SlideShare a Scribd company logo
ChrisBenston
Geographyof the Polar Regions
A comparisonpaperonchangesofseabirdphenologyoccurringwithintheArctic and Antarctic.
I believethe phenologyof seabirdsisinfluencedbynumerousvariablesandissubjectto changescaused
by variation in environmentalfactors,suchasthe physicallocationandthespeciesof the seabird.Thephenologyof
seabirdswillvary basedon if the birds live in the Arctic or the Antarctic regions,as each individual speciesresponds
differently to climatechange.
Thematerialsandmethodswhichwillbeutilizedfor this paperare the examinationofdata from previously
conductedstudiesintheArctic andthe Antarctic. Thedatafor the Antarctic study relates to changesinthe phenology
of seabirdsand the relationship toclimatechange.Thedatasetfor the Arctic study examineschangesinthe
hydrology of highArctic lakes causedbysalt water intrusion.At first glance,theconnectionsbetweenthesetwo
subjectsmaynot bereadilyapparent.However, salt waterintrusionis the biggestthreat to Arctic seabirdsresidingin
proximityto the Atlantic Ocean. However,there maybe other threats to the survival of seabirds withinthe Arctic
regions,sincethe distribution,migrationpatternsandbreedingpatternsof several speciesof theseArctic seabirdsis
not widelyunderstoodit is difficultto ascertainhowclimatechange will effectthesebirds.
A total of 64 marinebirdspeciesareclassified asArctic species,20 of the 64 birdspeciesare classifiedas
circumpolar.Thismaymeantwothingsthese birdseither spendpart of the year living in Arctic waters or their
breedinggroundsarelocatedinthe Arctic regions.Circumpolarseabirdscanbeobservedbothbreedingandliving in
the Pacific and Atlantic oceans.Fourteenofthese circumpolarseabirdspecieshavebreedinggroundsin the Atlantic
Oceanandtwenty-oneof these circumpolarseabirdspecieshavebreedinggroundsinthe Pacific Ocean.Themost
commonlyobservedArctic seabirdspeciesin the Atlantic Oceanarethe Dovekies. TheDovekiesareflexiblein
regardsto theirdiets andforagingskills, as a result climatechangeishavinglittle to no effect ontheir population
dynamics.Unlikeotherspeciesof seabirdsthe breedingpopulationis notdecliningasthe climatechanges,this is
partiallydueto theirflexibilitywhenit comestotheir dietsand foragingbehaviors.TheCommonandThick-billed
Murresare seeingfluctuationsinpopulationdynamicsonashort term basis.1
Thesechangesinpopulationdynamicsaredueto changesinthe seasurface temperature(SST)andthe
sea iceextent. These changesobservedinpopulationdynamicsaresynchronouswithineachbasin.Theseobserved
changesinpopulationdynamics willalternatebetweenthe Atlantic and Pacific Oceans.Themigrationpatternsof
these seabirdsworksto assist with the transport of nutrientsto their breedinggrounds.However,the seabirdsmay
alsotransport contaminatessuchasmercuryto their breedinggrounds.1
In the past decades,a significantwarming trendhasbeenfound to be occurringwithintheArctic Region.
Arctic seabirdbehavior, phenology,diets, physiology, rates of foragingand survival are foundto changeinresponse
to these drastic warmingevents. ThebiggestissuefacingArctic seabirdsinthe Atlantic Oceanisthe loss of habitat
causedbyclimatechangeand thesewarmingevents. As a result of the changingclimatemanyfreshwaterhabitats
are becomingmoresaline.These observedincreasesinsalinityis caused byincreased influxesofsalinewater
causedbythe retreatingglacialice.Thissalinewaterhasincreasedlevelsofsalinity andhighertemperatures,when
comparedto thefreshwater it is displacing. Theincreasedlevelsof salinityin the Atlantic OceannearGreenlandis
having detrimental effectson the copepods
Additionalresearchhasshownseabirdsbreedinginthe Arctic are subjectto additionalchallengescaused
by climatechange.Manyof these challengesarenotuniform andtend to be speciesspecific.Suchaswith the Black
–leggedKittiwakeswhichspendthewintersin the moresouthernregionsof the Arctic. As a resultof this the Black-
leggedKittiwakesare beingexposedto increasinglevelsofharmfulhumanbasedactivitiessuchasbycatchfrom
fishingnets and oilspills.TheDovekiesare the most abundantspeciesofseabirdslocatedintheArctic portionof the
Atlantic Ocean.Thisspeciesofseabirdneston rockyslopes, uponexaminationofthe datacollectedfrom 1963to
2008a distincttrend wasobserved. Thisdatashowed anearliermedianbreedingandhatchdatesforthis speciesof
1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky. "Seabirds." ArcticReportCard.11 Nov. 2012.Web. 6Dec. 2015
bird. Themostplausibletheoryof whythis is taking placewouldbethe snowis meltingearlier,whichmeansearlier
availabilityof potentialnestingsites. 1
Theresearchshowstheoppositeis true for the Black-leggedKittiwakes,thesespeciesofseabirdsare
showinga minortrendtowardsbreedinglater.Thepotentialcausesforthis is decreasesinamount of prey
availability. Thesedecreased amountsofprey are dueto the elevated seasurfacetemperatures(SST)and the
decreasedamountsofsea ice.Within the Arctic regionscopepodsare akey componentofthe food webfor seabirds,
the increasedinflowsofsalinewater combined withwarmerwatertemperaturesareleadingtosmallersized
copepods.Thesechangesin thewater chemistryleadsto seabirdsforagingon smallerspeciesofcopepodsand
traveling longerdistancestoobtaintheir prey. Little to no long-term monitoringhasoccurredfor thesechangesinthe
populationdynamicscurrentlybeingseenamongtheArctic seabirds, thereforeis difficultto determinewhateffects
climatechangewillhaveon Arctic seabirds.However long-term monitoringdataexistsfor two Arctic seabirdspecies,
the CommonandtheThick-billedMurre.Thesespeciesofbirdshave abundantpopulationsandarespread
throughoutthe entireArctic region.The datashowedthat the Thick–billedMurre’sbreedingcoloniesincreasedin
size whenthe sea surfacetemperature orSST increasedslightly.However, the oppositeis true for the Common
Murre,the data showedslightdecreasesinthe sea surfacetemperatureorSST islinked to increasedsizesof the
breedingcolonies. Thedatashowsextremechangesinthesea surface temperature(SST)ineitherdirectionwill
negatively influence thepopulationsizesof both species.Another sideeffect of this decreasedicecoveragecaused
by glacialretreatis the increasedpotential forcontamination.1
Thedecreasedlevelsoficecoveragecausedbyglacialretreathasfar reachingconsequencesforthese
Arctic ecosystems. Thedecreasedamountsoficecoverage areleadingto biggerwaves whichcanreachfurther
inland.As a result of this more salinewater is being increasinglypushed intothe deltas of freshwaterrivers. Someof
the consequencesofthisare increasederosionamongthe shoreline,transformationanddestructionoffreshwater
ecosystemsdueto this intrusion of salinewater. A recentlyconductedstudyshowedafter surveying forty milesof
1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky."Seabirds." Arctic Report Card. 11Nov.2012. Web. 6 Dec.2011
shorelinean average of 6.8 metersretreating shorelinewasdocumented.Theseextremechangesarecausedby
manyvariableswhichincludeincreasedlandexposuretostorms, decreasedicecoverageandincreasedlevelsof
meltingpermafrostwhichleadstoincreasedlevelsof coastalerosion.Theincreasedlevelsofsalinewater have the
abilityto negatively affect freshwaterecosystems. Theincreasedlevelsof salt water intrusion have the abilityto alter
