I present this presentation at Journalism 101, a two days workshop for journalist by Embassy of The United States Jakarta-Indonesia, April 11-12 2013. Part 1: A way to visualize and report events Part 2: Role of journalists in verifying crowd-sourced information

1. iskandar zulkarnaen | KOMPAS.com community editor | 4/12/2013

2. ISKANDAR
ZULKARNAEN Community Editor KOMPAS.com, 2011
 Jurnalist KOMPAS.com, 2009
 Copywriter KOMPAS.com, 2007
 Journalist Republika, 2004
S1  UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta,
Perbankan Syariah, 2002
www.kompasiana.com/iskandarjet
www.facebook.com/iskandarjet
www.twitter.com/iskandarjet
www.slideshare.net/iskandarjet
http://iskandarjet.wordpress.com

3.  Editor
 Writer
 Blogger
 Reporter
 Presenter
 Trainer
@iskandarjet
081314487352
iskandar@kompas.com
iskandarjet@gmail.com

4. PLAY THE VIDEO
Three Little Pigs
Cannes Lion Award
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDGrfhJH1P4

5. Where’s
CROWDSOURCING
come from?

6. It’s come from
SOMETHING
Products
Services
Content
Ideas
AFFORDABLE

7. CROWDSOURCING
is how the power of the many can be
leveraged to accomplish feats that were
once the responsibility of a specialized
few—Jeff Howe, author of
“Crowdsourcing”

8. CROWDSOURCING
is the practice of obtaining needed
services, ideas, or content by soliciting
contributions from a large group of
people, and especially from an online
community, rather than from traditional
employees or suppliers—Wikipedia

9. Marketplace for work

14. 2012 Online Donation for
Obama Campaign
0 Key Success: 78% of US Populations are using Internet
(245 million of 314 million people)
0 The campaign raising more than $700 million online.
That figure is up from the just under $500 million it
raised in 2008.
0 Obama brought in approximately $58.5 million from
individuals who donated $200 or less
0 Jim Messina, the campaign manager of Obama for
America said, that his team had built "the biggest
grassroots campaign in modern American history”

15. Cracking the Proto-Elamite
Code

20. PLAY THE VIDEO
Life in A Day
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePfNcj-SaZM

21. What about
CROWDSOURCING
News?

22. JFK Assassination, 1963
Abraham Zapruder
(1905 –1970)
PLAY VIDEO
JFK Assassination (Abraham Zapruder_s
8mm Filming, Best Qual)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51o8
-35SKK0

23. The guy who caused the riots,
1991
Rodney G King
George Holliday
and his Sony
handycam

24. Japan Tsunami, 2011
PLAY VIDEO
2011 Japan Tsunami Onagawa
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEQ0uu9XXlc

25. Mainstream vs Social Media
0 BROADCAST: top-down news
Pengiklan
Organisasi Media
TV,
Koran,
Majalah,
Website,
dll
Pemirsa,
Pembaca
Dan Gillmor, San Jose Mercury News

26. Mainstream vs Social Media
0 INTERCAST: bottom-up news
Komunitas Komunitas
Dan Gillmor, San Jose Mercury News

27. Crowd commonly write
about…
0 What is happening around
0 Product or service experience
0 Opinion, reaction, different viewpoints on news or
issue

28. Citizen News Identity
0 Reports from the scene
 Accidence, suicide, traffic, disaster
0 Not tied to the values ​​of mainstream news
 Magnitude, proximity, conflict, etc...
0 Light and attractive
 SBY mattress, travel, figure of beggars
0 Writing style: Narative

29. Social Media Channels
0 Blog: Online Jurnal online based on text or writing

30. Social Media Channels
0 Micro-Blog: Social media with mini content. The top
three: Twitter, Jaiku, Identi.ca

31. Social Media Channels
0 Podcast: Downloadable Content on audio or video format.
Soundcloud, podcast.com, iTunes U.

32. Social Media Channels
0 Social Network: Connect with others. Facebook, MySpace,
LinkedIn.

33. Social Media Channels
0 Crowdsourcing news: user-generated content, blogging,
networking in one platform.

34. OhmyNews, Korea (2000)
Oh Yeon Ho

35. NowPublic, Canada (2005)
Michael Tippett, Leonard Brody and Michael E. Meyers

36. Oknation, Thailand (2007)*

37. Kompasiana, Indonesia (2008)

38. KOMPASIANA
Is citizen media and crowdsourcing
content (news, opinion, fiction) that
empowering ordinary citizen.
Kompasiana manage every content like
what mass media did.

