SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Assignment Overview
This Case Assignment focuses on Volkswagen’s emissions
scandal and related
brand management and business ethics issues.
Case Reading
Boston, W., & Houston-Waesch, M. (2015, Oct 15).
Volkswagen suspends
another top engineer; berlin orders recall; transport minister
says recall of tainted
diesel cars is mandatory. Wall Street Journal (Online).
Cremer, A. (2016, April 20). VW to pay each U.S. customer
$5,000 to settle
dieselgate: Die Welt. Retrieved from
http://www.reuters.com/article
/us-volkswagen-emissions-court-idUSKCN0XH0ZV
Danny, Hakim, Kessler, A. M., & Ewing, J. (2015, Sep 27). As
VW pushed to be
no. 1, ambitions fueled a scandal. New York Times. De Cremer,
D., & de
Bettignies, H. (2013). PRAGMATIC BUSINESS ETHICS.
Business Strategy
Review, 24(2), 64-67.
De Cremer, D., & de Bettignies, H. (2013). PRAGMATIC
BUSINESS
ETHICS. Business Strategy Review, 24(2), 64-67.
Ewing, J. (2016, April 21). Volkswagen Reaches Deal in U.S.
Over Emissions
Scandal. New York Times. Retrieved from
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04
/22/business/international/volkswagen-emissions-
settlement.html?_r=0
Farrell, S. (2015, Oct. 26). Volkswagen loses sales top spot to
Toyota after
emissions scandal. Retrieved from
http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/oct
/26/volkswagen-top-spot-toyota-vw-emissions-scandal.
Fung, B. (2015). Volkswagen's U.S. CEO apologizes for
emissions cheating
scandal. Washington: WP Company LLC d/b/a The Washington
Post.
Lane, C. (2015, Oct. 26). Emissions scandal is hurting VW
owners trying to
Resell. Retrieved from
http://www.npr.org/2015/10/26/450238773/emissions-
scandal-is-hurting-vw-owners-trying-to-resell.
Listen
https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501-
DEC2016FT-2...
1 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM
La Monica, P.,R. (2015, Sep 23). Volkswagen has plunged 50%.
will it ever
recover? CNN Wire Service.
Sanger-Katz, M., & Schwartz, J. (2015, Sep 30). Gauging
human toll of VW
fraud. International New York Times.
Here are some articles on brand equity and brand management.
Keller, K. L. (1993). Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing
customer-based
brand equity. Journal of Marketing, 57(1), 1-22.
Helm, S., & Tolsdorf, J. (2013). How does corporate reputation
affect customer
loyalty in a corporate crisis? Journal of Contingencies & Crisis
Management, 21
(3), p144-152.
Case Assignment
Develop a report in terms of the following guidelines. A well-
written report should
have a brief introduction, headings or subheadings, and a brief
concluding
comment. Note that you should use some keywords as headings
or subheadings
such as "Brand Equity of VW”, instead of a sentence or a
question. Read and cite
required articles on Volkswagen’s emissions scandal, as well as
additional
research you have done, and address the following issues:
Briefly describe Volkswagen’s emissions scandal and provide
background on
the company and automobile industry.
1.
Do you think Volkswagen’s brand reputation was severely
damaged by the
emissions scandal? How about its brand equity? Discuss what
brand equity is,
and how Volkswagen’s brand equity will be impacted.
2.
How should Volkswagen handle the emissions scandal in an
ethical
way? Discuss the related ethical issues from both consumer and
brand
manager perspectives.
3.
What can you learn from this case? What suggestions could you
offer
to Volkswagen’s top management?
4.
Assignment Expectations
Expectations Regarding Your References and Defense of Your
Positions
Write clearly, simply, and logically. Your paper should be 750–
1,500 words long,
excluding title pages and references, but quality of writing is
more important than
length. Use double-spaced, black Verdana or Times Roman font
in 12 pt. type
size.
https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501-
DEC2016FT-2...
2 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM
Back up your positions or opinions with references to the
required readings for
this Case and those in the Module Background. In using those
references,
demonstrate your understanding of the concepts presented.
Rather than grading
on how much information you find, emphasis will be on the
defense of the
positions you take on the issues. Also remember that:
The “why” is more important than the “what.”1.
The defense of your positions on the issues is more important
than the
positions you take.
2.
Do not repeat or quote definitions. Your use of the required
reading to support
your opinions (that is, contentions or positions) should
demonstrate that you
understand the concepts presented. Do not include definitions or
summaries of
the readings or simply describe what the company did. Instead,
your responses to
the questions should be analytical and should demonstrate that
(a) you
understand the principles from the background reading and (b)
you can apply
them to this particular case. Vague, general answers will not
earn a good grade.
Avoid redundancy and general statements such as “All
organizations exist to
make a profit.” Make every sentence count.
Paraphrase the facts using your own words and ideas, employing
quotes
sparingly. Quotes, if absolutely necessary, should rarely exceed
five words.
When writing an academically oriented paper, you will uncover
many facts about
the company and the scandal. If you paraphrase the facts, cite
the sources in
your text and link those citations to references at the end of the
paper.
Here are some guidelines on how to conduct information search
and build critical
thinking skills.
Emerald Group Publishing. (n.d.). Searching for Information.
Retrieved from
http://www.emeraldinsight.com/learning/study_skills/skills/sear
ching.htm
Emerald Group Publishing. (n.d.). Developing Critical
Thinking. Retrieved from
http://www.emeraldinsight.com/learning/study_skills/skills/criti
cal_thinking.htm
Guidelines for handling quoted and paraphrased material are
found at:
Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Academic Writing. Retrieved
from
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/section/1/2/
Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Quoting, Paraphrasing, and
Summarizing.
Retrieved from
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/563/1/
Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Is it plagiarism yet?
Retrieved from
http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/1/
https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501-
DEC2016FT-2...
3 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM
Privacy Policy | Contact
Your paper consists of arguments in favor of your opinions or
positions on the
issues addressed by the guidelines; therefore, avoid the
following logical fallacies:
Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Logic in argumentative
writing. Retrieved from
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/659/01/
https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501-
DEC2016FT-2...
4 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM
Managing change and transitions:
a comparison of different models
and their commonalities
Claire V. Brisson-Banks
Family History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of this article is to analyze the
commonalities of various change and
transition models developed over time to assist with and support
managing organizational change.
Design/methodology/approach – The article provides an
examination of change and transition
models through a review of relevant literature and the
comparison of different models.
Findings – Each change and transition model has similar
methods of handling change. Their unique
methods and strategies provide additional insights into possible
applications to most organizations. In
some cases, models could be combined to form new models to
best fit the circumstances of the
organization.
Practical implications – This comparison can assist individuals
in evaluating and selecting the
model based on organizational need while remembering to focus
on both the physical and the
emotional changes in an organization.
Originality/value – The article shows that human resource
managers can benefit from learning the
commonalities between change and transition models when
considering what will work for their
organization in conjunction with the review of a number of well
known and relevant models.
Keywords Human resource management, Organizational change,
Leadership, Change management,
Adaptability
Paper type Research paper
Introduction
Change is evident everywhere from the simplest everyday
changes to the most difficult
situations encountered by human resource (HR) managers as
management grapples
with reorganizations, downsizing and/or cutbacks. A crucial
factor in the effectiveness
of an organization is the ability to adapt to change (French and
Delahaye, 1996).
According to Bridges and Mitchell (2000) “Business conditions
change and yesterday’s
assumptions and practices no longer work”.
While it may seem uncommon to some, most businesses are told
they have to
change everything from the way they think to the way they work
(Nortier, 1995).
Wagar (2000) provides a bit of history by reminding us of how
downsizing became an
obsession in the 1990s, the phrase “lean and mean” became a
primary focus of most
businesses at that time. Whether the success of downsizing
tactics worked is not the
topic for discussion here, however, the tactics employed at the
time are part of this
comparison. Today’s economic crisis has also added the new
dimension of change
needing to be immediate instead of over a period of time. Add
increased global
competition, outsourcing, fast changing and new technologies
and you have a recipe
for massive confusion to those involved in such a volatile
environment.
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is
available at
www.emeraldinsight.com/0143-5124.htm
Managing
change and
transitions
241
Received 15 August 2009
Revised 25 October 2009
Accepted 15 November 2009
Library Management
Vol. 31 No. 4/5, 2010
pp. 241-252
q Emerald Group Publishing Limited
0143-5124
DOI 10.1108/01435121011046317
Literature review
When beginning a review of studies surrounding change models,
it was discovered
that much time and energy has been devoted to bring about a
better understanding of
change as it relates to organizations. While this topic has been
looked at from various
disciplines, this article will only touch on some of the many
change and transition
models, which organizations have to choose from as they work
through their particular
organization change.
An awareness of the need for change is the beginning of the
whole change process
(Armstrong, 2006). A complete assessment of the current
situation is necessary to
begin the process of implementing any kind of change in an
organization.
Unfortunately, this kind of assessment may take longer than
management or
stakeholders have if the situation is very serious. What
happened to bring about the
need for change? What kind of issues and problems have
occurred to bring about this
crisis are questions which need to be answered as this helps to
determine the best
course of action to follow. Which change and/or transition
model will fit the
organization?
Another facet within change models are the individuals involved
in working
together to implement change. Ulrich and Brockbank (2005)
provide some insights to
this element of the equation by pointing out how “high-
performing HR professionals
make change happen successfully and thoroughly with their
most critical contribution
being to make sure the change happens quickly”. Just how
involved the HR
professional has to be for a successful change is up to the
organization. There are a
variety of reasons their involvement is imperative to the success
of any type of change.
Additionally, their familiarity with the organization’s culture
and employees becomes
a great asset to the individuals responsible for organizing
changes. This is most
significant in a change process as follow through skills become
extremely valuable and
adds to the facilitation of all types of organizational change.
Taking a step back to change itself, various studies have
revealed additional
strategies concerning the very nature of change and how it
relates to organizations.
Kanter (1985) relates how organizations have to be able to
adapt to change or face the
possibility of losing out to competition. Kanter (1985) further
expounds on how some in
top management attempt to force change by just simply
dictating it, changing polices
without warning and expecting their middle management to take
charge and make the
change work. These experiences reflect how strategic-planning
models are only a piece
of the change process, which usually results in some sort of
modifications to work with
an individual organization.
Burke (2004) looks at where the organizational development
field is in 2004, and
expresses how difficult it is to move forward without the
knowledge of what is coming.
Burke’s (2004) review of what is now known (in 2004)
evaluates change processes and
points out some of the change models which will be covered
further in this article.
Additionally, change effort is now enhanced with the aid of
training and feedback.
Burke’s (2004) comments bring out how any value-based
change effort requires
effective leadership and a business structure which includes
strategy, mission plans
and a model. When a change model is used in conjunction with
the business structure it
has a better chance of success and is part of the eight-step
change model from Kotter
(1995) where “to work together as a team united in the vision,”
is necessary for success.
LM
31,4/5
242
Axelrod (2001) reminds us of how change management and
models came to the
point of unleashing the power of employees. Previous studies
conducted by Kurt Lewin
during World War II revealed how allowing input from
employees when changes were
needed added to acceptance of the changes with a bonus of
increased productivity.
These studies were conducted with surveys and working
together to review the
collected data which resulted in better change solutions.
Axelrod (2001) further
explains there needs to be a new paradigm involving more
people and widening the
circle of involvement.
Dannemiller and Norlin (2001) have developed a different
approach altogether
calling it a whole-scale change where the business comes
together to connect the
collective wisdom of the organization creating the one brain and
one heart
methodology. This process brings in individuals from all levels
of the organization to
create the alignment needed for success. The additional touch of
requiring high
performance brings this model in line with another change
model introduced by Quinn
(2006).
Following the path of working together, Schein(2004) uses the
term “culture” and
shows how it is extremely important to investigate and study the
culture of an
organization in order to work with them in a more cohesive
manner. This very notion
of knowing the culture of the organization is the responsibility
of the leaders in order to
determine how to lead or Schein (2004) says the “culture will
lead them” making any
change model more difficult to implement.
Evans and Ward (2004) remind us how managers are in the
position of needing to
“be prepared for two types of change-planned and imposed”.
New managers are under
pressure to make a good impression and feel like they have to
implement change
correctly and operating under an unexpected or forced change
can cause great
difficulties with staff. While change can be risky and is time-
consuming, careful
preparation can enhance the process. Managers tackle the
situation of how most people
do not enjoy change, but somehow, because change must
happen, individuals will
adjust over time with the right people in management.
Beer et al. (1990) conducted studies of change programs with 12
different companies
and discovered how most do not work unless everyone is
involved and on board. Beer
et al. (1990) determined that “effective corporate renewal starts
at the bottom, through
informal efforts to solve problems”. Their studies revealed how
senior officials can be
committed to change and have to foster a climate of change
instead of mandating the
changes from the top as may have been done in the past. They
also discovered how all
departments and mangers need to be involved or the whole
process can break down.
Additional organizational change studies were conducted by
Dunphy and Stace
(1993) to show how no one model is universally applicable.
They point out how
“turbulent times demand different responses in varied
circumstances, so managers and
consultants need a model of change that is essentially a
situational or contingency
model”. Dunphy and Stace (1988) developed a contingency
model using a combination
of leadership styles and different types of changes. Identifying
the optimum mix of
leadership and change styles, while considering the
organization, is what makes the
change successful.
Bridges and Mitchell (2000) provide what they call a new model
for change. They
remind us how, over the years, a large amount of time and effort
has been spent in
studying the management of change and yet it seems to have
fallen short in providing
Managing
change and
transitions
243
the much needed solutions to the economical situations
organizations find themselves
in today as they work through a variety of necessary changes for
survival. While
change is not an easy or simple process, many still operate
today as if it is and fail to
understand why a business is unable to create a plan and follow
it through
successfully. Bridges and Mitchell (2000) point out “most
leaders imagine that
transition is automatic – that it occurs simply because the
change is happening. But it
doesn’t”. The human element of change needs to be addressed
for change to be
successful.
Kotter and Cohen (2002) have put together a collection of
success stories using
Kotter’s famous eight-step change model from 1996 as well as
situations which could
be considered failures. In the book, Kotter and Cohen (2002)
point out the reasons for
success are “[b]ecause their most central activity does not
center on formal data
gathering, analysis, report writing, and presentations . . .
instead, they compellingly
show people what the problems are and how to resolve the
problems”. It is this kind of
process that goes a long way into creating successful
organizational changes. This
change model will be discussed in this article.
Change and transition models
Lewin
One of the earliest change models was developed by Kurt
Lewin. According to Burnes
(2004) and Armstrong (2006) this model is referred to as the “3-
Step Model” developed
in 1947 and referenced in his Field Theory in Social Science
(Lewin, 1951). This model
breaks change down into three steps: unfreezing, changing, and
refreezing, Armstrong
(2006) provides greater detail to this process as follows:
. Unfreezing – is altering the present stable equilibrium which
supports existing behaviors
and attitudes. This process must take account of the inherent
threats that change presents
to people and the need to motivate those affected to attain the
natural state of equilibrium
by accepting change.
. Changing – developing new responses based on new
information.
. Refreezing – stabilizing the change by introducing the new
responses into the
personalities of those concerned (Armstrong, 2006).
This could be compared to overcoming bad habits by replacing
them with new and
better habits. The individual, like an organization, has to be
resolved and committed to
make the change and do what is necessary regardless of any
inconveniences involved
in the process. The end goal is to succeed with the change.
Burnes (2004) points out that Lewin is one of the early pioneers
of group dynamics
and how individuals will usually go along with the group norm
whether it is a positive
or negative situation or actions. Armstrong (2006) adds how
“Lewin suggests a
methodology for analyzing change which is called ‘field force
analyses’” and involves
the following:
. Analyzing the restraining or driving forces will affect the
transition to the future state;
these restraining forces will include the reactions of those who
see change as unnecessary
or as a constituting a threat.
. Assessing which of the driving or restraining forces are
critical.
. Taking steps both to increase the critical driving forces and to
decrease the critical
restraining forces (Armstrong, 2006).
LM
31,4/5
244
How does this apply to an organizational change? Ritchie
(2006) sheds some light on
how an organization can apply this to a change situation. The
unfreezing is the time
process required to prepare for change, to help the staff accept
the coming change, and
break down the status quo found through the evaluation
completed leading up to the
realization that changes were necessary for survival. This will
force the organization to
take a hard and difficult look at their very essence. Ritchie
(2004) calls this a “controlled
crisis” which adds the needed motivation to make a change.
Once the change is set in motion, individual workers may have
to find new ways to
accomplish their jobs, whether they are the same jobs in new
locations or new jobs in
the same locations. Once the workers have accepted these
changes they easily support
and adjust to the change. In Johnson’s (1998) Who Moved My
Cheese?, the character
Haw realizes he needs to move on and accept his situation
making the best of it, while
Hem refuses to change and just remains in his same state. This
is often what happens
in an organization when certain individuals refuse to accept the
changes while others
move on and work through them.
Richie (2004) states refreezing is at the point when there is a
new stable
organization, people are accepting the reorganization by
working through the new
methods and ways of accomplishing daily tasks. Once this
occurs, confidence in the
business increases and there is usually a new sense of hope and
the future looks
brighter for all in the new organization. It is at this point when
refreezing should take
place. A celebration of the new organizations should be held.
This allows everyone to
feel appreciated for their part in the success of the change.
(Remembering change is
cyclical and may have to be addressed again in the future.)
Beckhard
Richard Beckhard (1969) developed a change program, which
incorporates the
following processes (as cited in Armstrong, 2006):
. Setting goals and defining the future state or organizational
conditions desired after the
change.
. Diagnosing the present condition in relations to these goals.
. Defining the transition state activities and commitments
required to meet the future state.
. Developing strategies and action plans for managing this
transition in the light of an
analysis of the factors likely to affect the introduction of
change.
Depending on the circumstance, an organization may receive the
latest quarterly
reports and realize that change is required in order to survive or
successfully contend
with their existing or future competition. A business’s staff can
work together to plan
and implement change using this program.
To breakdown this change program further, Rouda and Kusy Jr
(1995) provide
Beckhard’s definition of organizational development; it is “[a]n
effort, planned,
organization-wide, and managed from the top, to increase
organization effectiveness
and health through planned interventions in the organization’s
process, using
behavioral-science knowledge”. This explanation provides
additional insights in how
the change program can be used in a business setting.
Looking at this change program with this added definition helps
to show how it can
be applied in a business or organizational setting when change
is imminent. According
to Rouda and Kusy Jr (1995), this model:
Managing
change and
transitions
245
[t]akes a long-range approach to improving performance and
efficiency in an organization by
looking at the total organization, adding the necessary support
from top management by
implementing it themselves along with tying it to the bottom-
line. Next apply incremental
changes over a period of time while involving the individuals in
the business providing them
an opportunity to make a positive contribution.
Additionally, Marshak (2004) states “The whole idea of planned
change assumes, in
essence, that it is possible to determine rationally how to
initiate and implement actions
to achieve and then maintain a predetermined, desired future
state”. While these steps
are not always applied in the correct order, they all need to
happen for change to be
successful.
Thurley
A third change model described in Armstrong (2006) was
introduced by K. Thurley
(1979) and has five main strategies to managing change:
“Directive, bargained, hearts
and minds, analytical and action-based”. Each strategy has
advantages and
disadvantages for all parties involved. The primary starting
point is to recognize
the need for change in an organization. An in depth review of
each strategy is valuable
when determining if and when there is any commonality with
each of the change
models discussed in this article exists and whether access to
particular strategies will
aid or hinder the success of the organizational change. Both
Armstrong (2006) and
Lockitt (2004) provide ample explanations of each strategy.
. Directive – “the imposition of change in crisis situations or
when other methods
have failed. This is done by the exercise of managerial power
without consultation”
(Armstrong, 2006). “The advantage here is that change can be
undertaken quickly,
however, the disadvantage is it does not take into consideration
any views, or
feelings, of those involved in the change” (Lockitt, 2004).
. Bargained – “this approach recognizes that power is shared
between employer
and the employed and that change requires negotiation,
compromise and
agreement before being implemented” (Armstrong, 2006).
“[w]illingness by
senior managers to negotiate and bargain in order to effect
change. This
approach acknowledges that those affected by change have the
right to have a
say in what changes are made, with disadvantages being the
additional time to
effect change” (Lockitt, 2004).
. Hearts and minds – “an all-embracing thrust to change the
attitudes, values and
beliefs of the whole workforce. This normative approach seeks
commitment and a
shared vision but does not necessarily include involvement or
participation”
(Armstrong, 2006). This strategy allows “full support of the
changes being made
and a shared set of organizational values that individuals are
willing and able to
support. Again the advantage is the positive commitment to the
changes being
made with the disadvantages being that it takes longer to
implement” (Lockitt,
2004).
. Analytical – “a theoretical approach proceeds sequentially
from the analysis and
diagnosis of the situation, through the setting of objectives, the
design of the
change process, the evaluation of the results and, the
determination of the
objectives for the next stage in the process” (Armstrong, 2006).
LM
31,4/5
246
. Action-based – “this recognizes that the way managers behave
in practice bears
little resemblance to the analytical, theoretical model. The
distinction between
managerial thought and managerial action blurs in practice to
the point of
invisibility. What managers think is what they do. Real life
often results in a
‘ready’, ‘aim’, and ‘fire’ approach” (Armstrong, 2006). “This
strategy stresses full
involvement of all those involved, and affected by, the
anticipated changes. Benefits
of this approach are that any changes made are more likely to be
supported due to
the involvement of all those affected, the commitment of
individuals and groups
within the organization as they all feel ownership over the
changes being made, the
disadvantages are the time it takes before changes are made”
(Lockitt, 2004).
Each of these strategies can be analyzed extensively, used
independently or in
combination in a manner appropriate for an organization. There
may be situations
arise which may require methods from one strategy mixed with
methods from a
different strategy to support a successful model for a particular
business. Lockitt (2004)
points out how “the skill of effective change management is to
recognize what
strategies to employ, when, where and how to use them in order
to be most effective”,
this can be an individual from human resources, management or
a hired change agent.
Often change models neglect the transition that is required to
occur within the
individuals in the organization during the actual change process.
It is important to include
this human element in the change process. Nortier (1995)
explains how Bridges (1986)
“considers transition as a dynamic in three stages”. Bridges and
Mitchell (2000) have
labeled these three stages as:
Endings, the neutral zone (explorations), and new beginnings.
Often, in the whole course of
action, whether using a change model or not, the benefits of a
change are presented, plans are
designed and implemented in coordination with managers,
policies, technical changes and
budgets leaving out one of the most important aspects, the
individuals who will be affected
by the changes (Nortier, 1995).
Bridges
Another thought on this is provided by Bridges (1991) in the
statement “it isn’t the
changes that do you in, it is the transitions”. In an earlier paper
by Bridges (1986), he
also points out how “change is the current corporate landscape
is the rule rather than
the exception”. It is worth noting that in 2009 this is still the
rule. Further explanations
of the three stages are as follows:
. The Ending Phase – Saying goodbye to the way things were, a
particular job, associates, a
location, even a manager or supervisor can all be changed when
realignment happens in
an organization.
. The Neutral Zone – New environment, new responsibilities,
the rules have changed, there
are different people to work with and report to, this can all be
unsettling as one explores
and experiments in this new setting.
. New Beginnings – This period requires the final adjustment to
new ways of doing many
different tasks or even similar tasks but in handling them in a
new manner (Bridges and
Mitchell, 2000).
The last phase is often when individuals lose it all hope; they
freeze and cannot move
forward. This is mentioned earlier in this article in reference to
Who Moved My Cheese?
( Johnson, 1998). Three of the four characters eventually make
it to this last phase, but
Managing
change and
transitions
247
one, Hem, is unable to move beyond his fears, and eventually,
he is left behind.
Organizational change models need to incorporate transitions in
their plans to improve
the success rate of their upcoming change.
Kotter
Kotter (2007) states “Leaders who successfully transform
businesses do eight things right
(and they do them in the right order)”. Kotter’s original article
by the same title published
in 1995 soon became a must read for organizational leaders
planning and implementing
change. Kotter (1996) states while change efforts have helped
improve some
organizations in the competitive markets, many situations have
been disappointing
and the results have been disastrous for the employees and those
in charge. Kotter points
out “the biggest mistake people make when trying to change
organizations is to plunge
ahead without establishing a high enough sense of urgency in
fellow managers and
employees”. The thought that this could not happen to our
organization is one of the main
causes of failure while instituting organizational change. Some
changes take years and
even after a number of years, they may fail for a variety of
reasons.
Armstrong (2006) goes through his eight steps as follows:
1. Establishing a sense of urgency
a. Examining market and competitive realities
b. Identifying and discussing crises, potential crises, or major
opportunities
2. Forming a powerful guiding coalition
a. Assembling a group with enough power to lead the change
effort
b. Encouraging the group to work together as a team
3. Creating a vision
a. Creating a vision to help direct the change effort
b. Developing strategies for achieving that vision
4. Communicating the vision
a. Using every vehicle possible to communicate the new vision
and strategies
b. Teaching new behaviors by the example of the guiding
coalition
5. Empowering others to act on the vision
a. Getting rid of obstacles to change
b. Changing systems or structures that seriously undermine the