andinfluencethefood web. In addition,the changesinsalinitymayleadto freshwater speciesofseabirdsbeing
outcompetedbyspeciesof seabirdswhich thrivein salineenvironments.In extremecasesthe environmentmay
becomeanoxic,whichwill turnthelakeinto a deadzone devoid of mostlife forms.2
As with the Arctic seabirdphenologyinthe Antarctic is beinginfluencedbythe changingclimaticconditions
as well. Therearenumerousvariableswhichaffectthephenologyseabirdsin the Antarctic whichdonot exist within
the Arctic regions. Thepresenceofnon-flyingseabirdsinthe Antarctic is a majorfactorwhich tendsto influencethe
phenologyof seabirds.As with the Arctic changesinseabirdphenologyistied to decreasedamountsofprey. The
flying seabirdshave the abilityto fly longerdistancesinorderto forage for food. However, the non-flying seabirds
have a limitedrange andcannottravel these longerdistancesinorderto forgefor food. Thismayexplain
discrepancybetweenthedata collectedonthe Arctic and Antarctic seabirds,sincenonon-flying speciesofseabirds
suchas penguinsresideinthe Arctic. As with the Arctic sea iceextent (SIE) andsea temperaturewillaffectthe
phenologyof seabirdpopulationsresidingintheAntarctic. Thelackofprey for seabirdsis a majorproblem forthese
birds, the lackof prey is tied to delays in migrationandmolting.Forthesereasonsseabirdstendto delaythese
activitiessincethey requireextensive amountsof energyandwhichmeansaplentifulfood supplyis required.
Researchhasfoundthat changesinthese activitieswillcauseseabirdsto changetheirbreedingschedules.The
biggestdifferenceamongArctic andAntarctic seabirdswerethey live and breed.TheArctic seabirdspeciestendto
live and breedin freshwaterlakes. TheAntarctic seabirdstendto live andbreedon the continentaliceshelf.These
2
Struzik, Ed. "As Arctic Sea IceRetreats, Storms TakeTollon theLand." ByEd Struzik: Yale Environment360.6 June2011. Web. 8 Dec.2015.
<http://e360.yale.edu/feature/as_arctic_sea_ice_retreats_storms_take_toll_on_the_land/2412/>.
facts mayhelpto explainthe variation amongonhowclimateisinfluencingseabirdsinboththe Arctic and
Antarctic.3,4
As the with Arctic, the sea surfacetemperatureisinfluencingseabirdpopulationsintheAntarctic. Any
changesinthe seasurfacetemperaturewillleadto changesinseabirdphenology. Thebiggestproblem causedby
this it puts the seabirdsout of sync with theirsourcesof prey.4 Another factor whichcouldexplainthe differences
amongtheAntarctic and Arctic seabirdsis phenotype plasticity.Phenotype plasticitycanbedefinedas when
different types of phenotypes with the sameof genotype reactdifferentlybasedon the environmentalconditions.
Phenotype plasticityis influencedbythe locationandvariationdifferent speciesofseabirds.Thiscouldexplain
differencesinphenologywhichareseenamongtheArctic andAntarctic seabirds.5 However, the biggestinfluences
of seabirdphenologyare the life spansandreproductiverates of thesebirds. Seabirdswith lowerreproductivetend
to breed onlyin optimalconditions,asdothe seabirdswitha longerlifespan. And seabirdswith shorter lifespansand
highreproductive rates of are knownto breed in less than optimalbreedingconditions.Thechartsseenbelowarea
comparisonofseabirdsliving the in Arctic and the Antarctic.As one canseethere are manyspeciesbirdsfoundin
the Arctic whicharenotin the Antarctic. Thesamecanbesaidfor the seabirdsliving inthe Antarctic. Thedata
presentedin thesechartsprovides strong evidenceof phenotype plasticityoccurringwithinboththeArctic and
3,4 Constable, Andrew J., Jessica Melbourne-Thomas, Stuart P. Corney, Kevin R. Arrigo,ChristopheBarbraud,David K.A. Barnes, NathanielL.
Bindoff, Philip W. Boyd, Angelika Brandt,DanielP. Costa,Andrew T. Davidson, Hugh W.Ducklow, LouiseEmmerson, MitsuoFukuchi, Julian Gutt,
Mark A. Hindell, Eileen E. Hofmann, Graham W.Hosie, Takahiro Iida,Sarah Jacob, NadineM. Johnston, SoKawaguchi, Nobuo Kokubun, Philippe
Koubbi, Mary-AnneLea, AzwianewiMakhado,Rob A. Massom, Klaus Meiners, MichaelP. Meredith,EugeneJ. Murphy, Stephen Nicol,Keith Reid,
KateRicherson, Martin J. Riddle, Stephen R. Rintoul, Walker O. Smith, Colin Southwell, JonathonS. Stark, MichaelSumner, KerrieM. Swadling,
Kunio T. Takahashi, PhilN. Trathan, Dirk C. Welsford, HenriWeimerskirch,Karen J. Westwood,Barbara C.Wienecke, Dieter Wolf-Gladrow, Simon
W. Wright, JoseC. Xavier, and PhilippeZiegler. "ClimateChangeand Southern OceanEcosystems I: HowChanges in PhysicalHabitats Directly
Affect MarineBiota." Glob Change BiolGlobalChange Biology 20.10(2014): 3004-025. Web. 10Oct.2015
Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climateas a Driver of PhenologicalChangein Southern Seabirds." IntJ
BiometeorolInternationalJournalof Biometeorology 58.4(2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015.
4
Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climateas a Driver of PhenologicalChangein Southern Seabirds." IntJ
BiometeorolInternationalJournalof Biometeorology 58.4(2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015.
5 Grémillet, David, and AnneCharmantier. "Shifts in Phenotypic Plasticity Constrain theValueof Seabirds as EcologicalIndicators of Marine
Ecosystems." EcologicalApplications 20.6(2010): 1498-503. October 5,2015.
Antarctic regions.(see chart1 and 2 for moreinformation.) Charts3 and4 show the variableswhichinfluencethe
breedingphenologyoftwo speciesofAntarctic Seabirdsthe EmperorpenguinandtheSnow petrel.As onecansee
the Emperorpenguinpopulationswilldecreaseinresponsetolower levels of sea iceanddecreasesinthe air
temperatureduringthespringmonths.Thedatafor the Snowpetrels showschangesinthe populationsdynamics
occurringifthesea iceextent wereto decreaseinsize. In addition,changesinthepopulationdynamics ofSnow
Petrels were observed if any of the followingchangesoccurreddecreasesintheair temperatureorthe southern
oscillation index.6,7 Thisproves the variablesinfluencingseabirdphenologytendsto vary greatlyboth in the Artic
andthe Antarctic regions.Thefinalset of chartsyou are seeingare the comparisonofconductivitymeasurements
taken from a highArctic lakefrom the years 1968 and2006.(See chartsnumber5 and6.) Thedatapresentedin
these chartsindicatescertainlayersof the lake arebecomingmoresalinewhileotherlayersare becomingless
saline.It is impossibletoget a baselinebycomparingthe1968and2006sets of data sincemanyof the variables
whichwereexaminedin2006werenotexaminedin1968.8 Basedon the data in this paper wecanconcludethat
climatechangeishaving adverse effects on seabirdpopulationsbothinthe Arctic andAntarctic regions.However,
sincechangesinseabird phenologyis highlyvariableandinfluencedbyspeciesandlocationitisimpossibleto
determinehoweachspecieswillreacttoclimatechange. Beforeany conclusionsonhowclimatechangeis
influencingthephenologyof seabirdson globalscalecan bemade furtherresearchisnecessaryand a long-term
monitoringprogram shouldbeestablishedbeforecomingtoanyconclusions.
6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud, and HenriWeimerskirch."Long-Term Contrasted Responses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird
Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015.