39. Milestone
2009
• In 2009,
Kompasiana
changed it’s
platform to social
blog with social
network features
for all netizen in
Indonesia.
2010
• Kompasiana
awarded silver
medal from Asian
Digital Awards
(ADMA 2010) as
the best content
in user-generated
content category.
2011
• Developed
Hybrid
Journalism in
KOMPAS.com
online news
portal as well as
KOMPAS daily
newspaper.
2012
• Kompasiana is
more social with
a lot of developed
sharing and
interaction
features.
• Kompasiana online for the very first time as the blog network
for Kompas Gramedia journalists, August 2008 .2008

40. Alexa Comparative (Traffic Rank)

41. Alexa Comparative (Pageviews)

43. NEWS FROM
CITIZEN

44. 0 Unique Visitor : 7,537,953 users
0 Visit : 8,955,941 visits
0 Pageviews : 12,184,378 opened pages
Google Analytic,
Sept 17, 2012 – Oct 17, 2012
0 Rank on Alexa : #29 in Indonesia
0 Local Website Rank : #11 Indonesian
Website
KOMPASIANA FACT SHEET

45. Awards
Best in
Citizen Journalism
Pesta Blogger 2010
Marketeers Netizen
Champions
MarkPlus

46. Awards
Asian Digital Media
Awards 2010
Best in Digital Content –
User Generated Content
WAN-IFRA

47. Blook

48. http://fiksiana.kompasiana.com/

49. HIGHLIGHTED CONTENTS

50. Indomie Raid, 2010

55. komisi8@yahoo.com, 2011

56. Sprindik Carrier

57. HYBRID JOURNALISM

62. Freez

63. CROWDSOURCE TOOLS

64. CNN iReport, USA (2006)

65. uReport – FOX News 2007

66. Stomp, Singapore (2007)*

72. CROWDMAP

75. iskandar zulkarnaen | KOMPAS.com community editor | 4/12/2013

76. Is it another kind of
CITIZEN
JOURNALISM?

77. The Definition
“The act of a citizen, or group of citizens, playing an
active role in the process of collecting, reporting,
analyzing and disseminating news and information.
The intent of this participation is to provide
independent, reliable, accurate, wide-ranging and
relevant information that a democracy requires.”
—Shayne Bowman and Chris Willis, Penulis We Media: How
Audiences are Shaping the Future of News and Information

78. The Prediction
“Citizens will produce 50 percent
of the news peer-to-peer in 2021
We Media: How Audiences are Shaping the Future of News and Information

79. The Layers
READ ARTICLE
The 11 Layers of Citizen Journalism
http://www.poynter.org/uncategorized/69328/the-11-
layers-of-citizen-journalism/

80. Incorrect examples

87. Apakah CJ sesuatu yang ideal?
0 Identitas dan kredibilitas sumber tidak jelas
0 Informasi yang disampaikan tidak komprehensif dan
out-of-context
0 Cara penyampaian tidak baku

88. HOW
To dig information from the crowd?

89. 0 Investigasi kasus. Ajak mereka mengungkap kasus
yang sedang terjadi.

90. 0 General observation. Angkat satu tema atau isu,
meminta mereka menceritakan yang terjadi
sekitarnya.

91. 0 Breaking News. Ajak warga menyampaikan peristiwa
atau kejadian yang terjadi di sekitar mereka

92. HOW
To verify crowd-sourced information

93. 0 Perlakukan warga sebagai sumber informasi
0 Waspadai akun palsu atau pembajakan akun
0 Waspadai informasi daur-ulang
0 Cek dan ricek, mutlak dilakukan:
0 Hubungi narasumber secara personal, lewat DM, Pesan
Facebook, Email, Telepon, atau SMS
0 Cek media sosial, apakah isu yang diangkat menjadi
perbincangan banyak orang
0 Cek lokasi foto
0 Warga tidak beraksi sebagai wartawan dan tidak terikat
dengan Kode Etik Jurnalistik

94. iskandar zulkarnaen | KOMPAS.com community editor | 4/12/2013