1. 1
From: Dr. Shri Padmasinh Dalsinh Parmar
President : Vishva Vedanti Parishad
19, Meghdut Society,
Godhra Road,
At & Po: Halol, Dist: Panchmahals
Pin: 389350, Gujarat
Date:
To
Sub: Authority of Law and Order
Ref: 1984 A.D.Riots
2002 A.D.Riots
Naxalites Problem
Kashmir Violance
North-East Violance
Muzaffarngar Violance
Namaste,
The Preamble of Indian Constitution assures or insures against loss of life of
citizens of India. Our Constitution has many demerits. As I have come to the
conclusion that our constitution in not written for happiness, progress and
prosperity but it a NOOSE on the neck of 'Bhartamata' {Birtmiti} or India.
Slavery of 800 years has indoctrinated people of India, 'IGNORANCE'. Our
first President of India pledged that our future programme will be ERADICATION
OF IGNORANCE. The successive governments have not taken cognizance of the
first republic day address to the nation on 26th
1950, by the first president of India.
Leaders of India are ignorant. The first reason is slavery. The second reason is
vote-bank politics. The third reason is violation of constitutional obligation. The
fourth reason is our constitution. The fifth reason is xenocetrism.
A king or a queen of U.K.(United kingdom) ruled over about 45 colonies.
The sun never set on his/her empire. The authority of colonial empire remained at
'Bunkinghum' palace in the hands of the king or queen to police-patels or
chaudharys of villages.
As soon as India became sovereign state the Constitution prevails over
India.
2. 2
Our Constitution has created chaos in India. Innocent people of India are
killed by political persons or political parties on accuase of riots. The Constitution
has failed to protect lives of citizens of India. Our Constitution has many demarits.
The Constitution must be written again or amend the rules in the context of 'LAW
AND ORDER'. Here are some maxims:
(1) The president of India must be a philosopher.
(2) Election of the president of India must be similar to election of the president of
France.
(3) Election of the president of India must be direct election by citizens of India.
(4) Home Ministry of India must be in the hands of president of India.
(5) Home Ministry of states must be in the hands of the governors of a state.
(6) Defense and foreign affairs ministry must be in the hands of the president of
India.
(7) Law and order authority must be in the hands of collectors of districts.
(8) The prime minister and Chief minister must be stripped of 'Law and order
authority'.
(9) Political rulers of the nation or the states must not be given authority of law
and order.
The President of India.
Now The President of India The qualities of The President of
India
1 Is a Politician 1 She/He must be a Philosopher
2 has a symbolic power 2 She/He must possess total
authority of India.
3 Violates constitutional obligation to
please prime minister and surrender
his/her authority to the PM
3 He/She should never sign on
resolution passed by parliament
which are against Constitutional
obligation.
4 Is authorityless 4 He/She must have complete
authority of India
5 remain spectator when violence take
place.
5 Within minutes, he/she must order
competent authority to protect
citizens of India.
The Prime Minister of India.
Now the Prime Minister of India Qualities of Prime Minister of India
1 Total Authority of India possesses the
PM.
1 Only welfare projects must be
administered by the PM.
2 Foreign affairs ministry is controlled by
the PM.
2 The foreign affairs must be
controlled by the President of
India.
3. 3
3 Home affairs ministry is governed by
the PM.
3 Home affairs ministry must be
ruled by the President of India.
4 Defense ministry is controlled by the
PM.
4 Defense ministry must be
governed by the President of India.
5 The Prime minister represents a
political party or political parties.
5 The Prime minister of India must
represent himself/herself as
apolitical person.
6 The Prime minister has grabbed
authority of the president of India.
6 The Prime minister of India must
be stripped of home affairs,
defence affairs and foreign affairs
ministries.
7 The Prime minister is governing our
nation, keeping in mind Vote-bank
politics.
7 The Prime minister must govern
the nation for welfare projects.
The Chief Minister of India.
Now Chief Minister of State Qualities of Chief Minister
1 Chief ministers run home affairs
ministries.
1 Chief minister must be stripped of
Home affairs.
2 Chief ministers run welfare projects
and possess law and order authority.
2 Law and order authority must be
under the governor of the State.
3 Chief ministers have grabbed
authority of the governor of States.
