Teaching Comprehension
Victoria Principe
“If we want students to
think differently, we
need to teach
differently.”
--Hilda Taba
Purposes for Reading
• Literary Experience —aesthetic reading;
Examples: novel, play, story, poem
• To Be Informed —efferent reading;
Examples: magazine, textbook, newspaper
• To Perform a Task —complete a process;
Examples: recipes, manuals, schedules
Tenets of Reading Comprehension
(McLaughlin & Allen, 2002)
Balanced literacy is a framework that fosters reading comprehension
Excellent reading teachers influence students’ learning
Reading needs to occur in meaningful contexts
Good readers are strategic and take an active role in the reading process
Comprehension skills and strategies can be taught
Students will benefit from transacting with a variety of genre as well as a
variety of levels
Engagement is an important factor in the comprehension process
Vocabulary instruction affects reading comprehension
Comprehension is a social constructivist process
Assessment informs instruction for reading comprehension
The Reading Process
STAGES
• Preparing to read—set purposes,
preview text, connect to own
experiences
• Reading—make predictions, use
skills & strategies as they read
the text
• Responding—respond to text
orally or in writing
• Exploring—revisit text to
discuss author’s style,
vocabulary and to think
critically, engage in minilessons
on strategies
• Applying—create projects,
reflect on reading
TEACHING IDEAS
• Probable Passages, Predict-o-
gram, Anticipation Guide, List-
Group-Label
• Think Aloud, Say Something,
Concept Squares, Sketch to
Stretch
• Reading Log, Literature Circle,
Double Entry Journal
• Reread Text, Concept/Word
Map, Story Map, Grammar
Lesson, Story Pyramids, Sequel
or Pattern Book, Word Sort,
Minilesson on concept or skills
• Reader’s Theatre, Diorama, Read
another book by same author
Adapted from Gail Tompkins, 1997
Reading Comprehension Strategies
(McLaughlin & Allen, 2002)
PREVIEWING—activating prior knowledge, predicting, setting
purposes
SELF-QUESTIONING—generating questions to guide reading
MAKING CONNECTIONS—relating reading to self, text, others,
and world
VISUALIZING—creating mental pictures and images while reading
the text
KNOWING HOW WORDS WORK—understanding words through
vocabulary development, including the use of a variety of cueing
systems for figuring out unknown words
MONITORING—asking if what is being read makes sense and
clarifying by adapting strategic processes to accommodate the
response
SUMMARIZING—synthesizing important concepts and ideas
EVALUATING—making judgements
Text Comprehension
• How to read both
narrative and expository
texts
• How to understand and
remember what they read
• How to relate their own
knowledge or experiences
to text
• How to use comprehension
strategies to improve
their comprehension
• How to communicate with
others about what they
read
• Explicitly explain, model, and
teach comprehension strategies,
such as previewing and
summarizing text
• Provide comprehension
instruction before, during, and
after reading narrative and
expository texts
• Promote thinking and extended
discourse by asking questions
and encouraging student
questions and discussions
• Use systematic classroom-based
instructional assessment to
inform instruction
• Adapted from PDE Website
What Students Need to Learn How We Teach It
INSTRUCTION OF COMPREHENSION
STRATEGIES
(McLaughlin & Allen, 2002)
EXPLAIN
DEMONSTRATE
GUIDE
PRACTICE
REFLECT
Comprehension is a social constructivist process…
Children will learn by making connections and by communicating with
others about their reading and thinking.
Predict-Read-Discuss Day
Name ________________
Name ________________
Title: ________________
Pages Read: ____ to ____
Directions: Make predictions about
text before reading. Share
predictions with your partner. Read
with your partner to confirm or
disconfirm predictions, discuss the
outcome and continue with the cycle.
•I predicted…
•This strategy helped me because…
•My predictions were…
BOOKMARK
STRATEGY
Reading Strategies for Active Readers
Make Connections
Ask Questions
Visualize
Draw Inferences
Determine Important Ideas
!
Synthesize Information
Repair Understanding
Goodreadersarestrategicandtakeactiverolesinthe
readingprocess…
Good readers are strategic and take
active roles in the reading process…
Bookmark Strategy
•Model through think aloud each of
the strategies on the bookmark.
•Provide students time to practice
using the bookmark while you monitor
what they are doing.
•Finally, allow students to use the
bookmarks for partner reading,
literature circles and guided reading
groups.