7 Jenouvrier, S., H. Weimerskirch, C. Barbraud,Y.-H. Park, andB. Cazelles. "Evidenceof a Shift in theCyclicity of Antarctic Seabird Dynamics Linked
to Climate." Proceedings of the RoyalSociety B: BiologicalSciences 272.1566(2005): 887-95. October 5, 2015.
8
Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical
Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print.
Antarctic
Seabirds
Adelie Penguins
AfricanPenguins
Antarctic Petrel
Antarctic petrel
Antarctic Prion
Antarctic prion
Antarctic Seabirds
Antarctic shag
Antarctic Skua
Antarctic tern
Black -belliedStorm Petrel
Black-browned Albatross
Blue Petrel
Broad -billedprion
Brown Skua
Brush-tailedPenguin
Cape Petrels
Chin-strap Penguin
Common diving Petrel
Diving Petrel
Emperor Penguin
FairyPrion
FiordlandPenguin
Fulmar prion
Galapagos Penguins
Gentoo Penguin
Graybacked- Storm Petrel
GrayDuck
Grayheaded Albatross
Graypetrel
Great Shearwater
Great -wingedpetrel
Grey-headed albatross
Humboldt Penguin
Imperial Shag
Kelp Gulls
Kerguelenpetrel
Kerguelenpintail
Kerguelenshag
Kerguelentern
King Penguin
Lesser-shealthbill
Light-mantledsooty albatross
Little Penguin
Little Shearwater
Mottled petrel
Narrow-billedPrion
Northern Giant Petrel
Rockhopper Penguin
Royal Penguin
Royal Albatross
Snow petrel
Snowy-sheathbill
Soft-plumagedpetrel
Sooty Albatross
Sooty Shearwater
South Georgia diving petrel
Southern Fulmars
Southern Giant Petrel
South-polar Skua
Speckled Teal
Wandering albatross
White -capped Albatross
White -chinned petrel
White- faced Storm Petrel
White facedAlbatross
White-cappedalbatross
White-headed petrel
Wilson's Storm Petrel
Yellownose Albatross
Yellow-billedPintail
Yellow-eyedPenguins
Yellow-nosedalbatross
Chart 1
9 McGonigal, David, and Lynn Woodworth. The Complete
Encyclopedia Antarcticaand the Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.:
Firefly, 2001. Print
Arctic Seabirds
Arctic Redpoll
Arctic Seabirds
Arctic Tern
Atlantic Puffins
Blacked -leggedKittiwake
Common Guillemots
Common Murre
Common Redpoll
Glaucous Gull
Horned Puffins
Ivory Gull
LaplandBunting
Long-tailed Skua
Northern Fulmar
Northern Gannets
Razor Gills
Red -Throated Divers
Red-necked Phalarope
Snow Bunting
Thick -billedMurres
TuftedPuffins
Chart 2
10
10 McGonigal, David, and LynnWoodworth. The Complete Encyclopedia Antarctica andthe Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.: Firefly, 2001. Print.
Chart 36
6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud, andHenriWeimerskirch. "Long-Term ContrastedResponses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird
Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
The breeding of Emperior Penguins and The Associated
Environmental Variables
Emperor Penguin So ( Survival during
the first year at sea)
Emperor Penguin BS (Breeding Success)
Emperor Penguin N(number of breeding
pairs)
Emperor Penguin Pb( Proportion of
breeders)
Emperor Penguin Pb+6 (Proportion of
birds attempting to bird for first time)
Chart 46
6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud,and HenriWeimerskirch."Long-Term Contrasted Responses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird
Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015
-1
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
The Breeding of Snow Petrels and The Associated Environmental Variables
Snow Petrel So ( Survival during the first year at sea)
Snow Petrel BS (Breeding Success)
Snow Petrel N(number of breeding pairs)
Snow Petrel Pb( Proportion of breeders)
Snow Petrel Pb+6 (Proportion of birds attempting to bird for first time)
Chart 58
Chart 68
8
Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical
Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print.
8
Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical
Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print.
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
Mixolimnion Monimolimnion Kongressvatn
springs
Outflow
Conductivity
(us cm-1 25 at Degrees Celsius 1968)
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
Conductivity(us cm-1 25 at Degrees Celsius
2006)
Bibliography
Holm, Trine Marianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, Anne Hormes, Dag Klaveness, and Roland
Psenner. "Rapid Physicochemical Changes in the High Arctic Lake Kongressvatn Caused by Recent Climate Change." Aquatic
Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print.
Jenouvrier, Stephanie, Christophe Barbraud, and Henri Weimerskirch. "Long-Term Contrasted Responses to Climate of Two
Antarctic Seabird Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5, 2015
McGonigal, David, and Lynn Woodworth. The Complete Encyclopedia Antarctica and the Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.: Firefly, 2001.
Print.
Jenouvrier, S., H. Weimerskirch, C. Barbraud, Y.-H. Park, and B. Cazelles. "Evidence of a Shift in the Cyclicity of Antarctic
Seabird Dynamics Linked to Climate." Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 272.1566 (2005): 887-
95. October 5, 2015.
Grémillet, David, and Anne Charmantier. "Shifts in Phenotypic Plasticity Constrain the Value of Seabirds as Ecological Indicators
of Marine Ecosystems." Ecological Applications 20.6 (2010): 1498-503. October 5, 2015.
Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climate as a Driver of Phenological Change in
Southern Seabirds." Int J Biometeorol International Journal of Biometeorology 58.4 (2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015.
Constable, Andrew J., Jessica Melbourne-Thomas, Stuart P. Corney, Kevin R. Arrigo, Christophe Barbraud, David K. A. Barnes,
Nathaniel L. Bindoff, Philip W. Boyd, Angelika Brandt, Daniel P. Costa, Andrew T. Davidson, Hugh W. Ducklow, Louise
Emmerson, Mitsuo Fukuchi, Julian Gutt, Mark A. Hindell, Eileen E. Hofmann, Graham W. Hosie, Takahiro Iida, Sarah Jacob,
Nadine M. Johnston, So Kawaguchi, Nobuo Kokubun, Philippe Koubbi, Mary-Anne Lea, Azwianewi Makhado, Rob A. Massom,
Klaus Meiners, Michael P. Meredith, Eugene J. Murphy, Stephen Nicol, Keith Reid, Kate Richerson, Martin J. Riddle, Stephen R.
Rintoul, Walker O. Smith, Colin Southwell, Jonathon S. Stark, Michael Sumner, Kerrie M. Swadling, Kunio T. Takahashi, Phil N.
Trathan, Dirk C. Welsford, Henri Weimerskirch, Karen J. Westwood, Barbara C. Wienecke, Dieter Wolf-Gladrow, Simon W.
Wright, Jose C. Xavier, and Philippe Ziegler. "Climate Change and Southern Ocean Ecosystems I: How Changes in Physical
Habitats Directly Affect Marine Biota." Glob Change Biol Global Change Biology 20.10 (2014): 3004-025. Web. 10 Oct. 2015
Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climate as a Driver of Phenological Change in
Southern Seabirds." Int J Biometeorol International Journal of Biometeorology 58.4 (2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015.
Struzik, Ed. "As Arctic Sea Ice Retreats, Storms Take Toll on the Land." By Ed Struzik: Yale Environment 360. 6 June 2011.
Web. 8 Dec. 2015. <http://e360.yale.edu/feature/as_arctic_sea_ice_retreats_storms_take_toll_on_the_land/2412/>.
1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky. "Seabirds." Arctic Report Card. 11 Nov. 2012. Web. 6 Dec. 2015

