjaschweigert1
 
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI supportEpistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
Alan Dix
 
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
Nexer Digital
 
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
James Anderson
 
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdfFIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
FIDO Alliance
 
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIsQuantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
Vlad Stirbu
 
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdfFIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
FIDO Alliance
 
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex ProofszkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
Alex Pruden
 
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
BookNet Canada
 
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
UiPathCommunity
 
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge GraphGraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
Guy Korland
 
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to ProductionGenerative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
Aggregage
 
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
KatiaHIMEUR1
 
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyesAssure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
ThousandEyes
 
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing DaysClimate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
Kari Kakkonen
 
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
Jen Stirrup
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software FuzzingRemoving Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
Removing Uninteresting Bytes in Software Fuzzing
 
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptxSecstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
Secstrike : Reverse Engineering & Pwnable tools for CTF.pptx
 
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
By Design, not by Accident - Agile Venture Bolzano 2024
 
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the FutureVideo Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future
 
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
A tale of scale & speed: How the US Navy is enabling software delivery from l...
 
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI supportEpistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
Epistemic Interaction - tuning interfaces to provide information for AI support
 
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
Elizabeth Buie - Older adults: Are we really designing for our future selves?
 
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
Alt. GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using ...
 
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdfFIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: Overview.pdf
 
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIsQuantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
Quantum Computing: Current Landscape and the Future Role of APIs
 
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdfFIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
FIDO Alliance Osaka Seminar: The WebAuthn API and Discoverable Credentials.pdf
 
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex ProofszkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
zkStudyClub - Reef: Fast Succinct Non-Interactive Zero-Knowledge Regex Proofs
 
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
Transcript: Selling digital books in 2024: Insights from industry leaders - T...
 
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
UiPath Community Day Dubai: AI at Work..
 
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge GraphGraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG is All You need? LLM & Knowledge Graph
 
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to ProductionGenerative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
Generative AI Deep Dive: Advancing from Proof of Concept to Production
 
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !
 
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyesAssure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
Assure Contact Center Experiences for Your Customers With ThousandEyes
 
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing DaysClimate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days
 
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
The Metaverse and AI: how can decision-makers harness the Metaverse for their...
 

