The Importance of Attracting
Skilled Tradespeople
Moderator:Moderator:
Suresh Parmachand, Sr. Marketing Mgr., Canada - Uponor
Panelists:Panelists:
Mark Eatherton, Executive Director – Radiant Professional Alliance
(RPA), Contractor Magazine
Adam Freill, Editor - Mechanical Business Magazine
Ron Jones, President – Green Builder Media
Steve Swanson, Trainer – Uponor
Mark Vreugdenhil, Publisher – HVAC & Plumbing Magazine
The CastThe Cast
The Generational IdentityThe Generational Identity
Current Market (Post War to Boomer)Current Market (Post War to Boomer) Future Market (Gen X, Y and Millennial)Future Market (Gen X, Y and Millennial)
Workaholic
Loyal to
company
Rank and
file
Risk Averse
GAPGAP
Work/Life
Balance
Loyal to
ideals
Capitalize on
Opportunities
Risk
1940’s1940’s 1960’s1960’s 1980’s1980’s 2000’s2000’s
1950’s 1970’s 1990’s
Today
A Generational SummaryA Generational Summary
War Child
Post War
Baby Boom ME Generation Millennial
Generation X Generation Y
$4 600
$10 950
$13 600
$23 400
$14 100
$6 450
$4 130
$2 400
$89 330
$22 100
$113 150
$35 900
$297 000
$46 326
Poverty
$23k
A Generational SummaryA Generational Summary
Source: AC Neilsen
Greatest Generation (1901-1924)
Silent Generation (1925-1945)
Baby Boomers (1946-1964)
Generation X (1965-1976)
Millennials/Gen Y (1977-1995)
--Younger Millennials (18-27)
--Older Millennials (28-36)
Generation Z (1995-Present)
What Are You Seeing
As The Hurdles For
Engaging New
Generations?
56 industry tradesperson average age
Source: US Census
Population DistributionPopulation Distribution
Source: emsi/career builder
53%
45+
With An Aging
Workforce How Do You
Feel the Industry Is
Perceiving the Issue Of
Industry Attraction?
Industry 2020Industry 2020
Prospective Students Have No Interest
54%
37%
25%
Young people believe
there is better future
working in computers
than skilled trades.
Young people believe that
skilled trades is old
fashioned.
Young people believe
working in an office is
more respected than
working with your hands.
11%
Students not interested
because they don’t think
the trades are cool.
Industry 2020Industry 2020
• Average age of skilled trades : 61
• Age impacts the ability to capitalize on market opportunities
• Labour rate on skilled trades increases by ~30%
• Unskilled workers enter market to fill market needs
• Problems are created within marketplace due to poor installation
• Skilled workers are called into fix problems
• Problem perpetuates
Skilled Trades Become Firefighters
What Are The
Pitfalls Of This
Scenario Playing
Out?
Source: Stats Canada, US Census
Canadian Population Breakdown US Population Breakdown
What Age Group Do
You Feel Can Drive
Change? Why?
Market DiversityMarket Diversity
Market DiversityMarket Diversity
Market DiversityMarket Diversity
Half of children under 5 are ethnic.
By 2019 half of children under 18 will be ethnic.
Source: NBC Nesws, US Census,
“More so than ever, we need to recognize the
importance of young minorities for the growth
and vitality of our labour force and economy.“
-William H Fey, Demographer - Bookings Institute
Notable Quotes:Notable Quotes:
How Are Changes
In Workforce
Diversity Going to
Impact Industry?
New Leadership ParadigmNew Leadership Paradigm
TraditionalTraditional New AgeNew Age
• Hierarchical
• Goal-oriented
• Manage resources
• Knowledge
• Extroversion
• Experience
• Egotism
• Empowering
• Intelligence
• Success
• Influence
• Effectiveness (myopic)
• Drives Consistency
Leadership is influence, nothing more,
nothing less.
-John Maxwell
Leadership is the process of influencing others
to work towards a mutually desired vision.
