Bonnie Bricker's son Reid went missing after being discharged from the hospital following multiple suicide attempts. Bricker is working to change the way the mental health system handles crisis situations like Reid's. The current system lacks proper protocols for discharging suicidal patients and does not provide adequate follow-up care or resources for mental health emergencies outside of regular business hours. Bricker is advocating for reforms like improved privacy laws, mandatory follow-up care, and increased community support programs to help prevent other families from experiencing what hers did.
I know why the caged bird sings: Human rights issues in mental health systemsVMIAC
Outlines consumer / survivor perspectives on common human rights issues in mental health systems, and outlines opportunities for change.
Presentation by Indigo Daya, VMIAC Human Rights Advisor, at The Mental Health Services (TheMHS) conference 2018.
Is trauma informed care really possible in mental health services?VMIAC
Keynote talk delivered at the 2018 Summer TheMHS Forum, in Sydney, Australia. Talk by our Human Rights Advisor, Indigo Daya.
While we know that trauma is a critical issue for most mental health consumers, we are also concerned that changes intending to implement trauma-informed practice are not always addressing the need. We highlight major issues to be resolved when considering the implementation of trauma-informed practice. This is too important to get it wrong.
I know why the caged bird sings: Human rights issues in mental health systemsVMIAC
Outlines consumer / survivor perspectives on common human rights issues in mental health systems, and outlines opportunities for change.
Presentation by Indigo Daya, VMIAC Human Rights Advisor, at The Mental Health Services (TheMHS) conference 2018.
Is trauma informed care really possible in mental health services?VMIAC
Keynote talk delivered at the 2018 Summer TheMHS Forum, in Sydney, Australia. Talk by our Human Rights Advisor, Indigo Daya.
While we know that trauma is a critical issue for most mental health consumers, we are also concerned that changes intending to implement trauma-informed practice are not always addressing the need. We highlight major issues to be resolved when considering the implementation of trauma-informed practice. This is too important to get it wrong.
AWAKEN THE GREATNESS WITHIN
Always look at the solution, not the problem
Learn to focus on what will give results
We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking that created them
Sometimes the easiest way to solve a problem is to stop participating in the problem
Review of the research, literature and expert advice on reducing discrimination and enhancing social inclusion in mental health / illness. Written by Neasa Martin, funded by Queensland Alliance, Australia 2009
HIV stigma and discrimination in health care settings in the Eastern Medite...danbernard
Presentation at the symposium “Family, the Millennium Development Goals and AIDS in the Middle East and North Africa region: Linkages, challenges and opportunities,” Doha, Qatar, hosted by the Doha International Institute for Family Studies and Development, UNAIDS, and UNICEF, November 2, 2011.
AIDSTAR-One Breaking New Ground in VietnamAIDSTAROne
Gender norms affect the behavior and life choices of both men and women. In Vietnam, these norms sometimes drive people into situations where they are at increased risk of violence, STI acquisition, and/or incarceration. This case study (one of nine in a series) examines CARE International's STEP program, which seeks to ensure that both men and women have equal access to services to prevent STIs, safeguard their health, avoid gender-based violence, and participate in income-generating activities.
http://www.aidstar-one.com/focus_areas/gender/resources/case_study_series/step_vietnam
Are you drinking TOO much?
Alcohol is the most commonly used potentially addictive substance in our society. Alcohol is responsible for over half of the $267 million dollars of substance related hospital costs in Canada. Problematic alcohol use significantly impacts individuals, families, and our community, but many struggle to know if they have a problem and where to go for help.
Learn more: http://www.theroyal.ca/mental-health-centre/news-and-events/newsroom/13411/alcohol-how-much-is-too-much/
AWAKEN THE GREATNESS WITHIN
Always look at the solution, not the problem
Learn to focus on what will give results
We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking that created them
Sometimes the easiest way to solve a problem is to stop participating in the problem
Review of the research, literature and expert advice on reducing discrimination and enhancing social inclusion in mental health / illness. Written by Neasa Martin, funded by Queensland Alliance, Australia 2009
HIV stigma and discrimination in health care settings in the Eastern Medite...danbernard
Presentation at the symposium “Family, the Millennium Development Goals and AIDS in the Middle East and North Africa region: Linkages, challenges and opportunities,” Doha, Qatar, hosted by the Doha International Institute for Family Studies and Development, UNAIDS, and UNICEF, November 2, 2011.