vision
c. Encourage risk taking and non-traditional ideas, activities
and actions
6. Planning for and creating short-term wins
a. Planning for visible performance improvement
b. Creating those improvements
c. Recognizing and rewarding employees involved in the
improvements
7. Consolidating improvements and producing still more change
a. Using increased credibility to change systems, structures and
polices that don’t fit
the vision
b. Hiring, promoting and developing employees who can
implement the vision
c. Reinvigorating the process with new projects, themes and
change agents
LM
31,4/5
248
8. Institutionalizing new approaches
a. Articulating the connections between the new behaviors and
corporate success
b. Developing the means to ensure leadership development and
succession (Armstrong,
2006).
It is interesting to note here how Kotter has managed to bring
together the change models
and transitions into an eight step process. In The Heart of
Change (Kotter and Cohen,
2002) these eight steps are linked to 34 real life organizations
located throughout the
world. The book is structured around these specific eight steps
because “this is how
people experience the process” (Kotter and Cohen, 2002). Both
books provide case studies
showing what works and what usually does not work. Kotter
(2007) also reviews what
happens when these eight steps are not followed in the correct
order or in the correct way.
The old adage of “this is the way we do things around here” is
very difficult to overcome,
but is very necessary to change when dealing with having to
change a culture.
Kotter (2007) states “his basic goal has been the same: to make
fundamental
changes in how business is conducted in order to help cope with
a new, more
challenging market environment”. This goal is evident as Kotter
(2007) reviews what
happens when these steps are not followed:
1. Not establishing a Great Enough Sense of Urgency
a. Transformation or changes begin but are frozen and can’t
move forward
b. Complacency has set in preventing any change from going
forward
2. Not creating a powerful enough guiding coalition
a. When just a few people are not supported by more along the
way, their efforts are
lost, major players need to be involved or the change will never
get off the ground
3. Lacking a vision
a. Without a clear vision, the whole effort can fall apart as
individuals struggle to be a
part of something not understood by the larger population
4. Under communicating the vision by a factor of ten
a. Everyone needs to be kept in the loop throughout the whole
process using every
possible means of communication available from meetings to
emails and everything
else in between. The management and the employees need to be
in sync with each other,
lack of communication can prevent major successes causing the
whole plan to fail
5. Not removing obstacles to the new vision
a. Everyone has to be working together to make this new vision
a reality, keeping those
who refuse to change need to be replaced or it will fail.
6. Not systematically planning for, and creating, short-term
wins
a. Change takes time; people lose momentum and need to be
congratulated when evidence
shows that the changes are going forward successfully
7. Declaring victory to soon
a. Some changes can take anywhere from five to ten years,
premature victory celebrations
can kill momentum and ruin the whole change
8. Not anchoring changes in the corporations culture
a. Making the new changes the way things are now done shows
that the change is most
likely to stay, however, if this is not happening and most things
beyond the surface don’t
really change then the change has failed (Kotter, 2007).
Managing
change and
transitions
249
It is crucial for successful change to help individuals adjust to
the ever-changing
business world and keep communication lines open at all times
while maintaining the
organization’s vision during the change process. When these
strategies are
implemented, taking everyone into consideration, than change is
more likely to be
completely successful.
Commonalities
Conclusions
Table I shows clearly there are significant commonalities
between these particular
change and transition models. It is interesting to note that is
while they are not all lined
up they each handle change in a similar fashion. All these
models are just guides to
assist organizations through the world of constant change which
exists today. While
no one exact and perfect model exists for everyone, each has
positive ways to handle
change and can be adapted according to the organization. It
must also be remembered
that change is constant. If an organization makes a set of
changes successfully, it
should be noted that one Kotter’s (1996) eight steps is to keep
improving, going
forward with new and more innovative ways to compete in the
market by adding new
products, always looking for new ways to handle situations and
keep the vision going
by adding new people as the organization continues to grow.
Senge (1990) points out how “from an early age we are taught
to break apart
problems, to fragment the world”. If problems are broken down
too soon or too quickly
perspective is lost and there are times when stepping back and
seeing the whole
situation first is very beneficial and usually necessary. In an
organizational
environment, creating a sense of urgency or mandating a
directive because market
forces have caused great economic upheaval, it is prudent to
step back, take a look at
the whole situation, analyze the problems, develop a plan of
action with support and
proceed to unfreeze, work with the employees, managers,
directors and stockholders in
creating a complete environment where everyone feels
ownership of the both the
problems and the solutions. This creates a solid foundation for
any organization to
Lewin Beckhard Thurley Bridges Kotter
Unfreezing Analyzing present condition Directive Sense of
urgency
Bargained Form guiding coalition
Hearts and
Minds
Ending
phase
Have powerful group to lead
change effort
Analytical
Neutral
zone Work together as a team
Changing
Setting goals for the future
Plan of action Create a vision
Communicate the vision
Implementing the plan
Action-
based
Empower others to act on the
vision
Plan for short-term wins
New
beginnings Improve on the changes
Refreezing
Institutionalize new
approachesTable I.
LM
31,4/5
250
handle the unexpected challenges brought on by a global market
and fast-paced
technological advances.
This article has provided a commonality view of change and
transition modes in
hopes of presenting additional insights into how they are still
relevant today in dealing
with the ever-changing organization world. Managing change is
definitely a challenge
but not impossible, linking together possible solutions can only
lead to improved ways
to handle changes and transitions and open up the possibility of
new and improved
methods not yet discovered.
References
Armstrong, M. (2006), A Handbook of Human Resource
Management Practice, 10th ed., Kogan,
London, pp. 343-57.
Axelrod, R. (2001), “Why change management needs changing”,
Reflections, Vol. 2 No. 3, pp. 46-7,
available at:
http://web.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/pdf?vid¼
4&hid¼7&
sid¼e8690d69-fd9a-4c85-add1-a821c755d5d7%40sessionmgr4
(accessed 27 July 2008).
Beckhard, R. (1969), Organizational Development: Strategies
and Models, Addison-Wesley,
Reading, MA.
Beer, M., Eisenstat, R.A. and Spector, B. (1990), “Why change
programs don’t produce change”,
Harvard Business Review, Vol. 68 No. 6, pp. 158-66, available
at: http://web.ebscohost.com.
libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/pdf?vid¼5&hid¼7&sid¼38c4fc2e-
bcf2-4ab6-834d-be9e5e2
afb52%40sessionmgr4 (accessed 25 July 2009).
Bridges, W. (1986), “Managing organizational transitions”,
Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 158
No. 1, pp. 24-33, available at:
http://web.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/
pdf?vid¼5&hid¼3&sid¼7f423133-1ef6-43c5-8073-
668c1e2d7a4d%40sessionmgr4
(accessed 11 August 2009).
Bridges, W. (1991), Managing Transitions Making the Most of
Change, Addison-Wesley,
Reading, MA.
Bridges, W. and Mitchell, S. (2000), “Leading transition: a new
model for change”, Leader to
Leader, Vol. 16 No. 3, pp. 30-6, available at:
www.berlineaton.com/resource_files/Bridges
%20Change%20Model.pdf (accessed 5 July 2009).
Burke, W. (2004), Organization Development: What We Know
and What We Need to Know Going
Forward, available at: www.g-
rap.org/docs/ICB/Warner%20Burke%202004%20-%20
Organisation%20Development.pdf (accessed 8 August 2009).
Burnes, B. (2004), “Kurt Lewin and the planned approach to
change: a re-appraisal”, Journal of
Management Studies, Vol. 41 No. 6, pp. 977-1001, available at:
www.busmgt.ulster.ac.uk/
modules/bmg899j3/doc/Burnes%20on%20Lewin%20and%20pla
nned%20change.pdf
(accessed 9 August 2009).
Dannemiller, K. and Norlin, P. (2001), “Leading whole-system
change”, available at: www.
dannemillertyson.com/leading.php (accessed 8 August 2009).
Dunphy, D. and Stace, D. (1993), “The strategic management of
corporate change”, Human
Relations, Vol. 46 No. 8, pp. 905-21, available at:
http://libaccess.sjlibrary.org/
login?url¼http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did¼1108411&Fmt
¼3&clientId¼17867&
RQT¼309&VName¼PQD (accessed 8 August 2009).
Dunphy, D.C. and Stace, D.A. (1988), “Transformational and
coercive strategies for planned
organizational change: beyond the O.D. Model”, Organizational
Studies, Vol. 9 No. 3,
pp. 339-55, available at:
http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct¼true&db¼bth&
AN¼5994762&loginpage¼Login.asp&site¼ehost-live (accessed
8 August 2009).
Evans, G.E. and Ward, P.L. (2004), Beyond The Basics: The
Management Guide for Library and
Information Professionals, Neal-Schuman Publishers, Inc, New
York, NY, pp. 68-92.
Managing
change and
transitions
251
French, E. and Delahaye, B. (1996), “Individual change
transitions: moving in circles can be good
for you”, Leadership & Organization Development Journal, Vol.
17 No. 7, pp. 22-9, available
at:
http://libaccess.sjlibrary.org/login?url¼http://proquest.umi.com/
pqdweb?did¼
117542778&Fmt¼3&clientId¼17867&RQT¼309&VName¼PQ
D (accessed 11 August
2009).
Johnson, S. (1998), Who Moved My Cheese?, Penguin Putnam,
Inc., New York, NY.
Kanter, R. (1985), The Change Masters: Corporate
Entrepreneurs at Work, Unwin Paperbacks,
London, pp. 84-87, 304-306.
Kotter, J. (1995), The 20%
Solution
: Using Rapid Redesign to Create Tomorrow’s Organizations
Today, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ.
Kotter, J.P. (1996), Leading Change, Harvard Business School
Press, Boston, MA.
Kotter, J.P. (2007), “Leading change why transformation efforts
fail”, Harvard Business Review,
Vol. 85 No. 1, pp. 96-103, available at:
http://search.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/
login.aspx?direct¼true&db¼bth&AN¼23363656&loginpage¼L
ogin.asp&site¼ehost-
live (accessed 6 July 2009).
Kotter, J.P. and Cohen, D.S. (2002), The Heart of Change: Real
Life Stories of How People Change
Their Organizations, Harvard Business School Press, Boston,
MA.
Lewin, K. (1951), Field Theory in Social Science, Harper and
Row, New York, NY.
Lockitt, B. (2004), “Change management”, available:
www.learninglab.org.uk/papers/CHANGE_
MANAGEMENT_3t.pdf (accessed 10 August 2009).
Marshak, R.J. (2004), “Morphing: the leading edge of
organizational change in the twenty-first
century”, Organization Development Journal, Vol. 22 No. 3, pp.
8-21.
Nortier, F. (1995), “A new angle on coping with change:
managing transition!”, The Journal of
Management Development, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 32-46, available
at: http://proquest.umi.com.
libaccess.sjlibrary.org/pqdweb?index¼5&did¼8695001&SrchM
ode¼3&sid¼1&Fmt¼
3&VInst¼PROD&
VType¼PQD&RQT¼309&VName¼PQD&TS¼1247461423&cli
entId
¼17867&aid¼1 (accessed 6 July 2009).
Quinn, J.B. (2006), “Organizational development, change and
transformation”, in Armstrong, M.
(Ed.), A Handbook of Human Resource Management, 10th ed.,
Cambridge University
Press, London, p. 349.
Ritchie, B. (2006), Lewin’s Change Management Model:
Understanding the Three Stages of
Change, available: www.consultpivotal.com/lewin’s.htm
(accessed 10 August 2009).
Rouda, R.H. and Kusy, M.E. Jr (1995), “Organization
development the management of change”,
Tappi Journal, Vol. 3 No. 3, pp. 1-4, available at:
http://alumnus.caltech.edu/,rouda/T3_
OD.html (accessed 10 August 2009).
Schein, E.H. (2004), Organization Culture and Leadership, 3rd
ed., John Wiley & Sons, Inc,
Danvers, CT, pp. 3-23.
Senge, P.M. (1990), The Fifth Discipline, Doubleday, New
York, NY.
Ulrich, D. and Brockbank, W. (2005), The HR Value
Proposition, Harvard Business School Press,
Boston, MA, p. 224.
Wagar, T. (2000), “Downsizing and restructuring”, in Belcourt,
M. and McBey, K. (Eds), Strategic
Human Resources Planning, Nelson Thompson Learning,
Ontario, pp. 231-57.
Corresponding author
Claire V. Brisson-Banks can be contacted at: [email protected]
LM
31,4/5
252
To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail:
[email protected]
Or visit our web site for further details:
www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further
reproduction prohibited without permission.
Read the following article from the required reading
assignment:
Preston, G., Moon, J., Simon, R., Allen, S., & Kossi, E. (2015).
The relevance of emotional intelligence in project leadership.
Journal of Information Technology and Economic Development,
6(1), 16-40.
After reading the article, analyze the following scenarios, and
choose one to discuss in your case study paper:
Scenario 1: You are an office manager who has recently moved
into a new department. It comes to your attention that there is a
member of senior management who has been falsifying expense
reports for himself and approving falsified reports for his
subordinates, resulting in over-payments to employees.
· Based on your preferred leadership style, what would be the
best way to handle this situation?
· What are some effective practices that you would use for
leading people and business processes in this situation?
· In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making
processes that serve to establish an organizational climate
oriented to meet business goals?
Scenario 2: You are a newly hired department director, brought
on board to help turn around a struggling department. The
members of this department are highly educated and are taking
steps to improve the professional development of department
members. Despite these efforts, they feel they are
underappreciated and lack a voice in the direction that the
department is moving. You have leadership experience in a
variety of industries, but you have never worked in this specific
field.
· Based on your preferred leadership style, how would you
proceed in attempting to align the goals of the organization with
the goals of the department? (The goals are actually the same
for the organization and the department, but the two groups
have different concepts on how to achieve them.)
· What are some effective practices that you would use for
leading people and business processes in this situation?
· In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making
processes that serve to establish an organizational climate
oriented to meet business goals?
Scenario 3: As a manager, you have two employees who have a
difficult time working together. While nothing specifically
unprofessional has been done by either one of them, other team
members have expressed concern that the differences between
them are causing tension and some other team members are
having difficulty performing their work. Some have even gone
so far as to say that the situation is causing a hostile work
environment.
· Based on your preferred leadership style, how would you
handle this situation?
· What are some effective practices that you would use for
leading people and business processes in this situation?
· In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making
processes that serve to establish an organizational climate
oriented to meet business goals?
· In your case study, be sure to address the following:
· Begin the discussion by identifying which of the scenarios you
chose.
· Include a brief statement as to which of the leadership styles
presented in the above article you are most comfortable with.
· Explain your top three, in order from most like you to least
like you, and explain why you chose them.
· Then, answer the questions provided with your chosen
scenario.
· Use the information provided in this unit to determine which
leadership styles you prefer to use when you are in a leadership
position (visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic,
pacesetting, and commanding).
· Then, considering the above points, how would you proceed
with handling the chosen scenario?
Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Be sure to include peer-reviewed sources to support
positions/conclusions. You are required to use at least two
outside sources beyond the required reading for this unit.
· Be sure that your analysis is highly relevant and informative,
and remains on topic.
· Accuracy should be strong with close attention to detail in
all parts of the assignment.
· Writing should be clear and concise with solid sentence
structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation, and
spelling errors.
· Your paper should be at least two pages in length.
· All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted
material must have accompanying citations in APA format.
Unit III Reflection Paper
It has been stated that different industries and organizational
differences influence which motivational techniques and
theories are most effective. It has also been stated that
situational factors, such as the type of power exerted, can
influence team and organizational effectiveness.
Given the fact that the employment of different types of power
might influence a team member’s satisfaction, and thus his or
her motivation to continue, in regards to your current industry
and/or the culture of your current organization, write a
reflection paper that considers the following:
· Describe leader power, follower motivation, and the aspects
of effective followership.
· Provide an overview of influence and the major process and
content motivational theories.
· Describe which motivational theory would be the most
appropriate at your industry/organization.
· Describe the power types from the French and Raven power
taxonomy that would fit best with that motivational theory.
· Are there any power types that should be avoided when
employing that motivational theory?
Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Writing should include proper grammar, sentence structure,
and writing mechanics.
· Organization should be logical.
· Your paper should be at least two pages in length.
Unit IV Essay
Research the Kelley model of followership. Write an essay
describing how a leader might utilize the Kelley model of
followership to assess follower effectiveness, and discuss how
this leader might develop this individual into a more effective
follower.
Be sure to include the following in your paper:
· Describe the importance of organizational climate and
motivation.
· Describe Kelley’s model of effective followership (moving
between roles).
· Explain how knowledge of effective followership can help
one’s leadership perspective.
Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Writing should include proper grammar, sentence structure,
and writing mechanics.
· Organization should be logical, clear, and appropriate.
· Provide strong evidence of critical thinking.
· Make use of logical transitions.
· Paragraphs should contain strong topic sentences.
· Your paper should be at least two pages in length.
· All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted
material must have accompanying citations in APA format.
Unit V Case Study
A textile manufacturer is closing its North Carolina plant and
moving the production of its products to a developing nation in
Southeast Asia. The primary reason for the move is the lower
labor cost that the organization can enjoy in the new location.
· Proponents of the decision laud the move as a means to save
the organization by taking advantage of the free market and
finding cheaper methods of producing the company’s goods.
· Opponents of the decision state that a breach of trust existed
between the company and the loyal employees in the North
Carolina facility. Additionally, opponents cite recent findings
that contractors in the Southeast Asia region where the company
is moving have been cited for utilizing child labor and failing to
provide working conditions equivalent to those in the United
States.
· Officials in the Southeast Asia region have answered the
criticisms of the use of child labor by pointing out that
oftentimes children are the only individuals in a family who are
capable of working, and to deny them that opportunity would
create greater hardship on the already desperately poor
population.
Based on the case study above, apply the deontological and
teleological frameworks learned in this unit to provide the
following information in your response:
· Describe which framework the proponents of this move
would use to support their statement that it be considered
ethical.
· Describe which framework the opponents of this move would
use to support their statement that it be considered unethical.
· Describe style of leadership this decision reflects, and
discuss whether this move would lead to a positive evaluation
of leadership and organizational performance.
· Describe the level of corporate responsibility this decision
reflects. Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Be sure to include peer-reviewed sources to support
positions/conclusions.
· Analysis should be highly relevant, informative, and remain
on topic.
· Accuracy should be strong with close attention to detail in
all parts of the assignment.
· Writing should be clear and concise with solid sentence
structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation, and
spelling errors.
· Your paper should be at least two pages in length.
· You must also use at least five outside sources to support
assertions and conclusions.
· All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted
material must have accompanying citations in APA format.
Unit VI Project
Assume that you have been tasked with preparing a cultural
brief for an upcoming trip that will put you and your travel
companions in touch with three different societal clusters.
Choose three clusters other than the one in which you currently
operate.
In a PowerPoint or Prezi presentation, briefly describe the
following:
· List and describe the three cultural clusters that will be
visited.
· Provide information on cultural norms from each of the
clusters to be visited. (Make sure to use specific information
from the GLOBE study.)
· Describe the leadership approaches preferred in the clusters
that will be visited.
· Describe the considerations for leading multicultural teams.
Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Your presentation should have originality, and the content
should be presented in a unique and interesting manner.
· Analysis should be thorough and fully developed.
· Organization should be clear in your paper. The main points
should be arranged logically to support the information
provided, with similar ideas grouped together and smooth
transitions.
· All graphics and texts should be appropriate and attractive
and support the theme and content. Be sure to use a consistent
and appropriate background.
· Any sources used should be properly cited and referenced
according to APA format.
· Writing should be clear and concise with correct use of
sentence structure and should be free from grammar,
punctuation, and spelling errors.
Unit VII Research Paper
Write a research paper that analyzes methods used to
appropriately manage groups and teams. In your paper, be sure
to include the following:
· Discuss the process of evolving a group into a team, and
discuss the importance of organizational culture in that process.
· Evaluate the leadership styles that are effective for managing
groups and teams, including unique considerations for leading
multicultural teams.
· Describe the benefits and drawbacks of having groups or
teams in terms of groupthink vs. teamthink. Be sure to follow
the guidelines below:
· Your introduction should engage the reader and clearly
present the thesis and a summary of the main points to clarify
your point of view.
· Review of literature should present a critical analysis and
synthesis of the existing research.
· Discussion should reveal insightful analysis of research.
· A summary should be present that reviews or summarizes key
points and provides a smooth transition between sections.
· Writing should be clear and concise with correct use of
sentence structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation,
and spelling errors.
· Your paper should be at least four pages in length.
· You must also use at least five outside sources to support
assertions and conclusions.
· All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted
material must have accompanying citations in APA format.
Unit VIII Article Critique
The Brisson-Banks (2010) article in the required reading for
this unit compares the five different change management models
presented in this unit, and it describes various situational
variables that could influence the effectiveness of each.
Utilizing all of the knowledge accumulated through this and the
previous units, write a critique of the article.
In your paper, be sure to include the following:
· Evaluate different aspects of organizational change.
· Discuss the role that leader vision and organizational climate
plays in a change management strategy.
· Discuss how the leadership style that was identified as your
primary preference would fit into the models of change
presented.
· Discuss how effective change initiatives can influence
organizational performance.
Be sure to follow the guidelines below:
· Accurately identify the premise and supporting points from
the article.
· Provide an insightful and thorough analysis of information
from the article, including using evidence and reasonable and
compelling interpretations.
· Link material to course content and real-world situations.
· Demonstrate solid critical evaluation by providing well-
supported opinions and conclusions using additional peer-
reviewed articles.
· Organize the material logically by using smooth transitions
and grouping similar material together.
· Your paper should be at least two pages in length.
· All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted
material must have accompanying citations in APA format.
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 16
The Relevance of Emotional Intelligence in Project Leadership
Genna Preston, Jayet Moon, Ryan Simon, Shayna Allen, Edem
Kossi
Project Management program
Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA, USA
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected],
[email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract
The Emotional Intelligence School of Leadership Styles major
paper invites readers to
uncover the six different styles of leadership that compose the
school. The paper identifies and
summarizes the following styles: Visionary, Coaching,
Affiliative, Democratic, Pacesetting, and
Commanding. Additionally the paper outlines the positives and
negatives associated with each
style of leadership as well as provides an example of those
styles in use. Lastly, the paper
concludes with the literature review and synopsis of how these
styles can be effectively integrated
into modern project management.
Introduction
Leadership is defined as, the power or ability to lead other
people (Bass,1960). Project
leadership is defined as, the ability to persuade others to
enthusiastically and diligently pursue the
projects objective (Salovey & Mayer, 1989). A project is always
evolving dynamically and
likewise, project leadership is situational. In a project, the
leader is required to have cognitive,
social, and emotional intelligence in order to assess the
situational and organizational needs and
adjust the pace of leadership accordingly (Mayer, Caruso &
Salovey, 1989).
Emotional intelligence is defined by Salovey and Mayer (1989)
as the subset of social
intelligence that involves the ability to monitor one’s own, and
others feelings and emotions, to
discriminate among them, and to use this information to guide
one’s own thinking and actions. For
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 17
a long time emotional dimension of leadership was associated
with the Visionary or Charismatic
School of Leadership (Popper & Zakkai, 1994). Since the mid
1990’s, emotional intelligence has
established itself as a leadership competence in its own right, as
well as numerous books,
publications, and exploratory studies, that lend credence and
justify its importance. Goleman
(1998) first synthesized and presented this idea of a new school,
and it soon found its way into
mainstream acceptance.
Great leaders are the ones who drive people to deliver optimum
performance. A critical
way of doing this is by tapping into employees emotions while
taking control of self-emotions.
Leading and performing is not easy under pressure, more so in a
project with hard deadlines. The
ability to manage self and teams emotions, as well as connect to
the emotions that drive their
behaviors is a competency that is necessary in a modern project
leader.
According to the proponents of the emotional intelligence
school, the emotional
intelligence of the leader has greater impact on leadership skills
and consequently the team
performance than his intellectual capacity. Goleman, Boyatzis,
& McKee (2002) identify four
dimensions of emotional intelligence.
1. Self-Awareness
2. Self-Management
3. Social Awareness
4. Relationship Management
Of these, 1&2 lie in the domain of personal competence while
3&4 lie in social competence
domain. Personal competence translates to, having
understandings of ones strengths, weaknesses,
motives, and values, while at the same time having attributes
like transparency, self-control,
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 18
initiative, and optimism (Avolio & Zakkai,1994). Social
competence means empathy, awareness,
and ability to understand and fulfill customer needs.
Relationship management is an important part
of social competence which involves influencing people,
navigating conflicts, and ensuring team
building and bonding. Based on such a distribution, there are
six leadership styles:
1. Visionary
2. Coaching
3. Affiliative
4. Democratic
5. Pacesetting
6. Commanding
Each style of leadership can be matched with a stage, and phase
of a project as shown. This is an
indicative generalization, and it is the prerogative of the project
manager as to which style he/she
adopts in each phase, such that most efficient performance is
realized.
Style Suggested Phase
Visionary Initialization
Coaching Planning
Affiliative Planning
Democratic Execution
Pacesetting Monitoring & Control
Commanding Closure
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 19
The styles listed above impact the organizational climate and
culture since, leadership and
management commitment directly translates to employee
commitment, responsibility, task, goal
orientation, and clarity of purpose (Detailed chart available in
Appendix A).
The sections below detail each of these styles in detail with
their positives and negatives
and examples of implementation. Some examples illustrate
versatile leaders who show different
styles, while some use a certain style as base and work within
that boundary, transgressing it as
the need dictates.
Visionary
The first style from the emotional intelligence school of
leadership that we will analyze is
the visionary leadership style. According to Dictionary.com
(n.d), a vision is defined as, an
experience in which a personage, thing, or event appears vividly
or credibly to the mind, although
not actually present, often under the influence of a divine or
other agency. A vision is something
imagined, and in business, it is where leaders of organizations
imagine their organization to be at
some point in the future. The visionary leadership style is
defined by Daniel Goleman as, the
leadership style where the “leader is inspiring in vision, and
