SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Case 121
Carson Manor
In late November, Ms. Elaine Taylor, director of supply for the city of Winston, was reviewing
proposals for the Carson Manor study. Three consulting groups had responded to a request for
proposal (RFP) to study the operation of the city-owned nursing home. Ms. Taylor knew that her
recommendations for selection of a consultant would have to be completed by mid-December.
page 360
CARSON MANOR
Carson Manor was opened about 30 years ago for persons requiring nursing care. Carson had a
bed capacity of 470. Staff totaled 235 with nonmanagement personnel unionized under the
District Service Workers Union Local 325.
Day-to-day operations of the Carson Manor were the responsibility of the Carson Manor
administrator, who reported to Mr. Henry Davis, the citys director of social services. Policy and
budget plans were developed by Mr. Davis and his staff in conjunction with Carson
administrative staff and the Carson Manor Committee of Management (CMCM). The CMCM
consisted of five aldermen who were appointed or volunteered to fill these positions. The
CMCM reported to another aldermanic committee, with broader community service concerns,
called the Committee for Community Services. This committee reviewed major expenditures and
decisions impacting community service policy. All major expenditures were then reviewed by
the Board of Control, consisting of the mayor and four elected controllers, prior to being sent to
city council for final approval.
As director of social services, Mr. Davis reported to the city administrator, Mr. J. Peterson, who
in turn reported to the mayor. The combined elected and appointed reporting structure is shown
in Exhibit 1.
PURCHASING AND SUPPLY DIVISION (PSD)
The PSD had purchasing and disposal authority for the citys engineering, fire, landfill/sanitation
departments, and social services division, and for city hall building support. The city operated
separate purchasing departments in the public utilities commission, the libraries, and the police
department. Purchasing authority was granted to the PSD director and her buyers by municipal
bylaw. This bylaw outlined the limits of purchasing authority and formed the basis of the PSDs
Policy Manual for Purchasing, Tendering, and Disposal.
The main objective of the PSD was to respond to the needs of other departments and divisions
for goods and services at minimum cost, consistent with desired quality, delivery timing, and
reliability. The PSD had expertise in the purchasing and tendering of goods and certain services,
such as equipment rental, maintenance contracts, and engineering/architectural consulting.
However, it had not dealt extensively with management consulting service procurement at that
time.
Elaine Taylor became director of PSD two years ago at the age of 35. Prior to this, she was chief
buyer and assistant director of purchasing for the city of Forestview, similar in size to Winston.
Elaine reported to the city treasurer, Mr. R. Holbright, and dealt directly with other department
and division heads on purchasing matters, as shown in Exhibit 1. She managed a staff of 15,
including three buyers.
EXHIBIT 1Reporting Structure
page 361
EXHIBIT 2Carson Manor
Excerpts from The Municipal Home for the Aged, a Review and Alternatives. A report to the
Carson Manor Committee of Management by J. Peterson, City Administrator, and H. Davis,
Director of Social Services.
Page 29
Increasing levels of care required by Carson Manor residents have a major influence on costs,
since care essentially is translated into staff to provide the necessary services. No objective
classification of resident care requirements has ever been carried out at the Carson Manor,
although there is no question that current residents and even new applicants require much more
nursing care than was formerly the case.
Page 33
An operational review could be carried out by an independent consulting firm of the States
Department of Community and Social Services and would provide a thorough analysis of options
and possible areas for improvement at the Carson Manor.
Such an approach would provide a firm basis for the development of strategies for operational
change but would not guarantee implementation of the necessary changes.
Page 34
The overall advantage of an operational review would be the ability to identify, in depth,
problem areas at the Carson Manor for which change strategies could be developed by the city.
Such strategies might include contract management of a specific service, for example. This type
of analysis would provide solid ground for future planning. On the negative side of the balance
are the costs of such a study and the necessity to subsequently develop and implement changes
for the identified problem areas.
THE CARSON MANOR STUDY
The Carson Manor had a history of problems related to budgeting and cost control. City council
felt that the cost per bed was unnecessarily high, when compared to privately run institutions.
Eight months ago the council directed the city administrator, Mr. Peterson, and the director of
social services, Mr. Davis, to prepare a report for submission to the Carson Manor Committee of
Management in early June. The report was to contain:
An analysis of the comparative costs at Carson Manor and other state facilities.
A review of the feasibility of increasing cost efficiency.
A review of the implications of possible alternatives such as:
Contract management.
An in-depth operational review and cost efficiency study carried out by an external agency.
The requested internal report, titled The Carson Manor for the Aged, a Review and Alternatives,
was tabled on June 9. It revealed that Carson Manor costs were approximately 14 percent higher
than state averages on a per-bed basis. The report highlighted the difficulties of measuring and
controlling costs in the absence of a patient classification system that would enable standard
levels of nursing care to be developed. The report recommended an operational review by an
outside agency and outlined some general guidelines and objectives. Sections of the internal
report, related to these guidelines and objectives, are shown in Exhibit 2.
Council accepted the reports recommendations and directed Messrs. Peterson and Davis to
initiate an independent consultants study of Carson Manor. This was not a budgeted expense;
and the approval of the CMCM, the Committee of Community Services, the Board of Control,
and City Council were necessary prior to letting a consulting contract. Mr. Davis requested the
assistance of Elaine Taylor and the PSD in identifying and evaluating potential study
participants. Elaine Taylor handled the Carson Manor Study personally, since it was beyond the
scope of responsibilities and experience of her buyers. She drafted an RFP, which is shown in
Exhibit 3. In-state consulting organizations were contacted, and a list of consulting companies
with relevant experience was developed. Five consulting companies were invited to submit
proposals.
analyze the cost differences as well as other differences in the proposal.
Required: Create a scorecard using at least five criteria (must include cost and savings as two of
the criteria) to aid in the analysis. Provide an explanation of why you chose the criteria you
chose and why you used the weights you chose (why is one criteria more or less important than
others). You are allowed to make assumptions but clearly state your assumptions.
Required: Provide an explanation of why you selected the solution that you recommended.
Use the table below as guidance. The scores should be out of 100 and the weights should add up
to 1.
Table 1: Scorecard for XYZ Corp.
CriteriaScoreWeightTotalCost850.3025.5Savings880.2522Criteria 3950.1514.25Criteria
41000.1515Criteria 5800.1512Final Score88.75