-David Burkus
• Holistic
• People-oriented
• Liberate resources
• Situational impact
• Self-motivated
• Intellectual Capital Management
• Self confident
• Without Boundaries
• Selfless
• Trust
• Effectiveness (peripheral)
• Collaborator
• Enabler
Source: Actionpointe, Journal of Applied Psychology
Meet business objectives
Creating an environment where individuals
will be allowed to foster positive change
“Management causes 85% of problems in an
organization.”
-Dr. Demmings
The cost of losing an employee in the first
year of hire is projected at 3 times their
annual salary.
-Wynhurst Group
How Is This New
Leadership
Paradigm Going To
Impact Industry?
Media Drives Perception
1 in 3
Parents would encourage
children to work in trade
High Schools have become incubators for College and University
3 Generations of Change…
Source: Association od University and Colleges of Canada (AUCC)
* Employment
changes in thousands
6 Million6 Million
BoomersBoomers
In 2 DecadesIn 2 Decades
The Hierarchy of Trades – Perception Drives Decisions
Stories Are Being Told
How Can We
Improve Perception
of the Trade?
49% 51%
Median Age
41
Gender Breakdown
source: Stats Canada, US Census 2010
source: Stats Canada
Are We Doing
Enough To Attract
Women To Our
Industry?
Special Education Funding
Sources: 2006 U.S. Budget, Historical Tables.
This graph shows that federal grants from special education rose from under $250 million in
1977 to $5 billion in 2000 nearly $12 billion in 2005.
20 % reduction20 % reduction
in technicalin technical
eductioneduction
Decline (millions)
How Does Public
Policy Need To
Change Our
Education System?
51% 49%
Smartphone
Audience
Social Landscape
72% 1919%%1919%%
22%%22%%
3535%%3535%%
4343%%4343%%
1313%%1313%%1313%%1313%% 2121%%2121%%
5252%%5252%%
Social @ PlaySocial @ Play
99%%99%%
44%%44%% 1111%%1111%%
7676%%7676%%
Social @ WorkSocial @ Work
22%%22%%
The Power Of One
Social mediaSocial media has changed the
way we consume and share
information.
Technology has provided a conduit for
individuals to shareindividuals to share their
stories, opinions, thoughts, content,
images, videos, etc. to theto the
massesmasses, with few restrictions.
Cognitive Learning
Gamification Of Industry LearningGamification Of Industry Learning
Source: www.interplayenergy.com/intercaz
How Have Social
Trends Changed in
Business? How Can
We Leverage These
Trends To Build
Awareness?
Brain Drain - Today
18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+
16 561 000
Age Distribution
3% 18% 24% 45% 11%
Brain Drain – 10 years
18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+
14 739 292
Age Distribution
2% 2% 18% 23% 44% 11%
Brain Drain – 15 years
18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+
11 261 480
2% 2% 10% 21% 33% 32%
Age Distribution
How Can We
Improve
Knowledge
Transfer?
Government Programs
Source: www.actionplan.gc.ca Source: www.skillsusa.org
Association Programs
Insert HRAI program
Source: www.careertap.ca Source: www.hrai.ca
Source: www.careersinhvacr.org
Association Programs
Governments &
Associations are
Trying, But Can They
Do It Alone? How Can
We Help?
It Takes A Village
To Raise A Child
It Takes A Community To
Develop A Tradesperson
The Community
How Do You Feel
The Community Can
Work Together?
We will need to
rethink where our
leaders are from…
• Advanced Technology
Services Inc., a Peoria,
Ill., factory-
maintenance company
that employs 2,300
workers
• In the classroom –
hands on secondary
school training for high-
school graduates at a
cost of $1,500 per
student
• War veterans transition
program
What Are Others Doing?
ATS
Source: www.advancedtech.com
What Are Others Doing?
Government Of Canada
The Government of Canada launched
the Federal Skilled Trades Program in
January 2013 to facilitate the
immigration of skilled tradespeople
who meet Canada’s current and
evolving economic needs. Skilled
tradespeople are assessed on relevant
criteria, such as language ability,
practical training and work experience
rather than formal academic
education.