helps others to see how they can
contribute to this vision; allowing the leader and followers to
move together toward a shared view
of the future,” (Toren, 2014). Daniel Goleman believes after
many of his research studies, the
visionary leadership style is the most effective one (Mersino,
2013).
Visionary Positives
The first advantage is the ability of the project leader to help
others see their contribution
in the big picture. This is perhaps the most important aspect of
the visionary leadership style; this
can help motivate the project team during the project life cycle,
and this motivation can contribute
to the success for the project. Project Team members would
have the great benefit of knowing
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 20
that what they do is important. The second advantage is that,
visionaries can describe the end goals
on a project, and leave the individuals plenty of latitude on how
to achieve them (Mersino, 2013).
This tactic can be beneficial to a project team that is made of
skill workers or experts who are in
this situation, given the ability to use their expertise to
successfully complete this project. Lastly,
a project leader with a visionary style can help a project team
easily navigate various changes in a
project. In fact, visionary leaders thrive on change and the
ability to draw new boundaries (Mark,
2012).
Visionary Negatives
In a project, a visionary leadership style can suffer from poor
articulated visions. Because
this style takes advantage of the project team members’ ability
to connect personally to the leader’s
vision, there may be a disadvantage if the leader is unable to
articulate his or her vision. This may
lead to the opposite results with disconnected and unmotivated
team members. Also, a project
manager might face a similar situation if he has many senior
people or experts reporting to him.
In this situation, the vision casting by the manager may fall flat
to resonate with the project team
(Mersino, 2013). Finally, this style may also have some
disadvantages if the project leader is full
of great visions, but lack the necessary details to carry out his
visions.
Visionary Example
One example of effective leaders who employ the visionary
leadership is Dr. Martin Luther
King Jr. Dr. King had a vision that he was able to channel to
millions of people decades ago; his
visions are still being deployed today. Through his “I have a
dream” speech and his non-violent
acts, he was able to connect his vision to millions people, and to
help them understand how they
fit into the end result, when it comes to humanity and human
rights (Toren, 2014).
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 21
Visionary Summary
The visionary leadership style, which is a style of leadership
that are inspires visions, can
be very effective for project leaders. Visionary leadership
qualities help their project teams
understand the true objectives and goals, as well as, how their
contributions are important to
achieve these goals. It helps to organically motivate the project
team
Pacesetting
The next leadership style that a project manager may use while
executing a project is
known as pacesetting. As defined in the Wall Street Journal
Online article, Leadership Styles
(Murphy, 2011), the pacesetting style is one in which “the
leader sets high standards for
performance. He or she is obsessive about doing things better
and faster, and asks the same of
everyone”. The pacesetting method allows for mangers with a
mastery of certain tasks to exemplify
his or her mastery over those tasks in the hopes that the
supporting project team will gain mastery
through osmosis. When utilized, this type of leadership style
presents a variety of positives and
negatives in relation to achieving overall success of a project’s
desired outcome. Below is an
examination of those positives and negatives as well as an
example of the pacesetting leadership
style in action.
Pacesetting Positives
The pacesetting leadership style is one of fast action. As
described in the Money-zine.com
article, Pacesetting Leaders, “one of the pros of the pacesetting
leadership style is they are able to
quickly achieve business results” (Money-zine, 2006). The
reason behind the fast results of this
style is because the project manager has great aptitude in the
work that is being done. Thus, the
project manager embarks on a lead by example approach and,
expects that the team has the same
aptitude and motivation for the project as he or she does.
Creating a high energy team, that is
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 22
challenged to constantly progress at the rate of the manger and
allowing for project results to occur
at a rapid pace. Pacesetting is an excellent leadership style to
use at the beginning of a project, as
you are able to build momentum off of the excitement
surrounding a new endeavor. It is an
effective style to use to achieve the first few milestones of a
project in short order.
Pacesetting Negatives
While pacesetting is excellent at achieving short-term goals,
this leadership style can have
a long-term negative impact on a project team. Primarily, this
style of leadership is conducive for
employees to burn out. Burn out occurs from the team being
unable to sustain the same enthusiasm,
drive, and competency of the project manager. The Changing
Minds.org article, Six Emotional
Leadership Styles, points out that pacesetting leaders, “tend to
be low on guidance, expecting
people to know what to do” (Goleman, 2002). Thus the
pacesetting style not only demands
constant amounts of high energy from its team but also it
demands self-correction and self-
sufficiency of its team. This type of environment causes
increased stress levels as any member
who struggles in a task will quickly fall behind the pace of the
remainder of the team and will not
have any guidance on how to take corrective measures.
Pacesetting Example
Pacesetting leaders are typically found in military settings,
however, the Money-zine.com
article, Pacesetting Leadership, provides businessman Jack
Welch as an example of person who
primarily implemented this leadership style (Pacesetting
Leaders, 2006). Welch served as CEO for
General Electric from 1981 to 2001. During his time as CEO,
Welch would interact with
employees at all levels of the organization as he believed “that
leaders should avoid micro-
managing, and spend their time inspiring others”(Pacesetting
Leaders, 2006). Welch was
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 23
accessible to his employees, however, he was also demanding of
them expecting the highest of
results while disposing of those who were unable to keep up.
Pacesetting Summary
In conclusion the pacesetting leadership style is one that is best
served in small doses. It
serves to help launch a project or to help complete a project
within a tight time frame. However,
the style will wear thin on the team if utilized to often, as
pressure builds and people are left feeling
burnt out and left behind.
Coaching
The next leadership style from the emotional intelligence
school of leadership to be
examined is coaching. The coaching style as defined in the Jeff
Hodgkinson article, Leadership
Styles for Program and Project Managers, is when the project
manager “instructs and motivates
others to enhance their skills to achieve maximum impact for
the team and project” (Hodgkinson,
2009). The coaching style puts the project manager in a
mentoring role in relation to the project
team. However, the coaching style isn’t mentoring in the truest
sense; the needs of the project
outweigh the needs of personal development or growth of a
project team member. That being said,
ideally the coaching style would be implemented with a team
member that is inexperienced in a
certain aspect of a project, which he or she is assigned so that
the goals of the project, and the
personal growth objects of the team member are aligned.
Coaching Positives
The coaching style is designed to cultivate a project member’s
professional skill set. It is a
relationship that is very similar to that of a teacher and student,
with the project manager serving
in the role of the teacher. Deidre Harris’ article, Project
Leadership Styles notes, a project manager
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 24
utilizing the coaching technique “challenges all to do better and
is encouraging when any failure
is present” (Harris, 2009). By utilizing this technique an
environment that is based on
encouragement and empathy is created, allowing for team
members to approach project goals
without trepidation. The warm working environment that is born
from this leadership style spurs
the creation of more substantial inter-personal relationship
amongst manger and team member.
Trust is thus established within this style, and a trusting
environment leads to productive
environment, working towards self-improvement, as well as
project success.
Coaching Negatives
The drawbacks behind utilizing the coaching leadership style
are that it is very time
consuming and that it runs the risk of being viewed as
micromanagement, if not executed properly
with the proper audience. In order to create a high level of trust
and to teach in a project
management setting, a large quantity of time is required for the
project manager to devote to
individual members. This time commitment isn’t feasible for
projects with hard and fast deadlines,
nor is it feasible on a project with a large project team.
Additionally, this style is only conducive
with a project member that is willing to learn and improve his
or her craft. A Money-zine.com
article aptly details, “if someone is managing employees that
are extremely resistant to change, or
are not interested in learning new things, the manager will
struggle if they choose this style”
(Coaching Leadership, 2006). Thus it is essential for a project
manager to understand the make-up
of the team, and the time constraints of the project before
implementing this strategy.
Coaching Example
Not surprisingly, the best examples of the coaching leadership
style come from the realm
of sports. Being that all sport teams require a manger or coach
in order to execute a strategy to
meet an objective through a temporary endeavor; the match or
game. It is easy to make the
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 25
connection between sports and project management. That is not
to say that all sports coaches or
managers utilize the leadership style of coaching, as they in fact
do not, but it is meant to set the
stage for a true example of this leadership style in action. Red
Holzman was an NBA coach that
achieved success in the league by winning multiple NBA titles,
but perhaps his greatest success
was his mentoring and development of his one-time player Phil
Jackson. Jackson developed into
one of the NBA’s all-time greatest coaches. The article Inspired
by Holzman, Jackson Arrives in
Springfield, beautifully depicts the Holzman-Jackson
relationship, and provides the following
quote from Jackson regarding his former coach; “Red took me
under his wing, he didn't have an
assistant coach, he made me his assistant coach and taught the
game to me and taught me a lot
about the game and encouraged me to go into coaching”
(Hareas, 2007).
Coaching Summary
In summation, the coaching leadership style is a one that can be
applied in any type of
situation but is most beneficial in situations that have loose
time constraints and eager team
members. Coaching aims to give a team member the skills to
succeed in a current project as well
as cultivate skills that will serve beyond the context of a
project, granted that it doesn’t divert too
much attention away from the project. It aligns personal goals
with project goals and provides
constructive feedback, but has the potential to be viewed as
overbearing to members unreceptive
to change and constant feedback. It is a leadership style that
should be implemented when possible,
but will not always be appropriate, especially within highly
demanding situations that have short
deadlines and oversized teams.
Democratic
Another leadership style within this school is the democratic
leadership style, also known
as the participative style. This style is, “an open approach to
leading, where decision making is
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 26
shared and the views of a team or group are valued and
contribute to the vison, goals and decision
that are made” (Democratic Leadership Style, 2013). This
allows members of the teams to feel
included and impactful in several stages of a project. With this
style of leadership offering equality
of power, and group decision making, it is imperative that it is
used in the right situation or task
(Detailed example available in Appendix B).
Democratic Positives
Democratic leadership brings teams together. With technology
capabilities many
organizations are outsourcing or working remotely. Democratic
leaders bring individuals together
in order for everyone to give their thoughts, ask questions, and
be involved in the entire project
and its processes. The inclusion of many opinions may offer a
different insight or thought that you
may have missed. This shows team members they are valued,
and allows for everyone to have a
clear understanding of the vision and goals of the project
(Democratic Leadership Style, 2013).
A democratic leader provides intrinsic motivation for their
team. Research has proven that
intrinsic motivation is a precursor to creativity and innovation,
and by offering democratic
leadership, individuals will satisfy their four motivators; sense
of meaningfulness, sense of choice,
sense of competence, and sense of progress. By satisfying these
needs, individuals will be
intrinsically motivated to go above and beyond any project or
task assigned, as well as assist their
organization in becoming front runners within their industry
(Mahmood A. Bodla, 2014).
Democratic Negatives
A democratic leader is a great assets to any team however, the
democratic leadership style
comes with some negatives as well. One of the major problems
with this style is that is very time
consuming. With the inclusion of many different people it may
take a longer period of time to
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 27
come to an agreement, receive a response, or communicate
effectively. This also effects crisis
management. During crises especially, time is of the essence,
and in situations where decision need
to be made right then and there, it just is not possible to lead
democratically and include everyone
in the plans (Ryan, 2015).
When applying democratic leadership, it is important to still
identify yourself as the leader.
Unfortunately, sometimes group members may misinterpret this
style with lack of leadership or
bad job performance. Individuals may also feel it is not their
place to make decisions, or they do
not have enough experience offering suggestions or their
opinions. Also, sometimes when opinions
are offered time after time, but never implemented or acted
upon, team members may feel deceived
or manipulated, which will ultimately negatively affect
employee morale, outcomes, and success
(Cosmato, 2011). If managerial boundaries, and roles are not
followed and respected, democratic
leaders may experience negative results using this method of
leadership.
Democratic Example
Civil Rights activist Rosa parks is a great example of a
democratic leader. Although many
people before Parks were arrested for ignoring racial boundaries
and laws, Rosa Parks became the
face of the civil rights movement. Supporters followed her as
she led, collaborated, and acted upon
change within the United States. She valued other people’s
opinions, challenges, and treated
everyone as an equal. Not only did she help change American
law and policies, she did it
effortlessly and democratically.
Democratic Summary
When used properly and productively, the democratic leadership
style has many positive
qualities and attributes. By allowing individuals to participate
in the entire project and processes,
it offers a sense of satisfaction, belonging, and accomplishment.
This leadership style has been
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 28
directly connected to organizational success and achieved goals.
As leaders continue to engage in
this style, projects and organizations continue to excel and
achieve successful outcomes.
Commanding
The commanding leader is a strong, authoritative individual
who forcefully commands
orders and tasks. A commanding leader will communicate
honestly, and let you know if you are
not progressing or working satisfactory (Larry Richard, 2008).
This person holds all of the power,
and will make changes and decisions without his or her
subordinate’s. Although this leadership
style has some positives attributes, it is comprised of more
negative effects, and should be used
with caution and only during demanding times (Coercive
Leadership, 2014).
Commanding Positives
This leader gets the job done! Fear is instilled upon team
members which drives them to
use their full potential; ultimately achieving their goals. This
leadership style is most effective
during times of crises; internal or external (Six Emotional
Leadership Styles, 2015). Because this
leader gets the job, it will allow organizations to bounce back in
times of crisis. This leadership
style is also beneficial during organizational change, because he
or she is the leader, and
“encourages action, activity, and work” (Sloane, 2013). Leaders
that command, extrinsically
motivate their staff by offering rewards, based on performance
and outcomes (Sloane, 2013).
Commanding Negatives
The commanding leader may negatively affect creativity and
innovation. Team members
do not feel a sense of meaningfulness or a sense of choice. This
lack of inclusion will hinder
intrinsic motivation; intrinsic motivation encourages individuals
to succeed through self-
satisfaction. Commanding limits intelligent thinking, team
work, and disregards team experience
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 29
and capabilities (Hughes, 2013). Team members will respond
negatively to this style, if it used all
of the time. If leaders are feared and unapproachable, team
members may feel insubordinate to
offer information that may be valuable or beneficial to a
particular situation. "Beware that in the
long run it may result in employees passively resisting,
rebelling or leaving altogether”
(Leadership Style, 2015).
• Today’s workforce does not accept the autocratic style often
adopted by leaders following
historical models of leadership.
• Leadership has had to evolve to match a growing sense of
democracy and independence in
the workforce
• Employees now have far more options and choices than the
foot soldiers of yesterday,
(Childs, 2004).
With that said, we can see why it is imperative to only use the
commanding leadership style during
necessary times of crises. Also, because of ever-changing times,
and a diverse group of team
members, practicing emotional intelligence will only benefit
your team’s organization and
outcomes.
Commanding Example
A great example of a commanding leader is America’s military
organizations; army, navy,
air force, national guard, etc. Depending on their rank and
institutional standing within the
organization, individuals control, direct, and order groups and
teams daily. Commanders,
sergeants, and lieutenants disregard their subordinates and
demand authority and cooperation.
Fear, respect, and obedience are demanded in the beginning, and
these principals are passed
throughout the different divisions of the military.
Commanding Summary
Although this leader will get the job done, it is important to use
this method sparingly.
Demanding and commanding attitudes will benefit your
organization in times or change and crises.
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 30
Leaders of the world use this style while when they want to
quickly establish authority and
organizational goals.
Affiliative
The affiliative leadership style is another style within the
emotional intelligence group of
leadership styles. Affiliative leaders create emotional bonds
and harmony (Leadership That Gets
Results, 2000). This particular style of leadership works best
when there are disagreements among
team members. This leadership style is also most effective
when team members need motivation
during stressful circumstances.
Affiliative Positives
The affiliative leadership style places an emphasis on placing
value on individuals, rather
than centering on goals and objectives. An affiliative leader has
the innate ability to forge strong
emotional bonds with others, leading to immense loyalty from
the individual. Building strong
relationships between others, sets a solid foundation to establish
positive team chemistry
(Leadership That Gets Results, 2000). With a harmonious
group, communication becomes smooth
and amiable; members are willing to engage in productive
conversation with one another, ideas
are traded back and forth, companionship increases, and
positive feedback becomes abundant and
consistent. A sense of belonging is felt, and this allows for a
positive work environment, strong
loyalty and very high-spirited employees (Leadership That Gets
Results, 2014).
Along with this style, autonomy amongst workers is increased,
predominantly driven by
the trust that members have with one another that the work and
task will get done no matter the
process used. Affiliative leaders help harbor that flexibility as
unnecessary rigid structures are not
imposed on the employees (Smith, 2014). Workers have the
ability to use the most efficient method
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 31
for them in order to complete their work, which, in turn can
lead to reduced pressure and more
favorable performance results.
One of the greatest qualities of an affiliative leader is the
ability to drive motivation among
members through solid and consistent feedback. Although
commentary remains largely
constructive and positive, this empowers the workers and
increases their sense of value. This is
very imperative today as Millennials begin to take over the
corporate landscape. Per a 2014 article
by Business Insider, CEO of Twilio, Jeff Lawson, discusses how
Millennials enjoys consistent
feedback (Smith, 2014). This generation is accustomed to quick
gratification given the world of
technology they were raised in, and the ample feedback
provided allows them to keep tabs on their
performance so there aren’t any surprises (Smith, 2014).
Combining that with an Affiliative leader
who will communicate nothing but positive and encouraging
remarks, the motivational level with
employees will soar.
Affiliative Negatives
While this leadership style is very effective at building a
positive work environment and
group culture, there are some downfalls when this style is over
utilized. Since Affiliative leaders
predominately remain constructive in the feedback they provide,
under-performing workers tend
to go unrecognized, which thereafter, fosters mediocrity. These
deficient workers will start to
become content with their performance, as affiliative leaders
leave these issues unaddressed, and
indirectly, their poor output is condoned (Money-zine n.d.).
Deficient workers lack the clear
direction that is needed in order to course-correct, thus they
must rely on themselves in order to
improve their performance. This can lead to an overall drag on
the group’s performance, cause a
disruption in the harmony, and ultimately lead to failure.
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 32
The affiliative leadership style should mainly be reserved when
building a team together
to create a harmonious balance and positive chemistry amongst
members. This style is ideal when
there is a lack of communication or when trusts needs to be
mended. Leaders who rely on this style
will run eventually into issues with meeting overall
performance targets since it focuses on the
mental and emotional health of the group. In order to
appropriately sustain a healthy and productive
team, it is suggested that this style be combined with other
styles, such as the authoritative
leadership style (Leadership That Gets Results, 2000). An
authoritative leader will establish clear
direction in order to maintain goals, and help workers
understand their role in helping the
organization meet its objectives. With appropriate execution on
combining the affiliative and
authoritative leadership styles, the stage is set for establishing
an environment of committed and
driven workers producing outsized performance (Smith, 2014).
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 33
Affiliative Example
A classic example of an affiliative leader is the ex-manager of
the New York Yankees, Joe
Torre. As manager for such a prominent team in baseball, Joe
Torre had many ego-centric players
to manage. Through all of this Joe Torre managed to hold the
team together while building a sense
of harmony among the teammates (Money-zine, n.d.). Joe Torre
would recognize the contributions
of individual players and express his gratitude for them. This
method of leading created an overall
cohesiveness that allowed the Yankees to be as successful as
they were (Money-zine, 2014).
Affiliative Summary
This leadership style is one that relies on emotions of the
individual, rather than task. The
affiliative leader strives to keep their employees happy and
create harmony among them (Money-
zine, 2014). This style focuses on the culture of the group in
order to create unity. Although this
style of leading seems ideal, the lack of constructive criticism
for the employees can lead to poor
performance and project failure.
Literature Review
Most cited definitions of emotional intelligence can be found in
(Salovey, 1989). More
modern and refined versions can be found at (Mayer, 1999) and
(Salovey, 2001). The literature on
the effect of Emotional Intelligence on leadership styles is vast;
however, an interpretation of the
term itself is manifold. The early interpretation of emotional
style can be found in (Avolio, 1991)
and (Popper, 1994), these papers start to identify values of
emotional intelligence, but do not assign
a separate school of leadership to it, rather, it is considered an
important but subsidiary aspect of
Visionary or Charismatic School of Leadership. They focus
more on influencing the emotions and
behavior, rather than on understanding them. The seminal
publication that birthed a new school of
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 34
leadership solely based on emotional intelligence was
(Goleman, 1998). (Goleman, 1998) and
(Cooper, 1998), together popularized and identified emotional
intelligence as a leadership
competency, and defined its dimensions and styles. Further
publications like (Goleman, 2002)
presented a detailed analysis of sub-styles within the emotional
school and established emotional
intelligence as a critical leadership competency separate from
cognitive and social intelligence.
The pioneer proponent of this school is Daniel Goleman, who
has published numerous papers and
books; his most recent being (Goleman, 2013).
Conclusion
Attempts have been made to identify various competencies that
define a successful leader. Authors
have identified these as cognitive, behavioral, emotional, and
motivational (Dulewicz, 2003) but
has been shown that emotional competence accounts for 36% of
the leadership performance
(Dulewicz, 2000) greatest amongst all competencies. Literature,
lists numerous schools of
leadership, but its clear emotional intelligence finds relevance
in each of them (Turner, 2005).
From a project viewpoint with fixed start and end dates, project
managers often tend to be more
task oriented than people oriented, which may hamper the
leadership role (Turner, 2005). This
division was propounded by the contingency school of
leadership (Turner, 2005) and, emotional
competence in a leader is crucial to bridge this gap.
Another factor is the global nature of projects in modern times.
Increasingly remote teams
are being used and a leader has to be competent enough to
identify, cope up with, and even utilize
the cultural and lingual differences. Literature has identified
personality traits for coping with the
cultural differences (Selmer 2002), and they heavily involve
social awareness and relationship
management dimensions from which the emotional
competencies arise.
The emergence of agile project management and self-organizing
and managed teams in
recent years has presented a new situational analysis of
leadership styles. Leaders do emerge in
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 35
such teams, either formally and informally, even if no
leadership need has been defined. Again, an
emotional competency of empathy in this case has been found to
play a significant role and
influence task focused and socio-emotional goals (Wolff, 2002).
While emotional dimensions have been largely nebulous and
debated aspects of leadership,
through theory and examples in this paper, we have tried to
define emotional competencies that
underlie the leadership styles and predict which style will be
appropriate in relevant phases of the
project. However there is an unanimous agreement that
leadership always lies in the situation. This
can demand dynamic shuffling of the various competencies for a
leader to emerge successfully.
Acknowledgement
We are grateful for the encouragement and mentorship of Dr.
Victor Sohmen, Project
Management Program, Drexel University, and for his useful
comments and editorial guidance in
this paper.
Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April
2015 36
References
Affiliative Leaders. (n.d.). Retrieved March 12, 2015, from
http://www.money-zine.com/career-
development/leadership-skill/affiliative-leaders/
Avolio, B. J., Waldman, D. A., & Yammarino, F. J. (1991).
Leading in the 1990s: The Four I's of
Transformational Leadership. Journal of European Industrial
Training, 15(4).
Bass, B. M. (1960). Leadership, Psychology, and Organizational
Behavior.
Childs, R. (2004). Emotional Intelligence and Leadership.
Retrieved March 12, 2015, from
Team Technology: http://www.team-
technology.co.uk/emotional-intelligence.html
Comindwork Weekly / Work Productivity Tricks The Six
Leadership Styles (Goleman). (n.d.).
Retrieved March 11, 2015, from
http://www.comindwork.com/weekly/2013-08-
12/productivity/the-six-leadership-styles-goleman
Coaching Leadership. (2006). Retrieved March 11, 2015, from
http://www.money
zine.com/career-development/leadership-skill/coaching-
leadership/
Coercive Leadership. (2014). Retrieved March 10, 2015, from
money-zine.com:
http://www.money-zine.com/career-development/leadership-
skill/coercive-leadership/
Cooper, R. K., & Sawaf, A. (1998). Executive EQ: Emotional
Intelligence in Leadership and
Organizations. Penguin.
Cosmato, D. (2011, July 30). Are Democratic Leaders Effective
in Large Companies? Retrieved
March 10, 2015, from Bright Project Management:
http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are-
democratic-leaders-
effective-in-large-companies/
Democratic Leadership Style. (2013). Retrieved March 10,
2015, from Defining Leadership:
http://www.defining-leadership.com/democratic-leadership-
style/
Dulewicz, V., & Higgs, M. (2000). Emotional Intelligence-A
Review and Evaluation Study.
Journal of Managerial Psychology, 15(4), 341-372.
Fiedler, F. E. (1967). A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness
Goleman, D. (1998). Working with
Emotional Intelligence. Bantam.
Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R., & McKee, A. (2013). Primal
Leadership, With a New Preface by the
Authors: Unleashing the Power of Emotional Intelligence.
Harvard Business Press
Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R. E., & McKee, A. (2002). The New
Leaders: Transforming the Art of
Leadership into the Science of Results. London: Little, Brown.
http://www.team-technology.co.uk/emotional-intelligence.html
http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are-
democratic-leaders-
http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are-
democratic-leaders-
http://www.defining-leadership.com/democratic-leadership-
style/
Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx
Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx
Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx
Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx
Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx

More Related Content

Similar to Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx

QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric Overvi.docx
QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric  Overvi.docxQSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric  Overvi.docx
QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric Overvi.docx
makdul
 
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docxASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
randymartin91030
 
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä t_engl
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä     t_englIcv iw dream_car_volatilitä     t_engl
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä t_englICV_eV
 
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docxThe ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
todd771
 
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is tHotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
ssuser47f0be
 
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docxWeek five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
helzerpatrina
 
Drinking Age Essay Conclusion
Drinking Age Essay ConclusionDrinking Age Essay Conclusion
Drinking Age Essay Conclusion
Erin Byers
 
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international buLength3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
JospehStull43
 
1 ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric .docx
1  ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric  .docx1  ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric  .docx
1 ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric .docx
honey725342
 
Davenport university hcmg 770
Davenport university hcmg 770Davenport university hcmg 770
Davenport university hcmg 770
leesa marteen
 
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docxQuestions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
makdul
 
1 Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS INTEGRATIN.docx
 1  Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS  INTEGRATIN.docx 1  Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS  INTEGRATIN.docx
1 Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS INTEGRATIN.docx
aryan532920
 

Similar to Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx (12)

QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric Overvi.docx
QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric  Overvi.docxQSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric  Overvi.docx
QSO 680 Module One Journal Guidelines and Rubric Overvi.docx
 
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docxASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
ASB 100Spring 2019Writing Assignment 3In this assignme.docx
 