3 The governor must possess total
law and order authority.
The governor of the State.
Now governor The qualities of the Governors.
1 The governor has symbolized
power. Governors are stripped of
law and order authority.
1 The governor must possess total law
and order authority.
2 The Chief ministers of the states
has grabbed authority of the
governors
2 The governors must work under the
president of India for law and order
authority.
The Collectors of India
Now the Collectors Qualities of Collectors
1 The Collectors have symbolic power.
They are stripped of authority by CMs
1 The collectors must have total law
and order authority of the Districts.
2 The collectors are like
- One man two masters, e.g.
- The governor and the chief minister
2 The collectors have nothing to do
with respective CMs
4. 4
3 The collectors must be under the
governor for law and order authority
only
3 The collectors have nothing to with
welfare projects
4 The collectors invigilate welfare
project
4 The welfare projects are run by
DDOs who works under CMs.
The Mamalatdars of Tehsil
Now Mamalatdars Qualities of Mamalatdar
1 Mamalatdar have symbolic power.
They are stripped of authority by CMs
1 Mamalatdars must have total
authority of Tehsil or Taluka
{t[hs)l yi til&ki}
2 Mamalatdars work under CMs 2 Mamalatdars must work under
collectors for law and order
authority.
Village Police Patels or Chaudhris
Now Police-Patels or Chaudhris Qualities of Police Patels or Chaudhris
1 The Police Patel or chaudhris post is
abolished by the government of India
1 There must be police Patel or
Chaudhari post to invigilate law
and order in the village
2 There is chaos in India in the field of
law and order.
2 The President of India, The
governors of States, The collectors
of districts and Mamalatdar of
tehsil must appoint policce Patels
or Chaudhris cadre for law and
order in the nation.
5. 5
Authority Models Relating To Law and Order
Sr.
No
Region Colonial
Authority model
Authority Model of
Independent India
Ideal Authority
model for
Sovereign Nation
Remarks
1 Nation King or queen of
U.K.
Governor-general
of India
Constitution
Symbolic Authority of the
President of India
Real Authority is
Possessed by the Prime
Minister of India
(1) Authority of Home
affairs
(2) Authority of Defence
ministry
(3) Authority of foreign
affairs
Constitution
In principle and
practice the
Authority must be in
hands of The
Presidents of India,
He/She must be a
Philosopher. He/She
must not be a
Politician
(1) Authority of
Home affairs
(2) Authority of
Defence ministry
(3) Authority of
foreign affair
(1) The PM is elected
by a political party
or group of
parties.
It means the
PM or political party
or parties has
grabbed authority of
the president of India.
(2) Home affairs
Defence affairs
and foreign affair
must be under the
president of India.
2 State Governor Symbolic Authority of
Governor of the State
Real Authority is
Possessed by the chief
Minister
(1) Authority of Home
affairs
In principle and
practice the
Authority must be
under the Governor
of the state. He/She
must be a
Philosopher
(1) Authority of
Home Affairs
The CM is elected by
political party or
parties It means
political party or
parties have grabbed
authority from the
governor. Home
affairs must be in the
hands of the
governor.
3 District Collector Symbolic Authority of the
Collector. For remains
law and order.
Real Authority is
possessed by the CM
and his/her ministers.
In principle and
practice law and
order Authority must
be in the hands of
collector
The CM and his/her
ministers have
grabbed Authority of
the collector. It
means political
parties have grabbed
Authority of the
collector
6. 6
4 Tehsil or
Taluka
Mamalatdar Symbolic Authority of
mamalatdar remains for
law and order. Real
Authority is possessed
by the CM and his
ministers
In principle and
practice Authority
must be in the hands
of the Mamlatdar
The CM and his/her
minister have
grabbed Authority of
Mamalatdar. It
means political
parties have grabbed
Authority of
Mamalatdar.
5 Village,
Town
Ward
Police Patel or
Chaudhari
- In Practice and
principle Authority
must be in the hands
of police patel or
chaudhris.
The government of
India has abolished
police patel cadre.
The real cause of
chaos in India
relating to law and
order is abolition of
police Patel or
Chaudhary Cadre.
Authority Model is Short
Sr.
No.
