Pair1 Tracks by RobynDavidsonandInto the WilddirectedbySeanPen
Compare the waysin whichcharacters inTracks andInto the Wild seek todiscoverwhatreally
mattersto them.
Compare how, inTracks and Intothe Wild, the natural environmentisbothwelcomingandhostile
Pair2 InvictusdirectedbyClintEastwoodandRansombyDavidMalouf
‘Revenge isfutile. Forgiveness isliberating.’ Compare how the twotextsexamine revengeand
forgiveness.
“The opportunity toact for ourselves. Totry somethingthatmightforceeventsintoadifferent
course.”(Ransom) Compare thewaysthe two textsexplore opportunities forchange.
Pair3 StasilandbyAnnaFunderandNineteenEighty-FourbyGeorge Orwell
“People were crazy withpainand secrets.”(Stasiland) “…if youwanttokeepa secretyoumust also
hide itfromyourself.”(NineteenEighty-Four) Compare how secretsaffectthe charactersinthese
texts.
Compare the waysthe two textsshow thatin orderto retainpowerauthorities rewrite history
Pair4 Joyful Strains:MakingAustraliaHome byKentMacCarter and Ali Lemer(eds),and The
Namesake byJhumpaLahir
‘It ispossible toneverfeel completely athome ina new country.’ Compare how these twotexts
examine thispossibility.
‘For many migrantfamilies, itisthe desires andexperiences of previous generations thatshape their
own.’ Compare how thisideaisexplored inthese texts.
Pair5 The Crucible byArthurMillerandYear of Wonders:A Novel of the Plague byGeraldine Brook
Compare how The Crucible andYear of Wondersexplore issuesof victimisation andblame
‘Ordinary people sometimes make extraordinary sacrifices forothers.’ Compare how thisideais
demonstrated inthese texts.
Pair6 Bombshells byJoannaMurray-SmithandThe Penelopiad:The Mythof Penelopeand
OdysseusbyMargaret Atwood
Compare the waysthat womenview otherwomeninbothBombshellsandThe Penelopiad.
Compare what the two texts say about individuals finding their
own solutions to life’s challenges.
Pair7 Black DiggersbyTom Wrightand The LongestMemorybyFred D’Aguiar
“The properwordisfair.” (The LongestMemory) “…I wishtopointout the gross injustice …” (Black
Diggers) Compare whatthese textssay aboutfairness andjustice.
Compare how these textsexplore the importanceof belonging.
Pair8 I Am Malala: The Girl WhoStood Up for EducationandWas Shot bythe Talibanby Malala
Yousafzai withChristinaLamb,andMade inDagenhamdirectedbyNigel Cole
Compare how the issue of genderinequality isexploredinthe twotexts.
‘Power comes fromunity and persistence.’ Compare how the issueof commitmenttoa cause is
presented inthe twotexts.

Comparative Essay prompts - All from 2017 - English VCE

  • 1.
    Pair1 Tracks byRobynDavidsonandInto the WilddirectedbySeanPen Compare the waysin whichcharacters inTracks andInto the Wild seek todiscoverwhatreally mattersto them. Compare how, inTracks and Intothe Wild, the natural environmentisbothwelcomingandhostile Pair2 InvictusdirectedbyClintEastwoodandRansombyDavidMalouf ‘Revenge isfutile. Forgiveness isliberating.’ Compare how the twotextsexamine revengeand forgiveness. “The opportunity toact for ourselves. Totry somethingthatmightforceeventsintoadifferent course.”(Ransom) Compare thewaysthe two textsexplore opportunities forchange. Pair3 StasilandbyAnnaFunderandNineteenEighty-FourbyGeorge Orwell “People were crazy withpainand secrets.”(Stasiland) “…if youwanttokeepa secretyoumust also hide itfromyourself.”(NineteenEighty-Four) Compare how secretsaffectthe charactersinthese texts. Compare the waysthe two textsshow thatin orderto retainpowerauthorities rewrite history Pair4 Joyful Strains:MakingAustraliaHome byKentMacCarter and Ali Lemer(eds),and The Namesake byJhumpaLahir ‘It ispossible toneverfeel completely athome ina new country.’ Compare how these twotexts examine thispossibility. ‘For many migrantfamilies, itisthe desires andexperiences of previous generations thatshape their own.’ Compare how thisideaisexplored inthese texts. Pair5 The Crucible byArthurMillerandYear of Wonders:A Novel of the Plague byGeraldine Brook Compare how The Crucible andYear of Wondersexplore issuesof victimisation andblame ‘Ordinary people sometimes make extraordinary sacrifices forothers.’ Compare how thisideais demonstrated inthese texts.
  • 2.
    Pair6 Bombshells byJoannaMurray-SmithandThePenelopiad:The Mythof Penelopeand OdysseusbyMargaret Atwood Compare the waysthat womenview otherwomeninbothBombshellsandThe Penelopiad. Compare what the two texts say about individuals finding their own solutions to life’s challenges. Pair7 Black DiggersbyTom Wrightand The LongestMemorybyFred D’Aguiar “The properwordisfair.” (The LongestMemory) “…I wishtopointout the gross injustice …” (Black Diggers) Compare whatthese textssay aboutfairness andjustice. Compare how these textsexplore the importanceof belonging. Pair8 I Am Malala: The Girl WhoStood Up for EducationandWas Shot bythe Talibanby Malala Yousafzai withChristinaLamb,andMade inDagenhamdirectedbyNigel Cole Compare how the issue of genderinequality isexploredinthe twotexts. ‘Power comes fromunity and persistence.’ Compare how the issueof commitmenttoa cause is presented inthe twotexts.