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä t_engl
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä     t_englIcv iw dream_car_volatilitä     t_engl
Icv iw dream_car_volatilitä t_engl
 
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docxThe ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
The ExternalEnvironment, Internal Profile,SWOTRemember that th.docx
 
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is tHotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
Hotel grim situation analysis project objectivethe report is t
 
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docxWeek five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
Week five Learning ObjectivesExplain how an organization.docx
 
Drinking Age Essay Conclusion
Drinking Age Essay ConclusionDrinking Age Essay Conclusion
Drinking Age Essay Conclusion
 
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international buLength3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
Length3,000 wordsDetails The world of international bu
 
1 ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric .docx
1  ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric  .docx1  ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric  .docx
1 ECO 500 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric .docx
 
Davenport university hcmg 770
Davenport university hcmg 770Davenport university hcmg 770
Davenport university hcmg 770
 
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docxQuestions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
Questions write in two postgrad level essays, each around 800 w.docx
 
1 Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS INTEGRATIN.docx
 1  Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS  INTEGRATIN.docx 1  Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS  INTEGRATIN.docx
1 Annotated comments by David Sotir, HELPS INTEGRATIN.docx
 

More from rock73

In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docxIn a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
rock73
 
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docxIn a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
rock73
 
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docxIn a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
rock73
 
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docxIn a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
rock73
 
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docxin a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
rock73
 
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docxIn a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
rock73
 
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docxIn a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
rock73
 
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docxIn a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
rock73
 
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docxIn a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
rock73
 
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docxIn a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
rock73
 
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docxIn a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
rock73
 
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docxin a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
rock73
 
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docxIn a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
rock73
 
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docxIn a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
rock73
 
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docxBASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
rock73
 
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docxBased on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
rock73
 
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires In her.docx
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires  In her.docxBarbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires  In her.docx
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires In her.docx
rock73
 
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docxBapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
rock73
 
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docxBarriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
rock73
 
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docxBarada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
rock73
 

More from rock73 (20)

In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docxIn a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (excluding the title and reference pag.docx
 
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docxIn a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
In a substantial paragraph respond to either one of the following qu.docx
 
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docxIn a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
In a study by Dr. Sandra Levitsky, she considers why the economic,.docx
 
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docxIn a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
In a response of at least two paragraphs, provide an explanation o.docx
 
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docxin a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
in a minimum of 1000 words, describe why baseball is Americas past .docx
 
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docxIn a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
In a minimum 200 word response, describe some ways how the public .docx
 
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docxIn a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
In a weekly coordination meeting, several senior investigators from .docx
 
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docxIn a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
In a memo, describe 1) the form and style of art as well as 2) the e.docx
 
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docxIn a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforce.docx
 
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docxIn a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
In a minimum 200 word response explain some of the reasons why, in.docx
 
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docxIn a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
In a maximum of 750 words, you are required to1. Summarize the ar.docx
 
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docxin a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
in a two- to- three page paper (not including the title and referenc.docx
 
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docxIn a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
In a two- to three-page paper (not including the title and reference.docx
 
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docxIn a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
In a group, take a look at the two student essays included in this f.docx
 
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docxBASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
BASEBALLRuns Scored (X)Wins (Y)70869875906547970480787957307166786.docx
 
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docxBased on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
Based on Santa Clara University Ethics DialogueEthics .docx
 
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires In her.docx
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires  In her.docxBarbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires  In her.docx
Barbara Corcoran Learns Her Heart’s True Desires In her.docx
 
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docxBapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
Bapsi Sidhwa’s Cracking India1947 PartitionDeepa Meh.docx
 
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docxBarriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
Barriers of therapeutic relationshipThe therapeutic relations.docx
 
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docxBarada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
Barada 2Mohamad BaradaProfessor Andrew DurdinReligions of .docx
 

Recently uploaded

The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
GeoBlogs
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Tamralipta Mahavidyalaya
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
siemaillard
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Anna Sz.
 
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Celine George
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Vivekanand Anglo Vedic Academy
 
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleHow to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
Celine George
 
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
Ashokrao Mane college of Pharmacy Peth-Vadgaon
 
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chipsFish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
GeoBlogs
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
Steve Thomason
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
TechSoup
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
rosedainty
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
Special education needs
 
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERPHow to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
Celine George
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdfUnit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
Thiyagu K
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
DeeptiGupta154
 
Cambridge International AS A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
Cambridge International AS  A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...Cambridge International AS  A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
Cambridge International AS A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
AzmatAli747758
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Jisc
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideasThe geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
The geography of Taylor Swift - some ideas
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
 
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
 
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute  Check Company Auto PropertyModel Attribute  Check Company Auto Property
Model Attribute Check Company Auto Property
 
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdfSectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
Sectors of the Indian Economy - Class 10 Study Notes pdf
 
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS ModuleHow to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
How to Split Bills in the Odoo 17 POS Module
 
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology ......
 
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chipsFish and Chips - have they had their chips
Fish and Chips - have they had their chips
 
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonThe Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve Thomason
 
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdfWelcome to TechSoup   New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
Welcome to TechSoup New Member Orientation and Q&A (May 2024).pdf
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
 
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERPHow to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
How to Create Map Views in the Odoo 17 ERP
 
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
How to Make a Field invisible in Odoo 17
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
 
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdfUnit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdf
 
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with MechanismOverview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
Overview on Edible Vaccine: Pros & Cons with Mechanism
 
Cambridge International AS A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
Cambridge International AS  A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...Cambridge International AS  A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
Cambridge International AS A Level Biology Coursebook - EBook (MaryFosbery J...
 