Source: www.cic.gc.ca
What Are Others Doing?
mikeroweWORKS Profoundly Disconnected:
A trillion dollars in student
loans. Record high
unemployment.
Three million good jobs that no
one seems to want. The goal of
Profoundly Disconnected is to
challenge the absurd belief that
a four-year degree is the only
path to success.
The Skills Gap is here, and if
we don’t close it, it’ll swallow
us all. Which is a long way of
saying, we could use your
help…
Source: www.profoundlydisconnected.com
What Are Others Doing?
Collaborative Effort
Canadian Apprenticeship Forum-Forum
www.caf-fca.org.
About Skills/Compétences Canada
www.skillscanada.ca.
About the Campaign
In 2006, the two organizations
partnered to develop and launch the
Skilled Trades: A Career you can Build
On campaign. The campaign reached
across Canada through various
resources, marketing materials, a new
website and even some theatre ads.
Source: www.careersincanada.ca
"What the industry needs is to be much more
aggressive in marketing and creating visibility.“
-Jim Ryan, Chief Executive Grainger
Notable Quotes:Notable Quotes:
"We've made work the enemy,"
-Mike Rowe, TV Personality
• Leverage government apprenticeshipLeverage government apprenticeship
programsprograms
• Work with Associations at the localWork with Associations at the local
chapter level to improve circumstancechapter level to improve circumstance
• Elevate the trade – tell your storiesElevate the trade – tell your stories
What Can you Do?What Can you Do?
suresh.parmachand@uponor.com
@mktngjnky
Linkedin.com/marketingjunky
marketingjunky.wordpress.com
Suresh ParmachandSuresh Parmachand
The Importance of AttractingThe Importance of Attracting
Skilled TradespeopleSkilled Tradespeople

The Importance of Attracting Skilled Tradespeople

  • 1.
    The Importance ofAttracting Skilled Tradespeople
  • 2.
    Moderator:Moderator: Suresh Parmachand, Sr.Marketing Mgr., Canada - Uponor Panelists:Panelists: Mark Eatherton, Executive Director – Radiant Professional Alliance (RPA), Contractor Magazine Adam Freill, Editor - Mechanical Business Magazine Ron Jones, President – Green Builder Media Steve Swanson, Trainer – Uponor Mark Vreugdenhil, Publisher – HVAC & Plumbing Magazine The CastThe Cast
  • 3.
    The Generational IdentityTheGenerational Identity Current Market (Post War to Boomer)Current Market (Post War to Boomer) Future Market (Gen X, Y and Millennial)Future Market (Gen X, Y and Millennial) Workaholic Loyal to company Rank and file Risk Averse GAPGAP Work/Life Balance Loyal to ideals Capitalize on Opportunities Risk
  • 4.
    1940’s1940’s 1960’s1960’s 1980’s1980’s2000’s2000’s 1950’s 1970’s 1990’s Today A Generational SummaryA Generational Summary War Child Post War Baby Boom ME Generation Millennial Generation X Generation Y $4 600 $10 950 $13 600 $23 400 $14 100 $6 450 $4 130 $2 400 $89 330 $22 100 $113 150 $35 900 $297 000 $46 326 Poverty $23k
  • 5.
    A Generational SummaryAGenerational Summary Source: AC Neilsen Greatest Generation (1901-1924) Silent Generation (1925-1945) Baby Boomers (1946-1964) Generation X (1965-1976) Millennials/Gen Y (1977-1995) --Younger Millennials (18-27) --Older Millennials (28-36) Generation Z (1995-Present)
  • 6.
    What Are YouSeeing As The Hurdles For Engaging New Generations?
  • 7.
    56 industry tradespersonaverage age Source: US Census
  • 8.
  • 9.
    With An Aging WorkforceHow Do You Feel the Industry Is Perceiving the Issue Of Industry Attraction?
  • 10.
    Industry 2020Industry 2020 ProspectiveStudents Have No Interest 54% 37% 25% Young people believe there is better future working in computers than skilled trades. Young people believe that skilled trades is old fashioned. Young people believe working in an office is more respected than working with your hands. 11% Students not interested because they don’t think the trades are cool.