AIDSTAR-One Breaking New Ground in VietnamAIDSTAROne
Gender norms affect the behavior and life choices of both men and women. In Vietnam, these norms sometimes drive people into situations where they are at increased risk of violence, STI acquisition, and/or incarceration. This case study (one of nine in a series) examines CARE International's STEP program, which seeks to ensure that both men and women have equal access to services to prevent STIs, safeguard their health, avoid gender-based violence, and participate in income-generating activities.
http://www.aidstar-one.com/focus_areas/gender/resources/case_study_series/step_vietnam
Are you drinking TOO much?
Alcohol is the most commonly used potentially addictive substance in our society. Alcohol is responsible for over half of the $267 million dollars of substance related hospital costs in Canada. Problematic alcohol use significantly impacts individuals, families, and our community, but many struggle to know if they have a problem and where to go for help.
Learn more: http://www.theroyal.ca/mental-health-centre/news-and-events/newsroom/13411/alcohol-how-much-is-too-much/
Mental Health Reform: Personal Responsibility & Social JusticeCitizen Network
Talk given at the RCN's International Conference for Psychiatric Nursing on mental health reform. The talk describes the ethical challenge facing nurses as government policy both undermines mental health and avoids the need for meaningful reform. Can nurses work with people to bring about the necessary changes?
Using the Cultural Formulation Interview to BuildCulturally .docxjessiehampson
Using the Cultural Formulation Interview to Build
Culturally Sensitive Services
Esperanza Díaz, M.D., Luis M. Añez, Psy.D., Michelle Silva, Psy.D., Manuel Paris, Psy.D., Larry Davidson, Ph.D.
As part of the development of DSM-5, the Cultural Formu-
lation Interview (CFI) was administered to 30 monolingual
Spanish-speaking adults at one site of a 2012 feasibility
study of the CFI. The authors identified salient themes in
data collected through use of the CFI, with a focus on
interventions that could lead to more culturally responsive
mental health services. Findings suggest that establishing
trust and focusing on the restoration of social ties while
attending to the impact of stigma and patients’ pressing
psychosocial needs are elements of culturally responsive
services for Hispanic persons. Routine use of the CFI can
help clinicians identify unique needs and preferences
by understanding an individual within his or her cultural
context.
Psychiatric Services 2017; 68:112–114; doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201600440
Cultural sensitivity increases the probability of a therapeutic
relationship by enhancing trust and improving communi-
cation between clinicians and patients (1). Culturally re-
sponsive services effectively address health care disparities
and increase providers’ knowledge of diverse cultures. In-
troducing culturally responsive care increases service utili-
zation and reduces premature termination (2,3). However,
few examples exist that illustrate culturally responsive care
in routine practice beyond its positive effect on help seeking
and service utilization.
The revision of the Outline for Cultural Formulation from
the DSM-IV resulted in the Cultural Formulation Interview
(CFI) to elicit information about perceived cultural influ-
ences of care with a set of 16 questions included in the
DSM-5 (4). This personalized interview facilitates individ-
ualized assessments by clinicians instead of their relying on
preconceived or stereotypic notions about race-ethnicity or
country of origin (5). The CFI captures the patient’s voice
systematically and documents what is “at stake” for the
person (6). The CFI field trial provided an opportunity to
observe this innovative way to elicit information and to
clarify cultural versus idiosyncratic details. The CFI has a
unique role, even in mental health services that are focused
on racial-ethnic minority groups. In this column, we de-
scribe CFI-elicited information in one of the trial sites and
discuss potential ways for the CFI to improve care.
