The document discusses the concept of software architecture, emphasizing its artistic and emergent nature rather than viewing it purely as a technical engineering discipline. It presents software development as a continuous process involving intention, realization, feedback, and synthesis, likening software programming to music where harmony and intentionality play critical roles. The author argues for the importance of conceptual integrity in software systems, suggesting that effective architecture requires collaboration from a cohesive and resonant team of developers.

1. architecture
in
so-ware
is
wri/en
with
lowercase
‘a’
Ruben
Gonzalez
Blanco
Nov12
DEVCON1
Telefonica
I+D

2. Wrong
Job
Title?
So-ware
Architect
So-ware
Engineer

3. Why
not
So-ware
Doctor?

4. What
is
So-ware
Development?
A
personal
understanding

5. So-ware
Development
is
a
process
of
conOnuous
Knowledge
TransformaOon
Problem
SoluOon
Knowledge
about

6. So-ware
Development
occurs
through
ConOnuous
Human
CreaOve
Cycles
IntenOon
RealizaOon
Feedback
Synthesis

7. Till
the
Desired
Working
So2ware
Emerges
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Compile
Failed
Run
Failed
Test
Failed
Test
Passed
Enhance
Idea/Design
Test
Failed
Inten%on' Realiza%on'
Feedback'
Synthesis'
Test
Passed
WORKING
SOFTWARE
IntenFonal
Emergent
Emergence
is
the
key
characterisOc
of
complex
systems.

8. In
some
sense
is
a
kind
of
Art
or
Cra-
Problem
&
Programming
Idea
Code,
Run
&
Test
Review
Outcome
Programmer
Scene
&
PainOng
Idea
Paint
Review
Outcome
Painter
Digital
Experience
Creators
Visual
Experience
Creators

9. So-ware
Programming
is
not
like
pure
Engineering

10. So-ware
Programing
is
not
like
Building
ConstrucOon

11. So-ware
Programmers
are
not
like
ConstrucOon
Workers

12. Does
So-ware
Architecture
and
So-ware
Architects
make
sense?

13. In
fact,
there
is
not
a
single
definiOon
of
So-ware
Architecture
and
the
role
of
So-ware
Architect

14. Looking
at
so-ware
from
a
different
perspecOve
trying
to
re-­‐understand
what
“So-ware
a-­‐rchitecture”
is

15. Perhaps
So-ware
is
like
Music

16. Computer
vs
Music
Player

17. Program
vs
Pentagram

18. Programming
vs
Composing

19. Running
a
Program
vs
Playing
Music
compiled
interpreted

20. So-ware
Programming,
like
music,
requires
deliberate
pracOce

21. Harmony
and
Melody
The
HARMONY
provides
the
base
for
the
MELODY
Harmony
is
transversal
to
the
music
Melodies

22. Perhaps
Programming
So-ware
is
like
Jazz
Original
Dixieland
Jass
Band
Melodies
are
improvised/created
on
top
of
a
shared
Harmony
created
by
a
composer
Everybody
is
a
Composer
The
Harmony
provides
consistency

23. So-ware
Architect
=
So-ware
Harmonist
=
So-ware
Harmony
Composer
See
the
lower
case
‘a’
So-ware
Programmers
=
So-ware
Melody
Composers
JAZZWARE
So-ware
Architecture
=
So-ware
Harmony
See
the
lower
case
‘a’

24. So-ware
Harmony
is
about
Conceptual
Integrity
Anywhere
you
look
in
your
system,
you
can
tell
that
the
design
is
part
of
the
same
overall
design
style,
theme,
mood
…is
about
Design
and
Style
Consistency
in
all
dimensions
of
the
system
Fed
Brooks:
“It
is
be>er
to
have
a
system...reflect
one
set
of
design
ideas,
than
to
have
one
that
contains
many
good
but
independent
and
uncoordinated
ideas”
User
interface,
technologies,
coding
styles,
naming
convenFons,
directory
structures,
classes,
components,
interfaces,
internal
and
external
behavior,
deployment…
Conceptual
Integrity
tries
to
limit
the
system
complexity
Conceptual
Integrity
simplifies
collaboraOon
when
creaOng
so-ware
The
Mythical
Man-­‐Month

25. Conceptual
Integrity
examples
• Unix
• based
on
the
noOon
of
a
"file”
(e.g.
directories,
devices,
filesystems,
named
pipes
and
sockets
are
all
sort-­‐of
files)
• Smalltalk
• "everything
is
an
object",
and
the
small
set
of
other
accompanying
principles
• SQL
• "all
data
is
in
tables",
with
keys
and
constraints
• Lisp
• "everything
is
a
list”
h>p://c2.com/cgi/wiki?ConceptualIntegrity

26. Not
having
Conceptual
Integrity
leads
to
chaoOc
systems
MulOple
minds
working
in
complex
system
without
unity
and
conceptual
integrity

27. 7
Dimensions
Process
Dimension
Deployment
Dimension
Logical
Dimension
External Dimension
Implementation
Dimension
Solu%on
Vision
Classes,
Modules,
Design
Components,
Interfaces,
Interac%ons
Use
Cases
/
User
Stories
UX
Guidelines
Run%me
Processes,
Threads
Protocols,
Inter-­‐process
Communica%on,
Integra%ons
Implementa%on
Structure
and
Components
Frameworks,
Libraries
Base
Technologies,
Programming
Languages
Infrastructure,
Hardware
and
Network
Topology
Data
Dimension
Environment
Dimension
Environments
Tools
Development
Process,
Methods
and
Prac%ces
Data
En%%es
Data
Messages
Logical
Physical

28. Achieving
Conceptual
Integrity
FredBrooks:
"Conceptual
integrity
in
turn
dictates
that
the
design
must
proceed
from
one
mind,
or
from
a
very
small
number
of
agreeing
resonant
minds"
Aristocracy
vs
Democracy?

