This is a lecture that I recently gave at the Ministry of Trade in Indonesia to kick off a series of lectures I will perform there over the final months of 2013 on NTBs and what Indonesia can do about them
International trade is distorted by countries applying tariff and non tariff trade barriers.
Want more FREE resources? Checkout the B2B Whiteboard youtube channel:
www.youtube.com/b2bwhiteboard
Or join us on Facebook today: www.facebook.com/b2bwhiteboard
International trade is distorted by countries applying tariff and non tariff trade barriers.
Want more FREE resources? Checkout the B2B Whiteboard youtube channel:
www.youtube.com/b2bwhiteboard
Or join us on Facebook today: www.facebook.com/b2bwhiteboard
Non-Tariff barriers are trade barriers that restrict imports but are not in the usual form of a tariff.
Some common examples are anti-dumping measures and countervailing duties also called non-tariff barriers.
Non-Tariff barriers include macro-economic measures affecting trade.
Non-Tariff barriers comes under Trade Policy.
China's Quest to Capture the International Financial Information Services MarketSimon Lacey
This presentation covers China's two attempts to capture the international financial information services markets, the first being in 1997, the other being in 2007. In both cases, China was ultimately dissuaded from pursuing this course any further and in both cases, the WTO played a significant role.
The 2012 World Trade Report is split into two main parts. The first is a brief summary of the trade situation in 2011. The second part focuses on the special theme of non-tariff measures in the 21st century.Section A of the Report presents an overview of the history of non-tariff measures in the GATT/WTO. Section B examines the reasons why governments use NTMs and services measures and the extent to which public policy interventions may also distort international trade. The phenomenon of offshoring and the crosseffects of services measures on goods trade are also considered. The section analyses choices among alternative policy instruments from a theoretical and empirical perspective. Finally, case studies are presented on the use of NTMs in particular contexts. These include the recent financial crisis, climate change policy and food safety concerns. The case studies consider how far measures adopted may pose a challenge for international trade. Section C of the Report surveys available sources of information on NTMs and services measures and evaluates their relative strengths and weaknesses. It uses this information to establish a number of “stylized facts”, first about NTMs (TBT/SPS measures in particular) and then about services measures. Section D discusses the magnitude and the trade effects of NTMs and services measures in general, before focusing on TBT/SPS measures and domestic regulation in services. It also examines how regulatory harmonization and/or mutual recognition of standards help to reduce the trade-hindering effects of the diversity of TBT and SPS measures and domestic regulation in services. Section E looks at international cooperation on NTMs and services measures. The first part reviews the economic rationale for such cooperation and discusses the efficient design of rules on NTMs in a trade agreement. The second part looks at how cooperation has occurred on TBT/SPS measures and services regulation in the multilateral trading system, and within other international forums and institutions. The third part of the section deals with the legal analysis of the treatment of NTMs in the GATT/WTO dispute system and interpretations of the rules that have emerged in recent international trade disputes. The section concludes with a discussion of outstanding challenges and key policy implications of the Report.
The ability to gain and to benefit from market access depends increasingly on compliance with trade regulatory measures such as sanitary requirements and goods standards. These non-tariff measures (NTMs) represent a challenge for exporters, importers and policy makers. Many NTMs have primarily non-trade objectives such as the protection of public health or the environment, while affecting trade de facto through procedural requirements. NTMs can be unintentionally discriminatory against smaller exporters and poorer countries. Appropriate trade regulatory measures in developing countries that are efficient, provide protection for consumers and support development is challenging but important.
Understanding the uses and implications of these trade policy instruments is essential for the formulation and implementation of effective development strategies.
World Trade Organization- Brief OverviewKashyap Shah
How and WHY GATT changed to WTO ?
What are the various functions & objectives of WTO.
Some of the key characteristics of WTO Agreements
From India's Perspective- Advantages & Disadvantages
Non-Tariff barriers are trade barriers that restrict imports but are not in the usual form of a tariff.
Some common examples are anti-dumping measures and countervailing duties also called non-tariff barriers.