Css classes 19 22 - developing compatible supportive design 120309

  • 1. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Classes 19-22 Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Using CSS to Develop Compatible Supportive Designs 1
  • 2. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Goal: Excellence Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Excellent transportation design • Satisfies stakeholder purpose, needs, and vision – Established early – Refined as process advances • Safe for users and community • Harmonious with community • Supports other community objectives • Preserves environmental values and resources 2
  • 3. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process • Determine context – Existing conditions •Physical – Roadway, transitway, pathway – Roadside, streetside, wayside – Adjacent development » Context zones » Land use site design » External factors •Activity – Transportation facility – Roadside, streetside, wayside – Adjacent land, buildings 3
  • 4. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process (cont.) • Determine context (cont.) – Environment (relevant) • Physical • Social – Planed changes – External factors CS3 – context sensitive sustainable solutions (Oregon DOT version) 4
  • 5. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process (cont.) • Identify issues, opportunities, constraints, threats, strengths, weaknesses – Issues – concerns, problems, questions, uncertainties – Opportunities – what could occur (physical, operational, policy, transportation, development, economic, etc.) – Constraints – limitations on opportunities – Threats – negative factors or prospects – Strengths – positive attributes on which to build – Weaknesses – shortcomings to strengthen 5
  • 6. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process (cont.) • Identfy goals, objectives, core values – Desired outcomes – Core values •Goals (general statements) •Aesthetics – Mobility and access •Safety – Economic development •Character – Land development – Activity •Etc. – Other •Objectives – More detailed statements 6
  • 7. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process (cont.) • Select criteria for evaluation, prioritization – Base on •Objectives •Mobility •Issues •Socio-econimic •Opportunities •Environmental •Concerns •Cost-effectiveness •Environmental impacts •Other 7
  • 8. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Process (Review) Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Project development process (cont.) • Vision – Outcome from goals •Functional •Appearance •Resulting conditions 8
  • 9. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Develop alternatives • Range • Design criteria • Approach • Flexibility • Components 9
  • 10. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Develop alternatives • Range in magnitude – “No build” •May include improvements elsewhere in system – Operational (TSM) improvements – Minor – Full “build” • Range in type – Modal – Alignment – Type of facility – Extent of improvement – Relationship with adjacent development 10
  • 11. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Develop alternatives • Design criteria – AASHTO green book (using flexibility) – AASHTO, FHWA Flexibility in Highway Design – State DOT design manual – City/county public works design manual – Local agency guidelines (incl. zoning overlays) – Modal guidelines (ITE CSS for walkable communities) • Ped – AASHTO ped guide • Bike – AASHTO bike facilities guide • Bus – TCRP 19, 33, 117 (pending TCRP D-09 • Rail – TCRP 17, 69 guide) – Landscaping 11
  • 12. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Develop alternatives 12
  • 13. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Develop alternatives • Components – Traveled way – Design each – Adapt per activity – Streetside, roadside, wayside – Enhance each to work – Land uses together – Sense of place • Urban design • Parks • Historic features • Social fabric • Arts and activity 13
  • 14. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Decision-Making Context Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Caltrain improvements – S.F. peninsula line TRANSIT THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT HSR SERVICES PROJECT Alignment Alignment WHAT Land Use Services Vehicles Circulation Vehicles TOD Vehicles Operations DECISIONS? Connectivity Operations Stations Stations Services Services WHO City Councils Transit Agency JPB/CHSRA Boards DECIDES? Board of Supervisors Federal agencies CHSRA Board Boards Elected officials Federal agencies PRP Elected officials Customers Customers Customers Facilitate consider COMMUNITY Incorporate community community input Direct engagement INFLUENCE community engagement in decisions input into decisions Regional/state Statewide accountabilility accountability
  • 15. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Evaluate • One measure per objective or issue – Quantifiable (with available data) – Sensitive to changes in performance • Can be categorical or ratio • Need quantification methodology • Can work within Delphi process 15
  • 16. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Evaluate – Option: Delphi process • Combines performance and importance • One measure per criterion – Objective – Issue • Quantified in ratio scale • Criteria weighted per stakeholder input – Initial – Again after interim results 16
  • 17. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Delphi example (or other evaluation table) 17