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
 

Assignment OverviewThis Case Assignment focuses on Volkswa.docx

  • 1. Assignment Overview This Case Assignment focuses on Volkswagen’s emissions scandal and related brand management and business ethics issues. Case Reading Boston, W., & Houston-Waesch, M. (2015, Oct 15). Volkswagen suspends another top engineer; berlin orders recall; transport minister says recall of tainted diesel cars is mandatory. Wall Street Journal (Online). Cremer, A. (2016, April 20). VW to pay each U.S. customer $5,000 to settle dieselgate: Die Welt. Retrieved from http://www.reuters.com/article /us-volkswagen-emissions-court-idUSKCN0XH0ZV Danny, Hakim, Kessler, A. M., & Ewing, J. (2015, Sep 27). As VW pushed to be no. 1, ambitions fueled a scandal. New York Times. De Cremer, D., & de Bettignies, H. (2013). PRAGMATIC BUSINESS ETHICS. Business Strategy Review, 24(2), 64-67. De Cremer, D., & de Bettignies, H. (2013). PRAGMATIC BUSINESS ETHICS. Business Strategy Review, 24(2), 64-67.
  • 2. Ewing, J. (2016, April 21). Volkswagen Reaches Deal in U.S. Over Emissions Scandal. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04 /22/business/international/volkswagen-emissions- settlement.html?_r=0 Farrell, S. (2015, Oct. 26). Volkswagen loses sales top spot to Toyota after emissions scandal. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/oct /26/volkswagen-top-spot-toyota-vw-emissions-scandal. Fung, B. (2015). Volkswagen's U.S. CEO apologizes for emissions cheating scandal. Washington: WP Company LLC d/b/a The Washington Post. Lane, C. (2015, Oct. 26). Emissions scandal is hurting VW owners trying to Resell. Retrieved from http://www.npr.org/2015/10/26/450238773/emissions- scandal-is-hurting-vw-owners-trying-to-resell. Listen https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501- DEC2016FT-2... 1 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM La Monica, P.,R. (2015, Sep 23). Volkswagen has plunged 50%. will it ever recover? CNN Wire Service.
  • 3. Sanger-Katz, M., & Schwartz, J. (2015, Sep 30). Gauging human toll of VW fraud. International New York Times. Here are some articles on brand equity and brand management. Keller, K. L. (1993). Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing customer-based brand equity. Journal of Marketing, 57(1), 1-22. Helm, S., & Tolsdorf, J. (2013). How does corporate reputation affect customer loyalty in a corporate crisis? Journal of Contingencies & Crisis Management, 21 (3), p144-152. Case Assignment Develop a report in terms of the following guidelines. A well- written report should have a brief introduction, headings or subheadings, and a brief concluding comment. Note that you should use some keywords as headings or subheadings such as "Brand Equity of VW”, instead of a sentence or a question. Read and cite required articles on Volkswagen’s emissions scandal, as well as additional research you have done, and address the following issues: Briefly describe Volkswagen’s emissions scandal and provide background on the company and automobile industry. 1.
  • 4. Do you think Volkswagen’s brand reputation was severely damaged by the emissions scandal? How about its brand equity? Discuss what brand equity is, and how Volkswagen’s brand equity will be impacted. 2. How should Volkswagen handle the emissions scandal in an ethical way? Discuss the related ethical issues from both consumer and brand manager perspectives. 3. What can you learn from this case? What suggestions could you offer to Volkswagen’s top management? 4. Assignment Expectations Expectations Regarding Your References and Defense of Your Positions Write clearly, simply, and logically. Your paper should be 750– 1,500 words long, excluding title pages and references, but quality of writing is more important than length. Use double-spaced, black Verdana or Times Roman font in 12 pt. type size.
  • 5. https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501- DEC2016FT-2... 2 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM Back up your positions or opinions with references to the required readings for this Case and those in the Module Background. In using those references, demonstrate your understanding of the concepts presented. Rather than grading on how much information you find, emphasis will be on the defense of the positions you take on the issues. Also remember that: The “why” is more important than the “what.”1. The defense of your positions on the issues is more important than the positions you take. 2. Do not repeat or quote definitions. Your use of the required reading to support your opinions (that is, contentions or positions) should demonstrate that you understand the concepts presented. Do not include definitions or summaries of the readings or simply describe what the company did. Instead, your responses to the questions should be analytical and should demonstrate that (a) you understand the principles from the background reading and (b)
  • 6. you can apply them to this particular case. Vague, general answers will not earn a good grade. Avoid redundancy and general statements such as “All organizations exist to make a profit.” Make every sentence count. Paraphrase the facts using your own words and ideas, employing quotes sparingly. Quotes, if absolutely necessary, should rarely exceed five words. When writing an academically oriented paper, you will uncover many facts about the company and the scandal. If you paraphrase the facts, cite the sources in your text and link those citations to references at the end of the paper. Here are some guidelines on how to conduct information search and build critical thinking skills. Emerald Group Publishing. (n.d.). Searching for Information. Retrieved from http://www.emeraldinsight.com/learning/study_skills/skills/sear ching.htm Emerald Group Publishing. (n.d.). Developing Critical Thinking. Retrieved from http://www.emeraldinsight.com/learning/study_skills/skills/criti cal_thinking.htm Guidelines for handling quoted and paraphrased material are found at:
  • 7. Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Academic Writing. Retrieved from https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/section/1/2/ Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Quoting, Paraphrasing, and Summarizing. Retrieved from https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/563/1/ Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Is it plagiarism yet? Retrieved from http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/1/ https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501- DEC2016FT-2... 3 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM Privacy Policy | Contact Your paper consists of arguments in favor of your opinions or positions on the issues addressed by the guidelines; therefore, avoid the following logical fallacies: Purdue Online Writing Lab. (n.d.). Logic in argumentative writing. Retrieved from https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/659/01/ https://tlc.trident.edu/content/enforced/89898-MKT501- DEC2016FT-2... 4 of 4 12/17/2016 2:27 PM
  • 8. Managing change and transitions: a comparison of different models and their commonalities Claire V. Brisson-Banks Family History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA Abstract Purpose – The purpose of this article is to analyze the commonalities of various change and transition models developed over time to assist with and support managing organizational change. Design/methodology/approach – The article provides an examination of change and transition models through a review of relevant literature and the comparison of different models. Findings – Each change and transition model has similar methods of handling change. Their unique methods and strategies provide additional insights into possible applications to most organizations. In some cases, models could be combined to form new models to best fit the circumstances of the organization. Practical implications – This comparison can assist individuals in evaluating and selecting the model based on organizational need while remembering to focus on both the physical and the
  • 9. emotional changes in an organization. Originality/value – The article shows that human resource managers can benefit from learning the commonalities between change and transition models when considering what will work for their organization in conjunction with the review of a number of well known and relevant models. Keywords Human resource management, Organizational change, Leadership, Change management, Adaptability Paper type Research paper Introduction Change is evident everywhere from the simplest everyday changes to the most difficult situations encountered by human resource (HR) managers as management grapples with reorganizations, downsizing and/or cutbacks. A crucial factor in the effectiveness of an organization is the ability to adapt to change (French and Delahaye, 1996). According to Bridges and Mitchell (2000) “Business conditions change and yesterday’s assumptions and practices no longer work”. While it may seem uncommon to some, most businesses are told they have to change everything from the way they think to the way they work (Nortier, 1995). Wagar (2000) provides a bit of history by reminding us of how downsizing became an obsession in the 1990s, the phrase “lean and mean” became a primary focus of most
  • 10. businesses at that time. Whether the success of downsizing tactics worked is not the topic for discussion here, however, the tactics employed at the time are part of this comparison. Today’s economic crisis has also added the new dimension of change needing to be immediate instead of over a period of time. Add increased global competition, outsourcing, fast changing and new technologies and you have a recipe for massive confusion to those involved in such a volatile environment. The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0143-5124.htm Managing change and transitions 241 Received 15 August 2009 Revised 25 October 2009 Accepted 15 November 2009 Library Management Vol. 31 No. 4/5, 2010 pp. 241-252 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0143-5124
  • 11. DOI 10.1108/01435121011046317 Literature review When beginning a review of studies surrounding change models, it was discovered that much time and energy has been devoted to bring about a better understanding of change as it relates to organizations. While this topic has been looked at from various disciplines, this article will only touch on some of the many change and transition models, which organizations have to choose from as they work through their particular organization change. An awareness of the need for change is the beginning of the whole change process (Armstrong, 2006). A complete assessment of the current situation is necessary to begin the process of implementing any kind of change in an organization. Unfortunately, this kind of assessment may take longer than management or stakeholders have if the situation is very serious. What happened to bring about the need for change? What kind of issues and problems have occurred to bring about this crisis are questions which need to be answered as this helps to determine the best course of action to follow. Which change and/or transition model will fit the organization? Another facet within change models are the individuals involved
  • 12. in working together to implement change. Ulrich and Brockbank (2005) provide some insights to this element of the equation by pointing out how “high- performing HR professionals make change happen successfully and thoroughly with their most critical contribution being to make sure the change happens quickly”. Just how involved the HR professional has to be for a successful change is up to the organization. There are a variety of reasons their involvement is imperative to the success of any type of change. Additionally, their familiarity with the organization’s culture and employees becomes a great asset to the individuals responsible for organizing changes. This is most significant in a change process as follow through skills become extremely valuable and adds to the facilitation of all types of organizational change. Taking a step back to change itself, various studies have revealed additional strategies concerning the very nature of change and how it relates to organizations. Kanter (1985) relates how organizations have to be able to adapt to change or face the possibility of losing out to competition. Kanter (1985) further expounds on how some in top management attempt to force change by just simply dictating it, changing polices without warning and expecting their middle management to take charge and make the change work. These experiences reflect how strategic-planning models are only a piece of the change process, which usually results in some sort of
  • 13. modifications to work with an individual organization. Burke (2004) looks at where the organizational development field is in 2004, and expresses how difficult it is to move forward without the knowledge of what is coming. Burke’s (2004) review of what is now known (in 2004) evaluates change processes and points out some of the change models which will be covered further in this article. Additionally, change effort is now enhanced with the aid of training and feedback. Burke’s (2004) comments bring out how any value-based change effort requires effective leadership and a business structure which includes strategy, mission plans and a model. When a change model is used in conjunction with the business structure it has a better chance of success and is part of the eight-step change model from Kotter (1995) where “to work together as a team united in the vision,” is necessary for success. LM 31,4/5 242 Axelrod (2001) reminds us of how change management and models came to the point of unleashing the power of employees. Previous studies conducted by Kurt Lewin during World War II revealed how allowing input from
  • 14. employees when changes were needed added to acceptance of the changes with a bonus of increased productivity. These studies were conducted with surveys and working together to review the collected data which resulted in better change solutions. Axelrod (2001) further explains there needs to be a new paradigm involving more people and widening the circle of involvement. Dannemiller and Norlin (2001) have developed a different approach altogether calling it a whole-scale change where the business comes together to connect the collective wisdom of the organization creating the one brain and one heart methodology. This process brings in individuals from all levels of the organization to create the alignment needed for success. The additional touch of requiring high performance brings this model in line with another change model introduced by Quinn (2006). Following the path of working together, Schein(2004) uses the term “culture” and shows how it is extremely important to investigate and study the culture of an organization in order to work with them in a more cohesive manner. This very notion of knowing the culture of the organization is the responsibility of the leaders in order to determine how to lead or Schein (2004) says the “culture will lead them” making any change model more difficult to implement.
  • 15. Evans and Ward (2004) remind us how managers are in the position of needing to “be prepared for two types of change-planned and imposed”. New managers are under pressure to make a good impression and feel like they have to implement change correctly and operating under an unexpected or forced change can cause great difficulties with staff. While change can be risky and is time- consuming, careful preparation can enhance the process. Managers tackle the situation of how most people do not enjoy change, but somehow, because change must happen, individuals will adjust over time with the right people in management. Beer et al. (1990) conducted studies of change programs with 12 different companies and discovered how most do not work unless everyone is involved and on board. Beer et al. (1990) determined that “effective corporate renewal starts at the bottom, through informal efforts to solve problems”. Their studies revealed how senior officials can be committed to change and have to foster a climate of change instead of mandating the changes from the top as may have been done in the past. They also discovered how all departments and mangers need to be involved or the whole process can break down. Additional organizational change studies were conducted by Dunphy and Stace (1993) to show how no one model is universally applicable. They point out how
  • 16. “turbulent times demand different responses in varied circumstances, so managers and consultants need a model of change that is essentially a situational or contingency model”. Dunphy and Stace (1988) developed a contingency model using a combination of leadership styles and different types of changes. Identifying the optimum mix of leadership and change styles, while considering the organization, is what makes the change successful. Bridges and Mitchell (2000) provide what they call a new model for change. They remind us how, over the years, a large amount of time and effort has been spent in studying the management of change and yet it seems to have fallen short in providing Managing change and transitions 243 the much needed solutions to the economical situations organizations find themselves in today as they work through a variety of necessary changes for survival. While change is not an easy or simple process, many still operate today as if it is and fail to understand why a business is unable to create a plan and follow it through successfully. Bridges and Mitchell (2000) point out “most
  • 17. leaders imagine that transition is automatic – that it occurs simply because the change is happening. But it doesn’t”. The human element of change needs to be addressed for change to be successful. Kotter and Cohen (2002) have put together a collection of success stories using Kotter’s famous eight-step change model from 1996 as well as situations which could be considered failures. In the book, Kotter and Cohen (2002) point out the reasons for success are “[b]ecause their most central activity does not center on formal data gathering, analysis, report writing, and presentations . . . instead, they compellingly show people what the problems are and how to resolve the problems”. It is this kind of process that goes a long way into creating successful organizational changes. This change model will be discussed in this article. Change and transition models Lewin One of the earliest change models was developed by Kurt Lewin. According to Burnes (2004) and Armstrong (2006) this model is referred to as the “3- Step Model” developed in 1947 and referenced in his Field Theory in Social Science (Lewin, 1951). This model breaks change down into three steps: unfreezing, changing, and refreezing, Armstrong (2006) provides greater detail to this process as follows: . Unfreezing – is altering the present stable equilibrium which
  • 18. supports existing behaviors and attitudes. This process must take account of the inherent threats that change presents to people and the need to motivate those affected to attain the natural state of equilibrium by accepting change. . Changing – developing new responses based on new information. . Refreezing – stabilizing the change by introducing the new responses into the personalities of those concerned (Armstrong, 2006). This could be compared to overcoming bad habits by replacing them with new and better habits. The individual, like an organization, has to be resolved and committed to make the change and do what is necessary regardless of any inconveniences involved in the process. The end goal is to succeed with the change. Burnes (2004) points out that Lewin is one of the early pioneers of group dynamics and how individuals will usually go along with the group norm whether it is a positive or negative situation or actions. Armstrong (2006) adds how “Lewin suggests a methodology for analyzing change which is called ‘field force analyses’” and involves the following: . Analyzing the restraining or driving forces will affect the transition to the future state; these restraining forces will include the reactions of those who see change as unnecessary
  • 19. or as a constituting a threat. . Assessing which of the driving or restraining forces are critical. . Taking steps both to increase the critical driving forces and to decrease the critical restraining forces (Armstrong, 2006). LM 31,4/5 244 How does this apply to an organizational change? Ritchie (2006) sheds some light on how an organization can apply this to a change situation. The unfreezing is the time process required to prepare for change, to help the staff accept the coming change, and break down the status quo found through the evaluation completed leading up to the realization that changes were necessary for survival. This will force the organization to take a hard and difficult look at their very essence. Ritchie (2004) calls this a “controlled crisis” which adds the needed motivation to make a change. Once the change is set in motion, individual workers may have to find new ways to accomplish their jobs, whether they are the same jobs in new locations or new jobs in the same locations. Once the workers have accepted these changes they easily support
  • 20. and adjust to the change. In Johnson’s (1998) Who Moved My Cheese?, the character Haw realizes he needs to move on and accept his situation making the best of it, while Hem refuses to change and just remains in his same state. This is often what happens in an organization when certain individuals refuse to accept the changes while others move on and work through them. Richie (2004) states refreezing is at the point when there is a new stable organization, people are accepting the reorganization by working through the new methods and ways of accomplishing daily tasks. Once this occurs, confidence in the business increases and there is usually a new sense of hope and the future looks brighter for all in the new organization. It is at this point when refreezing should take place. A celebration of the new organizations should be held. This allows everyone to feel appreciated for their part in the success of the change. (Remembering change is cyclical and may have to be addressed again in the future.) Beckhard Richard Beckhard (1969) developed a change program, which incorporates the following processes (as cited in Armstrong, 2006): . Setting goals and defining the future state or organizational conditions desired after the change. . Diagnosing the present condition in relations to these goals.
  • 21. . Defining the transition state activities and commitments required to meet the future state. . Developing strategies and action plans for managing this transition in the light of an analysis of the factors likely to affect the introduction of change. Depending on the circumstance, an organization may receive the latest quarterly reports and realize that change is required in order to survive or successfully contend with their existing or future competition. A business’s staff can work together to plan and implement change using this program. To breakdown this change program further, Rouda and Kusy Jr (1995) provide Beckhard’s definition of organizational development; it is “[a]n effort, planned, organization-wide, and managed from the top, to increase organization effectiveness and health through planned interventions in the organization’s process, using behavioral-science knowledge”. This explanation provides additional insights in how the change program can be used in a business setting. Looking at this change program with this added definition helps to show how it can be applied in a business or organizational setting when change is imminent. According to Rouda and Kusy Jr (1995), this model: Managing
  • 22. change and transitions 245 [t]akes a long-range approach to improving performance and efficiency in an organization by looking at the total organization, adding the necessary support from top management by implementing it themselves along with tying it to the bottom- line. Next apply incremental changes over a period of time while involving the individuals in the business providing them an opportunity to make a positive contribution. Additionally, Marshak (2004) states “The whole idea of planned change assumes, in essence, that it is possible to determine rationally how to initiate and implement actions to achieve and then maintain a predetermined, desired future state”. While these steps are not always applied in the correct order, they all need to happen for change to be successful. Thurley A third change model described in Armstrong (2006) was introduced by K. Thurley (1979) and has five main strategies to managing change: “Directive, bargained, hearts and minds, analytical and action-based”. Each strategy has advantages and disadvantages for all parties involved. The primary starting point is to recognize
  • 23. the need for change in an organization. An in depth review of each strategy is valuable when determining if and when there is any commonality with each of the change models discussed in this article exists and whether access to particular strategies will aid or hinder the success of the organizational change. Both Armstrong (2006) and Lockitt (2004) provide ample explanations of each strategy. . Directive – “the imposition of change in crisis situations or when other methods have failed. This is done by the exercise of managerial power without consultation” (Armstrong, 2006). “The advantage here is that change can be undertaken quickly, however, the disadvantage is it does not take into consideration any views, or feelings, of those involved in the change” (Lockitt, 2004). . Bargained – “this approach recognizes that power is shared between employer and the employed and that change requires negotiation, compromise and agreement before being implemented” (Armstrong, 2006). “[w]illingness by senior managers to negotiate and bargain in order to effect change. This approach acknowledges that those affected by change have the right to have a say in what changes are made, with disadvantages being the additional time to effect change” (Lockitt, 2004). . Hearts and minds – “an all-embracing thrust to change the attitudes, values and
  • 24. beliefs of the whole workforce. This normative approach seeks commitment and a shared vision but does not necessarily include involvement or participation” (Armstrong, 2006). This strategy allows “full support of the changes being made and a shared set of organizational values that individuals are willing and able to support. Again the advantage is the positive commitment to the changes being made with the disadvantages being that it takes longer to implement” (Lockitt, 2004). . Analytical – “a theoretical approach proceeds sequentially from the analysis and diagnosis of the situation, through the setting of objectives, the design of the change process, the evaluation of the results and, the determination of the objectives for the next stage in the process” (Armstrong, 2006). LM 31,4/5 246 . Action-based – “this recognizes that the way managers behave in practice bears little resemblance to the analytical, theoretical model. The distinction between managerial thought and managerial action blurs in practice to the point of invisibility. What managers think is what they do. Real life
  • 25. often results in a ‘ready’, ‘aim’, and ‘fire’ approach” (Armstrong, 2006). “This strategy stresses full involvement of all those involved, and affected by, the anticipated changes. Benefits of this approach are that any changes made are more likely to be supported due to the involvement of all those affected, the commitment of individuals and groups within the organization as they all feel ownership over the changes being made, the disadvantages are the time it takes before changes are made” (Lockitt, 2004). Each of these strategies can be analyzed extensively, used independently or in combination in a manner appropriate for an organization. There may be situations arise which may require methods from one strategy mixed with methods from a different strategy to support a successful model for a particular business. Lockitt (2004) points out how “the skill of effective change management is to recognize what strategies to employ, when, where and how to use them in order to be most effective”, this can be an individual from human resources, management or a hired change agent. Often change models neglect the transition that is required to occur within the individuals in the organization during the actual change process. It is important to include this human element in the change process. Nortier (1995) explains how Bridges (1986) “considers transition as a dynamic in three stages”. Bridges and
  • 26. Mitchell (2000) have labeled these three stages as: Endings, the neutral zone (explorations), and new beginnings. Often, in the whole course of action, whether using a change model or not, the benefits of a change are presented, plans are designed and implemented in coordination with managers, policies, technical changes and budgets leaving out one of the most important aspects, the individuals who will be affected by the changes (Nortier, 1995). Bridges Another thought on this is provided by Bridges (1991) in the statement “it isn’t the changes that do you in, it is the transitions”. In an earlier paper by Bridges (1986), he also points out how “change is the current corporate landscape is the rule rather than the exception”. It is worth noting that in 2009 this is still the rule. Further explanations of the three stages are as follows: . The Ending Phase – Saying goodbye to the way things were, a particular job, associates, a location, even a manager or supervisor can all be changed when realignment happens in an organization. . The Neutral Zone – New environment, new responsibilities, the rules have changed, there are different people to work with and report to, this can all be unsettling as one explores and experiments in this new setting.
  • 27. . New Beginnings – This period requires the final adjustment to new ways of doing many different tasks or even similar tasks but in handling them in a new manner (Bridges and Mitchell, 2000). The last phase is often when individuals lose it all hope; they freeze and cannot move forward. This is mentioned earlier in this article in reference to Who Moved My Cheese? ( Johnson, 1998). Three of the four characters eventually make it to this last phase, but Managing change and transitions 247 one, Hem, is unable to move beyond his fears, and eventually, he is left behind. Organizational change models need to incorporate transitions in their plans to improve the success rate of their upcoming change. Kotter Kotter (2007) states “Leaders who successfully transform businesses do eight things right (and they do them in the right order)”. Kotter’s original article by the same title published in 1995 soon became a must read for organizational leaders planning and implementing change. Kotter (1996) states while change efforts have helped improve some
  • 28. organizations in the competitive markets, many situations have been disappointing and the results have been disastrous for the employees and those in charge. Kotter points out “the biggest mistake people make when trying to change organizations is to plunge ahead without establishing a high enough sense of urgency in fellow managers and employees”. The thought that this could not happen to our organization is one of the main causes of failure while instituting organizational change. Some changes take years and even after a number of years, they may fail for a variety of reasons. Armstrong (2006) goes through his eight steps as follows: 1. Establishing a sense of urgency a. Examining market and competitive realities b. Identifying and discussing crises, potential crises, or major opportunities 2. Forming a powerful guiding coalition a. Assembling a group with enough power to lead the change effort b. Encouraging the group to work together as a team 3. Creating a vision a. Creating a vision to help direct the change effort b. Developing strategies for achieving that vision
