1. Sustainability in Tourism Unit
Unit Definition & Teaching Schedule
1. The Nature of Sustainability
Ethics & morality (and relationship to the law, regulation & self regulation)
Individual & socio-cultural context
Absolutism v relativism
2. Diffusion & Adoption of ‘Innovations’ (such as Sustainability)
Diffusion: message; media; influencers
Adoption: comparative advantage (at the level of the individual / organisation)
3. The ‘Origins’ of Sustainability
Ancient
Modern
Scale/ rate of growth of resource use / depletion.
Measurement of impacts & causal links (health / environment etc)
Message: need to change the terms of trade / slow development / compensate
‘Gaia’ theory (Lovelock) – ‘Managed Retreat’ rather than Sustainable Growth
Al Gore: ‘An Inconvenient Truth’
Monbiot, George: 'Heat'
4. Take-up of the Modern Message of Sustainability (generally)
Diffusion & Definitions:
Pressure groups / Science / Academics
World community (World Commission on Env & Devmt.)
National / Regional / Local / Organisational
Public / Private / Voluntary sector
Information / education / society / professional & peer groups
The Fair Trade movement
Adoption:
Receiving the message (recipients & perceptions)
Developed world
Less-Developed World
Decoding the message (recipients & perceptions)
Developed world
Less-Developed World
Response to the message
Some ethical trading (genuine)
Some ‘cosmethics’
2. 4. Take-up of the Modern Message of Sustainability (Contd.)
Inhibitors of Take-Up:
Role of profit and price in capitalist / Western societies
Willingness to bear the cost?
Lack of ‘critical mass’ (to reduce cost)
(In)consistency of message
Politics
3rd world priorities (v 1st world)
Difficulty of ‘enforcing’ ethics.
5. The Tourism Industry Context
The classic modern Tourism Development Model:
Profit-oriented
Low-cost driven
Short-termist
Western led (values & resources)
Homogenisation / western hegemony (socio-cultural)
Lack of community empowerment / (genuine) involvement
Environmental impact (natural)
Economic impacts
leakage
limited sharing of local benefits
local costs
Irreversible over-development
Lack of ‘policing’
The scale of the problem
Present global tourism volumes
WTO forecasts
Problem contradiction: massive demand growth-v-need to slow down growth and
its impacts.
6. The Tourism Industry & Sustainability to date.
Definitions & Principles of Sustainable Tourism:
Are they feasible / viable?
Confusions in terminology (Sustainable, Alternative, Eco, Green, Pro-Poor,
Responsible, Fair-Trade)
Local Agenda 21
WTO Code of Ethics for Tourism
EU & NTO approaches
Case illustrations: (inter alia)
British Airways ‘Tourism of Tomorrow Awards’ projects
Eco-Tourism labelling (Costa Rica)
Pro-Poor Tourism Projects etc
Green Globe
3. 7. Tourism Industry: An Analysis of Sustainability Progress to date.
Principally small scale projects
Temptation to ‘grow’ sustainable projects beyond carrying capacities
Some green veneer / cosmethics marketing
Impossibility of translating the mass market into small scale / low density model
The ironic ‘sustainable value’ of high density resort development
ISO sustainability standards
Sustainable and sustainable tourism brands, logos, certification and labelling schemes
8. The way forward: ‘carrots & sticks’ in short/medium/long term
Accept the mass model will not change overnight & consider strategies to improve
sustainability within the current supply side (subsidies / regulation & enforcement /
information & education)
Information and education of current & future tourists and hosts
LPHT Sustainable Tourism Teaching Schedule
Block Title
Introduction. Introduction to unit, resources, assessment.
The Nature of Sustainability: moral and ethical context.
Coursework Assignments set.
1 The ‘Origins’ of Sustainability
Micro Assignment Tutor Consultation
Macro Assignment Brainstorm & Progress Report
2 Diffusion & Adoption of ‘Innovations’ and the ‘take-up’ of the modern
concept of sustainability’ in society and business.
3 The Sustainable Tourism context.
4 The record of Tourism on Sustainability
5 Where do we go from here?
Macro Assignment Presentations: Assessed
These broad titles represent and reflect the 8 topic areas identified in the Unit Description.
4. Coursework Assignment Outline
In this unit you will have TWO pieces of assessed coursework, weighted as follows:
60% Assignment 1 Individual Written ‘Micro’
40% Assignment 2 Team Presentational ‘Macro’
Assignment 1 Can the world afford me?