CFI Field Trial
From February to September 2012, we recruited 30 par-
ticipants for a CFI feasibility study that included an audio-
recorded interview. The participants were monolingual
Spanish-speaking adults ages 18–70 from several Latin
American countries and were receiving outpatient services
at the Hispanic Clinic of the Connecticut Mental Health
Center, which serves individuals regardless of legal status
and ability to pay. We obtained institutional ...
Slides for WAAMH on elements of a reformed mental health system. An exploration of practical innovations - self-directed support, WomenCentre and PFG's peer support system. The presentation goes on to consider the challenges of social justice and system change in mental health.
Mental health continues to be an important issue affecting so many Canadians. I wrote three stories for the series for the Canadian Nurses Association in partnership with the Mental Health Commission of Canada. The stories were: Reducing Stigma in Health-Care Settings; Suicide Prevention and Postvention Initiatives; and When Mental Illness and the Justice System Intersect.
Cory McArthur; Catching His Breath in Winnipeg - Neighbours of Tuxedo April 2015
Bonnie Bricker Creating a Light at the End of the Tunnel
1. Bonnie Bricker
Creating a Light at the End of the Tunnel
by
Brian Campbell
When her son Reid went missing following his discharge from the Health Sciences
Centre on October 24, 2015, Bonnie Bricker decided that something needed to be
done to change the way the medical system deals with people who have mental
health problems.
Over the 10 day period prior to his disappearance, Reid had made three attempts on
his life. “The first time, he woke up in Seven Oaks Hospital,” Bonnie said. “He had
no recollection of how he got there. He woke up in the Emergency Room and
looked down and saw his shoes with his keys and a note telling him where to find
his car. He got dressed and walked out of the hospital and back to his car. He
didn’t recall talking to anyone or getting permission to leave the hospital; he knew
he had taken an overdose of his medication.”
On the 23rd
of October, Reid made another attempt on his life and was rushed by
ambulance from Whittier Park to the St. Boniface Hospital, where he stayed from
12:00 PM until 8:00 PM.
“Between these two points he may have made another attempt on his life, but that
is unclear,” Bonnie said. “On the 23rd
we contacted the police and gave them a
missing person’s report. Through their resources, the police established that he had
been at the St. Boniface Hospital and had just been released. They were waiting for
him at his apartment at around 9:00 PM. He had walked home from the St.
Boniface Hospital.”
The police took Reid to Health Sciences Centre at 10:00 PM on a ‘form three’
(involuntary custody), meaning that he couldn’t leave the hospital until he was
discharged by a doctor. The police stayed with him until at least midnight, at which
time they placed him in the custody of hospital security. What happened after that
is somewhat vague, but Reid was released from the Health Sciences Centre at 3:20
AM and hasn’t been seen since.
2. “One of the issues we are addressing with the WRHA (Winnipeg Regional Health
Authority) is discharge protocol,” Bonnie said. “The current discharge form is
generic, whether a person has a broken foot, a heart attack or suicidal ideation. You
are all discharged under the same protocol. This does not reflect the requirements
of discharging a person with psychological problems, and certainly not someone in
urgent crisis with suicidal ideation.
“The reality is that Emergency Departments are a 24-7 operation. They are going
to release people at any time of the day or night. They cannot keep them. They
don’t have the resources,” she added. “A person who goes to the Emergency Room
with psychiatric, mental health issues will not currently get the help that they need.
It is the wrong place to take them.”
The current system has places for people to go who have mental health issues if
they are in crisis during the day, Monday to Friday, but not late at night, when a
person is most likely to be feeling lonely, depressed and in greatest need of help.
This is one of many things about the way our system treats those dealing with
mental health issues that Bonnie is fighting to change. She is aware that she is not
alone in her frustration with the system.
“There is no question in my mind that the health care professionals Reid saw that
night are completely frustrated with the way that they have to cope with this,” she
said. “But nothing has changed. Even though there are good people out there trying
to enact change, things have remained the same.”