  • 11.
    Industry 2020Industry 2020 •Average age of skilled trades : 61 • Age impacts the ability to capitalize on market opportunities • Labour rate on skilled trades increases by ~30% • Unskilled workers enter market to fill market needs • Problems are created within marketplace due to poor installation • Skilled workers are called into fix problems • Problem perpetuates Skilled Trades Become Firefighters
  • 12.
    What Are The PitfallsOf This Scenario Playing Out?
  • 13.
    Source: Stats Canada,US Census Canadian Population Breakdown US Population Breakdown
  • 14.
    What Age GroupDo You Feel Can Drive Change? Why?
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Market DiversityMarket Diversity Halfof children under 5 are ethnic. By 2019 half of children under 18 will be ethnic. Source: NBC Nesws, US Census,
  • 18.
    “More so thanever, we need to recognize the importance of young minorities for the growth and vitality of our labour force and economy.“ -William H Fey, Demographer - Bookings Institute Notable Quotes:Notable Quotes:
  • 19.
    How Are Changes InWorkforce Diversity Going to Impact Industry?
  • 20.
    New Leadership ParadigmNewLeadership Paradigm TraditionalTraditional New AgeNew Age • Hierarchical • Goal-oriented • Manage resources • Knowledge • Extroversion • Experience • Egotism • Empowering • Intelligence • Success • Influence • Effectiveness (myopic) • Drives Consistency Leadership is influence, nothing more, nothing less. -John Maxwell Leadership is the process of influencing others to work towards a mutually desired vision. -David Burkus • Holistic • People-oriented • Liberate resources • Situational impact • Self-motivated • Intellectual Capital Management • Self confident • Without Boundaries • Selfless • Trust • Effectiveness (peripheral) • Collaborator • Enabler Source: Actionpointe, Journal of Applied Psychology Meet business objectives Creating an environment where individuals will be allowed to foster positive change
  • 21.
    “Management causes 85%of problems in an organization.” -Dr. Demmings The cost of losing an employee in the first year of hire is projected at 3 times their annual salary. -Wynhurst Group
  • 22.
    How Is ThisNew Leadership Paradigm Going To Impact Industry?
  • 23.
  • 24.
    1 in 3 Parentswould encourage children to work in trade High Schools have become incubators for College and University 3 Generations of Change… Source: Association od University and Colleges of Canada (AUCC) * Employment changes in thousands 6 Million6 Million BoomersBoomers In 2 DecadesIn 2 Decades
  • 25.
    The Hierarchy ofTrades – Perception Drives Decisions
  • 26.
  • 27.
    How Can We ImprovePerception of the Trade?
  • 28.
    49% 51% Median Age 41 GenderBreakdown source: Stats Canada, US Census 2010
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Are We Doing EnoughTo Attract Women To Our Industry?
  • 31.
    Special Education Funding Sources:2006 U.S. Budget, Historical Tables. This graph shows that federal grants from special education rose from under $250 million in 1977 to $5 billion in 2000 nearly $12 billion in 2005. 20 % reduction20 % reduction in technicalin technical eductioneduction Decline (millions)
  • 32.
    How Does Public PolicyNeed To Change Our Education System?
  • 33.
    51% 49% Smartphone Audience Social Landscape 72%1919%%1919%% 22%%22%% 3535%%3535%% 4343%%4343%% 1313%%1313%%1313%%1313%% 2121%%2121%% 5252%%5252%% Social @ PlaySocial @ Play 99%%99%% 44%%44%% 1111%%1111%% 7676%%7676%% Social @ WorkSocial @ Work 22%%22%%
  • 34.
    The Power OfOne Social mediaSocial media has changed the way we consume and share information. Technology has provided a conduit for individuals to shareindividuals to share their stories, opinions, thoughts, content, images, videos, etc. to theto the massesmasses, with few restrictions.
  • 35.
    Cognitive Learning Gamification OfIndustry LearningGamification Of Industry Learning Source: www.interplayenergy.com/intercaz
  • 36.
    How Have Social TrendsChanged in Business? How Can We Leverage These Trends To Build Awareness?