Students benefit from transacting with different genres at a variety
of levels…
Genres
Fiction
Expository (Nonfiction)
Fantasy
Realistic Fiction
Historical Fiction
Biography
Mystery
Levels
Independent
Literature Circles
Discussion Groups
Instructional
Guided Reading
Shared Reading
Buddy Reading
Difficult (Frustrational)
Read Aloud
COMPREHENSION SKILLS
AND STRATEGIES CAN BE
TAUGHT…
The Guided Comprehension Model
McLaughlin & Allen, 2002
Assessment
Assessment
Teacher Directed Comprehension
Instruction – Whole Group
Explain
Demonstrate
Guide
Practice
Reflect
Review
Guide
Practice
Reflect
Teacher Facilitated -
Small group (4-6 students)
Teacher Facilitated Reflection
and Goal Setting – Whole Class
Share
Reflect
Set new goals
Student
Facilitated
Comprehension
Routines
Student
Facilitated
Comprehension
Centers
PREVIEWING—
Anticipation-Reaction Guide
Expository or Narrative
PREVIEWING—
Anticipation Guide
Expository or Narrative
PREVIEWING—
Probable Passages
Narrative
SELF-QUESTIONING—
Thick and Thin Questions
Expository or Narrative
MAKING CONNECTIONS—
Double-Entry Journal
Narrative or Expository
VISUALIZING—
Sketch Through the Text
Expository or Narrative
KNOWING HOW WORDS WORK—
Rivet: Vocabulary Instruction
Expository or Narrative
KNOWING HOW WORDS WORK—
Concept of Definition Map
Expository or Narrative
MONITORING—
Patterned Partner Reading
Narrative or Expository
SUMMARIZING—
Summary Cube
Expository or Narrative
SUMMARIZING—
Bio Pyramid
Expository or Narrative
SUMMARIZING—
Main Idea Table
Expository
EVALUATING--
Journal Response/Alternate
Ending
Narrative
Assessment informs instruction for reading
comprehension…
Provides an approximate range of reading levels
for students
Offers insights into student attitudes and
interests
Facilitates student-text matches
Informs grouping for teacher-guided instruction
Provides windows to students’ thinking
Documents students’ performance
Provides information for evaluating progress
(McLaughlin & Allen, 2002)
REFLECTION & GOAL-SETTING
ORGANIZATION
ORGANIZATION
Reading is…
• Reading means the world to
me. It’s who I am. If anyone
ever took all my books away
and there weren’t any left in
the world, there would be no
more me.
Emily Nadal, Grade 3
• Reading is something teachers
use to get us hooked on
school.
Rosie Parker,
Grade 3
• Reading is exercise for your
brain.
Ashley Todd, Grade 4

Comprehension

  • 1.
  • 2.
    “If we wantstudents to think differently, we need to teach differently.” --Hilda Taba
  • 3.
    Purposes for Reading •Literary Experience —aesthetic reading; Examples: novel, play, story, poem • To Be Informed —efferent reading; Examples: magazine, textbook, newspaper • To Perform a Task —complete a process; Examples: recipes, manuals, schedules
  • 4.
    Tenets of ReadingComprehension (McLaughlin & Allen, 2002) Balanced literacy is a framework that fosters reading comprehension Excellent reading teachers influence students’ learning Reading needs to occur in meaningful contexts Good readers are strategic and take an active role in the reading process Comprehension skills and strategies can be taught Students will benefit from transacting with a variety of genre as well as a variety of levels Engagement is an important factor in the comprehension process Vocabulary instruction affects reading comprehension Comprehension is a social constructivist process Assessment informs instruction for reading comprehension
  • 5.
    The Reading Process STAGES •Preparing to read—set purposes, preview text, connect to own experiences • Reading—make predictions, use skills & strategies as they read the text • Responding—respond to text orally or in writing • Exploring—revisit text to discuss author’s style, vocabulary and to think critically, engage in minilessons on strategies • Applying—create projects, reflect on reading TEACHING IDEAS • Probable Passages, Predict-o- gram, Anticipation Guide, List- Group-Label • Think Aloud, Say Something, Concept Squares, Sketch to Stretch • Reading Log, Literature Circle, Double Entry Journal • Reread Text, Concept/Word Map, Story Map, Grammar Lesson, Story Pyramids, Sequel or Pattern Book, Word Sort, Minilesson on concept or skills • Reader’s Theatre, Diorama, Read another book by same author Adapted from Gail Tompkins, 1997
  • 6.