More Related Content

What's hot

freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animalsfreshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
Mariyam Nazeer Agha
 
Quick notes on our environment
Quick notes on our environmentQuick notes on our environment
Quick notes on our environment
komalranawat
 
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave newMarty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
Loretta Roberson
 
Term Paper1
Term Paper1Term Paper1
Term Paper1
Kyle Runion
 
11co36 & 11 co41
11co36 & 11 co4111co36 & 11 co41
11co36 & 11 co41
pareshpanshikar
 
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated InfestationEAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
Northern Institute of Applied Climate Science
 
Eops 2015 1_28
Eops 2015 1_28Eops 2015 1_28
Eops 2015 1_28
Christopher Krembs
 
Grimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo SalvageGrimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo Salvage
Lenny Grimaldo
 
Eops 2014 09_16
Eops 2014 09_16Eops 2014 09_16
Eops 2014 09_16
Christopher Krembs
 
042009 W S1 Input Coastal Communities
042009  W S1 Input  Coastal Communities042009  W S1 Input  Coastal Communities
042009 W S1 Input Coastal Communities
lisa.ito
 
Sea exploration
Sea explorationSea exploration
Sea exploration
Clube do Ambiente
 
Eops 2017 8_28
Eops 2017 8_28Eops 2017 8_28
Eops 2017 8_28
EOPS EOPS
 
Water quality & fisheries
Water quality & fisheriesWater quality & fisheries
Water quality & fisheries
An Taisce
 
Freshwater ecosystems
Freshwater ecosystemsFreshwater ecosystems
Freshwater ecosystems
David Rowel
 
Coral Reefs
Coral ReefsCoral Reefs
Coral Reefs
ironerika001
 
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water PollutionEarth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
mariscotes
 
Wetland ecosystem
Wetland ecosystemWetland ecosystem
Ecosystems and biomes keaton huffman
Ecosystems and biomes        keaton huffmanEcosystems and biomes        keaton huffman
Ecosystems and biomes keaton huffman
Seneca Highlands Intermediate Unit 9
 

What's hot (18)

freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animalsfreshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
freshwater habitat with ecological classification of freshwater animals
 
Quick notes on our environment
Quick notes on our environmentQuick notes on our environment
Quick notes on our environment
 
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave newMarty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
Marty 2013 ecological extinction and evolution in the brave new
 
Term Paper1
Term Paper1Term Paper1
Term Paper1
 
11co36 & 11 co41
11co36 & 11 co4111co36 & 11 co41
11co36 & 11 co41
 
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated InfestationEAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
EAB in Black Ash Wetlands: Impacts and Lessons from a Simulated Infestation
 
Eops 2015 1_28
Eops 2015 1_28Eops 2015 1_28
Eops 2015 1_28
 
Grimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo SalvageGrimaldo Salvage
Grimaldo Salvage
 
Eops 2014 09_16
Eops 2014 09_16Eops 2014 09_16
Eops 2014 09_16
 
042009 W S1 Input Coastal Communities
042009  W S1 Input  Coastal Communities042009  W S1 Input  Coastal Communities
042009 W S1 Input Coastal Communities
 
Sea exploration
Sea explorationSea exploration
Sea exploration
 
Eops 2017 8_28
Eops 2017 8_28Eops 2017 8_28
Eops 2017 8_28
 
Water quality & fisheries
Water quality & fisheriesWater quality & fisheries
Water quality & fisheries
 
Freshwater ecosystems
Freshwater ecosystemsFreshwater ecosystems
Freshwater ecosystems
 
Coral Reefs
Coral ReefsCoral Reefs
Coral Reefs
 
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water PollutionEarth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
Earth's Hydrosphere and Water Pollution
 
Wetland ecosystem
Wetland ecosystemWetland ecosystem
Wetland ecosystem
 
Ecosystems and biomes keaton huffman
Ecosystems and biomes        keaton huffmanEcosystems and biomes        keaton huffman
Ecosystems and biomes keaton huffman
 

Viewers also liked

Dr_Genin Letter of Recommendation
Dr_Genin Letter of RecommendationDr_Genin Letter of Recommendation
Dr_Genin Letter of RecommendationJohn Welby
 
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentation
Adam Chard
 
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
Patrick Elliott
 
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Travis Jansen Honours Thesis
Travis Jansen Honours ThesisTravis Jansen Honours Thesis
Travis Jansen Honours Thesis
Travis Jansen
 
FHElliott Resume
FHElliott ResumeFHElliott Resume
FHElliott Resume
Farah Elliott
 
RESUME2015
RESUME2015RESUME2015
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
Jhonny Antelo Films
 
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdfKonjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
unn | UNITED NEWS NETWORK GmbH
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Dr_Genin Letter of Recommendation
Dr_Genin Letter of RecommendationDr_Genin Letter of Recommendation
Dr_Genin Letter of Recommendation
 
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
Viva el Jeneral Melgarejo. 1865.
 
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
Francis Burdett O'Connor: Independencia Americana. 1875
 
Untitled Presentation
Untitled PresentationUntitled Presentation
Untitled Presentation
 
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
The race to capture experiential learning and competency based education (CBE)
 
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
Vicente Mariscal: Bolivia ante las demas naciones. 1868.
 
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
Ramón Sotomayor Valdéz: Campaña del ejército chileno contra la Confederación ...
 
Travis Jansen Honours Thesis
Travis Jansen Honours ThesisTravis Jansen Honours Thesis
Travis Jansen Honours Thesis
 
FHElliott Resume
FHElliott ResumeFHElliott Resume
FHElliott Resume
 
RESUME2015
RESUME2015RESUME2015
RESUME2015
 
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
José María Echenique Gandarillas: El tratado secreto de 1873 entre Perú y Bol...
 
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
Roberto Querejazu Calvo: Aclaraciones historicas sobre la guerra del pacifico...
 