More Related Content

Similar to Case 12�1Carson ManorIn late November, Ms. Elaine Taylor, direct.pdf

Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docxDeveloping a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
hcheryl1
 
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanSDeveloping a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
LinaCovington707
 
Essay Samples For Scholarship Applications
Essay Samples For Scholarship ApplicationsEssay Samples For Scholarship Applications
Essay Samples For Scholarship Applications
Liz Brown
 
City council candidate questionnaire Shereda Nosakhare - D6
City council candidate questionnaire   Shereda Nosakhare - D6City council candidate questionnaire   Shereda Nosakhare - D6
City council candidate questionnaire Shereda Nosakhare - D6
Make Oakland Better Now!
 
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014Final Report - Final 12.5.2014
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014Nicholas Armour
 
Medrano meeting 4 5-11
Medrano meeting 4 5-11Medrano meeting 4 5-11
Medrano meeting 4 5-11CNADallas
 
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274Hilary Rowell
 
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docxTOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
jolleybendicty
 
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
Chelsea Porter
 
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murrayEmergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
MayorEdMurray
 
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conference
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conferenceTom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conference
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conferenceElyk Venture Management
 
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy Conference
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy ConferenceDavid R. Goode National Transportation Policy Conference
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy ConferencePorts-To-Plains Blog
 
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay ExampleWhy Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
Susan Migliaccio
 
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes ProgramCost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
National Alliance to End Homelessness
 
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docxCLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
monicafrancis71118
 
Report of the Devolution Review Group
Report of the Devolution Review GroupReport of the Devolution Review Group
Report of the Devolution Review GroupTom Hayes
 
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, EsHelp With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
Jenny Smith
 
Denver 9/28 Russ Adams
Denver 9/28 Russ AdamsDenver 9/28 Russ Adams
Paul Martin on regulation v2
Paul Martin on regulation v2Paul Martin on regulation v2
Paul Martin on regulation v2
Daniel Ratchford
 