Non-Tariff barriers include macro-economic measures affecting trade.
Non-Tariff barriers comes under Trade Policy.
China's Quest to Capture the International Financial Information Services MarketSimon Lacey
This presentation covers China's two attempts to capture the international financial information services markets, the first being in 1997, the other being in 2007. In both cases, China was ultimately dissuaded from pursuing this course any further and in both cases, the WTO played a significant role.
The 2012 World Trade Report is split into two main parts. The first is a brief summary of the trade situation in 2011. The second part focuses on the special theme of non-tariff measures in the 21st century.Section A of the Report presents an overview of the history of non-tariff measures in the GATT/WTO. Section B examines the reasons why governments use NTMs and services measures and the extent to which public policy interventions may also distort international trade. The phenomenon of offshoring and the crosseffects of services measures on goods trade are also considered. The section analyses choices among alternative policy instruments from a theoretical and empirical perspective. Finally, case studies are presented on the use of NTMs in particular contexts. These include the recent financial crisis, climate change policy and food safety concerns. The case studies consider how far measures adopted may pose a challenge for international trade. Section C of the Report surveys available sources of information on NTMs and services measures and evaluates their relative strengths and weaknesses. It uses this information to establish a number of “stylized facts”, first about NTMs (TBT/SPS measures in particular) and then about services measures. Section D discusses the magnitude and the trade effects of NTMs and services measures in general, before focusing on TBT/SPS measures and domestic regulation in services. It also examines how regulatory harmonization and/or mutual recognition of standards help to reduce the trade-hindering effects of the diversity of TBT and SPS measures and domestic regulation in services. Section E looks at international cooperation on NTMs and services measures. The first part reviews the economic rationale for such cooperation and discusses the efficient design of rules on NTMs in a trade agreement. The second part looks at how cooperation has occurred on TBT/SPS measures and services regulation in the multilateral trading system, and within other international forums and institutions. The third part of the section deals with the legal analysis of the treatment of NTMs in the GATT/WTO dispute system and interpretations of the rules that have emerged in recent international trade disputes. The section concludes with a discussion of outstanding challenges and key policy implications of the Report.
The ability to gain and to benefit from market access depends increasingly on compliance with trade regulatory measures such as sanitary requirements and goods standards. These non-tariff measures (NTMs) represent a challenge for exporters, importers and policy makers. Many NTMs have primarily non-trade objectives such as the protection of public health or the environment, while affecting trade de facto through procedural requirements. NTMs can be unintentionally discriminatory against smaller exporters and poorer countries. Appropriate trade regulatory measures in developing countries that are efficient, provide protection for consumers and support development is challenging but important.
Understanding the uses and implications of these trade policy instruments is essential for the formulation and implementation of effective development strategies.
World Trade Organization- Brief OverviewKashyap Shah
How and WHY GATT changed to WTO ?
What are the various functions & objectives of WTO.
Some of the key characteristics of WTO Agreements
From India's Perspective- Advantages & Disadvantages
Restrictions on Internet Commerce - Trade Rules and their LimitsSimon Lacey
This is a presentation I gave at Georgetown University Law Center in May 2012. It discusses restrictions on the internet and how they constrain the commercial activities of some very big companies worldwide. It then discusses international trade rules and how these may be used to challenge the abuse of such restrictions now and/or constrain the impact of such restrictions in the future.
From Doha to Bali: Assessing the Bali Deliverables after 12 long years of mul...Simon Lacey
This is a lecture I prepared recently in anticipation of the WTO Ministerial Conference to be held from 3 to 6 December on Bali. It discusses the history of the Doha Round to date and offers a preliminary evaluation of the likely outcomes from the Ministerial meeting.