The biggest problem to be dealt with first, is PHIA (Personal Health Information
Act) which limits what a doctor can do to provide help for an adult dealing with
mental health problems. “PHIA appears to be a huge stumbling block for about
75% of the health care professionals in this province,” Bonnie said. “They can fine
a nurse or doctor 30 or 40 thousand dollars for breach of privacy, they can remove
their licence, they can fire them and make sure that they can’t get work in this
province.
“But, there is also a section of the PHIA act that gives them wiggle room to think
outside the box and make a better decision for their patient,” she added. “It was
pointed out to me that the WRHA has never been sued for a breach of privacy;
they have been sued, however, for not divulging information about a patient to that
person’s circle of care.”
3. The way things are currently run in the Emergency Room, the patient will see a
medical doctor, who will make sure that they haven’t physically harmed
themselves. From there, they will probably see a Psychiatric Emergency Nurse or a
psychiatrist who ask a standard list of questions to determine whether they are
mentally competent. The problem is that people with suicidal ideation have likely
been through this routine before and already know the ‘right answers’ to give.
From there, they are offered some alternatives and released.
“We need to change the way these circumstances play out,” Bonnie said. “Reid’s
case is not a rarity. This is the norm. At this very moment, there is somebody,
somewhere, sitting in an emergency room, not getting the proper care”
Even the Crisis Response Centre (CRC) is not a fail proof operation, because they
lack both the staff and the beds to handle current needs. “We don’t actually have
any follow up care in Manitoba,” Bonnie said.
“When Reid left the hospital that night, did they make arrangements for him to
check in with somebody? Maybe. How are they going to hold him accountable?”
asked Bonnie. “What they need is a mentoring system much like AA. The Mood
Disorder Association of Manitoba (MDAM) has a group of 200 peer volunteers
with lived experience. We need 2,000 or 10,000. There are 300,000 people in
Manitoba right now that need this.”
There are models around the world, and even in Canada, of how the system can be
done better, but they haven’t caught on in Manitoba. “That doesn’t mean there
aren’t a lot of people engaged in making changes,” Bonnie said. “We have health
care professionals who have dedicated their entire lives to changing the way the
system works and to helping these vulnerable people. But it is a tidal wave. One or
two or 10 people can’t stand against it. It has to be every single person in Manitoba
who has to stand up and make change. It has to be everybody, consciously aware,
having conversations and demanding answers.”
Bonnie is part of an advisory board with the WRHA working on trying to improve
the system. Referring to the other board members, she said, “These people have a
lot of experience; they are intelligent, strong people with a lot of know-how who
come to these meetings because they want to enact change.”
One of Bonnie’s goals is to bring all parts of the community together, working
towards recognising and helping those with mental health problems; the medical
community, the justice community, the educational community, and the public in
4. general. She is adamant that teachers and those working with young children
should be educated in cognitive behaviour therapy. “We need to change the
curriculum to include mental health wellbeing,” she said. “It is proven that the
earlier we detect this, the better chance the person has of surviving and having
quality of life.”
Bonnie spends a lot of time working with the Mood Disorder Association of
Manitoba and there are now two pieces of jewelry, a necklace and a lapel pin, that
were designed by Hilary Druxman that are exact replicas of Reid’s last sculpture,
‘LifesArt’, which has become the symbol of hope for MDAM. These pieces can be
purchased at either Hilary Druxman Studio or MDAM for $40. The net proceeds
support men’s depression and youth programming at MDAM.
She also helps with their annual gala and is working with Rheesa Schachter of
Kids Etc’s Youth Movement Company to do a dance camp for MDAM this
summer. “Music makes you feel better,” she said. “And dancing not only releases
endorphins that make you feel healthy, it lets you release and express your
feelings.”
She has dedicated her life to changing the current system and is involved in many
ways to make it happen. If she can’t help Reid, she is determined to do what she
can to make sure it doesn’t happen to others. She can’t change the past, but she
wants to rewrite the future.
“I’m optimistic,” Bonnie said. “I’m encouraged that there are more people willing
to help than not help. I know that there is a means that we can give a voice to this.
And if everybody joins the fight, the takeaway will be less illness, less sadness; we
will win in every single area of our lives.”