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
Agustín Aspiazu: El dia magno de La Paz. 1871.
 
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdfKonjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
Konjunkturbericht III 2011.pdf
 

Similar to Arctic vs Antarctic comparison paper

Models on climate change.pptx
Models on climate change.pptxModels on climate change.pptx
Models on climate change.pptx
AbhishekGautam802614
 
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change, Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change,  Fisherfolks, and the Coastal CommunityIRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change,  Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change, Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
meih
 
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
Shayantika Mazumdar
 
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and ClimateThe Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
chris benston
 
ocean role in climate change
ocean role in climate changeocean role in climate change
ocean role in climate change
home
 
Estuaries as marine ecosytems
Estuaries as  marine  ecosytemsEstuaries as  marine  ecosytems
Estuaries as marine ecosytems
Prof. A.Balasubramanian
 
Estuaries ecosystem
Estuaries ecosystemEstuaries ecosystem
Estuaries ecosystem
RaviranjanKumar168
 
Effect of dam on biodiversity
Effect of dam on biodiversityEffect of dam on biodiversity
Effect of dam on biodiversity
renjith rk
 
Coral reefs BT
Coral reefs BTCoral reefs BT
Coral reefs BT
Lis Regula
 
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFSA2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
George Dumitrache
 
Climate change
Climate changeClimate change
Climate change
Batiirii RooCii
 
cakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasdcakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasd
HalfHuman1
 
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheriesClimate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
SWAGATIKA SAHOO
 
NWF Report: Swimming Upstream
NWF Report: Swimming UpstreamNWF Report: Swimming Upstream
NWF Report: Swimming Upstream
National Wildlife Federation
 
Ocean acidification
Ocean acidificationOcean acidification
Ocean acidification
Dewa Ayu Mery Agustin
 
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geoMarine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
tishya20221245
 
Charting Advances in Marine Science
Charting Advances in Marine ScienceCharting Advances in Marine Science
Charting Advances in Marine Science
SEOExp
 
Vinay ppt
Vinay pptVinay ppt
Vinay ppt
vinayak Thumbagi
 
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9 copy
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9   copyFrm 607 threats to coral reef b9   copy
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9 copy
B. BHASKAR
 
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fishScientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
Geir Ottersen, Institute of Marine Research, Norway
 

Similar to Arctic vs Antarctic comparison paper (20)

Models on climate change.pptx
Models on climate change.pptxModels on climate change.pptx
Models on climate change.pptx
 
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change, Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change,  Fisherfolks, and the Coastal CommunityIRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change,  Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
IRREVERSIBLE? Climate Change, Fisherfolks, and the Coastal Community
 
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
Genetic regulation on carbon sequestration by mollusks
 
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and ClimateThe Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
The Hydrology of high Arctic Lakes and Climate
 
ocean role in climate change
ocean role in climate changeocean role in climate change
ocean role in climate change
 
Estuaries as marine ecosytems
Estuaries as  marine  ecosytemsEstuaries as  marine  ecosytems
Estuaries as marine ecosytems
 
Estuaries ecosystem
Estuaries ecosystemEstuaries ecosystem
Estuaries ecosystem
 
Effect of dam on biodiversity
Effect of dam on biodiversityEffect of dam on biodiversity
Effect of dam on biodiversity
 
Coral reefs BT
Coral reefs BTCoral reefs BT
Coral reefs BT
 
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFSA2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
A2 CAMBRIDGE GEOGRAPHY: COASTAL ENVIRONMENTS - CORAL REEFS
 
Climate change
Climate changeClimate change
Climate change
 
cakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasdcakdmlasmdasd
cakdmlasmdasd
 
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheriesClimate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
Climate change ,adaptation and mitigation in fisheries
 
NWF Report: Swimming Upstream
NWF Report: Swimming UpstreamNWF Report: Swimming Upstream
NWF Report: Swimming Upstream
 
Ocean acidification
Ocean acidificationOcean acidification
Ocean acidification
 
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geoMarine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
Marine Ecosystem detailed explaination geo
 
Charting Advances in Marine Science
Charting Advances in Marine ScienceCharting Advances in Marine Science
Charting Advances in Marine Science
 
Vinay ppt
Vinay pptVinay ppt
Vinay ppt
 
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9 copy
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9   copyFrm 607 threats to coral reef b9   copy
Frm 607 threats to coral reef b9 copy
 
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fishScientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
Scientific talk on effects of climate variation and young fish
 

More from chris benston

arctic seabirds
arctic seabirdsarctic seabirds
arctic seabirds
chris benston
 
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
chris benston
 
Hydrology of High Arctic Lakes
Hydrology of High Arctic LakesHydrology of High Arctic Lakes
Hydrology of High Arctic Lakes
chris benston
 
academic statement
academic statementacademic statement
academic statement
chris benston
 
advanced research paper draft complete-3
advanced research paper draft complete-3advanced research paper draft complete-3
advanced research paper draft complete-3
chris benston
 
500BurntBridgeReport
500BurntBridgeReport500BurntBridgeReport
500BurntBridgeReport
chris benston
 

More from chris benston (6)

arctic seabirds
arctic seabirdsarctic seabirds
arctic seabirds
 
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
Changes in climate conditions affect the phenology of seabirds 2
 
Hydrology of High Arctic Lakes
Hydrology of High Arctic LakesHydrology of High Arctic Lakes
Hydrology of High Arctic Lakes
 
academic statement
academic statementacademic statement
academic statement
 
advanced research paper draft complete-3
advanced research paper draft complete-3advanced research paper draft complete-3
advanced research paper draft complete-3
 
500BurntBridgeReport
500BurntBridgeReport500BurntBridgeReport
500BurntBridgeReport
 