Lesson Three | Principal Legal Obligations under WTO LawSimon Lacey
This is the third in a five-part series of lectures on WTO law and policy given at the Masters in Trade, Investment and Competition (MTIC) Program of the University Pelita Harapan Graduate School
An Introduction to Regionalism and WTO Rules on Preferential Trading Arrangem...Simon Lacey
This is the fifth lecture in a series on the world trading system. This lecture focuses on the proliferation of preferential trading arrangements and the relevant WTO rules governing such instruments
Indonesia and its Track Record at WTO Dispute SettlementSimon Lacey
This lecture reviews how Indonesia has engaged with the WTO dispute settlement system both as complainant and respondent and concludes that Indonesia still has a long way to go before it earns the fear and respect of other WTO Members as a no-hold's barred advocate of its own export interests!
Lesson One | Globalization and Economic IntegrationSimon Lacey
This is the first in a series of five lectures I am giving in 2014 at the University Pelita Harapan (UPH) Graduate School's Masters Program in International Trade, Investment and Competition (MTIC).
WTO and sanitary and phytosanitary measures.
Presentation for master students of international business. Preparation time: 2 hours. Presentation time: 10 minutes
Presentation can be viewed at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdzdT1kRV_c
Orderly Liquidation Authority under Dodd-FrankSimon Lacey
This is a presentation I prepared while at Georgetown University Law Center in 2001 on Orderly Liquidation Authority under the then newly enacted Dodd-Frank Act.
FTAs can result in some export gains, and possibly increased FDI flows, but the size and durability of these benefits – highly uncertain. FTAs will most likely lead to an increase in imports with impact for the trade balance and the external debt position.
International Business Dynamics by Nagarjun Reddy module 3PNagarjunReddyReddy
Complete detail of Second Module International Business Dynamics contents – WTO and Trading – Pitfall of International Strategic Alliances, for any queries and inputs, reach me through Instagram, Facebook (allnewcrazy).
What is WTO?
Objectives of WTO.
Rules of WTO.
WTO Issues in Pakistan.
What are the benefits of WTO?
What is an example of world trade?
What is the main function of the World Trade Organization?
What is the main purpose of the World Trade Organization?
The dangers of anti-globalization and moves against economic opennessSimon Lacey
This lecture was delivered as part of an online symposium organized by Trends Research and Advisory on the subject of Reopening of the National and Global Economies: The Lessons Learned.
Trade Tensions and the Global Technology Industry: A case study of HuaweiSimon Lacey
This presentation seeks to explain the rationale behind the recent U.S. enmity towards Chinese technology companies by framing it in terms of an attempt by the U.S. to retain its overwhelming military superiority.
Technological decoupling 5 reasons why it won't workSimon Lacey
This short slide presentation is a summary of an e-book I published with Trends Advisory and Research and sets out in five reasons why the U.S. policy of technological decoupling is bound to fail.
This paper, an excerpt from a larger collection of texts, contains some interesting historical background on international economic relations preceding and during the Great War and gives interesting context for the motives behind what ultimately lead to the post WWII economic order
The Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934 - The American Economic ReviewSimon Lacey
This 1935 article written right after the passage and signing into law of the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act is quite the historical gem and well worth reading for those with an interest in the field.
An Introduction to WTO Rules on Market AccessSimon Lacey
This is one of a series of lectures given on University Pelita Harapan's Masters in International Trade, Competition and Investment Law and Policy (MTIC) Program. This lecture discusses the WTO rules on market access, focusing on tariffs, quantitative restrictions, tariff-rate quotas, and other non-tarriff measures such as technical barriers to trade and sanitary and phytosanitary measures
Lesson Four | Market Access in the WTO (goods)Simon Lacey
This is lesson four of an introductory lecture series on WTO law and policy I am giving at Unviersity Pelita Harapan (UPH) Graduate School as part of the Masters in Trade, Investment and Competition Law and Policy (MTIC) Program in January 2014
002 Features and Functions of the World Trade OrganizationSimon Lacey
This is Part 2 in a series of 5 introductory lectures on the World Trading Organization that I was asked to give at Univesity Pelita Harapan in January 2014
Consistency of the EU's Renewable Energy Directive with WTO RulesSimon Lacey
This presentation discusses the WTO complaint by Argentina against the EU Renewable Energy Directive (DS 459) and frames this dispute in the context of whether or not Indonesia should also weigh in and file its own complaint
World in Crisis: Can the trading system still serve the needs of developing c...Simon Lacey
This is a presentation I gave in April 2009 at the South African Institute of International Affairs on the impact that the Global Financial Crisis had had on developing countries and the multilateral trading system
This presentation includes basic of PCOS their pathology and treatment and also Ayurveda correlation of PCOS and Ayurvedic line of treatment mentioned in classics.