Region Colonial
Authority
Model in Independent
India
Ideal Model in India Remarks
1 Nation King / Queen
Governor-general
of India
Constitution
Prime Minister of India
(Political Parties/Party)
Constitution
The President of India
2 States Governors Chief Minister (Political
Party or Parties)
Governors of States
under the President
3 District Collectors Collectors under chief
Ministers
Collectors under
Governors
4 Tehsil or
Taluka
Mamalatdars Mamalatdars under
Chief Minister
Mamalatdars under
Collectors
5 Villages
Towns,
wards
Police Patels or
Chaudharis
Nobody is responsible
for law and order
Police Patel or
Chaudharis must be
appointed under
Mamalatdar
7. 7
Conclusions :-
(1) Reinstate the president of India, the governors of states, the collectors of
districts, the mamalatdars of tehsil and police-patel or chaudharis of
villages, towns or wards for total law and order. authority
(2) PMs and CMs must be stripped of authority relating to law and order
because they are representing political party or parties.
(3) Political party or parties set their scores equal after getting authority of
nation and states.
(4) Political party or parties are observing vote-bank politics; so they neglect
national responsibly and violate constitutional obligations.
(5) The PM and CMs have grabbed authority relating law and order from the
president of India and the governors of states respectively.
(6) The president of India and the governors of states must be philosophers
(t_vdS)<)
(7) Paid Police-Patel or Chaudharis cadre must be reinstated as early as
possible in all villages towns and wards.
(8) Authority relating law and order is in the hands of political parties, So there
is chaos in India on the field of law and order.
(9) The colonial model of law and order must be reinstated as soon as possible
for the welfare, happiness, prosperity and progress of the citizens of India.
8. 8
AUTHORITY
THE CONSTITUTION OR THE PHILOSOPHY
THE PRESIDENT OF INDIA OR THE PHILOSOPHER
Authority of
Law and Order
Authority of
Welfare Projects
Defence
affairs
Home affairs foreign
affairs
central bureau of
investigation or
CBI
Prime Minister
Governors of
States or
Philosophers of
States
Commerce &
Technology
Health Education Agriculture
Chief Minister of States
RAF
Rapid
Action
Force
SRP(State
Reserved
Police)
Police
Force
Investigating
agencies
Commerce Health Education Agriculture
& Technology
Collectors of Districts District Development Officer or DDO
Home affairs Police Force Crime
Investigating
Department
Commerce
and
Technology
Health Land Education Agriculture
Mamlatdar of Tehsil or Taluka
Taluka or Tehsil Development
Officer or TDO
Police Force Home Guards Land Health Education Agriculture
Police Patels or Sarpanch (srp>c)
Chaudharies in every Village,
Town and wards
Primary Amenities Land Health Education Agriculture
9. 9
Conclusion :-
1. The president of India must be a Philosopher.
2. The election of the President of India must be done directly.
3. The constitution must reflect the Philosophy or Vedant (v[di>t)
4. All over India, Police – Patel or Chaudhary Cadre must be introduced. They
must be trained to restore law and order. They must be paid Servants.
5. The Police – Patel or Chaudhary is the first informer to mamlatdar of violation of
law and order. He/She is first person to stop quarrels, attacks on each other
groups. He/She is first eye witness of the crime.
6. Criteria for selection of Police – Patels or Chaudharis should be enacted.
7. PM and CMs have nothing to do with law and order authority
8. Law and order must be only and only under the President of India, Governer of
state, collector of district, Mamlatdar of Tehsil or Taluka and Police Patel or
Chaudhary of Village, town's and words are assistants
9. "The trigger of a gun" on and off must be under the authority of the president of
India. This means authority relating law and order remains only and – only
under the president of India.
10. The authority relating ' Law and order' flows or percolates from the president of
India to the Police Patel or Chaudhari.
Criticism on Existing Authority of India Criticism on Ideal Authority Model of
India
1 When swearing in ceremony take place at
Rashtrapati Bhavan the President of India
pledge or take an oath to protect the
constitution with letter and spirit. The
constitution promises to save or protect lives of
the citizens.
The president of India possesses -
symbolic authority. Literarily, if we humanize
the authority as a woman. The woman
(Authority) has ran away with prime minister of
India, who represents political party or group of
political parties.