  • 38.
    Brain Drain -Today 18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+ 16 561 000 Age Distribution 3% 18% 24% 45% 11%
  • 39.
    Brain Drain –10 years 18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+ 14 739 292 Age Distribution 2% 2% 18% 23% 44% 11%
  • 40.
    Brain Drain –15 years 18-25 26-37 38-49 50-60 61-70 71+ 11 261 480 2% 2% 10% 21% 33% 32% Age Distribution
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Association Programs Insert HRAIprogram Source: www.careertap.ca Source: www.hrai.ca
  • 44.
  • 45.
    Governments & Associations are Trying,But Can They Do It Alone? How Can We Help?
  • 46.
    It Takes AVillage To Raise A Child
  • 47.
    It Takes ACommunity To Develop A Tradesperson
  • 48.
  • 49.
    How Do YouFeel The Community Can Work Together?
  • 50.
    We will needto rethink where our leaders are from…
  • 52.
    • Advanced Technology ServicesInc., a Peoria, Ill., factory- maintenance company that employs 2,300 workers • In the classroom – hands on secondary school training for high- school graduates at a cost of $1,500 per student • War veterans transition program What Are Others Doing? ATS Source: www.advancedtech.com
  • 53.
    What Are OthersDoing? Government Of Canada The Government of Canada launched the Federal Skilled Trades Program in January 2013 to facilitate the immigration of skilled tradespeople who meet Canada’s current and evolving economic needs. Skilled tradespeople are assessed on relevant criteria, such as language ability, practical training and work experience rather than formal academic education. Source: www.cic.gc.ca
  • 54.
    What Are OthersDoing? mikeroweWORKS Profoundly Disconnected: A trillion dollars in student loans. Record high unemployment. Three million good jobs that no one seems to want. The goal of Profoundly Disconnected is to challenge the absurd belief that a four-year degree is the only path to success. The Skills Gap is here, and if we don’t close it, it’ll swallow us all. Which is a long way of saying, we could use your help… Source: www.profoundlydisconnected.com
  • 55.
    What Are OthersDoing? Collaborative Effort Canadian Apprenticeship Forum-Forum www.caf-fca.org. About Skills/Compétences Canada www.skillscanada.ca. About the Campaign In 2006, the two organizations partnered to develop and launch the Skilled Trades: A Career you can Build On campaign. The campaign reached across Canada through various resources, marketing materials, a new website and even some theatre ads. Source: www.careersincanada.ca
  • 56.
    "What the industryneeds is to be much more aggressive in marketing and creating visibility.“ -Jim Ryan, Chief Executive Grainger Notable Quotes:Notable Quotes: "We've made work the enemy," -Mike Rowe, TV Personality
  • 57.
    • Leverage governmentapprenticeshipLeverage government apprenticeship programsprograms • Work with Associations at the localWork with Associations at the local chapter level to improve circumstancechapter level to improve circumstance • Elevate the trade – tell your storiesElevate the trade – tell your stories What Can you Do?What Can you Do?
  • 58.
    suresh.parmachand@uponor.com @mktngjnky Linkedin.com/marketingjunky marketingjunky.wordpress.com Suresh ParmachandSuresh Parmachand TheImportance of AttractingThe Importance of Attracting Skilled TradespeopleSkilled Tradespeople

Editor's Notes

  • #7 Panelists: Krystal, Jennifer and Joanna (rest of the group as needed)
  • #13 Panelists: Mark, Ron and Jennifer (rest of the group as needed)
  • #15 Panelists: Ron, Jennifer and Joanna (rest of the group as needed)
  • #20 Panelists: All (round robin)
  • #25 Over the last 40 years, Canada’s economy has been driven by labour market growth. However, demographic projections confirm that Canada can no longer rely on rapid population growth to fuel our economy. In the next two decades, the number of Canadians over the age of 65 will double. More than 6 million baby boomers will retire and this older population will create greater demand for legal, health and social services throughout our economy.
  • #28 Panelists: Joanna and Mark
  • #46 Panelists: Joanna and Mark