Arctic vs Antarctic comparison paper

  • 1. ChrisBenston Geographyof the Polar Regions A comparisonpaperonchangesofseabirdphenologyoccurringwithintheArctic and Antarctic. I believethe phenologyof seabirdsisinfluencedbynumerousvariablesandissubjectto changescaused by variation in environmentalfactors,suchasthe physicallocationandthespeciesof the seabird.Thephenologyof seabirdswillvary basedon if the birds live in the Arctic or the Antarctic regions,as each individual speciesresponds differently to climatechange. Thematerialsandmethodswhichwillbeutilizedfor this paperare the examinationofdata from previously conductedstudiesintheArctic andthe Antarctic. Thedatafor the Antarctic study relates to changesinthe phenology of seabirdsand the relationship toclimatechange.Thedatasetfor the Arctic study examineschangesinthe hydrology of highArctic lakes causedbysalt water intrusion.At first glance,theconnectionsbetweenthesetwo subjectsmaynot bereadilyapparent.However, salt waterintrusionis the biggestthreat to Arctic seabirdsresidingin proximityto the Atlantic Ocean. However,there maybe other threats to the survival of seabirds withinthe Arctic regions,sincethe distribution,migrationpatternsandbreedingpatternsof several speciesof theseArctic seabirdsis not widelyunderstoodit is difficultto ascertainhowclimatechange will effectthesebirds. A total of 64 marinebirdspeciesareclassified asArctic species,20 of the 64 birdspeciesare classifiedas circumpolar.Thismaymeantwothingsthese birdseither spendpart of the year living in Arctic waters or their breedinggroundsarelocatedinthe Arctic regions.Circumpolarseabirdscanbeobservedbothbreedingandliving in the Pacific and Atlantic oceans.Fourteenofthese circumpolarseabirdspecieshavebreedinggroundsin the Atlantic Oceanandtwenty-oneof these circumpolarseabirdspecieshavebreedinggroundsinthe Pacific Ocean.Themost commonlyobservedArctic seabirdspeciesin the Atlantic Oceanarethe Dovekies. TheDovekiesareflexiblein regardsto theirdiets andforagingskills, as a result climatechangeishavinglittle to no effect ontheir population dynamics.Unlikeotherspeciesof seabirdsthe breedingpopulationis notdecliningasthe climatechanges,this is
  • 2. partiallydueto theirflexibilitywhenit comestotheir dietsand foragingbehaviors.TheCommonandThick-billed Murresare seeingfluctuationsinpopulationdynamicsonashort term basis.1 Thesechangesinpopulationdynamicsaredueto changesinthe seasurface temperature(SST)andthe sea iceextent. These changesobservedinpopulationdynamicsaresynchronouswithineachbasin.Theseobserved changesinpopulationdynamics willalternatebetweenthe Atlantic and Pacific Oceans.Themigrationpatternsof these seabirdsworksto assist with the transport of nutrientsto their breedinggrounds.However,the seabirdsmay alsotransport contaminatessuchasmercuryto their breedinggrounds.1 In the past decades,a significantwarming trendhasbeenfound to be occurringwithintheArctic Region. Arctic seabirdbehavior, phenology,diets, physiology, rates of foragingand survival are foundto changeinresponse to these drastic warmingevents. ThebiggestissuefacingArctic seabirdsinthe Atlantic Oceanisthe loss of habitat causedbyclimatechangeand thesewarmingevents. As a result of the changingclimatemanyfreshwaterhabitats are becomingmoresaline.These observedincreasesinsalinityis caused byincreased influxesofsalinewater causedbythe retreatingglacialice.Thissalinewaterhasincreasedlevelsofsalinity andhighertemperatures,when comparedto thefreshwater it is displacing. Theincreasedlevelsof salinityin the Atlantic OceannearGreenlandis having detrimental effectson the copepods Additionalresearchhasshownseabirdsbreedinginthe Arctic are subjectto additionalchallengescaused by climatechange.Manyof these challengesarenotuniform andtend to be speciesspecific.Suchaswith the Black –leggedKittiwakeswhichspendthewintersin the moresouthernregionsof the Arctic. As a resultof this the Black- leggedKittiwakesare beingexposedto increasinglevelsofharmfulhumanbasedactivitiessuchasbycatchfrom fishingnets and oilspills.TheDovekiesare the most abundantspeciesofseabirdslocatedintheArctic portionof the Atlantic Ocean.Thisspeciesofseabirdneston rockyslopes, uponexaminationofthe datacollectedfrom 1963to 2008a distincttrend wasobserved. Thisdatashowed anearliermedianbreedingandhatchdatesforthis speciesof 1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky. "Seabirds." ArcticReportCard.11 Nov. 2012.Web. 6Dec. 2015
  • 3. bird. Themostplausibletheoryof whythis is taking placewouldbethe snowis meltingearlier,whichmeansearlier availabilityof potentialnestingsites. 1 Theresearchshowstheoppositeis true for the Black-leggedKittiwakes,thesespeciesofseabirdsare showinga minortrendtowardsbreedinglater.Thepotentialcausesforthis is decreasesinamount of prey availability. Thesedecreased amountsofprey are dueto the elevated seasurfacetemperatures(SST)and the decreasedamountsofsea ice.Within the Arctic regionscopepodsare akey componentofthe food webfor seabirds, the increasedinflowsofsalinewater combined withwarmerwatertemperaturesareleadingtosmallersized copepods.Thesechangesin thewater chemistryleadsto seabirdsforagingon smallerspeciesofcopepodsand traveling longerdistancestoobtaintheir prey. Little to no long-term monitoringhasoccurredfor thesechangesinthe populationdynamicscurrentlybeingseenamongtheArctic seabirds, thereforeis difficultto determinewhateffects climatechangewillhaveon Arctic seabirds.However long-term monitoringdataexistsfor two Arctic seabirdspecies, the CommonandtheThick-billedMurre.Thesespeciesofbirdshave abundantpopulationsandarespread throughoutthe entireArctic region.The datashowedthat the Thick–billedMurre’sbreedingcoloniesincreasedin size whenthe sea surfacetemperature orSST increasedslightly.However, the oppositeis true for the Common Murre,the data showedslightdecreasesinthe sea surfacetemperatureorSST islinked to increasedsizesof the breedingcolonies. Thedatashowsextremechangesinthesea surface temperature(SST)ineitherdirectionwill negatively influence thepopulationsizesof both species.Another sideeffect of this decreasedicecoveragecaused by glacialretreatis the increasedpotential forcontamination.1 Thedecreasedlevelsoficecoveragecausedbyglacialretreathasfar reachingconsequencesforthese Arctic ecosystems. Thedecreasedamountsoficecoverage areleadingto biggerwaves whichcanreachfurther inland.As a result of this more salinewater is being increasinglypushed intothe deltas of freshwaterrivers. Someof the consequencesofthisare increasederosionamongthe shoreline,transformationanddestructionoffreshwater ecosystemsdueto this intrusion of salinewater. A recentlyconductedstudyshowedafter surveying forty milesof 1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky."Seabirds." Arctic Report Card. 11Nov.2012. Web. 6 Dec.2011