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
Community Links
 

Similar to Case 12�1Carson ManorIn late November, Ms. Elaine Taylor, direct.pdf (20)

Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docxDeveloping a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS.docx
 
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanSDeveloping a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
Developing a Progressive AdvocacyProgram Within a HumanS
 
Essay Samples For Scholarship Applications
Essay Samples For Scholarship ApplicationsEssay Samples For Scholarship Applications
Essay Samples For Scholarship Applications
 
City council candidate questionnaire Shereda Nosakhare - D6
City council candidate questionnaire   Shereda Nosakhare - D6City council candidate questionnaire   Shereda Nosakhare - D6
City council candidate questionnaire Shereda Nosakhare - D6
 
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014Final Report - Final 12.5.2014
Final Report - Final 12.5.2014
 
Medrano meeting 4 5-11
Medrano meeting 4 5-11Medrano meeting 4 5-11
Medrano meeting 4 5-11
 
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274
report_shaping_services_around_individuals_needs_274
 
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docxTOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
TOPIC Why should I stop smoking An experimental study on success.docx
 
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
A Government Agency With Fice Of Quality, Performance, And...
 
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murrayEmergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
Emergency task force on unsheltered homelessness recommendations to mayor murray
 
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conference
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conferenceTom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conference
Tom feltner-woodstock cra-expansion-ncrc2011_conference
 
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy Conference
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy ConferenceDavid R. Goode National Transportation Policy Conference
David R. Goode National Transportation Policy Conference
 
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay ExampleWhy Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
Why Do I Want To Go To College Essay Example
 
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes ProgramCost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
Cost Savings Analysis of the Streets to Homes Program
 
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docxCLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
CLASS MATE EXAMPLECLASS MATE EXAMPLEMayer Anthony Williams a.docx
 
Report of the Devolution Review Group
Report of the Devolution Review GroupReport of the Devolution Review Group
Report of the Devolution Review Group
 
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, EsHelp With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
Help With College Essay Writing College Essay, Es
 
Denver 9/28 Russ Adams
Denver 9/28 Russ AdamsDenver 9/28 Russ Adams
Denver 9/28 Russ Adams
 
Paul Martin on regulation v2
Paul Martin on regulation v2Paul Martin on regulation v2
Paul Martin on regulation v2
 
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
Deep Value Assessment: Improving employability through a new approach to asse...
 

More from rahulfancycorner21

Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdfConsider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdfConfigure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdfCIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdfCLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdfCase Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdfClara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdfChapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdfCASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdfcan i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdfCase 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdfCapstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE, am using V.pdf
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE,  am using V.pdfC++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE,  am using V.pdf
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE, am using V.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdfCan you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdfBusiness PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdfCan we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdfCan we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdfCan u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdfC++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdfBUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
rahulfancycorner21
 

More from rahulfancycorner21 (19)

Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdfConsider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
Consider a world in which there are two nations � the US and China, ea.pdf
 
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdfConfigure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
Configure iptables to ACCEPT packets by defaultConfigure iptables .pdf
 
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdfCIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
CIS611 SS Chung Lab Assignment 2 Implementing Big Data Processing Pipe.pdf
 
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdfCLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
CLIENT APPLICATION Create a standalone, interactive, and fully com.pdf
 
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdfCase Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
Case Study Makati CityMakati City is one of the sixteen cit.pdf
 
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdfClara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
Clara fears she may have made a mistake in how she handled the expen.pdf
 
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdfChapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
Chapter 11 Conrols for Information Security11.4 Which preventive, .pdf
 
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdfCASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
CASE STUDY 1 Alternative Water Supply Gordon Rivers, the city manage.pdf
 
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdfcan i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
can i have the Answers of the above questions 1. Compare and contr.pdf
 
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdfCase 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
Case 1 Why shareholders wealth maximization value maximization is c.pdf
 
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdfCapstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
Capstone Project E-Commerce Application with Firebase Firestore Obj.pdf
 
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE, am using V.pdf
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE,  am using V.pdfC++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE,  am using V.pdf
C++ code, please help! RESPOND W COMPLETED CODE PLEASE, am using V.pdf
 