  • 18. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Project Development Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Evaluation • Converge by narrowing, refining alternatives 1. Distinct ranging alternatives Cycle 2. Workable more detailed alternatives 1.Formulate/ refine 2.Evaluate 3. (optional) Variations on final alternative(s) 3.Discuss EIS 4.Narrow 4. Preferred alternative 5. Develop preliminary design 18
  • 19. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Communities want • Flexibility • Compatibility with adjacent land uses • Balanced land use/transportation functions • Safe and attractive streets • Multimodal facilities • Streets that are quality public space 19
  • 20. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation FDOT TDLC Roads* Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design *Transportation design for livable communities Examples of flexible DOT design criteria Minimum lane widths 20
  • 21. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation FDOT TDLC roads Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Techniques to support non-drive modes 21
  • 22. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Tenets of CSS • Balance – Safety – Mobility – Community objectives – Environment • Multimodal • Involve public, stakeholders • Interdisciplinary teams • Flexibility in design • Incorporate aesthetics 22
  • 23. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Placemaking • Community-based approach to the development and revitalization of cities and neighborhoods • Placemaking: – Unique places with lasting value – Compact, mixed-use – Pedestrian and transit oriented – Strong civic character – Contributes to economic development 23
  • 24. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design ITE framework • Context zones: – Suburbs to downtowns • Street classification: – Functional class – Thoroughfare type •Boulevard •Avenue •Street • Compatibility 24
  • 25. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Context Zones – An Organizing System for Thoroughfare Design Graphic source: Duany Plater-Zyberk and Company Source: Duany Plater-Zyberk and Company Source: Context Sensitive Solutions in Designing Major Urban Thoroughfares for Walkable Communities
  • 26. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Features that create context • Land use – Defines urban activity – Major factor in design criteria • Site design – Arrangement of buildings, circulation, parking and landscape – Vehicle or pedestrian-orientation • Building design – Height, massing shape context – Create enclosure/pedestrian interest 26
  • 27. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Land use influence • Major factor in thoroughfare design • Influences: •Travel demand •Activity in roadside •Width of roadside •On-street parking •Target speed •Freight and transit 27
  • 28. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Site design Feature Auto Oriented Pedestrian Oriented Building – Set well back into – Oriented to, and adjacent to Orientation and private property street Setback – Oriented to parking or – Direct pedestrian entrance landscape on street – Integrated with street using stoops, arcades, cafes Parking Type and – Surface lot between – Under or behind building Orientation buildings and street access by alleys – Structured – On-street Block Length - Large blocks, often with - Short blocks no public throughway - High connected network - Superblocks 28
  • 29. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Building design • Significant contributor to context defined by: – Height and thoroughfare enclosure – Width – Scale and variety – Entries 29
  • 30. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Street enclosure • Building height to thoroughfare width ratios: – 1:4 suburban – 1:2-1:3 urban • Pedestrians first perceive enclosure at a 1:4 ratio 30
  • 31. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design CSS tenet - thoroughfare design changes as context changes The thoroughfare both responds to and contributes to shaping the context and defining the place 31
  • 32. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Thoroughfare types • Three classifications: – Boulevard – Avenue – Street • Basis for: – Physical configuration – Design criteria – Design speed 32
  • 33. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Functional classification in thoroughfare design • Function and role in the network – Continuity – Trip purpose and length – Level of land access – Type of freight – Types of public transit • Design controls – Design speed for sight distance – Horizontal and vertical curvature 33
  • 34. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Relationship: functional classification and thoroughfare type 34
  • 35. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Thoroughfare type in design • Design criteria – Target speed (desirable operating speed) • Physical configuration – With surrounding context • Dimensions for: – Roadside – Traveled way – Intersections 35
  • 36. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Thoroughfare type characteristics 36
  • 37. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation FDOT TDLC Roads Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Speed reduction techniques 37
  • 38. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Boulevard • Divided arterial (4+ lanes) • Target speed (35 mph or less) • Through and local traffic • Serve longer trips • Access management • Major transit corridor • Primary freight route • Emergency response route • Limited curb parking 38
