Josh Smith’s emotional plea echoed through the Alpine school board meeting as he advocated for his son Michael, who has moderate autism and attends Orem Elementary. Smith, like many other parents, voiced his concerns about the Alpine School District’s plan to implement a new “consolidated” special education class structure this fall.

1. Alpine School District Faces
Backlash Over Special
Education Restructuring
S
H
A
R
E
Source-Daily Herald
Josh Smith’s emotional plea echoed through the Alpine school board meeting as he advocated for his son
Michael, who has moderate autism and attends Orem Elementary. Smith, like many other parents, voiced
his concerns about the Alpine School District’s plan to implement a new “consolidated” special education
class structure this fall. This restructuring will require approximately 150 special education students in
grades K-6 to transfer to different schools within the district.
Smith’s heartfelt plea, met with applause and support from fellow parents at the meeting, highlighted the
anxiety and frustration shared by families facing this abrupt change. The fear of disrupting their children’s
education and routines loomed large as parents took turns expressing their worries to the board members.
Remi Forrest, another concerned parent, emphasized the need for consistency for her child, who has
experienced multiple school changes in recent years. Forrest’s petition on Change.org opposing the
restructuring quickly gained traction, gathering over 2,500 signatures within a short period.

2. District Rationale and Challenges
Alpine school officials defended the decision, citing a need to reduce the frequency of school switches for
students at the elementary level. Rich Stowell, the district’s communications director, explained that the
current system often forces families to change schools too often, disrupting students’ learning experiences
and stability.
The district’s plan is particularly aimed at minimizing transitions as it prepares to implement all-day
kindergarten in the upcoming school year. Stowell highlighted the importance of honoring Individualized
Education Programs (IEPs), emphasizing that students are entitled to receive the specialized classes and
services outlined in their plans.
Within the Alpine School District, approximately 10,000 students have IEPs, indicating a substantial need
for tailored educational approaches. Stowell noted that not all students with IEPs require special classes
but stressed the district’s commitment to providing necessary accommodations and support.
Balancing Needs and Community Integration
The debate surrounding the restructuring underscores a delicate balance between meeting the educational
needs of special education students and ensuring their integration within community schools. While the
district aims to streamline services and reduce disruptions, parents argue that uprooting students from
familiar environments can have lasting negative effects.
For families of special education students, the sense of community and familiarity offered by
neighborhood schools goes beyond mere convenience—it plays a vital role in their children’s well-being
and development. The concern extends beyond logistics to encompass the emotional and social impact of
school transitions on vulnerable student populations.
As discussions continue between parents and school officials, finding common ground that prioritizes both
educational efficacy and the well-being of special education students remains paramount. Collaborative
efforts that consider parental input, student needs, and available resources will be key in navigating this
complex issue while upholding the principles of inclusivity and educational equity within the Alpine
School District.
Also Read: Education Funding Dilemma: Juneau School District Faces Budget Uncertainty