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdfCan you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
Can you draw a database design Entity relationship ERand the rela.pdf
 
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdfBusiness PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
Business PlanA business plan is any simple plan, not only limited .pdf
 
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdfCan we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
Can we please draw this BPM process roughly on paper and post a pict.pdf
 
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdfCan we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
Can we draw this BPM on paper showing shapes arrows and connectors .pdf
 
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdfCan u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
Can u give a CORAS ASSEST DIAGRAM for the following case study - The.pdf
 
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdfC++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
C++ code, please help! Troubleshooting and cannot for the life of me.pdf
 
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdfBUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
BUsiness law9.3 Implied-in-Fact Contract For six years, Lee Marvin.pdf
 

Recently uploaded

The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptxThe Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
DhatriParmar
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
Special education needs
 
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic ImperativeEmbracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Peter Windle
 
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
GeoBlogs
 
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp NetworkIntroduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
TechSoup
 
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
MysoreMuleSoftMeetup
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Anna Sz.
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxInstructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Jheel Barad
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
DeeptiGupta154
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Vikramjit Singh
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
siemaillard
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
Delapenabediema
 
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPhrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
MIRIAMSALINAS13
 
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Atul Kumar Singh
 
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Celine George
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
Jisc
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
Peter Windle
 
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxSynthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Pavel ( NSTU)
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptxThe Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau.pptx
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
 
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 5pptx.pptx
 
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic ImperativeEmbracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
Embracing GenAI - A Strategic Imperative
 
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
 
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp NetworkIntroduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
 
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
 
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free downloadThe French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
The French Revolution Class 9 Study Material pdf free download
 
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxInstructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptx
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official PublicationThe Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
The Challenger.pdf DNHS Official Publication
 
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPhrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
 
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.Language Across the  Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
Language Across the Curriculm LAC B.Ed.
 
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
 
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in EducationA Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
A Strategic Approach: GenAI in Education
 
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxSynthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptx
 