  • 29. 4. Communicating the vision a. Using every vehicle possible to communicate the new vision and strategies b. Teaching new behaviors by the example of the guiding coalition 5. Empowering others to act on the vision a. Getting rid of obstacles to change b. Changing systems or structures that seriously undermine the vision c. Encourage risk taking and non-traditional ideas, activities and actions 6. Planning for and creating short-term wins a. Planning for visible performance improvement b. Creating those improvements c. Recognizing and rewarding employees involved in the improvements 7. Consolidating improvements and producing still more change a. Using increased credibility to change systems, structures and polices that don’t fit the vision b. Hiring, promoting and developing employees who can implement the vision
  • 30. c. Reinvigorating the process with new projects, themes and change agents LM 31,4/5 248 8. Institutionalizing new approaches a. Articulating the connections between the new behaviors and corporate success b. Developing the means to ensure leadership development and succession (Armstrong, 2006). It is interesting to note here how Kotter has managed to bring together the change models and transitions into an eight step process. In The Heart of Change (Kotter and Cohen, 2002) these eight steps are linked to 34 real life organizations located throughout the world. The book is structured around these specific eight steps because “this is how people experience the process” (Kotter and Cohen, 2002). Both books provide case studies showing what works and what usually does not work. Kotter (2007) also reviews what happens when these eight steps are not followed in the correct order or in the correct way. The old adage of “this is the way we do things around here” is very difficult to overcome,
  • 31. but is very necessary to change when dealing with having to change a culture. Kotter (2007) states “his basic goal has been the same: to make fundamental changes in how business is conducted in order to help cope with a new, more challenging market environment”. This goal is evident as Kotter (2007) reviews what happens when these steps are not followed: 1. Not establishing a Great Enough Sense of Urgency a. Transformation or changes begin but are frozen and can’t move forward b. Complacency has set in preventing any change from going forward 2. Not creating a powerful enough guiding coalition a. When just a few people are not supported by more along the way, their efforts are lost, major players need to be involved or the change will never get off the ground 3. Lacking a vision a. Without a clear vision, the whole effort can fall apart as individuals struggle to be a part of something not understood by the larger population 4. Under communicating the vision by a factor of ten a. Everyone needs to be kept in the loop throughout the whole process using every
  • 32. possible means of communication available from meetings to emails and everything else in between. The management and the employees need to be in sync with each other, lack of communication can prevent major successes causing the whole plan to fail 5. Not removing obstacles to the new vision a. Everyone has to be working together to make this new vision a reality, keeping those who refuse to change need to be replaced or it will fail. 6. Not systematically planning for, and creating, short-term wins a. Change takes time; people lose momentum and need to be congratulated when evidence shows that the changes are going forward successfully 7. Declaring victory to soon a. Some changes can take anywhere from five to ten years, premature victory celebrations can kill momentum and ruin the whole change 8. Not anchoring changes in the corporations culture a. Making the new changes the way things are now done shows that the change is most likely to stay, however, if this is not happening and most things beyond the surface don’t really change then the change has failed (Kotter, 2007). Managing change and
  • 33. transitions 249 It is crucial for successful change to help individuals adjust to the ever-changing business world and keep communication lines open at all times while maintaining the organization’s vision during the change process. When these strategies are implemented, taking everyone into consideration, than change is more likely to be completely successful. Commonalities Conclusions Table I shows clearly there are significant commonalities between these particular change and transition models. It is interesting to note that is while they are not all lined up they each handle change in a similar fashion. All these models are just guides to assist organizations through the world of constant change which exists today. While no one exact and perfect model exists for everyone, each has positive ways to handle change and can be adapted according to the organization. It must also be remembered that change is constant. If an organization makes a set of changes successfully, it should be noted that one Kotter’s (1996) eight steps is to keep improving, going forward with new and more innovative ways to compete in the market by adding new
  • 34. products, always looking for new ways to handle situations and keep the vision going by adding new people as the organization continues to grow. Senge (1990) points out how “from an early age we are taught to break apart problems, to fragment the world”. If problems are broken down too soon or too quickly perspective is lost and there are times when stepping back and seeing the whole situation first is very beneficial and usually necessary. In an organizational environment, creating a sense of urgency or mandating a directive because market forces have caused great economic upheaval, it is prudent to step back, take a look at the whole situation, analyze the problems, develop a plan of action with support and proceed to unfreeze, work with the employees, managers, directors and stockholders in creating a complete environment where everyone feels ownership of the both the problems and the solutions. This creates a solid foundation for any organization to Lewin Beckhard Thurley Bridges Kotter Unfreezing Analyzing present condition Directive Sense of urgency Bargained Form guiding coalition Hearts and Minds Ending phase
  • 35. Have powerful group to lead change effort Analytical Neutral zone Work together as a team Changing Setting goals for the future Plan of action Create a vision Communicate the vision Implementing the plan Action- based Empower others to act on the vision Plan for short-term wins New beginnings Improve on the changes Refreezing Institutionalize new approachesTable I. LM 31,4/5 250 handle the unexpected challenges brought on by a global market
  • 36. and fast-paced technological advances. This article has provided a commonality view of change and transition modes in hopes of presenting additional insights into how they are still relevant today in dealing with the ever-changing organization world. Managing change is definitely a challenge but not impossible, linking together possible solutions can only lead to improved ways to handle changes and transitions and open up the possibility of new and improved methods not yet discovered. References Armstrong, M. (2006), A Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice, 10th ed., Kogan, London, pp. 343-57. Axelrod, R. (2001), “Why change management needs changing”, Reflections, Vol. 2 No. 3, pp. 46-7, available at: http://web.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/pdf?vid¼ 4&hid¼7& sid¼e8690d69-fd9a-4c85-add1-a821c755d5d7%40sessionmgr4 (accessed 27 July 2008). Beckhard, R. (1969), Organizational Development: Strategies and Models, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA. Beer, M., Eisenstat, R.A. and Spector, B. (1990), “Why change programs don’t produce change”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 68 No. 6, pp. 158-66, available
  • 37. at: http://web.ebscohost.com. libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/pdf?vid¼5&hid¼7&sid¼38c4fc2e- bcf2-4ab6-834d-be9e5e2 afb52%40sessionmgr4 (accessed 25 July 2009). Bridges, W. (1986), “Managing organizational transitions”, Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 158 No. 1, pp. 24-33, available at: http://web.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ehost/ pdf?vid¼5&hid¼3&sid¼7f423133-1ef6-43c5-8073- 668c1e2d7a4d%40sessionmgr4 (accessed 11 August 2009). Bridges, W. (1991), Managing Transitions Making the Most of Change, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA. Bridges, W. and Mitchell, S. (2000), “Leading transition: a new model for change”, Leader to Leader, Vol. 16 No. 3, pp. 30-6, available at: www.berlineaton.com/resource_files/Bridges %20Change%20Model.pdf (accessed 5 July 2009). Burke, W. (2004), Organization Development: What We Know and What We Need to Know Going Forward, available at: www.g- rap.org/docs/ICB/Warner%20Burke%202004%20-%20 Organisation%20Development.pdf (accessed 8 August 2009). Burnes, B. (2004), “Kurt Lewin and the planned approach to change: a re-appraisal”, Journal of Management Studies, Vol. 41 No. 6, pp. 977-1001, available at: www.busmgt.ulster.ac.uk/ modules/bmg899j3/doc/Burnes%20on%20Lewin%20and%20pla nned%20change.pdf (accessed 9 August 2009).
  • 38. Dannemiller, K. and Norlin, P. (2001), “Leading whole-system change”, available at: www. dannemillertyson.com/leading.php (accessed 8 August 2009). Dunphy, D. and Stace, D. (1993), “The strategic management of corporate change”, Human Relations, Vol. 46 No. 8, pp. 905-21, available at: http://libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ login?url¼http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did¼1108411&Fmt ¼3&clientId¼17867& RQT¼309&VName¼PQD (accessed 8 August 2009). Dunphy, D.C. and Stace, D.A. (1988), “Transformational and coercive strategies for planned organizational change: beyond the O.D. Model”, Organizational Studies, Vol. 9 No. 3, pp. 339-55, available at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct¼true&db¼bth& AN¼5994762&loginpage¼Login.asp&site¼ehost-live (accessed 8 August 2009). Evans, G.E. and Ward, P.L. (2004), Beyond The Basics: The Management Guide for Library and Information Professionals, Neal-Schuman Publishers, Inc, New York, NY, pp. 68-92. Managing change and transitions 251 French, E. and Delahaye, B. (1996), “Individual change
  • 39. transitions: moving in circles can be good for you”, Leadership & Organization Development Journal, Vol. 17 No. 7, pp. 22-9, available at: http://libaccess.sjlibrary.org/login?url¼http://proquest.umi.com/ pqdweb?did¼ 117542778&Fmt¼3&clientId¼17867&RQT¼309&VName¼PQ D (accessed 11 August 2009). Johnson, S. (1998), Who Moved My Cheese?, Penguin Putnam, Inc., New York, NY. Kanter, R. (1985), The Change Masters: Corporate Entrepreneurs at Work, Unwin Paperbacks, London, pp. 84-87, 304-306. Kotter, J. (1995), The 20% Solution : Using Rapid Redesign to Create Tomorrow’s Organizations Today, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ. Kotter, J.P. (1996), Leading Change, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. Kotter, J.P. (2007), “Leading change why transformation efforts fail”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 85 No. 1, pp. 96-103, available at:
  • 40. http://search.ebscohost.com.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/ login.aspx?direct¼true&db¼bth&AN¼23363656&loginpage¼L ogin.asp&site¼ehost- live (accessed 6 July 2009). Kotter, J.P. and Cohen, D.S. (2002), The Heart of Change: Real Life Stories of How People Change Their Organizations, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. Lewin, K. (1951), Field Theory in Social Science, Harper and Row, New York, NY. Lockitt, B. (2004), “Change management”, available: www.learninglab.org.uk/papers/CHANGE_ MANAGEMENT_3t.pdf (accessed 10 August 2009). Marshak, R.J. (2004), “Morphing: the leading edge of organizational change in the twenty-first century”, Organization Development Journal, Vol. 22 No. 3, pp. 8-21. Nortier, F. (1995), “A new angle on coping with change: managing transition!”, The Journal of Management Development, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 32-46, available
  • 41. at: http://proquest.umi.com. libaccess.sjlibrary.org/pqdweb?index¼5&did¼8695001&SrchM ode¼3&sid¼1&Fmt¼ 3&VInst¼PROD& VType¼PQD&RQT¼309&VName¼PQD&TS¼1247461423&cli entId ¼17867&aid¼1 (accessed 6 July 2009). Quinn, J.B. (2006), “Organizational development, change and transformation”, in Armstrong, M. (Ed.), A Handbook of Human Resource Management, 10th ed., Cambridge University Press, London, p. 349. Ritchie, B. (2006), Lewin’s Change Management Model: Understanding the Three Stages of Change, available: www.consultpivotal.com/lewin’s.htm (accessed 10 August 2009). Rouda, R.H. and Kusy, M.E. Jr (1995), “Organization development the management of change”, Tappi Journal, Vol. 3 No. 3, pp. 1-4, available at: http://alumnus.caltech.edu/,rouda/T3_ OD.html (accessed 10 August 2009).
  • 42. Schein, E.H. (2004), Organization Culture and Leadership, 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, Inc, Danvers, CT, pp. 3-23. Senge, P.M. (1990), The Fifth Discipline, Doubleday, New York, NY. Ulrich, D. and Brockbank, W. (2005), The HR Value Proposition, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA, p. 224. Wagar, T. (2000), “Downsizing and restructuring”, in Belcourt, M. and McBey, K. (Eds), Strategic Human Resources Planning, Nelson Thompson Learning, Ontario, pp. 231-57. Corresponding author Claire V. Brisson-Banks can be contacted at: [email protected] LM 31,4/5 252 To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: [email protected]
  • 43. Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Read the following article from the required reading assignment: Preston, G., Moon, J., Simon, R., Allen, S., & Kossi, E. (2015). The relevance of emotional intelligence in project leadership. Journal of Information Technology and Economic Development, 6(1), 16-40. After reading the article, analyze the following scenarios, and choose one to discuss in your case study paper: Scenario 1: You are an office manager who has recently moved into a new department. It comes to your attention that there is a member of senior management who has been falsifying expense reports for himself and approving falsified reports for his subordinates, resulting in over-payments to employees. · Based on your preferred leadership style, what would be the best way to handle this situation?
  • 44. · What are some effective practices that you would use for leading people and business processes in this situation? · In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making processes that serve to establish an organizational climate oriented to meet business goals? Scenario 2: You are a newly hired department director, brought on board to help turn around a struggling department. The members of this department are highly educated and are taking steps to improve the professional development of department members. Despite these efforts, they feel they are underappreciated and lack a voice in the direction that the department is moving. You have leadership experience in a variety of industries, but you have never worked in this specific field. · Based on your preferred leadership style, how would you proceed in attempting to align the goals of the organization with the goals of the department? (The goals are actually the same for the organization and the department, but the two groups have different concepts on how to achieve them.) · What are some effective practices that you would use for leading people and business processes in this situation? · In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making processes that serve to establish an organizational climate oriented to meet business goals? Scenario 3: As a manager, you have two employees who have a
  • 45. difficult time working together. While nothing specifically unprofessional has been done by either one of them, other team members have expressed concern that the differences between them are causing tension and some other team members are having difficulty performing their work. Some have even gone so far as to say that the situation is causing a hostile work environment. · Based on your preferred leadership style, how would you handle this situation? · What are some effective practices that you would use for leading people and business processes in this situation? · In this situation, what is your role in the decision-making processes that serve to establish an organizational climate oriented to meet business goals? · In your case study, be sure to address the following: · Begin the discussion by identifying which of the scenarios you chose. · Include a brief statement as to which of the leadership styles presented in the above article you are most comfortable with. · Explain your top three, in order from most like you to least like you, and explain why you chose them. · Then, answer the questions provided with your chosen scenario. · Use the information provided in this unit to determine which
  • 46. leadership styles you prefer to use when you are in a leadership position (visionary, coaching, affiliative, democratic, pacesetting, and commanding). · Then, considering the above points, how would you proceed with handling the chosen scenario? Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Be sure to include peer-reviewed sources to support positions/conclusions. You are required to use at least two outside sources beyond the required reading for this unit. · Be sure that your analysis is highly relevant and informative, and remains on topic. · Accuracy should be strong with close attention to detail in all parts of the assignment. · Writing should be clear and concise with solid sentence structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation, and spelling errors. · Your paper should be at least two pages in length. · All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format. Unit III Reflection Paper It has been stated that different industries and organizational differences influence which motivational techniques and theories are most effective. It has also been stated that situational factors, such as the type of power exerted, can influence team and organizational effectiveness.
  • 47. Given the fact that the employment of different types of power might influence a team member’s satisfaction, and thus his or her motivation to continue, in regards to your current industry and/or the culture of your current organization, write a reflection paper that considers the following: · Describe leader power, follower motivation, and the aspects of effective followership. · Provide an overview of influence and the major process and content motivational theories. · Describe which motivational theory would be the most appropriate at your industry/organization. · Describe the power types from the French and Raven power taxonomy that would fit best with that motivational theory. · Are there any power types that should be avoided when employing that motivational theory? Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Writing should include proper grammar, sentence structure, and writing mechanics. · Organization should be logical. · Your paper should be at least two pages in length. Unit IV Essay Research the Kelley model of followership. Write an essay describing how a leader might utilize the Kelley model of followership to assess follower effectiveness, and discuss how
  • 48. this leader might develop this individual into a more effective follower. Be sure to include the following in your paper: · Describe the importance of organizational climate and motivation. · Describe Kelley’s model of effective followership (moving between roles). · Explain how knowledge of effective followership can help one’s leadership perspective. Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Writing should include proper grammar, sentence structure, and writing mechanics. · Organization should be logical, clear, and appropriate. · Provide strong evidence of critical thinking. · Make use of logical transitions. · Paragraphs should contain strong topic sentences. · Your paper should be at least two pages in length. · All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format. Unit V Case Study A textile manufacturer is closing its North Carolina plant and moving the production of its products to a developing nation in Southeast Asia. The primary reason for the move is the lower labor cost that the organization can enjoy in the new location.
  • 49. · Proponents of the decision laud the move as a means to save the organization by taking advantage of the free market and finding cheaper methods of producing the company’s goods. · Opponents of the decision state that a breach of trust existed between the company and the loyal employees in the North Carolina facility. Additionally, opponents cite recent findings that contractors in the Southeast Asia region where the company is moving have been cited for utilizing child labor and failing to provide working conditions equivalent to those in the United States. · Officials in the Southeast Asia region have answered the criticisms of the use of child labor by pointing out that oftentimes children are the only individuals in a family who are capable of working, and to deny them that opportunity would create greater hardship on the already desperately poor population. Based on the case study above, apply the deontological and teleological frameworks learned in this unit to provide the following information in your response: · Describe which framework the proponents of this move would use to support their statement that it be considered ethical. · Describe which framework the opponents of this move would use to support their statement that it be considered unethical. · Describe style of leadership this decision reflects, and
  • 50. discuss whether this move would lead to a positive evaluation of leadership and organizational performance. · Describe the level of corporate responsibility this decision reflects. Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Be sure to include peer-reviewed sources to support positions/conclusions. · Analysis should be highly relevant, informative, and remain on topic. · Accuracy should be strong with close attention to detail in all parts of the assignment. · Writing should be clear and concise with solid sentence structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation, and spelling errors. · Your paper should be at least two pages in length. · You must also use at least five outside sources to support assertions and conclusions. · All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format. Unit VI Project Assume that you have been tasked with preparing a cultural brief for an upcoming trip that will put you and your travel companions in touch with three different societal clusters. Choose three clusters other than the one in which you currently operate.
  • 51. In a PowerPoint or Prezi presentation, briefly describe the following: · List and describe the three cultural clusters that will be visited. · Provide information on cultural norms from each of the clusters to be visited. (Make sure to use specific information from the GLOBE study.) · Describe the leadership approaches preferred in the clusters that will be visited. · Describe the considerations for leading multicultural teams. Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Your presentation should have originality, and the content should be presented in a unique and interesting manner. · Analysis should be thorough and fully developed. · Organization should be clear in your paper. The main points should be arranged logically to support the information provided, with similar ideas grouped together and smooth transitions. · All graphics and texts should be appropriate and attractive and support the theme and content. Be sure to use a consistent and appropriate background. · Any sources used should be properly cited and referenced according to APA format. · Writing should be clear and concise with correct use of sentence structure and should be free from grammar,
  • 52. punctuation, and spelling errors. Unit VII Research Paper Write a research paper that analyzes methods used to appropriately manage groups and teams. In your paper, be sure to include the following: · Discuss the process of evolving a group into a team, and discuss the importance of organizational culture in that process. · Evaluate the leadership styles that are effective for managing groups and teams, including unique considerations for leading multicultural teams. · Describe the benefits and drawbacks of having groups or teams in terms of groupthink vs. teamthink. Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Your introduction should engage the reader and clearly present the thesis and a summary of the main points to clarify your point of view. · Review of literature should present a critical analysis and synthesis of the existing research. · Discussion should reveal insightful analysis of research. · A summary should be present that reviews or summarizes key points and provides a smooth transition between sections. · Writing should be clear and concise with correct use of sentence structure and should be free of grammar, punctuation, and spelling errors. · Your paper should be at least four pages in length.
  • 53. · You must also use at least five outside sources to support assertions and conclusions. · All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format. Unit VIII Article Critique The Brisson-Banks (2010) article in the required reading for this unit compares the five different change management models presented in this unit, and it describes various situational variables that could influence the effectiveness of each. Utilizing all of the knowledge accumulated through this and the previous units, write a critique of the article. In your paper, be sure to include the following: · Evaluate different aspects of organizational change. · Discuss the role that leader vision and organizational climate plays in a change management strategy. · Discuss how the leadership style that was identified as your primary preference would fit into the models of change presented. · Discuss how effective change initiatives can influence organizational performance. Be sure to follow the guidelines below: · Accurately identify the premise and supporting points from the article. · Provide an insightful and thorough analysis of information from the article, including using evidence and reasonable and
  • 54. compelling interpretations. · Link material to course content and real-world situations. · Demonstrate solid critical evaluation by providing well- supported opinions and conclusions using additional peer- reviewed articles. · Organize the material logically by using smooth transitions and grouping similar material together. · Your paper should be at least two pages in length. · All sources used must be referenced; paraphrased and quoted material must have accompanying citations in APA format. Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 16
  • 55. The Relevance of Emotional Intelligence in Project Leadership Genna Preston, Jayet Moon, Ryan Simon, Shayna Allen, Edem Kossi Project Management program Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA, USA [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract The Emotional Intelligence School of Leadership Styles major paper invites readers to uncover the six different styles of leadership that compose the school. The paper identifies and summarizes the following styles: Visionary, Coaching, Affiliative, Democratic, Pacesetting, and
  • 56. Commanding. Additionally the paper outlines the positives and negatives associated with each style of leadership as well as provides an example of those styles in use. Lastly, the paper concludes with the literature review and synopsis of how these styles can be effectively integrated into modern project management. Introduction Leadership is defined as, the power or ability to lead other people (Bass,1960). Project leadership is defined as, the ability to persuade others to enthusiastically and diligently pursue the projects objective (Salovey & Mayer, 1989). A project is always evolving dynamically and likewise, project leadership is situational. In a project, the leader is required to have cognitive,
  • 57. social, and emotional intelligence in order to assess the situational and organizational needs and adjust the pace of leadership accordingly (Mayer, Caruso & Salovey, 1989). Emotional intelligence is defined by Salovey and Mayer (1989) as the subset of social intelligence that involves the ability to monitor one’s own, and others feelings and emotions, to discriminate among them, and to use this information to guide one’s own thinking and actions. For Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 17 a long time emotional dimension of leadership was associated
  • 58. with the Visionary or Charismatic School of Leadership (Popper & Zakkai, 1994). Since the mid 1990’s, emotional intelligence has established itself as a leadership competence in its own right, as well as numerous books, publications, and exploratory studies, that lend credence and justify its importance. Goleman (1998) first synthesized and presented this idea of a new school, and it soon found its way into mainstream acceptance. Great leaders are the ones who drive people to deliver optimum performance. A critical way of doing this is by tapping into employees emotions while taking control of self-emotions. Leading and performing is not easy under pressure, more so in a project with hard deadlines. The
  • 59. ability to manage self and teams emotions, as well as connect to the emotions that drive their behaviors is a competency that is necessary in a modern project leader. According to the proponents of the emotional intelligence school, the emotional intelligence of the leader has greater impact on leadership skills and consequently the team performance than his intellectual capacity. Goleman, Boyatzis, & McKee (2002) identify four dimensions of emotional intelligence. 1. Self-Awareness 2. Self-Management 3. Social Awareness 4. Relationship Management
  • 60. Of these, 1&2 lie in the domain of personal competence while 3&4 lie in social competence domain. Personal competence translates to, having understandings of ones strengths, weaknesses, motives, and values, while at the same time having attributes like transparency, self-control, Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 18 initiative, and optimism (Avolio & Zakkai,1994). Social competence means empathy, awareness, and ability to understand and fulfill customer needs. Relationship management is an important part of social competence which involves influencing people,
  • 61. navigating conflicts, and ensuring team building and bonding. Based on such a distribution, there are six leadership styles: 1. Visionary 2. Coaching 3. Affiliative 4. Democratic 5. Pacesetting 6. Commanding Each style of leadership can be matched with a stage, and phase of a project as shown. This is an indicative generalization, and it is the prerogative of the project manager as to which style he/she adopts in each phase, such that most efficient performance is realized.
  • 62. Style Suggested Phase Visionary Initialization Coaching Planning Affiliative Planning Democratic Execution Pacesetting Monitoring & Control Commanding Closure Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 19 The styles listed above impact the organizational climate and
  • 63. culture since, leadership and management commitment directly translates to employee commitment, responsibility, task, goal orientation, and clarity of purpose (Detailed chart available in Appendix A). The sections below detail each of these styles in detail with their positives and negatives and examples of implementation. Some examples illustrate versatile leaders who show different styles, while some use a certain style as base and work within that boundary, transgressing it as the need dictates. Visionary The first style from the emotional intelligence school of leadership that we will analyze is
  • 64. the visionary leadership style. According to Dictionary.com (n.d), a vision is defined as, an experience in which a personage, thing, or event appears vividly or credibly to the mind, although not actually present, often under the influence of a divine or other agency. A vision is something imagined, and in business, it is where leaders of organizations imagine their organization to be at some point in the future. The visionary leadership style is defined by Daniel Goleman as, the leadership style where the “leader is inspiring in vision, and helps others to see how they can contribute to this vision; allowing the leader and followers to move together toward a shared view of the future,” (Toren, 2014). Daniel Goleman believes after many of his research studies, the visionary leadership style is the most effective one (Mersino,