If we humanize political party as a man,
1 The principal responsibility of this
office is to function as the
guardian of our constitution.
- PRANAB
MUKHERJEE,
- President
2 The president of India pledges to
defend the constitution in
principle.
3 The president of India has a
symbolic power or authority in
practice Without authority how
can he/she defend constitution ?
10. 10
the woman (Authority) loves a man (Political
Party or Parties). This means in principle
authority must remain in Rashtrapati Bhavan
but in practice Authority remains in PMO –
Prime Minister's office. The man has abducted
the woman. The CMs of states have abducted
above woman's daughters. Her daughters
must remain at governors residence.
People of India are misguided by the
wrong interpretation of the constitution.
NO MAN CAN SERVE TWO MASTERS
4 Ideal authority model suggests
that law and order authority must
remain in the hands of President
of India.
5 Home affairs Ministry, Defence
ministry, foreign affairs ministry
must be under the president of
India.
6 The PM and CMs must possess
welfare projects authority only.
They have nothing to do with 'law
and order' authority. PM and CMs
have grabbed authority of the
president of India.
7 The President of India must hold
'law and order' authority totally.
8 Military, Paramilitary, Police force
must be under the President of
India.
The Governor The Chief Minister 9 'Law and Order' authority must be
passed to the Governers of
States.
10 The Governer must control
Paramilitary and Police force.
Authority Given by Authority given by
the
the President of India Prime Minister
to Governer to chief minister
11 Home affairs ministry of the state
must be abolished.
Rule of law and order Home Minister
according to the at state level
constitution
12 The governors of states must
pass law and order authority to
the collectors of districts.
13 The Police force must be under
the collectors for law and order.
11. 11
POLICE FORCE Dilema Whom to obey ? 14 The collectors must pass the
authority of law and order to the
Mamalatdars of tehsil or taluka.
The police force, Paramilitary force is
responcible to the governers of the states only.
The home affairs ministery is useless,
meaningless and violation of constitutional
obligations. The PM and CMs have nothing to
do with Law and order.
The law and order authority is grabbed by
PM and CMs. The PM and CMs are entitled to
practise according to rules of the welfare
projects only.
Distribution of authority by the
constitution is obscure as above.
The convicted police officers during riots in
Gujarat in 2002 A.D. are innocent. So they
must be freed from jails and criminal charges.
They must be reinstated to their respective
posts with dignity. They are victim of the
obsecurity of the constitution.
15 The Police force must be under
Mamalatdar.
16 The Mamalatdar must pass the
authority to police patels or
chaudhris of villages towns and
wards.
17 No political party and its followers
must not be allowed to interfere in
law and order process.
18 The constitution promises to save
lives of citizens.
The Collectors The Chief Minister
Authority given by Authority given
constitution or Governer by The PM
Dilemma
Police Force Whom to Obey?
1 The president of India has symbolic power.
So he/she is
1 The President of India has total
authority.
12. 12
- dumb
- deaf
- blind
- inactive
- insensitive
- rubber stem of PM
He/She violates constitutional obligations.
He/She can not save lives of citizens, in some
incidents.
So he/she
- speaks to restore law and
order.
- hears complaints regarding
law and order.
- invigilates the law and
order situation.
- remains very active.
- remains sensitive to the
citizens, feelings.
- make PM as rubber stamp.
- protects constitutional
values with letter and spirit.
- can save lives of citizens.
2 Due to symbolic power of the president of India
– many problems have arised.
(i) Possibility of civil war.
(ii) Possibility of world war.
(iii) higher birth rate in Muslim
community.
(iv) corruption increases.
(v) violence increases.
(vi) army and para military force can
not decide whom to follow PM or
President of India.
(vii) foreign policy is weakened.
(viii) law and order situation has
worsened.
(ix) riots take place now and then.
(x) criminal representatives for MPs and
MLAs posts are elected.
(xi) criminal incidents like thefts,
murders, dacoits, loots, abductions
rapes etc. have been increasing.
(xii) evasion of constitutional duties.
2 Due to total authority of the
president of India many problems
will be solved.
(i) common civil code will
be introduced.
(ii) family planning will be
compulsory.
(iii) army, paramilitary
force will obey only and
only the president of
India.
(iv) corruption in all fields
will come to its low ebb.
(v) violence will decrease.
