Sustainability  &  Place  
  Community  Matters  Conference  
       Denver,  Colorado  
       ©  Ed  McMahon  
What  is  Sustainable  
Development  and  
why  is  it  vital?  


                                           -- Brent
                    Toderian, Planning Director,
                    Vancouver, B.C
development is development
that meets the needs of the present without
     compromising the ability of future
   generations to meet their own


             Source: United Nations, Bruntland
                           Commission Report
It is about our children
harmony between man and


      -Aldo Leopold
Sustainability Goals
Healthy Environment

Vigorous Economy

Vibrant Community
Why Sustainability Now ?
                Climate Change
                Energy Issues
                Infrastructure
                Deficit
                Unsustainable
                Land use
                Population Growth
                Makes Business
                Sense
Global Warming

        unequivocal, and
        human activity is the
        main driver, very
        likely causing most of
        the rise in
        temperatures since

        Intergovernmental Panel on
        Climate Change Feb. 2007
Moral Imperative?
Climate Chaos

       hottest summer, in
       the hottest year, in
       the hottest decade



       Source: National Oceanic and
       Atmospheric Administration 2010
Regulatory Imperative?
           33 states representing 70% of US
           population are developing climate
           action plans.

           21 states have set carbon reduction
           targets.

           1060 US Mayors, representing over
           100 million people have adopted the
           Kyoto Protocol.

           President Obama endorsed and the
           US House of Representatives passed
           legislation to cap & trade carbon
           emissions.

           US EPA is now regulating carbon

           Sources: Newsweek, US Conference of Mayors,
High Energy Prices?
           In 1970 the US imported
           24% of its oil from foreign
           providers
           In 1990 the US imported
           42% of its oil
           In 2008 the US imported
           70% of its oil
           The cost of imported oil
           reached over $600 billion
           per year in 2008
Do you think the
long term trend
for energy prices
is to go up or
down?
Unsustainable Land Use in USA




Large  Lot  Subdivisions     Strip  Commercial  
Taking Up More Space
                Household vs. Lot Size
Lot
Size




Family
Size

         Even though the number of people per household has
         decreased from 3.57 to 2.62 over the last 50 years, the
         amount of land that each individual home consumes
         has increased by nearly 60 percent.
Growth Trends Reinforce Driving
Infrastructure Deficit
                                   US needs $220 billion per
                                   year for needed repairs to
                                   roads, bridges & other
                                   infrastructure
                                   Fed. state & local
                                   government spend less than
                                   half this amount

                                   raised since 1993

                                   global competitors

I-35 Bridge Collapse Minneapolis
Train Service in Europe & Japan

                 FAST

                 Frequent

                 Goes
                 Everywhere
Train Service in US
           Slow

           Infrequent, or

           Non-Existent
Population Growth
          100 Million New
          Residents by 2050
          44 Million New Housing
          units
          1.1 Million Units per year
          Demographic shifts and
          Immigration
          Decline of Traditional
          Households
Demographic Shifts
Baby Boomers and Retirees 80 million
Immigrants 40 million
Millennials (18 to 30 year olds) 80 million
Women (single-parent households) - 30
million
75 % of American households do not have
school age children
Sustainability in Action
Sustainability - More Than Technology
 The top issues:
   Energy
   Water
   Land use
   Transportation
   Waste
   Carbon
   Community Character

 It is about quality of life
   Affordability
   Walkability
   Placemaking
   Community Building
                                  23
not beautiful, it will not be loved, if it is




       Doug Kelbaugh, Dean, University of
        Michigan, School of Architecture
National  Automobile  Slum  
                                   
                Venice,  Italy    -­‐    Venice,  California              
Sense  of  Place     That  which  
makes  are  physical  surroundings  
      worth  caring  about  
The Distinctive
    Community


place may be the only truly
   defensible source of
competitive advantage for

                 Joe Cortwright, City Vitals
Secrets of Successful Communities
 Develop a vision for the future
 Inventory local assets and resources
 Build plans around the enhancement of assets
 Use education, incentives, partnerships and
 voluntary initiatives not just regulation
 Pick and choose among development proposals
 Cooperate with neighbors for mutual benefit
 Protect community character as well as ecology and
 economics
 Have strong leaders & committed citizens
Most Polluted City
Model for Sustainable Development
Key Lesson Learned
How much something costs is not
  the most important question.
Key Lesson Learned

Why would anybody invest in a
Inventory Assets
 Natural Resources
 Cultural Resources
 Human Resources
 Economic Resources
 Educational Resources
Sometimes the Assets are Obvious
Sometimes They Are Not Obvious
Explore  Beyond  Regulation  

  Education
  Incentives
  Partnerships
  Voluntary Initiatives
Why Do We Educate?
Why Should We Use Incentives?
Community Character Matters
take stock of a man. The clothes
or appearance are the externals



- Mark Twain
Community Character




Grand Union Hotel, Saratoga Springs, New York
Deteriorates One Project at a Time




 Grand Union Grocery Store, Saratoga Springs, New York
And it Can Get Better One Project at
               a Time




 Grand Union Plaza & Hotel, Saratoga Springs, New York
SUCCESSFUL
 COMMUNITIES PICK
AND CHOOSE AMONG
  DEVELOPMENT
    PROPOSALS
Would you rather shop here?
Or here?
spend more money
and come back more
often to places that
attract their




 Source:  Urban  Design  and  
the  Bottom  Line,  ULI,  2009  
Hometown  Hero's!  
Never doubt that a small group of
committed individuals can change the
world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever


                      - Margaret Mead
It Is Not Always Easy
Leadership is Important
   But often Unappreciated
Vision counts
       but
implementation
  is priceless!
Thank You!
Ed McMahon, Urban Land Institute
      emcmahon@uli.org
First Road Trip
               Horatio Nelson Jackson, Sewall K. Crocker & Bud