29. “TradiOonal”
So-ware
Architect
architect
derives
from
the
LaOn
architectus,
which
derives
from
the
Greek
arkhitekton
(arkhi-­‐,
chief
+
tekton,
builder),
i.e.,
chief
builder

30. Bad
So-ware
Architect
ConcepOon

31. Be/er
So-ware
Architect
ConcepOon
SOll
can
be
improved

32. So-ware
Harmonist
=
Technical
Leader
Services
Modules
Packages
Classes
Code
Breadth
&
Depth
Process
Dimension
Deployment (
Dimension
Logical(
(Dimension
External Dimension
Implementation
Dimension
Classes,'Modules,'Design''
Components,'Interfaces
Use'Cases'/'User'Stories'
UX'Guidelines'
Run=me'Processes,'Threads''
Protocols,''InterAprocess'
Communica=on'
Implementa=on'Structure'
and'Components'
Frameworks,'Libraries'
Base'Technologies,'
Programming'Languages
Infrastructure,'Hardware'and'
Network'Topology'
Data
Dimension
Environment
Dimension
Environments'
Tools'
Development'Process,'
Methods'and'Prac=ces'
Data'En==es'
Data'Messages'
7
Dimensions

33. So-ware
Harmonist
=
Technical
Leader
or
Development
Leader
• Is
able
to
compose
and
play
So-ware
• is
hands
on
• Guides,
Coaches
and
Leads
other
So-ware
Composers
• is
a
reference

34. So-ware
Harmonist
=
Technical
Leader
or
Development
Leader
• Keeps
Conceptual
Integrity
and
Unity
across
the
system
and
teams,
while
limiOng
complexity
• Retains
the
final
say
in
technical
disputes
or
arguments
within
the
team(s)
Small
teams
with
resonant
minds
could
not
need
an
specific
tech
leader

35. ElaboraOng
So-ware
Harmony

36. From
IntenOonal
to
Emerging
Initial team
Agile Project Kickoff
Management team
Architecture team
time
Initial project
team
Prototyping team
I1 I2 I3
Initial team
Agile Project Kickoff
Management team
Architecture team
time
Initial project
team
Prototyping team
I1 I2 I3
Feature 1 Team
Feature2 Team
Infraestructure Team
I4 I5
Prototyping team
• IntenOonal
harmony
(architecture)
is
explicitly
idenOfied
and
then
implemented
• Accidental
harmony
(architecture)
emerges
from
the
mulOtude
of
individual
design
decisions
that
occur
during
development,
only
a-er
which
can
we
name
that
architecture
Process
Dimension
Deployment (
Dimension
Logical(
(Dimension
External Dimension
Implementation
Dimension
Classes,'Modules,'Design''
Components,'Interfaces
Use'Cases'/'User'Stories'
UX'Guidelines'
Run=me'Processes,'Threads''
Protocols,''InterAprocess'
Communica=on'
Implementa=on'Structure'
and'Components'
Frameworks,'Libraries'
Base'Technologies,'
Programming'Languages
Infrastructure,'Hardware'and'
Network'Topology'
Data
Dimension
Environment
Dimension
Environments'
Tools'
Development'Process,'
Methods'and'Prac=ces'
Data'En==es'
Data'Messages'
INTENTIONAL
EMERGENT
GROWING

37. So-ware
Harmony(architecture)
is
Elaborated,
Built,
Used
and
Executed
Architecture=Harmony
is
created
as
set
of
subopOmal
design
decisions
that
can
be
re-­‐factor
later
on
SP1 SP2 SP3 SP4 SP5 SP6 SP7 SP8Sprint0 SP9
Building
the
Harmony
Using
Building
…..Using
IntenOonal
Emergent
IntenOonal
Emergent

38. The
Dilemma
Solu%on
:
Assuring
Conceptual
Integrity
via
Capacity
Alloca%on
to
architecture
=
Harmony
Source:
Dean
Leffinweel
,
h>p://scaledagileframework.com/guidance/assuring-­‐architectural-­‐integrity-­‐via-­‐capacity-­‐
allocaFon/

39. Desired
A/ributes
of
a
So-ware
Work
High
Cohesion
each
part/element
is
narrowed
focused
in
its
primary
task
Low
Coupling
each
part
is
self-­‐contained/orthogonal
achieved
thru
separaOon
of
concerns
and
encapsulaOon
Conceptual
Integrity
there
is
a
consistent
design*
and
style
across
all
so-ware
dimensions
(*)
programming
is
design
Source:
“The
Art
in
Computer
Programming”,
By
Andrew
Hunt
and
David
Thomas

40. There
is
no
silver
bullet
There
is
no
single
correct
architecture
and
no
single
“right
answer”.
JAZZWARE

41. Q
&
A