Do I think 'Sustainability' when I think 'Tourism'?
"I may be beginning to think sustainably in my home life when it comes to switching off
lights and recycling paper, glass and plastic; but when I think about choosing a holiday,
sustainability, frankly, just does not enter into it as a consideration. I suppose this is
because holidays are an escape from the cares of the day-to-day. If I'm honest I choose my
Tourism destination, transport and accommodation on the basis of value for money,
attractiveness, speed and personal convenience. My choices are not influenced by the
planet's carrying capacity at all – if we were so influenced, knowing, for example, the
massive pollution impact of air travel, no-one would ever fly, and that would be the end of
the Tourism industry." A.Typical-Tourist (2011)
NOW: Candidly analyse and evaluate yourself and your personal beliefs, attitudes and
actions in respect of your general consumption and, more specifically, in relation to
your Tourism choices. To what extent does the above quotation apply to you.? What
will it take for you to make Tourism choices which lie (as the World Commission on
Environment and Development put it) 'within the planet's ecological means'? [Include a
Carbon Footprint Calculator score in your report which indicates the number of planet
Earths we would need were everyone to live and consume like you... and your reaction to
your score].
Nature Individual. Written.
Weighting: 60%
Date set: First sustainability session
Date due: First sustainability class in the new year
(to be handed to Tutor in class).
Limit: 2000 Words Maximum
Format: Self- analytical report (NOT essay) .
Language: English or French. (NB. No penalties for errors in English as long as
your meaning is abundantly clear and I don’t have to guess at your
intention.)
5. Assignment 2 Sustainable Tourism TaskForce Alsace.
CONTEXT. (NB. I have made this up.... but something like this has to be going on
somewhere soon.... it could even be the subject of an EU programme if one drew in other
partners in other EU states!).........
The Minister for Sustainability, the Minister with responsibility for Tourism, the Nicholas
Hulot Foundation and regional/local government & Tourism authorities in Alsace have
joined forces and resources to develop a pilot project in Alsace, a Tourism
Sustainability TaskForce to make Tourism consumers think and act more
sustainably and Tourism suppliers operate more sustainably across all Tourism sub-
sectors.
This is NOT designed primarily to develop tent-based, low-impact eco-holidays in the
Vosges, but principally to make the existing Alsace Tourism operations and
consumers act far more sustainably. This is not just about Tourism IN or TO Alsace,
but also involves natives leaving Alsace to holiday elsewhere. This is therefore supply
AND demand side and looking at immediate, short, medium and long term actions.
The partners envisage the development and implementation of a fully-integrated Action
Programme.
[NB.This view is predicated upon the perception that the small, niche, green, responsible,
market is being served by a small number of providers – the real problem is with the mass
market which appears largely untouched, unconcerned and unchanging: A three-star
business hotel in the middle of town cannot obviously suddenly move to the countryside in
log cabins with wood harvested from sustainable forests.... but perhaps it can consider its
energy use, insulation, purchasing, staff training, advice to guests etc....]
Your first task is thus to produce a 'Position Statement', clearly identifying the 'problem',
then to brainstorm up potential solutions and opportunities then crystallise them in the
form of an Action Programme which is:
clear and well-structured,
identifies responsible bodies and individuals
defines the timeframes within which the activities they are leading should be
delivered.
[Your client is effectively after a 'turn-key' product from you: you show them to the 'door',
give them the 'key' and all they have to do is turn it to find everything ready and waiting to
'roll'].
You will present this project Action Programme to your client accompanied by a
written report.
6. The partners commissioning this research then intend to approve, resource and implement
your Action Programme and to promote it as an example of 'Best Practice' which may be
'cloned' elsewhere in France and Europe.
Nature Group / Team. Written & Presented.
Weighting: 40%
Date set: First day of sustainability unit
Date due: The final class of January Presentation to client & report submitted.
Limit: 5000 Words Maximum
Format: Report style
Language: English
NB. This is a 'project' for the whole group, but you will need to divide up your resources into
teams. I will be assessing not just the oral presentation to client and the written report, but
also the brainstorming session(s) and your overall management of this project. Wherever
there is team or group work I expect broadly equal contributions from all individuals and will
moderate individual marks where attendance, commitment and participation is lacking.
This is not a project 'about the state of Sustainability within the Tourism Industry', it is a
project designed to actually produce change in the industry. It will require you to establish
creative solutions!