  • 39. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Boulevard 39
  • 40. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Multi-way boulevard • Characterized by: – Central roadway for through traffic – Parallel roadways access abutting property, parking, and pedestrian and bicycle facilities – Parallel roadways separated from the through lanes by curbed islands • Require significant right-of-way • Special treatment of intersections 40
  • 41. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Multi-way boulevard 41
  • 42. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Avenue • Arterial or collector (4 lanes max) • Target speed (30 to 35 mph) • Land access • Primary ped and bike route • Local transit route • Freight - local deliveries • Optional raised landscaped median • Curb parking 42
  • 43. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Street • Collector or local street (2 lanes) • Target speed (25 mph) • Land access primary function • Designed to: – Connect residential neighborhoods – Connect neighborhoods with commercial districts – Connect local streets to arterials • May be commercial main street • Emphasizes curb parking • Freight restricted to local deliveries 43
  • 44. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Changing Thoroughfare & Context • Arterial Street • C-3: Suburban Source: TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co. CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage Existing Conditions
  • 45. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Changing Thoroughfare & Context • Boulevard Thoroughfare • C-4: General Urban Source: TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co. CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage Alternative Future with Initial Network
  • 46. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Changing Thoroughfare & Context • Avenue Thoroughfare • C-5: Urban Center Source: TJPDC, VDOT, City of Charlottesville, & Albemarle Co. CD+A, Meyer, Mohaddes, & Urban Advantage Alternative Future with Potential “Full” Network
  • 47. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Design controls • Speed • Design vehicle • Functional class • Location • Sight distance • Horizontal / vertical alignment • Access management • Pedestrians and bicyclists 47
  • 48. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Speed definitions • Target speed – Desirable operating speed in specific context – Balances •Vehicle mobility •Safe environment – Usually posted speed limit – In CSS set by context and thoroughfare type • Design speed – Governs certain geometric features – Usually set by functional classification 48
  • 49. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Design vs. Control Vehicle • Design Vehicle • Control Vehicle – Accommodated without – Encroachment allowed encroachment – Turns infrequently – Turns with considerable – Example: emergency frequency vehicle – High volumes in opposing lanes – Example: bus 49
  • 50. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Emergency vehicle operations • Turning capability • Access (clear areas) – Building entrances – Hydrants – Walls • Mountable median crossings (long blocks) • Work with fire department 50
  • 51. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design CSS vs. conventional design Conventional CSS Approach Context: Urban Context: Urban Suburban Rural General Urban Urban Center Urban Core Design criteria based primarily Design criteria based primarily on: on: Functional class Community objectives Design speed Thoroughfare type Travel demand forecasts Functional class Level of service objectives Adjacent land use 51
  • 52. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Speed and capacity of urban streets • Address capacity issues with: – Network capacity – Synchronized signal timing – Access management – Turn lanes – Other operational refinements • Address safety: – Case-by-case basis 52
  • 53. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design CSS design process 53
  • 54. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Thoroughfare Components Roadside 54
  • 55. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Considerations in cross-section design • Local objectives • Stakeholder priorities • Adjacent activities • Functional class • Context zone and thoroughfare type • Modal requirements • Other conditions – Right-of-way – Traffic volumes – Vehicle mix 55
  • 56. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Stages in cross-section design 1. Establish general parameters based on: – Context zone – Thoroughfare type – Select starting cross-section 2. Determine number of lanes based on: – Community objectives – Thoroughfare type – Long-range transportation plan – Corridor/network capacity analysis – Maximum 6 lanes in walkable urban areas 56
  • 57. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Stages in cross-section design 3. Determine design and control vehicle 4. Identify transit, freight, and bicycle requirements – Establish dimensions 5. Develop ideal cross-section - compare to ROW – Acquire ROW or narrow design elements, or – Widen high priority elements to match ROW – Avoid combining minimal widths 57
  • 58. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Designing in constrained ROW • Prioritize design elements • Develop sections – Optimal – unconstrained – Predominant – all priority elements – Functional minimum – many priority elements – Absolute minimum – highest priority only • ROW width less than absolute minimum – Acquire ROW incrementally – Change thoroughfare type 58