Source: www.pbs.org

CM10 Expect Change Seize Opportunity Ed McMahon

  • 1.
    Sustainability  &  Place  Community  Matters  Conference   Denver,  Colorado   ©  Ed  McMahon  
  • 2.
    What  is  Sustainable  Development  and   why  is  it  vital?   -- Brent Toderian, Planning Director, Vancouver, B.C
  • 3.
    development is development thatmeets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own Source: United Nations, Bruntland Commission Report
  • 4.
    It is aboutour children
  • 5.
    harmony between manand -Aldo Leopold
  • 6.
  • 7.
    Why Sustainability Now? Climate Change Energy Issues Infrastructure Deficit Unsustainable Land use Population Growth Makes Business Sense
  • 8.
    Global Warming unequivocal, and human activity is the main driver, very likely causing most of the rise in temperatures since Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Feb. 2007
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Climate Chaos hottest summer, in the hottest year, in the hottest decade Source: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2010
  • 11.
    Regulatory Imperative? 33 states representing 70% of US population are developing climate action plans. 21 states have set carbon reduction targets. 1060 US Mayors, representing over 100 million people have adopted the Kyoto Protocol. President Obama endorsed and the US House of Representatives passed legislation to cap & trade carbon emissions. US EPA is now regulating carbon Sources: Newsweek, US Conference of Mayors,
  • 12.
    High Energy Prices? In 1970 the US imported 24% of its oil from foreign providers In 1990 the US imported 42% of its oil In 2008 the US imported 70% of its oil The cost of imported oil reached over $600 billion per year in 2008
  • 13.
    Do you thinkthe long term trend for energy prices is to go up or down?
  • 14.
    Unsustainable Land Usein USA Large  Lot  Subdivisions   Strip  Commercial  
  • 15.
    Taking Up MoreSpace Household vs. Lot Size Lot Size Family Size Even though the number of people per household has decreased from 3.57 to 2.62 over the last 50 years, the amount of land that each individual home consumes has increased by nearly 60 percent.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Infrastructure Deficit US needs $220 billion per year for needed repairs to roads, bridges & other infrastructure Fed. state & local government spend less than half this amount raised since 1993 global competitors I-35 Bridge Collapse Minneapolis
  • 18.
    Train Service inEurope & Japan FAST Frequent Goes Everywhere
  • 19.
    Train Service inUS Slow Infrequent, or Non-Existent
  • 20.
    Population Growth 100 Million New Residents by 2050 44 Million New Housing units 1.1 Million Units per year Demographic shifts and Immigration Decline of Traditional Households
  • 21.
    Demographic Shifts Baby Boomersand Retirees 80 million Immigrants 40 million Millennials (18 to 30 year olds) 80 million Women (single-parent households) - 30 million 75 % of American households do not have school age children
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Sustainability - MoreThan Technology The top issues: Energy Water Land use Transportation Waste Carbon Community Character It is about quality of life Affordability Walkability Placemaking Community Building 23
  • 24.
    not beautiful, itwill not be loved, if it is Doug Kelbaugh, Dean, University of Michigan, School of Architecture
  • 29.
  • 30.
                                                      Venice,  Italy    -­‐    Venice,  California              
  • 31.
    Sense  of  Place   That  which   makes  are  physical  surroundings   worth  caring  about  
  • 32.
    The Distinctive Community place may be the only truly defensible source of competitive advantage for Joe Cortwright, City Vitals
  • 33.
    Secrets of SuccessfulCommunities Develop a vision for the future Inventory local assets and resources Build plans around the enhancement of assets Use education, incentives, partnerships and voluntary initiatives not just regulation Pick and choose among development proposals Cooperate with neighbors for mutual benefit Protect community character as well as ecology and economics Have strong leaders & committed citizens
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 39.
    Key Lesson Learned Howmuch something costs is not the most important question.
  • 42.
    Key Lesson Learned Whywould anybody invest in a
  • 43.
    Inventory Assets NaturalResources Cultural Resources Human Resources Economic Resources Educational Resources
  • 44.
  • 46.
    Sometimes They AreNot Obvious
  • 48.
    Explore  Beyond  Regulation  Education Incentives Partnerships Voluntary Initiatives
  • 49.
    Why Do WeEducate?
  • 50.
    Why Should WeUse Incentives?
  • 53.
  • 54.
    take stock ofa man. The clothes or appearance are the externals - Mark Twain
  • 55.
    Community Character Grand UnionHotel, Saratoga Springs, New York
  • 56.
    Deteriorates One Projectat a Time Grand Union Grocery Store, Saratoga Springs, New York
  • 57.
    And it CanGet Better One Project at a Time Grand Union Plaza & Hotel, Saratoga Springs, New York
  • 58.
    SUCCESSFUL COMMUNITIES PICK ANDCHOOSE AMONG DEVELOPMENT PROPOSALS
  • 59.
    Would you rathershop here?
  • 60.
  • 61.
    spend more money andcome back more often to places that attract their Source:  Urban  Design  and   the  Bottom  Line,  ULI,  2009  
  • 62.
    Hometown  Hero's!   Neverdoubt that a small group of committed individuals can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever - Margaret Mead
  • 63.
    It Is NotAlways Easy
  • 64.
    Leadership is Important But often Unappreciated
  • 65.
    Vision counts but implementation is priceless!
  • 70.
    Thank You! Ed McMahon,Urban Land Institute emcmahon@uli.org
  • 71.
    First Road Trip Horatio Nelson Jackson, Sewall K. Crocker & Bud Source: www.pbs.org