A review of the growth of the Israel Genealogy Research Association Database Collection for the last 12 months. Our collection is now passed the 3 million mark and still growing. See which archives have contributed the most. See the different types of records we have, and which years have had records added. You can also see what we have for the future.
Strategies for Effective Upskilling is a presentation by Chinwendu Peace in a Your Skill Boost Masterclass organisation by the Excellence Foundation for South Sudan on 08th and 09th June 2024 from 1 PM to 3 PM on each day.
A workshop hosted by the South African Journal of Science aimed at postgraduate students and early career researchers with little or no experience in writing and publishing journal articles.
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...RitikBhardwaj56
Discover the Simplified Electron and Muon Model: A New Wave-Based Approach to Understanding Particles delves into a groundbreaking theory that presents electrons and muons as rotating soliton waves within oscillating spacetime. Geared towards students, researchers, and science buffs, this book breaks down complex ideas into simple explanations. It covers topics such as electron waves, temporal dynamics, and the implications of this model on particle physics. With clear illustrations and easy-to-follow explanations, readers will gain a new outlook on the universe's fundamental nature.
Normal Labour/ Stages of Labour/ Mechanism of LabourWasim Ak
Normal labor is also termed spontaneous labor, defined as the natural physiological process through which the fetus, placenta, and membranes are expelled from the uterus through the birth canal at term (37 to 42 weeks
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleCeline George
In Odoo, the chatter is like a chat tool that helps you work together on records. You can leave notes and track things, making it easier to talk with your team and partners. Inside chatter, all communication history, activity, and changes will be displayed.
This slide is special for master students (MIBS & MIFB) in UUM. Also useful for readers who are interested in the topic of contemporary Islamic banking.
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and InclusionTechSoup
Let’s explore the intersection of technology and equity in the final session of our DEI series. Discover how AI tools, like ChatGPT, can be used to support and enhance your nonprofit's DEI initiatives. Participants will gain insights into practical AI applications and get tips for leveraging technology to advance their DEI goals.
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
An Introduction to Non-Tariff Barriers and WTO Rules
1. An Introduction to Non-Tariff Barriers
and WTO Rules
Simon Lacey | Last Updated 15 August 2013
2. Outline
Some definitional issues
A few words on history
A reminder of some core WTO principles
The main rules and agreements governing NTBs
Some disputes from the past, present and future
A few NTBs currently affecting Indonesia
Solving problems arising from NTBs
Simon Lacey
2
| www.uph-analytics.com
3. Definitions
Non-Tariff Measures (NTMs): generally defined as measures
other than tariffs, which have an effect on trade.
NTMs generally on the increase, particularly since the GFC
and particularly in handful of medium to large middle-
income countries
Although NTMs often pursue legitimate policy objectives, if
they are overly trade restrictive, they are considered Non-
Tariff Barriers (NTBs)
Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs): defined as selected (non-tariff)
measures that discriminate against foreign products,
directly or indirectly, de jure or de facto, or where trade
restrictiveness, whether or not deliberate, exceeds what is
needed for the measure’s non-trade objectives
Simon Lacey
3
| www.uph-analytics.com
4. Classifying NTMs
Simon Lacey
4
| www.uph-analytics.com
Source: International Trade Center (ITC)
http://www.intracen.org/article/Creating-clarity-out-of-complexity-Defining-obstacles-to-trade/
5. Historical Trends for NTBs
As tariffs were successfully negotiated downwards after 1947, the
incidence of non-tariff barriers increased in both relative and
absolute terms.