  • 59. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Lane widths • Up to 35 mph: 10-12 feet • Over 35 mph: 11-12 feet • With buses: 11-12 feet • Bike lanes: 5-6 feet (4 feet outside gutter pan) • Parking: 7-8 feet 59
  • 60. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Medians • Functions – Access management – Pedestrian refuge – Left turn lanes – Aesthetics • Widths – 4-22 feet • Landscaping – Trees (45 mph or less) • 6-10 foot medians - less than 4 inch caliper • 1½ feet lateral clearance 60
  • 61. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Transitions • Geometric transitions (use AASHTO) – Change in thoroughfare width – Lateral shifts – Lane drops • Location: on tangent sections • Context, visual, operational, environmental transition – Speed zone transition – Visual cues • Urban design, land uses, building design, gateways, signs – Change width of thoroughfare 61
  • 62. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Excerpt from ITE CSS guide – cross-sections 6 2
  • 63. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Streetside design • From property line to face of curb • Accommodates street activity – Mobility – Business – Social • Public space 63
  • 64. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Urban streetside uses • Movement of pedestrians • Access to buildings/property • Utilities/appurtenances • Transit stops • Landscaping • Urban design/public art • Sidewalk cafes • Business functions • Civic spaces (plazas, seating) 64
  • 65. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Streetside components • Streetside zones: – Edge Zone – Furnishings Zone – Throughway Zone (ADA) – Frontage Zone • Function and dimensions vary by context zone and adjacent land use 65
  • 66. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Streetside cross-section guidelines C-4 w/ Predominantly Commercial Ground Sidewalk Zone [1] C-6 and C-5 C-4 w/ Predominantly Residential Frontage Floor Use 1.5 feet 1.5 feet 21.5 foot (recommended) 16.5 foot (recommended) Edge 0.5 feet 19 foot (recommended) 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 12 foot (constrained) 12 foot (constrained) 8 feet 7 feet 7 feet Boulevard Furnishings (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or (trees in tree wells) (trees in tree wells) groundcovers) Throughway 10 feet 8 feet 8 feet 0 feet along lawn and groundcover Frontage 3 feet 2.5 feet 1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges 1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences Edge Boulevard Without Parking 0.5 feet 18.5 foot (Recommended) 10 feet Furnishings (landscape strip w/ trees and groundcovers or THIS THOROUGHFARE TYPE NOT APPLICABLE TO THE PREDOMINANTLY low shrubs) Throughway COMMERCIAL GROUND FLOOR LAND USES FOUND IN C-4 THROUGH C-6 CONTEXT 8 feet ZONES 0 feet along lawn and groundcover Frontage 1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges 1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences 1.5 feet 1.5 feet Edge 0.5 feet 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 19.5 foot (recommended) 14.5 foot (recommended) 16 foot (recommended) 12.0 foot (constrained) 8 feet 12 foot (constrained) With 6 feet 6 feet (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or Parking trees in tree wells (trees in tree wells) Furnishings groundcovers) Avenue Without 8 feet with 8 feet with 8 feet with Parking buffer landscaping buffer landscaping buffer landscaping Throughway 9 feet 6 feet 6 feet 0 feet along lawn and groundcover Frontage 3 feet 2.5 feet 1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges 1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences 1.5 feet 1.5 feet 11.5 foot (recommended) Edge 0.5 feet 16 foot (recommended) 16 foot (recommended) 12.0 foot (constrained) 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 2.5 feet at diagonal parking 12 foot (constrained) 5 feet 6 feet 6 feet Furnishings (landscape strip w/ trees and grasses or (trees in tree wells) (trees in tree wells) Street groundcovers) Throughway 6 feet 6 feet 6 feet 0 feet along lawn and groundcover Frontage 2.5 feet 6 2.5 feet 1 foot along low walls, fences, and hedges 6 1.5 feet along facades, tall walls, and fences
  • 67. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Edge zone • Interface with traveled way • Functions – Vehicle overhang and clearance – Door opening area – Wheelchair access at transit stops • No (rural) clear zone width • Lateral clearance – 1½ ft from curb face 67
  • 68. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Furnishings zone • Buffers pedestrians from traveled way • Functions – Street furniture, public art – Utilities (within zone) – Transit stops – Lighting – Public spaces (seating) – Business space (cafes) – Landscaping • Safe landscaping – Sight lines (CPTED) – Sight distances 68
  • 69. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Throughway and frontage zones • Throughway zone – Clear area for pedestrian travel – ADAAG requirements – No utilities • Frontage zone – Area adjacent to property line – “Shy” distance from buildings – Business space (cafes, signs) – Landscaping – Seating – Building access 69
  • 70. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Clear zones on urban thoroughfares • Defined as an edge zone clear of fixed objects • Less consequence than rural context – Lower speeds – Parked vehicles • Often not practical in urban areas • Rural standards not used in urban walkable areas 70
  • 71. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Driveways • Minimize in high pedestrian activity areas • Maintain sidewalk cross slope Best If necessary  71