  • 4. shorelinean average of 6.8 metersretreating shorelinewasdocumented.Theseextremechangesarecausedby manyvariableswhichincludeincreasedlandexposuretostorms, decreasedicecoverageandincreasedlevelsof meltingpermafrostwhichleadstoincreasedlevelsof coastalerosion.Theincreasedlevelsofsalinewater have the abilityto negatively affect freshwaterecosystems. Theincreasedlevelsof salt water intrusion have the abilityto alter andinfluencethefood web. In addition,the changesinsalinitymayleadto freshwater speciesofseabirdsbeing outcompetedbyspeciesof seabirdswhich thrivein salineenvironments.In extremecasesthe environmentmay becomeanoxic,whichwill turnthelakeinto a deadzone devoid of mostlife forms.2 As with the Arctic seabirdphenologyinthe Antarctic is beinginfluencedbythe changingclimaticconditions as well. Therearenumerousvariableswhichaffectthephenologyseabirdsin the Antarctic whichdonot exist within the Arctic regions. Thepresenceofnon-flyingseabirdsinthe Antarctic is a majorfactorwhich tendsto influencethe phenologyof seabirds.As with the Arctic changesinseabirdphenologyistied to decreasedamountsofprey. The flying seabirdshave the abilityto fly longerdistancesinorderto forage for food. However, the non-flying seabirds have a limitedrange andcannottravel these longerdistancesinorderto forgefor food. Thismayexplain discrepancybetweenthedata collectedonthe Arctic and Antarctic seabirds,sincenonon-flying speciesofseabirds suchas penguinsresideinthe Arctic. As with the Arctic sea iceextent (SIE) andsea temperaturewillaffectthe phenologyof seabirdpopulationsresidingintheAntarctic. Thelackofprey for seabirdsis a majorproblem forthese birds, the lackof prey is tied to delays in migrationandmolting.Forthesereasonsseabirdstendto delaythese activitiessincethey requireextensive amountsof energyandwhichmeansaplentifulfood supplyis required. Researchhasfoundthat changesinthese activitieswillcauseseabirdsto changetheirbreedingschedules.The biggestdifferenceamongArctic andAntarctic seabirdswerethey live and breed.TheArctic seabirdspeciestendto live and breedin freshwaterlakes. TheAntarctic seabirdstendto live andbreedon the continentaliceshelf.These 2 Struzik, Ed. "As Arctic Sea IceRetreats, Storms TakeTollon theLand." ByEd Struzik: Yale Environment360.6 June2011. Web. 8 Dec.2015. <http://e360.yale.edu/feature/as_arctic_sea_ice_retreats_storms_take_toll_on_the_land/2412/>.
  • 5. facts mayhelpto explainthe variation amongonhowclimateisinfluencingseabirdsinboththe Arctic and Antarctic.3,4 As the with Arctic, the sea surfacetemperatureisinfluencingseabirdpopulationsintheAntarctic. Any changesinthe seasurfacetemperaturewillleadto changesinseabirdphenology. Thebiggestproblem causedby this it puts the seabirdsout of sync with theirsourcesof prey.4 Another factor whichcouldexplainthe differences amongtheAntarctic and Arctic seabirdsis phenotype plasticity.Phenotype plasticitycanbedefinedas when different types of phenotypes with the sameof genotype reactdifferentlybasedon the environmentalconditions. Phenotype plasticityis influencedbythe locationandvariationdifferent speciesofseabirds.Thiscouldexplain differencesinphenologywhichareseenamongtheArctic andAntarctic seabirds.5 However, the biggestinfluences of seabirdphenologyare the life spansandreproductiverates of thesebirds. Seabirdswith lowerreproductivetend to breed onlyin optimalconditions,asdothe seabirdswitha longerlifespan. And seabirdswith shorter lifespansand highreproductive rates of are knownto breed in less than optimalbreedingconditions.Thechartsseenbelowarea comparisonofseabirdsliving the in Arctic and the Antarctic.As one canseethere are manyspeciesbirdsfoundin the Arctic whicharenotin the Antarctic. Thesamecanbesaidfor the seabirdsliving inthe Antarctic. Thedata presentedin thesechartsprovides strong evidenceof phenotype plasticityoccurringwithinboththeArctic and 3,4 Constable, Andrew J., Jessica Melbourne-Thomas, Stuart P. Corney, Kevin R. Arrigo,ChristopheBarbraud,David K.A. Barnes, NathanielL. Bindoff, Philip W. Boyd, Angelika Brandt,DanielP. Costa,Andrew T. Davidson, Hugh W.Ducklow, LouiseEmmerson, MitsuoFukuchi, Julian Gutt, Mark A. Hindell, Eileen E. Hofmann, Graham W.Hosie, Takahiro Iida,Sarah Jacob, NadineM. Johnston, SoKawaguchi, Nobuo Kokubun, Philippe Koubbi, Mary-AnneLea, AzwianewiMakhado,Rob A. Massom, Klaus Meiners, MichaelP. Meredith,EugeneJ. Murphy, Stephen Nicol,Keith Reid, KateRicherson, Martin J. Riddle, Stephen R. Rintoul, Walker O. Smith, Colin Southwell, JonathonS. Stark, MichaelSumner, KerrieM. Swadling, Kunio T. Takahashi, PhilN. Trathan, Dirk C. Welsford, HenriWeimerskirch,Karen J. Westwood,Barbara C.Wienecke, Dieter Wolf-Gladrow, Simon W. Wright, JoseC. Xavier, and PhilippeZiegler. "ClimateChangeand Southern OceanEcosystems I: HowChanges in PhysicalHabitats Directly Affect MarineBiota." Glob Change BiolGlobalChange Biology 20.10(2014): 3004-025. Web. 10Oct.2015 Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climateas a Driver of PhenologicalChangein Southern Seabirds." IntJ BiometeorolInternationalJournalof Biometeorology 58.4(2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015. 4 Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climateas a Driver of PhenologicalChangein Southern Seabirds." IntJ BiometeorolInternationalJournalof Biometeorology 58.4(2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015. 5 Grémillet, David, and AnneCharmantier. "Shifts in Phenotypic Plasticity Constrain theValueof Seabirds as EcologicalIndicators of Marine Ecosystems." EcologicalApplications 20.6(2010): 1498-503. October 5,2015.
  • 6. Antarctic regions.(see chart1 and 2 for moreinformation.) Charts3 and4 show the variableswhichinfluencethe breedingphenologyoftwo speciesofAntarctic Seabirdsthe EmperorpenguinandtheSnow petrel.As onecansee the Emperorpenguinpopulationswilldecreaseinresponsetolower levels of sea iceanddecreasesinthe air temperatureduringthespringmonths.Thedatafor the Snowpetrels showschangesinthe populationsdynamics occurringifthesea iceextent wereto decreaseinsize. In addition,changesinthepopulationdynamics ofSnow Petrels were observed if any of the followingchangesoccurreddecreasesintheair temperatureorthe southern oscillation index.6,7 Thisproves the variablesinfluencingseabirdphenologytendsto vary greatlyboth in the Artic andthe Antarctic regions.Thefinalset of chartsyou are seeingare the comparisonofconductivitymeasurements taken from a highArctic lakefrom the years 1968 and2006.(See chartsnumber5 and6.) Thedatapresentedin these chartsindicatescertainlayersof the lake arebecomingmoresalinewhileotherlayersare becomingless saline.It is impossibletoget a baselinebycomparingthe1968and2006sets of data sincemanyof the variables whichwereexaminedin2006werenotexaminedin1968.8 Basedon the data in this paper wecanconcludethat climatechangeishaving adverse effects on seabirdpopulationsbothinthe Arctic andAntarctic regions.However, sincechangesinseabird phenologyis highlyvariableandinfluencedbyspeciesandlocationitisimpossibleto determinehoweachspecieswillreacttoclimatechange. Beforeany conclusionsonhowclimatechangeis influencingthephenologyof seabirdson globalscalecan bemade furtherresearchisnecessaryand a long-term monitoringprogram shouldbeestablishedbeforecomingtoanyconclusions. 6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud, and HenriWeimerskirch."Long-Term Contrasted Responses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015. 7 Jenouvrier, S., H. Weimerskirch, C. Barbraud,Y.-H. Park, andB. Cazelles. "Evidenceof a Shift in theCyclicity of Antarctic Seabird Dynamics Linked to Climate." Proceedings of the RoyalSociety B: BiologicalSciences 272.1566(2005): 887-95. October 5, 2015. 8 Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print.