The accession of Japan to the GATT in 1955 which itself used a
complex system of broadly entrenched and complex behind-the-
border policies to control the domestic market for everything from
autos to photographic film;
The inventory of NTMs developed under the GATT in the years
between the end of the Kennedy Round and the start of the Tokyo
Round also highlighted the importance that NTBs had assumed as
tariffs had been on the decline
Adoption of a series of plurilaterial “codes” in the Tokyo Round
that later became part of the Single Undertaking in the Uruguay
Round that specifically addressed non-tariff barriers
Simon Lacey
5
| www.uph-analytics.com
6. Some Core WTO Principles
Non-discrimination
Transparency
Predictability
Proportionality (“no more burdensome than necessary”)
Regulations must be necessary to achieve a legitimate
policy objective
Regulations must not be applied in just a manner as to be
disguised barriers to trade or unnecessarily restrictive of
trade
Simon Lacey
6
| www.uph-analytics.com
7. WTO Rules on NTBs Specifically
GATT Article III (National Treatment)
GATT Article VI and the Anti-dumping Agreement
GATT Article VI and the Agreement on Subsidies and
Countervailing Measures
GATT Article VII and the Customs Valuation Agreement
GATT Article XI General Elimination of Quantitative
Restrictions
GATT Article XII (Balance of Payments Restrictions)
GATT Article XVII (State Trading Enterprises)
TBT Agreement
SPS Agreement
WTO Agreement on Pre-shipment Inspection
WTO Agreement on Rules of Origin
WTO Agreement on Import Licensing Procedures
Simon Lacey
7
| www.uph-analytics.com
8. WTO Dispute Settlement and NTBs
Because tariffs have ceased to be the main obstacle to trade, and
because any controversies in terms of the legal interpretation of
Members’ tariff obligations have long since been settled (in the
early years of the GATT mostly), dispute settlement at the WTO
(involving trade in goods) has predominantly concerned NTBs.
Some examples of major cases that concerned NTBs:
• US – Gasoline (DS 2)
• EC – Bananas (DS 27)
• EC – Hormones (DS 26)
• Japan – Film (DS 44)
• US – Shrimp (DS 58)
• US – Cool (DS 384,386)
• US – Clove Cigarettes (DS 406)
• Indonesia - Horticultural Products (DS 455)
Simon Lacey
8
| www.uph-analytics.com
9. Some NTBs Affecting Indonesia
Palm oil exports to the US being
potentially negatively impacted by
pending rule-making by the EPA
This is a NTB and market access issue involving
the legal interpretation of what constitutes a
technical barrier to trade, as well as of various
non-discrimination obligations.
The European Renewable Energy
Directive
This is a NTB and market access involving the
legal interpretation of WTO commitments and
obligations under the GATT, and the TBT
Agreement.
Plain-packaging tobacco products in
Australia and New Zealand
This is potentially is a non-tariff barrier in the
form of a denial of trademark protection.
Salak exports to China are being
obstructed domestic regulations on
permitted cadmium levels
This is a non-tariff barrier and market access
issue involving the legal interpretation of the
domestic regulation's compatibility with the WTO
SPS Agreement
Simon Lacey
9
| www.uph-analytics.com
10. Solving Problems with NTBs
Three ways to solve concerns arising from the
imposition of NTMs:
Raising concerns at the WTO technical committees
Enforcing rights through the WTO dispute settlement
mechanisms; and/or
Through trade negotiations.
Simon Lacey
10
| www.uph-analytics.com
11. Solving trade concerns arising
from NTMs (cont.)
WTO technical committees provide a forum for the solution of
concerns arising from the imposition of NTMs. Example: TBT
Committee and SPS Committee, for NTMs enacted as technical
regulations and SPS measures, respectively.