  • 72. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Traveled way • Central portion of thoroughfare between curbs • Provides for movement of vehicles • Interface with roadside via on-street parking 72
  • 73. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Traveled way components • Functions, modes • Widths, ROW allocations • Through travel and turn lanes • Access management • Parking, transit stops, bike lanes • Emergency vehicle operations • Transitions • Mid-block crosswalks • Medians, pedestrian refuge islands 73
  • 74. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Lane widths • Recommended practice – Urban freeways: • 12 feet normal • 11 feet constrained – Arterials and collectors •10–11 feet on arterials and collectors • 12-feet under special circumstances – Based on: • Target speed • Design vehicle • Right-of-way • Width of adjacent parking and bicycle lanes 74
  • 75. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Medians Recommended Median Widths on Low Speed Thoroughfares (35 mph or less) • Recommended practice Thoroughfare Type Minimum Width Recommende d Width Median for access control Arterial Boulevards and Avenues 4 ft. 6 ft. Collector Avenues and Streets Median for pedestrian refuge Arterial Boulevards and Avenues 6 ft. 8 ft. Collector Avenues and Streets Median for street trees and lighting Arterial Boulevards and Avenues 6 ft. 10 ft. Collector Avenues and Streets Median for single left-turn lane Collector Avenues and Streets 10 ft. 14 ft. Arterial Boulevards and Avenues 12 ft. 16-18 ft. Median for dual left turn lane Arterial Boulevards and Avenues 20 ft. 22 ft. 75
  • 76. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Street trees - Recommended practice • In medians – Min. median width • 6 feet for up to 4” caliper trees • 10 feet for larger trees – Avoid trees larger than 4” caliper • Speed > 45 mph • Or use barrier 76
  • 77. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Bicycle lanes • Recommended practice – Combined with on-street parking = 13 feet – Without on-street parking = 6 feet 77
  • 78. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design On-street parking – recommended practice Recommended Parallel Parking Lane Widths Thoroughfare Type in C-3 through C-6 Context Zones Parallel Parking Lane Width (commercial and residential areas) Arterial Boulevard (commercial) 8 ft. Arterial Boulevard (residential) 7 ft. Parallel Parking Lane Width (residential areas) Arterial Avenue 7 ft. Collector Avenue and Street 7 ft. Parallel Parking Lane Width (commercial areas) Arterial Avenue 8 ft. Collector Avenue and Street 8 ft. 78
  • 79. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Mid-block crosswalks - Recommended practice – Locate so crossings are 200-300 feet apart – Significant pedestrian demand – Criteria • 12,000 ADT or less • 15,000 ADT with median refuge • Speed less than 40 mph • Adequate sight distance 79
  • 80. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Urban intersections • General principles – Minimize conflicts between modes – Minimize pedestrian exposure – Provide crosswalks on all approaches – Minimize curb radii consistent with design/control vehicle – Ensure good visibility – Balance vehicle LOS with pedestrian convenience and safety 80
  • 81. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Urban intersections - Design elements – Through and turning lanes – Intersection sight distance – Medians – Curb return radii – Design vehicle – Channelized right turns – Modern roundabouts – Crosswalks and refuges – Curb extensions – Bicycle lane treatment – Bus stops – Traffic signals 81
  • 82. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Urban intersections • Avoid large undefined open spaces Source: City of Palo Alto CD+A, FPA, and Urban Advantage 82
  • 83. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Urban intersections - Creating opportunities to improve context Source: City of Palo Alto CD+A, FPA, and Urban Advantage 83
  • 84. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Intersections – simplify for all modes 84
  • 85. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Intersections – Curb return radius - recommended practice – Consider • Design vehicle • Effective width • Curb return radii – Minimum radius = 5 feet – Use 10-15 feet radius • High ped volumes • Low turning volumes and speed • Bike/parking lanes create higher effective radii 85
  • 86. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation FDOT TDLC Roads Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Curb extension and effective corner radius 86
  • 87. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Curb extensions • Improve visibility • Reduce crossing width • On streets with parking • Recommended practice – Extend curb line 1 ft. less than parking width – Curb return radius for control vehicle – Use with bus stops to increase waiting area 87
  • 88. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Channelized right turns - recommended practice • Generally discouraged in walkable environments • Signalized intersections with heavy right turns • Low pedestrian volumes • Where pedestrian volumes high – eliminate or install pedestrian signal • Low-angle turn • Clear visibility • Illumination 88