    Reading Comprehension Strategies (McLaughlin& Allen, 2002) PREVIEWING—activating prior knowledge, predicting, setting purposes SELF-QUESTIONING—generating questions to guide reading MAKING CONNECTIONS—relating reading to self, text, others, and world VISUALIZING—creating mental pictures and images while reading the text KNOWING HOW WORDS WORK—understanding words through vocabulary development, including the use of a variety of cueing systems for figuring out unknown words MONITORING—asking if what is being read makes sense and clarifying by adapting strategic processes to accommodate the response SUMMARIZING—synthesizing important concepts and ideas EVALUATING—making judgements
  • 7.
    Text Comprehension • Howto read both narrative and expository texts • How to understand and remember what they read • How to relate their own knowledge or experiences to text • How to use comprehension strategies to improve their comprehension • How to communicate with others about what they read • Explicitly explain, model, and teach comprehension strategies, such as previewing and summarizing text • Provide comprehension instruction before, during, and after reading narrative and expository texts • Promote thinking and extended discourse by asking questions and encouraging student questions and discussions • Use systematic classroom-based instructional assessment to inform instruction • Adapted from PDE Website What Students Need to Learn How We Teach It
  • 8.
    INSTRUCTION OF COMPREHENSION STRATEGIES (McLaughlin& Allen, 2002) EXPLAIN DEMONSTRATE GUIDE PRACTICE REFLECT
  • 9.
    Comprehension is asocial constructivist process… Children will learn by making connections and by communicating with others about their reading and thinking. Predict-Read-Discuss Day Name ________________ Name ________________ Title: ________________ Pages Read: ____ to ____ Directions: Make predictions about text before reading. Share predictions with your partner. Read with your partner to confirm or disconfirm predictions, discuss the outcome and continue with the cycle. •I predicted… •This strategy helped me because… •My predictions were… BOOKMARK STRATEGY
  • 10.
    Reading Strategies forActive Readers Make Connections Ask Questions Visualize Draw Inferences Determine Important Ideas ! Synthesize Information Repair Understanding Goodreadersarestrategicandtakeactiverolesinthe readingprocess…
  • 11.
    Good readers arestrategic and take active roles in the reading process… Bookmark Strategy •Model through think aloud each of the strategies on the bookmark. •Provide students time to practice using the bookmark while you monitor what they are doing. •Finally, allow students to use the bookmarks for partner reading, literature circles and guided reading groups.
  • 12.
    Students benefit fromtransacting with different genres at a variety of levels… Genres Fiction Expository (Nonfiction) Fantasy Realistic Fiction Historical Fiction Biography Mystery Levels Independent Literature Circles Discussion Groups Instructional Guided Reading Shared Reading Buddy Reading Difficult (Frustrational) Read Aloud
  • 13.
  • 14.
    The Guided ComprehensionModel McLaughlin & Allen, 2002 Assessment Assessment Teacher Directed Comprehension Instruction – Whole Group Explain Demonstrate Guide Practice Reflect Review Guide Practice Reflect Teacher Facilitated - Small group (4-6 students) Teacher Facilitated Reflection and Goal Setting – Whole Class Share Reflect Set new goals Student Facilitated Comprehension Routines Student Facilitated Comprehension Centers
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    SELF-QUESTIONING— Thick and ThinQuestions Expository or Narrative
  • 19.
  • 20.
    VISUALIZING— Sketch Through theText Expository or Narrative
  • 21.
    KNOWING HOW WORDSWORK— Rivet: Vocabulary Instruction Expository or Narrative
  • 22.
    KNOWING HOW WORDSWORK— Concept of Definition Map Expository or Narrative
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Assessment informs instructionfor reading comprehension… Provides an approximate range of reading levels for students Offers insights into student attitudes and interests Facilitates student-text matches Informs grouping for teacher-guided instruction Provides windows to students’ thinking Documents students’ performance Provides information for evaluating progress (McLaughlin & Allen, 2002)
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
    Reading is… • Readingmeans the world to me. It’s who I am. If anyone ever took all my books away and there weren’t any left in the world, there would be no more me. Emily Nadal, Grade 3 • Reading is something teachers use to get us hooked on school. Rosie Parker, Grade 3 • Reading is exercise for your brain. Ashley Todd, Grade 4

Editor's Notes

  • #8 <number> Additional information: Text comprehension is the process that enables readers to make meaning of text and to communicate meaning about what was read (National Reading Panel, 2000). Comprehension strategies are conscious plans or procedures, that good readers use to help them be aware of how well they are comprehending as they read and write (National Reading Panel, 2000).