  • 7. Antarctic Seabirds Adelie Penguins AfricanPenguins Antarctic Petrel Antarctic petrel Antarctic Prion Antarctic prion Antarctic Seabirds Antarctic shag Antarctic Skua Antarctic tern Black -belliedStorm Petrel Black-browned Albatross Blue Petrel Broad -billedprion Brown Skua Brush-tailedPenguin Cape Petrels Chin-strap Penguin Common diving Petrel Diving Petrel Emperor Penguin FairyPrion FiordlandPenguin Fulmar prion Galapagos Penguins Gentoo Penguin Graybacked- Storm Petrel GrayDuck Grayheaded Albatross
  • 8. Graypetrel Great Shearwater Great -wingedpetrel Grey-headed albatross Humboldt Penguin Imperial Shag Kelp Gulls Kerguelenpetrel Kerguelenpintail Kerguelenshag Kerguelentern King Penguin Lesser-shealthbill Light-mantledsooty albatross Little Penguin Little Shearwater Mottled petrel Narrow-billedPrion Northern Giant Petrel Rockhopper Penguin Royal Penguin Royal Albatross Snow petrel Snowy-sheathbill Soft-plumagedpetrel Sooty Albatross Sooty Shearwater South Georgia diving petrel Southern Fulmars Southern Giant Petrel South-polar Skua Speckled Teal Wandering albatross White -capped Albatross White -chinned petrel White- faced Storm Petrel White facedAlbatross White-cappedalbatross White-headed petrel Wilson's Storm Petrel Yellownose Albatross
  • 9. Yellow-billedPintail Yellow-eyedPenguins Yellow-nosedalbatross Chart 1 9 McGonigal, David, and Lynn Woodworth. The Complete Encyclopedia Antarcticaand the Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.: Firefly, 2001. Print Arctic Seabirds Arctic Redpoll Arctic Seabirds Arctic Tern Atlantic Puffins Blacked -leggedKittiwake Common Guillemots Common Murre Common Redpoll Glaucous Gull Horned Puffins Ivory Gull LaplandBunting Long-tailed Skua Northern Fulmar Northern Gannets Razor Gills Red -Throated Divers Red-necked Phalarope Snow Bunting Thick -billedMurres TuftedPuffins Chart 2 10 10 McGonigal, David, and LynnWoodworth. The Complete Encyclopedia Antarctica andthe Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.: Firefly, 2001. Print.
  • 10. Chart 36 6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud, andHenriWeimerskirch. "Long-Term ContrastedResponses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 The breeding of Emperior Penguins and The Associated Environmental Variables Emperor Penguin So ( Survival during the first year at sea) Emperor Penguin BS (Breeding Success) Emperor Penguin N(number of breeding pairs) Emperor Penguin Pb( Proportion of breeders) Emperor Penguin Pb+6 (Proportion of birds attempting to bird for first time)
  • 11. Chart 46 6 Jenouvrier, Stephanie, ChristopheBarbraud,and HenriWeimerskirch."Long-Term Contrasted Responses To ClimateOf Two Antarctic Seabird Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5,2015 -1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 The Breeding of Snow Petrels and The Associated Environmental Variables Snow Petrel So ( Survival during the first year at sea) Snow Petrel BS (Breeding Success) Snow Petrel N(number of breeding pairs) Snow Petrel Pb( Proportion of breeders) Snow Petrel Pb+6 (Proportion of birds attempting to bird for first time)
  • 12. Chart 58 Chart 68 8 Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print. 8 Holm, TrineMarianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, AnneHormes, Dag Klaveness, and RolandPsenner. "Rapid Physicochemical Changes in theHigh Arctic LakeKongressvatn Caused byRecent ClimateChange." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print. 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 Mixolimnion Monimolimnion Kongressvatn springs Outflow Conductivity (us cm-1 25 at Degrees Celsius 1968) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 Conductivity(us cm-1 25 at Degrees Celsius 2006)
  • 13. Bibliography Holm, Trine Marianne, Karin A. Koinig, Tom Andersen, Espen Donali, Anne Hormes, Dag Klaveness, and Roland Psenner. "Rapid Physicochemical Changes in the High Arctic Lake Kongressvatn Caused by Recent Climate Change." Aquatic Sciences Aquat Sci (2011): 385-95. Print. Jenouvrier, Stephanie, Christophe Barbraud, and Henri Weimerskirch. "Long-Term Contrasted Responses to Climate of Two Antarctic Seabird Species." Ecology 86.11 (2005): 2889-903. October, 5, 2015 McGonigal, David, and Lynn Woodworth. The Complete Encyclopedia Antarctica and the Arctic. Willowdale, Ont.: Firefly, 2001. Print. Jenouvrier, S., H. Weimerskirch, C. Barbraud, Y.-H. Park, and B. Cazelles. "Evidence of a Shift in the Cyclicity of Antarctic Seabird Dynamics Linked to Climate." Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 272.1566 (2005): 887- 95. October 5, 2015. Grémillet, David, and Anne Charmantier. "Shifts in Phenotypic Plasticity Constrain the Value of Seabirds as Ecological Indicators of Marine Ecosystems." Ecological Applications 20.6 (2010): 1498-503. October 5, 2015. Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climate as a Driver of Phenological Change in Southern Seabirds." Int J Biometeorol International Journal of Biometeorology 58.4 (2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015. Constable, Andrew J., Jessica Melbourne-Thomas, Stuart P. Corney, Kevin R. Arrigo, Christophe Barbraud, David K. A. Barnes, Nathaniel L. Bindoff, Philip W. Boyd, Angelika Brandt, Daniel P. Costa, Andrew T. Davidson, Hugh W. Ducklow, Louise Emmerson, Mitsuo Fukuchi, Julian Gutt, Mark A. Hindell, Eileen E. Hofmann, Graham W. Hosie, Takahiro Iida, Sarah Jacob, Nadine M. Johnston, So Kawaguchi, Nobuo Kokubun, Philippe Koubbi, Mary-Anne Lea, Azwianewi Makhado, Rob A. Massom, Klaus Meiners, Michael P. Meredith, Eugene J. Murphy, Stephen Nicol, Keith Reid, Kate Richerson, Martin J. Riddle, Stephen R. Rintoul, Walker O. Smith, Colin Southwell, Jonathon S. Stark, Michael Sumner, Kerrie M. Swadling, Kunio T. Takahashi, Phil N. Trathan, Dirk C. Welsford, Henri Weimerskirch, Karen J. Westwood, Barbara C. Wienecke, Dieter Wolf-Gladrow, Simon W. Wright, Jose C. Xavier, and Philippe Ziegler. "Climate Change and Southern Ocean Ecosystems I: How Changes in Physical Habitats Directly Affect Marine Biota." Glob Change Biol Global Change Biology 20.10 (2014): 3004-025. Web. 10 Oct. 2015 Chambers, Lynda E., Peter Dann, Belinda Cannell, and Eric J. Woehler. “Climate as a Driver of Phenological Change in Southern Seabirds." Int J Biometeorol International Journal of Biometeorology 58.4 (2013): 603-12. October, 5, 2015. Struzik, Ed. "As Arctic Sea Ice Retreats, Storms Take Toll on the Land." By Ed Struzik: Yale Environment 360. 6 June 2011. Web. 8 Dec. 2015. <http://e360.yale.edu/feature/as_arctic_sea_ice_retreats_storms_take_toll_on_the_land/2412/>. 1 Kuletz, K.J., and N.J. Karnovsky. "Seabirds." Arctic Report Card. 11 Nov. 2012. Web. 6 Dec. 2015