Case 12�1Carson ManorIn late November, Ms. Elaine Taylor, direct.pdf

  • 1. Case 121 Carson Manor In late November, Ms. Elaine Taylor, director of supply for the city of Winston, was reviewing proposals for the Carson Manor study. Three consulting groups had responded to a request for proposal (RFP) to study the operation of the city-owned nursing home. Ms. Taylor knew that her recommendations for selection of a consultant would have to be completed by mid-December. page 360 CARSON MANOR Carson Manor was opened about 30 years ago for persons requiring nursing care. Carson had a bed capacity of 470. Staff totaled 235 with nonmanagement personnel unionized under the District Service Workers Union Local 325. Day-to-day operations of the Carson Manor were the responsibility of the Carson Manor administrator, who reported to Mr. Henry Davis, the citys director of social services. Policy and budget plans were developed by Mr. Davis and his staff in conjunction with Carson administrative staff and the Carson Manor Committee of Management (CMCM). The CMCM consisted of five aldermen who were appointed or volunteered to fill these positions. The CMCM reported to another aldermanic committee, with broader community service concerns, called the Committee for Community Services. This committee reviewed major expenditures and decisions impacting community service policy. All major expenditures were then reviewed by the Board of Control, consisting of the mayor and four elected controllers, prior to being sent to city council for final approval. As director of social services, Mr. Davis reported to the city administrator, Mr. J. Peterson, who in turn reported to the mayor. The combined elected and appointed reporting structure is shown in Exhibit 1. PURCHASING AND SUPPLY DIVISION (PSD) The PSD had purchasing and disposal authority for the citys engineering, fire, landfill/sanitation departments, and social services division, and for city hall building support. The city operated separate purchasing departments in the public utilities commission, the libraries, and the police department. Purchasing authority was granted to the PSD director and her buyers by municipal bylaw. This bylaw outlined the limits of purchasing authority and formed the basis of the PSDs Policy Manual for Purchasing, Tendering, and Disposal. The main objective of the PSD was to respond to the needs of other departments and divisions for goods and services at minimum cost, consistent with desired quality, delivery timing, and reliability. The PSD had expertise in the purchasing and tendering of goods and certain services, such as equipment rental, maintenance contracts, and engineering/architectural consulting.
  • 2. However, it had not dealt extensively with management consulting service procurement at that time. Elaine Taylor became director of PSD two years ago at the age of 35. Prior to this, she was chief buyer and assistant director of purchasing for the city of Forestview, similar in size to Winston. Elaine reported to the city treasurer, Mr. R. Holbright, and dealt directly with other department and division heads on purchasing matters, as shown in Exhibit 1. She managed a staff of 15, including three buyers. EXHIBIT 1Reporting Structure page 361 EXHIBIT 2Carson Manor Excerpts from The Municipal Home for the Aged, a Review and Alternatives. A report to the Carson Manor Committee of Management by J. Peterson, City Administrator, and H. Davis, Director of Social Services. Page 29 Increasing levels of care required by Carson Manor residents have a major influence on costs, since care essentially is translated into staff to provide the necessary services. No objective classification of resident care requirements has ever been carried out at the Carson Manor, although there is no question that current residents and even new applicants require much more nursing care than was formerly the case. Page 33 An operational review could be carried out by an independent consulting firm of the States Department of Community and Social Services and would provide a thorough analysis of options and possible areas for improvement at the Carson Manor. Such an approach would provide a firm basis for the development of strategies for operational change but would not guarantee implementation of the necessary changes. Page 34 The overall advantage of an operational review would be the ability to identify, in depth, problem areas at the Carson Manor for which change strategies could be developed by the city. Such strategies might include contract management of a specific service, for example. This type of analysis would provide solid ground for future planning. On the negative side of the balance are the costs of such a study and the necessity to subsequently develop and implement changes for the identified problem areas. THE CARSON MANOR STUDY The Carson Manor had a history of problems related to budgeting and cost control. City council felt that the cost per bed was unnecessarily high, when compared to privately run institutions.
  • 3. Eight months ago the council directed the city administrator, Mr. Peterson, and the director of social services, Mr. Davis, to prepare a report for submission to the Carson Manor Committee of Management in early June. The report was to contain: An analysis of the comparative costs at Carson Manor and other state facilities. A review of the feasibility of increasing cost efficiency. A review of the implications of possible alternatives such as: Contract management. An in-depth operational review and cost efficiency study carried out by an external agency. The requested internal report, titled The Carson Manor for the Aged, a Review and Alternatives, was tabled on June 9. It revealed that Carson Manor costs were approximately 14 percent higher than state averages on a per-bed basis. The report highlighted the difficulties of measuring and controlling costs in the absence of a patient classification system that would enable standard levels of nursing care to be developed. The report recommended an operational review by an outside agency and outlined some general guidelines and objectives. Sections of the internal report, related to these guidelines and objectives, are shown in Exhibit 2. Council accepted the reports recommendations and directed Messrs. Peterson and Davis to initiate an independent consultants study of Carson Manor. This was not a budgeted expense; and the approval of the CMCM, the Committee of Community Services, the Board of Control, and City Council were necessary prior to letting a consulting contract. Mr. Davis requested the assistance of Elaine Taylor and the PSD in identifying and evaluating potential study participants. Elaine Taylor handled the Carson Manor Study personally, since it was beyond the scope of responsibilities and experience of her buyers. She drafted an RFP, which is shown in Exhibit 3. In-state consulting organizations were contacted, and a list of consulting companies with relevant experience was developed. Five consulting companies were invited to submit proposals. analyze the cost differences as well as other differences in the proposal. Required: Create a scorecard using at least five criteria (must include cost and savings as two of the criteria) to aid in the analysis. Provide an explanation of why you chose the criteria you chose and why you used the weights you chose (why is one criteria more or less important than others). You are allowed to make assumptions but clearly state your assumptions. Required: Provide an explanation of why you selected the solution that you recommended. Use the table below as guidance. The scores should be out of 100 and the weights should add up to 1. Table 1: Scorecard for XYZ Corp. CriteriaScoreWeightTotalCost850.3025.5Savings880.2522Criteria 3950.1514.25Criteria 41000.1515Criteria 5800.1512Final Score88.75