Some data on the issues raised before the TBT Committee as
STCs
- 365 so-called Specific Trade Concerns (STCs) were raised before the
TBT Committee from 1995 to 2012. 94 were raised in 2012 alone;
- The most commonly-stated objectives of the measures under
discussions are: health and safety, and environment protection;
- WTO Members maintaining most of the measures discussed at the
Committee are the EU, China and the US.
Simon Lacey
11
| www.uph-analytics.com
12. Solving trade concerns arising
from NTMs (cont.)
Some data on the issues raised before the SPS
Committee:
344 STCs were raised in the SPS Committee meetings from 1995 to
2012. 16 were raised in 2012 alone;
The stated objectives include food safety (30%), plant health (24%),
animal health and zoonoses (40%) or other issues, such as certification
requirements (6%);
WTO Members raising STCs include: developing country WTO Members
(89 STCs); developed country WTO Members (212 STCs); and LDC WTO
Members (5 STCs); and
In many occasions, STCs are supported by more than one WTO Member.
In these instances, the measure under discussion was maintained by: a
developed country Member in 202 cases; developing country Member in
178 cases; and an LDC Member in 1 case
Simon Lacey
12
| www.uph-analytics.com
13. Solving trade concerns arising
from NTMs (cont.)
WTO/ASEAN/bilateral dispute settlement mechanisms:
established to settle commercial disputes and seek redress of
the alleged violations of countries’ rights under
WTO/ASEAN/bilateral trade agreements.
Binding nature of the dispute settlement mechanism as a
necessary element to ensure enforceability of the rights (and
predictability of commercial concessions).
Trade negotiations: possible forum to solve trade concerns
arising from the imposition of NTMs. Examples: WTO DDA
Round; EU-Indonesia FTA.
Simon Lacey
13
| www.uph-analytics.com
14. Solving trade concerns arising
from NTMs (cont.)
A key tool to monitor and assess NTMs: transparency
requirements, which include publication of the measures and
notification. WTO and ASEAN rules are clear and call for the
establishment of effective instruments to achieve transparency:
enquiry points, notification authorities, ATR, NTRs, etc.
It is critical to make use of these instruments. Coordination with
domestic businesses, traders and trade associations must be
enhanced and built into national schemes.
Dont forget the power and support that can be received from
your “allies” in the importing countries.
Simon Lacey
14
| www.uph-analytics.com
15. Want to know more?
Simon Lacey
15
| www.uph-analytics.com
Editor's Notes
UNCTAD Definition of NTM: “policy measures, other than ordinary customs tariffs, that can potentially have an economic effect on international trade in goods, changing quantities traded, or prices, or both” For all their potentially trade-restricting effects, however, NTMs should not be thought of as merely what their name suggests—a trade policy instrument like a tariff but in a different legal form. They are fundamentally different from tariffs in a number of ways. First, there are different types of NTMs. In the new classification adopted by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, the term covers measures as different as quotas, technical regulations, SPS measures, preshipment inspection, and forced channels. Examples of NTMs quantitative restrictions technical regulations, or anticompetitive measures Global Trade Alert (a network of think tanks around the globe) shows that the number of non-tariff measures (NTMs)—including quotas, import licensing requirements, and discriminatory government procurement rules—increased in the first two years post-2008, and rose sharply in 2011. India, China, Indonesia, Argentina, the Russian Federation, and Brazil together accounted for almost half of all the new NTMs imposed worldwide NTMs may be legitimate measures addressing market or coordination failures and achieving a wide range of policy objectives, from consumers’ safety and health to environment purposes. However, when poorly designed, they can hurt competitiveness and unnecessarily raise the cost of living. Restricted access to key inputs and intermediate products, and cumbersome procedures for import and export licenses and permits cause delays and extra costs to firms, hurting small and medium enterprises particularly and dampening diversification efforts. NTMs can also increase the cost of important food staples and household consumer products, putting more pressure on the poorest. While some non-tariff measures evidently do not intend to restrict trade, they are considered non-tariff barriers (NTBs) when they are overly trade restrictive. The challenge is to identify ways to reduce the trade-impeding effect of NTMs while ensuring that legitimate regulatory objectives are attained.