  • 65. 2013). Visionary Positives The first advantage is the ability of the project leader to help others see their contribution in the big picture. This is perhaps the most important aspect of the visionary leadership style; this can help motivate the project team during the project life cycle, and this motivation can contribute to the success for the project. Project Team members would have the great benefit of knowing Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 20
  • 66. that what they do is important. The second advantage is that, visionaries can describe the end goals on a project, and leave the individuals plenty of latitude on how to achieve them (Mersino, 2013). This tactic can be beneficial to a project team that is made of skill workers or experts who are in this situation, given the ability to use their expertise to successfully complete this project. Lastly, a project leader with a visionary style can help a project team easily navigate various changes in a project. In fact, visionary leaders thrive on change and the ability to draw new boundaries (Mark, 2012). Visionary Negatives In a project, a visionary leadership style can suffer from poor articulated visions. Because
  • 67. this style takes advantage of the project team members’ ability to connect personally to the leader’s vision, there may be a disadvantage if the leader is unable to articulate his or her vision. This may lead to the opposite results with disconnected and unmotivated team members. Also, a project manager might face a similar situation if he has many senior people or experts reporting to him. In this situation, the vision casting by the manager may fall flat to resonate with the project team (Mersino, 2013). Finally, this style may also have some disadvantages if the project leader is full of great visions, but lack the necessary details to carry out his visions. Visionary Example
  • 68. One example of effective leaders who employ the visionary leadership is Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Dr. King had a vision that he was able to channel to millions of people decades ago; his visions are still being deployed today. Through his “I have a dream” speech and his non-violent acts, he was able to connect his vision to millions people, and to help them understand how they fit into the end result, when it comes to humanity and human rights (Toren, 2014). Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 21 Visionary Summary
  • 69. The visionary leadership style, which is a style of leadership that are inspires visions, can be very effective for project leaders. Visionary leadership qualities help their project teams understand the true objectives and goals, as well as, how their contributions are important to achieve these goals. It helps to organically motivate the project team Pacesetting The next leadership style that a project manager may use while executing a project is known as pacesetting. As defined in the Wall Street Journal Online article, Leadership Styles (Murphy, 2011), the pacesetting style is one in which “the leader sets high standards for
  • 70. performance. He or she is obsessive about doing things better and faster, and asks the same of everyone”. The pacesetting method allows for mangers with a mastery of certain tasks to exemplify his or her mastery over those tasks in the hopes that the supporting project team will gain mastery through osmosis. When utilized, this type of leadership style presents a variety of positives and negatives in relation to achieving overall success of a project’s desired outcome. Below is an examination of those positives and negatives as well as an example of the pacesetting leadership style in action. Pacesetting Positives The pacesetting leadership style is one of fast action. As described in the Money-zine.com
  • 71. article, Pacesetting Leaders, “one of the pros of the pacesetting leadership style is they are able to quickly achieve business results” (Money-zine, 2006). The reason behind the fast results of this style is because the project manager has great aptitude in the work that is being done. Thus, the project manager embarks on a lead by example approach and, expects that the team has the same aptitude and motivation for the project as he or she does. Creating a high energy team, that is Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 22 challenged to constantly progress at the rate of the manger and allowing for project results to occur
  • 72. at a rapid pace. Pacesetting is an excellent leadership style to use at the beginning of a project, as you are able to build momentum off of the excitement surrounding a new endeavor. It is an effective style to use to achieve the first few milestones of a project in short order. Pacesetting Negatives While pacesetting is excellent at achieving short-term goals, this leadership style can have a long-term negative impact on a project team. Primarily, this style of leadership is conducive for employees to burn out. Burn out occurs from the team being unable to sustain the same enthusiasm, drive, and competency of the project manager. The Changing Minds.org article, Six Emotional Leadership Styles, points out that pacesetting leaders, “tend to
  • 73. be low on guidance, expecting people to know what to do” (Goleman, 2002). Thus the pacesetting style not only demands constant amounts of high energy from its team but also it demands self-correction and self- sufficiency of its team. This type of environment causes increased stress levels as any member who struggles in a task will quickly fall behind the pace of the remainder of the team and will not have any guidance on how to take corrective measures. Pacesetting Example Pacesetting leaders are typically found in military settings, however, the Money-zine.com article, Pacesetting Leadership, provides businessman Jack Welch as an example of person who primarily implemented this leadership style (Pacesetting
  • 74. Leaders, 2006). Welch served as CEO for General Electric from 1981 to 2001. During his time as CEO, Welch would interact with employees at all levels of the organization as he believed “that leaders should avoid micro- managing, and spend their time inspiring others”(Pacesetting Leaders, 2006). Welch was Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 23 accessible to his employees, however, he was also demanding of them expecting the highest of results while disposing of those who were unable to keep up.
  • 75. Pacesetting Summary In conclusion the pacesetting leadership style is one that is best served in small doses. It serves to help launch a project or to help complete a project within a tight time frame. However, the style will wear thin on the team if utilized to often, as pressure builds and people are left feeling burnt out and left behind. Coaching The next leadership style from the emotional intelligence school of leadership to be examined is coaching. The coaching style as defined in the Jeff Hodgkinson article, Leadership Styles for Program and Project Managers, is when the project manager “instructs and motivates
  • 76. others to enhance their skills to achieve maximum impact for the team and project” (Hodgkinson, 2009). The coaching style puts the project manager in a mentoring role in relation to the project team. However, the coaching style isn’t mentoring in the truest sense; the needs of the project outweigh the needs of personal development or growth of a project team member. That being said, ideally the coaching style would be implemented with a team member that is inexperienced in a certain aspect of a project, which he or she is assigned so that the goals of the project, and the personal growth objects of the team member are aligned. Coaching Positives The coaching style is designed to cultivate a project member’s professional skill set. It is a
  • 77. relationship that is very similar to that of a teacher and student, with the project manager serving in the role of the teacher. Deidre Harris’ article, Project Leadership Styles notes, a project manager Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 24 utilizing the coaching technique “challenges all to do better and is encouraging when any failure is present” (Harris, 2009). By utilizing this technique an environment that is based on encouragement and empathy is created, allowing for team members to approach project goals without trepidation. The warm working environment that is born from this leadership style spurs
  • 78. the creation of more substantial inter-personal relationship amongst manger and team member. Trust is thus established within this style, and a trusting environment leads to productive environment, working towards self-improvement, as well as project success. Coaching Negatives The drawbacks behind utilizing the coaching leadership style are that it is very time consuming and that it runs the risk of being viewed as micromanagement, if not executed properly with the proper audience. In order to create a high level of trust and to teach in a project management setting, a large quantity of time is required for the project manager to devote to individual members. This time commitment isn’t feasible for
  • 79. projects with hard and fast deadlines, nor is it feasible on a project with a large project team. Additionally, this style is only conducive with a project member that is willing to learn and improve his or her craft. A Money-zine.com article aptly details, “if someone is managing employees that are extremely resistant to change, or are not interested in learning new things, the manager will struggle if they choose this style” (Coaching Leadership, 2006). Thus it is essential for a project manager to understand the make-up of the team, and the time constraints of the project before implementing this strategy. Coaching Example Not surprisingly, the best examples of the coaching leadership style come from the realm
  • 80. of sports. Being that all sport teams require a manger or coach in order to execute a strategy to meet an objective through a temporary endeavor; the match or game. It is easy to make the Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 25 connection between sports and project management. That is not to say that all sports coaches or managers utilize the leadership style of coaching, as they in fact do not, but it is meant to set the stage for a true example of this leadership style in action. Red Holzman was an NBA coach that achieved success in the league by winning multiple NBA titles,
  • 81. but perhaps his greatest success was his mentoring and development of his one-time player Phil Jackson. Jackson developed into one of the NBA’s all-time greatest coaches. The article Inspired by Holzman, Jackson Arrives in Springfield, beautifully depicts the Holzman-Jackson relationship, and provides the following quote from Jackson regarding his former coach; “Red took me under his wing, he didn't have an assistant coach, he made me his assistant coach and taught the game to me and taught me a lot about the game and encouraged me to go into coaching” (Hareas, 2007). Coaching Summary In summation, the coaching leadership style is a one that can be applied in any type of
  • 82. situation but is most beneficial in situations that have loose time constraints and eager team members. Coaching aims to give a team member the skills to succeed in a current project as well as cultivate skills that will serve beyond the context of a project, granted that it doesn’t divert too much attention away from the project. It aligns personal goals with project goals and provides constructive feedback, but has the potential to be viewed as overbearing to members unreceptive to change and constant feedback. It is a leadership style that should be implemented when possible, but will not always be appropriate, especially within highly demanding situations that have short deadlines and oversized teams. Democratic
  • 83. Another leadership style within this school is the democratic leadership style, also known as the participative style. This style is, “an open approach to leading, where decision making is Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 26 shared and the views of a team or group are valued and contribute to the vison, goals and decision that are made” (Democratic Leadership Style, 2013). This allows members of the teams to feel included and impactful in several stages of a project. With this style of leadership offering equality
  • 84. of power, and group decision making, it is imperative that it is used in the right situation or task (Detailed example available in Appendix B). Democratic Positives Democratic leadership brings teams together. With technology capabilities many organizations are outsourcing or working remotely. Democratic leaders bring individuals together in order for everyone to give their thoughts, ask questions, and be involved in the entire project and its processes. The inclusion of many opinions may offer a different insight or thought that you may have missed. This shows team members they are valued, and allows for everyone to have a clear understanding of the vision and goals of the project
  • 85. (Democratic Leadership Style, 2013). A democratic leader provides intrinsic motivation for their team. Research has proven that intrinsic motivation is a precursor to creativity and innovation, and by offering democratic leadership, individuals will satisfy their four motivators; sense of meaningfulness, sense of choice, sense of competence, and sense of progress. By satisfying these needs, individuals will be intrinsically motivated to go above and beyond any project or task assigned, as well as assist their organization in becoming front runners within their industry (Mahmood A. Bodla, 2014). Democratic Negatives A democratic leader is a great assets to any team however, the
  • 86. democratic leadership style comes with some negatives as well. One of the major problems with this style is that is very time consuming. With the inclusion of many different people it may take a longer period of time to Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 27 come to an agreement, receive a response, or communicate effectively. This also effects crisis management. During crises especially, time is of the essence, and in situations where decision need to be made right then and there, it just is not possible to lead democratically and include everyone
  • 87. in the plans (Ryan, 2015). When applying democratic leadership, it is important to still identify yourself as the leader. Unfortunately, sometimes group members may misinterpret this style with lack of leadership or bad job performance. Individuals may also feel it is not their place to make decisions, or they do not have enough experience offering suggestions or their opinions. Also, sometimes when opinions are offered time after time, but never implemented or acted upon, team members may feel deceived or manipulated, which will ultimately negatively affect employee morale, outcomes, and success (Cosmato, 2011). If managerial boundaries, and roles are not followed and respected, democratic leaders may experience negative results using this method of leadership.
  • 88. Democratic Example Civil Rights activist Rosa parks is a great example of a democratic leader. Although many people before Parks were arrested for ignoring racial boundaries and laws, Rosa Parks became the face of the civil rights movement. Supporters followed her as she led, collaborated, and acted upon change within the United States. She valued other people’s opinions, challenges, and treated everyone as an equal. Not only did she help change American law and policies, she did it effortlessly and democratically. Democratic Summary When used properly and productively, the democratic leadership
  • 89. style has many positive qualities and attributes. By allowing individuals to participate in the entire project and processes, it offers a sense of satisfaction, belonging, and accomplishment. This leadership style has been Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 28 directly connected to organizational success and achieved goals. As leaders continue to engage in this style, projects and organizations continue to excel and achieve successful outcomes. Commanding
  • 90. The commanding leader is a strong, authoritative individual who forcefully commands orders and tasks. A commanding leader will communicate honestly, and let you know if you are not progressing or working satisfactory (Larry Richard, 2008). This person holds all of the power, and will make changes and decisions without his or her subordinate’s. Although this leadership style has some positives attributes, it is comprised of more negative effects, and should be used with caution and only during demanding times (Coercive Leadership, 2014). Commanding Positives This leader gets the job done! Fear is instilled upon team members which drives them to use their full potential; ultimately achieving their goals. This
  • 91. leadership style is most effective during times of crises; internal or external (Six Emotional Leadership Styles, 2015). Because this leader gets the job, it will allow organizations to bounce back in times of crisis. This leadership style is also beneficial during organizational change, because he or she is the leader, and “encourages action, activity, and work” (Sloane, 2013). Leaders that command, extrinsically motivate their staff by offering rewards, based on performance and outcomes (Sloane, 2013). Commanding Negatives The commanding leader may negatively affect creativity and innovation. Team members do not feel a sense of meaningfulness or a sense of choice. This
  • 92. lack of inclusion will hinder intrinsic motivation; intrinsic motivation encourages individuals to succeed through self- satisfaction. Commanding limits intelligent thinking, team work, and disregards team experience Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 29 and capabilities (Hughes, 2013). Team members will respond negatively to this style, if it used all of the time. If leaders are feared and unapproachable, team members may feel insubordinate to offer information that may be valuable or beneficial to a particular situation. "Beware that in the
  • 93. long run it may result in employees passively resisting, rebelling or leaving altogether” (Leadership Style, 2015). • Today’s workforce does not accept the autocratic style often adopted by leaders following historical models of leadership. • Leadership has had to evolve to match a growing sense of democracy and independence in the workforce • Employees now have far more options and choices than the foot soldiers of yesterday, (Childs, 2004). With that said, we can see why it is imperative to only use the commanding leadership style during necessary times of crises. Also, because of ever-changing times, and a diverse group of team members, practicing emotional intelligence will only benefit
  • 94. your team’s organization and outcomes. Commanding Example A great example of a commanding leader is America’s military organizations; army, navy, air force, national guard, etc. Depending on their rank and institutional standing within the organization, individuals control, direct, and order groups and teams daily. Commanders, sergeants, and lieutenants disregard their subordinates and demand authority and cooperation. Fear, respect, and obedience are demanded in the beginning, and these principals are passed throughout the different divisions of the military. Commanding Summary
  • 95. Although this leader will get the job done, it is important to use this method sparingly. Demanding and commanding attitudes will benefit your organization in times or change and crises. Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 30 Leaders of the world use this style while when they want to quickly establish authority and organizational goals. Affiliative The affiliative leadership style is another style within the emotional intelligence group of
  • 96. leadership styles. Affiliative leaders create emotional bonds and harmony (Leadership That Gets Results, 2000). This particular style of leadership works best when there are disagreements among team members. This leadership style is also most effective when team members need motivation during stressful circumstances. Affiliative Positives The affiliative leadership style places an emphasis on placing value on individuals, rather than centering on goals and objectives. An affiliative leader has the innate ability to forge strong emotional bonds with others, leading to immense loyalty from the individual. Building strong relationships between others, sets a solid foundation to establish
  • 97. positive team chemistry (Leadership That Gets Results, 2000). With a harmonious group, communication becomes smooth and amiable; members are willing to engage in productive conversation with one another, ideas are traded back and forth, companionship increases, and positive feedback becomes abundant and consistent. A sense of belonging is felt, and this allows for a positive work environment, strong loyalty and very high-spirited employees (Leadership That Gets Results, 2014). Along with this style, autonomy amongst workers is increased, predominantly driven by the trust that members have with one another that the work and task will get done no matter the process used. Affiliative leaders help harbor that flexibility as unnecessary rigid structures are not
  • 98. imposed on the employees (Smith, 2014). Workers have the ability to use the most efficient method Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 31 for them in order to complete their work, which, in turn can lead to reduced pressure and more favorable performance results. One of the greatest qualities of an affiliative leader is the ability to drive motivation among members through solid and consistent feedback. Although commentary remains largely constructive and positive, this empowers the workers and increases their sense of value. This is
  • 99. very imperative today as Millennials begin to take over the corporate landscape. Per a 2014 article by Business Insider, CEO of Twilio, Jeff Lawson, discusses how Millennials enjoys consistent feedback (Smith, 2014). This generation is accustomed to quick gratification given the world of technology they were raised in, and the ample feedback provided allows them to keep tabs on their performance so there aren’t any surprises (Smith, 2014). Combining that with an Affiliative leader who will communicate nothing but positive and encouraging remarks, the motivational level with employees will soar. Affiliative Negatives While this leadership style is very effective at building a
  • 100. positive work environment and group culture, there are some downfalls when this style is over utilized. Since Affiliative leaders predominately remain constructive in the feedback they provide, under-performing workers tend to go unrecognized, which thereafter, fosters mediocrity. These deficient workers will start to become content with their performance, as affiliative leaders leave these issues unaddressed, and indirectly, their poor output is condoned (Money-zine n.d.). Deficient workers lack the clear direction that is needed in order to course-correct, thus they must rely on themselves in order to improve their performance. This can lead to an overall drag on the group’s performance, cause a disruption in the harmony, and ultimately lead to failure.
  • 101. Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 32 The affiliative leadership style should mainly be reserved when building a team together to create a harmonious balance and positive chemistry amongst members. This style is ideal when there is a lack of communication or when trusts needs to be mended. Leaders who rely on this style will run eventually into issues with meeting overall performance targets since it focuses on the mental and emotional health of the group. In order to appropriately sustain a healthy and productive team, it is suggested that this style be combined with other styles, such as the authoritative
  • 102. leadership style (Leadership That Gets Results, 2000). An authoritative leader will establish clear direction in order to maintain goals, and help workers understand their role in helping the organization meet its objectives. With appropriate execution on combining the affiliative and authoritative leadership styles, the stage is set for establishing an environment of committed and driven workers producing outsized performance (Smith, 2014). Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 33 Affiliative Example
  • 103. A classic example of an affiliative leader is the ex-manager of the New York Yankees, Joe Torre. As manager for such a prominent team in baseball, Joe Torre had many ego-centric players to manage. Through all of this Joe Torre managed to hold the team together while building a sense of harmony among the teammates (Money-zine, n.d.). Joe Torre would recognize the contributions of individual players and express his gratitude for them. This method of leading created an overall cohesiveness that allowed the Yankees to be as successful as they were (Money-zine, 2014). Affiliative Summary This leadership style is one that relies on emotions of the
  • 104. individual, rather than task. The affiliative leader strives to keep their employees happy and create harmony among them (Money- zine, 2014). This style focuses on the culture of the group in order to create unity. Although this style of leading seems ideal, the lack of constructive criticism for the employees can lead to poor performance and project failure. Literature Review Most cited definitions of emotional intelligence can be found in (Salovey, 1989). More modern and refined versions can be found at (Mayer, 1999) and (Salovey, 2001). The literature on the effect of Emotional Intelligence on leadership styles is vast; however, an interpretation of the term itself is manifold. The early interpretation of emotional
  • 105. style can be found in (Avolio, 1991) and (Popper, 1994), these papers start to identify values of emotional intelligence, but do not assign a separate school of leadership to it, rather, it is considered an important but subsidiary aspect of Visionary or Charismatic School of Leadership. They focus more on influencing the emotions and behavior, rather than on understanding them. The seminal publication that birthed a new school of Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 34 leadership solely based on emotional intelligence was (Goleman, 1998). (Goleman, 1998) and
  • 106. (Cooper, 1998), together popularized and identified emotional intelligence as a leadership competency, and defined its dimensions and styles. Further publications like (Goleman, 2002) presented a detailed analysis of sub-styles within the emotional school and established emotional intelligence as a critical leadership competency separate from cognitive and social intelligence. The pioneer proponent of this school is Daniel Goleman, who has published numerous papers and books; his most recent being (Goleman, 2013). Conclusion Attempts have been made to identify various competencies that define a successful leader. Authors have identified these as cognitive, behavioral, emotional, and motivational (Dulewicz, 2003) but has been shown that emotional competence accounts for 36% of
  • 107. the leadership performance (Dulewicz, 2000) greatest amongst all competencies. Literature, lists numerous schools of leadership, but its clear emotional intelligence finds relevance in each of them (Turner, 2005). From a project viewpoint with fixed start and end dates, project managers often tend to be more task oriented than people oriented, which may hamper the leadership role (Turner, 2005). This division was propounded by the contingency school of leadership (Turner, 2005) and, emotional competence in a leader is crucial to bridge this gap. Another factor is the global nature of projects in modern times. Increasingly remote teams are being used and a leader has to be competent enough to identify, cope up with, and even utilize
  • 108. the cultural and lingual differences. Literature has identified personality traits for coping with the cultural differences (Selmer 2002), and they heavily involve social awareness and relationship management dimensions from which the emotional competencies arise. The emergence of agile project management and self-organizing and managed teams in recent years has presented a new situational analysis of leadership styles. Leaders do emerge in Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 35 such teams, either formally and informally, even if no leadership need has been defined. Again, an
  • 109. emotional competency of empathy in this case has been found to play a significant role and influence task focused and socio-emotional goals (Wolff, 2002). While emotional dimensions have been largely nebulous and debated aspects of leadership, through theory and examples in this paper, we have tried to define emotional competencies that underlie the leadership styles and predict which style will be appropriate in relevant phases of the project. However there is an unanimous agreement that leadership always lies in the situation. This can demand dynamic shuffling of the various competencies for a leader to emerge successfully. Acknowledgement We are grateful for the encouragement and mentorship of Dr. Victor Sohmen, Project
  • 110. Management Program, Drexel University, and for his useful comments and editorial guidance in this paper. Journal of IT and Economic Development 6(1), 16-40, April 2015 36 References Affiliative Leaders. (n.d.). Retrieved March 12, 2015, from http://www.money-zine.com/career- development/leadership-skill/affiliative-leaders/ Avolio, B. J., Waldman, D. A., & Yammarino, F. J. (1991). Leading in the 1990s: The Four I's of
  • 111. Transformational Leadership. Journal of European Industrial Training, 15(4). Bass, B. M. (1960). Leadership, Psychology, and Organizational Behavior. Childs, R. (2004). Emotional Intelligence and Leadership. Retrieved March 12, 2015, from Team Technology: http://www.team- technology.co.uk/emotional-intelligence.html Comindwork Weekly / Work Productivity Tricks The Six Leadership Styles (Goleman). (n.d.). Retrieved March 11, 2015, from http://www.comindwork.com/weekly/2013-08- 12/productivity/the-six-leadership-styles-goleman Coaching Leadership. (2006). Retrieved March 11, 2015, from http://www.money zine.com/career-development/leadership-skill/coaching- leadership/ Coercive Leadership. (2014). Retrieved March 10, 2015, from
  • 112. money-zine.com: http://www.money-zine.com/career-development/leadership- skill/coercive-leadership/ Cooper, R. K., & Sawaf, A. (1998). Executive EQ: Emotional Intelligence in Leadership and Organizations. Penguin. Cosmato, D. (2011, July 30). Are Democratic Leaders Effective in Large Companies? Retrieved March 10, 2015, from Bright Project Management: http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are- democratic-leaders- effective-in-large-companies/ Democratic Leadership Style. (2013). Retrieved March 10, 2015, from Defining Leadership: http://www.defining-leadership.com/democratic-leadership- style/ Dulewicz, V., & Higgs, M. (2000). Emotional Intelligence-A Review and Evaluation Study.
  • 113. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 15(4), 341-372. Fiedler, F. E. (1967). A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness Goleman, D. (1998). Working with Emotional Intelligence. Bantam. Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R., & McKee, A. (2013). Primal Leadership, With a New Preface by the Authors: Unleashing the Power of Emotional Intelligence. Harvard Business Press Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R. E., & McKee, A. (2002). The New Leaders: Transforming the Art of Leadership into the Science of Results. London: Little, Brown. http://www.team-technology.co.uk/emotional-intelligence.html http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are- democratic-leaders- http://www.brighthubpm.com/resource-management/75623-are- democratic-leaders- http://www.defining-leadership.com/democratic-leadership- style/