This document discusses early childhood assessment and development. It notes that the Development Matters guidelines contain over 500 statements to assess children across multiple aspects of development. For a typical nursery class, this could result in over 150 levels to assess for each child. It also summarizes concerns that such detailed assessment can limit children's learning and view them through "levels" rather than as whole people. The document advocates focusing instead on observing children's exploration and thinking, with assessment through conversations and celebrating their learning.

1. Dr Julian Grenier
grenier@outlook.com
@juliangrenier
Celebrating young
children’s learning
Learning from the past - and shaping a
future beyond levels

2. Early years practitioners in
2017?

3. Measurement, evidence, data

4. How much assessment?
• There are about 570 bullet-point
statements in Development Matters

5. • With the common practice of breaking
down each band into beginning,
developing, secure, stages:
• In a nursery class where children’s levels
of development range from 16-26, 22-36,
30-50 months - there are 9 levels across
17 aspects = 153 levels to assess.
• And some schools still require “evidence”
for each assessment….

6. • There are 141
children aged 3
and 4 years old on
roll at Sheringham
Nursery School.
• There are 18
aspects in
Development
Matters
• That adds up to 18
x 141 = 2538 cells
of data and looks
like…

8. Chores
• “Doing
observations”
can be
experienced as
a time-
consuming
demand by
many staff
working with
young children.

9. • Jayne Osgood quotes Delia, one of the
practitioners in her study, discussing the
“stress of report writing, record keeping and
all those other chores”. Osgood comments
that “Delia’s reference to “other chores” is
indicative of the perceived laboriousness of
current expectations in nursery practice.”
Osgood, Negotiating Professionalism (2012,
p.127)

10. Reframing
children

11. And what about levels?
• Do we really want to find ourselves talking
to parents about children’s learning in
terms of ages?
• How might it feel as a parent of a four-
year-old to be told that your child’s
development is like a two-year-old’s (e.g.
“in the 22-36 month band”)?

12. “I am concerned that the tool intended to support
practitioners to understand and foster children’s
development is too often misused. When used as a
tick list of descriptors of what children must achieve,
it can sadly limit both children’s development and the
professional awareness and skills of practitioners.”
Nancy Stewart (2016)

13. “Assessment, as
Development
Matters points out,
means ‘analysing
observations
and deciding what
they tell us about
children’.”
Nancy Stewart
(2016)

14. Susan Isaacs

15. Tommy and the figs

16. Phineas and the train picture

17. Mary-Jane Drummond comments on
Phineas and the train

18. Priscilla and the worm

19. Mary-Jane Drummond on cruelty and
tenderness in Isaacs

20. Isaacs’s thinking was of her time

21. Margaret Donaldson’s “paradise”

22. Two things we need to get away from
• From metaphors of children’s development
and learning “unfolding”
• From talking about “tracking children’s
development”

23. What style of pedagogy?
• “a close and nurturing adult-child relationship
… is necessary for intersubjectivity, which
allows the caregiver to judge how much the
child already knows and understands, so that
she can provide appropriate scaffolding to
extend development.”
• Smith (1999, p.86)

24. Intersubjectivity
Intersubjective relationships depend on the child
having agency, and the adult’s commitment to
giving more agency to the child over time – as
opposed to models which only position the child
as the recipient of care.
• Smith (1999, p.87): “children’s ability to handle
intersubjective encounters depends on:
“reciprocal interaction with … more competent
members of the culture, adults treating the child
as an agent and bent on ‘teaching’ him to be
more so” (Bruner, 1995, p.6)”.

25. Jerome Bruner
• “Knowledge about children
that comes from outside
one’s own experience seems
to make little headway
against received wisdom
and ‘commonsense’
practice. It is only when the
research helps one to see
with one’s own eyes that it
gets beneath the skin”.

26. Celebrating children’s learning: a
joint project by a group of
London nursery schools
Our aim was to avoid the
discourse of ‘tracking’,
and develop instead a
discourse around
celebrating learning,
learning about learning,
and thinking about
teaching.

27. A jump in the puddle

28. A jump in the puddle
Clinton and Jaden
Clinton said to Jaden “Jump!”
Jaden jumped and landed in the puddle
“I do it” said Clinton and he had a turn but missed the puddle.
Jaden said “Oh no, Clinton, you have to do it like this” He jumped again. “You look at the
puddle and jump on it”
Clinton says “OK, Jaden” He got on the step and had another go. “Look at the puddle
Clinton”, “Ready, Jump!” said Jaden.
This time Clinton landed in the puddle. He laughed.
L
To celebrate Queen Elizabeth's 90th birthday we printed
some photos of the queen, L was interested in the photo of
the queen at her Coronation sitting on her throne. "I want to

29. The stopwatches

30. The bridge in the garden
the ramp so you took a long ‘run up’ and whizzed up the steep slope.
that if you weren’t to crash off the side of the bridge you needed to a
line. Excellent skills, Maria!

31. The bridge in the garden
the guttering leaning up against the edge of the sand pit. Then you poured the water down
the pipe and watched it flow along the pipe, gutter and then up the pipe leaning against the
side of the sand pit. We both watched it flow back down again. Then you collected some
sand and put it in the guttering – I asked you what you thought might happen, you told me
“It will block the water, maybe make another flood”. You watched the water flowing down
and saw it backing up behind the sand and flowing over. You let other children help with
putting water down the pipes.
Maria
Hi Maria, do you remember the day I made a bridge in the garden? I set all the children a
challenge – could they ride their bikes over the bridge without stalling or crashing? You had
to go quite fast in order to mount the up ramp, and if you weren’t careful it was easy to
crash off the sides of the bridge. Lots of children got stuck on the up ramp or ended in a
heap by the side of the b ridge, but you, Maria, managed the challenge with great skill. You
knew that you needed to build up your momentum if you were going to get to the top of
the ramp so you took a long ‘run up’ and whizzed up the steep slope. You also understood
that if you weren’t to crash off the side of the bridge you needed to approach it in a straight
line. Excellent skills, Maria!

32. Counting with
string

33. Counting with string

34. Repeating Development Matters

35. Recording and also capturing
dialogue and teaching
• During our trip to the Science Museum, R is
observing the travellers on the tube train. “He’s
got black hands” she says, pointing to a man. She
looks at her own hands and says “I have white.”
She looks at my hands and says “you have white.”
When we got back to nursery we looked together
at our ‘different families’ poster and R said,
“some people are different colours” and she
compared her skin colour to those she could see
on the poster. I asked her,“Can you see any other
children?” and she said “yes – they’re children,
but their hands are different colours to mine.”

36. Keen
observation

37. Features of best practices
• you can hear the child’s
voice
• there is keen observation of
the child’s exploration, play
and thinking
• the practitioner has noticed
that the child is learning a
new skill, or is making new
links between aspects of
knowledge
• there are examples of
sustained conversation and
thinking, sometimes with
feelings of awe

38. www.eleysp.co.uk/celebrating-
childrens-learning/

39. The Red Queen