Trends Issues Pub Ethics
•Download as PPTX, PDF•
0 likes•117 views
The document summarizes a presentation on trends and issues in publication ethics given by Dr. Daniel T. Kulp to the Academic Divisions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. It discusses the work of COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) in establishing core practices for publication ethics. It outlines current trends COPE is focused on such as retractions, text recycling, and peer review manipulation. It also provides an overview of COPE's resources for journals, publishers, and members on these topics.
Recommended
Recommended
More Related Content
What's hot
What's hot (20)
Similar to Trends Issues Pub Ethics
Similar to Trends Issues Pub Ethics (20)
More from C0pe
More from C0pe (20)
Recently uploaded
Recently uploaded (20)
Trends Issues Pub Ethics
- 1. Trends and Issues in Publication Ethics Academic Divisions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Publishing Seminar September 13, 2021 Dr. Daniel T. Kulp. COPE Chair Senior Director, Editorial Development American Chemical Society
- 2. Trends and Issues in Publication Ethics Agenda • COPE: Who we are • Current Trends • Retractions • Text recycling • Peer review • Systematic manipulation of peer review • Working together
- 3. COPE TRUSTEES AND COUNCIL MEMBERS
- 4. COPE CORE PRACTICES Policies and core practices required to reach the highest standards in publication ethics: Ethical oversight Intellectual property Journal management Peer review processes Allegations of misconduct Authorship and contributorship Complaints and appeals Conflicts of interest/ Competing interests Data and reproducibility Post-publication discussions and corrections
- 6. COPE RESOURCES Retractions • Retraction guidelines • The scientometrics of retractions, COPE seminar presentation • Retractions: a publisher's perspective, COPE seminar presentation • Undisclosed conflict of interest in a published article flowchart • 155 cases
- 7. COPE RESOURCES Text recycling • Text recycling guidelines • Understanding text recycling, COPE webinar 2020 with members of the Text Recycling Research Project • Redundant (duplicate) publication in a submitted manuscript flowchart • Redundant (duplicate) publication in a published article flowchart
- 8. COPE RESOURCES Peer review • Ethical guidelines for peer reviewers • What to consider when asked to peer review a manuscript • What to do if you suspect peer review manipulation
- 9. Definition of systematic manipulation of the publication process
- 10. COPE RESOURCES Paper mills • Infographic shows suspicious activity that might indicate systematic manipulation of the publication process, and flowcharts to follow where manipulation is suspected either before or after publication. • Forum discussion topic Sept 2020: systematic manipulation of the publishing process via paper mills
- 11. COPE RESOURCES Citation manipulation • Citation manipulation discussion document Fabrication, falsification and plagarism flowcharts • Image manipulation in a published article • Fabricated data in a submitted manuscript • Fabricated data in a published article • What to do if you suspect peer review manipulation
- 12. Working together STM Association • Technical solutions to identifying image manipulation • Duplicate submissions across publishers NISO • Retraction taxonomy
- 13. Working together Universities as COPE members • Facilitate communication between Editors/Journals/Publishers and Universities • Discuss, Educate, and Engage on themes in Publication Ethics • Work together to institute and maintain the highest standards in Publication Ethics
- 14. THANK YOU
- 15. Registered charity No 1123023 Registered in England and Wales, Company No 6389120 Registered office: COPE New Kings Court, Tollgate, Chandler's Ford, Eastleigh, Hampshire, SO53 3LG, United Kingdom ©2021 Committee on Publication Ethics (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) facebook.com/publicationethics @C0PE LinkedIn