  • 89. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Roundabouts - recommended practice Minimum Urban Urban Urban “Mini- Compact Single-Lane Double-Lane Parameter Roundabout” Roundabout Roundabout Roundabout Maximum Entry Speed (mph) 15 15 20 25 Bus and WB-67 with Bus and Single-unit lane Design Vehicle Single-Unit WB-50 truck drive encroachment Truck over apron on truck apron Inscribed circle diameter (feet) 45 to 80 80 to 100 100 to 130 150 to 180 Maximum number of entering 1 1 1 2 lanes Typical capacity (vehicles per day entering from all 10,000 15,000 20,000 40,000 approaches) Applicability by Thoroughfare Type: Not Not Not Boulevard Applicable Applicable Applicable Applicable Not Not Arterial Avenue Applicable Applicable Applicable Applicable Not Collector Avenue Applicable Applicable Not Applicable Applicable Street Applicable Applicable Applicable Not Applicable 89
  • 90. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design 9 0
  • 91. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Developing Designs Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Roundabouts 91
  • 92. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Design exceptions – 13 controlling criteria – Design/target speed • Vertical alignment – Lane width • Grade – Shoulder width • Stopping sight distance – Bridge width • Vertical clearance – Horizontal alignment • Horizontal clearance – Superelevation • Structural capacity – Cross slope • Needed when – Cannot meet minimums in applicable design manual – Reasonable alternative design will work safely 92
  • 93. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Frequent design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Number state DOTs reporting frequent design exceptions by criterion NCHRP Synthesis 316 93
  • 94. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Consider trade-offs • Mobility, access • Road user needs • Environmental impacts • Capital and operating costs • Safety • Aesthetics • Local considerations 94
  • 95. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Design Domain and Risk Speed or Volume Lower limit of extended design domain – new roads Increasing liability risk, Decreasing scope Extended Normal for defense Design Domain Lower limit of extended design domain – existing roads Standard Design Criteria Minimums Adapted from: O. Arndt, R. Cox, “Using an Enlarged Design Domain for Road Restoration Projects,” Queensland Department of Main Roads, 2006. 95
  • 96. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Strong case – Show criteria not applicable •Project can be safe not following criteria •Environmental or community needs prohibit meeting criteria •Criteria impractical to meet – Weak case •Saves money •Saves time •Designer found loop hole •Design similar to other existing designs 96
  • 97. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Minimum documentation • Established design criteria • Reasons criteria cannot be met • Why proposal is most applicable • Applicable background information • Pertinent information – Safety assessment – Operations 97
  • 98. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exception Form Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design 98
  • 99. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Documentation must be • Deliberative • Defensible • Clearly written • Explicitly evaluate safety – Who is at risk • Motorists, pedestrians, etc. – Exposure • Traffic volumes • Location – Extent of exception – How risk is managed (solely relying on standards does not guaranty facility free of risk) 99
  • 100. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exception Process Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Florida DOT design and utility exception process 100
  • 101. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Rule of thumb for success • No reasonable, feasible, practical solution available that meets criteria, or • Selection of proposed criteria is advantageous and results in overall superior design and • Use of proposed criteria is not expected to unduly degrade or hinder safety or operational performance of the proposed facility 101
  • 102. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design Exceptions Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design Reference (available on-line): 102
  • 103. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Design References Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design AASHTO • A Guide for Achieving Flexibility in Highway Design, 1st Edition • A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets, 5th Edition • Guide for the Planning, Design, and Operation of Pedestrian Facilities, 1st Edition • Guide for High-Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) Facilities, 3rd Edition • Guide for Park-and-Ride Facilities, 2nd Edition • Guide for the Development of Bicycle Facilities, 3rd Edition • Roadside Design Guide, 3rd Edition • Roadway Lighting Design Guide • Design for Transit Vehicles and Facilities on Streets and Highways (pending from TCRP D-09) ITE •Context Sensitive Solutions in Designing Major Urban Thoroughfares for Walkable Communities (2nd edition pending – retitled to Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: A Context Sensitive Approach) •Urban Geometric Design Handbook •Guidelines for Driveway Location and Design •Guidelines for Neighborhood Street Design TRB •A Guide for Transportation Landscape and Environmental Design (update pending) •Access Management Manual 103
  • 104. Context Sensitive Solutions in Transportation Class Project Discussion Planning, Environmental Analysis and Design • Projects to be – Presented Class 28 – Submitted at start of Class 29 • Student questions? 104

Editor's Notes

  1. Insert ITE CSS cross-section sketch
  2. Location: S.F. peninsula - El Camino Real @ Los Robles – EXISTING CONDITIONS