(vi) life of citizens will be
protected.
(vii) happiness, prosperity
and progress will
prevail over India.
(viii) criminalization of
assemblies and
parliament will be
13. 13
(xiii) one nation and observance of two
constitution.
(xiv) Division of the society.
(xv) threat to national unity and integrity.
(xvi) destruction of Vedant culture
{v[di>t s>AkZ(t}
(xvii) the nation is heading towards
slavery again for ever under Muslim
community.
(xviii) Vote bank politics have emerged.
(xix) criminalization of assemblies and
parliament.
(xx) xenocentrism prevails.
(xxi) Vedant culture has been vanishing
due to attack of foreign culture.
(xxii) education process spreads
ignorance.
- He/She is rubber stamp of PM.
- He/She is politician, So he/she remains
obliged to the political parties.
- He/She is elected by the voting of MPs
of and MLAS.
- Chaos in all fields of governance
prevails.
- religionization of the nation is going on
rapidly.
abolished.
(ix) Ethnocentrism will
prevail.
(x) Vedant culture will be
restored.
(xi) There will be no threat
to unity and integrity.
(xii) foreign policy will
increase dignity of the
nation.
(xiii) ignorance will be
abolished by the
education.
(xiv) The Philosophy will
prevail over India.
(xv) chaos in all fields of
governance will be
abolished.
(xvi) home affairs ministry
defence ministry,
foreign affairs ministry
will be under the
president of India.
(xvii) He/She will be elected
by direct voting of the
citizens.
(xviii) The president of India
will not be obliged to
the political parties.
(xix) He/She will not be
rubber stamp of the
PM.
14. 14
After independence successive governments have failed to protect lives of
citizens of India. Federalism has failed in India. Events shown in reference are
examples of violent incidents. The president of India have been violating
constitutional obligations. The PM and CMs also violating constitutional obligations.
If the President of India, the prime minister of India and chief ministers of
respective states fail to protect life of civilians of India. The human rights
organization must impeach the president of India, prime minister of India and chief
minister of state. Where citizens are killed by conspiracy hatched by political
groups.
Federalism does not confer authority of law and order upon states.
Federalism confer only authority of welfare projects upon states.
Every square of centimetre of Indian territory must be ruled by the president
of India and authority of law and order must prevail over India. The Prime minister
and chief ministers are not authorized to possess law and order authority in the
context of constitutional provision.
NO MAN CAN SERVE TWO MASTERS
Authority
President's authority to protect
lives of civilians, according to
the constitution
Authority to protect lives of
civilians; according to the
Federalism
Police Force
Dilemma
Whom to obey ?
Who is accountable, when innocent people are killed ?
I as a civilian come to the conclusion that the president of India is
accountable for the killings of innocent citizens, because he/she is a guardian of
the constitution.
Federalism does not allow to kill innocent people. The PM and CMs
sometimes become insensitive, inactive, cruel, unaccountable and vengeful to
some groups. The constitution never allows to harbor such types of criminal
feelings. The law and order authority of PM and CMs must be confiscated by the
15. 15
president of India. The PM and CMs represent their political parties, who practice
vote-bank politics.
The traitor of India practice vote-bank politics.
A B
Authority of
law and order Percolates
Authority of welfare projects Percolates
from from
The constitution of India The constitution of India
to to
president of India The prime minister of India
to to
The Governors of states The CMs of states
to to
The collectors of districts The DDOs of Districts
to to
The Mamalatdars of Tehsils The TDOs of Tehsils
to to
Police Patels of Villages, Towns and wards The Sarpanchs of villages, Towns and
wards.
Army, paramilitary force, crime investigation agencies, SRP, CRPF, Plice
force, RAF, HG etc government agencies to restore and enforce law and order in
India they must remain under the president of India. The president of India not only
possesses authority of law and order but possesses authority of welfare projects
also. So the PM and CMs are ruling nation and states respectively under the
authority of the president of India, because The president of India is a guardian of
the constitution of India.
Chaos in the context of law and order authority will be abolished from India,
if the above 'A' model will be introduced by the government of India. If the
government fails to save lives of citizens. It is human rights violation and violation
of constitutional obligations. So responsible government rulers and bureaucrats
are liable to be impeached and punished.